WEDNESDAY i’m lovin’ it!
HIGH 89ºF LOW 79ºF
The Tribune Established 1903
24/7 BREAKING NEWS ON TRIBUNE242.COM
Biggest And Best!
VOLUME:115 No.225, OCTOBER 17TH, 2018
THE PEOPLE’S PAPER: $1
ALICIA WALLACE: DISNEY RALLY SHOWS WE HAVE TO BE BETTER
Post Office’s new landlord - Brent? Symonette owns property picked as five-year HQ By TANEKA THOMPSON Tribune News Editor and RICARDO WELLS Tribune Staff Reporter THE government is expected to bring a resolution to Parliament today which will allow the Minnis administration to rent facilities at the Town Centre Mall to house the General Post Office for a period of five years. While the move could bring an end to years of turmoil for workers at the facility and months of anguish for Bahamians that depend on its operations, it will also likely prove
controversial, as Town Centre Mall is partly owned by Brent Symonette, minister of financial services, trade and industry and immigration. The proposed rental agreement, if approved by Parliament, is expected to last five years, according to a draft document seen by The Tribune, until a new General Post Office is built through a public-private partnership. The proposed rental price is a “concessionary” rate of $12 per square foot, said to be “far below” the going SEE PAGE SIX
THE Bahamas’ major investment product was yesterday singled out for allegedly undermining the fight against global tax evasion in a move one realtor branded “a damn disgrace”. The Organisation for Economic Co-Operation and Development (OECD) caught the financial services industry and wider private sector off-guard by listing this nation’s
By NICO SCAVELLA Tribune Staff Reporter nscavella@tribunemedia.net
THE Court of Appeal has ordered a retrial for a man previously convicted of stabbing another man to death five years ago. The appellate court, in a 2-1 majority verdict, quashed Shadrach Gibson’s conviction and sentence concerning the death of Sidney Brian Hart in June 2013. Acting appellate Justices Sir Michael Barnett and Milton Evans both agreed Gibson should be retried because the trial judge did not properly direct the jury on how to treat evidence that Gibson was oppressed and/or beaten by police. SEE PAGE TEN
LIGHTHOUSE POINT D-DAY DELAYED FOR 72 HOURS
By RICARDO WELLS Tribune Staff Reporter rwells@tribunemedia.net
OECD RATTLES ITS SABRE ON INVESTOR RESIDENCY By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net
JUDGES ORDER ‘KILLER’ RETRIED
economic permanent residency offering among 21 incentive regimes it says jeopardise “the integrity” of automatic tax information exchange. The Ministry of Finance last night slammed as “false and misleading” descriptions of the OECD’s action as another “blacklisting”, saying officials who are currently in Paris had received assurances from the forum’s representatives that it was nothing of the kind.
HONEST, IT WON’T HURT...
FULL STORY - SEE BUSINESS
LAUGHTER during a practice session for the World Judo Championships yesterday at Atlantis. 491 competitors from 79 nations have arrived in The Bahamas to take part in the four-day competition, which starts today. See Sports for more. Photo: Shawn Hanna/Tribune Staff
WE’RE MAKING PROGRESS ON POACHING PLAGUE By MORGAN ADDERLEY Tribune Staff Reporter madderley@tribunemedia.net
BAHAMAS Commercial Fishers Alliance Vice President Keith Carroll yesterday described poaching as a “plague” that is afflicting the country and dubbed the weekend arrest of 124 Dominican poachers as
SOME of the Dominicans detained by the RBDF. “one of the best things” to have ever happened in the southern Bahamas.
Yesterday, the poachers, who engaged in a shootout with the Royal Bahamas Defence Force on the high seas before they were arrested, were brought to shore along with their three vessels and remanded to the Carmichael Road Detention Centre.
Nassau & Bahama Islands’ Leading Newspaper
SEE PAGE FIVE
THE government’s decision on Lighthouse Point is now expected to be made on Friday, Prime Minister Dr Hubert Minnis said yesterday. Cabinet was expected to make its final decision on which of the two proposals put forward for the property it would support, but in a brief interview with The Tribune yesterday, Dr Minnis said discussions on National Economic Council matters were pushed back to Friday to accommodate several ministers away on business. SEE PAGE TWO
CRUISE LINES LOSE REBATE WORTH $12M By NATARIO McKENZIE Tribune Business Editor nmckenzie@tribunemedia.net THE Minister of Tourism yesterday revealed the government could save $12m per year after it completely “scrapped” the tax incentive regime for cruise lines. Dionisio D’Aguilar, speaking ahead of a Cabinet meeting, said the departure tax rebates offered to the cruise lines had amounted to roughly $1m per month. FULL STORY - SEE BUSINESS
PAGE 2, Wednesday, October 17, 2018
THE TRIBUNE
Group hopes to breathe new life into long-stalled project By AVA TURNQUEST Tribune Chief Reporter aturnquest@tribunemedia.net STALLED Long Island project Port St George has been given new life, according to a press release announcing plans for an entirely off-grid five-star hotel and spa, 515 luxury homes, and a 640-berth marina. Star Resort Group Inc, in a statement yesterday, described the mixed-use development as the first “eco-engineered luxury waterfront destination” spanning from “coast to coast” featuring a 100acre protected harbour and an 18-hole golf course. When the project was unveiled in 2008, it was touted to create over 300 jobs on a 951.4-acre site in northern Long Island. According to Tribune Business, it featured plans for a boutique hotel with 146 suites/villas; 60 boutique villas; more than 300 residential lots and 331 multi-family lots; and marinas with numerous boat slips; plus golf courses, a town centre and other resort/community amenities. The project was projected to have an annual economic
AN ARTIST’s impression of the Port St George project on the Star Resort Group website. impact of between $54m to and other sporting facilities roadworthy, modified elec$90m, and at the time the include an Olympic-sized tric golf cart. “Port St George is taking developers had also signed pool and solar-powered a major step toward operata 25-year management watercraft. On its website, the pro- ing entirely off-grid through agreement with Langham Hotels International. Some ject states Langham Hotels extensive use of solar tiles 875 construction work- International will adopt a and storage batteries,” ers were forecast to be contemporary approach – a according to the release employed over the build- break from the tradi- issued yesterday. tion ‘grand hotel’ style of “The mixed-use developout phase. In 2014, developers Ian its city hotels. The hotel ment will be designed for Moorcroft and his business will reportedly occupy a those seeking an experience partner Jon Houghton were 27.2-acre site on the coast characterised by an authensaid to be hunting for a joint surrounded by water on tic Bahamian environment, luxurious, modern ameniventure partner to move three sides. There will be 500 condo- ties and an eco-friendly the proposed $110m Port St miniums and townhouses lifestyle.” George project forward. It continued: “Port In its release yesterday, and 15 luxury villas, accordStar Resort Group stated ing to the press release, St George will exemthe proposed marina will be which noted each home plify the next evolution the largest in the country, will be equipped with a of luxury destinations,
as eco-engineering and future-proofing is being incorporated into every aspect of the project. “An organic hydroponics farm will provide fresh fruits and vegetables, reducing the need for imported products. Food waste will be distributed directly from residential and commercial structures to a composting centre, which will reduce waste and create a product for soil enrichment. “Rainwater will be collected in cisterns and a solar-powered, reverseosmosis desalinization plant will convert seawater into fresh, drinkable water for
the development.” Yesterday’s release flagged market research by industry specialist Richard Ragatz, of Ragatz Associates, who found the project an “attractive and proven concept” noting the “strong resortresidential real estate market throughout the Bahamas, limited competition and apparent untapped markets in specific price levels.” Star Resort Group President Duane Gerenser said: “Port St George will serve as a vibrant oasis from which to explore the untouched wonders of Long Island. “The sustainable development will create an environment that is inclusive of the Bahamian people and local culture, an uncommon effort among many secluded luxury resorts. Mr Gerenser said: “The eco-engineered project will bring employment opportunities, provide athletic facilities and instruction to local schools, and offer a platform for artists, craftspeople, and entrepreneurs to thrive.” The Tribune tried to contact several government officials for comment yesterday, but up to press time received no response.
LIGHTHOUSE POINT D-DAY DELAYED FOR 72 HOURS from page one “Quite a number of the Cabinet ministers are away and we wanted as many as possible present, so we dealt with Cabinet matters (yesterday) and will deal with NEC (National Economic Council) matters on Friday at 10am,” he told The Tribune. Hours earlier, Press Secretary Anthony Newbold had suggested that some conclusions could have been made as early as yesterday afternoon, insisting that discussions on the property had been prioritised by Dr Minnis in the days following his recent trip to Eleuthera for a town hall meeting on the matter. “The prime minister did commit to discussing it this week and making a decision on it,” Mr Newbold said yesterday, “so, you will hear about all of those things, in all likelihood.” He added: “I know that there was some discussion about possibly releasing a statement this afternoon after Cabinet; not sure if that will happen. We don’t know what happens in the
Cabinet room. But, I am sure we will hear something about what is happening there, by the end of this week.” The One Eleuthera Foundation (OEF) and its coalition group Lighthouse Point Partners (LPP), is aiming to convince both the public and the government to back its bid for the multiacre property. LPP last Friday presented its 42-page proposal centred on establishing a Lighthouse Point National Park at the site to officials from the Office of the Prime Minister. Dr Minnis did not attend the meeting, according to a representative for the coalition. Since Friday, the group has requested the government delay its final decision and commence a national campaign to educate Bahamians on the proposals presented by both itself and Disney Cruise Lines. Additionally, the group has proposed constructing a sustainable development which will include a 100-unit eco-lodge and a learning and research centre with space to accommodate a
20-person class on a 100acre site adjacent to the national park. The coalition claims the project should yield permanent economic contributions of 190 jobs, $7.7m in annual earnings, $13.76m in economic output annually, $11.56m in annual GDP increase and $300,000 in annual NIB payments. Meanwhile, Disney has remained committed to its pitch to develop the property into one of the region’s top cruise ports, capable of generating millions in annual revenue. To date, neither Disney Cruise Lines nor the Lighthouse Point Partners (LPP), has carried out a full environmental impact assessment, which is required by law. Mr Newbold yesterday said he was not aware if any of the sides had moved closer to submitting an EIA. Lighthouse Point is currently owned by The Related Group, which has agreed in principle to sell the property to Disney Cruise Lines, pursuant to it getting clearance from the government for its proposed development.
