TABLE OF CONTENTS 1.
Cover Letter
2.
Firm Overview
3.
Project Understanding Project Approach Scope Project Schedule Overview
4.
Relevant Project Experience
5.
Project Team
6.
Client References
7.
Required Forms and Certifications
SECTION NO.
ONE Cover Letter
LET US ENTERTAIN YOU. Or perhaps you’d rather be Amazed. Inspired. Even Enlightened. We partner with our clients to shape uncommon experiences unique to each Community, Patron and Venue.
February 22, 2018 John Rumble, Purchasing Manager City of Tavares 201 East Main Street Tavares, FL 32778
Re: Performing Arts Center and Library Study | RFQ 2018-0005
Dear Members of the Selection Committee, “Tavares…America’s Seaplane City,” a truly unique identity that sets Tavares apart from other communities and an integral part of its recent revitalization. Now imagine the next addition to the Tavares renaissance, a transformative arts, entertainment, and information center that is a true destination…a place where “things happen.” A center active all day and into the night engaging the Tavares community and utilizing the power of culture and information as a catalyst for growth. A memorable, provocatively designed facility, one will want to return to again and again, as parent and child for story hour, as patron for classical and experimental theater, or as a country music performer. Wilson Butler Architects is a firm unique in our focused dedication to architecture for the arts and have an unsurpassed wealth of knowledge regarding this complex building type. We have assembled a team of additional consultants, all with equal specialization within their fields and together we understand the challenges that are at the core of your project, the concerns of multiple stakeholders often involved, and how to design for the future of the performing arts and the new role of the library. To achieve this goal, the process and subsequent solutions will require extraordinary attention, and innovative thinking from an experienced Design Team to clarify and translate the visions of the Tavares leadership, stakeholders, and community. It demands a team familiar with bringing complex projects to fruition under the constraints of time and budget. Collaborating with clients to uncover exciting, elegant, and functional solutions is what we do. Per the request of the RFQ, we have included the Benefactor Group on our team as Fundraising Consultants, and their impressive credentials can be found within this submission. Although allocated costs for a study such as this are in the general range of similar project studies, Fundraising Consultants are typically not within this scope. Wilson Butler Architects and our team are pleased to submit for your consideration, the following qualifications. We are enthused by the prospect of your project. Tavares has an outstanding opportunity, let’s all visualize the future of a Performing Arts Center and Library in Tavares – a facility that fills a missing niche, creates a cultural/information nexus and makes all that visit say “WOW!” We’re ready to get started.
Sincerely, 70 Federal St., 5th Floor Boston, MA 02110 P: 617.720.7127 wilsonbutler.com
Scott C. Wilson, AIA Paul Vaivoda, AIA, LEED AP BD+C Director, Wilson Butler Architects Senior Associate, Wilson Butler Architects scw@wilsonbutler.com pv@wilsonbutler.com
BLANK PAGE
SECTION NO.
TWO Firm Overview
SMALL STUDIO BIG IDEAS Founded in 1997, Wilson Butler Architects (WBA) is a firm unique in our focused dedication to architecture for the arts. Our projects span a wide range within this specialty area, including new and renovated educational arts facilities dedicated to students of the performing arts, civic performing arts centers, the restoration and expansion of historic theatres and the design of state-of-the-art entertainment venues.
CITY OF TAVARES, FL - PERFORMING ARTS AND LIBRARY STUDY
1
WE DESIGN PLACES WHERE PEOPLE WANT TO BE. These are spaces to experience life – to be enlightened by the arts, take in a class on animation, relish in great conversation over food and wine, or be reduced to tears of laughter by a wicked performance.
OUR SERVICES
REPRESENTATIVE CLIENTS
Feasibility Studies
Akron Civic Theatre Auburn University Berklee College of Music Boch Performing Arts Center Boston Arts Academy Boston Ballet School Boston University, College of Fine Arts Broward Center for the Performing Arts Bushnell Center for the Performing Arts Calderwood Pavilion Celebrity Cruises City of Boston, MA, Strand Theatre City of Herndon, VA, Cultural Arts Center Colonial Theatre Franklin School for the Performing Arts Hartford Stage Company Howard Community College Merrimack Repertory Theatre New England Foundation for the Arts Ogunquit Playhouse Ordway Center for the Performing Arts Richmond CenterStage Royal Caribbean International St. Tammany Parish, Cultural Arts District Towson University, Center for the Arts Virginia Performing Arts Foundation Worcester Business Development Corporation
Programming Master Planning
29
Full-Service Architecture Design Interior Design Construction Administration
Professional & Technical Staff
ABOUT US Our focus on architecture for the arts is the product of our directors’ 30+ year careers designing performance and cultural facilities. With this singular focus, WBA can bring our clients an unsurpassed wealth of knowledge regarding this particularly complex building type, while successfully leading projects from the programming/master planning phases through construction and occupancy. To understand the history of this success, you should know more about WBA’s history prior to its founding. WBA’s founding directors, Scott Wilson and Scott Butler, began their careers working for Benjamin Thompson + Associates, the nationally-recognized and award-winning firm that emphasized buildings are about creating a “setting for an enriched way of life.” Having spent a decade working under Ben’s design influence, they proudly continue that approach as they design facilities which meet each client’s unique requirements, respond to the individual physical context of each site, and celebrate the joy embodied in the arts. Our buildings reflect that creative energy, the character of their distinct surroundings and the unique personality of their users. As a result, our projects are distinctive without a ‘signature style.’ We take great pride in our work and the energy we apply to each challenge. More importantly, our enthusiasm energizes our clients, our consultant partners, and the construction teams. By maintaining an open door policy for our clients and designing in a transparent method, we invite all project participants to be as invested in the design outcome as we are. Employing a staff of 29, our repeat client business is a testimony to our dedication and high level of service.
* Blue text indicates project is highlighted in this submittal
Wilson Butler Architects 70 Federal Street, 5th Floor Boston, MA 02110 www.wilsonbutler.com
2
CITY OF TAVARES, FL - PERFORMING ARTS AND LIBRARY STUDY
SECTION NO.
THREE Project Understanding Project Approach Scope Project Schedule Overview
Calderwood Pavilion, Boston, MA
PROJECT UNDERSTANDING
The Request for Qualifications outlines the key tasks for this study, each of which requires experience and innovation:
The Project outlined in the Request for Qualifications presents an exciting opportunity for the City of Tavares to develop a cultural arts project within the context of a vibrant and engaged community that will not only strengthen its relationship with its current residents but will also strengthen its relationship with the greater artistic community. Wilson Butler Architects (WBA) recognizes that this project has the potential to redefine the arts experience in Tavares. We look forward to developing a solution that exceeds the expectations of the City, its residents and, the greater community. Through a collaborative approach to design, the WBA team will strive to deliver new ideas, creative solutions, and innovative design techniques while respecting the development principles the City has developed over time. We believe our design philosophy and the City’s goals are well-aligned – each focused on the connections between urban redevelopment and improving the arts within a community. We are pleased to submit the following response to the Request for Qualifications for the Performing Arts and Library Study.
OUR DESIGN PROCESS IS DEEPLY COLLABORATIVE, WE BELIEVE IN TOTAL TEAM INVOLVEMENT AND TRANSPARENCY.
Our firm is an energized and interdisciplinary group of designers dedicated to the improvement of the quality of life in American cities through rigorous planning, exceptional design, and strong community partnerships. In recent years, this shared mission has manifested in working relationships with many great Florida communities including, Fort Lauderdale, Jacksonville, and Miami. We also recognize that every City is unique and requires a fundamentally different design response. Through the exploration ideas, WBA, working with the City, will create a locally-grounded yet nationally-significant new performing arts center and library. We envision a space for both residents and visitors, where public life is vibrant year-round. The new Performing Arts Center and Library have the powerful potential to further knit the City and the residents of Tavares to the downtown urban core.
CITY OF TAVARES, FL - PERFORMING ARTS AND LIBRARY STUDY
1
Site Selection: Conduct a site selection analysis and “best location” recommendation
2
Program & Uses: Given the two sites, identify the program (uses/users and square footage of the uses - Performing Arts Center, Black Box Theater, Library, Parking Garage, Studio Rooms, Gallery, HVAC, dressing rooms, Roof Top Meeting Area etc.….)
3
Construction Budget: Develop a budget for design and construction of the proposed facility based on the City Council’s selected one location and program to pursue
4
Funding Sources For Construction: Identify all potential sources of funding for the facility (Grants, City, County, State, Tax Incremental financing, and Tourist and Development Council (TDC) “Heads in beds tax”, Economic Development Administration funds, Investors, Philanthropy etc.….)
5
Annual Operating Budget: Develop an operating budget that includes annual anticipated revenues and annual anticipated expenses. Identify a cost sharing program for the continued and ongoing operations and maintenance of the facility
6
Presentations: Present the report to the City Council and Library boards
7
Final Report: Develop a final report entitled “Performing Arts Center & Library Study”
3 The process that follows represents our proposed approach for this effort. We anticipate refining and tailoring the process, scope and schedule to best align with the needs, timeframe, working patterns, and culture of the City. A strong working partnership between our team and the City will be critical to the plan’s success. Our experience on similar projects of this scope and scale will ensure we lead a precise and coordinated effort.
