Monday, December 12, 2016 by The Tufts Daily

Tufts: Just one battleground in national ‘sanctuary campus’ movement see FEATURES / PAGE 5

MEN’S BASKETBALL

Jumbos win one, drop a nailbiter

ABC goes to Baltimore: ‘Hairspray Live!’ is ‘ultra-clutch’ see ARTS&LIVING / PAGE 9

SEE SPORTS / BACK PAGE

THE

INDEPENDENT

STUDENT

N E W S PA P E R

TUFTS

UNIVERSITY

E S T. 1 9 8 0

T HE T UFTS DAILY

VOLUME LXXII, NUMBER 61

tuftsdaily.com

Monday, December 12, 2016

MEDFORD/SOMERVILLE, MASS.

Somerville, Medford reaffirm commitment to undocumented immigrants by Jei-Jei Tan News Editor

Despite President-elect Donald Trump’s recent threats to block funding from sanctuary cities, Somerville Mayor Joseph Curtatone reiterated the city’s commitment to remaining a sanctuary city in an open letter released on Nov. 21. “Somerville will stand with you regardless of your race, creed, color, sex, nationality, legal status, religion, gender identity or sexual orientation,” the letter, which Curtatone authored along with Executive Director of The Welcome Project Ben Echevarria, reads. “We’re going to keep bringing people together, making sure we remain a sanctuary for all. We are one community. We’ve got values that work.” According to Associate Professor of Sociology Helen Marrow, sanctuary cities — a term that encompasses a variety of policy commitments — do not make extra efforts to police undocumented immigrants at the local level. They are still bound by state and federal law with regard to requesting and using immigration status information however, including in determining benefit eligibility. According to the letter, Somerville has been a sanctuary city since 1987, and its violent crime rates and unemployment rates are lower than state and national averages. “So for anyone who claims that cracking down on sanctuary cities has something to do with high crime or a stagnant economy, Somerville stands as a flashing, neon billboard for how wrong that thinking is,” the letter reads. This was reiterated at an open meeting with Curtatone held by the Somerville Democratic City Committee on Nov. 30 to

by Joe Walsh News Editor

MAX LALANNE / THE TUFTS DAILY

Mayor Joe Curtatone speaks to the audience during a Somerville Democratic City Committee meeting at the Somerville High School Auditorium on Nov. 30. discuss Somerville’s status as a sanctuary city in light of the presidential election. “We need you to keep talking about our values. We need you … to have conversations with friends and relatives,” Curtatone told the audience. “I think you need to remind people, these are our neighbors, these are our friends … They love this country as much as anyone else … probably more, and we can’t let the lie become the truth.” Statistics show that crime rates among undocumented immigrants are lower than crime rates among immigrants in general, which in turn are lower than the average among U.S.-born citizens, according to Marrow. Likewise, a 2015 report from the Immigration Policy Center, a pro-immigration reform think tank, found that immigrants are less likely to be incarcerated than U.S.-born citizens and that the same trend

would likely hold for undocumented immigrants. According to Curtatone and Echevarria’s letter, Somerville currently receives approximately $6 million in recurring federal funds per year, about three percent of the city’s annual budget. These funds go towards programs including special education, school lunch, substance abuse prevention and homeland security. In an interview with the Daily after the Nov. 30 meeting, Curtatone emphasized that Somerville would not abandon its values because of the threat of loss of federal funding. “If it happens, we have to tighten our belts … we might have to make some tougher decisions about what we don’t fund, but see SANCTUARY, page 2

Late-night study hours Tisch Library, Edward Ginn Library and Eaton Hall will each be offering extended late night study hours during reading period and finals week this semester. Tisch Library: began Dec. 11, ends Dec. 22 at 5 p.m. Sunday: general hours 10 a.m. to 1 a.m., extended study until 6 a.m. Monday-Thursday: general hours 8 a.m. to 1 a.m., extended study until 6 a.m. Friday: general hours 8 a.m. to midnight, extended study until 6 a.m. Saturday: general hours 10 a.m. to midnight, extended study until 6 a.m.

Please recycle this newspaper

Rain 46 / 30

/thetuftsdaily

Students, faculty hold post-election teach-in

Ginn Library: began Dec. 5, ends Dec. 21 at 5 p.m. Sunday: general hours 9 a.m. to 1 a.m., no extended study Monday-Thursday: general hours 8 a.m. to 1 a.m., no extended study Friday: general hours 8 a.m. to 9 p.m., extended study until 1 a.m. Saturday: general hours 9 a.m. to 9 p.m., extended study until 1 a.m.

Monday-Thursday: general hours 8 a.m. to 1 a.m., extended study until 6 a.m. Friday: general hours 8 a.m. to midnight, extended study until 6 a.m. Saturday: general hours 10 a.m. to midnight, extended study until 6 a.m. Eaton Hall Computer Lab: begins Dec. 13, ends Dec. 22 at 5 p.m. Every Day: open 24 hours

Eaton Hall: begins Dec. 13, ends Dec. 22 at 5 p.m. Sunday: general hours 10 a.m. to 1 a.m., extended study until 6 a.m.

For breaking news, our content archive and exclusive content, visit tuftsdaily.com @tuftsdaily

tuftsdaily

—by Kathleen Schmidt

Students, faculty and community members held panel discussions and workshops focused on activism, particularly in the wake of the election of President-elect Donald Trump, as part of a teach-in in Paige Hall over the weekend. The teach-in, which was sponsored by the Consortium of Studies in Race, Colonialism, and Diaspora, Department of Education and Program in Women’s, Gender, and Sexuality Studies, featured more than 20 individual events over the course of two days, according to the event schedule. On Saturday, the focus of the teachin was “Building Solidarity,” and many of the speakers discussed histories of racism, Islamophobia and discrimination, according to the schedule. Several student groups, including Tufts Labor Coalition, Tufts Climate Action and Tufts United for Immigrant Justice, participated. The teach-in’s theme on Sunday was “Building Knowledge, Skills and Resources,” and it featured events focused on strategies for activism, protest and resistance, according to the schedule. One panel discussion, called “What does it mean to be a Student of Color in Trump’s America,” included a group of eighth grade students from KIPP Academy in Boston, who reflected on Trump’s electoral victory and how they plan to respond to it. The discussion was moderated by Bryce Turner (LA ’15), the students’ history teacher. Turner drew parallels between the walkout held by Boston high school students on Dec. 5 and the #TheThreePercent protests at Tufts last November, which Turner had helped organize. “It’s really been important to me to not only be a student, not only be a teacher, but to also practice what you preach [and] to be committed to a lifelong journey of activism both in and out of the classroom,” Turner said. After Turner’s opening remarks, his students discussed their outlooks following Election Day. Several of them explained that, after Trump’s victory, many students at their school worried that life could become more difficult. However, they said they hope to resist, in part through education. In particular, a student named Aaliyah said she drew inspiration from Claudette

NEWS............................................1 FEATURES.................................5 ARTS & LIVING.......................9

see TEACH-IN, page 2

COMICS......................................11 OPINION...................................12 SPORTS............................ BACK

THE TUFTS DAILY | News | Monday, December 12, 2016

T HE T UFTS D AILY Arin Kerstein Editor-in-Chief

EDITORIAL

Sophie Lehrenbaum Jake Taber Managing Editors Evan Sayles Associate Editor Kathleen Schmidt Executive News Editor Gil Jacobson News Editors Melissa Kain Robert Katz Liam Knox Catherine Perloff Jei-Jei Tan Hannah Uebele Joe Walsh Juliana Furgala Assistant News Editors Jesse Najarro Danny Nelson

Miranda Willson Executive Features Editor Constantinos Angelakis Features Editors Nina Joung Becca Leibowitz Justin Krakoff Executive Arts Editor John Gallagher Arts Editors Eran Sabaner Isaac Brown Assistant Arts Editors Jocelyn Contreras Alison Epstein Elliot Storey Emma Henderson Executive Op-Ed Editor Shannon Geary Cartoonists Stephen Dennison Allie Merola Miranda Chavez Editorialists Frances DeFreitas Eriko Koide Anita Ramaswamy Noah Weinflash Phillip Goldberg Executive Sports Editor Yuan Jun Chee Sports Editors Maddie Payne Eddie Samuels Maclyn Senear Josh Slavin Brad Schussel Assistant Sports Editor Noah Smith Max Lalanne Mia Lambert Caroline Ambros Ray Bernoff Scott Fitchen Jean Gonzalez Kevin Ho Thaw Htet Lilia Kang Sitara Rao Evan Sayles Zachary Sebek Alexis Serino Seohyun Shim Angelie Xiong Ezgi Yazici

Executive Photo Editor Photo Administrator Picture Tufts Editor Staff Photographers

PRODUCTION David Westby Production Director Allie Merola Executive Layout Editors Sebastian Torrente Lilia Aronoff-Aspatur Layout Editors Morgan Berman Jewel Castle Connor Dale Brianna Mignano Emily Sharp Astrid Weng Ezgi Yazici Sharmitha Yerneni Alice Yoon Petrina Chan Creative Director Allie Merola Executive Graphics Editor Petrina Chan Graphics Editors Peter Lam Sebastian Torrente

Zach Hertz Executive Copy Editors Jei-Jei Tan Norrie Beach Copy Editors Arthur Beckel Caroline Bollinger Alison Epstein Gil Jacobson Melissa Kain Reena Kerasin Bibi Lichauco Kathleen Martensen Netai Schwartz Nihaal Shah Arielle Sigel Liora Silkes Dan Strauss

