


Seize a once in a lifetime moment and preserve your legacy for generations to come.




Seize a once in a lifetime moment and preserve your legacy for generations to come.
One can enjoy a front row seat to Nantucket Harbor with the sea life of sailboats, fishing boats, paddle boarding and picnic boats dotting the harbor, offering the best of what Nantucket has to offer.
Complete privacy can be expected as the several acre property is surrounded by vast conservation lands and the idyllic Nantucket "Creeks" for nearly a mile.
A rarity along the Nantucket shoreline. Located in Monomoy, where the view lines are endless. With direct beach and water access
along a private path, this special compound has been perfectly placed for Nantucket’s most discerning buyer.
Constructed with the Highest Quality of Craftsmanship.
Architect: Lyman Perry | Built by: Ron Winters
Enter an expanse of bright, light filled rooms as a large double height entry with open views to the water welcomes you. In the main house, the large and open chef’s kitchen was designed by Clive Christian in NYC. Timeless finishes such as limestone floors add to the understated elegance of this home. The floorplan and flow were designed with full scale entertaining and family living in mind, showcasing the fine craftsmanship of artisans local to the island.
The Main House was built in 2008.
The Guest Cottage, 1 Lovelace, was the original home built in 1910.
The Garage & Guest Studio #2 were built in 2008.
The dining room and living room are classically stunning, with antique chandeliers and thoughtful wall sconces, a hand carved fireplace in the living room and antique french limestone in the dining room. Multiple smaller spaces create an ease for entertaining throughout the house, and intimate places for quieter evenings.
French doors open wide from all rooms onto expansive terraces, and a magnificent trellised entertainment area offers an outdoor kitchen and additional dining spaces.
From the beachside pathways to the private bedroom decks, take in the vast views of Nantucket Harbor from anywhere on the property
Born and raised in Boston, Marybeth Gilmartin-Baugher brings a local’s perspective to her work with Compass, having lived in the Greenwich area for more than two decades. In addition to her deep New England roots, Marybeth is an experienced entrepreneur: Prior to her career in real estate, she built one of the most reputable boutique executive search firms in the country from the ground up, producing consistently strong results across all economic cycles. That critical management experience allowed her to develop and maintain high-level relationships with a wide range of top investment banks and family offices that continue to pay off for her clients today.
Loyal, ethical, and discrete, buyers and sellers are often quick to praise her honesty and sharp intuition when working on their behalf. Through a combination of charisma and kindness, she always strives to provide elite-level service, and knows how to deliver. Marybeth is also remarkably at ease with high net worth clients, thanks to years of representing many of the world’s largest financial institutions.
A graduate of the University of Massachusetts, where she studied Political Science, she is a proud mother of a Division 1 athlete and Honors student, and an avid supporter of her son’s lacrosse team. In her free time, she enjoys volunteering for the Greenwich Historical Society and is a devoted member of the Nantucket Island Chapter of the American Ireland Fund.
Shelly Tretter Lynch is considered one of the top professionals in Greenwich, CT and is a Founding Member of the Compass Greenwich office. In her 25 years of experience in representing properties from Backcountry to waterfront communities, Shelly consistently represents some of the finest estates in Greenwich and Fairfield County. Having achieved national recognition, Shelly has expanded her business to Nantucket, MA.
Shelly is the No. 1 agent in Connecticut and in the top 0.5% in the nation for Compass. Shelly has been acknowledged by the Wall Street Journal as one of the Top 50 Agents in the United States by dollar volume. She has also been featured in Who’s Who in Residential Real Estate in North America and noted by The Real Trends as one of the Top 10 brokers in Westchester County and Connecticut for 2020. Shelly was also named the #1 Agent in Greenwich and Connecticut for Compass in 2021.
Shelly enjoys working in every facet of real estate, she has an extensive background in land development, planning, new construction, and investment opportunities. Shelly has formed a global partnership with the top brokers around the world.
Shelly earned her bachelor’s degree in Communication Arts and has conducted graduate work in Film Studies. Consistently involved in charity work, she also sits on several boards.
Shelly is actively involved with the Compass Luxury Division, and is a member of REALM and the Compass Sports + Entertainment Division.
Founded in 2012, Compass, a Fortune 500 Company, pairs best-in class agents with cutting edge technology and unparalleled marketing. Our innovative approach has secured over $1.5 billion in capital from the world’s most prominent investors, allowing for the development of tools and recruitment of talent to build a once-in-ageneration company.
