Workshop on
Regulatory Barriers to Competition in Professional Services : Measurement and Reform Experiences 📆
18 & 19 November 2021
📧
Registration Link
📌
Virtually via Zoom
📖
Documentation: Workshop’s Website
AGENDA DAY 1 - 18 November 2021 - 12.30-16.00, CET
12.30 – 13.10
Introductory remarks: Alain de Serres, Deputy Director, Economics Department, OECD: Introducing the OECD PMR indicators on professional services Keynote speech: Jacques Pelkman, CEPS and visiting professor at College of Europe and Goethe University Frankfurt: A critical assessment of PMR indicators on professional services
Session 1 - Why competition matters in professional services and what drives it Discussant: Frank Verboven, Professor, University of Leuven Chair: Cristiana Vitale, Senior Economist, Economics Department, OECD 13.10 - 14.20
14.20 – 14.30
1.
Rhys Williams, Economic Consultant, London Economics: Can unregulated Professional Business Services markets deliver effective competition?
2.
Elena Salmaso, Senior Economist, Prometeia: Impact of regulation on digital automation in professional services
3.
Francesco Stolfi, Assistant Professor, Macquarie School of Social Sciences: Border clashes: the distributive politics of professional liberalisation in Greece, 2010–2018
Short break
Session 2 - Evidence on the impact of existing regulatory constraints of professional services Chair: Rosamaria Bitetti, Economics Department, OECD and Luiss University 1. Christopher Decker, Research Fellow in Law and Economics, University of Oxford: Reform and ‘modernisation’ of legal services in England and Wales: motivations, measurement and impacts 14.30 – 16.00
2. Robert Mysicka, Partner, Bennett McIntyre Mysicka LLP: Licence to Capture: The Cost Consequences to Consumers of Occupational Regulation in Canada1 3. Antonio Cappiello, Senior Economist, Italian National Chamber of Notaries: OECD PMR Indicators for professional services. Are civil law notaries different? 4. Frank Verboven, Professor of Economics, University of Leuven: Private Monopoly and Restricted Entry. Evidence from the Notary Profession 5. Kathryn Meghen, Chair, Working Group on Regulatory Issues, Architects’ Council of Europe: The European architectural sector
1
All opinions expressed in the paper are the personal view of the authors.
1
DAY 2 - 19 November 2021 - 12.30-15.45 CET
Session 3 - Challenges and lessons learned from reform initiatives – experiences of international organisations Chair: Cristiana Vitale, Senior Economist, Economics Department, OECD 1.
Manol Bengyuzov, Policy Officer, Unit on Skills, Services, Professions, Directorate General for Internal Market, Industry, Entrepreneurship and SMEs, European Commission: The EU perspective: fostering competition in professional services
2.
Maciej Drozd, Senior Economist, Finance, Competitiveness & Innovation Global Practice, World Bank: Are all restrictions equally important for competition? Lessons from the review of occupational regulation in Croatia
3.
Ania Thiemann, Competition Expert, Competition Division, OECD: OECD experiences in assessing competition barriers in regulated professions in Iceland and Portugal
12.30 – 13.10
13.10 – 13.15
Short break
Session 4 - Challenges and lessons learned from reforms – experiences of competition authorities Discussant: Christopher Decker, Research Fellow in Law and Economics, University of Oxford Chair: Ania Thiemann, Competition Expert, Competition Division, OECD
13.15 - 14.20
1. Sonia Moura, Senior legal advisor, Portuguese Competition Authority (AdC): Liberalisation of regulated professions in Portugal 2. Lucile Fournereau, Deputy head of the service for regulated professions, French Competition Authority (AdC): Reform of the regulation of notaries in France and its impact 3. Karabo Motaung, Senior analyst, Competition Commission of South Africa: Competition Interventions in the Architectural Profession 4. Pavel Jacunskij, Head, Competition Policy Group, Lithuanian Competition Council: Pricing regulation of notarial services in Lithuania 5. Gabor Horvath, Head of Unit, Competiveness Department, Ministry of Finance, Hungary: Future reforms of regulated professions in Hungary 6. Ninette Mwarania, Manager, Planning, Policy and Research, Competition Authority of Kenya: Competition interventions in the professional services sector and their impacts to consumers
14.20 – 14.30
Short break
14.30 – 14.50
Keynote speech: Morris Kleiner, AFL-CIO Chair Professor of Labor Policy, Humphrey School of Public Affairs, University of Minnesota: The welfare impact of occupational licensing
Session 5 - Ongoing reforms in the legal profession in the England and Wales: focus on consumers 14.50 – 15.35
15.35 – 15.45
1.
Sharon Horwitz, Director, Policy & International, Competition and Markets Authority, UK: Conclusion of recent review of its 2016 market study on legal services in England and Wales
2.
Steve Brooker, Head, Policy Development and Research, Legal Services Board (oversight regulator for legal services in England and Wales): Assessment of impact of current and upcoming reforms in England and Wales
3.
Dakshina Chandra, Fellow, Regulatory Governance, National Law School of India University, Bangalore: Evaluating Recent Efforts and Missed Opportunities Towards Competitive Legal Services in India
Concluding remarks: Antonio Gomes, Deputy Director, Directorate for Financial and Enterprise Affairs, OECD
2