THE TRIBUNE
Wednesday, October 17, 2018, PAGE 3
More than 500 fee increases for hospital ‘by end of year’ By KHRISNA RUSSELL Deputy Chief Reporter krussell@tribunemedia.net THE government is preparing for push back over more than 500 potential fee increases at the Princess Margaret Hospital to be implemented before year’s end, Health Minister Dr Duane Sands said yesterday, as he suggested civil servants may also be affected by the changes. He stressed that these fees will be “progressive”, meaning people with better financial means will pay more than the poor and most vulnerable. Speaking to reporters yesterday, Dr Sands noted the “missteps” regarding
the implementation of new fees at the morgue earlier this year, which were rescinded, adding it is clear now this issue comes down to a change in culture. “We need to ensure that we get it right so when we implement it, you know there would be some push back,” he told reporters yesterday before heading into a Cabinet meeting. “We’d like that push back to be not on the basis of something that was done inappropriately.” Asked if Bahamians would see the fees implemented by the end of the year, he said: “I believe you will.” He continued: “Bear in mind our goal is to make the
$6M FOR NEW FLEET OF POLICE VEHICLES By RIEL MAJOR
POLICE Commissioner Anthony Ferguson distributed more than 50 new vehicles, valued at about $6m, yesterday to various divisions and departments of the Royal Bahamas Police Force, including the new branch located in Grand Bahama. Commissioner Ferguson said: “Assembled you’ll see some happy looking officers. Right now, we have just over 34 vehicles issued today, we have also sent to the brand-new station that was recently opened in Grand Bahama, we have sent four vehicles there to that station, two Jeeps and two cars, so you can imagine by the next couple of months the station should be well equipped. “They will be presented with the keys and will drive off to go to those divisions and departments. I’m sure the Bahamian people will be very happy to know that officers are given more resources in order to make them safe. I expect to see
a large number of vehicles complement the ones that are currently on division and in department.” In total, 58 vehicles have been acquired. Speaking to reporters at Police Headquarters, the commissioner said this was only the first phase of vehicles being issued and the approval for the second phase is being finalised. He said the public should see increased police presence with the addition of the new cars. Commissioner Ferguson said: “You can expect to see more visibility, there are a number of vehicles on the road now but can you imagine what can happen when you see more vehicles out? That means more persons are mobile and could move around quickly and can respond to incidents and cover a wide area so it will act as a detour to criminals.” He continued: “Physically (we) will be in all of the communities particularly in those communities where you have high criminal
changes in the fee schedule fairly progressive and so its anticipated that people with more will pay more and so if you have insurance and that insurance is paid for by the people of The Bahamas, there is no reason why that insurance can’t be used to the benefit of the public health care system. “I mean Bahamians spend almost $80m a year buying insurance for people like me, for teachers, for nurses, for doctors, for defence force officers, etc. “And we also have rules that say civil servants don’t pay. Now if I were a civil servant, I would not want a change in policy to mean that I now have to reach
THE Minnis administration is well aware of the mounting issues at the Bahamas Department of Correctional Services, press secretary Anthony Newbold has said. Responding to questions on overpopulation at the facility and the lack of adequate funding, Mr Newbold yesterday told reporters that discussions are “ongoing” on ways to mitigate problems there. “There is always work going on with the prison,” Mr Newbold said when asked what was the government’s position on claims made by BDCS acting Commissioner Charles Murphy on Monday. Mr Newbold added: “… The prison is one of those institutions that requires or demands a lot of attention. And we know it has been overcrowded for years. So, whatever is happening over there, it is an ongoing situation where whatever funds can be provided are being provided. “Discussions are on going as to how you
mitigate the problems that are there.” “But it is something like, you know somebody asked me about the Princess Margaret Hospital; I was talking about the air conditioning being repaired and I was asked, you know, are you repairing the air conditioning as opposed to paying attention to the doctors - no. “It is one of many situations, one of many priorities, one of many serious situations that must be dealt with and the prison is like this. Now, those discussions continue,” he contended. On Monday, Commissioner Murphy revealed that the department was
existing financial arrangements, insurance plans, etc, which is not to say that we’re not going to be changing the fee schedule for the average person coming into the facility, but the goal is to have it weighted such that those with the ability to pay will pay more and we remain committed to the view that the least among us, the most vulnerable, the poor will not be denied health care services.” Last week, the heath minister told Tribune Business that implementing the 500 fees was not as simple as it may seem. He said the government would not accomplish its revenue targets if the fees fail to capture more than the
13 percent of persons currently paying for services at PMH. “I have said repeatedly that 87 percent of people who use services in our healthcare system don’t pay anything,” Dr Sands said at the time. “It’s all well and good to change the fee schedule, but if you’re still only getting 13 percent of persons paying the fees it’s not going to accomplish what you want. We are going to have to, in some cases, legislatively modify the approach and in other cases change some of the contractual agreements, some of the union agreements and so on. That process is not as simple as it may seem,” he said.
COMMISSIONER of Police Anthony Ferguson presented a new fleet of police vehicles to several departments yesterday. Photo: Shawn Hanna/Tribune Staff activity and we always talk about hot spots and we know where they are, and you know where they are, and we want to make sure you are safe while you are (Christmas) shopping. “We have them shopping areas, y’all know where y’all like to go and shop and you look around, I want you to see the patrol cars nearby, so criminals will see them and deter them from taking any kind of action they would wish to take.” The commissioner highlighted the importance of communities working along with the police officers to ensure a safer Bahamas. He said crime is trending down, adding police will continue to work to improve crime statistics. Commissioner Ferguson said: “All of us live here in the Commonwealth of The Bahamas, each and every one of us. The persons who visit the Commonwealth of The Bahamas, they love this place I love this place and so it’s very important that we come together as a
MINNIS ‘WELL AWARE’ OF CONCERNS OVER PRISON By RICARDO WELLS Tribune Staff Reporter rwells@tribunemedia.net
into my pocket. But if the people of the Bahamas are paying for a health plan why shouldn’t that plan benefit the primary healthcare institutions in the country as opposed to Cleveland Clinic (or) Jackson Memorial, etc? That don’t make no sense. “So when you look at the Road Act, the number of people mashing up cars and hurting people on the road is just out of control, but when those people come into the hospital, the public has to pay for them as opposed to the insurances. “But when we start talking about revising the fee schedule we are specifically looking to make sure that we are taking advantage of
using aspects of its new BAMSI-led agriculture initiative to “subsidise” portions of its budget due to overcrowding. According to numbers he presented, the maximum-security section of the facility, built to house around 200 inmates, currently sleeps over 1,000. Commissioner Murphy said the department’s population has ballooned to over 1,700 inmates overall. When asked by The Tribune if the issues of overcrowding and lack of adequate funding were affecting the aspects of the facility’s operations, Commissioner Murphy would only say: “Yes, I would think so.”
team and make it very difficult for criminals to operate in our community. “We are trending down, I think everybody can see that from the numbers in terms of homicides . . . Are we satisfied with the way armed robberies are?
Absolutely not and we will continue to do our best to make sure we bring it right down. “People have to understand and to give the commissioner an opportunity. He knows exactly what he wants to do, he
created the plan so allow him to really roll the plan out.” He also said the official crime statistics will be released at the end of the year and body cams will be introduced very soon to all frontline officers.
PAGE 4, Wednesday, October 17, 2018
THE TRIBUNE
The Tribune Limited NULLIUS ADDICTUS JURARE IN VERBA MAGISTRI “Being Bound to Swear to The Dogmas of No Master”
LEON E. H. DUPUCH,
SIR ETIENNE DUPUCH,
jamaaltheartist@gmail.com
Publisher/Editor 1903-1914 Kt., O.B.E., K.M., K.C.S.G., (Hon.) LL.D., D.Litt .
Publisher/Editor 1919-1972 Contributing Editor 1972-1991
EILEEN DUPUCH CARRON,
C.M.G., M.S., B.A., LL.B. Publisher/Editor 1972-
Published daily Monday to Friday
Shirley & Deveaux Streets, Nassau, Bahamas N3207 TELEPHONES
News & General Information Advertising Manager Circulation Department Nassau fax Freeport, Grand Bahama Freeport fax
(242) 322-1986 (242) 502-2394 (242) 502-2386 (242) 328-2398 (242)-352-6608 (242) 352-9348
WEBSITE, TWITTER & FACEBOOK www.tribune242.com
@tribune242
tribune news network
Why exercise is still important to weight loss “EXERCISE isn’t really important for weight loss” has become a popular sentiment in the weight loss community. “It’s all about diet,” many say. “Don’t worry about exercise so much.” This idea crept out amid infinite theories about dieting and weight loss, and it quickly gained popularity, with one article alone citing 60 studies to support and spread this notion like wildfire. The truth is that you absolutely can – and should – exercise your way to weight loss. So why is anyone saying otherwise? For 10 years, I have been studying the epidemic of failed weight loss attempts and researching the phenomenon of hundreds of millions of people embarking on weight loss attempts – then quitting. In the meantime, exercise remains the most common practice among nationally tracked persons who are able to maintain weight loss over time. In fact, 90 percent of people who lose significant weight and keep it off exercise at least one hour a day, on average. How the myth got started, and rebuttals There are a few reasons that exercise for weight loss gets a bad rap. First, the public is looking, in large part, for a quick fix – and the diet and weight loss industry exploits this consumer desire for an immediate solution. Many studies have shown that exercise changes your body’s composition, improves your resting metabolism and alters your food preferences. These plain and simple facts have stood the test of time, but go largely unnoticed compared to most sensationalized diet products (change through exercise over time is a much tougher sell than a 5-day “cleanse”). Moreover, many people consider one hour a day for exercise to be unreasonable or undoable, and find themselves looking elsewhere for an easier fix. Second, the unknown. Doctors and nutritionists have done a poor job of explaining the link between exercise and dietary habits, perhaps because they often exist as separate camps. Exercise directly changes our dietary habits, which means we actually have an easier time making healthier choices when engaged in exercise over time. Without exercise, abrupt changes in dietary habits, especially if they result in calorie restrictions, are very difficult for dieters to sustain. In addition, the longer we make those healthy choices, the more likely they will become habit. For example, when a 42-year-old female who is 5 foot 4 inches and 240 pounds decides to lose weight on her own, she is likely to struggle with abruptly switching her food choices
to vegetables and broiled fish, mostly because she will feel overwhelming hunger pangs (but also for other reasons, like new onset fatigue, soreness, depression and irritibality, among other things). However, if we take that same person and increase his or her exercise capacity to a critical point, those choices become much easier to endure. Third, limited capacity. Exercise originally got demoted following a series of studies that enrolled overweight or obese folks looking to lose weight who had limited ability to exercise. Asking someone with limited ability to exercise to lose weight using exercise is like telling someone to empty a pool full of water with a plastic cup. It cannot be accomplished in any reasonable amount of time. So, when you measure how much weight they can “burn off” over time, the answer is not much, because most sedentary patients can burn 500 or fewer calories a week. As a result, the shaky conclusion that exercise was less important for weight loss emerged and was quickly sensationalised. What is missing from this logic, though, is that people can change exercise capacity. As exercise capacity goes up for an otherwise sedentary individual and approaches that of a lean person, the ability to lose weight with exercise dramatically changes. If you give a man a bucket… It’s like giving the participant in our pool-emptying example a bucket, or even a hose. The ability to jog for 30 minutes uninterrupted, or ride a bicycle for 60 minutes, is what separates so many would-be dieters from their lean counterparts and accounts for most tried and failed weight loss attempts. Moreover, once a person achieves a critical point of exercise capacity, the experience of exercise itself becomes more pleasant, and the experience can even be fun. So, can you exercise your way to weight loss? Absolutely. Of course abrupt calorie restrictions will result in weight loss for the short run, but it is extremely difficult for folks to maintain that restriction for significant lengths of time, and most either end up quitting or regaining lost weight. Exercise, though, is a tried and true way to make dietary changes more tolerable. Focusing on exercise and changing exercise capacity first makes it easier to ultimately make better food choices and enjoy clean living, which in the end means significant weight loss that can be maintained over time. By David Prologo of Emory University. First published in The Conversation
Thanks to Mr Nygard EDITOR, The Tribune I WRITE this letter to express my personal feelings about the kindness and profound generosity toward me and my sick child from Mr. Peter Nygard. My child was in hospital with cancer and needed special treatment. I approached Mr Nygard with regards to assist me with the financing of his hospital stay in the United States of America. Mr Nygard was more than accommodating as he
gave us his total support. He made us feel like we were his own family, he was there every step of the way. Most of the time I did not speak to him directly, but he made it known that whenever I needed anything he was to be told and he got right on it. I can truly say that this gentleman was very thoughtful, kind and concerned and many people can attest to this because I know of similar cases that he took care of personally. I see the way that he is
being treated but I am not here to justify anything that he has done. Nothing can stop me from singing his praises as a humanitarian and I know that many Bahamians would agree with me. Why are we so anxious to pull people down, when we have many things that we ourselves are not proud of. He that is without sin, cast the first stone. ELIZABETH HEPBURN Nassau October 16, 2018
Time for the Post Office to deliver EDITOR, The Tribune I AM wondering if it is possible for our Post Office, could offer some partial service, with regards to placing mail(s) in our boxes. Having paid for a letter box in January, and having
to stare into an empty box for the past four weeks on my twice weekly visit. I am not sure if the Postal Department is out of business, or whether there are weird games being played. It is obvious that mails are in the building, because I can see them piled up on a
stand, when I look through my box. Perhaps the Post Master is not aware of this! I do hope something could be done soon, to remedy this situation. K KELLY Nassau October 1, 2018.