Maxwell Bernstein Executive Tech Manager Nitesh Gupta Online Editor Mia Lambert Social Media Editor

BUSINESS Josh Morris Executive Business Director

tuftsdaily.com

Local communities pledge support for all residents following presidential election SANCTUARY

continued from page 1 we’re not going to allow the very fabric of this community to disintegrate at the threat of hanging money over our heads just to have us run away from who we are,” Curtatone said. “We’re not going to do it. We’re going to make a stand.” Nevertheless, Curtatone said that he hoped Trump and his advisors would find it prudent not to cut federal funding from sanctuary cities. “The president-elect on Election night said he wants to be the president of all people,” Curtatone said. “[Cutting federal grants affects] the very programs that serve the most vulnerable populations that he exclaimed throughout the campaign have been neglected by the Democratic Party and that he wanted to be the champion for.” Marrow said it is plausible that the Trump administration would try to make federal funding dependent on cooperation with federal deportation efforts, but it is unlikely that such efforts would be legally successful, as such laws would have to be made well in advance and explicitly state that federal grants are tied to certain state and local actions. There is also legal precedent that forbids the federal government from withholding funds in ways that “coerce” state governments into enforcing federal law, according to Marrow. Marrow emphasized that there is a difference between local non-cooperation and breaking state and federal law. For instance, U.S. Immigrations and Customs Enforcement (ICE) has increasingly encouraged local police to detain people who have been arrested for something other than their immigration status — since entering the country illegally is a civil violation and not a crime — so that their immigration status can be investigated, Marrow stated. Marrow said that sanctuary city policies discourage cooperation with these “ICE holds,” because performing immigration regulation is often not in local police’s economic or professional interests. “[Police agencies have found that they] lose the trust and they create tensions in their local communities that … work against the goals of policing,” Marrow explained, referring to their experiences experimenting with ICE holds in the past.

She added that many local police agencies have previously resisted the extra work of immigration regulation because the federal government did not sufficiently fund local detainment costs. Similarly, in an email statement from University President Anthony Monaco to the Tufts community on Nov. 30, Monaco reaffirmed that the university is committed to supporting undocumented students. “High-achieving students who have earned a place at Tufts deserve the opportunity to obtain their degree and use that education to better our society,” the statement read. “The university will not provide information about our students or assist in the enforcement of immigration laws except as mandated by a subpoena, warrant, or court order … Our policy is consistent with what Somerville, one of our host communities, has had in place for some time.” According to Emma Kahn, a member of Tufts United for Immigrant Justice (UIJ), Monaco has committed to housing undocumented Tufts students on the Somerville side of campus if Somerville remains a sanctuary city. “We are open to any number of strategies for accommodating our [Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals] and undocumented students,” Executive Director of Public Relations Patrick Collins told the Daily in an email. Kahn, a junior, added that although UIJ’s initial demands asked that ICE and other immigration enforcement officials be banned from all Tufts buildings, Monaco did not specifically address this in his statement. Meanwhile, Medford Mayor Stephanie Burke presented a resolution supporting the diversity of Medford’s population at the Medford City Council meeting on Nov. 29. The resolution was passed unanimously, according to the Medford Transcript. “The City of Medford is a community that welcomes and values the varied racial and ethnic makeup of our residents, and … stands in support of all immigrant groups and newcomers as they pursue the ‘American Dream,’” the resolution read. “The City of Medford will work to model our city as a safe and welcoming place that equally encourages all to seek personal advancement and to reside in peaceful contentment in Medford.” Medford’s Diversity Director Diane McLeod

said that the statement was a response to the “hateful rhetoric that eventually led to the results of the presidential election.” “The goals of putting out the statement were to publicly alleviate fear and ensure our community that everyone will be treated with dignity and respect,” McLeod wrote in an email to the Daily. “Although this has always been our mission, it seemed important at this time to say it publicly and have our community representatives and elected officials sign on to that statement.” Dale Bryan, who, aside from his role as assistant director of Peace and Justice Studies, is co-director of the Medford Conversations project, highlighted the racial, ethnic and generational diversity of the city’s population. The topic of Medford Conversations’ Winter Conversation Series, titled “Who Belongs? Dialogues about Race and Ethnicity in Medford and Beyond,” was selected during the presidential primaries earlier this year and reflects the concerns of Medford residents who participated in the project’s events, according to Bryan. Neither McLeod nor Bryan has heard of any calls to make Medford a sanctuary city, although Bryan noted that the Medford Community Coalition had sent an email to Burke in mid-November calling for her to issue a statement of inclusivity. McLeod said that a possible reason she has not received sanctuary city requests is that Medford police have not participated in ICE efforts such as Secure Communities, which encouraged local jurisdictions to help federal authorities identify undocumented immigrants. “They do not report illegal immigrants who are stopped for minor infractions,” McLeod said. “Our police chief is, and has been, a member of the Medford Human Rights Commission (HRC) for many, many years.” According to McLeod, the HRC leads the city in community building, race relations and inclusivity efforts. “The HRC is continuously community building and discussing issues such as race, ethnicity, and equality as these issues are, and will always be part of our community,” she wrote. “We constantly strive to make Medford a welcoming community.” Max Lalanne and Rebecca Redelmeier contributed reporting on this article.

Local eighth graders discuss reactions to Trump win TEACH-IN

continued from page 1 Colvin, who refused to give up her seat on a segregated bus in Montgomery, Ala. in 1955, nine months before Rosa Parks’ protest. Aaliyah explained that Colvin’s activism was notable because she was only 15 years old at the time. “No matter what age you are, you can take a stand,” Aaliyah said. Some of the students disagreed about whether they should feel hopeful about Trump’s presidency. A student named Cameron said that he is optimistic about the future and that people should give Trump a chance because, in the aftermath of the election, they have few other choices. However, Shelby, another student, argued that much of Trump’s rhetoric is unforgivable and worried that the progress marked by President Barack Obama‘s tenure will be reversed. “On the day when [Trump] won the election, there was kind of a still silence … like a wave got flushed over you,” Shelby said. Later, another group of students said that their view of the United States changed somewhat after Trump’s electoral victory because it revealed deeply-held prejudices that were previously not as visible.

Finally, the students said that they are determined to resist oppression in the future, particularly through education. One of the students emphasized that, in spite of the elec-

tion, she will not allow Trump to dictate the course of her life. At the end of the panel, the students took questions from the audience.

COURTESY SABINA VAUGHT

Students listen to talks at a teach-in by the department of education on Dec. 11.

tuftsdaily.com

Monday, December 12, 2016 | ADVERTISEMENT | THE TUFTS DAILY

THE TUFTS DAILY | ADVERTISEMENT | Monday, December 12, 2016

1/4

tuftsdaily.com

1/8

1/2

Monday, December 12, 2016

Features

National discourse on sanctuary campuses: Where does Tufts fit in? Rebecca Redelmeier Contributing Writer

For students looking to effect change outside the “Tufts bubble,” the sanctuary movement serves as at least one way in which Tufts students are connecting to a growing movement taking place across the country. Since Election Day, almost 200 sanctuary campus petitions have emerged nationwide, according to Xavier Maciel, a first-year transfer student at Pomona College. Maciel has compiled a Google spreadsheet that lists all of these schools, including Tufts, in order to provide an online resource for students across the country petitioning and protesting for sanctuary campus policies. On Nov. 30, University President Anthony Monaco declared in an email to the Tufts community that the university would remain committed to its efforts to support and protect undocumented students, including those with Deferred Action for Childhood Arrival (DACA) status. The release of this statement marks Tufts as one of dozens of colleges that have made similar declarations.

Staff Writer

Tufts students abroad, like their counterparts on the Medford/Somerville campus, are coming to grips with their feelings following the presidential election. Some students studying through Tufts Programs Abroad in Madrid, Santiago and Paris described a sense of separation from political events in the United States. Several students also participated in demonstrations in their host countries and engaged in conversations with locals following the election. Cameron Eck, a junior in the Tuftsin-Chile program, described walking the streets of Santiago in a daze after the election as he realized how distant his experience was from that of the Chilean public. “[Chilean natives], for the most part, they don’t care. It doesn’t affect them,” he said. “And it was only when I’d find myself around American friends that I would feel [okay] … I wanted to talk

tuftsdaily.com

Rainbow House 2016 On Queer

On home (and Hogwarts)

A EVAN SAYLES / THE TUFTS DAILY

After a campus-wide walkout, hundreds of Tufts students join community members for a march and rally demanding that Tufts become a sanctuary campus on Nov. 16. Provost and Senior Vice President David Harris expressed pride in this fact. “We are proud to be among a number of colleges and universities that have taken steps to enhance protection

for our DACA and undocumented students,” Harris told the Daily in an email. Maciel, who compiled the spreadsee CAMPUS, page 6

Tufts students abroad respond to results of U.S. election Elie Levine

about it with people and vent about it with people.” Rebecca Schaub, another junior studying in Chile, said she spoke to her host family about the election results and felt that their responses, while sympathetic, indicated a lack of full comprehension. “I don’t think that anyone in my [host] house really understands the gravity of what’s happening in the [United States] with this or what I was feeling,” she said. “Because it was a lot of like, ‘Don’t worry,’ ‘Have hope’ … I know that at home, those aren’t the words people are saying. It’s more like, ‘How do we deal with this?’” According to junior Adam Kercheval, another Tufts student in Chile, Augusto Pinochet’s dictatorship in Chile from 1973 to 1990 stands out as potentially similar to a Trump presidency. Kercheval said that many Chileans have chosen to understand the election results through the lens of Pinochet’s rule. Comparing the two political leaders, Chileans have responded with messages of