3
OUR APPROACH
TASK 1 – SITE SELECTION
We believe that an approach establishes the working style of an individual, a team, and a process. It is an opportunity to plan a coordinated effort that will directly link those that share a common goal to an engaged programming and design dialogue with the City of Tavares. It is essential to understand your history, learn your culture, and embrace your aspirations. We believe this process will lead to innovative and thoughtful design approach – inspired by the history and mission of the City.
Selection of the most suitable location for the Tavares Performing Arts Center and Library is not only one of the initial tasks but is also one of the most important. An architectural design solution is greatly impacted and informed by the specific site on which it is located. Not only will the design be influenced by the physical attributes of the site, the perception of the site within the “whole” and community context but it will also embrace the current development activity in Tavares.
WBA’s approach to design problem solving is one that is based on our extensive experience leading diverse and multi-faceted clients and stakeholders, while tailoring the specific procedures to your unique project. However, at its fundamental core, it is a process of inclusion. We expect and encourage our clients, and in your case when appropriate, the Tavares community, to get involved. We are there to challenge their assumptions and ask them to challenge ours. We pose provocative questions, often exposing overlooked or unknown issues. Through this process, the best planning concepts emerge not from preconceived notions, but from a thoughtful, collaborative process. It is a process that is fundamentally sequential and at every step of the design process, we bring the project back to the broader context to ensure that it connects to the whole. A successful outcome is only possible through a rigorous investigation of the design problem, innovative solutions for the performing arts and library programs, and collaboration among all team members and stakeholders. After all, we often say that it is hard to vote against something that one has helped to create.
As part of the physical evaluation and analysis of each of the site options, WBA will review and prepare documentation of the following site characteristics including: Natural conditions, including solar paths and prevailing winds Topography and site drainage Zoning and land use restrictions Circulation, including pedestrian and vehicular, parking, and service Utilities and infrastructure Potential acoustical concerns Available buildable area(s) Neighborhood context and uses
* *
*
SCOPE To complete the Performing Arts Center and Library Study, we propose a four to a six-month planning process that commences in April 2018 and concludes in August of 2018. Please note that this schedule is flexible and is dependent on required review times. Please reference the accompanying schedule for the specific timeframe of required tasks. While the schedule is somewhat linear, we see the process as iterative and realize there may be overlap between phases as we refine and retest ideas. The schedule is organized to provide a deliberate and interactive process with the Tavares community.
Tavares Square Site
BIG PICTURE VISIONING. Before embarking on the following tasks, we will conduct a high-level
visioning session with the City, Stakeholders, and the broader Tavares Community. This visioning session is intended to be explored hand-in-hand with Problem Definition. It is an intensive session with stakeholders and users where the collecting of ideas begins to inform an inspirational future – “Where should we be headed?” Combining statements from core values to operational objectives to aspirations, we will collectively begin to define and delineate the Guiding Principles of the project. This will establish the Guiding Principles of the project and will aid the team in solution evaluation.
Extended T Site
Each of the Tasks 1 through 7 may be initially seen as distinct efforts, but they cannot necessarily be treated independently. There are interrelationships and concurrent efforts that inform one another to result in the most grounded decisions and solutions. However, in the interest of responding to your RFQ, the below describes our approach to each of the Tasks while at the same time, defining what additional Task exercises and research will be conducted during specific tasks. Library Block Site
4
CITY OF TAVARES, FL - PERFORMING ARTS AND LIBRARY STUDY
S
ails
300
My Map Basemap
As stated earlier, site evaluation is more than what can be found in underground utility drawings, site surveys or zoning ordinances. It is about the perception of the site. As part of our evaluation, we will be “experiencing” the sites – walking the area at various times of the day and night and understanding existing activity zones – in order better understand and evaluate what the sites have to offer to the project and what the project offers the neighboring context. It is about the Opportunities and Constraints that work towards creating a sense of place for the Performing Arts and Library within Tavares and alignment with the Guiding Principles. We will approach our analysis without pre-conceived notions and present our findings, experiences, and the preferred site recommendations to the Tavares City Council in clear, graphics and written formats for consensus and approval. Print
The Task 2 programming exercise will be orchestrated by WBA with the Library programming spearheaded by our Library Specialist Consultant, Kimberly Bolan, and Associates (KBA). KBA’s approach revolves around “rethinking, re-envisioning, and redesigning” and includes everything from understanding 21st-century services and services models and how they impact physical design to creating flexible and creative library spaces that can adapt into the future; meeting library and community needs as they continue to evolve and change.
LIBRARIES ARE STILL ABOUT KNOWLEDGE, BUT NOW THEY ARE EVOLVING INTO LIFELONG LEARNING CENTERS.
The Renaissance of the City of Tavares ‘Live-Work-Play’ Tavares High School
Tavares Public Safety Complex
Library Block Site Lake County Clerk of Courts Extended T Site
Lake County Administration Building
Tavares City Hall
Lake County Courthouse Lake County Sheriff’s Office
Tavares Square Area Ruby Street Beautification Plan Key West Resort on Lake Dora
Wooton Park Expansion
Proposed Site Options
Recent Developments/Improvements
Municipal Buildings/Public Education
600ft
During our Site Selection Task 1, identified Tasks 4 and 5 would need to begin to provide information for the Programming Task 2. AMS Planning & Research (AMS) will start initial Market Analysis and User Assessment, while the Benefactor Group will begin their initial investigations of potential funding sources.
Once we have had the opportunity to translate information gathered from interviews and research, we can begin looking at building organization concepts. By utilizing both 2-D graphics and 3-D block representations of the program spaces, all stakeholders can grasp a better understanding of the scale of spaces and the potential interrelationships. These simple block tools enable us together to examine possible alternate configurations from adjacency and massing standpoints on each of the two preferred sites. These studies then inform the site organization for the development of Conceptual Site Plans.
TASK 2 – PROGRAM & USES As we begin the programming and needs assessment portion of the project, we delve deeper into the more specific requirements of both the performance (front-of-house and back-of-house) and library spaces through meetings with all primary stakeholders. This will entail information gathering sessions with both distinct user groups and City officials. This is a time for all voices to be heard. It is a challenging task, and throughout our extensive experience, and proven methodologies, we simplify the process by breaking the program into more manageable parts. We are expert distillers, and with the help of stakeholders, we can together build consensus of what’s most important and develop the driving space goals and systems to guide the project. The programming effort builds upon the breadth and depth of the previous and ongoing findings of AMS, most specifically the size of the House or number of seats that would best be supported by the local and regional market, united with the specific types of performances to be accommodated, the design team can address programing with a more focused purpose. CITY OF TAVARES, FL - PERFORMING ARTS AND LIBRARY STUDY
5
The Public Presentation Workshop One is a critical first exposure of the project to the Tavares community, and it will purposely be organized to bring the community up to speed on the decision making process to date – Guiding Principles, Site Analysis, Market Research, Programming, and options. During this workshop, the community will be exposed to the early design process through drawings and models, with resident input in this open forum is paramount. The workshop format consists of initial presentations by the WBA team on various related topics and small group work sessions that allow specific topics to be examined in greater detail. It is when early buy-in, support, and excitement begins to build. Following this meeting, input can be incorporated and prepared into a score matrix forming the basis for recommendation and City Council approval.
Although during the Programming Phase, we may have assigned an approximate per square foot cost to the project, it is not until the Conceptual Design is well underway that true conceptual pricing can be accomplished. Our cost consultant, Cost+Plus, specializes in this complex building type and we have worked together for years on multiple projects. More accurate definition of areas, materials selection, and systems descriptions will all gel to provide the basis for conscientious cost estimating. Upon completion, the Conceptual Cost Estimate will be presented to the City Council before any public release for review. Public Presentation Workshop Two will present to the Tavares community Conceptual Design to date and include both 2-D and 3-D representations of the design. These presentation materials are intended to excite the community but are also presented in a way that still allows for input and comment. Following the public meeting, the Design Team will respond to appropriate community comments and present the Conceptual Design and Cost Estimate to the City Council.
TASK 3 – CONCEPTUAL DESIGN AND CONSTRUCTION BUDGET Up to this point in the process, we have purposely focused our collaborative design efforts on defining of needs, analysis, and the pragmatic functional requirements of the Performing Arts Center and Library. Because of the differing characteristics of each of the sites, venturing into the architectural aesthetic character and response would be premature. However, now that we have a program and site, the fun can really begin.
Conceptual Rendering, Rooftop Club, Jay and Susie Gogue Performing Arts Center
Conceptual Design is without question the most exciting part for all involved. It is a time to explore all the possibilities to translate practicality of function into a stirring architectural expression – Solutions that cause the future visitor from near or far to say “Wow!” The Stakeholder Workshop Charrette at the beginning of the Conceptual Design phase will be about the walls of our meeting space covered with examples of inspiration and precedents. What are the best examples of similar facilities elsewhere in the world? What makes them inspiring? What makes them memorable? What makes them forward thinking? This exploration opens the eyes of the team and stakeholders to what could be. With our program blocks and simple “floor plate” models, we can quickly test and evaluate options as we re-evaluate site decisions to date. Our study models are especially helpful to laypeople to better understand spacial relationships. During Conceptual Design the Design Team is further expanded to include engineering consultant, TLC Engineering who will bring their experience and insights to define the most appropriate structural and mechanical systems. Economics, constructability, and sustainable design will be integral evaluation tools throughout the Conceptual Design Phase. Conceptual Design Presentation, Lower Orchestra Plan, St. Tammany Parish PAC
6
CITY OF TAVARES, FL - PERFORMING ARTS AND LIBRARY STUDY
TASK 4 – FUNDING SOURCES FOR CONSTRUCTION OUR APPROACH Successful fundraising is built on a foundation that includes the following essential elements. 1.