A lifeline we must throw EDITOR, The Tribune
LETTERS
CERTAIN so-called opinion leaders have worked themselves into letters@tribunemedia.net quite a lather because the government has stepped into the breach to stop portfolio struggled with what surely looked like an rooms reportedly being economic tsunami hitting sold at wholesale to tour operators for as little as $50 Grand Bahama. Some seem to think that a night. Hutchinson also joined there is no role for the government in our economy, with the St Georges and conveniently forgetting that the Haywards in ventures around the world the gov- with the Port Authority on ernment is often the largest Grand Bahama including the Development Complayer in the economy. Candidate Dr Hubert pany and the international Minnis came into our living airport. Imagine two private famrooms in 2016 and said he was going to govern with ilies and a foreign investor empathy and with an eye owning the Lynden Pinon protecting the displaced dling International Airport and downtrodden. It is in Nassau. But we subjected surprising now how many Grand Bahamians to this in people are shocked when as the name of “efficiency”. The experiment didn’t prime minister he is doing work. Today the airport has just that. Since taking office, one of the highest costs for Minnis has put on his super- airlines in the entire Caribman cape and is standing bean. Enough airlines don’t up for the so-called “small come because the costs are man” in our economy. too high. And the costs Why then are we surprised are high because enough when he throws a lifeline to airlines don’t come. It’s a vicious circle. Grand Bahama? Meanwhile, because The ills that befall Grand governments Bahama did not start under previous this FNM Government. were desperate to appease Previous governments anyone interested in operhave looked the other way ating on Grand Bahama, because Freeport, the eco- even Hutchinson Whamthey negotiated nomic engine room of Grand poa, Bahama, was always a quasi- “stop-loss” clauses and generous incentives that public-private partnership. That model worked for put taxpayer dollars into a time before an inter- investors’ pockets even as necine war broke out it became harder to classify between the second and some hotels as “going conthird generation pri- cerns” in the accounting vate sector owners of sense of the term. When hurricane Matthew the Grand Bahama Port Authority. Then we hit a few years ago, some enticed the deep-pocketed investors took the insurChinese owners of the ance payout and bailed. successful port operations Meanwhile our fellow citithere to branch out into zens on Grand Bahama had areas that seemed outside their lives turned upside down from the attendant their Bahamas remit. Hutchinson Whampoa uncertainty and economic have their tentacles in instability. The prime minister many industries, including the hotel business in would be guilty of politiHong Kong. Somehow, cal malpractice if he did they allowed themselves to not step in and try to right be swung and they bought the sinking Grand Bahama ship. hotels in Freeport. For years Grand Bahama One of their hotels, the Harbour Grand Kowloon, was essentially a cash cow across the bay in Hong sending probably billions Kong is a super luxury five- of dollars to the national star property where rooms treasury. What’s wrong average $500 a night but, with us pitching in to throw while their Hong Kong them this lifeline in their hotels command top dollar, time of need? Instead we the Freeport hotels in their pile on with superfluous
drivel about the government not running or owning hotels. Any government when it is elected automatically inherits a mandate to keep the labour force in work. What is conveniently forgotten is the fact that Hutchinson Whampoa purchased the hotels from the Hotel Corporation in the first place at a price no doubt way less than the $65 million we are now paying to buy them back Ideally government should induce the private sector to provide jobs but when investors don’t, won’t or can’t then the government must step up to prevent the massive loss of jobs (and tax receipts) which lead to higher unemployment, a severe hit to our GDP and, as has happened elsewhere, could lead to currency devaluation There are legitimate questions that the Government still has to answer to settle the country down and get us all behind this policy. We need to know how much it is going to cost to renovate and spruce up the hotel, retrench some staff and retrain others. Then there are marketing and promotional expenses. Together these could be as much as the purchase price. The bigger question is the one hiding in plain sight. When is the government going to stop the dysfunction on Grand Bahama by facilitating the purchase of the omnipresent Grand Bahama Port Authority, or simply bite the bullet and buy it? That should be the centre-piece of a northern strategy that will help first and foremost the people of Grand Bahama and, secondly, it will hand a political windfall to the party with the guts to do it. And if they want to set the cat amongst the pigeons and keep Hutchinson Whampoa on their toes at the same time, government could ask an entity like Dubai Ports World to run it for them. THE GRADUATE Nassau October 15, 2018
THE TRIBUNE
Wednesday, October 17, 2018, PAGE 5
OUR RELATIONSHIP WITH DOMINICANS IS STRONG, SAYS HENFIELD
By KHRISNA RUSSELL Deputy Chief Reporter krussell@tribunemedia.net
FOREIGN Affairs Minister Darren Henfield admitted yesterday Dominican poachers continue to pillage Bahamian territorial waters despite efforts to discourage the practice in that country dating back to the former Christie administration, but insisted the government’s relationship with the republic is “firm and strong”. He expressed confidence the Bahamian government’s message is resonating with these foreign officials, noting the latest detention of 124 Dominican fishermen and their “motherships” was a collaborative effort, an historic first. While, he said, this is a sign the government is making progress,
the minister encouraged Bahamian fishermen to call the relevant authorities at the sight of Dominican vessels on the high seas rather than engaging them. His comments came as 124 Dominican fishermen were brought into the Coral Harbour Defence Force Base and then taken to the Carmichael Road Detention Centre after they fired upon marines at sea. What appeared to be thousands of pounds of fish and lobster was found on the three vessels, which were also brought to the capital yesterday. “I believe our relationship with the Dominican Republic is firm and strong,” he said. “We have done things in the past. Formerly, the foreign minister who was in office just before me (Fred Mitchell) led a delegation
to the Dominican Republic with ministerial colleagues and other technocrats to discuss this very issue of Dominican fishing in Bahamian territorial waters. “We had a good response then and we met yesterday with a technical team, a committee designed to continue with these discussions. We have been engaged with the Dominican Republic since coming to office. I myself have met with the Dominican foreign minister in bilateral meetings and international meetings that we attend where we discuss how do we continue. “In the previous version the minister came away with some firm agreements from the Dominican Republic which encouraged us. Some of these issues were that navy to navy, the defence force and the Dominican navy would
talk and be able to cooperate in these instances that communications would be made locally in the Dominican Republic touting the dangers and illegality associated with fishing in Bahamian territorial waters and that even as it relates to trade of our fisheries resources with the Dominican Republic, which surely is a need of marine resources that we could make some agreements in that regard, and we look to build upon those talks and solidify what we would think to be a relationship between ourselves, Cuba and the Dominican Republic that would mitigate and ameliorate these circumstances of Dominicans fishing in Bahamian waters and then drifting in to Cuba.” Asked if he was confident the government’s message was hitting
home with Dominican officials, he said: “I think the confidence that our message is hitting home is the fact that we were able to have assistance in this arrest with the Cuban government. “That is very important that the Cuban ambassador, my director general, myself and the Cuban foreign minister were in conversations all day Saturday and working out the details of how we would continue the pursuit from Bahamian waters into Cuban territorial space. I think at the end of the day, it all bodes well because we have been able for the first time in the history of The Bahamas to have three Dominican vessels. “You know earlier this year we had a smaller vessel handed over to us after an arrest of a Dominican poaching vessel in our waters.”
Pintard promises stiffer penalties against poachers By MORGAN ADDERLEY Tribune Staff Reporter madderley@tribunemedia.net MARINE Resources Minister Michael Pintard yesterday promised stiffer penalties for poachers caught in Bahamian waters as he described as “tragic” the quantity of undersized lobsters caught by the 124 Dominican poachers who were arrested over the weekend. Mr Pintard said Cabinet is set to review tougher amendments to the Fisheries Act, promising the government will continue to be aggressive against poachers. The poachers, who engaged in a shootout on Saturday with Royal Bahamas Defence Force on the high seas before they were arrested, were brought to the capital yesterday morning and remanded to the Carmichael Road Detention Centre. Mr Pintard could not confirm at the time whether the poachers will be charged with attempted murder, adding the investigation is continuing. However, he predicted the $3m fine levied against 46 Dominican poachers in August will “pale in comparison to what will come in the future, as well as the time spent incarcerated.” RBDF Commodore Tellis Bethel added that this was the largest arrest that has taken place in the last year. After the three steelhulled Dominican vessels were docked at the RBDF Coral Harbour Base, Mr Pintard, law enforcement officers, and members of the press were allowed to tour the severely rusted boats and see the torrid living conditions on the vessels. Speaking to reporters on the docks, Mr Pintard
expressed concern about the impact poaching has on the sustainability of the country’s marine life. “When you go on these vessels, you (can) clearly see that the poachers who are coming in our waters have no concern about future generations, whether they are Bahamians or others, who we feed by virtue of the fact that the Bahamas is a breeding ground for a number of marine species,” Mr Pintard said. “It is tragic when you go into the hold and you see the amount of catch, the fact that so many of the lobsters that have been caught and fished are undersized.” Mr Pintard added it is “too early to tell” the estimated dollar value of the haul, noting this will be reported after fisheries officers and the Ministry of Finance have done their inspections. “In November, the Fisheries Act which will be amended, will go to the Cabinet of the Bahamas, which calls for far stiffer penalties for those persons who are captaining these vessels as well as those persons who are working on these vessels in tremendously bad conditions,” Mr Pintard continued. “So you can expect that we’re going to continue to be aggressive and we’re going to continue to produce results.” “If you…recall, we inspected the ‘Ronnye’ several weeks ago, and the catch on these vessels far exceed the catch on that vessel,” Mr Pintard said. On July 8, RBPF vessel HMBS Madeira arrested 46 Dominicans aboard their vessel “Ronnye” approximately 20 nautical miles south east of Cay Lobos. HMBS Madeira was under the command of Senior Lieutenant William Sturrup. Approximately
33,000 pounds of fishery products were confiscated from the Dominican vessel at the time. Sr Lt Sturrup and HMBS Madeira also led this most recent arrest and was the ship that engaged in gunfire with the poachers, after the Dominicans were reportedly the first to fire at the marines. Sr Lt Sturrup spoke to reporters yesterday as well, describing the incident. “On Friday past, HMBS Madeira was dispatched from HMBS Coral Harbour base on routine patrol,” he said. “While in the area of the southern Bahamas, near Cay Lobos, we got reports from base that there was a likelihood of Dominicans operating in that area. “Upon approaching that area we noticed the Dominicans’ small skiff and three ships. We pursued them. They headed towards Cuba, only 14 miles separating the Bahamas. In the channel we made an attempt to board the vessel. They resisted with violence…[firing] at us. We exchanged. We were unable to stop them before they left Bahamian waters.” Sr Lt Sturrup could not provide any information on the number of weapons that were uncovered or the number of shots fired, saying the matter is still under investigation. However, he confirmed that no Dominicans were injured. “We interviewed them, we searched them before they came on our ships and no one had any injuries on them,” he said. He added language barriers are overcome through language apps and bilingual poachers who sometimes serve as translators. Sr Lt Sturrup noted the Coral Harbour base assisted them with the chase and coordinated
WE’RE MAKING PROGRESS ON POACHING from page one Mr Carroll was among the fishermen present at the RBDF Coral Harbour Base as this occurred. The fishermen hoped that the arrest would inspire stricter anti-poaching legislation and that Cuba’s role in the operation will deter others from following suit. Their remarks were echoed by Press Secretary Anthony Newbold, who noted during his press briefing yesterday that fishermen “complain for good reason.” However, Mr Newbold could provide no further updates on legislation, saying that matter has to go through the Office of the Attorney General. “For the fishing industry, especially for the southern Bahamas, this (is) one of the best things that ever happened down there; getting these boats, these amount of men from off our banks and knowing that the Cuban government and the Americans are now working with the Bahamas government to combat this plague that was going on in this country for so long,” Mr Carroll told The Tribune.
He also described the poachers’ use of gunfire as “attempted murder,” adding the justice system should therefore handle this case “the same (way) that they do with anybody else who try to kill somebody, especially an officer.” “These young (marines) go out to sea to protect us and that’s what happened to them,” Mr Carroll continued. “The Bahamas government gotta do something about this.” He called for stricter punishments in these matters, particularly for upper level crew members. “These boats that come here, the majority of (their) crew… don’t know exactly where they going when they leave Santo Domingo,” he said. “It’s really the captain. The captain decides where you go. So, I think that the captain, the mate, and the engineer, if they would give them just say…’if you get caught in the Bahamas, you get up to 20 years hard labour.’ They’ll think twice about coming in the Bahamas knowing that if they get caught, they’re going to spend time.” Mr Carroll added that in
his estimation, the amount of crawfish found on a single one of the Dominican’s vessels were worth a million dollars — far more than the fines often levied against poachers in the Bahamian judicial system. Meanwhile yesterday, Mr Newbold said poaching legislation is something that the Office of the Attorney General has to put together. “You know, talking about poachers, people complain for good reason; fishermen complain for good reason,” Mr Newbold added. Referring to this latest arrest and the recent repairs made to RBDF vessel HMBS Bahamas in the Netherlands, Mr Newbold said all these endeavours are done “to make sure that our borders are protected as much as we can.” “(National Security Minister Marvin) Dames, of course, spoke about that (Monday) as well, a whole wide-ranging effort to make sure that those uniform branches are at the point where they can do the kind of job that they are mandated to do, which is to protect our borders,” Mr Newbold said.