SOPHIE HECHT / THE TUFTS DAILY

Junior Adam Kercheval looks at a waterfall in Chile on Nov. 6.

courage and resilience, Kercheval said. “A lot of the things they keep telling us are that we can’t live in fear. That’s kind of the main thesis of what they’re saying,” Kercheval said. “And I think that’s an interesting perspective that they can have, kind of personally, because they were all here during something very similar to what’s going on now.” Eck heard similar feedback from Chilean locals. “Nobody likes him here. Nobody likes Trump at all. They mostly were just like, ‘I’m sorry, there’s nothing we can do about it now,’” he said. “I think the comparisons to the dictatorship are the predominant thing that people have talked about.” Luis Del Rosario, a junior studying at Sciences Po in Paris with the Tufts-in-Paris program, sees a growing isolationist trend in world politics that he believes has been exacerbated by the results of the election. He noted that European countries seem to be drawing inward, turning to the United States less for guidance and leadership. Del Rosario added that, from his perspective in Europe, the election reminded him of Brexit, the June 23 referendum in which British citizens voted to exit the European Union. “It was like Brexit had happened all over again, but it was 10 times worse,” he said. Schaub also compared the election results to Brexit, drawing an analogy between Americans’ reactions to Brexit and Chileans’ reactions to Trump’s win. “It’s just something that’s happening in another country,” she said. “I keep comparing [my experience] to [that of] everyone in the [United States] when Brexit happened. We knew that it was serious, but we were like ‘Ah! I can’t believe England did that!’” Students in the Tufts-in-Madrid program, run jointly by Tufts and Skidmore College as Tufts-Skidmore Spain, have actively protested against the U.S. election. Juniors Ana see ABROAD, page 6

s the saying goes, “Home is where the heart is.” But for many LGBTQ people, figuring out where that is can be more than a little bit complicated. As Harry Potter said when asked how he felt about returning to Privet Drive, “Hogwarts is my home.” I’m always a fan of reading queer allegory into just about anything, so let’s go for it: Harry spent his life oppressed by the culture of his home and abused by his family. Having escaped this environment, he found his way to a place where he could explore his identity (as a wizard, but since I’m pretty convinced that LGBTQ people are actually magic, we can go with it) and where he had friends with whom he could share his experiences. In short, he found somewhere safe (except for the giant three-headed dog, the evil wizard living in the back of his teacher’s head, the entire Forbidden Forest and the giant snake in the basement). Then, at the end of the year, he found himself on the train back to a place where he would face abuse and discrimination once again. Just about every queer person I know has experienced some version of this since coming to college: We discover a community of people who are willing to accept us for who we are, and we experiment with our identities in ways that we were never allowed to before. Then, inevitably, winter break or summer comes around, and we find ourselves back on the Hogwarts Express (or at Logan), bound for a place where we feel unsafe or unable to exist as ourselves again. I hail from a conservative, rural part of eastern Maine. I’m a queer trans woman. That’s really not the best mix. I’m not out to anyone in my town, as much as I wish I could be. My winter break is going to be four weeks of being misgendered and deadnamed, of dressing butch (entirely contrary to what has been described as my “crop top and maxi skirt lesbian” aesthetic) and focusing all of my energy on not slipping up, on not carrying anything with my name on it or using she-series pronouns to describe myself. At the same time, my fondest memories from my childhood are set in my town, featuring the people from whom I will have to spend a month hiding myself. At the same time as I dread being cheerily deadnamed by the owner of the only coffee shop in town, I can’t wait to see my dogs and to smell the ocean again. For me, as for many queer people, concepts of “home,” “safety,” “self” and “family” are tied up in a knot so unfathomably complex that I can’t see where to start untying it. Through all of it, however, one thing remains true: If home is where the heart is, my home is with my friends, my chosen family and the community that has welcomed me upon arrival. Tufts is my home. This column was written by an anonymous resident of the Rainbow House. They can be reached at rhouse@gmail.com.

THE TUFTS DAILY | Features | Monday, December 12, 2016

tuftsdaily.com

Students in Madrid, Santiago, Paris share post-election experiences abroad ABROAD

continued from page 5 Manriquez, Anna Del Castillo and Mateo Davis worked together to organize a rally on Nov. 27. The goal of the demonstration, according to Del Castillo, was to hold the U.S. government accountable for the harm it is doing to minority communities. As a Latina, Manriquez has felt personally victimized by Trump’s rhetoric. A permanent resident of the United States who moved to the country from Mexico at the age of six, she said that the election results personally affect her and the people she loves. Del Castillo and Manriquez said they named their working group “Love Trumps Hate Madrid” because of the powerful message of love that drives their activism.

“I know that although our goal is to hold the U.S. government accountable for protecting people in our communities, we’re only going to get that done if, at the root of what we are doing, we are doing it with this radical love,” Del Castillo said. Manriquez highlighted the importance of putting love at the center of their work. “We chose the theme of love so that we can love one another, and by loving one another … gain the strength that we need now to not be silenced,” Manriquez said. Tufts students in France and Chile have not been involved in political activism as a unified group, according to Del Rosario and Eck. They attribute this to the low numbers of students in these programs compared to the number of students in Madrid. There are 15 Tufts students in Santiago,

according to Eck, and 11 in Paris, according to Del Rosario. In comparison, Eck said there are 70 Tufts and Skidmore students studying abroad in the TuftsSkidmore Spain program. Eck, Schaub and Kercheval said they did not hear of protests against the American election in Chile. “What’s interesting is that there [are] a lot of protests already going on about the government’s health care programs and social security programs, so I don’t even think that a lot of Chileans want to protest the American election. It’s probably not the first thing on their mind,” Kercheval said. There have been anti-Trump demonstrations in Paris following the election, including one at the U.S. Embassy in Paris, Del Rosario said.

Manriquez said that one of the most difficult aspects of studying abroad has been leaving behind certain communities at Tufts, specifically Tufts United for Immigrant Justice and the Latino Center. “[I am] trying to stay as connected to them as I possibly can,” she said. Manriquez added that she is proud of the work students at Tufts have done so far in fighting to make Tufts a sanctuary campus as well as of the administration’s continued commitment to accepting undocumented students. Del Castillo said she wanted to push to hold governments accountable for protecting marginalized communities. “At this time, we … need to use our bodies and voices to show the world that Trump’s rhetoric is harming our communities,” Del Castillo said.

Sanctuary campus movement continues to grow across universities CAMPUS

continued from page 5 sheet just days after the election, included links to any relevant petitions or statements from different universities in the spreadsheet. “The spreadsheet started off with only three schools on it,” Maciel said. “I thought it was a good idea to consolidate all the petitions into a spreadsheet so that I could share it on Facebook, and maybe my friends in schools on the East Coast would see it.” Maciel attributed some of the sanctuary campus movement’s momentum to the leadership of schools that first declared themselves as sanctuaries. “At first, people were saying that colleges can’t declare themselves as sanctuary campuses. Then, out of nowhere, the same day, Reed [College] did,” Maciel said. Wesleyan University was also one of the first colleges to specifically declare itself a sanctuary campus on Nov. 20. Tomás Rogel, a sophomore at Wesleyan and one of the creators of the Wesleyan sanctuary campus petition letter, said he was glad that Wesleyan could be a role model to students at other schools trying to establish a sanctuary campus. However, he noted that steps must still be taken at Wesleyan to effectively support undocumented students. “Declaring a sanctuary campus [at Wesleyan] is a huge step and a great example for other schools,” Rogel said. “But, that’s part of why I’m so wary of what our

sanctuary campus means. I want it to be a damn good example.” Tufts United for Immigrant Justice (UIJ) is the student organization that penned the initial petition for a sanctuary campus at Tufts. According to junior Emma Kahn, a member of UIJ, Tufts followed the example of other schools that had started similar petitions to become sanctuary campuses. “We took a lot from other sanctuary campus petitions that were out there [when creating our own],” Kahn said. Maciel also noted that individual campus efforts toward sanctuary status and protection of immigrant rights might be receiving more attention due to the national scale of the movement. “A lot of schools are learning from each other. [University] presidents are starting to talk about DACA students more than they ever did before,” Maciel said. But not every school’s sanctuary campus movement has received administrative support to the same degree as those at Reed, Wesleyan and Tufts, all of which have liberal-leaning student bodies. Since the sanctuary campus movement began, some schools have experienced backlash against their sanctuary campus petitions. At Wake Forest University in North Carolina, the campus’ conservative news source, the Wake Forest Review, published a petition that countered the sanctuary campus movement signed by “Concerned Members of the Wake Forest Community.” The petition asked Wake

Forest University President Nathan Hatch to not adopt “radical sanctuary policies” at Wake Forest. Richard Cabán Cubero, one of the student authors of the initial petition to make Wake Forest a sanctuary campus, said that the release of the counter-petition created a polarized atmosphere on campus, with some students feeling shocked. In a response letter to both petitions sent on Dec. 1, Hatch declined to endorse either petition. “I do not believe adopting the position of either petition will strengthen our community,” he wrote. “While I will not sign either statement, I will do everything in my power as the president of Wake Forest University to support every member of our community in their pursuit of an education.” Just as the first campuses that adopted sanctuary policy acted as pioneers for future movements, Cubero, a senior, noted that he and fellow supporters were in a unique — and difficult — position as one of the first campus groups that had to determine the response to a sanctuary campus rejection. “We looked at other school’s petitions as best practices while creating our own, but there are no best practices for how to handle a rejection,” Cubero said. Cubero and others in Wake Forest’s sanctuary campus movement opted to propose a resolution in favor of a sanctuary campus to the Wake Forest Student Government, which passed on Dec. 6, according to the

Wake Forest Review. Maciel said that backlash against the sanctuary campus movement has also emerged at schools such as New Mexico State University and the University of Mississippi. As Inauguration Day approaches, sanctuary campus movements are still active nationwide, and updates continue to pop up on Maciel’s spreadsheet. At Tufts, UIJ is not losing energy. One of the group’s more recent goals is to release its own message to complement Monaco’s statement of support for undocumented students, according to Kahn. “We have already planned research and prep for over winter break,” Kahn said. But with the end of the semester quickly approaching, Rogel said that students are concerned about how the movement to create sanctuary campuses and provide resources on campus for undocumented students will persevere. “It feels weird to leave [campus for winter break] and leave this movement behind,” Rogel said. At Tufts, Kahn said UIJ is concerned about and hopes to address the growing fear surrounding this issue in the coming months. “I think things for undocumented students are about to get really bad,” she said. “Even if no students are faced with deportation threats and federal funds [for Tufts] aren’t threatened, there will be new and unprecedented experiences of terror.”

