SOLUTIONS MANUAL for The Legal and Regulatory Environment of Business, 19th Edition by Marisa Pagnattaro, Daniel Cahoy, Julie Manning Magid, Peter Shedd Chapter 1-22
Chapter 1 Law as a Foundation for Business Learning Objectives The purpose of this chapter is to introduce the students to the subject of law and to some classifications of its subject matter. In addition, it is designed to instill in them respect for the role of the ―rule of law‖ in the society and that the judicial system is the most important stabilizing force in society. It should create an awareness that law is a foundation for the private market and ―property‖ as a legal concept underpins that market and contributes to the maximum wealth of nations through productivity. This chapter also describes stare decisis, basic sources of the American law, and sanctions that can be imposed when the law is not followed.
References
Bethell, Tom, The Noblest Triumph (1999). Bernstein, William J., The First of Plenty. McGraw-Hill (2004). Driegel, Blandine, The State and the Rule of Law. Princeton U. Press (1995). Friedman, Lawrence M., American Law, 2d ed. Norton (1998). Harnett, Bertram, Law, Lawyers and Laymen: Making Sense of the American Legal System. San Diego: Harcourt Brace Jovanovich (1984). Helpman, Elhanan, The Mystery of Economic Growth. Belknap Press (2004). Holmes, The Common Law. Little, Brown and Company (1922). Kelman, M., A Guide to Critical Legal Studies. Harvard (1988). Pound, An Introduction to the Philosophy of Law. Yale University Press (1922). Reed, O. Lee, ―Law, the Rule of Law, and Property,‖ American Business Law Journal, Vol. 38 (2001). Reed, O. Lee, ―Nationbuilding 101: Reductionism in Property, Liberty, and Corporate Governance,‖ 36 Vanderbilt Journal of Transitional Law 673 (2003). The Spirit of the Common Law. Marshall Jones Co. (1921).
1-1 Copyright ©2022 McGraw-Hill Education. All rights reserved. No reproduction or distribution without the prior written consent of McGraw-Hill Education.
Teaching Outline I. Introduction A. Why Law and Regulations Are Fundamental Foundations for Business (LO 1-1) Emphasize: That by studying the legal and regulatory environment of business, students will gain an understanding of basic legal vocabulary and gain the ability to identify problematic situations that could result in liability. That because of the positive role lawyers can play, they are increasingly being asked to join corporate boards. Sidebar 1.1 titled ‗Sustainability and Integrity: Cautionary Tales of Legal Liability.‘ II. Law, the Rule of Law, and Property A. Law Emphasize: The simple definition of law. It can be elaborated by observing that law is a rule-based, state-enforced formal ordering system with moral elements. That adequate law and legal institutes promote the certainty and trust necessary for complex, long-term business arrangements. In an economic sense, they lower the costs of transacting business. Additional Matters for Discussion: Discuss that law formalizes values and traditions and that law is more needed in a large, heterogeneous modern nation than in a smaller, homogeneous nation. Compare the U.S. and Japan. It is not too early in this chapter to ask students whether or not lack of law and strict regulation facilitated the economic crash and recession that began in 2008. Ask students to comment on how mistrust of law and lawmakers precipitated the ―Occupy Wall Street‖ and other ―Occupy…‖ movements that arose in 2011. Discuss how the law impacts the COVID 19 restrictions on businesses opening in 2020. B. The Rule of Law Emphasize: That under a rule of law, laws are generally and equally applicable. That lack of the rule of law internationally has produced hundreds of calls for it in the 1-2 Copyright ©2022 McGraw-Hill Education. All rights reserved. No reproduction or distribution without the prior written consent of McGraw-Hill Education.
last several years by business and political leaders. Get students to search for rule-oflaw references in computer databases. That the complete rule of law is an ideal rather than a fact in even the most democratic societies.
