S TA R - K
KO S H E R C E R T I F I C AT I O N
ד ב אלטי מ א ר
הכ ש ר ו ת
ועד
Kashrus Kurrents VOLUME 42
!חג כשר ושמח
Spring 5779–2019
Danger - Sakana:
Keeping Our Food Safe & Healthy RABBI TZVI ROSEN EDITOR, KASHRUS KURRENTS
In an ongoing effort to keep food processing on a high level of quality, a new position known as Director of Food Safety has been created in the Quality Assurance departments of food processors. In fact, there is a relatively new certification program that companies undergo known as SQF certification. SQF stands for Safe Quality Food, and there are different levels of SQF certification: 1, 2 or 3. SQF standards are very rigorous, some may say bordering on excessive. However, the repercussions can be devastating if a company’s production environment is compromised or unsanitary. A common nemesis to food producers that Quality Assurance valiantly tries to battle is the presence of E-coli, bacteria comprised of many different strains that are commonly found in one’s intestines. Most are harmless, yet there are some E-coli that can cause severe food poisoning. When the bagged salad industry was in its fledgling stage, E-coli food poisoning was traced back to a bagged spinach producer. This caused industry-wide panic. Another incident was traced to a famous lettuce producer who did not take proper precautions with its H-Vac (air conditioning) system. Due to improper maintenance, E-coli subsequently found its way to romaine and iceberg lettuce and was responsible for many reports of food poisoning and even death. Listeria is another type of bacteria that can be found in uncooked poultry or other raw food products. It can be quite harmful if someone is infected with this food-borne bacterium. For these and other reasons, there is no place in the world of food processing for substandard or unsanitary food production. In fact, STAR-K certifies Intralytix, a biotechnology company focused on food safety, sanitation and other products developed to control bacterial pathogens in a food processing setting. The Torah is passionate concerning health and safety in general, and food safety in particular. Based on the pasuk, “”רק השמר לך ושמר נפשך מאד, “Only be careful and watch yourselves closely”,1 one is to exercise spiritual as well as physical watchfulness. There is discussion amongst the commentaries regarding risk-taking, personal safety and being careful to maximize food safety and a high standard of hygiene in food establishments. C O N T I N U E D O N PA G E 2 1. ט:דברים ד
Leadership in
N O. 2
?נישט אויף שבת גערעט The Guide to Proper Speech on Shabbos RABBI DOVID HEBER K A S H R U S A D M I N I S T R AT O R
Shabbos is the most beautiful day of the week, and our Neviim and Chazal have enhanced its sanctity by establishing various mitzvos d’rabanan. These mitzvos include activities that maintain kedushas Shabbos and render it more enjoyable, and prohibitions to ensure we do not perform a melachah d’oraisa. One example of an issur d’rabanan is what Yeshayahu Hanavi1 refers to as “daber davar”, a restriction on business and melachah-based discussions on Shabbos. According to the Talmud Yerushalmi,2 when we are careful with speech on Shabbos, we emulate the Ribono Shel Olam, Who rested from speech3 on Shabbos Beraishis following the completion of the creation of the world. The following halachos are based upon the psak of Harav Moshe Heinemann, shlit”a, Rabbinic Administrator of STAR-K Kosher Certification.4 I. Discussions of Melachah In general, on Shabbos one is not allowed to say that he will perform a melachah after Shabbos. For example, it is forbidden to say, “Tonight I will write down your address” or “I will water my flowers tomorrow”, as these activities are not permitted on Shabbos. Furthermore, on Shabbos one may not say, “Let’s go shopping tomorrow”5 or “Can you bake a cake after Shabbos?”6 The following are exceptions and may be discussed on Shabbos: 1. One is allowed to speak about a melachah that already occurred. For example, “Last Thursday we drove from Los Angeles to San Diego”. C O N T I N U E D O N PA G E 3 1. Sefer Yeshayahu (58:13). This pasuk is read in the Haftorah of the morning of Yom Kippur and some recite it as part of Kiddush on Shabbos morning. Some halachos are addressed in the Shabbos Zemer, “Mah yedidus… chafatzecha assurim…” 2. End of 15th perek of Meseches Shabbos. 3. As it says, “B’asara maamaros nivra haolam” (Avos 5:1). 4. Many of these halachos are based on Shulchan Aruch Orach Chaim (S.A., O.C.) and Mishna Brura Siman 306 & 307. 5. This is because Daber Davar applies to Rabbinic prohibitions, as well. 6. It does not help to preface your prohibited statement with the words “Nisht oyf (or im) Shabbos geredt.” For example, you may not say, “Nisht oyf Shabbos geredt – Can you bake a cake after Shabbos?” In this case, although you are stating the halacha that it is prohibited to say this, your obvious intent is to ask the person to bake the cake after Shabbos.