Monday, December 12, 2016 | ADVERTISEMENT | THE TUFTS DAILY

tuftsdaily.com

Hall Closing Reminders Important Dates Winter Recess Closing Checklist

Classes End: Monday, 12/12 Reading Days: 12/13 & 12/14 Finals Begin: Thursday, 12/15 Finals End: Thursday, 12/22

 CLOSE

and LOCK all windows, pull shades down  All electronics are turned off and unplugged  Defrost/unplug any fridges  Take out all trash  Turn heat to #1 setting Shhh!  If you have fish, take them Continuous Quiet Hours home  Take any items home you may Quiet Hours begin on Monday, 12/12 need over the break. The halls at 11pm and continue through are locked and alarmed Thursday, 12/22. Please be respectful during this period of your fellow residents during this  If you live in an apartment, crucial time of year! please clean the kitchen and wash any dishes. You don’t want to come back to bugs! If you are leaving at the end of the semester and not returning:  LOCK YOUR DOOR You will need to make arrangements with residential staff to properly check out of your room. You will also need to return your keys to one of the following areas: Residential Facilities (520 Boston Ave) 9a-5p Monday - Friday Campus Police Key Drop Box (419 Boston Ave) open 24 hours

Residence Halls CLOSE: Friday, 12/23 promptly at 12pm

You will be charged for any keys NOT returned at the end of the semester!

Looking ahead… Halls re-open at 9:00am on Mon. January 16, 2017 Residence Hall Spring Closings Non-graduating students Saturday, May 13, 2017 Graduating Seniors Monday, May 22, 2017

The Office of Residential Life & Learning would like to wish all of you the best of luck on your final exams and a safe & happy holiday season! Questions? Please call us at 7-3248 or email reslife@tufts.edu

See you in 2017!

Help Someone Go To College!

Volunteer as a Coach with Let’s Get Ready! Work with local high school students for 3 hours per week. Tutor in SAT prep, college essay writing, and the application process. Make a difference in your community.

THE PROGRAM

1/2 AD

The Somerville and Medford Let’s Get Ready Programs are nine weeks and include: • • • • •

SAT prep College application support Tours of college campuses Financial aid review and assistance Small groups of 10 or less

Somerville High School Mondays and Wednesdays 5:30 - 8:30 PM 81 Highland Ave Somerville, MA 02143

Medford High School Tuesdays and Thursdays 5:30 - 8:30 PM 489 Winthrop St Medford, MA 02155

LEARN MORE & APPLY

https://www.tfaforms.co m/451366

Programs starts February 2017 Questions? Contact us at sbissonnette@letsgetready.org

THE TUFTS DAILY | ADVERTISEMENT | Monday, December 12, 2016

1/4

1/8 FULL AD 1/2

Co Sponsored by

tuftsdaily.com

Monday, December 12, 2016

ARTS&LIVING

Larraín, Portman stun in ‘Jackie’ by Jocelyn Contreras

While my computer gently weeps

Assistant Arts Editor

G COURTESY FOX SEARCHLIGHT

“Jackie,” starring Natalie Portman in the titular role and Sir John Hurt as Father Richard McSorley, was released on Dec. 2. The film opens with the latter interview, which quickly lays to rest any preconceived impressions audience members will undoubtedly bring with them. Portman’s Jackie is methodical and powerful. She is acutely aware of how important appearances are in political theater. She demands the final say in what Theodore H. White, played by a purposefully unlikable Billy Crudup, decides to include in the print copy of their interview. She taunts him by giv-

ing the gory details she knows he came for, only to deny any mention of it in the article. She’s in charge and unapologetically so. By jumping around the timeline, the film presents a careful balance between public and private personas. Portman’s fine-tuning of both is mesmerizing. Due in large part to the decision to keep the majority of the film’s frame in close-up see JACKIE, page 10

MUSICAL REVIEW

‘Hairspray Live!’ brings strong singing, strong message by Alison Epstein

Assistant Arts Editor

Gone are the days of hate-watching live television adaptations of musicals. They have come a long way since 2013, when country singer Carrie Underwood appalled audiences with her astoundingly poor acting capabilities in the first live televised musical special in almost 50 years on NBC, “The Sound of Music Live!” (2013). “The Wiz Live!” (2015) and “Grease: Live” (2016) showed that these musicals did have the potential for actual quality. NBC’s “Hairspray Live!” is the network’s

tuftsdaily.com

Nikki Margaretos Is This Thing On?

FILM REVIEW

When movie-goers got wind that Natalie Portman would be playing Jackie Kennedy – not yet Onassis – in Pablo Larraín’s “Jackie” (2016), there is no doubt they thought, “Well that makes sense.” Make no mistake: Nothing in her performance is conventional. She has outdone herself, if that is even possible. “Jackie” was released on Dec. 2, just two weeks before “Neruda” (2016), Larraín’s second film of the year. “Neruda” centers around Nobel Prizewinning Chilean poet Pablo Neruda, which, given Larraín’s background as a Chilean filmmaker, seems like a more obvious choice than “Jackie.” Considering the experimental tendencies in his films, Larraín expressed some doubt when one of the producers, Darren Aronofsky, approached him about the film. But it is precisely Larraín’s distinct style that elevates “Jackie” to something more than a standard prestige biopic. S c re e n w r i t e r No a h O p p e n h e i m , with previous works such as “Allegiant” (2016) and “The Maze Runner” (2014), makes an impressive leap with “Jackie.” He constrains the film’s timeline to a mere week after the assassination. The film takes a non-linear form as the devastating proceedings are intercut with two separate interviews with the first lady – one given during the 1962 White House Tour she gave and the other with Life magazine just a week after she became a widow.

latest musical and latest attempt to remedy its nose-diving ratings. Definitely not as good as “Grease: Live,” but probably more important because of its (unfortunate) relevance, “Hairspray Live!” was still a fun, star-studded event with only a few low points. The night started off with a slightly rocky start, as newcomer Maddie Baillio, playing Tracy, suffered from a few audio glitches. Despite this, Baillio showed early on why she was chosen out of over 1,000 people at an open casting call for the role of Tracy. Her enthusiasm shined and her singing was excellent, though it was hard for her to

COURTESY JUSTIN LUBIN FOR NBC

Ariana Grande (left) plays Penny Pingleton and Maddie Baillio (right) plays Tracy Turnblad in “Hairspray Live!,” which aired on Dec. 7.

compete with the monster voices of some of her female co-stars. Broadway superstar Kristin Chenoweth was delightfully vicious as Velma, and her rendition of “(The Legend of) Miss Baltimore Crabs” was an early highlight. But the real standout of the night was Jennifer Hudson as Motormouth Maybelle. She absolutely brought the house down near the end of the night with “I Know Where I’ve Been.” She left nothing on the table, bringing so much power and emotion (and several key changes!) to this anthem for racial equality. Chenoweth and Hudson weren’t the only famous faces on NBC last Wednesday night. Other stars included pop sensation and doughnut-licker Ariana Grande (Penny), Derek Hough (Corny Collins), Martin Short (Wilbur) and Harvey Fierstein, reprising his Tony-award winning role as Edna. There were also guest appearances from Billy Eichner, Sean Hayes, Rosie O’Donnell and two former “Tracys,” Marissa Jaret Winokur and Ricki Lake. Also in the cast was current Disney Channel star Dove Cameron, who played Amber. Her speaking voice was overly shrill and got to be a bit grating, but her singing voice was a whole different story. Who would’ve thought such a powerful voice could come out of that tiny girl? Unfortunately, the other Disney kid in the production was by far the weakest “Link” (Sorry, too easy). Garrett Clayton, best known see HAIRSPRAY, page 10

