INSIDE: COMPETITIVE CATFISHING
M O N TANA FISH, WILD L IF E & PA R KS | $3 . 50
HARVEST OR RELEASE?
RECONSIDERING A SANCTIFIED PRACTICE
IN THIS ISSUE:
BACK TO THE CAVERNS BIRDS AREN’T RUINING OUR FISHING SHARED SACRIFICE ON THE BIG HOLE APPRECIATING THE LANDOWNER’S PERSPECTIVE
MAY–J UNE 2020
MONTANA OUTDOORS VOLUME 51, NUMBER 3 STATE OF MONTANA Steve Bullock, Governor MONTANA FISH, WILDLIFE & PARKS Martha Williams, Director FIRST PLACE MAGAZINE: 2005, 2006, 2008, 2011, 2017, 2018 Association for Conservation Information
MONTANA OUTDOORS STAFF Tom Dickson, Editor Luke Duran, Art Director Angie Howell, Circulation Manager
MONTANA FISH AND WILDLIFE COMMISSION Tim Aldrich Logan Brower Pat Byorth Shane Colton Richard Stuker MONTANA STATE PARKS AND RECREATION BOARD Angie Grove, Chair Jeff Welch Mary Sheehy Moe Betty Stone Scott Brown
Montana Outdoors (ISSN 0027-0016) is published bimonthly by Montana Fish, Wildlife & Parks in partnership with our subscribers. Subscription rates are $12 for one year, $20 for two years, and $27 for three years. (Please add $3 per year for Canadian subscriptions. All other foreign subscriptions, airmail only, are $48 for one year.) Individual copies and back issues cost $4.50 each (includes postage). Although Montana Outdoors is copyrighted, permission to reprint articles is available by writing our office or phoning us at (406) 495-3257. All correspondence should be addressed to: Montana Outdoors, Montana Fish, Wildlife & Parks, 930 West Custer Avenue, P.O. Box 200701, Helena, MT 59620-0701. Website: fwp.mt.gov/mtoutdoors. Email: montanaoutdoors@mt.gov. ©2020, Montana Fish, Wildlife & Parks. All rights reserved. For address changes or subscription information call 800-678-6668. In Canada call 1+ 406-495-3257 Postmaster: Send address changes to Montana Outdoors, Montana Fish, Wildlife & Parks, P.O. Box 200701, Helena, MT 59620-0701. Preferred periodicals postage paid at Helena, MT 59601, and additional mailing offices.
CONTENTS
MAY–JUNE 2020 FEATURES
12 Give a Big Hand for the Big Hole Applauding the consensus-based, collaborative approach to conserving this premier southwestern Montana trout and grayling river. By Tom Reed
20 Catfish Crazy For the past 20 years, Glasgow has stayed up late the first Saturday in June to celebrate the Catfish Classic and the Milk River’s remarkable channel cat fishery. By Andrew McKean. Photos by John Warner
26 Has Catch-andRelease Gone Overboard? The case for harvesting more trout. By Tom Dickson
20
32 Living Limestone Revisiting the ever-changing geological wonders of Lewis & Clark Caverns, Montana’s first state park. By Julie Lue. Photos by Braden Gunem
40 Blaming the Birds Are pelicans, cormorants, and other winged piscivores harming game fish populations? By Jack Ballard
DEPARTMENTS
2 LETTERS 3 TASTING MONTANA Simple and Fancy Fried Trout 4 OUR POINT OF VIEW Appreciating Landowners INTO THE WONDERGROUND Visitors follow a guide through the entrance of world-famous Lewis & Clark Caverns, one of Montana’s most popular state parks. Turn to page 32 to see what they discovered. Photo by Braden Gunem. FRONT COVER Does releasing fish always make sense? See our story starting on page 26 to learn why some fisheries might be better off with more harvest. Photo by Pat Clayton/Engbretson Underwater Photography
5 FWP AT WORK Ladd Knotek, Fisheries Biologist 6 SNAPSHOTS 10 OUTDOORS REPORT 44 SKETCHBOOK Reassurance 45 OUTDOORS PORTRAIT American Avocet MONTANA OUTDOORS | 1
LETTERS Recommended reading I’ve always enjoyed reading this great magazine, but your MarchApril 2020 edition was exceptional. I usually read your Tasting Montana page first, have tried many of the recipes, and they have increased my ability to cook gourmet meals using wild game. The article on raptors [“16 Raptors That Every Montanan Should (Kinda) Know”] was beneficial and timely because I recently challenged myself to improve my identification skills. Lastly, the Sketchbook column titled “Looking Down” was a reminder of my need to remain observant when afield. I’ve found that the more I see and understand, the more I love and feel a part of Montana. Keep up the great work. Mike Getman Lewistown
What a great issue. I enjoyed learning about the natural history of fishers, reestablishing trumpeter swans, and the editor’s quest to spot spring wildflowers on Mount Helena. The recipe (Venison Carbonnade) looks delicious, and we are planning to prepare it using some locally grown lamb we have in the freezer. Our days of traveling back to Montana are probably over, but we sure do enjoy every copy of the magazine.
the only place in the world where that happens? Kendall Smith Boise, ID
early February. They leave when the weather starts cooling down, which around here is usually in October. Lee Ann Jones Collensville, OK
AIS Mystery Boater? I read with interest the “Plugging the Leaks” article in the March-April issue on how a boat from Chicago carrying invasive mussels escaped detection at two Montana AIS check stations.
The solution was what they called the Gates Mystery Man, who traveled the country with a frayed and worn belt.”
I have passed the Anaconda watercraft inspection station many Harry Johnson times. Each time I think, “What Redwood Falls, MN a difficult job. The hours are long, and considerable time can pass between boats. It must be Sooner State robins My husband and I enjoyed the hard to stay alert, even though it essay by Emma Marris on robins is an important job protecting (“Welcome Back, Stranger,” the safety of Montana valuable March-April). Every summer waterways.” The challenge at those staour yard is filled with robins. We always look forward to their tions reminds me of my college arrival in early spring. This year days in the 1960s, when I worked we were pleasantly surprised to in a gas station. Back then gas see 30 to 40 robins feasting on stations were full service. Besides earthworms in our back yard in filling the tank, we checked the 2 | MAY–JUNE 2020 | FWP.MT.GOV/MTOUTDOORS
oil and fan belts. It was especially hard to remember the fan belts, as they were hard to see and usually did not need to be changed. The solution by the Gates Belt Company was what they called the Gates Mystery Man, who traveled the country with a frayed and worn belt. If a gas station attendant caught him, they got a reward of $25. The station I worked for would match that amount, so it was well worth our time to be vigilant and check
those belts. Could a similar idea work at the AIS check stations? I can think of all kinds of other creative ways to keep inspectors on their toes and give rewards. Just a thought. Gary Swant Deer Lodge
Montana’s odd connection with eastern Canada I especially liked the article on the Continental Divide (“The Great Divide,” July-August 2019) but had never before heard of Triple Divide Peak. Is it
The editor replies: Several readers wrote asking for more information on that geographical oddity, about 15 miles south of St. Mary. Triple Divide Peak is where the east–west Laurentian Divide connects to the north–south Continental Divide in Glacier National Park. In answer to Mr. Smith’s question, Triple Divide Peak is one of only a few places in the world where streams feeding three major watersheds originate. Snowmelt and rain go in three directions from the summit: southwest through the park to the Flathead, Clark Fork, and Columbia Rivers before emptying into the Pacific Ocean; southeast to Cut Bank Creek, then to the Marias, Missouri, and Mississippi Rivers to the Gulf of Mexico; and north into Hudson Bay Creek, through the two St. Mary’s Lakes, into St. Mary’s River, then up into the Saskatchewan River system northeast to Hudson Bay. The Saskatchewan Watershed hydrologically connects a tiny portion of Montana with much of eastern Canada. It’s not surprising then that Montana is home to four native fish species originally found only in the tiny triangle formed by the Saskatchewan River watershed where it lies within our state border: northern pike, lake whitefish, deepwater sculpin, and trout-perch. Some, like the northern pike, have since been distributed in other waters. Correction The bird we identified as a golden eagle on the bottom of page 25 of the article “16 Raptors That Every Montanan Should (Kinda) Know,” (March-April 2020) is actually an immature bald eagle. We’re still learning.