Inside
this issue
Danger-Sakana: Keeping our Food Safe & Healthy ............................................................. .............................Page 1
נישט אויף שבת גערעט: The Guide to Proper Speech on Shabbos ������������������������������������������������������������������� Page 1 When You Can Drink and Drive ................................................................................................................................. Page 5 Bedikas Chometz: Search For Dough Like A Pro ������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������� Page 6 First Ever Pan-Asia Kosher Training Seminar Held in Shanghai �������������������������������������������������������������������� Page 8
Kashrus Education
1
Danger - Sakana:
Keeping Our Food Safe & Healthy RABBI TZVI ROSEN EDITOR, KASHRUS KURRENTS C O N T I N U E D F R O M PA G E 1
Although the argument can be made שמר פתאים השם,2 “Hashem watches over the unaware, the truth is that Chazal tell us אין סומכין על הנס, we don’t count on miracles. Halacha is quite insistent about not taking risks and chances with one’s health and well-being. In fact, there is another aspect to health, well-being and taking health risks. Chazal tell us מאסורא חמירא סכנתא,3 one should be careful to avoid dangerous situations that can pose health threats to life and limb. Of course, there are the“no brainers” – walking alone in a dangerous neighborhood or climbing a high tree while untethered. Moreover, there is a whole area that transcends the obvious areas of risk known as שמירת הגוף והנפש, health precautions. Volumes have been written regarding the subject of well-being and health risks. Some of the most well-known areas of discussion include mixing fish and meat, leaving peeled onions, garlic and eggs overnight, uncovered beverages and leaving food and beverages under a bed or stroller. There are many “hanhagos” that are commonly practiced and many that are not. The following דינים ומנהגיםreflect STAR-K policy and the p’sakim of HaRav Moshe Heinemann, shlit”a, Rabbinic Administrator of STAR-K. I. Mixing Meat & Fish Chazal maintain that mixing fish and meat is forbidden.4 Worcestershire sauce often lists anchovies as one of its ingredients. Sometimes, kosher certification categorizes the Worcestershire sauce as Kosher-Fish, and other times as Kosher-Pareve. The difference is the percentage of fish in the recipe. If the amount is greater than >( שישים1.6%), then the Worcestershire sauce may not be used to flavor meat or chicken; when it is less than <( שישים1.6%), it is permissible.5 Although according to most authorities it is permissible to cook meat in a fish pot or fry fish in a meat pan,6 it is STAR-K policy to follow the opinion of “ ”יש מחמיריםand require caterers to have separate utensils for meat and fish. In the event that fish was cooked in a meat pot or vice versa, מעיקר הדיןit is permitted. STAR-K policy is to be מחמיר. Halachically, there is no difference between cooking, roasting or broiling. Similarly, it is forbidden to cook fish and meat uncovered in the same oven even if they are dry, due to סכנה. However, if one of the dishes is covered, meat and fish may be prepared in the same oven.7 II. Peeled Onion, Garlic and Eggs The Gemara states that it is forbidden to leave peeled onions, garlic, hard boiled eggs, cracked eggs, (whites or yolks) overnight unless the head whiskers of the onion and garlic clove are intact, the 2. תהלים קט”ז 3. ב:חולין י‘ עמוד א‘; א”ח קע”ג 4. יורה דעה קט”ו 5. ש”ך שם 6. ג:ט”ז יו”ד צ”ה 7. א:חכמת אדם ס”ח 8. שמירת הגוף ובנפש 9. ג:ח”א ס”ח 10. שמירת הגוף והנפש 11. ibid 12. ‘מד:‘פ‘ שמיני יא
2
Leadership in
skin of the unused onion or the peel of the unused garlic is intact, or the egg is in its shell. It does not help to cover the eggs, onion or garlic in a container. However, if they are mixed in a salad or if they are salted they may be kept overnight.8 Do the same restrictions apply to chopped or peeled raw onions, garlic or cracked eggs that have been left overnight? Some authorities say they do, and some are lenient in this regard based on a ruling by Rav Moshe Feinstein, zt”l. He stated that since the custom of not leaving peeled onions, garlic and eggs overnight is not mentioned in the Shulchan Aruch, we are permitted to be more lenient with peeled raw products from a factory or industrial setting. It is STAR-K policy to follow the ruling of Rav Moshe Feinstein, zt”l. III. Food & Beverages Under A Bed It is forbidden to put food under a bed, whether open or closed, cooked or raw. The food becomes forbidden if someone slept in the bed. Included in this prohibition is leaving food under a stroller in which a baby fell asleep.9 In the event food was unintentionally left unattended, בדיעבד, the food is permitted. Another way to reverse the status of forbidden food is to wash Negel Vasser directly over the food or tovel it in a mikvah.10 IV.
Uncovered Beverages
In previous eras, it was forbidden to drink water or other uncovered beverages that were left unattended. The reason for this prohibition was that there was a חשש, a concern, that a snake would drink the water and deposit venomous poison in the water. Since snakes are not as commonly found today, the minhag is to be more lenient. However, there are other authorities who are still strict with the laws of גילוי, uncovered liquids which include water, milk, olive oil and wine. The timeframe in which to forbid uncovered liquids is three seconds.11 As we know, the Torah mandates “”והתקדשתם והייתם קדושים12, we should sanctify ourselves so that we should be holy; just as the Ribono Shel Olam is קדוש, so too should we emulate Him. Just as we follow the laws of kashrus unwaveringly without question or compromise so, too, the laws of שמירת הגוף והנפשshould be treated with the same sanctity and zeal.
2019 Passover Directory Available in Jewish bookstores after Purim. App for smartphone and tablet users accessible in Google Play Store and on Apple iTunes.
Kashrus Education
?נישט אויף שבת גערעט The Guide to Proper Speech on Shabbos RABBI DOVID HEBER K A S H R U S A D M I N I S T R AT O R C O N T I N U E D F R O M PA G E 1
2. One may discuss plans to take place after Shabbos if no melachah is involved. For instance, one may say, “I will walk over to your house tomorrow.” Since this can be done on Shabbos, it may be discussed on Shabbos. It is also permitted to say, “I will come over to your house tomorrow,” even if the house is 20 miles away, since a melachah was not stated and it is possible to walk. 3. One may discuss something “potentially” permissible on Shabbos. For example, if someone lives in a city with no eruv he may say, “I will bring some pictures to your house tomorrow.” Since this activity could be performed if that city had an eruv, it is permissible to make such a statement on Shabbos.7 4. An extension of the previous halacha allows one who resides in a city to say, “Tomorrow, I am going to another city” (e.g., someone in Lakewood may say he is going to Baltimore on Sunday). Although there are at least two prohibitions involved in this activity – driving a car and leaving the tchum - such a statement would be permitted since he did not say he is driving.8 Furthermore, one could theoretically walk to another city using a route if it would be built up with burganin,9 so that it falls within the tchum. Therefore, someone in Los Angeles may say, “I am going to New York tomorrow.”10 5. If the melachah is about performing a d’var mitzvah, one may discuss it if necessary.11 For example, if it were necessary on Shabbos to discuss specific travel arrangements for attending a levaya in order to avoid “losing a ride”, one may discuss this on Shabbos. Although this activity is a melachah, it is permitted to discuss since it involves a mitzvah. II. Speaking About Business One may not speak about business issues on Shabbos. This includes the following:12 1. Prices – One may not discuss the price of various items with someone who can utilize this as business information. This applies to a “big ticket item” (e.g., “The house around the block is selling for $500,000”) or one of lesser value (e.g., “Cookies at the kosher market are on sale for $1.00”), or any case in between. This includes prices on almost any item – food, travel, household items, etc.13