Developed in-house, every Compass tool is designed to modernize both sides of the real estate experience. Just as we compare properties and measure marketing performance with sellers, we also offer buyers exclusive access to listings not seen anywhere else.
Locally, we're counted among the top five brokerages in every one of our core markets; meanwhile, our national presence and uniquely collaborative culture present agents with unlimited co-brokering and referral opportunities.
The 150+ members of our in-house marketing and advertising agency ensure that every home we represent is portrayed in its finest light across every platform—from eye-catching billboards and installations to stunning print materials and digital campaigns.
Discover how we're helping buyers and sellers find their place in the world every day, one home at a time.
Nantucket Island was discovered by Bartholomew Gosnold in 1602, at which time the Indian population was about 1,500. The island was purchased by Thomas Mahew in 1641, but was not settled until 1659 when Thomas Mayhew sold his interest to a group of investors: Tristram Coffin, Peter Coffin, Thomas Macy, Christopher Hussey, Richard Swain, Thomas Barnard, Stephen Greenleaf, John Swain and William Pike. These men are considered the founding fathers of Nantucket, and many islanders are related to these families.
The island suffered great economic hardships, worsened by the “Great Fire” of July 13, 1846, that, fueled by whale oil and lumber, devastated the main town, burning some
40 acres The fire left hundreds homeless and povertystricken, and many people left the island. By 1850, whaling was in decline.
As a result of this depopulation, the island was left underdeveloped and isolated until the mid-20th century. The isolation kept many of the pre-Civil War buildings intact and, by the 1950s, enterprising developers like Walter Beinecke began buying up large sections of the island and restoring them to create an upmarket destination for wealthy people. While he might be remembered as a developer, he was a preservationist at the core. Beinecke eventually sold his properties to the First Winthrop Corporation of Boston.
Need sandwiches for the beach? A quick bite? How about live music? Let us help you plan your time on the island by sharing our list of favorites.
The Hub 31 Main St.
Handlebar 15 Washington St
Expresso to Go 1 Toombs Court
Roastd 159 Orange Street
Blackeyed Susans 10 India St
SANDWICHES
Something Natural 50 Cliff Rd
The Green 18 Sparks Ave
Provisions 3 Harbor Square
Claudettes Sconset Rotary Fresh 5 Salem Street
DINNER
The Galley 54 Jefferson Ave
The Straight Wharf 6 Harbor Square Cru 1 Straight Wharf
Brant Point Grill 50 Easton St
American Seasons 80 Center St
CASUAL EATERIES
Millies 326 Madaket Rd Pi Pizza 11 West Creek Rd
Sophie Tee’s 7 Dave St
Sandbar at The Jetties 4 Bathing Beach Rd
Lemon Press 41 Main St
FISH STORES
167 Raw 167 Hummock Pond Rd
Straight Wharf Fish Store 4 Harbor Square
Nantucket Seafoods 56 Old South Rd
Gliddens 115 Pleasant St Souza’s Seafood 23 Trotters Lane
Stop and Shop 31 Sparks’ Ave or 9 Salem St
Bartletts Farm Main St
Moors End Farm Polpis Rd
Nantucket Meat and Fish 21 Old South Rd
Sconset Market ‘Sconset Center
LIVE MUSIC
Cisco Brewery 54 Jefferson Ave
The Chicken Box 16 Dave St
The Rose and Crown 23 South Water St
The Muse 44Surfside Dr
The Gaslight 3 N. Union St
ICE CREAM
The Juice Bar 12 Broad St
Jack & Charlie’s Ice Cream 10 Sraight Wharf
Stars Ice Cream 4 Harbor Square Yummy 63 Surfside Rd
Nantucket is known for its unique shopping. In 2006, local residents voted to ban any new chain stores with more than 14 outlets that have standardized menus, trademarks, uniforms or other homogeneous decor from opening downtown. It’s better to shop on a beautiful day when everyone else is at the beach!
HOME STORES
Atlantic 16 Federal St Nantucket Looms 51 Main St Bodega 2 Candle St Freedmans 14 North Centre St Coastal 7 South Beach St
CLOTHING STORES
Milly & Grace 2 Washington St Murray’s Toggery 62 Main St
The Lovely 11 Washington St Vis-A-Vis 34 Main St
Nalu 14 Cambridge St
There is so much to do on Nantucket! When the weather is good, there is a beach for everyone. There are also several reputable children’s summer camps. Just make sure you reserve far in advance, as they fill up fast. On a rainy or foggy day, head to the many museums and galleries. Also, the Nantucket Film Festival in June is a must, as are the several theatrical performances throughout the Summer months.