TASTING MONTANA
Simple and Fancy Fried Trout Preparation time: 15 minutes I Cooking time: 30 minutes I Serves 4
This recipe for four small trout is based on a popular recipe by the Food Network’s Anne Burrell. Halve the ingredients for two trout. INGREDIENTS 1½ c. bread crumbs 1 clove garlic, smashed 2 t. dried oregano Pinch crushed red pepper flakes 2 lemons, juiced, and the zest of 1 lemon Salt ½ c. Dijon mustard 4 (10- to 12-ounce) trout, cleaned, rinsed, and dried with paper towels Extra-virgin olive oil or vegetable oil 1 T. butter
M
aybe one reason so few anglers keep trout anymore is that they don’t know how to clean and cook fish. That’s what one FWP biologist suggested while reviewing the article “Has Catch-and-Release Gone Overboard?” (page 26). There are other reasons, most notably the success of catchand-release in protecting fish populations from overharvest. Yet biologists say that some populations could actually grow larger fish if more anglers kept a few smaller ones to eat. If you’re new to harvesting trout for their organic protein (talk about “wildcaught” seafood!), their delicious taste, and the benefits to fish population size structure, here’s how it’s done: u
Make a clean kill by firmly holding the fish belly side up in both hands and bringing the back of the head down crisply against a streamside rock or boat gunnel. If you are wading, keep the fish as cool as possible by placing it in the stream (anchored by a stringer or a few rocks to keep it from floating away). Or put it in a cooler with ice in your boat or vehicle.
u
To clean a trout, turn it upside down and insert the tip of a small knife into the anal vent. Cut a deep slit all the way to and through the lower jaw. Pull out the intestines and, with the knife tip or your thumbnail, scrape away the bloodline along the spine. Pull or cut off the red gills. Give the cavity a brief wash. Keep the fish cool until ready to cook.
SHUTTERSTOCK
u
The easiest way to cook trout when backpacking is to sprinkle dried cajun or seafood seasoning over the fish and in the cavity. Drizzle on a little oil, if you have some. Wrap the fish in aluminum foil, then put it on a campfire grill or coals for a few minutes on each side. The simplest method at home is to dry the fish with paper towels, dip it in a wash of one egg beaten with 1 T. water, then coat it in flour seasoned with salt and pepper. Fry in oil until both sides turn golden brown. Serve with a lemon slice. For something fancier, try the recipe at right. —Tom Dickson is editor of Montana Outdoors.
DIRECTIONS On a large plate, combine the bread crumbs, garlic, oregano, red pepper flakes, lemon zest, and salt to taste. In a small bowl, mix the mustard and juice of one lemon. Brush both sides of the trout with mustard mixture. Coat the fish on both sides with the seasoned bread crumbs and press firmly to adhere the crumbs to the fish. Preheat the oven to 250 degrees F. Coat a large skillet with ½ inch of oil and place over medium-high heat. When the oil is hot, add the fish, skin side down, and cook 6 minutes. Flip the fish and cook the other side 2 minutes until golden brown and crispy. Drain fish on paper towels then place in a rack in the oven to keep warm. You will likely need to work in two batches to do four fish. Discard the oil and wipe out any brown bits from the pan with a paper towel. Add the butter and remaining lemon juice and swirl to combine as the butter melts. Season with salt, to taste, and reduce by about half. Transfer the fish to a serving platter, drizzle with the butter lemon sauce, and serve. u Another delicious recipe is Sesame-Crusted
Pan-Fried Trout from our May-June 2017 issue: http://fwp.mt.gov/mtoutdoors/HTML/articles/ recipes/sesametrout.htm. MONTANA OUTDOORS | 3
OUR POINT OF VIEW
Appreciating landowners
4 | MAY–JUNE 2020 | FWP.MT.GOV/MTOUTDOORS
It’s a given that the public trust concept requires landowners to tolerate a certain level of crop loss or inconvenience from wildlife. But if the public trust concept asks this of landowners, then we must not take their tolerance for granted. We need to recognize that landowners are a vital part of the public trust equation. Acknowledging this in no way subverts the public trust or the North American Model of Wildlife Conservation, as some people claim. If anything, it strengthens both. We cannot sustain the wildlife populations we’ve so long enjoyed without farmers and ranchers. We need their help maintaining wildlife connectivity and protecting habitat on their property. We need their support at the state capitol for wildlife-friendly policies and programs. We need their generosity to provide places to hunt for the majority of people who don’t own land. I constantly meet landowners who understand that wildlife
I want to make clear to all Montana landowners that we appreciate you, and we appreciate how hard it can be to have wildlife on your property. diversity, including predators, is an essential element of the Montana landscape and a large part of what makes this state unique. They take pride in helping steward that wildlife. They recognize that hunting is part of our rich Montana heritage and accept the responsibility of allowing some access to the wildlife on their property. FWP is charged with the stewardship of Montana’s wildlife. We and the wildlife conservation community regularly ask landowners to listen to our concerns, and we’ll continue to do so. But the road runs both ways. If we want ranchers and farmers to respect our perspective, we need to respect theirs in turn by putting ourselves in their boots and seeing the world—especially burgeoning wildlife populations—through their eyes. —Martha Williams, Director, Montana Fish, Wildlife & Parks
NATE HOWARD
E
arlier this year I visited Havre and Malta to attend Block Management “cooperator appreciation” dinners. Each spring, FWP holds these events across Montana to thank landowners for participating in the program, which opens millions of acres of private property to public hunting. As always at these dinners, I met many wonderful people and heard funny and heart-warming stories about ranching and farming life. On the drive home, I started thinking about “appreciation,” and how it applies not only to Block Management cooperators but to all Montana landowners who share their land with wildlife. As noted in my previous Director’s Messages, a defining characteristic of the United States is that we view wildlife as part of commonly shared resources known as the public trust. The framework of laws and guiding principles that came out of the public trust concept—including the Migratory Bird Treaty Act, Endangered Species Act, and North American Model of Wildlife Conservation—have led to remarkable recoveries of elk, pronghorn, bighorn sheep, Canada geese, bald eagles, wolves, grizzly bears, and more. While we celebrate those success stories and treasure the public trust concept that led to them, we also need to recognize the strain that expanding wildlife populations sometimes put on Montana’s ranchers, farmers, and rural communities. Deer ravage hay bales and vegetable gardens. Elk consume crops, trample fences, and carry brucellosis that could infect cattle. Geese descend on crop fields. Wolves prey on sheep and cattle, or, at a minimum, cause stress that reduces livestock weight and disease tolerance. Then there’s Montana’s growing number of grizzly bears. Yes, these are magnificent animals, symbols of wildness and rugged independence. But some are also troublemakers that raid beehives and orchards, break into outbuildings, harass or even kill livestock, and wander too close to where people work and live. Add to all this the ramifications of hunters pursuing Montana’s restored game populations on private property: litter in parking areas, gates left open, trucks that chew up muddy roads and drive across “walk-in-only” areas, shot-up signs and farm equipment, phone calls and knocks on the front door that start before dawn and last all day. All while landowners and their families are trying to steward their land or livestock. I want to make clear to all Montana landowners that we appreciate you, and we appreciate how hard it can sometimes be to have wildlife on your property. We appreciate that your land serves as vital habitat for wildlife and native plants. We appreciate the responsibilities you shoulder as stewards of your land. Many of us in FWP grew up on farms or ranches. We understand your concerns about wildlife depredation, property rights, and trespass. We know many of you appreciate Montana’s wildlife—even grizzly bears—just as everyone else does, but that you have to balance that admiration with earning a living and protecting your family’s safety.