DOMINICANS detained by the RBDF.
with Cuba. However, he could not say what happened to the Dominicans in Cuban waters. According to a RBDF statement released on Sunday, one of the Dominican vessels ran aground in those waters. Commodore Bethel
noted this has been the largest arrest in the last year. “This is the fifth arrest of (a) Dominican vessel for the year,” he said. “Very proud of the work that Sr Lt (Sturrup) and his crew members have done, because out of
the five vessels that have been arrested this year, he and his crew account for four of those arrests, totaling almost 200 Dominican poachers. So very proud of what they’ve done and we will continue with this effort.”
BOUYGUES BATIMENT INTERNATIONAL, MSC Ocean Cay Marine Reserve, is seeking for its
PROJECT ENVIRONMENTAL OFFICER POSITION SUMMARY: The candidate will be required to assist with the Company’s Environmental Management System (EMS) administration, incident reporting, corrective action follow up, Environmental audits and advisory functions to all project employees as required. RESPONSABILITIES: • • • • • • • • • • • • •
Implement relevant environmental management programs. Conduct project site environmental impact assessments. Implement and maintain environmental education awareness programs. Ensure that environmental management system requirements are implemented and maintained and follow up on all aspects requiring legal compliance. Review and update Company’s environmental procedures and policies when necessary. Maintain a system of reporting environmental incidents and review of recommendations to rectify deviations. Conduct weekly and monthly environmental inspections and audits based on project requirements. Updating and delivering employee training programs related to hazardous materials and waste. Maintaining accurate records related to chemical inventories. Submitting clear and concise written reports based on field inspections. Recommending and coordinating the development of programs needed by the Company to comply with hazardous materials regulations. Provide support as needed on the execution of the Company Health & Safety Management System. Back up the Company’s Health & Safety Officer in the performing of his duties when required.
EXPERIENCE & QUALIFICATIONS: • • • • • • • • • • •
Bachelor’s degree or higher biological science and /or NEBOSH national Diploma in Environmental Management. Diploma or certificate on Health & Safety will be an asset. Minimum of 2 years’ experience in the field of environmental management (preferably Construction sites). Good verbal and written communication in English. Good knowledge on Health & Safety Management System & OHSAS 18001 Standards. Experience with waste and water management practices or with natural resource conservation. Working knowledge of ISO 14001 requirements and Local Bahamians Regulations. Experience with waste and water management practices or with natural resource conservation. Advanced computer literacy is essential. Technical knowledge of risk assessment and evaluation, environmental management tools, programs and systems. Effective interaction with clients, customers, officials, contractors and others
Please email resumes to recruitment@bouygues-bahamas.com for consideration
PAGE 6, Wednesday, October 17, 2018
THE TRIBUNE
Post Office’s new landlord - Brent? from page one rate for business premises in the country, the document also states. The Tribune was told Mr Symonette was not a part of Cabinet discussions about the rental and will not be present in Parliament whenever a debate occurs on the resolution. When contacted yesterday, Mr Symonette said he was in Miami, Florida, adding he knew nothing about the proposed rental of the property. “I’m not sure because I have been out of town so I wasn’t part of Cabinet today. I’m at a conference in Miami,” Mr Symonette said yesterday. He also said: “I wouldn’t have been part of any Cabinet discussions on that.” Yesterday, a well-placed source told this newspaper the matter will be debated in Parliament to ensure transparency. “The government is trying to resolve the issue of the post office because Christmas is coming and too many people have been working without an efficient post office,” the source said. “After searching, Town Centre Mall, which had been recommended under the former government, the government has looked at it again and government will be debating that matter (today) in the interest of transparency.” The Christie administration had looked at relocating the General Post Office to the Town Centre Mall during its last term, but
THE TOWN Centre Mall, which could house the post office in a five-year deal. ultimately decided to enter into a public-private partnership (PPP) to construct a new building at the Independence Drive Shopping Centre opposite the mall instead. Tribune Business previously reported that project was placed on hold following traffic flow-related complaints from local residents and concerns over whether proper due diligence had been conducted. After the Minnis administration assumed office, officials announced it had acquired the old Phil’s Food Services building on Gladstone Road to house the General Post Office. But last month, Transport Minister Renward
Wells revealed the government had gone back to the drawing board on plans to relocate the facility. Mr Wells, at the time, said while the government had identified the old Phil’s building as a possibility, Cabinet had discovered it would cost more to renovate the building than it had budgeted. “We anticipated it was going to be about $4m to renovate the building,” Mr Wells said last month. “Obviously it is a whole lot more than that and the Ministry of Works is now going through the whole design process as to how we get that done so we’re looking over the next week or
two to being able to come back with a subsequent stop gap measure. “We’re looking at something else that we may be able to do in regards to the post office so we can get the post office fully functioning while we look at the finished site as to where the post office is going to be.” The Tribune was told yesterday by a government source that the needed renovations at the Phil’s building are extensive and it will take “a least a year to get that done”. Meanwhile yesterday, press secretary Anthony Newbold told reporters Cabinet was expected to make a final decision on
REQUEST FOR EXPRESSIONS OF INTEREST
INDIVIDUAL CONSULTANT
Procurement Officer for (1) The Climate Resilient Coastal Management and Infrastructure Program and (2) Airport Infrastructure Program
Institution: Inter-American Development Bank Country: The Commonwealth of The Bahamas Projects: (1) Climate Resilient Coastal Management and Infrastructure Program and (2) Airport Infrastructure Program Project Number: (1) BH-L1043 and (2) BH-L1041 Loan Number: (1) 4363/OC-BH and (2) 3907/OC-BH Sector: (1) Environment and Natural Disasters and (2) Transport Deadline: October 19, 2018 The Ministry of Public Works (MOPW) is seeking an experienced Procurement Officer or Consultant to ensure smooth and quality implementation of procurement processes for both the (1) Climate Resilient Coastal Management and Infrastructure Program and (2) Airport Infrastructure Program, financed by the Inter-American Development Bank, and implemented by a dedicated Project Implementation Unit (PIU) within the MOPW. The position will be based in the PIU. . The main activities are as follows: • • • • • • •
• •
•
responsible for all project related procurement/bidding services related to the Programs components, and will facilitate the implementation of planned activities in a timely manner. Prepare and maintain updated Procurement Plans and Monitoring Plans for the Program Provide day-to-day active technical support and advice to the PIU/Program Coordinator Negotiate with consulting firms or individuals the procurement of goods, services and works necessary for the implementation of activities under each of the project components Prepare reports and report on project procurement matters to the PIU/Program Coordinator Understand and ensure application of IDB procurement policies and procedures Support the PIU/Program Coordinator in the preparation of key documents as per Monitoring &Evaluation Plan for the PIU, including comparison between planned and actual progress in physical and financial terms and identification of procurement delays and recommendations for actions Monitor progress of contracts implementation to ensure that it aligns with the stipulated standards, procedures and procurement timetable Prepare specific procurement documents, e.g. Tender Documents, Requests for Quotations, Requests for Expressions of Interests and Request for Proposals for new activities as required. Preparation of Evaluation of Tender reports Guide and participate in the evaluation for pre-qualification of the contractors, expressions of interest for short listing, tenders and proposals and in preparing the corresponding reports
Summary of experience and qualifications: • Bachelor’s degree in procurement, business administration or other related areas • At least three (5) years of work experience in procurement of goods and services, particularly in civil works • Knowledge on national rules and legislations in the field of procurement and civil construction/engineering • Knowledge and/or experience in Ministry and IDB procurement policies and procedures, or other standards set forth for a procurement is an advantage The Government of The Commonwealth of The Bahamas now invites eligible consultants to indicate their interest in providing procurement services. Interested consultants should provide their CV’s and information demonstrating that they are qualified to perform the services (description of similar assignments, experience in similar conditions). The duration of the contract is two (2) year full-time with the possibility of being renewed based on satisfactory performance evaluation. Consultants will be selected in accordance with the procedures set out in the Inter-American Development Bank: Policies for the Selection and Contracting of Consultants Financed by the Inter-American Development Bank GN-2350-9 and is open to all eligible bidders as defined in the policies. Interested consultants may obtain further clarification on the technical aspects or scope of services from Robert Mouzas, Deputy Director, Ministry of Public Works robertmouzas@bahamas.gov.bs tel: (242) 302-9530 during office hours between 09:00am to 5:00pm Monday – Friday, except on public holidays. Expressions of Interest inclusive of CV’s must be submitted to the address below in person, by e-mail idbfiairports@bahamas.gov.bs or idbcoastal@bahamas.gov.bs or by mail, on or before October 19, 2018 at 4pm. Antoinette Thompson –Permanent Secretary Acting Ministry of Public Works REF:- Climate Resilient Coastal Management and Infrastructure Program /Airport Infrastructure Program P.O. Box N 8156,Nassau, Bahamas
how to proceed with remedying issues surrounding the dilapidated post office. Mr Newbold told reporters that discussions in Cabinet yesterday would be about the situations surrounding the property and its relocation. “I want to first apologise to the Bahamian people that use that facility and of course, I most profoundly and profusely apologise to the employees who have to work there and endured the misery,” Mr Newbold said during his weekly press briefing. He added: “Prime Minister Minnis and his government have promised some relief, certainly by
the end of the year and I suspect that you may hear at the end of the day (yesterday), but most certainly tomorrow (today) in the House of Assembly would be concerning what the government intends to do with that General Post Office.” For much of the last year, workers at the General Post Office have worked shortened shifts at their East Hill Street location because of the “hazardous” conditions; they have also staged several protests. The building has been plagued with a myriad of issues including mould and a broken air-conditioner system. The situation has led to a backlog in mail delivery.
THE TRIBUNE
Wednesday, October 17, 2018, PAGE 7
Two BAIC directors removed from posts By AVA TURNQUEST Tribune Chief Reporter aturnquest@tribunemedia.net TWO directors on the board at the Bahamas Agricultural and Industrial Corporation have been removed. Officials confirmed to The Tribune that directors Bernard Adderley and Mark Turnquest will be replaced by Bar Association President Khalil Parker and realtor Ethan Adderley. Agriculture Minister Michael Pintard declined to speak on the new appointments yesterday. BAIC executive chairman Michael Foulkes confirmed the two board members had been removed and referred this newspaper to Mr Pintard for comment. Mr Adderley and Mr Turnquest were informed of the decision at a board meeting on Monday, The Tribune was told. Both men will reportedly
REQUEST FOR EXPRESSIONS OF INTEREST
INDIVIDUAL CONSULTANT
MINISTER of Agriculture Michael Pintard. still be engaged by the Ministry of Agriculture in different capacities. The board changes come amidst human resources challenges at the corporation. A source close to the matter said the ministry was currently engaged in an audit of BAIC and its some 165 employees. Thirteen employees were terminated from BAIC earlier this year with the
dismissals ranging from longstanding employees to recently confirmed workers. The dismissals came as a shock to some who were affected, and were branded as “politically motivated” by the opposition Progressive Liberal Party. Assertions of victimisation led Labour Minister Dion Foulkes, at the time, to emphatically deny the claims.
Institution: Inter-American Development Bank Country: The Commonwealth of The Bahamas Projects: (1) Climate Resilient Coastal Management and Infrastructure Program and (2) Airport Infrastructure Program Project Number: (1) BH-L1043 and (2) BH-L1041 Loan Number: (1) 4363/OC-BH and (2) 3907/OC-BH Sector: (1) Environment and Natural Disasters and (2) Transport Deadline: October 19, 2018 The Ministry of Public Works (MOPW) is seeking an experienced Program Coordinator to lead the implementation, and oversight for both the (1) Climate Resilient Coastal Management and Infrastructure Program and (2) Airport Infrastructure Program, financed by the Inter-American Development Bank, and implemented by a dedicated Project Implementation Unit (PIU) within the MOPW. The position will be based in the PIU. . The main activities are as follows: • • • • • • • • • • • • • • •
• •
A WOMAN outside her ruined home after the quake that hit Haiti.