A highly regarded institution that has earned the respect of stakeholders and the community for exceptional services and prudent administration.
2.
A compelling case for support that describes fundraising goals as sound philanthropic investments that will appeal to prospective funders.
3.
Generous financial commitments that account for the majority of the goal and inspire generosity from others.
4.
Committed leaders who will devote their time and talent to achieve the fundraising results.
5.
Ample financial potential within your prospect pool.
6.
Sufficient technology, infrastructure, and personnel within the organization to carry out the appropriate fundraising tactics.
The preliminary case for support offers compelling arguments for completing the campaign vision with a sense of urgency. It will serve as the basis of a conversation between Benefactor Group consultants and potential funders during discovery interviews. DISCOVERY Individual Interviews Benefactor Group will speak with past, current, and potential supporters whose involvement in this project can make it successful. To that end, we will seek 15 to 20 interviews. Each prospective interviewee will receive the preliminary case for support and a letter of invitation to participate in the feasibility study. This allows interviewees to be prepared for a productive conversation. Benefactor Group will work with City staff to determine the best approach to scheduling interviews. We attempt to conduct interviews in person; however, we would conduct telephone interviews when schedules preclude personal meetings. Through these discussions, we will accomplish the following. • Assess the appeal of the proposed goals among potential funders • Evaluate the likelihood of attracting strong leaders and funding to support the project.
Raise Money
Build Capacity
Strengthen Leadership
They’re All Connected
• Identify external factors such as competition and the general economic climate that may affect the timing and strategy of the effort. FOCUS GROUP DISCUSSIONS (OPTIONAL) While the personal interviews are being conducted, Benefactor Group can organize and schedule focus groups. We will prepare a letter of invitation and develop the questionnaire for distribution at the conclusion of the focus group discussions. All data collected from the discussions will come directly to Benefactor Group and be held in confidence. BENCHMARKING AND RESEARCH We gather publicly available data from sources such National Center for Charitable Statistics, Giving USA, GuideStar, and similar sources. We will also utilize existing data and research from organizations that have done similar work. The result of this research will establish a baseline and benchmarks for a successful project.
Our study will examine each of these elements and factor them into our findings, recommendations, and financial forecast. ORIENTATION Benefactor Group will initiate this phase of the project by planning a kickoff meeting with City officials and related partners to establish rapport; identify stakeholders to be interviewed (e.g., City officials, community leaders, corporations, foundations, etc.); and identify the individuals that will define the case for support. Benefactor Group consultants will create the agenda and lead the meeting. PRELIMINARY CASE FOR SUPPORT To assess the fundraising potential of the project, we must first define and document the case for support. Benefactor Group will work with the City of Tavares staff, and/or other individuals identified in the kickoff meeting, to develop a two- to three-page document that provides a powerful and succinct articulation of the project’s goals. Staff will review a draft of the document and provide feedback to Benefactor Group, who will make two revisions to the document. CITY OF TAVARES, FL - PERFORMING ARTS AND LIBRARY STUDY
FAST/SLOW CAMPAIGNS TODAY’S CAMPAIGNS CAN RANGE FROM A SINGLE DAY EVENT, SUCH AS #GIVINGTUESDAY, LOCAL GIVING DAYS, OR A ONE DAY RUN/WALK/RIDE EVENT, TO A TEN YEAR COMPREHENSIVE CAMPAIGN MARATHON.
7
ANALYSIS Once all interviews, focus group discussions, and benchmarking research have been completed, Benefactor Group consultants will analyze the data gathered during discovery. We gather quantitative information—data, statistics, and responses to yes-no and multiple-choice questions on our questionnaires. We also collect qualitative information—stories, anecdotes, and the answers to open-ended questions from the interviews. We enter the quantitative data into a common source that allows us to collate and cross tabulate the information. We will also add the qualitative information from our interviews and discussions, and perform text analysis of this information. FINDINGS, RECOMMENDATIONS, AND PRO FORMA REVENUE FORECAST Our final deliverable is a comprehensive report of findings and recommendations that includes the following. • Executive Summary—a concise synopsis of the report. • Method—documentation of the study process, including the timeframe, tasks accomplished, and the individuals we engaged on your behalf. • Findings—analysis of the data we gathered to assess the likelihood of a successful campaign, interpretation of the interviews to evaluate support for your fundraising objectives, and potential leadership and leadership giving for a campaign; we will include selected quotes, without attribution, that represent comments made during the discovery interviews. • Recommendations—our advice, based on the findings, and our suggested strategies for such elements as potential funding sources, fundraising strategy, campaign leadership recruitment, timing, funding goal, staffing and infrastructure refinements, and the resources needed to guide and manage the fundraising campaign. • Pro forma revenue forecast – based on the assumptions defined in the findings and recommendations, we will create a pro forma forecast that illustrates anticipated revenue flow for the project.
TASK 5 – ANNUAL OPERATING BUDGET
In order to determine potential events and programs hosted at the Tavares PAC, AMS will use proven standardized protocol, and together with the project team, AMS would survey potential users (including known and/or prospective users) regarding their current patterns of use, desired spaces and systems, and the frequency and nature of any potential enhanced or additional activity, and willingness-to-pay for rental space. This would include other venues utilized and current rental rates. Based on stakeholder and public feedback gained in Task 2, and potential user assessment data, with steering committee input, AMS will outline type and quantity of space needed in a proposed facility for performing arts programming, estimate the number of performances, classes, exhibits, and other activities, which would inform the development of the building program and operating pro forma. Based on project goals, research findings and the proposed activity profile, AMS will recommend an appropriate governance and management structure for the project including staffing and recommended volunteer structure. AMS will then prepare a pro forma operating forecast for the arts component and collaborate with the library and fundraising team members to prepare a normalized year of operations, typically the third year following a facility’s opening and then build a model out for the first five years of operation. This will include: projected income including program fees, rentals, leases, concessions, and contributed revenue and endowment earnings; and forecast operating expenses, including staffing level with associated salaries and wages, payroll costs, advertising, administration, maintenance and repairs, utilities, presentation costs, equipment leases/rentals, insurance, overhead and capital reserves and an analysis of net gain/loss. Deliverable to conclude the study’s work, AMS will submit a comprehensive final planning report, including an executive summary and relevant appendices. The final report will identify a series of recommended next steps to advance the project, and timeline for implementation. Although not identified as part of Task 5, if the Performing Arts Center is meant to be a rental facility or whether they are looking to increase PAC programming and it goes beyond identified user needs, AMS suggests a community survey on program priorities and gaps.
AMS brings to the WBA team nearly 30 years of serving arts clients, from small repertory theatre companies, museums, and communities to major universities, and regional and metropolitan arts organizations. WBA have been collaborating with AMS since our beginning over 20 years ago.
1 Potential Users Assessment
AMS would issue a web-based survey to potential users (including known or prospective users) regarding their interest in using a new performing arts center.
8
2 Local Market Conditions AMS would inventory existing performance spaces, rental rates, programmatic content and facility users to assess opportunities and understand how current conditions may inform operating recommendations.
3 Comparable 3 Facilities Research
AMS would research three comparable facilities to form a basis for assumptions regarding program content, rental policies, staffing and other operational considerations.
4 Activity Profile AMS would outline a base year of activity for the proposed facility for performing arts programming, estimating the number of performances, classes, exhibits, and other activities, which would inform the development of the operating pro forma.
5
Management and Staffing Recommendations
AMS would recommend an appropriate governance and management structure for the project including staffing and recommended volunteer structure.
6 Operating Pro Forma
AMS would prepare a pro forma operating forecast for the arts components and collaborate with the library and fundraising team members.
CITY OF TAVARES, FL - PERFORMING ARTS AND LIBRARY STUDY
TASK 6 & 7 – FINAL REPORT AND PRESENTATIONS As indicated in our proposed Project Schedule that follows, the sequence of Tasks 6 & 7 will be flipped, for we believe that before the final report can be assembled, it is important to have an opportunity for a last review and buy-in by stakeholders. In essence, what is presented to the Board, Staff, and Tavares City Council will be the culmination of the Team’s recommendations and include Conceptual Design material, Cost Estimate, Market Analysis and Operating Budget, Potential Funding, together with recommendations for the reuse of the Library Block Site should it not be the selected site for the new Performing Arts Center and Library. Minor content make-up or document order can be discussed and finalized before printing. We might also recommend the preparation of two final documents; one is the comprehensive report that assembles both Team recommendations along with support material delineating the process of arriving at these decisions, and the second devoted to exciting images and “bottom lines” used expressly for marketing and fundraising.
Conceptual Physical Model
Computer Rendering
CITY OF TAVARES, FL - PERFORMING ARTS AND LIBRARY STUDY
Watercolor Rendering
9
PROJECT SCHEDULE OVERVIEW The proposed WBA Team schedule is based upon an approximate five-month timeline and is fundamentally organized around the coordination of Design Team contributors, together with the synchronization of on-site interview/meeting dates throughout the course of the project. As described earlier, the information and research shared by the Design Team members with one another during the project process is critical for ongoing decision making and is timed accordingly. Additionally, coordination of meetings, presentations, interviews, etc. with stakeholders, Boards, City Council, and the Tavares community have been scheduled to provide both collective disseminating of Design Team conclusions and to reduce costs. The proposed schedule can be modified following review and discussion with the City of Tavares leadership, stakeholders, and the Design Team should a more aggressive completion date be required.