This also includes conversations about free items including, “If you want a free round trip ticket to Eretz Yisroel you can get one on United Airlines if you have 85,000 frequent flyer miles.” Generally, speaking about stocks, bonds, mutual funds, banks and credit cards is forbidden even without mentioning specific financial information. 2. In general, one may not give “business advice” on Shabbos. An accountant may not discuss financial matters with a client or anyone else. Asking an accountant for tax advice on Shabbos (e.g., “Can I count my married child as a dependent if her chasunah was last December?”) is not permitted. This also applies to asking a mechanic for automobile advice (e.g., “What do you recommend for squeaky brakes?”) or a computer expert for recommendations (e.g., “What is the best program for graphics?”). Furthermore, one may not make certain calculations,14 especially those related to business. For example, one may not say “I bought a tie for you which cost twenty dollars plus 5% tax. So the total amount you owe me is twenty dollars plus one dollar tax, or twentyone dollars.”15 If someone asks you something that is prohibited to discuss on Shabbos you should not discuss such issues. The correct response is to say, “Let’s speak after Shabbos.” One should not respond, “Let’s speak about ‘it’16 after Shabbos.” 3. The following situations are exceptions and may be discussed during Shabbos, even though they are financial or business related: a. Tzedakah Matters – This is a heter for the gabbai to announce nedavos (donations declared following aliyos), as this financial discussion is for the purpose of tzedakah. Calculations for tzedakah and other mitzvos are also allowed. b. Public Affairs – Something that will benefit the general public is permitted. An example is a city engineer who comes on Shabbos to survey the area in order to install a traffic light and crosswalk in an area frequented by the tzibbur (e.g., outside the shul). In such a case, one may speak with the engineer about the project as it will benefit the entire community. c. If one’s “business” is teaching Torah or other divrei mitzvah, then one may discuss such topics on Shabbos. For example, one C O N T I N U E D O N PA G E 4
7. S.A. O.C. 307:8 based on the Gemara Shabbos 150b that states one can speak about leaving the tchum because “burganin” (huts for guards) could be built to make it in the tchum (by spacing the huts close enough). 8. Driving was not stated, and since it does not have to definitively happen it is considered as hirhur on the part of those listening (see Rashi, Shabbos 150a Hanireh). 9. See footnote 7 10. One may even say, “I am going to Eretz Yisroel”, since under optimum conditions one could walk through Canada and Alaska, then over the Bering Strait (when frozen) through Russia. Furthermore, one may travel on a boat during Shabbos under certain conditions (e.g., the journey does not begin or end on Shabbos). Therefore, one may even say, “I am going to Australia tomorrow.” 11. S.A. O.C. 306:6 12. The prohibition applies even if one derives “oneg”, pleasure, from discussing business matters. (The Rama - 307:1 only allows interesting news, etc. for oneg, not business affairs.) 13. One may mention a price that was paid for an item in the past which has absolutely no current relevance to himself or the listener. 14. However, one may make a calculation to “sharpen skills” if it has no relevance, e.g., one may ask a third grader, “What is 5 times 5?” 15. Even to simply say “You owe me twenty-one dollars for the tie” is prohibited. 16. Stating that we will discuss the business issue (“it”) after Shabbos is assur because one would be stating that he wants to do an issur D’rabanan (Daber Davar) after Shabbos. However, one may simply state, “Let’s talk after Shabbos”, since the prohibited activity is not referenced.
Leadership in
Kashrus Education
3
?נישט אויף שבת גערעט The Guide to Proper Speech on Shabbos C O N T I N U E D F R O M PA G E 3
may speak to his son’s rebbi or teacher on Shabbos regarding how his child is performing in shiur. He may hire a tutor17 to teach Torah, provided salary is not discussed on Shabbos. One may also discuss shidduchim on Shabbos. One may even say “support will be available.” Some opinions allow even specific financial arrangements for the shidduch to be discussed on Shabbos.18 Consult your rav. Likewise, one may ask a kashrus professional for advice (e.g., “Can I eat this product that has no hechsher?”). One may also speak with others who work for chesed organizations (e.g., asking a member of the Bikur Cholim organization about a hospital). d. Health care professionals may give advice on Shabbos (but may not discuss related financial issues). This includes speaking to one’s doctor or two doctors who are conferring about a medical technique or issue. Nurses and occupational, physical or speech therapists, etc., may discuss health issues or techniques for helping others. They may also speak to a patient who is seeking their advice on Shabbos. III. Miscellaneous Cases 1. One should avoid sharing sad news or something that brings tzaar (distress)19 on Shabbos, unless it is necessary. For example, on Shabbos one should not tell his friend, “Did you hear that Ploni died?” However, one may tell a relative or someone who is involved if they need to know (e.g., “Your uncle, who was my neighbor, was niftar this morning. I think your cousins would appreciate if you came over on Shabbos for guidance.”). 2. One may ask a shayla or “speak in learning” regarding a case that involves business (e.g., asking a rav, ‘Reuven is lending Shimon $10,000 and would like to charge 5% interest. How should I tell him to set up a heter iska?”). 3. Thinking about a melachah or business (hirhur) is permissible; however, for oneg Shabbos it is best to avoid doing so.20 4. Similar prohibitions apply to Yom Tov, as well. However, there are “exceptions” in the case of Yom Tov: a. On Yom Tov, one may discuss a melachah that is permissible on Yom Tov, even if it is forbidden on Shabbos. For instance, one
may not say on Shabbos,“Let’s bake a cake after Shabbos.” However, on Yom Tov one may say, “Let’s bake a cake after Yom Tov.” This is because under certain conditions, it is permissible to bake on Yom Tov. b. On Yom Tov, one may discuss non-melachah prohibitions related to that particular Yom Tov (e.g., on Yom Kippur one may say, “I know you find fasting difficult, before Yom Tov I brought food for you to eat immediately after Havdalah in shul.”). It is noteworthy that the restriction of Daber Davar is the basis for the prohibition of handling muktzah on Shabbos. According to the Rambam,21 Chazal realized that if “business speech”, which is intangible, was prohibited by the Neviim on Shabbos, kal v’chomer (how much more so) would the Neviim forbid one from handling items that are related to business or have no normal Shabbos use. Furthermore, one of the reasons for the prohibition of Amira l’Akum (asking a non-Jew to perform work on Shabbos) is Daber Davar. The fact that Daber Davar is a m’kor (source) for muktzah and Amira l’Akum illustrates the importance of how we speak on Shabbos.22 The enhancement of Shabbos through proper speech is illustrated in a story found in Sefer Ktzos Hashulchan.23 A king once gave his subjects the opportunity to request their needs. A homeless individual with a skin disorder, who normally picked through garbage cans for food, approached the king with the following request. “Today there are no garbage cans available. My request is that you provide me with garbage cans through which I can rummage for food.” Everyone who heard this ridiculous request laughed and said, “You fool! The king could have had the best dermatologists treat your illness or he could have given you a house in which to live. Instead, you choose the same garbage cans from which you eat every day?” On Shabbos, the Ribono Shel Olam grants us the opportunity to spend Shabbos in an enhanced way with divrei Torah, which spiritually and physically heal and protect us. It is a day with more time for Torah, tefillah, our families, inspiring seudos, gemilas chasadim and proper speech. Why would anyone want to treat this special day as just another day to discuss business and financial matters, as we do every other day of the week?