TOMMY MARTINO
FWP AT WORK
HABITAT GUARDIAN ALL FWP FISHERIES BIOLOGISTS monitor native and sport fish populations, work to protect and restore aquatic habitat, conduct public outreach, and complete administrative tasks like stream permitting and fishing regulation revisions. What’s great about working for FWP is that we’re allowed to tailor the proportion of these responsibilities to our particular work area. That gives us the chance to be flexible and accomplish things that matter most for the residents and natural resources in each community. When people think of a fish biologist, they might envision someone pulling nets from a reservoir or wading a stream with a backpack shocker, as shown in this picture. We definitely do those things, but we also conduct stream permit inspections and attend conservation district meetings. These administrative activities protect fisheries habitat, and it’s some of the most important and lasting work we do. I work in Missoula and other parts of western Montana where there is a lot of construction, expanding development, and a rapidly growing human population. These pressures can threaten lakes,
LADD KNOTEK FWP Fisheries Biologist, Missoula
rivers, and streams. Thankfully, Montana has strong stream and aquatic resource protection laws like the 1975 Natural Streambed and Land Preservation Act (310 Law) and 1963 Stream Protection Act (124 Law). These provide legal tools used to balance development with resource protection and help lessen unintended damage to wild places and fisheries. Although I enjoy working on the stream restoration and enhancement parts of my job, I actually accomplish far more for streams and fish populations by reviewing 310 and 124 stream permit applications and working with local conservation districts and floodplain administrators. Unfortunately, most of their work goes unnoticed. What they do is prevent bad things from happening to streams or lessen the damage that comes from development. That’s something you can’t see. The next time you drive past the Blackfoot, Bitterroot, or other river or stream, bear in mind that one reason it looks so good and is producing so many fish is because of Montana’s environmental protection laws and the people who administer them. MONTANA OUTDOORS | 5
SNAPSHOT
In the spring of 2019, Jacelyn Bronte of Bozeman spotted a pair of nesting sandhill cranes at a wetland just north of town. She visited the birds regularly for the next few weeks. After the pair hatched two eggs, Bronte says she spent “hours and hours” photographing the family from about 20 yards away with a 200–500 mm telephoto lens. Known as “colts,” sandhill chicks often climb up onto a resting parent to stay warm in the feathers. “What I like about this shot is the relationship between the mom and the colt. It was just the second day after hatching, and already it could climb right up there,” says Bronte, who works as a clinical psychologist when she’s not photographing wildlife. Bronte lost track of the family after it moved to denser cattail stands to avoid dogs and walkers using a nearby trail. “But then a month later I heard from a National Geographic videographer who’d been filming them that both colts were still alive,” she says. n 6 | MAY–JUNE 2020 | FWP.MT.GOV/MTOUTDOORS
MONTANA OUTDOORS | 7
SNAPSHOT
“It’s the end of the road in the most remote place you can imagine,” says Glasgow photographer Sean R. Heavey of his photograph titled “Welcome to Bonetrail.” Heavey visited the site, roughly 50 miles (as the crow flies) southwest of Glasgow, early last summer with Glasgow Courier editor A.J. Etherington (seen in the blue shirt along the right-hand bluff) in search of scenic vistas and story opportunities. “In western Montana, it’s the mountains that are majestic, but here 8 | MAY–JUNE 2020 | FWP.MT.GOV/MTOUTDOORS
in eastern Montana it’s the way the sky interacts with the land that builds the majesty,” Heavey says of the photograph. “What I also like about this image is how your eye goes through the opening in the bluff then drops down to discover the lake in the background, like it’s a hidden gem. That’s what Fort Peck is. It’s not like Flathead or other lakes, where you can look at it from the highway. To see Fort Peck, you need to practically drive to the end of the earth.” n MONTANA OUTDOORS | 9
OUTDOORS REPORT
1974
The year that Montana stopped stocking rivers and switched to wild trout management, the first state to do so.
Campers who transport firewood long distances could endanger Montana forests and urban trees, according to natural resources agencies. People who cut or gather firewood then take it with them when camping or traveling, especially across state lines, could introduce pine beetles, emerald ash borers, gypsy moths, and other harmful invasive insects to native trees that have no natural defenses. For instance, emerald ash borers first showed up in North America in Michigan in 2002. The beetles have since spread to 35 states and five Canadian provinces in infested firewood, killing tens of millions of ash trees. August Kramer, forest pest specialist for the Montana Department of Natural Resources and Conservation in Missoula, says the most important thing campers can do to prevent the spread of invasive insects is to purchase or gather firewood at or near where they plan to burn it, rather than transporting it from home. “If buying firewood, make sure it’s cut from Montana forests. Or gather firewood near your camping area if it’s legal to do so,” Kramer adds. For additional information, visit dontmove firewood.org/.
10 | MAY–JUNE 2020 | FWP.MT.GOV/MTOUTDOORS
Now unprotected, temporary wetlands are critical for ducks and other wildlife. HABITAT THREATS
EPA water ruling undermines wetland and stream protection
T
he Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) announced earlier this year that it had redefined which waters are eligible for protection under the Clean Water Act. The change leaves important fish and wildlife habitat vulnerable to pollution and significant harm, national conservation leaders say. In a widely published op-ed, Chris Wood, president of Trout Unlimited; Collin O’Mara, president of the National Wildlife Federation; and Dale Hall, former director of the U.S. Fish & Wildlife Service, denounced the recent EPA decision as “ill informed” and “flat wrong on every level.” They say the new rule will leave roughly half of the nation’s wetlands and almost one out of five of its stream miles without federal protection from pollution. In drier western states, as many as 90 percent of stream miles will lose pollution protections. Agribusiness groups, fossil fuel producers, and real estate developers long opposed the Obama-era “Waters of the United States” (WOTUS) rules, claiming the rules shackled
them with onerous and unnecessary burdens. The EPA’s replacement, called the “Navigable Waters Protection Rule,” rolls back key portions of a 2015 rule that guaranteed protections (under the 1972 Clean Water Act) to certain wetlands and streams that flow intermittently or run temporarily underground. It also relieves landowners of the need to seek certain permits. “Research by Trout Unlimited suggests that more than 6 million miles of streams— half the total in the United States—will now be unprotected by the Clean Water Act, because they flow only after rainfall,” wrote Wood, O’Mara, and Hall. “More than 42 million acres of wetlands—again, about half the country’s total—will no longer be protected because they are not immediately adjacent to larger waters. In the Great Plains, the EPA will no longer conserve freshwater marshes known as prairie potholes that fill with water in the spring and provide critical, timely habitat for more than half of North America’s migratory waterfowl,” they added. n
CLOCKWISE FROM TOP LEFT: CARTOON BY MIKE MORAN; SHUTTERSTOCK; MONTANA FWP
Burn it where you buy it
OUTDOORS REPORT FISH APPRECIATION
New app answers “What fish is that?”