10
CITY OF TAVARES, FL - PERFORMING ARTS AND LIBRARY STUDY
CITY OF TAVARES, FL - PERFORMING ARTS AND LIBRARY STUDY
11
12
CITY OF TAVARES, FL - PERFORMING ARTS AND LIBRARY STUDY
SECTION NO.
FOUR Relevant Project Experience
Jay and Susie Gogue Performing Arts Center Auburn, AL
Completion Date: est. 2019 Project Size: 80,000 SF Construction Cost: est. $50M Team Members: A. Scott Butler – Principal-in-Charge Scott C. Wilson – Principal-in-Charge Paul Vaivoda – Project Manager Josh Stiling – Project Architect Chris Dynia – Technical Architect Kelly McFerran – Interior Designer
Located at the southern end of campus, Auburn University’s new Performing Arts Center, together with the Julie Collins Smith Museum of Fine Art, defines the Cultural Arts District and establishes the southern gateway to campus.
The 1,200-seat multi-purpose hall has been designed with natural, variable acoustics, orchestra pit/lift, adjustable proscenium, with a stage (and stagehouse) to accommodate a full range of performers: from a small ensemble or dance troupe, to a full symphony orchestra and chorus, to touring Broadway shows.
The performing arts center is organized around two primary venues: a 1,200 seat multi-purpose performance hall, and a 250-seat flexible venue. These two venues are linked with a transparent multi-story lobby oriented towards the art museum and major campus entry roadway, inviting all to join in the celebration of the arts. Efficient back-of-house programming and design adjacencies allow these critical support spaces to serve both venues thus eliminating unnecessary duplication, while still serving the performer’s important pre and post-performance needs.
The second venue is intended to serve a variety of needs from rehearsal space, banqueting/event space (working in concert with the lobby and outdoor “porch”), and of course, performance space. The second venue will not only facilitate the technical needs of a multi-media experimental theatre, but also has the additional feature of operable “hanger-type” doors that allow for performers to play to an outdoor “lawn” with a capacity of over 2,500 concert goers. The bidding for Site Development began in July 2017 with full bidding in September 2017 for an estimated
completion of the project in the Fall of 2019. The project is designed to achieve LEED Silver Certification.
Project Details: 1,200-seat multi-purpose performance venue 250-seat flexible venue Multi-story lobby Administrative Suite Outdoor theater space Seeking LEED Silver Certification Design Competition Award
Scope of Services: Master Planning Programming Architecture Interior Design Construction Administration
CITY OF TAVARES, FL - PERFORMING ARTS AND LIBRARY STUDY
13
14
CITY OF TAVARES, FL - PERFORMING ARTS AND LIBRARY STUDY
CITY OF TAVARES, FL - PERFORMING ARTS AND LIBRARY STUDY
15
Broward Center for the Performing Arts Fort Lauderdale, FL
Completion Date: 2014 Project Size: 220,000 SF Construction Cost: $40.5M Team Members: A. Scott Butler – Co-Design Director Scott C. Wilson – Co-Design Director Tom Hains – Project Architect Ben Marcionek – Project Designer Kelly McFerran – Interior Designer
In 2009, WBA was selected to develop the design for the $40 million renovation of the 220,000 GSF Broward Center for Performing Arts (BCPA), originally designed by the firm’s partners, Scott Wilson and Scott Butler in 1986 - 1987 (completed 1991), while working with Benjamin Thompson Associates. BCPA asked WBA to study effective ways to create patron interactions with the Center and performers and to enrich the social experience that ensures long-term patronage and broader support from the community. The project was executed in 3 main phases and the facility remained open during the entire construction period. Phase I focused on the
renovation of the 2,700 seat Au-Rene Theater and the creation of the new Club Level, an allinclusive patron experience modeled after those offered in sports arenas, a first in the performing arts industry. Phase II continued with new and improved patron experiences; the new Intermezzo Lounge, Peck Courtyard, renewed lobbies and vastly improved restrooms.
Project Details: 2,700 seat Au-Rene Theater Lounge Outdoor Courtyard 590 seat Amaturo Theater Huizenga Pavilion - Certified LEED Silver Award-Winning Project
Phase III concluded the main project with the grand opening of the new Huizenga Events Pavilion which was sited along the New River and the addition of the Rose Miniaci Arts Education Center. During the summer of 2015, BCPA opted to finish what they started and renovate the 590 seat Amaturo Theater as the final chapter in the ambitious project.
Scope of Services: Programming Master Planning Architecture Interior Design Construction Administration
16
CITY OF TAVARES, FL - PERFORMING ARTS AND LIBRARY STUDY
CITY OF TAVARES, FL - PERFORMING ARTS AND LIBRARY STUDY
17
Cultural Arts Center Herndon, VA
Completion Date: 2003 Project Size: N/A Construction Cost: Study Team Members: Scott C. Wilson – Co-Design Director A. Scott Butler – Co-Design Director
Scope of Services: Site Selection
The master plan and conceptual design for a new Cultural Arts Center for Herndon, VA, a suburb of Washington DC, guides the way for a new home for local arts groups and performances, as well as pointing to a transformation of a significant portion of downtown. Located in western Fairfax County, Herndon is the third largest town in Virginia with a population of 22,000: over the past 20 years, the town has become a center for internet technology yet still retains a strong sense of community with a smalltown charm. The design team identified local and regional users and developed a building program for the center that balanced expansive ‘wish lists’ with
more restrictive budgets. Once the building program, which includes a 275-seat theatre, a 100-seat function hall, and an art gallery, was developed, the program was tested with the firm’s technique of “program massing blocks” on a model of downtown sites and studied for urban design strengths and weaknesses.
Project Details: 275 seat theater 100 seat function hall Art Gallery
We worked with the Town, the board of directors and the user groups to identify the site that would most successfully incorporate the needs of the facility with the Town’s urban design goals, second to sponsor a design process the articulates and satisfies all of the diverse needs of the Art Center’s many constituents and finally to create an economic plan that would allow the Center to be funded and built in phases.
Building Program Verification Conceptual Architectural Design
18
CITY OF TAVARES, FL - PERFORMING ARTS AND LIBRARY STUDY
CITY OF TAVARES, FL - PERFORMING ARTS AND LIBRARY STUDY
19
Virginia Performing Arts Foundation Richmond, VA
Completion Date: 2009 | 2014 Project Size: 179,000 SF Construction Cost: $63M Team Members: Scott C. Wilson – Design Director Josh Stiling – Project Designer Peter Cameron – Project Architect Rebecca Durante – Interior Designer
Scope of Services:
Wilson Butler Architects led the development of a city-wide performance art center master plan for Richmond, Virginia, collaborating with over 15 arts groups along with city and business leadership. The CenterStage complex was Phase 1 of this effort. It joins together two buildings - a 1,800 seat “atmospheric” great theatre of the 1920s with what had been the empty shell of a 1940s department store to create a new performing arts facility. CenterStage now includes the 200 seat Gottwald Playhouse, the popular 150 seat Rhythm Hall, the Brightlights Education Center, and houses the Richmond Symphony Orchestra. The renovation of the Altria Theater is the most recent manifestation of a citywide performance
art center master plan for Richmond. The project is helping to attract people back into the city and be a part of a vibrant arts, entertainment, and cultural reawakening. The 3,600 seat auditorium is purposed for large, Broadway-style shows and music artists. The performance spaces were improved for the patron’s comfort and experience. The artists’ experience and technical support of shows were upgraded via theatrical lighting, new AV systems, stage rigging, stage flooring and dressing rooms. A new box office, creative restoration of lobby entrance, new ‘parlors’ with bars, a new subscriber lounge and an increase of restrooms provide areas of respite and relaxation before, during and after the show. These spaces afford unique opportunities that create an unforgettable audience experience.
The proposed 560-seat, 25,200 SF Empire Theatre will be restored and expanded to include 37,000 SF of new space. The existing theater will be renovated to accommodate the needs of both today’s patrons and performers. This work will also include updated theater rigging and audio systems, improved dressing rooms and a rebuilt scene shop. The new addition will include a new entrance/box office lobby with restrooms and a coat check, rehearsal space, a 200seat studio theater, offices and a new loading dock.
Project Details: 1,800 seat “atmospheric” great theatre 200 seat playhouse 150 seat rhythm hall 3,600 seat auditorium Education Center
Master Planning Architecture Interior Design Construction Administration
20
CITY OF TAVARES, FL - PERFORMING ARTS AND LIBRARY STUDY
CITY OF TAVARES, FL - PERFORMING ARTS AND LIBRARY STUDY
21
Slover Library* Norfolk, VA
Completion Date: 2014 Project Size: 138,000 SF Construction Cost: $65M Team Members: Kimberly Bolan Cullin - Project Manager
Scope of Services: Community Engagement Programming Schematic Design Review
Kimberly Bolan & Associates (KBA) partnered with Providence Associates to develop the program for the new library facility that included a restoration of the 115- year-old Seaboard Building, a new seven-story glass-walled addition, and the renovation of an adjacent commercial building. The 138,000 square foot Slover Library complex— designed by Newman Architects and completed in association with Tymoff & Moss of Norfolk Virginia — reimages the traditional library and provides patrons with an opportunity for creativity, collaboration and research. The new Slover Library embodies the principal roles of today’s library: as a storehouse for the region’s
history and artifacts, as a portal to digital access, and as a community gathering place. Slover Library reflects a relationship between the old and new: the solidity of the restored masonry Seaboard and a transparent and inviting addition. The spaces are structured to link to each other through the Forum, a three-story atrium at its center. Visitors can see the library contents upon entering the building and elect to explore the collection and engage in the programs. The library is a series of spaces and activities displayed off this central space.