17. One may even hire a teacher for limudei chol, such as math or science (provided salary is not discussed), because it is a mitzvah l’lamdo umnos (see Mishna Brura 306:30 based on Kiddushin 29a). 18. See Ktzos Hashulchan 107:14 19. Mishna Brura 307:3 20. S.A., O.C. 306:8 21. Hilchos Shabbos (24:12) 22. On Shabbos, when people come together at family gatherings and social events one should be extra nizhar (careful) in all halachos of proper speech that are relevant every day. See Chofetz Chaim, footnote at the end of Psicha Asin Os 6. 23. Written by Rav Avraham Chaim Noeh, zt”l, in Chalek 4, Siman 107, Os 29 in the name of Aishel Avraham m’Butchoch in the name of Toldos Yaakov Yosef.
STAR-K’s 16th Annual Kashrus Training Program will take place July 22-25, 2019. This intensive seminar, held at STAR-K’s offices in Baltimore, Maryland, is limited to 25 students – rabbonim, kollel members and others serving as klei kodesh – who have studied Yorah Deah. In addition to lectures, audio-visual presentations and a hands-on practicum, several field trips are planned. STAR-K will also be running its annual Food Service Mashgichim Training Seminar for people involved (or who want to get involved) in hashgocha for restaurants, catering halls, and hotels. The course will be held August 5-7, 2019 To apply, call the STAR-K office at 410-484-4110 and speak with Rabbi Zvi Goldberg, or go to www.star-k.com to download the application form.
4
Leadership in
Kashrus Education
WHEN YOU CAN DRINK AND DRIVE: THE HALACHIC IMPLICATIONS OF DRINKING COFFEE ON THE ROAD RABBI BORUCH BEYER K A S H R U S A D M I N I S T R AT O R
Happy Fact: Unflavored roasted coffee beans, whole and ground, are considered kosher without a hechsher (kosher certification). Bearing this in mind, buying a cup of unflavored regular, decaf, or High-Octane coffee (my usual choice) should not present any kashrus issues, right? Not so fast fellow caffeine heads; life is never so simple. The Problem: Some coffee vendors sell kosher and treif (nonkosher) items, like the Bacon & Gouda Breakfast Sandwich and the Pepperoni & Tomato Savory Foldover1. The keilim (utensils) used for coffee and treif can at times be washed together, causing blios, absorbed tastes, from the treif kli to enter the coffee equipment. In Starbucks, for example, it’s been established that the brew basket that holds the coffee grounds while the coffee is being made is sometimes washed with keilim that may have come into contact with treif. If we have a “perfect storm” situation in which the wash water is yad soledes,2 and no soap enters the water before the treif equipment is placed in the water, then the brew basket is considered treif and the coffee made afterwards is treif. We do not know the cleaning procedures used by all coffee vendors, but most of them sell treif items along with coffee and the possibility exists that similar keilim issues may be present. Based on these facts and assumptions, the psak (halachic decision) should be that one is permitted to buy hot coffee only from vendors that he knows do not sell treif, or whose cleaning procedures do not impact the kashrus of the coffee. This is, indeed, STAR-K’s opinion on purchasing coffee from stores that sell treif items. The Exception: True or False? If one is traveling on the road – by car, plane, bus, or horse – he can stop at a rest stop, gas station or even a Starbucks and purchase a hot cup of Joe. Give yourself a star if you answered True. Upon what is this exception based? We need some background to answer this question. Our concern centers on the keilim used to make coffee and/or the utensils from which one may drink that may have blios from treif. The halacha is that tastes that are pagum, or off-tasting, do not have an ability to impart a treif status to kosher foods or utensils.3 The halacha also states that tastes absorbed in a utensil that is not a Ben Yomo, i.e., has not been used within 24 hours, are considered pagum.4
Furthermore, Shulchan Aruch paskens in Yoreh Deah (Y.D.) 122:6, that if one is unsure if the eating utensils or cooking equipment owned by non-Jews was used for non-kosher within 24 hours, one may assume that they were not. This concept is known as Stam Keilim Eiynon Bnei Yoman, or just Stam Keilim ( )סתם כליםin halachic shorthand. With this in mind, the Mechaber paskens that if someone mistakenly used the pot of a non-Jew to heat up something, the food is permitted since it is assumed that the pot was not used within the past 24 hours. This is a great din to keep handy when faced with a b’dieved5 situation, like the one in the Shulchan Aruch.6 The question we need to answer is if buying coffee in a non-kosher establishment while traveling has the status of a b’dieved situation. This would allow us to apply the principle of Stam Keilim to the coffeemaking equipment and grant us a guilt- free cup of Starbucks (how to avoid guilt while paying $5 for a cup of coffee is beyond the scope of this article). Rabbi Moshe Heinemann, shlit”a, answered this question by marshalling a Yad Ephraim7 that appears on the page in the Shulchan Aruch that we previously mentioned in Y.D. 122: 6. The Yad Ephraim references a responsa from the Nodah B’Yehuda8 (Nb”Y) which discusses the propriety of Jews drinking coffee in the Gentile-owned coffeehouses of 18th century Prague. As they say, the more things change the more they stay the same! It is almost 300 years later, and Jews still want their coffee ככל העמים. The issue addressed by the Nodah B’Yehuda revolved around drinking coffee from the coffeehouse’s mugs. It was assumed that the mugs had non-kosher milk in them when the Gentile patrons drank their coffee. In those days, there was no heter (permission) to drink non-cholov Yisroel milk or cholov stam and it was considered אסור, not kosher. Since paper cups had not yet made their way onto the scene, the only way to drink the coffee was to use the mugs that had absorbed the taste of non-kosher milk. What was a Jew to do? The Jews who drank from the mugs back then had two possible reasons why it should be allowed: 1. The mug was a Kli Sheni9 and, therefore, not hot enough to cause a transfer of treif milk taste into the coffee. 2. Stam Keilim. The halacha we referenced earlier allows us to assume that utensils have not been used within 24 hours, and any blios are pagum. The Nb”Y dismisses the Kli Sheni heter by referencing the Taz and Rashal, who pasken that this only helps in a b’dieved situation. C O N T I N U E D O N PA G E 7
1. I didn’t make these up, they are actual choices on the Starbucks menu. 2. Literally, the temperature at which someone will quickly remove his hand to avoid being burned. The food must be at least this hot before its taste is considered to have been transferred into a utensil. Rabbi Heinemann holds yad soledes is 120oF. 3. ש"ע סי' ק'ג 4. Ibid. 5. A scenario in which the halacha allows a lenient approach to be applied. 6. סתם כלים אינן בני יומןis based on ספק ספיקה, maybe this pot was not used within 24 hours, rendering any absorbed taste pagum (off tasting). Even if it was used within 24 hours, maybe the absorbed non-kosher taste is pagum in this particular food that was cooked, הובא בטור סי‘ קכ”ב בשם הרא”ש. 7. Rabbi Ephraim Zalman Margolis ZT”L d: 5588-(1828) 8. נודע ביהודה יו”ד שאלה ל”ו 9. The mug or bowl into which food from a pot on the fire is poured into is called a Kli Sheni, a second level utensil. This means that the walls of the utensil are considered to have cooled the temperature of the food to an extent where it is not hot enough to transfer its taste into the utensil walls.