reetings again! It is my last column of the semester, and I wanted to bring things full circle. I opened by introducing this as a commentary on popular music in the context of college and beyond. This is the music I will look back on with both fond memories and embarrassment and perhaps have difficulty explaining to my kids. Therefore, in order to get my children as excited about Ariana Grande as I was, I’m going to have to sort something out. Were I writing this same column a few decades ago, I would have framed that idea more like: How am I going to show my children my Ariana Grande record collection? Or more recently: How am I going to show my children my Ariana Grande CDs? Or in ten years: How am I going to show my children my Ariana Grande holograms? The point is, the way in which we listen to and collect “our” music has evolved rapidly. Think back to the first iPod released 15 years ago. It was chunky and monochromatic, yet still seemed years beyond its time. Today, we laugh at it. However, the iPod’s significance lies in the transition from analog to digital music collection. 10 years ago, I would peruse the same record (later CD) stores my mom used to love as a kid, which have since gone out of business. There was something about being able to flip through the squares of plastic, even just to inspect the album artwork and track listings on the back. Music was something you could hold in your hands and call a piece of your own. Sometimes you could discover the artist’s secrets inside. Did you know that Taylor Swift’s jewel cases contain hidden, sappy love messages in the lyrics with capitalized or lowercase letters? It’s a type of artistry that’s lost in standardized online delivery. Back to the idea of ownership, I still held on to some sense of cohesiveness when I graduated to my own first iPod in 2005. As years passed, I ran into issues such as maximizing the number of authorized computers connected to my iPod and was locked out of my songs if they had been downloaded to too many devices. Slowly, I lost access to my carefully curated collection. When I opened Spotify today, I was greeted with a banner: “Hello. We’ve got a new version of Spotify ready for you. Restart now to make it yours.” Except Spotify was neither made ready for me nor is it mine. Am I going to have my account until I’m 80? Will Spotify even survive until 2025, or will some hot new application chew it out? Further, all of my favorite songs and playlists could be deleted from my profile in three minutes, at most! So, I’ll offer a Beatles lyric from “In My Life” (1965) as a parting thought: “And these memories lose their meanings / When I think of love as something new / Though I know I’ll never lose affection / For people and things that went before.” Nikki Margaretos is a junior majoring in international relations and economics. Nikki can be reached at nikoletta.margaretos@tufts.edu.

THE TUFTS DAILY | Arts & Living | Monday, December 12, 2016

tuftsdaily.com

Larraín’s aesthetic choices lift ‘Jackie’ well above its genre JACKIE

continued from page 9 and most often on her, every expression is magnified. Even in moments of silence, Portman is never passive. She weaves in and out of countless layers of grief. With each mask she takes off, it becomes clear that Portman might have just delivered the performance of her career. While Portman was initially hesitant in accepting the role, Larraín refused to direct the film without her, and it is very clear that his strong stance was worth it.

Other players such as Jackie’s aide Nancy Tuckerman (Greta Gerwig) and even John F. Kennedy (Caspar Phillipson) himself are played in an understated fashion, which serves the film beautifully. “Jackie” is full of aesthetic choices that make Larraín’s work quite unnerving. Mica Levi, whose stage name is “Micachu,” was chosen to compose the score. This is only the second film she’s composed for, but she’s proven herself a force to be reckoned with. She earned a BAFTA nomination for her previous work in “Under the Skin” (2013). Her work in “Jackie” is steady and creeps in

and out of the moments that are hardest to watch with a play on strings that will raise the hair on anyone’s neck. There’s hardly a moment in “Jackie” that allows for any ease. While the result is somewhat exhausting by the end, it feels appropriate. Any lighter moments throughout the film only make the grief weigh heavier. There is no escaping it, given that the camera hardly ever leaves her side. The effect is so devastating that it borders on voyeuristic. What Larraín has done here is create a world in which Jackie is no longer an unreachable myth. The uncertainty regard-

ing her identity was all her doing, and as depicted in the film, it was a rather obsessive task she took on in creating Jackie, the public figure. Instead of faulting her for this, however, the film acknowledges her dedication and intelligence in a way the many previous depictions of her in TV and film have not. In a moment of self-reflection, Jackie states, “I believe that the characters we read about on the page end up being more real than the men who stand beside us.” Larraín grapples with this theme astutely, and it would serve everyone well to pay attention to his work going forward.

Clever mise-en-scene strengthens the musical HAIRSPRAY

continued from page 9 for “Teen Beach Movie” (2013), just could not find his footing as Link. First of all, he had an entire bottle of the wrong color of foundation on his face. Not his fault, but it was extremely distracting and borderline disturbing. His acting, dancing and singing were all subpar, and therefore did not make up for his John Boehner-esque skin tone. He and Baillio unfortunately had little-to-no chemistry, and his performance contradicted the claim that Link was supposedly a singing and dancing heartthrob. Bring back Zac Efron please. Also, it needs to be mentioned that Darren Criss appeared to have gotten lost and somehow ended up as the “host” of the evening. During commercial breaks, Criss would occasionally come out and fangirl over the performers and try to get viewers to tweet about the show using the hashtag #HairsprayLive. The whole thing was pretty #stupid, and it would’ve been better to scrap this whole idea to

potentially cut down on the three-hour runtime. That’s not to say the three hours were a waste of time. “Hairspray Live!” took some ideas out of “Grease: Live’s” playbook and used a similar form of staging, with several sound stages of different settings. This kept for a pretty fast-paced show as performers could bounce around the different sound stages. Also, “Hairspray” is filled with upbeat music and colorful costumes, both of which added to the fun, lively atmosphere. The end was heartwarming, as the end of “Hairspray” always is, with the whole cast – villains Velma and Amber included – coming together for “You Can’t Stop the Beat.” Even Tracy and Link’s painfully hard-to-watch kiss couldn’t ruin this finale. If the conflict of this musical was a little too reminiscent of some of the darkness many feel in our political climate today, this ending number served as a symbol of hope. You can’t stop progress. You can’t stop the beat.

COURTESY JUSTIN LUBIN / NBC

Maddie Baillio went from being an unknown actress to playing the lead role in “Hairspray Live!,” which aired on Dec 7.

Monday, December 12, 2016 | Comics | THE TUFTS DAILY

tuftsdaily.com

Comics

LATE NIGHT AT THE DAILY Sophie: “I haven’t peed in public in a long time.”

Comics

SUDOKU

DOONESBURY BY GARRY TRUDEAU

NON SEQUITUR BY WILEY MILLER

Difficulty Level: Finishing the last slice of pizza.

Friday’s Solution

CROSSWORD

Studying abroad spring 2017? Required pre-departure meetings: Non-Tufts Study Abroad Tufts Programs Abroad all meetings in Dowling 745

all meetings in Dowling 745

Non-Tufts Africa/Asia/ Tufts in London*/Madrid*/ Caribbean/Latin Paris*/Tübingen America/Middle East Tues., Dec. 13 @ 1:30 pm Tues., Dec. 13 @ 10:30 am Tufts in Hong Kong/Japan Non-Tufts Mainland Europe Wed., Dec. 14 @ 10:30 am Wed., Dec. 14 @ 1:30 pm Non-Tufts UK/Ireland/ Australia/New Zealand Wed., Dec. 14 @ 3:30 pm

*for those who did not participate in the group meeting with the Resident Director

PLEASE NOTE: If you cannot make your scheduled nonTufts meeting, please attend another non-Tufts meeting. If you cannot make your scheduled Tufts meeting, please attend another Tufts meeting.

Meetings are required.

Friday’s Solution

12 tuftsdaily.com

Opinion EDITORIAL

Aren Torikian The Arena

Closing time

remember sending in my first column for “The Arena” last September. When the Daily accepted my proposal, I think I let it get to my head. I figured I would drop knowledge bombs and be the campus Nate Silver crossed with Jon Stewart crossed with Brad Pitt. But this election process made me feel more like Seamus Finnigan in “Harry Potter,” struggling to convert water into rum. My boldest prediction of the whole term made me look like a moron. On Nov. 1 2015, I titled my column “Rubiowning it,” completely confident in Marco Rubio’s candidacy for the Republican ticket. He proceeded to have arguably the worst debate performance in modern history in New Hampshire and was out of the running by March. We went from “Rubiowning it” to “Rubi-uh-oh” to “Rubiover” (sorry, puns are my everything). I guess I jinxed it. I don’t blame myself for making such a bold statement. Rubio reflected everything I figured a Republican candidate would need. He hailed from a competitive state (Florida), was fairly young, had a bipartisan record and spoke Spanish. I firmly believed in the “party decides” thesis — that the elites of a party nudge forward candidates they find most electable. Despite the norm, Trump won only a small handful of party endorsements before he clinched the nomination. But even once Donald Trump won the Republican primary, I was confident he had little to no chance of actually winning the presidency. While studying at the University of Oxford this semester, I attended a speech by a so-called expert in American politics. He seemed as sure of Hillary Clinton’s victory as he was of the sun rising the next day. It is clear that Americans were — to put it nicely — ticked off. Voters wanted something different from the status quo and were willing to vote for a man hardly qualified to play the board game “Risk.” This anger is certainly not isolated to the United States; the Brexit referendum is proof of similar anger in Europe. France and Germany both have big elections in the upcoming year, with the far right having a shot at the presidency in the former and a shot at a large parliamentary presence in the latter. Considering this is the my final column of the term, I believe a sentimental note is in order. I hope those isolated pockets of “The Arena” fans (anyone beyond my mother is a plus) have enjoyed reading this column as much as I have enjoyed writing it. From writing in Carm’s dining hall to London’s famed Gatwick Airport and even a cheaprate hotel in Dublin, I have had a blast. I am sure that for many, your ever-faithful columnist included, this election was a first chance to vote for the president. I hope my column convinced you to engage with our democratic system, no matter how you feel about its outcome. It is pretty remarkable how much I personally have changed throughout this process. Donald Trump’s election has put asterisks next to just about everything I thought I knew about politics. Our next president campaigned on erroneous and twisted statements, any one of which could have ended a political career. But the beast that is the electoral process spat him out as our president, and with that we must cope. Aren Torikian is a junior majoring in Economics and International Relations. He can be reached at Aren.Torikian@tufts. edu.