Project Details: Seven-story glass wall addition Renovation of adjacent commercial building Three-story atrium Community gathering space AIA/ALA Award-Winning Project
From the project’s inception, the architect worked with New Haven-based sculptor, Kent Bloomer, to develop a system of ornament that is an integral, organic part of the architectural whole. Bloomer’s ornament amplifies three distinct points of the building: the ceiling of the Forum, the front entrance, and the third floor terrace of the loggia.
*in association with Providence Associates
22
CITY OF TAVARES, FL - PERFORMING ARTS AND LIBRARY STUDY
CITY OF TAVARES, FL - PERFORMING ARTS AND LIBRARY STUDY
23
Tiverton Public Library* Tiverton, RI
Completion Date: 2015 Project Size: 23,866 SF Construction Cost: $9.8M Team Members: Kimberly Bolan Cullin - Project Manager
Scope of Services: Programming Design Feedback & Review Furniture Consulting
The Tiverton Public Library is located within close proximity to the Town’s middle school and high schools, and it is designed as the primary meeting place and neighborhood focal point for this growing community of 17,000 people. Kimberly Bolan & Associates (KBA) completed a Needs Assessment for the Tiverton Library in 2012. Through the study, it was determined that a new 23,886 SF building would replace the 2,800 SF Essex Library that served the town since 1938. Following this study, KBA worked with Union Studio Architects on schematic design, design development, and FF&E planning. When selecting furniture, we emphasized modularity and mobility. The pieces were designed so they can be easily moved and re-arranged in a variety of different ways for future use.
The new 24,000 SF library includes a community meeting hall, café, children’s library, teen room and exterior public courtyard spaces. Sustainability, flexibility, and delivering excellent service that exceeds expectations were key factors in this new building design. The new library provides a state of the art library while retaining the personality of the small-town library that is beloved by the town. The environmentally-friendly design received LEED Silver designation.
Project Details: Community meeting hall Children’s library Teen room Award-Winning Project LEED Silver designation
*in association with Union Studio Architects
24
CITY OF TAVARES, FL - PERFORMING ARTS AND LIBRARY STUDY
CITY OF TAVARES, FL - PERFORMING ARTS AND LIBRARY STUDY
25
26
CITY OF TAVARES, FL - PERFORMING ARTS AND LIBRARY STUDY
SECTION NO.
FIVE Project Team
Towson University, Center for the Arts, Towson, MD
WILSON BUTLER ARCHITECTS Design Director
Project Manager
Scott Wilson, AIA
Paul Vaivoda, AIA, LEED AP BD+C
SUBCONSULTANTS
Library Consultant
Structural Engineer
Electrical Engineer
Mechanical/Plumbing/ Fire Protection
Kimberly Bolan Cullin
Gary Krueger, P.E.
Wayne Allred, P.E.
Matthew Wiechart, P.E.
Market Research
Market Research
Fundraising Consultant
Cost Consultant
Melora Cybul
Laura MacDonald, CFRE
Joe Perryman
Kimberly Bolan and Associates, LLC
Michele Walter
AMS Planning & Research
CITY OF TAVARES, FL - PERFORMING ARTS AND LIBRARY STUDY
TLC Engineering
AMS Planning & Research
TLC Engineering
Benefactor Group
TLC Engineering
Cost+Plus
27
Wilson Butler Architects Scott C. Wilson, AIA Project Role: Design Director Education: M.A. Architecture University of Illinois, 1976 B.S. Architecture University of Illinois, 1974
Professional Registrations: Massachusetts, Illinois, Rhode Island, Virginia, Maine, Florida, Connecticut, Louisiana
Relevant Project Experience: Broward Center for the Performing Arts, Fort Lauderdale, FL
Jay and Susie Gogue, Performing Arts Center Auburn, AL
Scott is a founding partner of Wilson Butler Architects, with a 40-year career focused on the planning and design of award-winning performing arts and entertainment facilities. Clients and users alike respect his ability to lead the architectural planning and design process while connecting all the dots. In WBA’s beginning, Scott, with his partner Scott Butler, developed a unique array of visual tools that allow clients to actively engage in the design process. Scott’s depth of experience includes “out of the box” approaches to stretch existing conditions, coordinate building systems and maximize construction value with thoughtful, smart, creative, often clever and efficient planning and design. With Scott as design leader, no option gets overlooked, no detail forgotten.
Broward Center for the Performing Arts Fort Lauderdale, FL Cultural Arts Center Herndon, VA Parker Playhouse Fort Lauderdale, FL Berklee College of Music New Performing Arts Venue (Site Study) Boston, MA Calderwood Pavilion Boston, MA Richmond CenterStage Richmond, VA Ogunquit Playhouse Ogunquit, ME Altria Theater Richmond, VA
28
I love designing from a bird’s eye view, and then diving into the weeds to work out every detail. Without such an approach, we miss an opportunity to create timeless experiences.
As champion of the WBA-brand of “hands-on collaboration”, Scott mentors our growing design staff- infusing their state of the art digital skills with a proven design approach that continues to succeed. Scott has wide-ranging experience in urban design, community realm design, and land-use that integrates performing arts and entertainment into all aspects of a campus and/or community plan. Under Scott’s careful guidance Wilson Butler has also fostered their signature design process, blending traditional methods of conveying design ideas (model building) with the most up to date computer rendering programs. The tools they use and the approach they bring are tailored to meet each client’s unique requirements, respond to the individual physical context of each building site and, in the end, celebrate the joy that is embodied in the arts and entertainment. Project Availability: Mr. Wilson is currently working on various projects within the office, but is able to dedicate between 25-30% of his time to work on this project. CITY OF TAVARES, FL - PERFORMING ARTS AND LIBRARY STUDY
Wilson Butler Architects Paul Vaivoda, AIA, LEED AP BD+C Project Role: Project Manager Education: M.A. Architecture University of Pennsylvania, 1985 B.A. Environmental Design University of Colorado, 1983
Professional Registrations: Massachusetts, Pennsylvania, New York
Relevant Project Experience: Jay and Susie Gogue, Performing Arts Center Auburn, AL
Jay and Susie Gogue Performing Arts Center, Auburn AL
SUNY Oswego, Tyler Hall Choral Practice Oswego, NY
Paul has spent the past 30 years designing projects within almost every conceivable market. These sectors include higher education, corporate, hospitality, healthcare, retail, multi-family housing, and arts. His projects have been honored with numerous design awards on the local, state, and national levels.
Berklee College of Music New Performing Arts Venue (Site Study) Boston, MA
Paul approaches each new design challenge with fresh enthusiasm producing architecture that is grounded in the translation of the client’s goals and aspirations. The resultant environments are meaningful, functional and exciting. His strengths not only include creative design solutions, but also the ability to lead and coordinate a design team of architects, engineers, and consultants towards timely and budget-conscious project delivery.
Philadelphia City Hall* Philadelphia, PA North Syracuse Public Library* Syracuse, NY Marcellus Town Hall & Library* Marcellus, NY Colgate University, Blackmore Media Center* Hamilton, NY Hobart & William Smith College, Elliott Studio Arts* Geneva, NY
On campus, in the audience or onboard, I believe that it is memorable spaces and people that enrich our lives.
Paul is a registered architect in Massachusetts, New York, and Pennsylvania, and a LEED accredited professional. In addition, he is a member of the American Institute of Architects, National Council of Architectural Registration Boards, and the Society for College and University Planning (SCUP). Project Availability: Mr. Vaivoda is currently working on various projects within the office, but is able to dedicate between 25-30% of his time on this project.
Colgate University, Cooley Science Library* Elmira, NY *work completed while at other firms
CITY OF TAVARES, FL - PERFORMING ARTS AND LIBRARY STUDY
29
Kimberly Bolan and Associates Library Consultant
10917 Valley Forge Circle Carmel, IN 46032 P: 585.739.7003 www.rethinkinglibraries.org
KIMBERLY BOLAN AND ASSOCIATES (KBA) IS ABOUT HELPING LIBRARIES SURVIVE AND THRIVE IN TIMES OF CONSTANT CHANGE. ABOUT US
SERVICES
In 2004 Kimberly Bolan Cullin started Kimberly Bolan & Associates (KBA), a library consulting company based outside Indianapolis (IN). KBA has consulted with and provided training for hundreds of libraries across the U.S. and abroad. Clients range from public to K-12 to academic libraries of all shapes, sizes, and budgets.