Leadership in
Kashrus Education
5
Bedikas Chometz
Search for Dough Like a Pro RABBI MORDECHAI FRANKEL D I R E C TO R , I N S I G H T S F R O M T H E I N S T I T U T E
Before Pesach, a person is obligated to perform bedikas chometz; a search of his house and possessions to ensure that he does not own any chometz. The bedikah should be conducted at the beginning of the night of the 14th of Nissan, immediately after tzeis hakochavim.1 If he did not do so, the bedikah can be done all night. Bedieved, if he did not perform the bedikah that night he should do it on the day of the 14th of Nissan.2 If he will not be home on the night of the 14th of Nissan, he should appoint another adult to perform the bedikah on his behalf.3 If he leaves his house within thirty days of Pesach, and is not planning to return and conduct a bedikah or have someone else perform a bedikah for him, then he should do bedikas chometz without reciting a brocha at night before he leaves.4 If he leaves his house more than thirty days beforehand (i.e. the 14th of Adar or earlier) and is not planning to return for Pesach, he does not need to perform bedikas chometz and may rely on the bittul that he recites on erev Pesach at the time of chometz burning. However, he should remove or sell any known chometz in the house. If he plans to return home on Pesach and will not have someone else perform a bedikah for him, he must perform bedikas chometz before he leaves.5 There is no need to check areas containing chometz which will be sold to a non-Jew before Pesach.6 If a person is home on the night of the 14th of Nissan but is planning to leave for the duration of Pesach, he may arrange to sell the chometz in all the rooms of his house except one - to a non-Jew and check that room to fulfil the mitzva of bedikas chometz.7 (If it is his custom not to sell chometz gommur, then he should make sure that there is no chometz gommur in the other rooms). If guests will be staying in the house during Pesach and using some of the rooms, those rooms must be checked for chometz. Guests who arrive before the night of the 14th of Nissan are obligated to check for chometz. If the owner of the house does not want them searching his house, he can perform a bedikah on the house himself and leave one area for the guests to be bodek. People staying at a hotel for Pesach should perform a bedikah on their room. If
they arrive on the day of the 14th of Nissan, a bedikah should be done at that time. A brocha is not recited over the bedikah of a hotel room.8 One should not begin any melacha within half an hour before tzeis hakochavim on the night of bedikas chometz. He should not eat a beitzah or more of bread, cake or cookies at that time; he may eat other food. He may learn Torah but should arrange for a shomer or set an alarm to ensure that he stops for bedikas chometz. At tzeis hakochavim, he should stop whatever he is doing, no longer eat any food, and conduct the bedikah.9 He could daven maariv before the bedikah, although if he always davens at a specific later time he can do the bedikah first and daven at that time.10 When performing bedikas chometz, one should search his house for any edible crumbs of chometz.11 Meikar hadin, it is not necessary to clean one’s house from small soiled particles of chometz which will not come into contact with food on Pesach.12 Nevertheless, many are stringent and attempt to rid their house of all chometz.13 It is not necessary to check books and sefarim for chometz, although those which will be brought to the table on Pesach should be cleaned to ensure that they do not contain crumbs which could fall into one’s food.14 The bedikah should be conducted by the light of a candle with a single wick.15 Some have the custom to turn off the house lights during the bedikah.16 Others leave them on, using both the house lights and a candle to conduct the search.17 The prevailing custom is for ten pieces of bread to be placed in different areas of the house before the bedikah18 (although some do not have this minhag).19 Some people take care that each piece is smaller than a kezayis,20 and it is a good idea to wrap them up in order to ensure that no crumbs are left behind. The person conducting the bedikah could position the pieces of bread, but it is customary for another member of the household to do so.21 One may use a flashlight to aid in the search.22 For the purposes of this article, we will assume that the reader is familiar with the process of bedikas chometz. Among other C O N T I N U E D O N PA G E 7