SPORTS
Miacomet Golf Course
Full 18 hole public course
Siasconset Golf Course
Eight hole public course
Sankaty Head Golf Course
Public hours in the off season
Nantucket Tennis Jetty’s Beach
Siasconset Casino Association
Public hours available
There are several good fishing charters on Nantucket. Consider
Monomoy Charters, Capt. Tom’s Charters or Bill Fisher.
If the high seas don’t appeal, consider a tour by van or bus with:
Gail’s Tours or Nantucket Island Tour
Childrens
Lifeguard, no surf, great for children, playground
Francis Street
No lifeguard, on harbor, kayak rental available
Jetties
Lifeguard, no waves, watersports rentals available, tennis courts
Lifeguard, no surf, great for kids
Dionis
Lifeguard, shallow, family beach
ACKventure Day & Sports Camp
22 Different camps including baseball and fishing,
Murray Camp ages 4-14, various activities
Boys & Girls Club Camp Grades 2-8, affordable
Strong Wings Camp Ages 5-15, outdoor adventure
Maria Mitchell Ages 5-16, science and exploring
Old Mill
The oldest perating Windmill in the US
Churches
There are 10 churches to visit.
Brant Point Lighthouse Beautiful but often crowded
Sankaty Head Lighthouse
Consider visiting by bicycle
Great Point Lighthouse Only accessible by 4 wheel drive
Nantucket Historical Association/Whaling Museum
Check the NHA website for current exhibitions, lectures and activities at the 1800 House
Nantucket Antheneum Library & Community Center with programs
Maria Mitchell Natural Science Museum
Vestal Street & Loines Observatories
For the scientists in your family
Shipwreck & Lifesaving Museum
Discover Nantucket’s maritime heritage and heros.
Lightship Basket Museum
Learn how basketweaving kept men occupied for months at sea.
Most island galleries have openings on the first or second Friday evening of July and August. Some of our favorites include:
Hostetler Gallery
Petty Folk Art & Carving
The Galleries at Old Spouter
Quidley & Company
Samuel Owen Gallery
Dreamland Film and Cultural Center
Newly renovated movie theater and performing Arts Center.
Theatre Workshop of Nantucket Where Broadway meets ACK.
White Heron Theatre Company
Truly transformative theater in a newly renovated facility.
Nantucket Musical Arts Society
Summer concerts at the First Congregational Church.
On the Isle
Once a summer production in Sconset with local talent of all ages.
The kids are at camp, the houseguests are on the ferry, isn’t it time for some self care? Perhaps a yoga or pilates class and then a mani/pedi and a blowdry? Here are some of our favorite fitness classes and clubs. There are several qualified beauticians and hairstylists on island, some will make house calls. Book ahead, appointments are in high demand!
FITNESS
The Yoga Room Fairgrounds Rd.
Supta Yogaoga 9 Amelia Drive
Dharma Yoga Upstairs at Bartlett’s Farm 1111 Nantucket Yoga Studio at 3 West Creek Road
The Nantucket Club The Nantucket Hotel 77 Easton St.
SALONS
RJ Miller 6 Amelia Drive
On-Glaze Nail Salon 8 West Creek Road
Emma Ross Hair & Beauty 19 North Beach Street
Darya Afshari Salon & Spa 7 South Beach Street
Margie Malone Beauty Bar, 3 Hanabea Lane
Licensed Real Estate Salesperson
Founding Member, The Nantucket Advisory Group at Compass marybeth.gilmartin@compass.com M: 917.561.5995 • O: 508.257.0888
Licensed Real Estate Salesperson
Founding Member, The Nantucket Advisory Group at Compass shelly.tretterlynch@compass.com M: 203.550.8508 • O: 508.257.0888
Marybeth Gilmartin-Baugher and Shelly Tretter Lynch are real estate licensees affiliated with Compass, a licensed real estate broker in Connecticut and Massachusetts and abides by Equal Housing Opportunity laws. All material presented herein is intended for informational purposes only. Information is compiled from sources deemed reliable but is subject to errors, omissions, changes in price, condition, sale, or withdrawal without notice. This is not intended to solicit property already listed. Photos may be virtually staged or digitally enhanced and may not reflect actual property conditions.