Monday, December 12, 2016

Reflections on 2016 To say that 2016 has been a turbulent year at Tufts is an understatement. Following the unforeseen results of the presidential election, controversies surrounding Greek life, a divisive free speech resolution and the tragic passing away of one of our very own professors, in many respects, 2016 was disheartening at the very least. And yet, despite these difficult moments, 2016 also saw a culmination of efforts to promote positive changes on campus. From the janitors successfully obtaining a fair contract agreement to University President Anthony Monaco’s pledge to support and protect undocumented students to the celebration of Tufts’ first Indigenous People’s Day, we have welcomed a variety of positive and progressive changes amidst a backdrop of campus-wide and national divisiveness and unease. Our campus found reason for optimism during a year of turmoil. In response to hateful dialogue and threats to inclusivity on the national level, we banded together to effect change in our own community. From volunteering for civic programs on campus to casting ballots and organizing rallies and protests, student involvement and activism have thrived this year.

The strong student response to issues that have been brought to light — in the form of op-eds in campus publications, open discussion groups, Tufts Community Union (TCU) Senate resolutions and discussions with administrators — have demonstrated our students’ ability to work proactively to promote change on this campus. Following the controversy surrounding our Greek organizations, student leaders, councils and the administration have come together and committed themselves to reworking existing policies and bettering the Greek community for members and non-members alike. While a consensus about how to combat issues within the Greek system has not yet been reached, our campus is engaging in a much-needed dialogue about how to address spaces in which not all students feel safe or included. Furthermore, the university’s commitment to protect its undocumented students proves that Tufts has the capacity to enact change on the campus level that can have national exposure. Following a student-organized walk-out, the administration heard student voices and responded. The Tufts Labor Coalition worked alongside 32BJ

Service Employees International Union (SEIU) to promote fair wages and working conditions for valued members of our campus community. Members of the Tufts community have proven that they are active and resilient in the face of challenges. If anything, 2016 was the year of the student. It was the year that we fought for and won the rights of on-campus workers. It was the year we celebrated and respected indigenous peoples by instituing Indigenous People’s Day and local efforts to support the fight against construction of the Dakota Access Pipeline. It was the year we fought for undocumented students in the face of national threats to citizenship. It was the year we continued to strive to bring down environments of exclusivity and misogyny on our campus. We must continue the fight to uphold the university’s stated values, which can only happen if the student body continues its trend of active engagement in the pursuit of a safe and equal campus for all. As students, we have already laid the groundwork for 2017 to be a better year so long as we keep up the effort.

APOLOGY: The Daily’s print edition on Friday, Dec. 9 included a misprint of an advertisement from the Residential Life and Learning Office on page 7 due to a publishing error. The advertisement has been reprinted in today’s edition on page 7.

The Tufts Daily is a nonprofit, independent newspaper, published Monday through Friday during the academic year, and distributed free to the Tufts community. The content of letters, advertisements, signed columns, cartoons and graphics does not necessarily reflect the opinion of The Tufts Daily editorial board. EDITORIALS Editorials represent the position of The Tufts Daily. Individual editors are not necessarily responsible for, or in agreement with, the policies and editorials of The Tufts Daily. OP-EDS The Op-Ed section of The Tufts Daily, an open forum for campus editorial commentary, is printed Monday through Thursday. The Daily welcomes submissions from all members of the Tufts community; the opinions expressed in the Op-Ed section do not necessarily represent the opinions of the Daily itself. Opinion articles on campus, national and international issues should be 600 to 1,200 words in length and submitted to oped@tuftsdaily.com. The editors reserve the right to edit letters for clarity, space and length. All material is subject to editorial discretion and is not guaranteed to appear in the Daily. Authors must submit their telephone numbers and day-of availability for editing questions. ADVERTISING All advertising copy is subject to the approval of the Editor-in-Chief, Executive Board and Executive Business Director.

Monday, December 12, 2016 | Opinion | THE TUFTS DAILY

Opinion

OP-ED

The university’s climate responsibility by Bruce Everett

Since the election, emotions have run high on campus concerning the new administration’s possible actions on climate. Junior Julia Hackel expressed this worry in her Nov. 29 Tufts Daily op-ed entitled “Climate action under Trump.” I have no intention of defending Mr. Trump or any of the comments he has made about climate change. However, I think we should take a moment for reflection on this important issue. In 1990, former University President Jean Mayer authored the Talloires Declaration, committing the university to the fight against carbon dioxide. In doing so, he changed the university from a center of learning and dialogue to a political advocacy organization, which valued commitment and action over analysis and understanding. President Mayer’s mistake was in seeing climate change as a moral crusade rather than as a scientific issue. When students come to Tufts, they are taught to think critically and question authority but not on the climate issue. On this issue, students are told that older, wiser and better-credentialed people have solved this problem beyond any doubt or debate and that opposition to the climate agenda is a moral failing. The university has even hired staff to promote this orthodoxy. In my 13 years of teaching at The Fletcher School of Law and Diplomacy, many students have told me privately that they disagree with or question the climate agenda but are afraid

to speak out for fear of censure by faculty and classmates. Before students accept the university’s orthodoxy, they might wish to consider the following points: Ms. Hackel refers to carbon dioxide as “pollution.” In fact, carbon dioxide is plant food and essential to all life on Earth. Carbon dioxide has been proven to increase crop yield and drought-resistance, leading to an observable greening of many areas of the planet. In a world of increasing pressures on food supply, the lives of the poorest and most vulnerable people in the developing world depend on our getting this right. Carbon dioxide is a greenhouse gas with a warming effect on the atmosphere. Some share of the modest warming we have experienced over the past 100 years or so is attributable to human emissions of this gas. There is virtually complete agreement on this point. The real scientific question is how much warming results from a doubling of atmospheric carbon dioxide — a parameter known as “climate sensitivity.” Contrary to the popular narrative, the UN Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) is agnostic on this critical parameter, stating that climate sensitivity could be anywhere between 1.5 and 4.5 degrees Celsius – in other words, between benign and apocalyptic. The IPCC provides no “best estimate.” Research suggests that climate sensitivity is in fact near or even below the bottom end of the IPCC range — on the order of two degrees celsius or fewer. At this sensitivity level, the carbon dioxide emissions

expected this century would be entirely beneficial to mankind. The climate change agenda rests on sensitivities of three to four degrees or even higher. These catastrophic scenarios come not from any actual evidence but from assumptions embedded in computer models that have never had any predictive ability. Such models are an extraordinarily weak foundation on which to rest critical public policy decisions. Should we really consider this situation “settled science?” It is often argued that impending climate disaster is already manifest in increased storms, rainfall, droughts, flooding and fires. This assertion is simply incorrect. Significant data indicates that weather patterns over the past 10 to 20 years have not been outside the bounds of natural variability. What we have witnessed instead is the impact of the economic and demographic growth of the last 50 years, which has pushed development into new areas and massively built up our coastlines. Therefore, storms now cause greater economic damage — not because the storms are more frequent or more severe but because there are more people and structures in their path. Economic development has also stressed water supplies in places like California, so that naturally occurring droughts are more painful than in the past. Ms. Hackel is particularly concerned about the future of the Paris Agreement on climate, but this accord needs to be scrutinized for its actual content, not for its symbolism. This agreement is nothing more than a set of promises to make promises. President Obama offered a mod-

2016: IT WAS YUGE

STEPHEN DENNISON

est but expensive reduction in U.S. carbon dioxide emissions, about a third of which took place before the agreement was signed. China has promised to do nothing other than continue its planned economic growth path. Ms. Hackel makes the odd claim that China, a country that gets twothirds of its energy from coal and less than five percent from wind and solar as of 2015, has made “tremendous progress in cleaning up emissions and innovating in the alternative energy sector.” The Paris Agreement will cost American taxpayers money, but have no measurable impact on the amount of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere. Even those who believe in catastrophic climate change should question this agreement. Catastrophic climate change remains a prediction, not a reality, and that prediction ought to be subject to scrutiny, analysis and debate. Slavery is a moral issue, but climate change is a scientific problem that cannot be understood by resort to moral reasoning. Evidence, not emotion, should rule. The university’s advocacy on climate change does a disservice to the community. The administration should encourage students and faculty to think critically, look at the evidence, make up their own minds and act accordingly and not pressure them to become missionaries for the administration’s viewpoint. Editor’s note: If you would like to send your response or make an op-ed contribution to the Opinion section, please email us at tuftsdailyoped@gmail.com. The Opinion section looks forward to hearing from you.

THE TUFTS DAILY | ADVERTISEMENT | Monday, December 12, 2016

tuftsdaily.com

trust your instincts. We can all have a hand in keeping our community safe from harm. A change in behavior indicating violence or a potential for violence is one of the first signs that something is wrong and a person needs assistance. When you think “it may be nothing, but…,” err on the side of caution, and let us know so we can intervene.