Additional Matters for Discussion: Get students to discuss why the managing director of J.P. Morgan and Co. called the rule of law ―a cornerstone of free trade.‖ Ask students why the rule of law tends to produce rules that benefit everyone. Answer: Because laws apply generally and equally to everyone, the only way lawmakers can benefit themselves is by benefitting everyone. This answer is theoretical, of course. Lawmakers are often benefited individually for making laws that favor special interests. Ask students to imagine how society would be with no laws. What if the governor of one‘s state announced that tomorrow would be no-law day and that nothing would be penalized or enforced, no police would be present and no penalties would result from anyone‘s actions. What would the students do? One is likely to find that after a few fleeting and whimsical thoughts, they would agree that they would primarily act to protect their real and personal property. C. Property (LO 1-2) Emphasize: The two meanings of property. That property is not the resource or thing itself. It is a right (or series of rights). That the property right gives a major incentive to develop resources. That the exclusionary right of property provides a basis for the private market and modern business. Additional Matters for Discussion: Ask students to discuss the incentive to grow and prosper and the incentive to innovate and progress under a system with a right to private property ownership and a communist system where private ownership of property is greatly diminished for most. Would they even be in school if accumulation of property rights were not attainable? D. Property in its Broadest Sense Emphasize: How in its broadest sense ―property‖ is the central concept of Western legal systems. How property can be thought of as the hub of a wheel and the various legal topics studied in the text as spokes of the wheel. Law and the rule of law provide the unifying 1-3 Copyright ©2022 McGraw-Hill Education. All rights reserved. No reproduction or distribution without the prior written consent of McGraw-Hill Education.
rim of the wheel. (Refer to Figure 1.1) That for Madison and other constitutional framers, property protected not only physical resources like land but also human rights like freedom of speech, freedom of religion, and freedom from unreasonable intrusion by the government.
Additional Matters for Discussion: Ask students to discuss the statement: ―Bill Gates and your professor have equal property.‖ The point is to examine the confusion between ―resources‖ and ―property.‖ Arguably, although Bill Gates and the student may have vastly different amounts of resources, he and the student have exactly the same right to these respective resources, thus the same ―property.‖ In Federalist Paper 10, Madison wrote: ―Property… in its particular application means that ‗domination which one man claims and exercises over the external things of the world, in exclusion of every other individual.‘ In its larger and juster meaning, it embraces everything to which a man may attach a value and have a right; and which leaves to everyone else a like advantage. In the former sense, a man‘s land, or merchandise, or money is called his property. In the latter sense, a man has property in his opinions and the free communication of them. He has a property of peculiar value in his religious opinions, and in the profession and practice dictated by them. He has property very dear to him in the safety and liberty of his person. He has an equal property in the free use of his faculties and free choice of the objects on which to employ them. In a word, as a man is said to have a right to his property, he may be equally said to have a property in his rights.‖ Madison‘s ―larger and juster meaning‖ of property opens up all sorts of opportunities for discussion with students. Note that although a system of property is basic to private business in the modern nation, it does not preclude redistribution of resources for education, health, and relief of poverty and adversity, etc. Even as the American revolutionaries maintained ―no taxation (of our individual resources) without representation,‖ they appreciated the necessity of appropriate taxation (of one‘s resources) with democratic representation. The importance of the broader sense of private property in the common law grows out of the Magna Carta. From the 13th through the 18th centuries, the importance of private property created constitutional tension between the English monarchs and their subjects. The monarchs often claimed in essence that they owned the nation, its land, and its produce, yet in opposition to this there was a growing sense that people owned things privately and could be taxed on this private ownership only through their own representative consent. Thus, the British colonists in the new world claimed they could not be taxed without representation. The Sons of liberty, one of the first revolutionary groups, had as their slogan ―Liberty, Property, and no Stamps.‖
1-4 Copyright ©2022 McGraw-Hill Education. All rights reserved. No reproduction or distribution without the prior written consent of McGraw-Hill Education.
