Situated in the Palisades of La Jolla, this Mid-century modern William Lumpkins residence has been brought to life with new luxurious materials. The state of the art redesign has been newly constructed to perfection with designer finishes. The expansive main level features ocean views from a gourmet chef's island kitchen with Costentino quartziite inclusive of a custom dining area and master suite which flows to the outdoor terraces. Enjoy multiple entertaining areas with pool, outdoor shower, and more!
Listed Date Jun 01, 2020 Contract Date Aug 05, 2020 Sold Date Sep 25, 2020
5780 Rutgers Rd
ADDRESS SUBJECT
5780 Rutgers Rd, La Jolla, CA 92037
5976 Germaine Ln, La Jolla, CA 92037
1253 La Jolla Rancho Rd, La Jolla, CA 92037
1654 La Jolla Rancho Rd, La Jolla, CA 92037
ADDRESS SUBJECT
5780 Rutgers Rd, La Jolla, CA 92037
#1
5976 Germaine Ln, La Jolla, CA 92037 COMP #2
1253 La Jolla Rancho Rd, La Jolla, CA 92037
COMP #3
1654 La Jolla Rancho Rd, La Jolla, CA 92037
PROPERTY
ADDRESS SUBJECT
5780 Rutgers Rd, La Jolla, CA 92037
#4 5736 La Jolla Corona Dr, La Jolla, CA 92037
5150 Gordon Ln, San Diego, CA 92109
5115 Gordon Ln, San Diego, CA 92109
ADDRESS SUBJECT
5780 Rutgers Rd, La Jolla, CA 92037
COMP #4
5736 La Jolla Corona Dr, La Jolla, CA 92037
COMP #5
5150 Gordon Ln, San Diego, CA 92109
COMP #6
5115 Gordon Ln, San Diego, CA 92109 PROPERTY
ADDRESS SUBJECT
5780 Rutgers Rd, La Jolla, CA 92037
5114 Gordon Ln, San Diego, CA 92109
7145 Country Club Dr, La Jolla, CA 92037
7272 Country Club Dr, La Jolla, CA 92037
ADDRESS SUBJECT
5780 Rutgers Rd, La Jolla, CA 92037
5114 Gordon Ln, San Diego, CA 92109 COMP #8
7145 Country Club Dr, La Jolla, CA 92037
7272 Country Club Dr, La Jolla, CA 92037 PROPERTY
ADDRESS SUBJECT
5780 Rutgers Rd, La Jolla, CA 92037
2365 Via Siena, La Jolla, CA 92037
8656 Glenwick Ln, La Jolla, CA 92037
6344 La Pintura Dr, La Jolla, CA 92037
ADDRESS SUBJECT
PROPERTY
5780 Rutgers Rd, La Jolla, CA 92037 COMP #10
2365 Via Siena, La Jolla, CA 92037
COMP #11
8656 Glenwick Ln, La Jolla, CA 92037
COMP #12
6344 La Pintura Dr, La Jolla, CA 92037
ADDRESS SUBJECT
5780 Rutgers Rd, La Jolla, CA 92037
1126 Muirlands Vista Way, La Jolla, CA 92037
6887 Avenida Andorra, La Jolla, CA 92037
FEES - -LISTED DATE Jun 01, 2020 Sep 24, 2025 Nov 17, 2025 SOLD DATE Sep 25, 2020 Feb 27, 2026 -
ADDRESS SUBJECT
5780 Rutgers Rd, La Jolla, CA 92037
COMP #13
1126 Muirlands Vista Way, La Jolla, CA 92037
COMP #14
6887 Avenida Andorra, La Jolla, CA 92037
PROPERTY
Comparable property #1
La Jolla, CA 92037 5976
Listing description
Located in La Jolla's prestigious Muirlands neighborhood, this stunning 6bedroom, 65-bathroom home offers a seamless blend of luxury, privacy, and breathtaking views With 3,968 square feet of living space in the main house and an additional 646 square feet in the game room/guest house, every detail has been thoughtfully crafted, from the beautiful Brazilian Rainforest marble countertops to the natural seagrass limestone flooring with visible fossils. The primary