Inequality, productivity and the organisation of labor Oriana Bandiera The London School of Economics and Political Science
2021 Annual Conference of the Global Forum on Productivity
Two ways of thinking about productivity
Symptoms
Causes
Remedies
References
There are two ways of thinking about productivity
1. making workers/firms more productive, taking as given the organisation of labor 2.improving the organisation of labor we mostly think of (1) makes sense only if (2) is optimal -is it?
Oriana Bandiera
Global Forum: Two ways of thinking about productivity
Slide 2 / 23
Two ways of thinking about productivity
Symptoms
Causes
Remedies
References
The organisation of labor how society allocates people with different talents to: unpaid work (home) vs. paid work self-employed vs. firm managers vs. workers
do we get this right?
Oriana Bandiera
Global Forum: Two ways of thinking about productivity
Slide 3 / 23
Two ways of thinking about productivity
Symptoms
Causes
Remedies
References
This talk
misallocation symptoms misallocation causes: gender and wealth inequality misallocation and the pandemic: crisis or opportunity?
Oriana Bandiera
Global Forum: Two ways of thinking about productivity
Slide 4 / 23
Two ways of thinking about productivity
Symptoms
Causes
Remedies
References
1.Managers vs workers
managers have a much larger impact on economic activity –> gains from swapping until all managers are more talented than all workers test with OECD PIAAC data on numeracy skills
Oriana Bandiera
Global Forum: Symptoms
Slide 5 / 23
Two ways of thinking about productivity
Symptoms
Causes
Remedies
References
Validation
Firms are better managed where managers are more talented Oriana Bandiera
Global Forum: Symptoms
Slide 6 / 23
Two ways of thinking about productivity
Symptoms
Causes
Remedies
References
But often the most talented are not managers country 1
Oriana Bandiera
Global Forum: Symptoms
Slide 7 / 23
Two ways of thinking about productivity
Symptoms
Causes
Remedies
References
very often
country 2
Oriana Bandiera
Global Forum: Symptoms
Slide 8 / 23
Two ways of thinking about productivity
Symptoms
Causes
Remedies
References
nearly always
country 3
Oriana Bandiera
Global Forum: Symptoms
Slide 9 / 23
Two ways of thinking about productivity
Symptoms
Causes
Remedies
References
Richer countries reward talent more
Oriana Bandiera
Global Forum: Symptoms
Slide 10 / 23
Two ways of thinking about productivity
Symptoms
Causes
Remedies
References
Richer countries allocate talent better
A ratio>1 means that the top 25% of BC is more talented than the bottom 25% of managers Oriana Bandiera
Global Forum: Symptoms
Slide 11 / 23
Two ways of thinking about productivity
Symptoms
Causes
Remedies
References
2. The size of firms
over the process of development, self employment disappears as firms and salaried jobs increase sharply (source: JWD)
Oriana Bandiera
Global Forum: Symptoms
Slide 12 / 23
Two ways of thinking about productivity
Symptoms
Causes
Remedies
References
As firms grow, wages rise
the same worker earns 1.6X more in a large (250+) vs. small (10-49) firm (source: Moser 21 on 26 EU Countries) Oriana Bandiera
Global Forum: Symptoms
Slide 13 / 23
Two ways of thinking about productivity
Symptoms
Causes
Remedies
References
The FSWP is larger in lower income countries
If large firms are more productive, why don’t small firms grow? (source: Moser 21) Oriana Bandiera
Global Forum: Symptoms
Slide 14 / 23
Two ways of thinking about productivity
Symptoms
Causes
Remedies
References
Taking stock
(dis)organisation of labor creates misallocation of talent that hampers productivity in line with existing evidence on the misallocation of capital (Hsieh and Klenow, 2009; Bau and Matray, 2020) improving the allocation will be more powerful than trying to improve the productivity of misallocated workers
Oriana Bandiera