M
PAPER LICENSES
MONTANA STATE UNIVERSITY/LUKE DURAN/MONTANA OUTDOORS
ost anglers can identify a handful of the 90 fish species swimming in Montana: rainbow trout, brown trout, mountain whitefish, walleye, yellow perch, goldeneye, and maybe one of the state’s two cutthroat trout species. But that’s about it. Very few can tell a carp from a carpsucker or a peamouth from a pikeminnow. That’s changing fast, however. Montana State University (MSU) recently
released its Fishes of Montana app, which makes it easy for students, anglers, and others to identify species as soon as they are caught. The app can be downloaded for free on Android and iOS handheld devices thanks to a $10,000 grant from Patagonia. Once downloaded, Fishes of Montana requires no cellular coverage or wireless connection. Let’s say you’re fishing the lower Yellowstone River and land a slender, dark fish you can’t identify. While allowing the fish to stay in the water, you take out your phone, click on the app, and go to “Search by Characteristics.” The app provides options for various physical traits. In this hypothetical case: “Fins” (your fish has a single dorsal fin), “Tail” (forked), “Adipose Fin” (absent), “Mouth” (downward facing), and “Barbels” (not apparent). Now the app shows images of three species swimming in that part of eastern Montana that fit your description. One of them appears to be the fish you caught: a blue sucker. Voila! Fishes of Montana contains a complete species list that includes common and scientific names, and notes whether a species is native or introduced, and whether it is a threatened species or a game fish. The app also displays a glossary, maps of major drainages, diagrams
Starting in 2020, FWP switched to paper hunting and fishing licenses, permits, and carcass tags, replacing previous plastic-paper versions. Hunters and anglers can now print licenses that don’t require tags from their home printers when they buy them online and can store those licenses on their smartphones. FWP mails out the carcass tags, which also are now printed on paper.
of fish anatomy, and links to additional resources. The app was produced by MSU researchers with technical assistance from Montana Fish, Wildlife & Parks field biologists. MountainWorks developed the app, and Conservation BenchMarks managed the project. Both companies are based in Bozeman. Correct species identification is critical for fish conservation. For instance, anglers need to know the difference between brook trout and similar-looking young bull trout, a federally protected species. And between shovelnose sturgeon and pallid sturgeon, another protected fish. It’s also just Harvest limits fun to know often differ bewhich species tween cutthroat trout and simiare swimming lar-looking rainin the waters bow trout, and where you fish.” between walleye and sauger. “It’s also just fun to know which species are swimming in the waters where you fish,” says David Schmetterling, FWP Fisheries Research Program coordinator in Missoula. For anglers who are unable to identify a species or want to share information, the app contains a direct email link to Schmetterling inviting them to attach photos. “What I especially like about the way Fishes of Montana was developed is how it promotes communication between the people using the app and those of us out here managing and conserving Montana’s fisheries,” he says. n
FWP made the switch so customers can obtain licenses at their convenience. Also, the thermal printers that produced the old plastic-paper licenses had become obsolete and were no longer able to print hot enough to secure lettering to the plastic. To ensure that a paper carcass tag stays attached to an animal, hunters can place it in a Baggies-type bag (or laminate it) and then secure it as usual. n MONTANA OUTDOORS | 11
MONTANA RIVERS
Give a Big Hand for the
Big Hole Applauding the consensus-based, collaborative approach to conserving this premier southwestern Montana trout and grayling river. BY TOM REED
12 | MAY–JUNE 2020 | FWP.MT.GOV/MTOUTDOORS
STUNNING The Big Hole Valley is so vast and scenic that it’s impossible to ignore, even in a state where picturesque rivers are commonplace. The upper section, shown here, is characterized by a sea of pasture and hay fields bisected by one of the world’s most famous trout rivers. PHOTO BY KEN TAKATA
MONTANA OUTDOORS | 13
MONTANA RIVERS
T
For hundreds of years the Flathead, or Salish, occupied the valley, which they called Iskumtselalik Pah (“the place of ground squirrels”). Lewis and Clark and other EuropeanAmericans first reached the valley in the early 1800s, and a Mexican trapper named Emanuel Martin brought the first wagons there in the early 1850s. Miners found gold and silver in Big Hole headwaters and arrived in force during the 1860s and ’70s. They built impressive stamp mills and smelters, road networks, and small communities like Glendale—now a ghost town just west of Melrose. Cattlemen came here too, first in the lower valley and then, attracted by a sea of wild hay, to the upper valley. Eventually, a handful of homesteaders braved the area’s long and brutally cold winters and settled. Many modern-day ranching the fishery and rural culture requires families are descendants of those tough and respecting each other’s perspective and determined pioneers. Today, the Big Hole River and surroundfinding ways to work together. “What it ultimately boils down to is what those of us ing high mountain valley appear and funchere call ‘shared sacrifice, shared success,’” tion much as they did in those early says Pedro Marques, executive director of pioneer days, thanks in part to the area’s the Big Hole Watershed Committee, a local remote location and two traditional ranching practices—beaver-slide haystacks and conservation group. flood irrigation—still used in this “Valley of 10,000 Haystacks.” Credit also goes to local “PLACE OF THE GROUND SQUIRRELS” People have been visiting and living along and regional residents, anglers, and outfitthe Big Hole River for thousands of years. ters who take deep pride in the river itself. There is no archaeological evidence that The Big Hole remains one of the most Indian tribes fished the river, but they cer- pristine trout rivers in the West and, coupled tainly hunted bison, elk, and small game. with an unforgettable panorama, among
But one river is impossible to unconsciously ignore: the Big Hole. You don’t “drive up” or “drive down” the Big Hole Valley as on most rivers. You come into it, much as you’d enter a vast theater surrounded by a gawk-worthy IMAX screen. The vistas are equally spectacular to the east, north, south, and west. No matter how, or how often, you encounter the Big Hole, you pay attention every time. On a map, the Big Hole is that giant open spot in the middle of southwestern Montana, a huge valley surrounded by mountains through which the river flows north, then south, then north again. The Big Hole’s puzzling name, hardly indicative of the breathtaking scenery, came from trappers who worked the West’s vast rivers in search of beaver and called some of these big valleys “holes.” Though initially settled by rugged individualists, the Big Hole’s sustained success as a world-class fishery surrounded by a thriving ranching economy is primarily the result of communal action. Big Hole ranchers, anglers, outfitters, and others often disagree. But as on the Blackfoot, Musselshell, Clark Fork, and other Montana rivers where diverse interests find common ground, they acknowledge that protecting The author of Give Me Mountains for My Horses and several other books, Tom Reed lives with his family on their ranch outside Pony. 14 | MAY–JUNE 2020 | FWP.MT.GOV/MTOUTDOORS
EARLY HOMESTEADERS By 1914, when this photo was taken, families had established themselves in the upper Big Hole Valley, attracted by abundant water and vast tracts of wild hay.
ARCHIVES AND SPECIAL COLLECTIONS, MANSFIELD LIBRARY, UNIVERSITY OF MONTANA
hose who live among beauty too often grow oblivious to the loveliness around them. Here in Montana, it’s common for residents to drive along any of the state’s famous trout rivers on a late summer evening and forget to look up from the road and past a windshield splattered by the evening’s hatch. The water and mountains become peripheral, like the walls of a personal tunnel.
irrigators watering fields of alfalfa. Olsen says this lower stretch contains miles of remote river without access and offers anglers their best chance of hooking a five-pound rainbow or brown: “People catch some monsters down there.”