suite is a true sanctuary, featuring quartzite white Macaubas countertops and leathered seagrass walls, while the great room showcases a striking pillar adorned with exotic zebrawood bands. Step outside to a private oasis with an Ipe Brazilian wood deck in the meditation garden, ideal for moments of peace and relaxation, or entertain in style with a heated pool, hot tub, BBQ area, and putting green. Enjoy south-facing views of downtown, the ocean, and even Mexico, which can be seen from both the home’s expansive windows and the roof deck. Set on a generous 17,000 sqft lot with fully aluminum gating and lush landscaping,
Continued on next page TRANSACTION INFORMATION Original Listing Price
$6,895,000 Last Asking Price $6,895,000 Closing Price $6,930,000 PPSF $1,502
Listed Date Feb 16, 2025
Contract Date Mar 02, 2025 Sold Date Apr 14, 2025 DOM - Days on Market 13
Comparable property #1
La Jolla, CA 92037
5976 Germaine Ln
Listing description (continued)
the property offers ultimate privacy, while 52 fully paid solar panels ensure energy efficiency Located on a peaceful, traffic-free street, this exceptional residence is a rare find TRANSACTION INFORMATION
$6,895,000 Last Asking Price
Listed Date Feb 16, 2025
Contract Date Mar 02, 2025
Sold Date Apr 14, 2025
DOM - Days on Market 13
Comparable property #1
5976 Germaine Ln
Comparable property #2
La Jolla, CA 92037
Listing description
Sleek sophistication meets iconic mid-century inspiration in this stunning, fully reimagined Muirlands residence with jaw-dropping, panoramic views. From the first light of sunrise over the mountains to gorgeous Pacific sunsets and city lights twinkling past the Coronado Bridge, nearly every room captures a cinematic sweep of San Diego’s most breathtaking vistas. The home has been taken to the studs and expanded with a 2,000 sq. ft. addition, blending timeless architectural elements open beam wood ceilings, vast panels of glass, clean lines, and indoor-outdoor flow with the finest contemporary finishes. The result: a uniquely seductive and livable design that elevates comfort and style. Lounge poolside while watching the ocean shimmer, or take in fireworks over the bay from your spa A rare, refined offering in one of La Jolla’s most prestigious neighborhoods
Sold Date Jul 31, 2025 DOM - Days on Market 64 SOLD 7/31/25 SOLD 4.6% BELOW ASKING
$1,430
Listed Date May 12, 2025
Contract Date Jul 16, 2025
Comparable property #3
La Jolla, CA 92037 1654
Listing description
One-Of-A-Kind "Rancho La Jolla" Estate Property Cherished by the same family for six decades, this extraordinary estate graces 1.23 prime acres. A rare opportunity to create your own legacy in one of La Jolla's most desirable enclaves nestled in privacy and seclusion. The grand, "Rancho La Jolla" estate features a 6,338 square foot classic Ranch Style residence surrounded by mature landscaping with multiple courtyards/seating areas to enjoy the serenity and quietude of the park-like-resort-style setting. See supp...