. ועי' מש"כ בזה בספר הליכות שלמה (פסח פ"ה סעי' י) בשם הגרש"ז אויערבאך זצ"ל,מ"ב סי' תלא ס"ק א11 שו"ע סי' תלג סעי' א ומ"ב שם ס"ק ב22 אמנם הערוך השלחן סי' תלז סעי' ז פסק שמותר לכתחלה למנות אשה וכתב "האידנא נשי דידן בודקות יותר טוב ומחטטין אחר משהו חמץ ורוחצין ומנקין כל המקומות ומדקדקות יותר, ועיי"ש שטוב יותר למנות אנשים לבדיקה, מ"ב סי' תלב ס"ק ח וסי' תלו ס"ק א33 . ובשו"ת שבט הלוי ח"ט סי' קיח כתב שעדיף לבדוק ע"י שליח בליל י"ד בזמנו מלבדוק בעצמו קודם זמנו."מאנשים שו"ע סי' תלו סעי' א44 . שו"ע שם ומ"ב שם ס"ק ה ושו"ת אגרות משה או"ח ח"ד סי' צה55 . והגרש"ז אויערבאך (הליכות שלמה פסח פ"ה דבר הלכה אות ו) אמר שהמנהג פשוט להקל בדבר, עי' במ"ב סי' תלו ס"ק לב66 . כעין מש"כ בשו"ע הגר"ז סי' תלג סעי' ז שאפשר לדבוק שאר חדרי הבית מקודם ולהניח חדר אחד לבדיקה בליל י"ד77 https://www.star-k.org/articles/kashrus-kurrents/105/the-travelers-halachic-guide-to-hotels ' ועי. כן שמעתי ממו"ר ר' משה היינעמאן שליט"א שכיון שמנקין החדר קודם ביאתו י"ל דהוי כמקום שאין מכניסין בו חמץ88 כל זה בשו"ע סי' תלא סעי' ב ומ"ב שם99 . שמועות משה סי' תלא סעי' ב) שיש להתפלל תפילת ערבית בזמנה מיד לאחר צאה"כ ואח"כ לבדוק- וכן הובא בשם הגר"מ פיינשטיין זצ"ל (שמעתתא דמשה, ובארחות רבינו ח"ב עמ' א כתב שהחזו"א והקהלת יעקב בדקו לאחר מעריב, עי' במ"ב סי' תלא ס"ק ח110 והגרי"ש אלישיב זצ"ל (אשרי האיש או"ח ח"ג עמ' שנח) כתב, אמנם החיי אדם כלל קיט סעי' ו כתב שהצריכו חכמים לבדוק אף לפרורין מחשש שמא יבא לאכלם, בשעה"צ סי' תלג ס"ק לג משמע שא"צ לבדוק לפירורין וכמש"כ בהליכות שלמה פסח עמ' קג111 .שהמנהג כהחיי אדם לבדוק אפילו לפירורים . וע"ע במ"ב סי' תמד ס"ק טו, המ"ב סי' תמב ס"ק לג כתב שחמץ מטונף קצת ופחות מכזית א"צ לבער לכו"ע112 והגרי"ש אלישיב. ופי' המ"ב שם ס"ק כח דר"ל שאין ללעוג על המנהג לומר שהוא חומרא יתירא, והשו"ע סי' תמב סעי' ו כתב שנהגו לגרר הכתלים והכסאות." כתב הרא"ש (פסחים פ"ג סי' ב) "ישראל קדושים הם וגוררין כל החמץ הנמצא אפילו כל שהוא113 .(אשרי האיש ח"ג עמ' שנח) כתב שבחורין וסדקין שיש לחוש בהם לחמץ אך קשה לו לבודקם ישפוך לתוכם חומר שפוגם את החמץ ופוסלו מאכילת כלב וכעי"ז דעת. והגרי"ש אלישיב (אשרי האיש ח"ג עמ' שנה) כתב שמצד הדין א"צ לבדוק ספרים אבל לא יניחם על שלחנו בפסח שמא יפול פירור חמץ לתוך האוכל. וכ"ה בחזו"א או"ח סי' קטז ס"ק יח, במעשה רב אות קע"ח כתב שהגר"א היה בודק את הספרים114 . וגם הגרש"ז אויערבאך (הליכות שלמה פסח פ"ה סעי' ו) כתב שא"צ לבדוק הספרים,) שמועות משה סי' תלג סעי' ג- הגר"מ פיינשטיין (שמעתתא דמשה שו"ע ורמ"א סי' תלג סעי' א וסעי' ב115 . ובשו"ת שבט הלוי ח"א סי' קלו כתב שרגיל לבדוק לאור הנר בלבד אבל אם חסר לטיב הבדיקה מדליק גם החשמל, בספר בדיקת חמץ וביעורו עמ' קפה הערה לה כתב שכן נהג מרן הגרי"ז116 והגרש"ז אויערבאך (הליכות שלמה פסח פ"ה דבר הלכה אות יט) ס"ל. ולדעת הגר"מ פיינשטיין (שמעתתא דמשה – שמועות משה סי' תלג סעי' א) מוטב לבדוק כשהאור פתוח.) כן נהגו החזו"א (ארחות רבינו ח"ד פ"ד אות ג) והקהלת יעקב (שם ח"ב עמ' ב117 אבל אין לשנות ממנהג ישראל לבדוק גם ע"י נר (וע"ע מש"כ, וכן דעת הגרי"ש אלישיב (אשרי האיש ח"ג עמ' שסא) שאין צריך לכבות את החשמל שהרי אור כזה אינו מחשיך ואדרבה מסייע הוא לבדיקה,שאם דולק אור החשמל בבית בשעת הבדיקה א"צ לכבותו .)בזה בספר הל' חג בחג פסח עמ' עט . ולדעת הגרי"ש אלישיב (אשרי האיש ח"ג עמ' שס) בזמנינו מעיקר הדין צריך להניח פתיתים, רמ"א סי' תלב סעי' ב ומ"ב שם ושעה"צ שם ס"ק יב118 והחזו"א לא נהג להניח פתיתים (ארחות רבינו ח"ב עמ' ב) וגם הגר"מ פיינשטיין לא, והשעה"צ שם ס"ק יא כתב שלדעת הט"ז יותר טוב שלא להניח שמא יאבד, הגר"א שם פסק שא"צ להניח פתיתין והחיי אדם כלל קיט סעי' כב כתב שאין לחוש להניח פתיתים119 .)נהג כן (שמעתתא דמשה – שמועות משה סי' תלב סעי' ב שערי תשובה סו"ס תלב220 וכן משמע מדברי הרמ"א (סי' תלב, אמנם מנהג העולם הוא שבני הבית מניחים את הפתיתים ולא הבודק.) וגם הגרי"ש אלישיב היה מניח הפתיתים לעצמו (אשרי האיש ח"ג עמ' שס, בארחות רבינו (ח"ב עמ' ב) כתב שהקהלת יעקב היה מניח הפתיתים בעצמו221 .) וכן מבואר מדברי החק יעקב (שם ס"ק יד,סעי' ב) שכתב שנוהגים להניח הפתיתים במקום שימצאם הבודק וכעי"ז הובא בשם הגרש"ז אויערבאך (הליכות. ובמקום שקשה לבדוק לאור הנר מותר לכתחלה ע"י פנס, לדעת הגרי"ש אלישיב (אשרי האיש ח"ג עמ' שסא) מותר לבדוק ע"י פנס דק שמאיר היטב לחורים וסדקים אלא שלכתחלה אין לשנות המנהג לבדוק לאור הנר222 .)שלמה פסח עמ' קי) והגר"מ פיינשטיין (שמעתתא דמשה – שמועות משה סי' תלג סעי' ב
6
Leadership in
Kashrus Education
WHEN YOU CAN DRINK AND DRIVE: THE HALACHIC IMPLICATIONS OF DRINKING COFFEE ON THE ROAD C O N T I N U E D F R O M PA G E 7
The Shach writes that we need to be strict in applying the heter of Kli Sheni regarding earthenware utensils, such as the mugs that were used. The heter of Stam Keilim also doesn’t work here since he says that these mugs are certainly used daily. Therefore, the Nodah B’Yehuda paskens that these mugs should not be used l’chatchila, and that whoever has it within their power to protest the practice of Jews drinking in Gentile coffeehouses should do so.10 Let’s return to the future now. We don’t need to use the nonkosher mugs in our Gentile-owned coffeehouses. We have disposable everything these days, including cups, Baruch Hashem. Yay! Order up that Starbucks Venti (20 oz size for the uninitiated)! Not so fast. If you recall, our 21st century issue is not mugs – it’s the washing procedures that may mix treif dishes with the coffeemaking equipment. Disposable cups won’t save us from that. “But wait,” you say. “What about Stam Keilim?” Whew, crisis averted! Sorry for the rollercoaster of emotions I’m putting you through, but the heter of Stam Keilim applies to b’dieved situations only, as previously mentioned. Is all hope lost?! No! Rabbi Heinemann, shlita, has ridden to our rescue using ten words in the Nodah B’Yehuda that we quote here, ”ולהלכה למעשה בדרך באושפיזא “‘שאין שם כלים אחרים מיחשב דיעבד וכו, Practically speaking, when someone