TOP TO BOTTOM: BUTTE-SILVER BOW CHAMBER OF COMMERCE VISITOR CENTER; STEVEN AKRE
HAIL TO THE CHIEF No one was more central to Big Hole River conservation and fly-fishing than George Grant. The Butte native, born in 1906, advocated for the river throughout the 1970s with a newsletter he edited called the River Rat. The River Rat later became the official publication of Montana Trout Unlimited and helped raise public consciousness and support for water conservation issues on the Big Hole and other rivers. The “Chief Rat,” as Grant called himself, was also an internationally known fly tier whose patterns combined woven-hair hackles with bodies of flat mono-nylon to replicate stonefly nymphs. The local Trout Unlimited chapter is named after Grant, who died in 2008.
the world’s most famous. Jim Olsen entered this storied landscape in 2008 as the Montana Fish, Wildlife & Parks fisheries biologist. “Honestly, I was a bit nervous about the whole prospect,” Olsen says. “My first goal was simply not to screw anything up.” This, after all, was the home water of angling and conservation legends like George Grant and Tony Schoonen, who spent their lives on the river, learning its mysteries and fighting to protect flows, water quality, and fish populations. Grant and Schoonen were conservation trailblazers who helped focus national attention from Trout Unlimited (TU) and other groups on the Big Hole and its tributaries. Olsen says the Big Hole comprises three distinct sections as it flows roughly 115 miles from the Beaverhead Mountains southwest of Jackson to its confluence with the Ruby and Beaverhead Rivers near Twin Bridges to form the Jefferson. The upper river down to the Fish Trap Fishing Access Site is a mellow, high-meadow stream. Here anglers find brook trout, westslope cutthroats, and fluvial (river) Arctic grayling— a species once proposed for federal endangered species listing—and a few
browns and rainbows. From Fish Trap past Divide to Melrose, the Big Hole speeds up, challenging floaters with large rapids and granite boulders beneath steep cliffs. “Rainbows and browns dominate the pocket water in this stretch,” Olsen says. The final reach from Melrose to what locals call “Bridges” slows a bit as the river flows through semiarid canyons and past pivot
WAKE-UP CALL The Big Hole has a long history of conservation activism. In the 1960s, local ranchers and anglers galvanized to oppose the Bureau of Reclamation’s proposed Reichle Dam, which would have inundated 18 miles of river. Big Hole advocates, mostly anglers from Butte, also helped pass Montana’s Stream Protection Act (1963), Natural Streambed and Land Preservation Act (1975), and Stream Access Law (1986). A pivotal year for Big Hole conservation was 1988. As Yellowstone National Park burned during the long, hot summer, parts of the Big Hole went dry for nearly a month near the town of Wisdom. Grayling numbers, already dwindling from stream habitat degradation and low water throughout the 1980s, plummeted. In one stretch near Wisdom, grayling numbers per mile dropped from 111 to 22. One reason for the river’s chronic low flows was drought; the other was diversion of water to irrigate pasture and alfalfa. For ranchers like Randy Smith, the severe drought in 1988 and another in 1994 were a wake-up call. “We didn’t want to be blamed for diverting all the water and killing
STEAKS AND SALMONIDS The main issue in the Big Hole Valley is water allocation. In years past, portions of the upper river and key spawning tributaries went completely dry.
MONTANA OUTDOORS | 15
all the fish, particularly grayling,” he says. and eat shade-producing streamside vegeSmith and other Big Hole ranchers decided tation. “Right from the start we decided to to take steps to keep more water in the river. do things by consensus,” Smith says. “We “We tried to come up with a plan to include fashioned the process so if somebody had other interests because there was a future in a problem with something, they needed to being able to talk about things and not piss be part of the solution, too. The business of each other off,” Smith says. voting [with majority rule] and telling The result was the Big Hole Watershed someone they lose just doesn’t work.” Committee (BHWC), which today includes The “shared sacrifice” philosophy emranchers, business owners, outfitters, county braced by BHWC members has meant that commissioners, water utilities, and trout while ranchers are asked to voluntarily reanglers. With a paid staff of five, the BHWC duce irrigation withdrawals during critical (motto: “Conservation Through Consen- low-water periods, anglers and outfitters are sus”) coordinates restoration projects on required to reduce or even stop fishing. headwater streams damaged by historic “Everyone works together and gives up mining activity, works with the Montana something to benefit the river’s fishery,” Department of Environmental Quality on Olsen says. maintaining clean water, and monitors water flow and temperature. BALANCING ACT The committee also maintains a phone- While the watershed committee focuses on tree among ranchers who, when the river maintaining healthy river flows, Olsen figdrops and warms in late summer and early ures out ways to keep both native and nonfall, ask neighbors to use less water so fish native salmonid species healthy and as can survive. New wells, drilled in part with abundant as possible. “Sometimes there’s a federal conservation funds, provide stock conflict between the two, like when we have tanks that keep cattle away from the river to remove non-native brook trout to restore and tributaries, where they trample banks westslope cutthroats in a tributary,” Olsen
says. “But that’s only in a few streams.” Most of the time FWP has been able to manage both the rainbows and browns that anglers prize as well as the cutthroats and grayling that the Montana legislature mandated the department protect so they don’t become federally endangered. The key to FWP’s management is tracking fish populations, using electrofishing and surveys of angler catches. “Rainbow numbers have almost doubled in the last few years from Glen downstream to Twin Bridges,” Olsen says. One reason may be the work FWP and cooperating landowners have done to boost water flows and restore spawning habitat on several Jefferson River tributaries. “We suspect that increasing numbers of rainbows are finding their way upriver from the Jeff to the Big Hole,” Olsen says. In cooperation with the BHWC, FWP crews also protect and restore Big Hole spawning tributaries, which produce all of the water and most of the fish in the main river. One ranch in the valley that modernized its irrigation system now uses just 3 cubic feet per second (cfs) of tributary
BIG HOLE RIVER One of the world’s most famous trout rivers, the Big Hole flows for roughly 115 miles from the Beaverhead Mountains southwest of Jackson to the confluence of the Ruby and Beaverhead Rivers near Twin Bridges to form the Jefferson.
Butte
State or BLM Water Access Site
The Big Hole’s upper section extends from Jackson downstream (north) to Fish Trap Fishing Access Site. This stretch is a mellow, high-meadow stream with grassy banks where anglers can catch brook trout, westslope cutthroats, Arctic grayling, and the occasional brown and rainbow.
Jackson 16 | MAY–JUNE 2020 | FWP.MT.GOV/MTOUTDOORS
Melrose
Glen
Notch Bottom Apex
Riv er Silver Star
Twin Bridges
LOWER SECTION
gH ole River
Je
he er v a Be
Ri by Ru
In the middle section from Fish Trap past Divide to Melrose, the river widens, picks up speed, and rushes among large boulders. Known as the Canyon Stretch, this section, dominated by browns and rainbows, is where the famous June salmonfly hatch takes place.
Divide
Whitehall
ffe rs on
Wise River
Riv er
UPPER SECTION
The lower section runs from Melrose to Twin Bridges. This “Bridges” section is slower and flows through semiarid canyons. The local FWP fisheries biologist says this is the best spot to hook a 5-pound brown or rainbow. “People catch some monsters down there,” he says.
