Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 1 of 156
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK
ASSOCIATION FOR MOLECULAR PATHOLOGY, ET AL., Plaintiffs,
09 Civ. 4515
-against-
OPINION
UNITED STATES PATENT AND TRADEMARK OFFICE, ET AL., Defendants
A P P E A R A N C E S :
Attorneys for Plaintiffs
AMERICAN CIVIL LIBERTIES UNION FOUNDATION 125 Broad Street - 18th Floor New York, NY 10004 By: Christopher A. Hansen, Esq. Aden Fine, Esq.
Lenora M. Lapidus, Esq.
Sandra S. Park, Esq.
PUBLIC PATENT FOUNDATION
Benjamin N. Cardozo School of Law
55 Fifth Ave., Suite 928
New York, NY 10003
By: Daniel B. Ravicher, Esq.
Attorney for Defendant USPTO
PREET BHARARA
United States Attorney for the
Southern District of New York
86 Chambers Street, 3rd Floor
New York, NY 10007
By: Ross Morrison, Esq.
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 2 of 156
A t t o r n e y s f o r D e f e n d a n t s Myriad G e n e t i c s and D i r e c t o r s of t h e U n i v e r s i t y o f Utah Research Foundation
JONES DAY 22 E a s t 41st N e w York, NY By: B r i a n M . Barry R. Laura A .
Street 10017-6702 P o i s s a n t , Esq. S a t i n e , Esq. C o r u z z i , Esq.
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 3 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 4 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 5 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 6 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 7 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 8 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 9 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 10 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 11 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 12 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 13 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 14 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 15 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 16 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 17 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 18 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 19 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 20 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 21 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 22 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 23 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 24 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 25 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 26 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 27 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 28 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 29 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 30 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 31 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 32 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 33 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 34 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 35 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 36 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 37 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 38 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 39 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 40 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 41 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 42 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 43 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 44 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 45 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 46 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 47 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 48 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 49 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 50 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 51 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 52 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 53 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 54 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 55 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 56 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 57 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 58 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 59 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 60 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 61 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 62 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 63 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 64 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 65 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 66 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 67 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 68 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 69 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 70 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 71 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 72 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 73 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 74 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 75 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 76 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 77 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 78 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 79 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 80 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 81 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 82 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 83 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 84 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 85 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 86 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 87 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 88 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 89 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 90 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 91 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 92 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 93 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 94 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 95 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 96 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 97 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 98 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 99 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 100 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 101 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 102 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 103 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 104 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 105 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 106 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 107 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 108 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 109 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 110 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 111 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 112 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 113 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 114 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 115 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 116 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 117 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 118 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 119 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 120 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 121 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 122 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 123 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 124 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 125 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 126 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 127 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 128 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 129 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 130 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 131 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 132 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 133 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 134 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 135 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 136 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 137 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 138 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 139 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 140 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 141 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 142 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 143 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 144 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 145 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 146 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 147 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 148 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 149 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 150 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 151 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 152 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 153 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 154 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 155 of 156
Case 1:09-cv-04515-RWS
Document 255
Filed 03/29/2010
Page 156 of 156