Listed Date Sep 20, 2025
Date Nov 06, 2025
Date Dec 08, 2025
Comparable property #3
1654 La Jolla Rancho Rd
Comparable property #4
La Jolla, CA 92037
$7,995,000
$7,770,000
Listing description
With panoramic ocean views on display from most of the living areas, including a secluded, resort like backyard with a pool and a spa, this sophisticated coastal ,home offers a lifestyle that many can only dream about. Located in a quiet cul-de-sac in one of La Jolla's most preferred neighborhoods, the residence features an artistic, designer quality interior with unsurpassed attention to detail, walnut floors and a bespoke gourmet kitchen which is a stylish designer showcase, as has a fun backsplash, that echoes the sea with Subzero Refrigerator with glass door, a gas range, double ovens and a Bosch dishwasher, European cabinets, a center island with counter seating and a coffee bar with gorgeous, custom built wood shelves and cabinets The home offers an impressive entry with towering double doors, framed by unique custom sidelights by the late artist Leslie Perris The appeal continues with two stories ceilings and a minimalist interior that places inspiring blues of the ocean on center stage Floor to Ceiling windows allow for sit-down views in the living room, which has a
Continued on next page
$1,833
Listed Date Nov 09, 2023
Contract Date Feb 23, 2024
Sold Date May 23, 2024
Comparable property #4
La Jolla, CA 92037
5736 La Jolla Corona Dr
Listing description (continued)
fireplace and French doors that connect to the entertainers backyard A climate controlled wine room positioned between the living room and the spacious formal dining room serves as a centerpiece of the thoughtful well-conceived floor plan Open and bright the home is illuminated by several skylights Automatic window shades, and integrated sound system and a smart home technology. Expansive Flagstone patio surrounding the spacious pool and spa. Outdoor kitchen with riveting sunset view, a fridge, built in BBQ and Bar. Opening to the backyard, the primary suite features a large picture window, a retreat and a unique custom FP flanked by builtin bookshelves. A pocket door revel a posh like spa with an adjacent dressing room, dual vanities, distinctive tile and an oversized steam shower with glass enclosures. Generous secondary bedrooms with built in desk. An attached 3 car garage w/epoxy floors and built in cabinets in many rooms. Central vacuum, lush tropical landscaping, and Nutone lighting system. With a peaceful location overlooking the ocean and an enthralling, interior that is a work of art in its own right, this single level home is the ultimate legacy property
$9,500,000 Last Asking Price
$7,995,000
Closing Price
$7,770,000
PPSF $1,833
Listed Date Nov 09, 2023
Contract Date Feb 23, 2024
Sold Date May 23, 2024
DOM - Days on Market
Comparable property #4
5736 La Jolla Corona Dr
Comparable property #5
San Diego, CA 92109
$7,399,999
$7,399,999
Listing description
A New Standard in Coastal Sophistication Set on newly developed Gordon Lane home to just 13 architecturally distinct residences this justcompleted property offers a rare blend of design integrity, ocean views, and calm, coastal luxury Crafted by Golba Architecture, built by Redline Custom Contracting, and finished by AGK Design Studio, every detail of the home was envisioned with intention and brought to life with elevated precision. The interiors feel as if they’ve evolved, not been assembled layered in soft greens, muted blues, and natural textures that draw from the surrounding landscape. Light pours in through large-format skylights and custom steel doors, illuminating the sculptural kitchen centered by a 60" Ilve range imported from Italy’s Veneto region. Distressed oak cabinetry, honed Calacatta Cremo marble, custom brass rail detailing, and panel-ready appliances elevate both form and function. Throughout the home, you’ll find handcrafted moments: artisan tilework, Studio McGee fixtures, custom paneling by GMJ Woodworks, and bespoke ceiling treatments in each bedroom The
Continued on next page
$7,250,000 PPSF $1,434
Listed Date Jun 05, 2025
Contract Date Oct 15, 2025
Sold Date Oct 24, 2025
Comparable property #5
San Diego, CA 92109
5150 Gordon Ln
Listing description (continued)
outdoor living is seamless and serene, with a private backyard framed for connection and calm Tucked into the foothills of Mt Soledad, just above Kate Sessions Park and minutes from La Jolla and the coastal vibrance of Pacific Beach this is a home built to stand apart Not just new Not just luxury? This is intentional living, beautifully done
Listed Date Jun 05, 2025
Contract Date Oct 15, 2025
Sold Date Oct 24, 2025
DOM - Days on Market 70
Comparable property #5
5150 Gordon Ln
Comparable property #6
San Diego, CA 92109
Listing description
Welcome to where your soul will feel at home: Gordon Lane! The legendary PB surfboard brand (Founded by Larry Gordon) justifiably gets the recognition in the best sunlight - big, wide ocean views, clear sight of the breakpoints for surf, sun and sailing days and admiring the sunsets from the only brand new community in Pacific Beach. When you waltz into this home you will immediately feel the love and care that has gone into 5115 Gordon Lane. Luxury begins with the 10’ front door and windows casing the entry walkway, 12’ ceilings and angelic floating staircase all with a stunning view of the even more impressive green, blue, custom palm leaf tile and sunken fire pit yard. Did someone say there was a hidden door to the ADU? Yes! We hired James Bond for that idea (maybe, guess you will never know until you see the disclosures!) We won’t bore you with all of the extras - they are all here; whole house speakers, salt water pool, solar, top of the line appliances, a master closet the size of your first apartment, blah blah blah The home is perfect for entertaining large parties and yet
Continued on next page
$7,000,000
Price $6,955,734 PPSF $1,343
Listed Date Oct 11, 2023
Contract Date Jan 26, 2024
Date Mar 11, 2024
Comparable property #6
San Diego, CA 92109 5115 Gordon Ln
Listing description (continued)
it’s also perfect for an intimate, quiet evening at home with your cup of coffee, or tequila, your choice When you see what is in store for you, you will will never want to leave Soak in every last sparkle of the water, light, skyline and hey! don’t miss that green flash (yes, it really exists!) The views will take your breath and your motivation for being anywhere else away before you can say, Gordon Lane!