MIDDLE SECTION
Bi
D EA RH NS E V I BEA UNTA MO
Wisdom
r ve Ri
Dickie Bridge
ad
Big H
UPPER SECTION
ol e
Fish Trap
ve r
Sheridan
LEFT TO RIGHT: LUKE DURAN/MONTANA OUTDOORS; LISA BALLARD
DELICATE JEWEL The upper Big Hole holds the last population of fluvial (river-dwelling) Arctic grayling in the lower 48 states. Cooperative conservation agreements between the federal government and local landowners have kept enough water in the river to prevent extinction.
water instead of 15 cfs; the rest flows back than brookies, and many anglers also like partnership with the state of Montana to the Big Hole. catching native fish in these small streams and the U.S. Fish & Wildlife Service. In Another project restored a half-mile reach and headwater lakes.” exchange for undertaking conservation of French Creek. The project, championed measures, the agreements exempt landby the Anaconda Sportsmen’s AVERTING DOOM owners from several federal regulations in Club, re-routed the stream The biggest fisheries the future if grayling are listed as endanaway from an area prone to challenge for Olsen gered. CCAA conservation measures inOverall, they’ve bank erosion to one with abunand other coldwater clude removing barriers blocking grayling dant streamside vegetation and increased somewhat conservationists in migration, maintaining minimum river little erosion. The restoration the Big Hole water- flows for fish survival, improving and proin abundance. Given shed is protecting tecting streamside habitat, and reducing benefited not only grayling and westslope cutthroats but also Arctic grayling. The the number of fish stranded in irrigation that they are a fish wildlife like moose and elk. upper Big Hole holds ditches, known as “entrainment.” that lives almost For westslope cutthroats, the last remaining Olsen says the CCAAs are helping stave off which occupy less than 6 perfluvial (river-dwel- local grayling extinction, even in the face of exclusively on pricent of their historic habitat in ling) grayling popu- warming temperatures due to climate change. vate streams, that’s the drainage, Olsen has folation in the lower 48 “Overall, they’ve increased somewhat in very encouraging.” cused on restoring headwater states. Despite work abundance in the past few years,” he says. streams and lakes mainly in by the BHWC and “Given that they are a fish that lives almost exsurrounding national forests. others, the drought clusively in streams running through private “Our goal is to get them reestablished in of the early 2000s appeared to doom the land, that’s very encouraging. It shows that about 20 percent of their historic habitat,” he sail-finned salmonid. Then in 2006, Big fish conservation can be compatible with says. “We’re finding that the cutthroats are Hole ranchers were given an opportunity to working landscapes.” In 2014, thanks in large becoming more popular with high-country enter into federal Candidate Conservation part to landowner participation in CCAA anglers because they are generally bigger Agreements with Assurances (CCAA) in water-conservation practices, the federal MONTANA OUTDOORS | 17
RESTORED TRIBUTARY Above: On French Creek, a Big Hole River tributary, crews reconfigured 4,000 feet of stream channel away from an eroding hillside. They created new wetlands to store water and planted willows and other streamside vegetation that shades the water while providing browse for moose, elk, and other wildlife. Below: Landing a big rainbow near Wise River.
government deemed that listing the grayling was “not warranted,” Olsen adds.
ALL TO THEMSELVES On a rare day when few other boats create competition, three anglers fish the Canyon Stretch below Divide for browns and rainbows. During April, May, and early June, the upper river fishes best. But as water temperatures rise, many fish begin moving downstream and concentrate in the middle and lower sections. During fall, many fish move back upstream.
Fishing the Big
TOP TO BOTTOM: BIG HOLE WATERSHED COMMITTEE; WADE FELLIN
SHARED SACRIFICE Cooperation has also helped anglers, outfitters, and FWP manage increased fishing pressure and user conflict. Fueled in part by the popularity of the movie A River Runs Through It, fishing pressure on the Big Hole grew rapidly throughout the 1990s. During the famous salmonfly hatch in June, boats would crowd productive stretches, fraying tempers and degrading the experience of local anglers. After listening to outfitters, resident anglers, and local businesses, the Montana Fish and Wildlife Commission restricted, on a rotating schedule, float fishing
by nonresident anglers and outfitters on certain sections of the Big Hole. “It’s not perfect, but my dad was very much at the negotiating table, and he said, ‘Yeah, we need to sacrifice, too, and rotate our boats around, rest the river, and close sections,’” says Wade Fellin, co-owner with his father of the Big Hole Lodge. Eric Thorson, co-owner of the Sunrise Fly Shop in Melrose, echoes the theme of individual sacrifice for the greater good that characterizes the Big Hole community. “The way that outfitters work to spread out the pressure makes a big difference,” Thorson says. “It takes a ton of coordination, but if that’s what we need to do to keep this river as it is, we’ll do it.”
18 | MAY–JUNE 2020 | FWP.MT.GOV/MTOUTDOORS
Some dedicated anglers are so desperate to fish the Big Hole they have been known to slide their boats over bankside ice as early as March, hoping to hit early hatches of Skwala stoneflies, midges, or Baetis mayflies. As days lengthen and water levels rise, streamer fishing takes off. Eric Thorson, coowner of the Sunrise Fly Shop in Melrose, likes to hit the upper river starting in April, fishing to the bank with streamers for big browns. He favors the Smoke ’N’ Mirrors pattern tied by Dan Soltau of Dirty Water Fly Company. Traditional streamer patterns like Woolly Buggers work well, too, as longer daylight hours warm the water enough to wake up fish sluggish from winter’s near-freezing tem- Smoke ’N’ Mirrors peratures. Current lines along banks, side channels, and soft water at the head and tail of boulders are all smart spots to toss and strip streamers. Spring is also a good time to fish for grayling on the upper river, when the small
salmonids are often looking up Sofa Pillow for early season mayflies and caddis flies. Anglers can’t go wrong using Adamses, PMDs or similar small dry flies. The Mother’s Day caddis hatch happens in early May, when size 14 Grannom caddis start coming off. The fishing can be just as good as the Big Hole’s legendary salmonfly hatch, but with far less crowding. That famous salmonfly action starts in late May or early June on the lower river and works its way up to Fish Trap Fishing Access Site above Wise River by late June. If you don’t mind competing with flotillas of boats, Thorson says you can try to fool big browns and rainbows into attacking oversized salmonfly imitations like the Sofa Pillow. Start at the Glen Bridge and working your way upriver, day by day, as the hatch progresses upstream. Salmonflies—two-inch stoneflies—live most of their lives among large boulders in fast-moving rivers like the Big Hole, Madison, and upper
Yellowstone. One way to beat the salmonfly hordes is to fish early (from dawn to 9 a.m.) or late (from 6 p.m. to sundown). The major hatch doesn’t come off during those hours, but fish are often still looking up and will take a Chubby Chernobyl, Madam X, Kaufmann’s Stimulator, or—a local fave—Cat Vomit dry fly flung toward the bank below overhanging willows. Yes, most fly patterns are named by men. A popular combo fly that’s deadly before and after the hatch is the Turd and a Worm: a Pat’s Rubber Leg stonefly imitation with a San Juan Worm trailer. Jim Olsen, FWP fisheries manager for the Big Hole, likes Sex Dungeon fishing the Sex Dungeon, a massive five-inch articulated
MONTANA OUTDOORS | 19
CLOCKWISE FROM TOP LEFT: JASON SAVAGE; MONTANAFLYCOMPANY.COM; ORVIS.COM; COLORADO FLY FISHING REPORTS; FLYFISHUSA.COM; OUTDOORCANADA.COM; DIRTYWATERFLYCO.COM
Hole through the Year
streamer in olive and yellow invented by Kelly Galloup, of Madison River fame. “My favorite thing about the fly is it has a bright head that I can see under the water,” Olsen says. “So you get the heart-pounding thrill of seeing a brown trout come out from under a willow bush and chase after your fly.” Most anglers fish the Big Hole f r o m Cat Vomit boats, but the river definitely is wadeable in its upper reaches and near the bank farther down, where it can be accessed from FWP fishing access sites. The water can be swift and the rocks slippery, so consider using a wading staff and cleated wading boots. After the salmonfly hatch tails off, so does some of the boat traffic. During July and August and into the fall, the middle and lower Big Hole produce steady hatches of other insects and dependable fishing for all species. Many trout from the upper river move downstream to the cooler water in late summer, increasing fish densities just as surface action on terrestrial insects like grasshoppers, Elk Hair ants, and beetles picks up. Caddis This is also when spruce moths, matched by a gray size 14 caddis (though hard to see, CDC caddis patterns are especially effective), start fluttering on the water surface. The tiny black-bodied Trico mayflies start coming off in mid-August and last through mid-September. Trout begin looking up to the surface starting Trico Spinner at about 9 a.m., as the “spinners”— Tricos that died after mating in midair, not the bright-bladed lures—drop to the water surface. When fall arrives, anglers transition back to streamers for big browns, which go on a feeding binge when water temperatures cool. Unlike the Missouri below Holter Dam and other tailwater fisheries, the Big Hole becomes too cold to fish in winter and freezes over except in a few major rapids. Consider winter a season that gives both fish and anglers a welldeserved couple of months rest.