Children and Teen Facilities Design Services Facilities Planning Needs Assessment Strategic Planning Technology Planning
Our approach to library service and facility planning is centered on collaboration, open communication, and showing stakeholders the possibilities for today’s libraries. It is about understanding the library and its community and identifying what the community wants and needs in regards to services and spaces. KBA’s approach revolves around “rethinking, re-envisioning, and redesigning” and includes everything from understanding 21st century services and services models and how they impact physical design to creating flexible and creative library spaces that can adapt into the future; meeting library and community needs as they continue to evolve and change. We work actively with your community and staff via one-on-one interactions, focus groups, and brainstorming sessions. Our unique approach to interacting with stakeholders and gathering feedback and idea generation involves numerous techniques including interactive sessions that use visuals and real world examples to “show people the possibilities” for creating thriving and dynamic library services and facilities. KBA does not take a “canned” approach to consulting. We prefer to work with each client to get a sense of what they want and need and then customize – in both style and substance – an approach and content that meets that need.
REPRESENTATIVE CLIENTS Allen County Public Library Anderson Public Library Charlotte Mecklenburg Public Library Community Library Network Fort Worth Public Library, New North Fort Worth Branch Free Library of Philadelphia Greenwich Library Hamilton East Public Libraries Hudson Area Library The Indianapolis Public Library, New Eagle Branch Jennings County Library Latah County Public Library Lincoln County Public Library Mary Riley Styles Library Monroe County Public Library Mooresville Public Library Niles Public Library District Orion Township Public Library Peter White Public Library Slover Library St. Joseph County Public Library Tiverton Public Library Washington-Centerville Public Library, Woodbourne Branch Westborough Public Library * Blue text indicates project is highlighted in this submittal
30
CITY OF TAVARES, FL - PERFORMING ARTS AND LIBRARY STUDY
Kimberly Bolan and Associates
Monroe County Public Library, Bloomington, IN
Kimberly Bolan Cullin Project Role: Library Consultant Education: MLS, Library and Information Science Syracuse University, 1995 B.A. Art and Art History SUNY Geneseo, 1992
Publications: Teen Spaces, 1st and 2nd Editions Chicago: ALA, 2003 and 2009 Technology Made Simple Chicago: ALA, 2007
Relevant Project Experience: Free Library of Philadelphia Philadelphia, PA Tiverton Public Library Tiverton, RI Charlotte Mecklenburg Public Library Charlotte, NC Queens Library Queens, NY Jennings County Library North Vernon, IN Mary Riley Styles Library Falls Church, VA
Kimberly (Kim) Bolan Cullin is an experienced librarian, consultant, and author with a broad background in libraries as well as planning and design. She is the president and principal consultant of KBA. Prior to starting KBA, Kim worked in academic, K-12, and public libraries. As a library administrator she conducted several strategic plans as well as planned and managed two public library building and expansion projects. As a library consultant, KBA has provided services to hundreds of public, school, and academic libraries across 18 states and abroad. Kim is a Library Journal recognized “Mover & Shaker� (2004), and the author of Teen Spaces: The Step-by-Step Library Makeover and Technology Made Simple: An Improvement Guide for Small and Medium Libraries (both published by ALA Editions) and numerous journal articles, and is a frequent speaker at state and national conferences and training workshops.
Indianapolis Public Library Indianapolis, IN Greenwich Library Greenwich, CT Union County Public Library Monroe, NC
CITY OF TAVARES, FL - PERFORMING ARTS AND LIBRARY STUDY
31
AMS Planning & Research Market Research and Analysis
107 John Street Southport, CT 06890 P: 203.256.1616 F: 203.256.1311 www.ams-online.com
FOR NEARLY 30 YEARS, AMS HAS HELPED OUR CLIENTS DEFINE, REFINE, AND DEVELOP SUCCESSFUL VENTURES IN THE ARTS. ABOUT US
SERVICES
For nearly 30 years, AMS has made the business of arts and culture our business. Founded with a deep commitment to the role of the arts in our communities, we’ve dedicated ourselves to working with arts and community leaders to develop ventures that are both effective and vital.
Audience and Market Research Benchmarking Business Planning and Strategy Cultural Facility Feasibility Policy and Cultural Planning
Each year, we measure and analyze the operations of hundreds of arts organizations and facilities across North America, and are deeply involved in innovative change to help producers, presenters, artists and service organizations succeed in these complex times. We develop and apply sophisticated consumer and audience research methodologies to assess market behavior and preferences. We track long-term industry and societal trends to understand the future environment in which our clients will operate. Since our founding in 1988, AMS has gained particular recognition for our work on important facilities planning projects. Our team has participated in the successful development of more than $8 billion in capital facilities for the arts, ranging from small projects to those costing hundreds of millions of dollars. We have guided feasibility studies, project development efforts, and provided implementation planning on arts and cultural projects of every type and every scale. Our notion of moving organizations beyond “sustainable” to “vital” enterprises is built on fundamental changes in how success is defined for arts and culture, how arts enterprises engage with their communities and their partners, and how a nextgeneration business model might work. As a result, success is measured not only by the level of activity and excellence, but also by the effectiveness and entanglement in the community; the creation of lasting public value.
32
REPRESENTATIVE CLIENTS Andrew W. Mellon Foundation Auburn University Ball & Socket Arts Boston Lyric Opera Carson Valley Arts Council City of Beaverton City of Boise City of Redmond Community Foundation of Greater Greensboro Dr. Phillips Center for the Performing Arts Economic Development Authority of Western Nevada Foundation for the Carolinas GableStage John F. Kennedy Center for the Performing Arts Kentucky Center for the Arts Mann Center for the Performing Arts New Spire Arts New York Botanical Garden Santa Clara Pueblo St. Tammany Parish, Cultural Arts District Theatre for a New Audience The George S. and Dolores Dore Eccles Theater Van Wezel Foundation
CITY OF TAVARES, FL - PERFORMING ARTS AND LIBRARY STUDY
AMS Planning & Research
New Spire Arts, Frederick, MD
Michele Walter Project Role: Arts Management, PD Education: B.A. French University of Michigan, 1983
Professional Affiliations: Americans for the Arts
Relevant Project Experience: Jay and Susie Gogue, Performing Arts Center Auburn, AL New Spire Arts Frederick, MD GableStage Coral Gables, FL St. Tammany Parish Cultural Arts District Covington, LA John F. Kennedy Center for the Performing Arts Washington, DC City of Boise Boise, ID Community Foundation of Greater Greensboro Greensboro, NC
With more than 20 years of practical experience in the non-profit performing arts arena, Michele has a thorough understanding of the operating issues and opportunities facing many of our performing arts organizations. At AMS, Michele specializes in partnering with clients to guide their organizations through institutional development, as well as implementation of new arts facilities. Most recently, she led Auburn University through testing and development of a performing arts center concept, assisted in the architect selection process, supported the University in its Executive Director search process, and partnered with the design and construction team in a decision support role. Michele has also partnered with New Spire Arts, in Frederick, MD, to provide a comprehensive planning approach to assist with organizational development and strategy for a new performing arts and education facility in two newly acquired buildings. Her work in St. Tammany Parish, LA supported the Parish government with a process to define a Cultural Arts District and Performing Arts Center. Recent planning and strategy work includes partnership with GableStage to implement a long-range plan to relocate into a new, expanded theatre at the site of the former Coconut Grove Playhouse in Miami. Her process guides organizations to define a shared vision for success, analyzes and assesses lines of business, and creates detailed plans with recommendations for implementation.
CITY OF TAVARES, FL - PERFORMING ARTS AND LIBRARY STUDY
33
AMS Planning & Research
Jay and Susie Gogue Performing Arts Center, Auburn AL
Melora Cybul Project Role: Arts Management, PM Education: MBA | MFA Theatre Management University of Alabama, 2015 B.S. Theatre Education Columbus State University
Professional Affiliations: International Association of Venue Managers (IAVM)
Relevant Project Experience: Jay and Susie Gogue, Performing Arts Center Auburn, AL Dr. Phillips Center for the Performing Arts Orlando, FL John F. Kennedy Center for the Performing Arts Washington, DC City of Boise Boise, ID Andrew W. Mellon Foundation New York, NY Mann Center for the Performing Arts Philadelphia, PA Ball & Socket Arts Cheshire, CT
34
Melora Cybul is a consultant with AMS Planning & Research. Since joining the AMS team in 2015, Melora has worked on numerous projects in facilities planning, operations assessment, program design, and industry research. Melora has worked with organizations across the country to explore the feasibility, form, and function of new, renovated or expanded cultural facilities, including Auburn University, the Kennedy Center for the Performing Arts, the Mann Center for the Performing Arts, and Ball & Socket Arts. She enables clients to define or re-think success for their communities by synthesizing stakeholder input, mapping cultural assets, analyzing historical trends, and modeling scenarios given programmatic aspirations or potential capital investment. In addition to market and best practices research, Melora co-authored a white paper on performing arts center development for the City of Boise and supported a team led by former BAM president and Andrew W. Mellon Foundation senior fellow Karen Brooks Hopkins to understand the role of anchor arts institutions and the impacts of those organizations on their communities. Melora has also supported national executive searches for the Columbus Association for the Performing Arts and Auburn University.