Listed Date Oct 11, 2023
Contract Date Jan 26, 2024
Sold Date Mar 11, 2024 DOM - Days on Market
Comparable property #6
5115 Gordon Ln
Comparable property #7
San Diego, CA 92109
$6,995,000
Listing description
Stunning New Construction with Panoramic Bay, Ocean & City Views
Completed in December 2024 and never before lived in, this exquisite softMediterranean villa is perched on the view side of Gordon Lane, a brandnew street with all-new infrastructure and homes—ideally located west of Kate Sessions Park on the sunny side of Mount Soledad Spanning 4,927 sq ft, this 4-bedroom, 35-bath home blends sophisticated design with coastal elegance. The open-concept layout showcases polished marble floors, dramatic open-beam ceilings, and a striking Italian stone fireplace. A chef’s dream, the gourmet kitchen features a large granite island, premium built-in appliances, and a custom service cart for seamless entertaining. The entry-level primary suite is a private sanctuary with hardwood floors, a spa-inspired ensuite with soaking tub, dual vanities, and a designer walk-in closet complete with integrated laundry. Indooroutdoor living is effortless on this level with a 420 sq. ft. covered patio outfitted with a built-in Wolf gas BBQ, ice maker, TV, overhead heaters, and wind-blocking glass
Continued on next page
Listed Date Jul 25, 2025
Contract Date Oct 02, 2025
Date Oct 20, 2025
Comparable property #7
San Diego, CA 92109 5114 Gordon Ln
Listing description (continued)
panels perfect for year-round enjoyment Upstairs, a 413 sq ft rooftop deck offers breathtaking, unobstructed views and a cozy gas fire pit The lower level—accessible by elevator or stairs—features a spacious great room, a second fully equipped kitchen, wine cellar, fireplace, and three additional bedrooms, including a second luxurious primary suite with steam shower, walk-in closet, and private laundry.