Global Forum: Symptoms
Slide 15 / 23
Two ways of thinking about productivity
Symptoms
Causes
Remedies
References
Causes
wealth inequality –> ”inherited” jobs –> restricted pool differential barriers on traits orthogonal to productivity –> women, ethnic minorities, cannot get the jobs that their talent deserves –> replaced by less talented groups
Oriana Bandiera
Global Forum: Causes
Slide 16 / 23
Two ways of thinking about productivity
Symptoms
Causes
Remedies
References
Restricting the pool: 1. Managers
When managers are mostly selected from the owning family talent is lower Oriana Bandiera
Global Forum: Causes
Slide 17 / 23
Two ways of thinking about productivity
Symptoms
Causes
Remedies
References
Restricting the pool: 2. Inventors
Invention is the engine of growth.. we use 1% of it (Bell et al., 2019). Oriana Bandiera
Global Forum: Causes
Slide 18 / 23
Two ways of thinking about productivity
Symptoms
Causes
Remedies
References
Restricting the pool: 3. Women
women LFP is much lower than men’s nearly everywhere Hsieh et al. (2019) estimate that between 20-40% of growth in output per person btw 1960-00 was due to improved allocation in Ashraf et al. (2021) we use HR data from a large MNE to compute the effect of misallocation on productivity –> average gain is 33%
Oriana Bandiera
Global Forum: Causes
Slide 19 / 23
Two ways of thinking about productivity
Symptoms
Causes
Remedies
References
Every crisis, an opportunity?
The pandemic is worsening the allocation of talent both current and future by restricting opportunities Two channels: 1 2
Oriana Bandiera
women’s labor force participation education
Global Forum: Remedies
Slide 20 / 23
Two ways of thinking about productivity
Symptoms
Causes
Remedies
References
The (not so) great equaliser
Children in countries with lower PISA scores lost more school days to COVID (Schleicher 21) Oriana Bandiera
Global Forum: Remedies
Slide 21 / 23
Two ways of thinking about productivity
Symptoms
Causes
Remedies
References
The (not so) great equaliser
Children in poorer families lost more learning opportunities to COVID (Chetty et al., 2020) Oriana Bandiera
Global Forum: Remedies
Slide 22 / 23
Two ways of thinking about productivity
Symptoms
Causes
Remedies
References
Remedies
inequalities generate misallocation of talent misallocation lowers productivity and fosters more inequality policies that level the playing field can break this vicious cycle, and will be needed to recover from the pandemic
Oriana Bandiera
Global Forum: Remedies
Slide 23 / 23
Two ways of thinking about productivity
Symptoms
Causes
Remedies
References
Ashraf, Nava, Oriana Bandiera, Virginia Minni, and Victor Quintas-Martínez. 2021. “The Misallocation of Women’s Talent Across Countries: Evidence from Personnel Data.” Working Paper. Bau, Natalie, and Adrien Matray. 2020. “Misallocation and capital market integration: Evidence from India.” National Bureau of Economic Research. Bell, Alex, Raj Chetty, Xavier Jaravel, Neviana Petkova, and John Van Reenen. 2019. “Who becomes an inventor in America? The importance of exposure to innovation.” The Quarterly Journal of Economics, 134(2): 647–713. Chetty, Raj, John N Friedman, Nathaniel Hendren, Michael Stepner, et al. 2020. “The economic impacts of COVID-19: Evidence from a new public database built using private sector data.” National Bureau of Economic Research. Hsieh, Chang-Tai, and Peter J Klenow. 2009. “Misallocation and manufacturing TFP in China and India.” The Quarterly journal of economics, 124(4): 1403–1448.
Oriana Bandiera
Global Forum: References
Slide 23 / 23
Two ways of thinking about productivity
Symptoms
Causes
Remedies
References
Hsieh, Chang-Tai, Erik Hurst, Charles I Jones, and Peter J Klenow. 2019. “The allocation of talent and us economic growth.” Econometrica, 87(5): 1439–1474.
Oriana Bandiera
Global Forum: Remedies
Slide 23 / 23