is traveling and is in a place where no kosher utensils are available, he is considered to be in a b’ideved situation” and he may use the gentile owned mugs. The Nodah B’Yehuda allows the use of the mugs based on the heter of Kli Sheni because traveling is a b’dieved situation. Rabbi Heinemann applies the same lomdus (thinking) to our modern coffeehouse issue. He says when someone is on the road traveling, he is considered to be in a b’dieved situation. Based on our investigations, we also know that the treif dishes are not always washed with the coffee equipment.11 Therefore, we can use the heter of Stam Keilim since we are in a b’dieved situation. One Venti House Blend coming up! While you are savoring your caffeine-fix, let me remind you of a few caveats. Once you get home, it’s back to Moishe’s Coffee Café for you. You are no longer considered to be in a b’dieved situation; you’re back in L’chatchila12 Land, and non-kosher coffee places should be avoided unless you know clearly that no treif utensils are washed with the coffee equipment. Bear in mind that even while traveling, you can only order regular or decaf coffee and a Latte made with stam cholov (if you don’t keep Cholov Yisroel). Frappuccinos and other similar flavored coffee creations contain additional ingredients that need to be reviewed before they can be recommended. Happy Trails!
10. The actual words of the Nb”Y are illustrative of how serious he felt this issue was; ... אם הם בני תורה אינם בני יראה והמה קלי דעת, ידע רום מעלתו,ומה שהשיב לו המשיב שבפראג שותין בני תורה בבתים של אינו יהודי 11. The fact that the treif dishes are not washed with the coffee equipment every day allows us to avoid the issue the Shach mentioned earlier, that the mugs could not be allowed based on סתם כליםsince they are used daily with non-kosher milk. 12. A scenario in which the strict halacha must be applied.
Bedikas Chometz
Search for Dough Like a Pro C O N T I N U E D F R O M PA G E 6
areas, one should remember to check clothing pockets, handbags, strollers, car seats, children’s knapsacks, pet cages, fish tanks, pet and fish food, cars and garages. One should ensure that vacuum bags containing chometz are discarded and that garbage cans are cleaned. Areas which were thoroughly cleaned beforehand do not need to be scrutinized at the time of bedikas chometz.23 For example, clothing pockets which were cleaned well and checked beforehand do not need to be rechecked during bedikas chometz.24 However, the person conducting the bedikah should enquire and verify that all the pockets were, in fact, cleaned.25 One should remove or sell all chometz at his workplace. If he owns the workplace, he should perform bedikas chometz, preferably on the night of the 14th of Nissan.
One is not obligated to move a heavy piece of furniture to check behind it for chometz.26 However, if it is known that chometz is present it is customary to remove it if possible.27 One is not obligated to check areas of the house into which chometz is never brought. However, those areas do need to be checked if children live in the house and could reach them.28 One should not speak between the brocha and the beginning of the bedikah. During the bedikah he should preferably speak only about things related to the search. If he did speak about non-related matters after starting the bedikah, he does not repeat the brocha.29 If he goes to the bathroom during the bedikah, he may recite Asher Yotzar.30 At the conclusion of the bedikah, he should say Kol Chamira.
. עי' אשל אברהם מבוטשאטש סי' תלד סעי' א ודעת תורה להמהרש"ם סי' תלג סעי' ב223 . עי' בארחות רבינו (ח"ב פסח עמ' ה) שהחזו"א אמר שאחר שמכבסים את הבגדים לפסח ונזהרים עליהם מפני חמץ הוי כמקום שאין מכניסים שם חמץ וא"צ בדיקה בליל י"ד224 בזמננו שמכבדין את הבית היטב לפני ליל י"ד אע"פ שחיוב הבדיקה במקומו עומד מ"מ אין בעל הבית חייב לפשפש בשעת הבדיקה בכל המקומות אלא ידקדק ויבחון היטב אם כבר ניקו כל מקום ופינה,) לדעת הגרש"ז אויערבאך (הליכות שלמה פסח פ"ה סעי' א225 .)שנז- ועי' בדברי הגרי"ש אלישיב בזה (אשרי האיש ח"ג עמ שנה. ואם לאו ינקהו,מחמץ . שדינו כמקום שאין מכניסים בו חמץ226 ואם הוא. ומ"מ אמר מו"ר ר' היינעמאן שליט"א שאם אפשר נוהגים להסיר החמץ, עי' בשו"ע הגר"ז סי' תלג סעי' יט שאם נפל חמץ תחת קרקעית הבית המרוצפת בנסרים א"צ לקעקע את הנסרים לבדוק תחתיהם אפילו אם ראה שנפל שם חמץ אלא מבטלו ודיו227 . עי' בשו"ע סי' תלג סעי' ח ובשו"ע הגר"ז בקו"א שם,מקום ששייך חפישת הכלב י"ל שחייב מעיקר הדין שו"ע סי' תלג סעי' ג ומ"ב שם ס"ק יט228 שו"ע סי' תלב סעי' א ומ"ב שם229 .) כן פסק הגרי"ש אלישיב (אשרי האיש ח"ג עמ' שסא330
Leadership in
Kashrus Education
7
STAR-K CERTIFICATION, INC.