Threat assessment provides intervention for people exhibiting behavior that indicates violence or the potential for violence. Tufts Threat Assessment and Management is designed to prevent violence and keep our community safe. Call Tufts University Police: Boston: 617.636.6610 Grafton: 508.887.4900 Medford/Somerville: 617.627.3030

Email the TTAM team: threatassessment@elist.tufts.edu Make a report online using Ethics Point may be anonymous Consult with a TTAM team member

If you sense trouble, we can help Tufts Threat Assessment and Management ttam.tufts.edu School of Arts and Sciences

Monday, December 12, 2016 | Sports | THE TUFTS DAILY

Sports MEN'S BASKETBALL

Tufts outscores Wentworth, falls short to UMass by Maddie Payne Sports Editor

The Jumbos moved to 7-2 on the season on Saturday after a convincing 78-63 win over the Wentworth Institute of Technology Leopards (2-5). A tough loss on Dec. 6, courtesy of a buzzer beater by the UMass Boston Beacons (6-3), consigned the team to their second consecutive loss. Following the win on Saturday, however, the Jumbos look in better shape for their match up Tuesday against the Framingham State Rams (2-7). “On Tuesday, we got out to a slow start, we weren’t very focused and didn’t have energy from anybody, whereas on Saturday we knew it was a must-win game,” senior center Drew Madsen said. “We were very focused and had a lot of guys playing. Everybody came in ready to go.” Against Wentworth, Tufts came out to a better start than it did during Tuesday’s game. In the opening five minutes, the two teams remained level, scoring six apiece. The ball traveled up and down the court several times, with neither team able to finish their shots. Although the Leopards took the lead briefly at 9-8, the Jumbos went on a 7-1 run after junior guard Ben Engvall made a 3-pointer, and junior guard Everett Dayton and sophomore guard Ethan Feldman added two points each. After the Leopards tied the game up at 20-20 with eight minutes remaining in the first half, the Jumbos responded with eight consecutive points to retake the lead. Engvall registered another three-pointer, junior guard Stefan Duvivier and senior co-captain guard Tarik Smith each added a layup, and Dayton made a free throw to add to the lead. With five minutes remaining in the first half, the teams were both in the foul bonus, so consecutive fouls on the Jumbos allowed the Leopards several free throw opportunities. After junior guard Vincent Pace made a layup and a free throw, the Leopards answered with a three-pointer, meaning the Jumbos ended the half with a 35-32 lead. Senior co-captain center Tom Palleschi led the team to a dominant start to the second half and was individually responsible for seven of 12 unanswered points. The other points came from Pace (with three) and Dayton (with two). Jumping out to a 47-34 lead gave the Jumbos the momentum they needed, and they maintained the advantage for the rest of the game. As the second half progressed, the Leopards demonstrated a lack of discipline with their fouling. Wentworth offered up 10 free throw points in only two and a half minutes, of which Tufts made nine. With 7:33 remaining the Jumbos had racked up a 15-point lead, but the next four minutes saw a scoring drought that allowed the Leopards to briefly narrow the gap.

EVAN SAYLES / THE TUFTS DAILY

Senior center Drew Madsen dribbles down the court in the game against the UMass Boston Beacons on Dec. 6. Despite taking several timeouts and attempting to regroup, the Leopards could not catch the Jumbos, and the game ended 78-63. Pace led Tufts with 15 points, eight rebounds and four assists, while Dayton was close behind with 14 points, seven rebounds and three assists. The Jumbos had 13 turnovers in the game, partly due to their fast paced offense, which sometimes means that the team has less control than they would like. “One thing we have to do more is focus on our approach of getting the ball into the ball-handler’s hands,” junior guard KJ Garrett said. “So we look for our point guards in transition and make sure our ball-handlers can focus on running the offense. Once we get there, we will have fewer turnovers.” Garrett added that while turnovers are inevitable, they could be reduced. “I don’t think we average more turnovers than most teams we play, but we can definitely limit those,” he said. Tuesday was a different story from Saturday. The Jumbos got off to a slow start, allowing the Beacons to jump out to an 8-3 lead. Tufts could not stop UMass Boston’s senior center/forward Sam Freeman, who finished the game as the leading scorer with 26 points. Seven early points from Engvall kept the Jumbos competitive, while Feldman and Smith added threes of their own to take the lead 10 minutes into the game. The lead grew to 33-26 thanks to five points from Feldman and was extended even further to 39-28 with 3:42 remaining in the half. However, it was truly a game of momentum, and as fast as the Jumbos’ lead grew, it shrank just as quickly. The Beacons pressed the Jumbos hard and managed to decrease their deficit to 41-38 as the game went to halftime. In the second half, there were numerous lead changes as both teams went on scoring runs. The Beacons made two

two-pointers and two three-pointers to jump to a 48-43 lead. However, the Jumbos answered with three two-pointers to take the lead again. The remaining 14 minutes of the game were neck and neck, with the teams going nearly one for one until the Jumbos couldn’t finish several offensive possessions and the Beacons took a 72-65 lead with 1:33 left. Smith gave the Jumbos the opportunity to stay in the game with two three-pointers to tie the game at 74-74 with 19 seconds left. However, the Beacons had the final offensive possession and made sure to wind down the clock. At the last moment, Freeman scored a buzzer beating jump shot with one second left to win the game 76-74. The loss was an unpleasant surprise for the No. 5 Jumbos, having fallen to a second unranked team in as many games. While the team bounced back against Wentworth, the week revealed what the Jumbos needed to work on. Tufts was out-rebounded in both games and often missed second-chance points as a result. The slow start against UMass Boston demonstrated the necessity of having the right preparation, and the repercussions when they didn’t. “We know [rebounds are] definitely an issue,” Madsen said. “We have to focus on making sure that we have five guys going after it instead of one guy while everyone else watches it from the perimeter. We’ve been trying to hammer down in practice, and make sure that everyone is going after the ball. Hopefully we get it together before the conference starts.” Still, at this point in the season last year, the Jumbos had the same 7-2 record and went on to have one of their most successful seasons in history. The Jumbos have one last game in 2016, but in the new year, the pressure will be on to play more consistently, as they have five consecutive conference games between Jan. 6 and Jan. 20.

Gap closing between Tufts, first-place WashU LEARFIELD

continued from back season, respectively, while senior goalkeeper Scott Greenwood posted 12 shutouts in 19 games. Bowdoin knocked Tufts out of the NESCAC tournament, but Tufts received a bid to the NCAA Tournament on the strength of its regular season results. The Jumbos marched to the national semi-finals, dispatching four opponents without letting up a single goal. In the national finals game, junior midfielder Tyler Kulcsar was the hero, scoring the national championship winning goal in the 103rd minute of double overtime.

It was Kulcsar’s first goal of the season. Women’s volleyball Volleyball netted an impressive 27-4 record and posted a number of lengthy win-streaks this season. Tufts won its first eight games, including wins over NESCAC opponents Williams and Amherst while at home. From late September through October, Tufts went on an 11-game win streak, during which only two teams, Wesleyan and Middlebury, were able to take more than one set. The Jumbos were the heavy favorite going into the NESCAC Tournament, but were upset in the championship game by the Panthers. First-year outside hitter Brigid Bell led Tufts in kills

with 264 while senior co-captain middle hitter Elizabeth Ahrens was second with 219. Sophomore setter Angela Yu led the Jumbos with 680 assists and first-year libero Kelly Klimo posted a team-high 508 digs. In the NCAA tournament, the Jumbos blanked Maine Maritime Academy before defeating UMass Boston and Springfield 3-1 each. Tufts won the NCAA Regional Championship but fell to Southwestern University 3-2 in the NCAA Quarterfinal round to end its season. Ranking No. 5 nationally, volleyball added 73 points to the Directors’ Cup total.

Max Goder-Reiser Out of Left Field

12 Days of baseball

n the first day of Christmas, baseball gave to me: a Bartolo Colon home run. On the second day of Christmas, baseball gave to me: two David Ortiz stolen bases and a Bartolo Colon home run. On the third day of Christmas, baseball gave to me: three Mookie Betts home runs in one game (happened twice in 2016), two Ortiz stolen bases and a Bartolo Colon home run. On the fourth day of Christmas, baseball gave to me: four active players named Tom, three Betts home runs in one game, two Ortiz stolen bases and a Bartolo Colon home run. On the fifth day of Christmas, baseball gave to me: 5.06 ERA for Jered Weaver (third worst in baseball this year), four active players named Tom, three Betts home runs in one game, two Ortiz stolen bases and a Bartolo Colon home run. On the sixth day of Christmas, baseball gave to me: six Chris Sale complete games, 5.06 ERA for Weaver, four active players named Tom, three Betts home runs in one game, two Ortiz stolen bases and a Bartolo Colon home run. On the seventh day of Christmas, baseball gave to me: seven 110+ mph batted balls by Giancarlo Stanton, six Sale complete games, 5.06 ERA for Weaver, four active players named Tom, three Betts home runs in one game, two Ortiz stolen bases and a Bartolo Colon home run. On the eighth day of Christmas, baseball gave to me: eight consecutive Yoan Moncada strikeouts, seven 110+ mph batted balls hit by Stanton, six Sale complete games, 5.06 ERA for Weaver, four active players named Tom, three Betts home runs in one game, two Ortiz stolen bases and a Bartolo Colon home run. On the ninth day of Christmas, baseball gave to me: 9.4 Fangraphs Wins Above Replacement for Mike Trout, eight consecutive Moncada strikeouts, seven 110+ mph batted balls hit by Stanton, six Sale complete games, 5.06 ERA for Weaver, four active players named Tom, three Betts home runs in one game, two Ortiz stolen bases and a Bartolo Colon home run. On the 10th day of Christmas, baseball gave to me: 10 Daniel Murphy intentional walks, 9.4 fWAR for Trout, eight consecutive Moncada strikeouts, seven 110+ mph batted balls hit by Stanton, six Sale complete games, 5.06 ERA for Weaver, four active players named Tom, three Betts home runs in one game, two Ortiz stolen bases and a Bartolo Colon home run. On the 11th day of Christmas, baseball gave to me: 11 walks issued by Clayton Kershaw (!), 10 Murphy IBB, 9.4 fWAR for Trout, eight consecutive Moncada strikeouts, seven 110+ mph batted balls hit by Stanton, six Sale complete games, 5.06 ERA for Weaver, four active players named Tom, three Betts home runs in one game, two Ortiz stolen bases and a Bartolo Colon home run. On the 12th day of Christmas, baseball gave to me: 12 balks by the Cincinnati Reds (most in MLB), 11 walks issued by Kershaw, 10 Murphy IBB, 9.4 fWAR for Trout, eight consecutive Moncada strikeouts, seven 110+ mph batted balls hit by Stanton, six Sale complete games, 5.06 ERA for Weaver, four active players named Tom, three Betts home runs in one game, two Ortiz stolen bases and a Bartolo Colon home run. Thank you to everybody who read this column semester, which might have just been my parents, but nonetheless, it’s been a ton of fun writing these every week and hopefully imparting some baseball knowledge. Max Goder-Reiser is a senior majoring in biology. Max can be reached at max. goder_reiser@tufts.edu