Listed Date Jul 25, 2025
Contract Date Oct 02, 2025
Sold Date Oct 20, 2025
DOM - Days on Market 61
Comparable property #7
5114 Gordon Ln
La Jolla, CA 92037
Comparable property #9
La Jolla, CA 92037
Listing description
Views, view, views and vast square footage! With stupendous panoramic golf course and ocean views and a sought-after Country Club address, this spectacular manse includes two separate complete guest suites with kitchens, a fabulous disappearing-edge pool and spa, fairway-to-sea view terraces, patios, and lush exotic fruit plantings to include kumquat, various citrus, and avocado trees, fig varietals, and more. Vast windows bring the magnificent views into almost every room in this property and soaring cathedral ceilings offer light, bright ambience throughout. Nestled and built into the hillside to accommodate the natural lay of the land in this phenomenal environment while maximizing enjoyment of views and grounds, this property invites the buyer's own aesthetic selections to its easy move-in condition
Apr 09, 2025
Apr 17, 2025
Comparable property #9
7272 Country Club Dr
Comparable property #10
La Jolla, CA 92037
Listing description
Perched atop the exclusive Hidden Valley neighborhood, this brand-new 2024-built gated estate offers unmatched luxury and breathtaking ocean views spanning La Jolla Shores, Blacks Beach, and beyond Designed for seamless indoor-outdoor living, this single-level, open-concept masterpiece blends contemporary elegance with La Jolla’s premier coastal lifestyle Expansive floor-to-ceiling windows flood the space with natural light, framing stunning Pacific Ocean vistas. The chef’s kitchen boasts quartz waterfall countertops, a plaster range hood, brass accents, and an integrated full-size refrigerator and freezer. The primary suite is a private sanctuary with his-and-her spa baths, custom wardrobes, ample storage, and a dedicated laundry. Of the six en-suite bedrooms, one is detached with a private entrance, ideal for guests or a home office. Luxury finishes include wide-plank herringbone wood flooring, imported stone, and meticulous craftsmanship. A separate guest house ensures premium accommodations, while two lanais provide tranquil outdoor retreats. The expansive rooftop deck with a
Continued on next page
$7,500,000 Last Asking Price $7,500,000
Closing Price $7,150,000 PPSF $1,673
Listed Date May 01, 2025
Contract Date Oct 22, 2025
Sold Date Nov 17, 2025 DOM
Comparable property #10
La Jolla, CA 92037
Listing description (continued)
fire pit offers unparalleled sunset and coastline views The oversized patio features a fireplace, pool, jacuzzi, and an automatic pool cover A side yard with lush garden beds and a grass area adds to the home’s serene outdoor appeal On the garage level, a newly epoxy-coated three-car garage awaits your luxury collection, alongside a fully equipped wine cellar. Tucked behind private gates on a 12,812 sq. ft. lot, this new construction estate epitomizes La Jolla luxury real estate.
$7,150,000
$1,673
Listed Date May 01, 2025
Contract Date Oct 22, 2025
Sold Date Nov 17, 2025
DOM - Days on Market 174
Comparable property #10
2365 Via Siena
Listed Date Aug 12, 2024
Contract Date Aug 13, 2024
Date Aug 13, 2024
Comparable property #11
8656 Glenwick Ln
Comparable property #12
La Jolla, CA 92037
Listing description
Exquisite residence in La Jolla with a sophisticated design that enhances its timeless essence and ideal open layout. This spectacular light filled home spreads across on a flat large lot surrounded by lush green views. Splendor permeates throughout every detail of this astonishing home, it has 6 spacious beds and 7.5 baths, accompanied by a modern cabana equipped with BBQ, 3 TVs and private bathroom connected to the grandiose pool, spa and entertainment area. High ceilings and windows surrounding the property allow for uniform lighting throughout with refined engineering hardwood floors. This open layout promotes gatherings due to its multiple rooms
Listed Date Jun 25, 2023
Contract Date Dec 27, 2023
Date Jan 23, 2024
Comparable property #13
La Jolla, CA 92037
1126 Muirlands Vista Way
Bedrooms 6 Baths 6 Square Feet 6,077
HOA FeesYear Built 2010
Listing description