Photo: Dieu Nalio Chery/AP
MINNIS ‘DID NOT REFUSE AID’ By RICARDO WELLS Tribune Staff Reporter rwells@tribunemedia.net
PRESS Secretary Anthony Newbold has again defended Prime Minister Dr Hubert Minnis’ response to the Haitian earthquake, yesterday categorically denying the nation’s leader had expressed a refusal to send aid. Mr Newbold yesterday read out the direct words used by Dr Minnis during an interview with reporters on October 8 outside of Government House, insisting that at no point did the prime minister express an intent not to help Haiti. Mr Newbold hit out at the Nassau Guardian’s reporting on the matter in particular and called that initial report “a misleading story,” one which he asserted resulted in a “firestorm of controversy”. He said this led to intense criticism by talk show hosts, members of the Official Opposition and the Bahamas Christian Council. Moreover, Mr Newbold said the report forced Dr Minnis to call Haitian President Jovenel Moise to apologise on behalf of his office and The Bahamas, for the pronouncements made in the article. The article read: “The government is not now considering giving aid to Haiti following another earthquake, which left at least a dozen dead and around 200 injured, Prime Minister Dr Hubert Minnis suggested yesterday, stating that his focus is on putting Bahamians first.” It continued: “‘When asked if he intends to give aid to Haiti similar to the help offered to Dominica after Hurricane Maria last year,’ Minnis told reporters outside of Government House, ‘At this point in time, I am looking at moving The Bahamas forward. Bahamas first.’” “Minnis said he has heard reports of the earthquake compromising a Haitian prison and is concerned that hardened criminals might be headed toward The Bahamas.” Addressing the article yesterday, Mr Newbold said: “Now, for God sake I
Project Coordinator for (1) The Climate Resilient Coastal Management and Infrastructure Program and (2) Airport Infrastructure Program
say someone, anyone, here or outside this room; I want you to tell me where did the prime minister say that he is not sending any aid to Haiti. “What you heard was the prime minister of The Bahamas doing his first duty, which is trying to ensure that his citizens is safe,” he added. Last week, Mr Newbold in his initial defence of Dr Minnis, said the prime minister had to ultimately ensure Bahamians are not “adversely impacted” by these events, particularly as it relates to the possibility of an increase in illegal immigration. Reflecting on that position yesterday, Mr Newbold admitted he was someone caught off guard by the line of questions he faced in response to the article. He claimed while he did see the article, he dismissed it as a non-story because he was able to decipher what was being implied and what was actually said. “I said the prime minister made no such statement, so I couldn’t understand why anyone would jump to such a conclusion. And so, I dismissed it,” he told reporters. “Nevertheless, some people did and as a result the prime minister ended up having to call President Moise, with who he has a personal relationship, as does Mrs Minnis and the wife of President Moise, to reassure the president that he had made no such statement and would always be willing to help in any way that he could and the Bahamas could,” he added. Mr Newbold continued: “So let me say, a little more forcefully than I said last week, the prime minister never said that he would not give aid nor assistance to Haiti. Never did he say that. “Now, if someone thought - that not was their business to get in people’s head - but the prime minister never said those words. “For the record, there is a protocol involved in the way that assistance is provided among the CARICOM countries, of which The Bahamas is a part. “...As is usually the case, if it is requested, The
Bahamas will participate; as we have. We’ve had assistance given to us through CEDEMA and CARILEC, and we have participated in providing assistance as well.” In the days that following Dr Minnis’ comments on October 8 and subsequent media reports, Rights Bahamas denounced his remarks and accused him of using tragedy in Haiti to encourage fear, xenophobia and ethnic hatred.
•
Ensures PIU compliance with IDB/GOBH Loan Contract in project execution Supervise and evaluate PIU staff Develop project proposals, requirements, documentation and presentations as requested Lead project review exercises designed to adjust, organize and streamline project procedures/schedules/plans. Manage and control project implementation according to the project plans Facilitate project staff in the definition of project tasks and resource requirements Ensure effective coordination between, and reporting from, procurement, financial, and project staff Lead and direct special Program Steering Committees developed to expedite project implementation Participate in regular project evaluation and review meetings to identify current and future bottlenecks/challenges/risks Ensure timely processing of projects through the governmental tenders’ committees and other relevant agencies, according to established procedures Ensure that disbursement projections are accurately updated in line with Annual Operating Plan (AOP) timelines Proactively manage and communicate changes in project scope, schedule and budget Participate in IDB Missions, meetings with the PIU, IDB and other managerial or technical activities of the PIU as deemed necessary and reasonable Conduct project post mortems and create a recommendations report to identify successful and unsuccessful project elements with recommendations Liaise with external auditors as appropriate/Lead the engagement with the external auditors of the Program Summary of experience and qualifications: Advanced university degree in Civil or Structural Engineering or other relevant technical area Minimum five (5) years of professional experience at national and international levels in the relevant field of civil engineering, especially in preparation of construction technical documentation Experience in working in complex environments and large infrastructure and/or civil works
The Government of The Commonwealth of The Bahamas now invites eligible consultants to indicate their interest in providing project management services. Interested consultants should provide their CV’s and information demonstrating that they are qualified to perform the services (description of similar assignments, experience in similar conditions). The duration of the contract is two (2) year full-time with the possibility of being renewed based on satisfactory performance evaluation. Consultants will be selected in accordance with the procedures set out in the Inter-American Development Bank: Policies for the Selection and Contracting of Consultants Financed by the Inter-American Development Bank GN-2350-9 and is open to all eligible bidders as defined in the policies. Interested consultants may obtain further clarification on the technical aspects or scope of services from Robert Mouzas, Deputy Director, Ministry of Public Works robertmouzas@bahamas.gov.bs tel: (242) 302-9530 during office hours between 09:00am to 5:00pm Monday – Friday, except on public holidays. Expressions of Interest inclusive of CV’s must be submitted to the address below in person, by e-mail idbfiairports@bahamas.gov.bs or idbcoastal@bahamas.gov.bs or by mail, on or before October 19, 2018 at 4pm. Antoinette Thompson –Permanent Secretary Acting Ministry of Public Works REF:- Climate Resilient Coastal Management and Infrastructure Program /Airport Infrastructure Program P.O. Box N 8156,Nassau, Bahamas
PAGE 8, Wednesday, October 17, 2018
BY NOW, most of us have at least heard about Lighthouse Point — 700 acres of privately-owned property in South Eleuthera — Disney Cruise Line’s bid to buy and develop it, and the opposition this plan has received, particularly from environmentalists. Disney submitted a proposal for the acquisition and development of the property, making it a second cruise destination the company would manage. This plan was first shared in a meeting held in Eleuthera in August where a Disney representative circulated flyers about the “significantly smaller and less dense development” than others proposed and “sustainable design and building practices” to minimise environmental impact. Organisations and individuals including Bahamas National Trust (BNT) and reEarth have called for the site to become a national park. BNT has stated the proposed development of Lighthouse Point is not sustainable and would negatively impact the environment. The organisation noted that, in additional the environment harm, developments of this kind generally do not create many jobs and limit public access. The Institute of Bahamian Architects (IBA) supported the call for the government to purchase and protect Lighthouse Point, noting no matter how “sustainable” Disney says the development would be, it would cause irreparable damage to the environment. IBA said in a statement in August: “We all know that there is no enforcement and just servicing thousands of persons on a daily basis will cause massive and irreparable environmental degradation and pollution in many ways.” IBA has gone a step further, calling for a Family Island development plan — part of a long-term solution to the issues with developments of this kind. There are, of course, people in support of the development by Disney. The promise of jobs is enough to excite and draw support. It is difficult for any person or group of people in economic crisis to see past immediate needs. We have been taught to think of job creation as the answer to economic woes, and to see foreign investors as saviours. It seems like a quick fix — sell property, a company who has done it before can build an attractive tourism-centred structure, and Bahamians can benefit by working for those investors whose profits leave the country. It seems easier, faster, and more certain than a community response because we have not
THE TRIBUNE
Eleuthera’s Disney rally shows us there has to be a better way
seen fellow Bahamians given comparable opportunities. We have not explored options outside of sun, sand, and sea tourism and job creation. We think about development in limited terms, without imagining how the protection of sites like Lighthouse Point could benefit us, as Bahamians, while being seen and appreciated by visitors. It has become more difficult to see what we already have when there is a promise of “more” to come. There is a long, tiring game of tug-of-war between development as we understand it and sustainability.