CATFISH CRAZY
BY ANDREW MCKEAN PHOTOS BY JOHN WARNER
FOR THE PAST 20 YEARS, GLASGOW HAS STAYED UP LATE THE FIRST SATURDAY IN JUNE TO CELEBRATE THE CATFISH CLASSIC AND THE MILK RIVER’S REMARKABLE CHANNEL CAT FISHERY.
T
yler George checks his stopwatch. In eight more minutes he’ll reel in his line, run 100 yards downstream, and flip his bait into the next hole, a spot no larger than a sectional sofa, where a submerged cottonwood tree temporarily quickens the Milk River. “You soaking shrimp?” Tyler yells upstream to his brother, Ryan George, who shouts back his confirmation. In their pickup, parked above the river next to an alfalfa field, the brothers have a cooler also stocked with cut-up goldeye, a jar of leopard frogs, a bag of chicken livers, and a secret bait Tyler won’t reveal to me. “Great!” Tyler yells back, checking the stopwatch. “You’ve got 2 minutes, 20 seconds to your next hole!” During this riverside quarterbacking, Tyler never takes his eye off the tip of his rod, which pulses rhythmically as the current pulls on his submerged bait and lead weight. Wearing a Montana Catfish Association (MCA) shirt, camouflage pants, and Muck boots, he crouches on the muddy bank of the Milk River, ready to grab his rod the instant it registers a bite. The George brothers are one of 80 teams in the Catfish Classic fishing tournament, and they need a few big fish to have a shot at winning the event, as they did in 2015 and 2016. Their strategy, Tyler says, is to “hole-hop,” spending a defined amount of time (confirmed by the stopwatch) at each of a dozen 20 | MAY–JUNE 2020 | FWP.MT.GOV/MTOUTDOORS
spots that hold the promise of a five-pound or larger channel catfish.
nearly 12 pounds, back when he was in junior high. That fish, plus the promise of others like it, galvanized his interest in catfishing HOME HOLES and learning the Milk River, which typically The brothers grew up in Glasgow. While has a barely perceptible current as it bends Tyler now teaches middle school in Sheridan, and twists back on itself. During high water, Wyoming, and Ryan works for Burlington though, the Milk churns and claws at its Northern Santa Fe railroad outside Billings, gumbo banks with ferocity, tipping cottonthey return to their hometown every June to woods into the current and flooding riverfish the Classic, and the river of their youth. side alfalfa fields. In all seasons, it’s home “We both went to college in Missoula, and to channel catfish, a native species found fished trout on the Clark Fork and Bitterroot throughout the lower Missouri River, Yellowstone River, and their tributaries. Tonight, as the light lingers long into the lazy June evening, the Milk is relatively tame, making it fishable for the Georges and 79 other teams spread up and down the river hoping for a double-digit fish that would put them in the money. The tournament ends at midnight, when all teams present their fivefish “basket” at the weigh-in downtown. The heaviest basket of the tournament wins $2,000, but even runners-up win cash, fishevery chance we had,” Tyler says. “The hy- ing rods, and jackets sporting the MCA logo— drology of a river is the same, no matter if it’s a surly channel cat swimming through the a clear-water trout stream or a catfish river. outline of the state—embroidered on the Riffle, run, hole. We hit the holes, but only if back. The evening’s single biggest catfish they have tasty riffles and runs above them.” wins the lucky angler $200. The Georges aim to finish this evening in About half the teams in the Classic use a series of what they call “home holes,” boats small enough to navigate the Milk’s broad bends of the muddy river behind their tight turns and shallow stretches. The rest late grandfather’s farm just outside Glas- fish from the bank, spending their entire gow. That’s where Tyler caught his biggest evening on one stretch of river or hopping Milk River channel cat, a fish weighing from one spot to the next.
“
The fishing turns on when the lights go out!”
CAN’T KEEP CALM Glasgow chief of police Brien Gault and his daughter Autumn Gault, of Bozeman, pose with a channel catfish that Autumn pulled from the Milk River during the 2019 Catfish Classic fishing tournament.
MONTANA OUTDOORS | 21
“We’re hard core, from the shore!” Tyler George shouts after me as I leave the brothers’ spot to check on other anglers. CATFISH CARNIVAL First, though, I swing through downtown Glasgow. It’s still eight hours until the raucous traditional midnight weigh-in, but already spectators have begun gathering in front of a stage set up in the empty lot across from D&G Sports & Western. Country western music plays from speakers under party lights strung between poles. Spectators line up at food trucks for tacos and cold beer, awaiting reports from the river. Last night, a street dance kept the bars hopping. The downtown party—Glasgow’s biggest of the year—continued earlier this morning with a pancake breakfast, kids’ carnival, cornhole tournament, and 5k fun run. Some Montana
towns have their summer rodeos, others sponsor art fairs. Glasgow turns out for the Cat Classic, which celebrated its 20th anniversary in 2019. The native channel catfish is an unlikely celebrity in a state renowned for its coldwater trout and world-class walleye fishing. Some people think of these larger cousins to the bullhead as “trash fish,” apparently because they feed along the bottom of warm, turbid waters flowing through the state’s eastern prairies. It’s an uninformed opinion. Catfish are a popular food fish across the United States. And when hooked, their deeply forked tail allows them to power hard against even the stoutest spinning rod. For more than a dozen years, the MCA has elevated the reputation of channel cats by holding summertime catch-and-release
Outdoor Life hunting editor and longtime Montana Outdoors contributor Andrew McKean lives on a small ranch outside Glasgow. John Warner is a photojournalist in Billings.
“
Do we have a strategy? Sure. Have fun and hopefully catch some fish.” fishing tournaments on the lower Yellowstone and Missouri Rivers. The Super Bowl of the MCA circuit is the Milk River Catfish Classic, and there’s no more enthusiastic booster than Brenner Flaten, founder of the tournament and the evening’s emcee. “The Classic has become a community fixture,” says Flaten, vice principal at Glasgow’s elementary school and the Glasgow Scotties’ athletic director. “It’s not uncommon to have 300 people come out at midnight in downtown Glasgow for the weigh-in.” They turn out to see fish, of course, but also for the spectacle that’s grown up around
SOCIAL HUB Still eight hours before the midnight weigh-in, spectators begin gathering near the stage set up in downtown Glasgow across from D&G Sports & Western. Though catfishing is the carnival’s main draw, many spectators come as much for the food, music, and summer socializing.