Timeless Luxury in La Jolla Muirlands! Discover the pinnacle of coastal elegance in this exceptional 6-bedroom, 6 bath, 6,077 sq ft residence nestled in the coveted La Jolla Muirlands Framed by breathtaking ocean panoramas, this home embodies the effortless sophistication and vibrant lifestyle that make La Jolla one of the world’s most desirable destinations Designed with entertaining in mind, the expansive great room opens seamlessly to a spectacular view terrace with a fire pit, creating the perfect setting for sunset gatherings. The gourmet chef’s kitchen, complete with top-of-the-line appliances and custom finishes, flows outdoors to a resort-style pool kitchen with a wood-fired pizza oven. Sparkling pool with cascading waterfall, spa, and abundant terraces offer the ultimate in relaxation and al fresco dining. Inside, rich walnut floors and refined details set a tone of timeless luxury. The primary suite is a serene retreat, featuring a spa-inspired bath with hydro-system soaking tub. With six spacious bedrooms and generous living areas, there is ample space for family and
Continued on next page
TRANSACTION INFORMATION
Original Listing Price $8,488,000 Last Asking Price $8,488,000
Closing Price $7,800,000 PPSF $1,284
Listed Date Sep 24, 2025
Contract Date Feb 02, 2026
Sold Date Feb 27, 2026
DOM - Days on Market 123
Comparable property #13
La Jolla, CA 92037
1126 Muirlands Vista Way
Listing description (continued)
guests to enjoy privacy and comfort All of this is just minutes from La Jolla’s renowned beaches, coastal trails, and the charming Village where world-class boutiques, art galleries, and restaurants await This home offers not just a residence, but a lifestyle defined by luxury, leisure, and the unparalleled beauty of La Jolla
Listed Date Sep 24, 2025
Contract Date Feb 02, 2026
Sold Date Feb 27, 2026
DOM - Days on Market 123
Comparable property #13
1126 Muirlands Vista Way
Comparable property #14
La Jolla, CA 92037
Listing description
Tucked away at the end of a private cul-de-sac in the coveted Muirlands West neighborhood, this exceptional single-level La Jolla residence blends refined design with modern convenience on nearly half an acre of beautifully landscaped grounds Every detail has been thoughtfully curated throughout this single level estate, offering a seamless balance of luxury, privacy, and functionality Step inside to expansive open living spaces bathed in natural light through oversized La Cantina sliding doors, creating a fluid connection between indoors and out. The chef’s kitchen is a true centerpiece, featuring quartzite Cristallo counters, Wolf/Sub-Zero appliances, dual wine fridges, and custom cabinetry. Wide-plank hardwood floors, designer lighting, and sophisticated finishes enhance the home’s contemporary coastal aesthetic. The primary suite provides a serene retreat with an oversized walk-in closet, spa-inspired bathroom with steam shower, soaking tub, and custom stonework. Additional highlights include an executive office, dual laundry, and whole-home smart systems with security and
Continued on next page
Listing Price $6,995,000 Last Asking Price $6,995,000
Closing PricePPSF $1,371
Listed Date Nov 17, 2025
Contract Date Dec 17, 2025
Sold DateDOM - Days on Market 26
Comparable property #14
La Jolla, CA 92037 6887
Listing description (continued)
electric shades Resort-style living continues outdoors with a brand new 42-foot saltwater pool, built-in BBQ island with Neolith counters, fire pit, putting green, and outdoor shower—all framed by lush landscaping, new hardscape, and ambient lighting
Closing PricePPSF $1,371
Listed Date Nov 17, 2025
Contract Date Dec 17, 2025
Sold DateDOM - Days on Market 26
Comparable property #14
6887 Avenida Andorra
Status comparison
Price estimate for 5780 Rutgers Road
$7,150,000 - $7,500,000
Sold listing average (13)
$7,327,749
$1,399 Per Sq Ft 76 Days on Market
Other listing average (1)
$6,995,000
$1,371 Per Sq Ft 26 Days on Market
* This represents an estimated sale price for this property. It's not the same as opinion of value in appraisal developed by a licensed appraiser under the Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal practice. The information contained herein is derived from the local MLS and does not purport to be complete nor, necessarily, accurate and should be independently verified; nor does it represent or constitute a legal analysis or financial advice. Changes in price, condition, sale, or withdrawal may be made without notice. All measurements and square footage are approximate. Equal Housing Opportunity. Compass and its affiliated real estate companies and its agents disclaim any and all liability for representations and warranties, express or implied, contained in, or for omissions from, the information contained herein or any other written or oral communication transmitted or made available to the recipient. This is not intended to solicit property already listed. Compass is a real estate broker licensed by the State of California operating under multiple entities. License Numbers 01991628, 1527235, 1527365, 1356742, 1443761, 1997075, 1935359, 1961027, 1842987, 1869607, 1866771, 1527205, 1079009, 1272467.