Sam Duncombe of reEarth spoke of 200 species of birds, the lighthouse itself, and other natural features of Lighthouse Point. Can the site not be monetised without destruction? Is economic development and monetisation more important than all else? Is it our failing to see and understand the value of what we have that leads others to undervalue (or understate and downplay) it so we get robbed? What we are now accustomed to has limited our imagination, and our rush for short-term gain is the vacuum that makes real value, financial and otherwise, disappear. Late last week, The Lighthouse Point Partnership — a group of organisations including One Eleuthera Foundation, Leon REQUEST FOR EXPRESSIONS OF INTEREST Levy Foundation, Bahamas National Trust, and The Island School — unveiled they had months ago also submitted a proposal to build an eco-resort on Lighthouse Point. The Partnership is prepared to purchase the property and have it vested in a non-profit Financial Specialist for (1) The Climate Resilient Coastal Management and Infrastructure Program and organisation with the people of Eleuthera as (2) Airport Infrastructure Program stakeholders and decision-makers. Key difInstitution: Inter-American Development Bank ferences in this proposal from that of Disney Country: The Commonwealth of The Bahamas include Bahamian ownership, diversificaProjects: (1) Climate Resilient Coastal Management and Infrastructure Program and tion of tourism, and a focus on stop-over (2) Airport Infrastructure Program visitors. Project Number: (1) BH-L1043 and (2) BH-L1041 Before The Partnership’s proposal was Loan Number: (1) 4363/OC-BH and (2) 3907/OC-BH revealed, last week’s meeting in Eleuthera Sector: (1) Environment and Natural Disasters and (2) Transport (which was virtually a pro-Disney Deadline: October 19, 2018 rally) received the attention of many Bahamians — especially those with access to The Ministry of Public Works (MOPW) is seeking an experienced Financial Specialist for both the (1) Climate Resilient social media and who have seen videos and Coastal Management and Infrastructure Program and (2) Airport Infrastructure Program, financed by the Inter-American heard reports of what took place. Development Bank, and implemented by a dedicated Project Implementation Unit (PIU) within the MOPW. The position Disgust, disappointment, and embarrasswill be based in the PIU. ment are just a few of the feelings expressed . The main activities are as follows: by people who attended the meeting in Eleuthera which started with a pro-Disney • Ensuring that appropriate financial and accounting systems and controls are implemented so that all Program rally that went on for over an hour. When activities are executed in accordance with the applicable GoBH and the Bank’s financial and accounting the prime minister finally spoke, he did what requirements. now seems to be the norm. He detracted • Establishing and maintaining adequate financial, accounting, and internal control systems to ensure the integrity, from the topic at hand by talking about compliance and transparency of all transactions undertaken by the PIU. some of our other favourite issues. He spoke • Managing, in an effective and transparent manner, the financial resources of the Program and undertaking the about access to education through Bahamas corresponding fiduciary responsibilities as well as the implementation and operation of the necessary internal and Technical and Vocational Institute and the external controls. affordable housing scheme, neither of which • Assisting the Program Coordinator with the monitoring activities of the Program to meet the stipulated Program are new. financial objectives, transparency and accountability requirements as they relate to the planned and actual He then went on to contrast Disney’s expenditures. plan with a decade-old development plan. • Participating in the preparation of the Program Annual Operational Plan (AOP) to ensure that budget and cash flow He discouraged disagreement with the proestimates are compatible with work priorities, objectives and timelines. posal, including — and perhaps especially — on the basis of environmental concerns. • Carrying out the budgeting processes of the Program, consistent with the programmatic structure agreed with the The prime minister of The Bahamas saw fit Bank. Implementing and ensuring the effective and transparent reach and operation of the internal control systems to shut the conversation down before of the Program and its administration. Preparing the budget execution reports and financial statements of the it began because, according to him, Program by sources and uses of funds, and in compliance with the norms of the IDB and GoBH. it was not an issue before, so no • Assisting the Program Coordinator in the in the preparation of periodic financial and physical implementation need to discuss it now. reports, along with supporting documentation in accordance with the Program Operating Manual (POM) and as It is outrageous to preclude required by the MLNI, Ministry of Finance and the Bank. Participating in the periodic update of the POM to ensure people from speaking and that proper accounting, financial management and internal controls are effective and consistent with GoBH and IDB sharing their points of view, policies and procedures. especially when they have come to a forum to do just that. The The consultant must hold a post-graduate degree in Economics, Business Administration (Finance), Public meeting was not promoted as a Administration or Accounting. He/she must have a minimum of 5 years of relevant work experience in project-financial gathering for everyone in support management of investment initiatives funded by international development institutions, preferably in The Bahamas. of Disney developing Lighthouse Point. Previous knowledge and exposure of/to IDB’s fiduciary, procurement, financial administration and project management It was a space for conversation, where difpolicies and procedures is desired. ferent perspectives could be shared and challenged. The Government of The Commonwealth of The Bahamas now invites eligible consultants to indicate their interest in Minnis’ statement - and use of the Disney providing financial specilist services. Interested consultants should provide their CV’s and information demonstrating print material to make his point - set the that they are qualified to perform the services (description of similar assignments, experience in similar conditions). The tone for the rest of the meeting. People who duration of the contract is two (2) year part-time with the possibility of being renewed based on satisfactory made contributions contrary to the properformance evaluation. Disney rhetoric of more jobs, more money, more access to resources were effectively Consultants will be selected in accordance with the procedures set out in the Inter-American Development Bank: shut down by others in the room who booed Policies for the Selection and Contracting of Consultants Financed by the Inter-American Development Bank GN-2350-9 and jeered. There was no moderation. There and is open to all eligible bidders as defined in the policies. Interested consultants may obtain further clarification on the was no attempt to create and maintain an technical aspects or scope of services from Robert Mouzas, Deputy Director, Ministry of Public Works environment where people could share their robertmouzas@bahamas.gov.bs tel: (242) 302-9530 during office hours between 09:00am to 5:00pm Monday – Friday, thoughts, ask questions, and challenge ideas. except on public holidays. Expressions of Interest inclusive of CV’s must be submitted to the address below in person, Increasingly, spaces and people are closed to by e-mail idbfiairports@bahamas.gov.bs or idbcoastal@bahamas.gov.bs or by mail, on or before October 19, 2018 at critical dialogue. 4pm. It is as though we are subjects, meant to ignore relations of power, our own needs, Antoinette Thompson – Permanent Secretary Acting Ministry of Public Works and the environment around us. We are REF:- Climate Resilient Coastal Management and Infrastructure Program /Airport Infrastructure Program expected to buy into the idea that we elect P.O. Box N 8156, Nassau, Bahamas people to lead us blindly rather than representatives mandated to listen to and
INDIVIDUAL CONSULTANT
champion our positions. It is almost as though our democratic system is not working as it should. In recent years, government administrations have talked about consultative processes and transparency, and they have suggested that there is interest in real engagement with citizens on issues that matter to all of us. We have seen a few town hall meetings and the like, but they are clearly not effective — especially on their own — as tools for national communication. Aside from the challenge of our geography as an archipelagic nation, it is difficult to hear everyone in a short period time. There is, however, more than enough room to use tools available to us to reach people where they are, and make it easy for Bahamians to participate in national conversations. Make proposals public. Create forums for public commentary. Conduct proper surveys. Hold regular constituency meetings. Accept invitations to talk about programmes, proposals and policies on radio programmes and at civic group meetings. Produce informative, accessible print material. Involve citizens in decision making using the same systems engaged to encourage us to vote. Engage in social listening. Use text messaging to share information and request feedback. These, of course, only make sense if an administration is actually interested in citizens’ points of view. The government has to care first. The people forming the government have to care. The people who vote for representatives have to care enough to demand real, meaningful engagement. If the government is determined to do as it wishes, the meetings are a farce, and a waste of time, money and energy. If the government does not want to listen to us and if the prime minister has decided that we do not deserve to speak on a particular issue (even if it is true that we had nothing to say ten years ago), we have a serious problem. A precedent has been set, and we have participated in its construction. Before we can rally together and demand to be heard, we have to be willing to listen to one another. We cannot be so steeped in our own experiences that we refuse to hear another’s. We cannot see new information or different perspectives as enemies. It is better to be wrong and learn than to isolate ourselves, silence others, and collectively suffer the consequences. We may not all agree on what should happen to Lighthouse Point, but something will happen. It could become a national park, accessible to the public. It might become a Disney destination, closed to everyone but its cruise passengers. It is possible that it will become the site of a small hotel that boast various “sustainable” features. It could even be the gem of eco-tourism in The Bahamas. There are more than two possibilities that will affect thousands of people, not just in the immediate future, but for generations to come. It will not save us, but do we care to save it? We can be concerned about multiple issues at once. Foreign investment and Bahamian ownership, economic development and sustainability, job creation and entrepreneurship, tourism and national integrity. These are not mutually exclusive pairs, but one can wipe out the other. In the same way, our refusal to listen to and respect one another can severely compromise our collective power. We have to listen (to individuals) if we want to be heard (as a collective). We have to honour our voices and demand the same of this administration.
THE TRIBUNE
Wednesday, October 17, 2018, PAGE 9
Google Pixel 3 phone aims to automate more daily tasks NEW YORK Associated Press THERE’S not much about the physical details of Google’s new Pixel 3 phone that you can’t find elsewhere. That bigger display and curved design? Apple and Samsung phones already have that. But the Pixel doesn’t intend to wow people with its hardware anyway. It’s really a showcase for Google’s latest advances in software, particularly in artificial intelligence. Google wants to help you manage daily life, from screening unwanted phone calls to predicting what you’ll type. The software underscores how Google is tapping its strengths in personalisation — and perhaps make money through ads in the process. You get free services in exchange for letting Google deeper into your life. The Pixel isn’t likely to work for anyone uncomfortable with that trade-off. As impressive as Google’s ambitions are, though, AI is still new at the job of saving us from meaningless tasks. That may not come until an eventual Pixel 9 or Pixel 13. The Pixel 3, out on Thursday starting at about $800, is for those who can’t wait. CALL SCREENING No doubt you’ve gotten an automated call from a telemarketer pitching lower interest rates or vacation shares. Google now lets you fight back with an automated response. When a mystery call comes in, just hit “Screen call.” Google’s voice assistant takes over and asks for
THE GOOGLE Pixel 3, left, and Pixel 3 XL. Google’s new Pixel 3 phone plays catch-up with Apple and Samsung on hardware. It’s really designed to showcase Google’s advances in software, particularly in artificial intelligence. a name and purpose of the call. Transcribed responses appear in real time, so you can decide whether to pick up. You can even request more information by tapping buttons such as “Tell me more”. It’s a good concept, though it’s not clear that it really saves time. You still need to follow the voice assistant’s chatter; taking the call and hanging up would often be faster. Perhaps Google’s assistant could one day handle all that for you without even ringing the phone, then decide based on the response whether to interrupt your game of “Fortnite”. But legitimate callers would still find this annoying. It didn’t help that I kept tapping “I can’t understand”, forcing friends to repeat themselves over and over to a robot.
TEXT RECOGNITION Point the camera at a business card, flyer or other printed text, and Google will try to extract phone numbers and addresses. It also works with QR and barcodes. If this sounds familiar, it’s because it is. Last year’s Pixel phones had this Google Lens feature, while Samsung has a similar feature called Bixby Vision. The difference: Before, you had to tap something to activate a feature. Now it’s automatic. The feature is most useful if you have a business card or flyer handy when you’re ready to make a call, visit a website or get directions through Google Maps. You still need a few extra taps to add the information to your contact list. Then there’s the task of tagging which number is for home, work or cell, and what context you met that person in.
That much management might incline you to let those piles of business cards keep stacking up. A SMART STAND-IN Place the phone on an optional $79 Pixel Stand charging station, and it can display a rotating set of images from an album you choose. Or you can trust Google to select the best shots. Soon, you’ll be able to let Google’s facial-recognition technology just pick out photos of your family, including new shots as you take them (though not in the European Union, where privacy regulations are tighter.) The photo display will take you down memory lane, as images from past trips, weddings and family events come up. If only Google was smart enough to remove the party shots never meant for public, sober viewing. The stand works well as a
bedside companion. Before bed, it offers to set your alarm. In the morning, one tap gets you the weather, upcoming calendar events and details about traffic on your commute. It’s not perfect, though: Google still hasn’t figured out that I don’t own a car and have no use for driving directions. Or that I don’t need commute information on weekends. SMART SNAPPING Just smile or make a funny face for the selfie camera to automatically take the shot. For regular photos, Google captures extra shots as alternatives, in case someone blinks or blocks the view, though Google’s recommendations aren’t always spot on, as even humans can disagree on what looks best. The camera also uses software to combine multiple versions of images, essentially filling in some gaps so that zoomed-in shots come out sharper than they normally would. It starts to cross the line of digital manipulation, but pictures do look nice. It’s still no replacement from a real zoom, which the latest Apple and Samsung phones offer via a second lens. Google turns to software to make up for what it lacks in hardware. A NOTE ON PRIVACY Google executives emphasise that much of the AI analysis is taking place on the phone, not Google’s servers. When screening calls, for instance, all interactions stay private unless you report the number as spam, in which case it gets added to Google’s database as a warning to others.
MICROSOFT CO-FOUNDER, PHILANTHROPIST PAUL ALLEN DIES AT 65 SEATTLE Associated Press PAUL G Allen, who cofounded Microsoft with his childhood friend Bill Gates before becoming a billionaire philanthropist who invested in conservation, space travel, arts and culture and professional sports, died Monday. He was 65. He died in Seattle from complications of non-Hodgkin’s lymphoma, his company Vulcan Inc announced. Gates said he was heartbroken about the loss of one of his “oldest and dearest friends”. “Personal computing would not have existed without him,” Gates said in a statement. “But Paul wasn’t content with starting one company. He channeled his intellect and compassion into a second act focused on improving people’s lives and strengthening communities in Seattle and around the world. He was fond of saying, ‘If it has the potential to do good, then we should do it,’” Gates wrote.
MICROSOFT Chairman Bill Gates, left, chats with Portland Trail Blazers owner and former business partner Paul Allen during a game between the Trail Blazers and Seattle SuperSonics in Seattle in 2003. (AP) Microsoft CEO Satya Nadella called Allen’s contributions to the company, community and industry “indispensable”. “As co-founder of Microsoft, in his own quiet and persistent way, he created magical products, experiences and institutions, and in doing so, he changed the world,” Nadella wrote on Twitter. Allen, an avid sports fan, owned the Portland Trail
Blazers and the Seattle Seahawks. Allen and Gates met while attending a private school in north Seattle. The two friends would later drop out of college to pursue the future they envisioned: A world with a computer in every home. Gates so strongly believed it that he left Harvard University in his junior year to devote himself full-time
to his and Allen’s startup, originally called Micro-Soft. Allen spent two years at Washington State University before dropping out as well. They founded the company in Albuquerque, New Mexico, and their first product was a computer language for the Altair hobby-kit personal computer, giving hobbyists a basic way to program and operate the machine. After Gates and Allen found some success selling their programming language, MS-Basic, the Seattle natives moved their business in 1979 to Bellevue, Washington, not far from its eventual home in Redmond. Microsoft’s big break came in 1980, when IBM Corp. decided to move into personal computers and asked Microsoft to provide the operating system. Gates and company didn’t invent the operating system. To meet IBM’s needs, they spent $50,000 to buy one known as QDOS from another programmer, Tim Paterson. Eventually the product refined by Microsoft — and renamed DOS, for
Disk Operating System — became the core of IBM PCs and their clones, catapulting Microsoft into its dominant position in the PC industry. The first versions of two classic Microsoft products, Microsoft Word and the Windows operating system, were released in 1983. By 1991, Microsoft’s operating systems were used by 93 percent of the world’s personal computers. The Windows operating system is now used on most of the world’s desktop computers, and Word is the cornerstone of the company’s prevalent Office products. Gates and Allen became billionaires when Microsoft was thrust onto the throne of technology. With his sister Jody Allen in 1986, Paul Allen founded Vulcan, the investment firm that oversees his business and philanthropic efforts. He founded the Allen Institute for Brain Science and the aerospace firm Stratolaunch, which has built a colossal airplane designed to launch satellites into orbit. He has also backed research into nuclear-fusion power.