E. Jurisprudence Emphasize: The various schools of jurisprudence. How the various schools of jurisprudence overlap. That the word jurisprudence also refers to the general body of law interpreted by judges as opposed to legislation. II. Classifications of Law A. Common Law and Civil Law (LO 1-3) Emphasize: That the ―common law‖ countries are those that were colonized by England and take the legal approach of that nation. That common law emerged as judge-made law and even today emphasizes the importance of judges in the legal system. That civil law relies on the legislation rather than judicial decisions to determine what the law is. Under civil law, courts are primarily fact-finding bodies. B. Public and Private Law Emphasize: The distinction between public and private law. That constitutional law, administrative law, and criminal law are three of the main sources of public law. That property law, contract law, and tort law are three of the main types of private law. C. Civil Law and Criminal Law Emphasize: That for administrative purposes, courts usually separate criminal actions from all other lawsuits. That civil law as a classification of law is not the same as civil law as discussed previously as a system of law. The context of the term‘s use must be considered when defining the term. Sidebar 1.4 titled ―Goldman Sachs: ‗Rogue‘ Bankers and a $1 Billion Legal Charge‖ D. Substantive Law and Procedural Law 1-5 Copyright ©2022 McGraw-Hill Education. All rights reserved. No reproduction or distribution without the prior written consent of McGraw-Hill Education.
Emphasize: The distinction between substantive and procedural laws. That substantive rules of law define rights and duties, while procedural rules of law provide the machinery for enforcing those rights and duties. IV. Sources of Law (LO 1-4) A. Federal Law Emphasize: That federal law is a very important source of law. It includes the U.S. Constitution, which is the supreme law of the nation. That any law, federal or state, that conflicts with the Constitution is said to be void and has no legal effect. That next in the hierarchy of federal law comes the legislation passed by Congress, also called ―acts‖ or ―statutes‖ (collections of legislation, often on the same subject, are codes). B. State Law Emphasize: The distinction between a statute, a code, and an ordinance. The benefits of uniform legislation and especially the Uniform Commercial Code. Additional Matter for Discussion: The problem of clear, concise, and accurate statutory drafting. Have the students write a definition for a law prohibiting ―conduct unbecoming a student.‖ C. Judicial Decisions or Case Law Emphasize: How a judicial opinion becomes a precedent and how a case is cited. The distinction between a holding of a case that establishes precedent and dicta. Additional Matters for Discussion: Discuss how in America‘s property-based legal system, resolving disputes over the meaning and application of the law is imperative. Judicial decision-making formally resolves disputes. Talk about the need to have impartial judges. Have the students express their views on originalism. Do they think that originalism can be fair and effective over 200 years after a document was drafted? 1-6 Copyright ©2022 McGraw-Hill Education. All rights reserved. No reproduction or distribution without the prior written consent of McGraw-Hill Education.
Advantages Emphasize: The importance of stare decisis. The advantages of stare decisis. Disadvantages Emphasize: That the disadvantages of case law include volume of cases, conflicting precedents, dicta, rejection of precedent, and conflicts of law. The problem of conflict of laws and the attempts at resolution. Additional Matters for Discussion: Discuss how a wrongly decided case can create bad precedent (such as Plessy v. Ferguson, and how the Court corrected it in Brown v. Board of Education).
D. Sources of Law Hierarchy in Review Emphasize: That law comes in a hierarchy. Law higher in the hierarchy overrules or preempts lower law. E. Legal Sanctions Emphasize: That sanctions are necessary to encourage or force compliance with the law. That the Fourteenth Amendment mandates that individuals receive due process. That the right of an individual to take another person‘s resources (especially money) because that person has failed to meet the requirements of the law (e.g., the breach of a contract) is known as a remedy. F. Sanctions for Criminal Conduct Emphasize: That criminal actions may result in one or more of the five sanctions listed. That the purposes of sanctions are to protect the public and deter further criminal conduct. 1-7 Copyright ©2022 McGraw-Hill Education. All rights reserved. No reproduction or distribution without the prior written consent of McGraw-Hill Education.