NON PROFIT ORG US POSTAGE PAID BROOKLYN, NY PERMIT #7379
122 Slade Avenue, Suite 300 Baltimore, Maryland 21208-4996
FIRST EVER PAN-ASIA KOSHER TRAINING SEMINAR
Held in Shanghai
MARGIE PENSAK
They come from Perth; Yerushalayim; Mumbai; Manila; Boston; Scottsdale; and Los Angeles, but truly the mashgichim attending the inaugural STAR-K Pan-Asia Kosher Training Seminar in Shanghai, January 9-14, live out of their suitcases. Dedicated to the mission of ensuring and spreading kashrus, even at a moment’s notice, implies where they are from is wherever their luggage happens to be.
Dateline and possible time issues when davening while traveling. Mashgichim and STAR-K office personnel paired up to inspect factories. Seminar highlights included: a Shabbaton and Malaveh Malka shiur; an interactive SKYPE visit with STAR-K Rabbinical Administrator HaRav Moshe Heinemann, shlit”a; and an erev Shabbos walking tour of Jewish Shanghai.
Representing the premier kosher certifier in Asia, these STAR-K mashgichim are the “eyes and ears” in the field who help certify thousands of products --from canned goods and nori sheets in China and South Korea, to spices and coconut products in India and Sri Lanka, and banana chips and coco sugar in the Philippines-mostly exported as “bulk” ingredients to be processed globally into consumer products.
Rabbi Yosef Wexler, who traveled from Yerushalayim to attend, mentioned in his letter to STAR-K President Avrom Pollak, “As I go back into the field today, it is with renewed energy after the inspiring few days that I spent in Shanghai with Rabbi Mushell, Rabbi Heber and the incredible team of STAR-K Asia Pacific. All the shiurim and events were informative and inspiring. The Q & A session with Rabbi Mushell was an important opportunity for us in the field to discuss face-to-face with our Kashrus Administrator various issues that come up in the factories. Rabbi Heber’s shiur on zmanim and the International Dateline helped me gain a clear picture and practical guidelines in this complicated area of halacha often encountered by the traveling mashgiach. However, without a doubt, the highlight was the Q & A session with the Rav HaMachshir Rabbi Heinemann, shlit”a. It was a tremendous zechus to ask various shailos to such an adom gadol. The Rav answered all our shailos at length with tremendous insight and depth and even a little humor sprinkled in. Yasher koach!”
STAR-K operates regional support centers in Shanghai, China and Cochin, India and representative offices in Manila, Philippines; Colombo, Sri Lanka; Karachi, Pakistan; and Jakarta, Indonesia. Joining Baltimore-based STAR-K Kashrus Administrators Rabbi Dovid Heber and Rabbi Avrohom Mushell were Amos Benjamin and Joel Weinberger, who run the STAR-K Far East and India/Sri Lanka offices, respectively. STAR-K mashgichim Rabbis Jonathan Goldschmidt, Yofiel Jacob, Yitzchok Kaufman, Nosson Levin, Aryeh Mendoza, Eli Putney, Ariel Stein, Yosef Wexler, and Shmuel Zvuloni also attended. For some, it was the first time they were able to put a face to the voice after much telecommunication. Seminar topics covered were: Plant report development; rabbinical prohibitions in kosher law; insect removal from vegetables-process and methodology; the International
Participant Aryeh Mendoza, from Manila, concluded, “To date, this was the most impactful weekend of my career. I now truly recognize the amazing people I work with, and we all gained a deeper understanding of the holy work in which we are involved.”
STAR-K Kosher Certification A non-profit agency representing the Kosher consumer in promoting Kashrus through Education, Research and Supervision. FOUNDING EDITOR: A.J. Levin
Phone: 410.484.4110 Fax: 410.653.9294 E-mail: info@star-k.org www.star-k.org
EDITOR: Rabbi Tzvi Rosen MANAGING EDITOR: Mrs. Pesi Herskovitz COPY EDITOR/COORDINATOR: Ms. D. Rosenstein CONTRIBUTING WRITER: Mrs. Margie Pensak GRAPHIC ARTIST: Miss Hudi Neuberger
Copyright: 2019. STAR-K Certification, Inc. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission of STAR-K Certification, Inc.
Subscriptions
$10(USD) annually for 4 issues -US & Canada $15(USD) annually for 4 issues -Overseas
Kashrus Kurrents is also available online at www.star-k.org/kashrus-kurrents. To receive an email when the most recent issue has been uploaded, please send an email to kashruskurrents-subscribe@star-k.org.
This publication is dedicated to the memory of M. Leo Storch, of blessed memory, through a grant from Mrs. M. Leo Storch & Family.
(The STAR-K Passover Book, not included in this subscription, is available for purchase in Jewish bookstores during the Passover season.)
Name ________________________________________________ Address _______________________________________________ City _________________ State _________ Zip _______________ Phone ________________________________________________ Please send your tax deductible checks made payable to: KASHRUS KURRENTS 122 Slade Avenue, Suite 300, Baltimore, MD 21208-4996 Phone: (410) 484-4110 • Fax: (410) 653-9294
Download our STAR-K app on your Android and Apple Smartphones. Available on the App Store, Google Play, and Amazon Kindle.
Receive late breaking kashrus news and alerts in your email. Send an email to alerts-subscribe@star-k.org or visit www.star-k.org/alerts
8
Leadership in
Kashrus Education