• GOOGLE plans to start charging smartphone makers to pre-install apps like Gmail, YouTube and Google Maps on Android handsets sold in Europe, a response to a record $5bn antitrust fine imposed by the European Union. The US tech company’s announcement yesterday is a change from its previous business model of letting manufacturers install Google’s suite of popular mobile apps for free on phones running its Android operating system. Device makers will also now be able to install rival modified, or “forked”, versions of Android, the most widely used mobile operating system. The company is taking the measures to comply with the July ruling by EU authorities that found Google allegedly abused the dominance of Android to stifle competitors. Google is introducing the changes at the end of October to meet a deadline set out in the European Commission’s decision, which it is appealing in a process that could take years. EU regulators decided it was unfair for Google to force smartphone makers that used Android to also install its apps. The company argued that giving away its open-source operating system resulted in cheaper phones and more competition with chief rival Apple. • JAPAN’S space agency is delaying a spacecraft touchdown on an asteroid because scientists need more time to find a safe landing site on the extremely rocky surface. The spacecraft Hayabusa2 left Earth in 2014 and traveled 280 million kilometres (170 million miles) to the area of asteroid Ryugu, which it reached in June. The Japan Aerospace Exploration Agency plans to attempt three brief touchand-go landings on Ryugu to collect samples in hopes of gaining clues to the origin of the solar system and life on Earth. JAXA Hayabusa2 project manager Yuichi Tsuda said last week that the rockierthan-expected asteroid hardly has any flat spaces for landing. “Those rocks are our biggest headache,” Tsuda said. “Ryugu is extremely rocky and it’s almost cruel.” He said his team needs at least a month to revise the landing plan, and is still hopeful. “We will not let Hayabusa2 come back empty-handed,” Tsuda said earlier. A one-month delay at this time of year means two more idle months because the spacecraft will be on the other side of the sun from the Earth in November and December, making it unable to communicate. Scientists are analysing data that Hayabusa2 collected when it moved close to the asteroid to release three rovers, as well as images and other data collected by the rovers, to determine the best landing spot.
PAGE 10, Wednesday, October 17, 2018
THE TRIBUNE
Police brutality claim leads to murder retrial from page one
knowing they were crossing the road to beat up the deceased, the group did so. Instead, Sir Michael conGibson said Takoyo asked tended the directions the Hart “what he saying”, and trial judge gave invited the Hart responded by saying jury to give “full weight” “ain’t nothing” because to the confession, notwithhe wasn’t “on that run”. standing the possibility that Gibson said Takoyo subthe jurors may have had sequently snatched Hart “doubts as to whether the while two more of his confession was given volfriends held him. Gibson untarily or in the absence said Takoyo then took a of oppression or unlawful knife out of his pocket and conduct”. started stabbing Hart. Appellate president Sir Afterwards, Gibson said Hartman Longley disahe walked to his home and greed, however, stating as told his mother about what there was no direct evihad happened. dence of police oppression/ Police were called to a brutality, such as Gibson scene opposite AID where giving evidence or the they discovered Hart lying police witnesses agreeing on the ground. He was subto or admitting it occurred, sequently taken to hospital it was not necessary to where he was pronounced give directions to the jury dead on arrival. Forensic concerning oppression or pathologist Dr Caryn Sands unlawful means. said Hart died from mulAnd in the absence of tiple stab wounds to the that evidence, Sir Hartman torso. She said the characreasoned, no reasonable teristics of the wounds on jury could have found the his skin were indicative of APPELATE PRESIDENT SIR HARTMAN LONGLEY statement was not given being cause by a “singlevoluntarily. Pearline McKenzie testi- recognised him as the man edged sharp weapon”. According to the ruling, fied she was sitting outside she knew as “Fox Hill”. According to the ruling, on June 9, 2013, Hart died the Wulff Road Police StaGibson was arrested the the only evidence that confrom multiple stab wounds tion when a man she knew same day at SuperWash nected Gibson to the crime to the torso. The stab- as “Fox Hill” walked up to on Wulff Road, at which was the information in the bing took place near AID her and told her a group time he allegedly told the record of interview. Based on Wulff Road. Hart was of boys “jook him up” and officer that he was there on a review of that inforfound at Wulff Road west that the youngest one was but “Takoyo jook him up”. mation, Sgt 1095 Johnson of Jerome Avenue, with ten years old. At the end Gibson was searched by put certain “information” multiple stab wounds in the of her testimony, she was Corporal 2688 Coakley and to Gibson to which he early hours of the date in shown the voter’s card a black, flip-blade knife responded. However, the question. of the deceased and she was found in his right front ruling noted there was no pocket. indication as to how that Gibson was interviewed officer obtained the “inforby police and allegedly told mation” that he put to them he knew Takoyo had Gibson. a black, flip-blade knife and During the course of the that as he and a group of his trial, objection was made friends were walking along to the Crown’s reliance on Wulff Road when they the record of interview, spotted Hart on the oppo- however the interview was site side of the road. admitted. As a part of its Gibson said when they case, the Crown called saw Hart, Takoyo said Dr Timothy Providence “let’s cross the road” and to interpret the results of Gibson’s medical report prepared at the prison, which was exhibited into evidence. REQUEST FOR EXPRESSIONS OF INTEREST The report revealed that Gibson was examined upon being admitted to the Fox Hill facility, and that he made a complaint about being beaten by the police. Environment, Health & Safety Specialist for (1) The Climate Resilient Coastal Management and The doctor in question, who Infrastructure Program and (2) Airport Infrastructure Program died before the commencement of trial, did not note
To advertise in The Tribune, contact 502-2394
INDIVIDUAL CONSULTANT
Institution: Inter-American Development Bank Country: The Commonwealth of The Bahamas Projects: (1) Climate Resilient Coastal Management and Infrastructure Program and (2) Airport Infrastructure Program Project Number: (1) BH-L1043 and (2) BH-L1041 Loan Number: (1) 4363/OC-BH and (2) 3907/OC-BH Sector: (1) Environment and Natural Disasters and (2) Transport Deadline: October 19, 2018
The Ministry of Public Works (MOPW) is seeking an experienced Environment, Health, and Safety Officer to lead the implementation, and oversight of environmental, health and safety aspects, plans and procedures for both the (1) Climate Resilient Coastal Management and Infrastructure Program and (2) Airport Infrastructure Program, financed by the Inter-American Development Bank, and implemented by a dedicated Project Implementation Unit (PIU) within the MOPW. The position will be based in the PIU. . The main activities are as follows: • Oversee the development and implementation the necessary plans and procedures, for design and construction activities undertaken in the Program, based on the proposed Environmental and Social Management Framework set out in the Environmental and Social Analysis Report • Liaise with government authorities, the IDB, project architects and developers to determine if additional environmental and social assessment is required for infrastructure projects in the programs • Coordinate and review subsequent environmental and social assessments required and/or Enviroment and Social Management Plans (ESMPs) produced, to ensure compliance with international best practice. Liaise with government authorities, project architects and developers to ensure that environmental, health and safety requirements are integrated into final designs • Revise the ESMPs developed by contractors to ensure compliance with national laws and IDB’s policies • Supervise environmental, health and safety processes ensuring compliance with local and national legislation, best international practice, and contractual commitments with the IDB//Supervise the implementation of the contractors’ ESMPs • Identify and track appropriate environment, health, and safety Key Performance Indicators • Maintain records and prepare various environmental, health and safety reports. Conduct periodic audits, to pinpoint unsafe working conditions, behaviors, and practices. Conduct and/or coordinate environmental monitoring quality tests periodically at site and analyze data • Production of monthly progress reports and final report, at the end of the project Summary of experience and qualifications: • Degree in Environmental Science, Engineering and/or Health and Safety discipline • Minimum five (5) years of Environment, Health, and Safety experience in the construction field; • Demonstrated success at developing and implementing HSE Management Systems • Detailed knowledge of relevant national legislation as well as HSE international standards • Experience with safety hazard recognition, behavioral-based safety, job hazard analysis, process hazards analysis and environmental site assessment based on international standards The Government of The Commonwealth of The Bahamas now invites eligible consultants to indicate their interest in providing environment, health, and safety services. Interested consultants should provide their CV’s and information demonstrating that they are qualified to perform the services (description of similar assignments, experience in similar conditions). The duration of the contract is two (2) year full-time with the possibility of being renewed based on satisfactory performance evaluation. Consultants will be selected in accordance with the procedures set out in the Inter-American Development Bank: Policies for the Selection and Contracting of Consultants Financed by the Inter-American Development Bank GN-2350-9 and is open to all eligible bidders as defined in the policies. Interested consultants may obtain further clarification on the technical aspects or scope of services from Robert Mouzas, Deputy Director, Ministry of Public Works robertmouzas@bahamas.gov.bs tel: (242) 302-9530 during office hours between 09:00am to 5:00pm Monday – Friday, except on public holidays. Expressions of Interest inclusive of CV’s must be submitted to the address below in person, by e-mail idbfiairports@bahamas.gov.bs or idbcoastal@bahamas.gov.bs or by mail, on or before October 19, 2018 at 4pm. Antoinette Thompson –Permanent Secretary Acting Ministry of Public Works REF:- Climate Resilient Coastal Management and Infrastructure Program /Airport Infrastructure Program P.O. Box N 8156.Nassau, Bahamas
any injuries on the medical report, but did prescribe a painkiller to be taken twice a day by Gibson. At the close of the prosecution’s case, Gibson exercised his right to remain silent and did not call any witnesses. He was later acquitted of murder but convicted of manslaughter on March 30, 2016, and sentenced to 30 years imprisonment on May 11. Gibson, via his attorneys Christina Galanos and Bjorn Ferguson, appealed the decision, contending amongst other things that the trial judge erred by telling the jury that there was no evidence in the trial of police brutality; and that they may rely on the record of interview even if it was obtained through oppression. According to the ruling, the trial judge said in her summation: “…An allegation or a question does not become fact unless the witness accepts the truth of the assertion in their answer. The witness for the prosecution never accepted that they beat (Gibson), and (Gibson) himself never gave evidence to assert that he was beaten. So other than the medical evidence from the prison doctor, Dr Providence…there is no evidence in this trial about police brutality.” However, Justice Evans said based on that excerpt, there is “no direction that the jury must be satisfied beyond a reasonable doubt that the record of interview was obtained without oppression”. Justice Evans further said his “real concern” was that the trial judge “did not clearly direct the jury that it was the prosecution’s duty to prove that the interview was voluntary”. “It is not, in my view, sufficient to say that the witnesses for the prosecution never accepted that the defendant had been beaten,” Justice Evans said. “It is true that suggestions which are not accepted do not become evidence. However, the fact that the
officers did not accept the allegations of beating does not necessarily mean that the jury could not have doubts as to the truth of their evidence. “The presence of the medical evidence and the fact that allegations were being made via crossexamination could very well cause the jury to have doubts. In my view, the jury was not properly assisted on how they should approach the question of whether the record of interview was voluntary obtained. “Accordingly, I allow the appeal and quash the conviction and sentence; and I order that the case be remitted to the Supreme Court for retrial.” Sir Michael, though limiting his decision on the issue of the confession evidence, nonetheless supported Justice Evans’ view that the appeal should be allowed and a retrial ordered. Sir Michael further said that for him, Gibson’s case raises the “important issue” as to “what is the proper direction to be given by a judge to a jury as to what weight it should give to a confession made by an accused person and in what circumstances should such a direction be given”. “In my judgement whenever a jury is being directed as to how to consider a confession, it is incumbent on the judge to direct the jury that ‘if they have any reasonable doubt that a confession was made as a result of oppression or some other improper circumstance they should disregard it,” Sir Michael said. “The burden is on the Crown to prove that the statement was obtained voluntarily and if the jury, having seen the demeanour of the police witnesses and heard their evidence, is not satisfied that the confession was given voluntarily, they are entitled to disregard the confession. This does not in my judgement depend upon the presence of actual evidence given by the accused as to the circumstances as to how the confession.”