CITY OF TAVARES, FL - PERFORMING ARTS AND LIBRARY STUDY
TLC Engineering for Architecture Structural, MEP/Fire Protection
TLC ENGINEERING FOR ARCHITECTURE IS A HIGH-GROWTH ENGINEERING FIRM WITH A DIVERSITY OF EXPERTISE, AND EXPERIENCE. ABOUT US
255 South Orange Avenue, Suite 1600 Orlando, FL 32801-3463 P: 407.841.9050 F: 407.425.7367 www.tlc-engineers.com
With 400+ employees and an enthusiastic embrace of leading-edge technology, we are among the largest and most respected multi-disciplined engineering firms in the Southeast. We provide engineering services in mechanical, electrical, plumbing, fire protection, structural, communications, technology and security systems, LEED design and consulting, commissioning, and energy services. Among the firm’s accolades, TLC was selected by ENR SE as the 2016 Design Firm of Year. Using the latest software and tools, TLC’s RCDD-credentialed staff produce cuttingedge designs that support unique project requirements. Rapidly evolving technology demands that designs are crafted for flexibility, growth and change. Specialized applications include integrated security, audio/visual presentation, voice/video/ data distribution, public address/sound, acoustical analysis, intercom, closed circuit television, broadband distribution and video telepresence. TLC was also an early adopter of BIM for MEP/FP engineering with more than a decade of experience, resulting in streamlined designs that are integrated with architectural partners, support construction activities and achieve clients’ goals. TLC is adept at providing engineering services for public facilities with an emphasis on providing innovative solutions to address a client’s unique needs and to provide the most beneficial, cost-effective solutions. We understand the importance of constant communication between the client and architect to provide a smooth design and construction process. TLC has a seasoned team of experts with a strong history working with Wilson Butler on complex projects, including the Broward Center for the Performing Arts.
CITY OF TAVARES, FL - PERFORMING ARTS AND LIBRARY STUDY
SERVICES Commissioning Communications Energy Services Fire Protection LEED Design and Consulting Mechanical, Electrical, Plumbing Structural Technology and Security Systems
REPRESENTATIVE CLIENTS Arlington Performing Arts Atlanta-Fulton County Public Library System Broward Center for the Performing Arts Cagan Crossing Library Deltona Regional Library Dorothy Lumley Melrose Center Dr. Phillips Center for the Performing Arts Ernest N. Morial Convention Center, Vision Plan John and Mable Ringling Museum of Art Long Center for the Performing Arts News-Journal Center at Daytona State College Northwest Regional Library Ocean Center Expansion Orange County Convention Center Parker Playhouse Perez Art Museum Miami Salvador Dali Museum South Regional Library, Broward County The Morgan Center University of Central Florida, Performing Arts Center Washington Convention Center Winter Park Library and Events Center
35
TLC Engineering for Architecture Gary Krueger, P.E., LEED AP BD+C Project Role: Structural Engineer Education: M.S. Structural Engineering Michigan State University, 1983 B.S. Civil Engineering Michigan State University, 1983
Professional Registrations: Florida #40788
Relevant Project Experience: Broward Center for the Performing Arts Fort Lauderdale, FL Dr. Phillips Center for the Performing Arts Orlando, FL Parker Playhouse Fort Lauderdale, FL Orange County Convention Center Valencia Room Renovation Orlando, FL Cocoa Village Historical Playhouse Modifications Cocoa, FL Miami Beach Convention Center Structural Analysis Miami Beach, FL
Broward Center for the Performing Arts, Fort Lauderdale, FL
Gary is the Division Director in TLC’s Cocoa office, as well as a Senior Structural Engineer. He joined TLC in 1988 with six years of prior experience and has risen through the firm to sit on the Board of Directors. He is intimately involved in developing new projects and clients for TLC and remains active through the design and construction process. Gary has a wide array of structural design experience and is particularly well versed in addressing wind loads requirements. His experience includes building analysis and design involving conventional structural steel, reinforced concrete, and precast concrete systems as well as foundations, high rise structures, long span space trusses, and prestressed concrete design, and challenging mat deep foundations. Gary also consults as a forensic engineer and is a Diplomat member of the American Board of Forensic Engineers. He also holds Florida Special Inspectors license and is a certified manager as recognized by the Institute of Certified Professional Managers.
Brevard County School Performing Arts Prototype Brevard County, FL
36
CITY OF TAVARES, FL - PERFORMING ARTS AND LIBRARY STUDY
TLC Engineering for Architecture Wayne Allred, P.E., LEED AP BD+C Project Role: Electrical Engineer Education: M.S. Engineering Management Florida Institute of Technology, 1992 B.S. Electrical Engineering University of Central Florida, 1987
Professional Registrations: Florida #45800
Relevant Project Experience: Dr. Phillips Center for the Performing Arts Orlando, FL Winter Park Library Winter Park, FL Dorothy Lumley Melrose Center at Orlando Library Orlando, FL
Dorothy Lumley Melrose Center, Orlando, FL
Wayne applies his 29 years of experience in electrical engineering to meticulously provide clients a consistent level of service. As Principal and Senior Electrical Engineer, Wayne is highly experienced in all phases of electrical engineering analysis, design and construction administration for power generation and distribution, lighting, lightning protection, controls, circuiting and electronic systems will serve this project’s complex and technically challenging engineering design demands. Wayne strives at bringing attention to detail with his ability to develop multiple options that benefit the owner and team during design development. Matt holds a MS degree in Engineering Management from the Florida Institute of Technology and a BS in Electrical Engineering from the University of Central Florida.
CITY OF TAVARES, FL - PERFORMING ARTS AND LIBRARY STUDY
37
TLC Engineering for Architecture Matthew Wiechart, P.E., LEED AP Project Role: Mechanical, Plumbing, FP Education: B.S. Mechanical Engineering Georgia Institute of Technology, 1997
Professional Registrations: Florida #58442
Relevant Project Experience: Dr. Phillips Center for the Performing Arts Orlando, FL Winter Park Library Winter Park, FL Dorothy Lumley Melrose Center at Orlando Library Orlando, FL
Dr. Phillips Center for the Performing Arts, Orlando, FL
Matt has 18 years of experience in the design of sophisticated mechanical and energy management systems. He is committed to providing a high level of responsiveness to his clients and engineering buildings that meet owners’ requirements, while balancing budgetary limitations. As both a LEED AP and commissioning agent, he uses mechanical principles and energy conservation methods to create sustainable designs. Matt particularly enjoys working on complex buildings that allow innovative approaches. His inherent ability to quickly address and resolve project concerns coupled with his creativity and passion make him an outstanding leader and team player. Matt holds a BS degree in Mechanical Engineering from Georgia Institute of Technology. He is also a Professional in High-Performance Building Design and Commissioning Project Management.
38
CITY OF TAVARES, FL - PERFORMING ARTS AND LIBRARY STUDY
Benefactor Group Fundraising Consultant
HELPING NONPROFIT LEADERS SUCCEED IN FUNDRAISING, CAPITAL CAMPAIGNS, AND STRATEGIC PLANNING. ABOUT US
450 South Front Street Columbus, OH 43215 P: 614.437.3000 www.benefactorgroup.com
Benefactor Group was established in 1999 to provide innovative consulting and management services to nonprofit organizations, donors and civic leaders. Since then, Benefactor Group has won a reputation for innovative nonprofit consulting services that support fundraising, philanthropy, volunteer leadership, leadership development, talent management, and executive transition. The firm represents a wealth of expertise and has served clients at home and around the world in all capacities of leadership development, planning, and fundraising. Our access to human resources, research and reference materials, technology, and professional networks is tailored to meet each client’s particular needs. We strive to nurture mutually rewarding relationships serving those who serve the common good®. Benefactor Group’s dedicated team of consultants and expert advisors provides counsel and services to help nonprofit leaders develop themselves, their teams, and their organizations. We are positioned to help nonprofit organizations expand capacity and build long-term sustainability because we have deep and varied expertise in planning, leadership, fundraising, and development. We provide a variety of services to help nonprofit organizations in a multitude of categories. • • • • • •
Capital Campaigns Leadership and Search Strategic Planning Annual Fundraising Endowment Building Nonprofit Technology
CITY OF TAVARES, FL - PERFORMING ARTS AND LIBRARY STUDY
SERVICES Annual Fundraising Capital Campaigns Endowment Building Leadership and Search Nonprofit Technology Strategic Planning
REPRESENTATIVE CLIENTS Alliance for Artists Communities American Institute of Architects American Music Center Aspen Music Festival and School Birch Creek Music Center Columbus Children’s Theatre Columbus Metropolitan Library Columbus Museum of Art Columbus Symphony Orchestra COSI Eastman School of Music, University of Rochester Greater Columbus Arts Council Hancock County Performing Arts Center Highlands Museum & Discovery Center Indianapolis Symphony Orchestra Jeanne B. McCoy Community Center for the Performing Arts Marathon Center for the Performing Arts Nashville Public Library Foundation Norman Rockwell Museum Ohio Arts Council The Ohio State University School of Music Saint Louis Art Museum Seattle Public Library Springfield Museum of Art Victoria Theatre Association Virginia Museum of Fine Arts
39
Benefactor Group Laura MacDonald, CFRE Project Role: Fundraising Consultant Education: B.A. Communications Capital University
Relevant Project Experience: Aspen Music Festival and School Aspen, CO Columbus Children’s Theatre Columbus, OH Columbus Metropolitan Library Columbus, OH Columbus Symphony Orchestra Columbus, OH Indianapolis Symphony Orchestra Indianapolis, IN Nashville Public Library Foundation Nashville, TN Saint Louis Art Museum St. Louis, MO Seattle Public Library Seattle, WA Springfield Museum of Art Springfield, OH Virginia Museum of Fine Arts Richmond, VA
Columbus Museum of Art, Margaret M. Walter Wing, Columbus, OH
President of Benefactor Group, is a certified fundraising executive with more than 25 years’ experience in nonprofit leadership, fundraising, and philanthropy. She has served as the vice president and creative director of a national fundraising firm, chief development officer in arts and higher education, and as a key volunteer for community organizations. In 1999, she established Benefactor Group to serve the needs of those who serve the common good: nonprofit institutions, donors, and civic leaders. The firm is currently working with arts, culture, and educational institutions; human service organizations; women’s funds; and others working to improve the quality of life. The firm has grown to a staff of 13 and served hundreds of clients, ranging from universities, art museums, hospitals, and global NGOs, to start-up community organizations. Prior to establishing Benefactor Group, Laura was chief development officer at The Ohio State University’s Wexner Center for the Arts where she helped the organization secure its largest-ever corporate sponsorship and foundation grant and highest membership. During her tenure she also served as a senior development officer in the University’s $1.2 billion capital campaign. She is a frequent speaker at local, regional, and national conferences and has written articles related to advancement and philanthropy. She serves on the editorial review board for Giving USA: The Annual Report on Philanthropy, the seminal publication reporting on the sources and uses of charitable giving in the United States. She is a member of the Association of Fundraising Professionals and was named the Central Ohio Chapter’s “Fundraising Professional of the Year” in 2007.