16 tuftsdaily.com

Sports

Monday, December 12, 2016

Jumbos to make a run at Learfield Cup by Phillip Goldberg

Executive Sports Editor

Tufts finished fourth in Div. III in the Learfield Directors’ Cup last year, and after the fall season, it ranks No. 2 behind only Washington University in St. Louis. The National Association of Collegiate Directors of Athletics awards the Learfield Directors’ Cup to whichever school earns the most points in a predetermined set of sports by the end of the academic year. Sports teams earn points by their finish nationally. Tufts garnered 365.5 points through Dec. 8 — just 20 behind WashU at 385 and ahead of Calvin College’s 314 points. The sports under consideration were women’s and men’s cross country, women’s and men’s soccer, women’s field hockey, women’s volleyball and men’s water polo. Women’s cross country Tufts finished eighth out of 32 at the NCAA Championship on Nov. 19 after a successful season that included multiple meet championships and almost exclusively top five finishes. The Jumbos opened the season at the Bates Invitational where they earned first place behind third, fourth and fifth place finishes from junior Brittany Bowman, senior Kelly Fahey and sophomore Natalie Bettez, respectively. Bowman finished third at the Connecticut College Invitational, while Fahey and Bettez crossed in sixth and 11th place, earning Tufts first place out of a field of 21 teams. The Jumbos finished second to the Ephs in the NESCAC Championship race and Bettez was the runner-up with a time of 22:52.53. Bowman won the NCAA Regional Championship, overtaking MIT first-year Megan McCandless in the last 300 meters and setting a Stanley Park course record in 21:14.29. Tufts finished third at NCAA Regionals. In the National

Championship race, Bowman placed 18th, earning All-American honors and pacing Tufts en route to an eighth place finish that added 70.5 points to Tufts’ Learfield Directors’ Cup total. Men’s cross country Senior co-captains Luke O’Connor and Tim Nichols monopolized first and second place in just about every race this season. Their reign this season started at the Bates Invitational where Tufts placed second. Nichols crossed first in 25:11.9 and O’Connor was exactly 23 seconds behind him. The two posted Tufts’ best ever times at the Paul Short Invitational before again claiming first and second place at the Connecticut College Invitational. The Jumbos placed third at the NESCAC Championship where Nichols was the first Jumbo to claim an individual NESCAC title since 1981. In the spirit of setting records, Nichols set a Stanley Park course-record time at the NCAA Regional Tournament, crossing in 23:54.58. O’Connor finished third in 24:32.45. Tufts missed out on the NCAA Championship meet, but Nichols and O’Connor were invited thanks to their All-Region performances. Nichols ran a 24:09.7 for third place and the best-ever finish for a Tufts men’s cross country runner at nationals. O’Connor’s 24:42.2 earned him All-American honors. Despite the captains’ individual successes, the Jumbos ranked No. 33 nationally and added 32 points to Tufts’ Directors’ Cup total. Women’s field hockey Tufts came close to winning a national championship this season, losing in a shootout after a double overtime championship game. The Jumbos went 19-3 on the season and were undefeated for the entire month of September. Playing in the toughest conference in the country, Tufts dominated the NESCAC Tournament, besting Bates 2-0, over-

EVAN SAYLES / THE TUFTS DAILY

Junior Brittany Bowman runs at the Conn. College Cross Country Invitational at Harkness Memorial State Park on Oct. 15. whelming Williams 5-0 and outlasting Middlebury 3-1 in the championship game. Senior Annie Artz led the team with 14 goals on the season while junior Mary Travers posted nine goals to go along with a team-high eight assists. The Jumbos rolled through the NCAA Tournament all the way to the championship game, posting three shutouts against the University of New England, Skidmore and Salisbury, successively. The final contest against Messiah was a heartbreaking loss for Tufts, as Messiah won the shootout 2-1 and Tufts came as close as possible to a National Championship. The Jumbos added 90 points to the Directors’ Cup total. Women’s soccer Tufts finished the season 7-6-3 — an improvement from last season’s 6-8-2 finish — but still fell in the NESCAC quarterfinals. Despite a 5-4-1 conference record, the Jumbos were unable to overcome the Bantams in the NESCAC quarterfinals and fell 1-0. Senior for-

ward Jess Capone led the team with five goals while senior co-captain midfielder Robin Estus and sophomore defender Taylor Koscho assisted on a team high of four scores each. Women’s soccer did not receive a bid to the NCAA Tournament and therefore did not score in the Directors’ Cup. Men’s soccer Men’s soccer won its second national championship in three years this season and added 100 points to Tufts’ Learfield Cup total. After a slow 0-2-1 start, the Jumbos rattled off three straight shutout wins, including a 3-0 victory over NESCAC opponent Bates on Sept. 17. The Jumbos entered the month of October on a mission, refusing to lose for seven straight games and shutting their opponents out in all but two of the contests. Senior forwards Gaston Becherano and co-captain Nate Majumder led the Jumbos with 12 and four goals on the see LEARFIELD , page 15

WOMEN'S SQUASH

Jumbos off to hottest start in program history by Marc Weisglass Staff Writer

The Jumbos are off to an unprecedented start to their season. After wins against Bard College and Vassar College on Dec. 4, the Jumbos head into the holiday break with an undefeated record of 7-0. Tufts has shown in early performances that it has what it takes to make noise in the College Squash Association (CSA) and perhaps achieve an unprecedented NESCAC championship win. In their three games against their Bard opponents, first-years Claire Davidson and Sahar Tirmizi held their opponents to three and two points, respectively. However, Tirmizi faced a much closer match later that day against Vassar junior Cherylann Mucciolo. Tirmizi won that match 11-0, 11-5, 11-7. Davidson did not compete against Vassar but fellow first-year Catherine Shanahan did, winning her match 11-6, 11-0, 11-2 to secure two wins on Sunday.

Tufts has already defeated some of last years toughest challenges including St. Lawrence (6-3), Hamilton (6-3) and Colby (5-4), all ranked schools, with St. Lawrence and Hamilton both sitting higher than Tufts. Tufts is ranked No. 21 in the country in the most recent CSA rankings from Nov. 27. The Jumbos have moved up one spot from their preseason ranking and two spots from their ranking at the end of last season. They are only six wins shy of matching their win total from last season when they finished 13-9. A big factor in their early success has been the work put in by the players before their matches. “The training sessions, especially the preseason training and also the practice sessions and warmups have been pretty effective and have a lot to do with our general success,” sophomore Sahana Karthik said. Sophomore Chista Irani attributes their dominance to unbreakable chemistry. “This year the team’s dynamic is one of the main reasons why we have per-

formed so well in the first half of the season,” Irani told the Daily in an email. Another bright spot for the Jumbos comes from a strong first-year class, featuring Davidson, Tirmizi, Shanahan and Katherine Deveaux. Davidson was named the Harrow Sports College Squash Player of the Week last week and has an impressive record of 5-1 overall so far. In the team’s match against St. Lawrence, Davidson beat senior Emily Terry 11-9, 11-7, 3-11, 5-11, 11-7. Terry was ranked last season as one of the CSA’s top-80 players. The team is very young, with no seniors and the bulk of team coming from the sophomore class. In addition, the team is currently without some of its juniors who are currently studying abroad. By comparison, last year’s team was composed of no juniors and only one senior, so the team is familiar with its current circumstances. Karthik noted that the team’s firstyears are very talented and committed. “They’re definitely not inexperienced

and they bring their own expectations and their own goals,” Karthik said. “We don’t really have to set an example because we learn from them just as much as they learn from us.” The Jumbos will be looking to continue their undefeated streak after the long break. When Tufts returns from the holiday hiatus on Jan. 13, it will take on two-time First Team All-American Laila Samy and Wesleyan as well as Haverford at a trimatch hosted by Wesleyan. The Jumbos enter a difficult stretch prior to the NESCAC championship that includes matches against Bates, Colby and Conn. College, ranked 16th, 23rd and 29th in the country, respectively. At the moment, the young team is focused on giving its all on the court and staying spirited as both a team and as individuals. “The main goal is to keep up the focus and intensity in every practice as that really helps us prepare for some of our hardest matches,” Irani said.