MAN CLEARED OF BTC ROBBERY By NICO SCAVELLA Tribune Staff Reporter nscavella@tribunemedia.net
A SUPREME Court jury has acquitted a man previously accused of robbing a BTC store at gunpoint eight years ago. The jury found Desmond Pratt not guilty by a vote of 7-1 of the hold up at the BTC store on Shirley Street on November 26, 2010. It was previously alleged that sometime between 9am and 9.30am on the date in question, Pratt, armed with a handgun, and accompanied by another man, Godfrey Hepburn, robbed the BTC store of some $787.67. Detective Constable Philip Deveaux,
testifying before Justice Bernard Turner, claimed when he arrested Pratt in the Johnson Estates area, the 27-year-old said: “Officer, I just pretended as if I wanted internet service for my cell phone at BTC. I only handcuff the security guard.” However, in taking the witness stand subsequent to the close of the Crown’s case against him, Pratt denied taking part in the robbery insisting: “I don’t know where Shirley Street is.” He further stated he had only lived in New Providence for approximately a year prior to the incident in question, having previously lived in Wemyss Bight, Eleuthera.
As a result, he said he wasn’t too familiar with New Providence. Pratt also denied knowing Hepburn prior to the incident, and insisted that during a confrontation at the Central Detective Unit, Hepburn denied knowing him and claimed Hepburn committed the armed robbery by himself. Pratt also claimed he was beaten by police, more specifically, was gun-butted in the head. Attorney Ramona Farquharson-Seymour, testifying on Pratt’s behalf, said he did complain of being “roughed up” by police when she visited him at the Central Detective Unit within days after the incident in question. Calvin Seymour represented Pratt during trial.
D’AGUILAR THREATENS LEGAL MOVE MINISTER of Tourism and Aviation Dionisio D’Aguilar threatened legal action against a group he alleged had taken possession of a vacant lot next door to his home, a situation which led to a confrontation with his wife and an unidentified man that was shared on social media yesterday. The video, captured on a cell phone, showed Mr D’Aguilar’s wife arguing with a man at a property across the street from a beach. Mrs D’Aguilar is heard screaming “this is my land” before the man recording interrupts and asks her why she was “pulling up” his fence. She then asks him why he had taken down her trees. The two then argue about who owned the land
in question. The man also recorded Mrs D’Aguilar pulling up steel poles from the ground which he claimed were a part of his fence. When contacted about the incident, Mr D’Aguilar released a statement, which alleged: “An individual . . .and a group of friends turned up a week ago and decided to take possession of the vacant land next door to my home which is not owned by them. “Yesterday, they hired a bulldozer and cleared down vegetation and started to occupy the land by building a shack,” he alleged. “They are classic land grabbers and my wife was quite rightly upset by the destruction that they caused on land that she had nurtured and landscaped at the behest of the legitimate
owners over many, many years. “These land grabbers, with no legitimate title, need to be stopped and it is my full intention to do so within the confines of the law and with the full support of the legitimate owners.” He said the group should “cease and desist from causing further destruction to property that they do not own and to vacate the land forthwith.” The Free Town MP said police were called to the scene and he claimed they told the man in question to stop working on the land. “The owners are moving aggressively to get an injunction to get him (to) cease and desist and vacate the property,” the statement added.
THE TRIBUNE
Wednesday, October 17, 2018, PAGE 11
THE FIRE at John Chea #8 on Carmichael Road yesterday.
Photos: Terrel W Carey Sr/Tribune Staff
Power turned off as crews battle blaze at John Chea POLICE were called to the scene of a massive fire at John Chea #8 on Carmichael Road yesterday. Chief Superintendent Walter Evans, director of Police Fire Services, said police got the call shortly before 11am and responding officers met a massive blaze emanating from the rear of the food store. CSP Evans said all available units in New Providence were called as well as a truck from the airport Crash and Rescue Department. Police closed a portion of Carmichael Road from Gladstone Road to Golden Isles Road, as they fought the blaze and also asked Bahamas Power and Light to turn off the power supply in the area as well. Two women were taken to hospital as a result of the fire. “During operation, we knew that two ladies were transported to the hospital for smoke inhalation,”
FIRE Services director Chief Supt Walter Evans. CSP Evans said. “We are not sure whether they are employees but there were in a conscious state when transported to hospital.” In addition to windy conditions aiding the spread of the fire, police firetrucks had to go to nearby fire hydrants to replenish their water supply, CSP Evans said. He was asked if a lack of water hindered fire fighting efforts. “Water had to be trucked here, each one of the trucks
THE BLAZE at John Chea #8. that arrived here, they came trucked with water and one can imagine in an operation such as this, this requires a significant amount of water far beyond what one truck, two trucks, three, four, five will carry. “Water has not been a major challenge, it has just been the process by which we have had to manually truck the water. .. and we had a home on the side we had to protect, on the northwestern side and business in the southeastern
area.. all of these were exposures here today.” CSP Evans said it was too early to say what caused yesterday’s blaze. When asked if the Fire Services had manpower issues, he said there is always a demand for more human resources, adding a group of firefighters are being trained right now. He said the group of 34 should finish training in the next two months, which will augment Police Fire Services.
PAGE 12, Wednesday, October 17, 2018
THE TRIBUNE
NEVADA PIMP HOF FOUND DEAD AFTER 72ND BIRTHDAY Nevada Associated Press
DENNIS Hof, a pimp who gained notoriety for an HBO series about his brothel business and who fashioned himself as a Donald Trump-style Republican candidate for the state Legislature, was found dead hours after his 72nd birthday He was found unconscious and later pronounced dead in his private residence at his Love Ranch brothel west of Las Vegas,
said Nye County Sheriff Sharon Wehrly. Ron Jeremy, a porn star who attended Hof’s birthday party, said he and a woman found Hof’s body. Wehrly, who also serves as county coroner, said she saw Hof at his birthday party late on Monday at a local casinohotel reception room with more than 100 of his friends, including former Phoenix-area sheriff Joe Arpaio. “He was sitting on a stool talking with people when I left about
10,” Wehrly said of Hof, who she said had celebrated at another party during the weekend in northern Nevada. “I guess that’s partying at 72.” The sheriff said there was no preliminary indication of foul play but her office was investigating. An autopsy will be conducted by the Clark County coroner in Las Vegas. Wehrly said results of the medical examination could take six weeks. Hof was the Republican candidate in a heavily GOP state
HOF enjoyed a party.
legislative district. He had said his party would be attended by Arpaio, the former six-term sheriff of metropolitan Phoenix. “Boy, that’s shocking,” Arpaio said of Hof’s death. Arpaio, who lost a Senate GOP primary in Arizona in August, said he had taken part in some of Hof’s campaign efforts and was asked by Hof to speak at the party. The lawman said he delivered his comments to the crowd, wished Hof well and ate birthday cake.
Trump: Don’t blame me if Republicans lose WASHINGTON Associated Press FACING an electoral defeat that could imperil his presidency, President Donald Trump said yesterday that he won’t accept the blame if Republicans lose the House in November, arguing that he is “helping people” in the midterms. In a wide-ranging interview, Trump also accused his longtime personal attorney Michael Cohen of “lying” under oath, defended his use of the derisive nickname “Horseface” for porn actress Stormy Daniels and argued that the widespread condemnation of the Saudis in the disappearance of a Washington Post columnist was a rush to judgment. Of his efforts on the campaign trail, Trump said: “I don’t believe anybody has ever had this kind of impact.” He resisted comparisons to former President Barack Obama, who took responsibility for the Democrats’ defeat in 2010 by
PRESIDENT Donald Trump in the Oval Office of the White House yesterday. AP Photo/Evan Vucci
acknowledging that his party got “shellacked.” Democrats are hopeful about their chances to
recapture the House, while Republicans are increasingly confident they can hold the Senate. If Democrats
take the House and pursue impeachment or investigations — including seeking his long-hidden tax returns— Trump said he will “handle it very well.” Trump also declared that Cohen’s testimony was “totally false” in his August plea deal to campaign finance violations alleging he coordinated with Trump on a hush-money scheme to buy the silence of Daniels and a Playboy model who alleged affairs. But in entering the deal with Cohen, prosecutors signaled that they accepted his recitation of facts and account of what occurred. He derided Cohen, who worked for Trump for a decade, as “a PR person who did small legal work,” and
said it was “very sad” that Cohen had struck a deal to “achieve a lighter sentence.” And Trump did not back down from derisively nicknaming Daniels “Horseface” in a tweet hours earlier. Asked if it was appropriate to insult a woman’s appearance, Trump responded, “You can take it any way you want.” Trump said that Washington lawyer Pat Cipollone will serve as his next White House counsel and that he hoped to announce a replacement for UN Ambassador Nikki Haley in the next week or two. He again repeated his frustration with Attorney General Jeff Sessions over the special counsel investigation, saying, “I can fire him
whenever I want to fire him.” On the ongoing Russia investigation, Trump defended his son Donald Trump Jr for a Trump Tower meeting with a Kremlinconnected lawyer offering damaging information about Democrat Hillary Clinton. Trump called his son a “good young guy” and said he did what any political aide would have done. Trump also touted the successful confirmation of Supreme Court Justice Brett Kavanaugh as helping to motivate GOP voters. Trump said he spoke to former President George W Bush about Kavanaugh but, when asked, said he did not thank him for the calls he made to lobby GOP senators.
CANADA BECOMES THE SECOND AND LARGEST COUNTRY WITH A LEGAL NATIONAL MARIJUANA MARKETPLACE TORONTO Associated Press TOM Clarke has been dealing marijuana illegally in Canada for 30 years. He wrote in his high school yearbook that his dream was to open a cafe in Amsterdam, the Dutch city where people have legally smoked weed in coffee shops since the 1970s. Turns out, Clarke didn’t have to go nearly so far to open his own retail cannabis outlet as yesterday, Canada becomes the second and largest country with a legal national marijuana marketplace. Uruguay was first. Clarke, 43, will be among the first to legally
sell recreational marijuana when his shop opens at midnight in Newfoundland, Canada’s easternmost province. “I am living my dream. Teenage Tom Clarke is loving what I am doing with my life right now,” he said. At least 111 legal pot shops are planning to open across the nation of 37 million people on the first day, according to a survey of the provinces. That is a small slice of what ultimately will be a much larger marketplace. No stores will open in Ontario, which includes Toronto. The most populous province is working on its regulations and doesn’t
expect stores until next spring. Canadians everywhere will be able to order marijuana products through websites run by provinces or private retailers and have it delivered to their homes by mail. Canada’s federal government, led by Prime Minister Justin Trudeau, spent about two years planning for legalisation, fuelled by a desire to bring dealers like Clarke out of the black market and into a regulated system. Canada’s national approach has allowed for unfettered industry banking, inter-province shipments of cannabis and billions of dollars in investment.
ETHIOPIA’S NEW CABINET 50 PERCENT WOMEN ADDIS ABABA Associated Press ETHIOPIA’S new Cabinet is now a record 50 percent female, including the country’s first woman defence minister, after lawmakers on unanimously approved the nominations put forward by reformist Prime Minister Abiy Ahmed. “Our women ministers will disprove the old adage that women can’t lead,” Abiy said while presenting his choices. “This decision is the first in the history of Ethiopia and probably in Africa.”
Ethiopia has faced sweeping political and economic reforms since the 42-year-old prime minister took office in April after months of anti-government protests and made pledges that include free and fair elections. The Horn of Africa power joins a handful of countries, mostly European, where women make up 50 percent or more of ministerial positions, according to the Inter-Parliamentary Union and U.N. Women. French President Emmanuel Macron and Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau in recent
years unveiled “genderbalanced” Cabinets. Aisha Mohammed Musa will lead Ethiopia’s defence ministry. Another woman, former House speaker Muferiat Kamil, will lead the new Ministry of Peace at a time when Africa’s second most populous country faces sometimes violent ethnic tensions as the wider political freedoms are explored. UN Women has said. “Women and girls in Ethiopia are strongly disadvantaged compared to boys and men in several areas, including literacy, health, livelihoods and basic human rights.”