40
CITY OF TAVARES, FL - PERFORMING ARTS AND LIBRARY STUDY
Cost+Plus, Inc. Cost Estimating
970 Lake Carillon Dr., Suite 300 St. Petersburg, FL 33716 P: 727.290.2575 www.cost-plus-inc.com
PROVIDING PROFESSIONAL PROJECT AND COST MANAGEMENT SERVICES FOR CULTURAL FACILITIES WORLDWIDE. ABOUT US
SERVICES
Cost+Plus is a professional firm dedicated to providing cost management services for cultural projects worldwide. We work on no other building type except performing arts and museum facilities.
COST+PLUS provides a complete spectrum of professional Project and Cost Management Services for cultural facilities worldwide. Our Services are completely focused on providing solutions, strategies and realistic and reliable budget projections for our clients.
For any performing arts project to be a quality, schedule and budget success, it will require cost management with strong attributes including leadership, in-depth experience, project and cost management understanding, business acumen, and attention to the highest quality of detail and accuracy. Cost+Plus provides realistic and reliable budget projections exclusively for cultural projects comprising performing arts, museums, and attraction facilities. These budget projections are provided at the very outset of the project (Capital Cost Budget Projections, Master Planning Projections and Feasibility Studies), during the actual design stages of the project (Concept, Schematic, Design Development, and Construction Documents), and at Bid and Construction stages. We are fortunate to have worked with architects, theatre planners, acoustical consultants, exhibit designers, museum planners, engineering teams, construction management firms, and performing arts clients of the highest quality on all of our cultural projects and we know what to expect, and what to allow for, when carefully preparing our cost projections for these complex building types. Our Services are completely focused on providing realistic and reliable budget projections for our performing arts and museum clients. We are experts on providing both construction cost projections and capital cost projections for all types of cultural projects. Providing estimates is only a portion of our cost management process. Our in depth analytical, comparison and tracking skills are what truly defines the Cost+Plus experience of cost management.
CITY OF TAVARES, FL - PERFORMING ARTS AND LIBRARY STUDY
REPRESENTATIVE CLIENTS Actors Theater Alliance Theatre American Repertory Theatre Artis-Naples Avery Fisher Hall, Lincoln Center Atlanta Symphony Hall all, Lincoln Center Bing Concert Hall Bonfils Theatre Renovations at DCPA Broward Center for the Performing Arts Dr. Phillips Center for the Performing Arts Ent Center for the Arts, University of Colorado Experimental Media & Performing Arts Center Grand Theatre de Rabat Gulfshore Playhouse Guthrie Theater King Center at AHEC Mixon Recital Hall at Cleveland Institute of Music New World Symphony PAC at College of the Holy Cross PAC at University Northern Colorado Performing Arts Center, Brown University Renovations to Paramount Theatre Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute West Kowloon Cultural District Winspear Opera Wyly Theatre
41
Cost+Plus, Inc. Joe Perryman Project Role: Cost Consultant Education: RICS, Project Management College of Estate Management, UK, 2003 BSc, Quantity Surveying College of Estate Management, UK, 1998
Professional Affiliations: Fellow - Royal Inst. of Chartered Surveyors Chair - RICS Assessment Panels
Relevant Project Experience: Performing Arts Center At the World Trade Center New York, NY Guthrie Theater Minneapolis, MN Dr. Phillips Center for the Performing Arts Orlando, FL Experimental Media & Performing Arts Center Troy, NY Gaillard Center Charleston, SC Smith Center for the Performing Arts Las Vegas, NV Artis-Naples Naples, FL David Geffen Hall at Lincoln Center New York, NY Gulfshore Playhouse Naples, FL
42
Charleston Gaillard Center, Charleston, SC
As President and founder of Cost+Plus, Joe acts as project cost manager, client contact, and design team liaison for all Cost+Plus projects. Joe has 25 years of cost management experience in the European and North American construction markets working in both professional and contracting environments. Joe has an in-depth knowledge of cost management and specialist cost control techniques gained from his involvement in the private and commercial sector, embracing exclusively cultural facilities for the past 18 years. Educated in the UK at the College of Estate Management he received a BSc in Quantity Surveying (with Merit) and followed that with a RICS Postgraduate Diploma in Project Management at the same University. Joe is recognized at the highest level of the cost management profession by being elected a Fellow of The Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors (FRICS). Joe is also a qualified RICS Assessor and has been Chair of RICS Assessment Panels for interviewing members seeking Chartered status. Joe is also a fully qualified Owner’s Representative. He was certified a LEED AP in 2004 and has vast experience in managing and advising on the cost implications of the LEED process for cultural facilities. He has written, and had published, many articles on the “The Cost of LEED Certification.” His philosophy for Cost+Plus - which was the foundation for forming Cost+Plus and which he demonstrates by example - is that vision, effort, time and discipline will always be the cornerstones required for a cultural project’s budgetary success. CITY OF TAVARES, FL - PERFORMING ARTS AND LIBRARY STUDY
SECTION NO.
SIX Client References
“Wilson Butler Architects was selected based upon their strong understanding of the processes, development of strong solutions, support of our constituents and their connection with the community in a substantive way during the charrette.� Jim Carroll, AIA, Former University Architect, Auburn University
Jay and Susie Gogue Performing Arts Center
Broward Center for the Performing Arts
City of Herndon, VA, Cultural Arts Center
Client Contact:
Client Contact:
Client Contact:
Auburn University 1161 W Samford Avenue, Auburn, AL 36849 Jim Carroll, AIA | Former University Architect p. 530.754.1073 e. jimcarroll@ucdavis.edu
Broward Center for the Performing Arts 201 SW Fifth Avenue Kelley Shanley | President & CEO p. 954.522.5334 e. kshanley@browardcenter.org
City of Herndon, Virginia 11725 Newbridge Court, Reston, VA 20191-3518 Les Zidel | Former Cultural Arts Advisory Committee Member p. 703.262.7903 e. lzidel@aol.com
Virginia Performing Arts Foundation
Slover Library
Tiverton Public Library
Client Contact:
Client Contact:
Client Contact:
AMS Planning & Research Corporation 107 John Street, Southport, CT 06890 Michele Walter | Former VP of Operations, VPAF p. 203.256.1616 e. mwalter@ams-online.com
Slover Library 235 E Plume St, Norfolk, VA 23510 Norman Maas | Former Director of Libraries p. 757.647.3035 e. woodhousemaas@yahoo.com
Tiverton Public Library 34 Roosevelt Ave, Tiverton, RI 02878 Ann Grealish-Rust | Director p. 401.625.6796 x12 e. arust@tivertonlibrary.org
Auburn, Alabama
Richmond, Virginia
CITY OF TAVARES, FL - PERFORMING ARTS AND LIBRARY STUDY
Fort Lauderdale, Florida
Norfolk, Virginia
Herndon, Virginia
Tiverton, Rhode Island
43
BLANK PAGE
SECTION NO.
SEVEN Required Forms and Certifications
Secretary
(S E A L)
My Commission Expires:
State of Florida at Large
Notary Public
___________________________
Subscribed and sworn to before me this ____day of __________________, 2018.
7
Before me, a Notary Public duly commissioned, qualified, and acting personally appeared ______________________________________to me well known, who being by me first duly sworn upon oath says that he is the Attorney-in-Fact for ______________________, Surety, and that he has been authorized by said Surety corporation to execute the foregoing Bond on behalf of the Contractor named therein in favor of the City of Tavares, Florida.
STATE OF FLORIDA ) COUNTY OF ) CITY OF )
(SEAL)
_______________________________
I, ______________________, certify that I am the Secretary of the corporation named as Principal in the foregoing Bond; that ________________________________, who signed the said Bond on behalf of the Principal was then _________________________ of said corporation that I know his signature, and his signature thereto is genuine; and that said Bond was duly signed, sealed and attested for and in behalf of said corporation by authority of its governing body.
CERTIFICATE AS TO CORPORATE PRINCIPAL
Wilson Butler Architects 70 Federal Street, 5th Floor Boston, MA 02110 www.wilsonbutler.com