22 | MAY–JUNE 2020 | FWP.MT.GOV/MTOUTDOORS
the tournament. Flaten struts across the stage like a televangelist, delivering hyperbolic commentary about each team’s strategy, the fishing conditions, and testimony to the religion of catch-and-release catfishing. Dry-ice fog rolls off the stage, speakers boom, and colored lights give downtown the feel of a dust-country revival. “The fishing turns on when the lights go out!” Flaten bellows to the growing crowd. In the early years of the Classic, Flaten’s stage was the bed of a pickup parked at the Glasgow Civic Center, and the winning basket of channel cats weighed less than 20 pounds. Now, the 80-team field fills in a couple of days, and the winning basket routinely weighs 35 pounds or more. Tyler Haddix, Montana Fish, Wildlife & Parks fisheries biologist in Glasgow and a big channel cat fan himself, appreciates how the tournament highlights the often-disparaged species. “Being so close to Fort Peck Reservoir, walleye is usually king around here, but
not this weekend,” he says. Flaten attributes the tournament’s success to increasingly better fishing, which he and Haddix believe is the result of 12 years of relatively high water in the Milk. The river heads in Glacier National Park, flows into Alberta before reentering the United States northwest of Havre, then hugs the Hi-Line through Glasgow until joining the Missouri below Fort Peck Dam about 20 miles downstream. “The Milk is the northwesternmost native catfish river in the United States,” says Flaten. Like the George brothers and many of the tournament’s other top anglers, he was a decorated prep wrestler at Glasgow High School. Catfish are pugnacious, hardy, and durable, not unlike the smash-mouth grapplers who fish for them. Flaten says that Milk River fishing, for channel cats and the dozen or so other game and nongame species—including shovelnose sturgeon, sauger, walleye, and blue suckers— has never been better. “There were summers
when I was a kid when the Milk didn’t flow,” he says. “We’d catch the occasional three- to four-pound cat, and a six-pounder was considered a monster, but the average fish was a little over a pound. Now, the average Milk River cat is around 2½ pounds and a 10pounder is considered a trophy. We’ve also seen the number of fish you can expect to catch in a night double over the past 15 years.” GOTTA HAVE SHRIMP A few miles downstream from Glasgow, as the summer sun slips below the cottonwoods, Brien Gault straps on a headlamp, pounds a rod holder into the bank, and checks the cooler next to his lawn chair. Both bait and drinks are cooling on ice. Gault, Glasgow’s police chief, looks down the bank to his daughter, Autumn, who’s come home from college in Bozeman to fish the Classic with her dad. “You got shrimp on?” Autumn nods. She tells me that they almost didn’t bring shrimp, but then ran into
READY FOR RETURN Above left: All channel catfish caught during the tournament are kept in an oxygenated tank for later live release back into the Milk River. Above right: Five-time Cat Classic champion Nate Molstad of Havre carries his team’s catch to the weigh-in stage.
MONTANA OUTDOORS | 23
BRAGGING RIGHTS The team of Steve Harris Jr. (Sidney) and Steve Lowrey (Fairview)—struggling to hold their slippery catch on the weigh-in stage in the photo to the right—won the 2019 Catfish Classic with a five-fish basket of 36.42 pounds. Carter Pederson’s (Wolf Point) 11.12-pounder was the largest fish of the tournament. Brothers Tyler and Ryan George came in 24th with a combined catch of 21.74 pounds, while the Gaults placed 47th with a basket of 16.9 pounds. The 2020 Milk River Catfish Classic is scheduled to take place June 6. For more information, visit montanacats.com.
THE BIG NIGHT Clockwise from top left: Two-time Cat Classic champion Tyler George sets his rod after a catfish takes his bait; Brien Gault nets a nice catfish caught by his daughter, Autumn; 2019 tournament runners-up Peyton Pederson of Billings and her brother Carter Pederson of Wolf Point display their two largest catfish to a cheering crowd; Jake Aune and Shawn Wersal, both of Glasgow, show off their night’s catch; early leader Jake Knaff awaits other teams’ official weights while his tired son sits on the lap of the Glasgow Chamber of Commerce mascot, Catfish Charlie.
24 | MAY–JUNE 2020 | FWP.MT.GOV/MTOUTDOORS
the George brothers at the grocery store earlier in the day. “We didn’t want to be obvious about it, but we checked out their cart, and they had frozen shrimp, so we went back and bought the store out,” Brien says. “If the Georges have it, it’s got to be working.” Autumn checks the silver bell attached to the tip of a rod 20 yards upstream from her chair. The bell will sound when the rod jiggles, signaling a bite, giving her time to run
up the bank in the dark and set the hook. For the past 10 years the Gaults have fished this stretch of river, 50 yards of grassy bank on a friend’s farm that Brien mows like a golf green the week before the tournament. They’ve cracked the top 20 teams twice, but Brien says that’s not really the point. “This is our weekend,” he says. “Neither of us fish much the rest of the year, but we entered the Classic one year and had so much fun that we just kept doing it. Do we have a strategy? Sure.
Have fun and hopefully catch some fish.” Some years the mosquitoes drove them to town early; other times the river’s rainslick banks made it hard to move, even in mud boots. Last year, it was the bats. “They were so bad they knocked my headlamp off if I stood up,” says Brien. “And they hit our line so often that our bells were going off pretty much constantly.” “It was miserable,” says Autumn, adding, “but tonight’s almost perfect.”
BRONZE MEDALISTS Above: Defending champions Cole Plouffe of Glendive and Nevadan Jason Flaten finished third in the 2019 tournament.
The lower Milk River is packed with 1- to 3-pound channel catfish, but environmental conditions prevent the fishery from producing many larger cats like the ones anglers pick up in the Musselshell or Missouri. “Big fish come up those rivers from Fort Peck Reservoir, where they beef up on abundant forage fish like river carpsuckers, smallmouth and bigmouth buffalo, blue suckers, and shiners,” says Tyler Haddix, FWP fisheries biologist in Glasgow. “There’s not that forage base in the Milk to grow many catfish over 10 pounds. “ Some anglers have called on FWP to lower the Milk River catfish possession limit from 10 daily and 20 in possession, hoping to increase fish size. But Haddix, who notes that the daily limit was already lowered from 20 to 10 in 2010, says there’s not enough fishing pressure on the river to justify a further reduction. “This isn’t like Nebraska or Arkansas, where catfish get hammered every day and harvest adjustments can make a difference,” he says. Catfish are named for their whiskerlike barbels, Though FWP isn’t opposed to exploring harvest limit changes on more heavily fished cat- which are sensory organs used to smell food. fish fisheries, “a lower limit on the Milk would simply deny the handful of harvest-oriented anglers opportunities to take home fish,” Haddix says. In fact, what would actually help boost average catfish size on the Milk is increased harvest. “The Milk is loaded with small catfish. If we could remove more of those, that would free up food to grow larger cats,” Haddix says. Limits aside, FWP and tournament anglers agree that the fishery benefits from high water. “Everyone recognizes those flows flush silt out of spawning gravel for forage species, increasing reproduction, and providing more fish habitat overall,” Haddix says. Steve Dalbey, FWP regional fisheries manager in Glasgow, says what would most benefit the catfish and other fish populations in the Milk and lower Missouri Rivers would be if Fort Peck Dam began releasing water in ways that mimic historic flows before the dam was built in the 1930s. “Warm-water releases and periodic spring pulses from Fort Peck Dam would benefit catfish and their forage in the Milk River and the nearly 200 miles of the Missouri that have been severely disrupted by the dam,” he says. —Tom Dickson, Editor MONTANA OUTDOORS | 25
CRAIG & LIZ LARCOM
The Milk River Catfish Fishery
Has Catch-and-Release Gone Overboard? The case for harvesting trout By Tom Dickson
26 | MAY–JUNE 2020 | FWP.MT.GOV/MTOUTDOORS
fishing boats don’t help. And heaven help the naïve angler who shows a stringer on social media. “It’s reached a point on Facebook that if you post a shot of yourself holding a big fish and don’t tag it with ‘Still Swimming’ or ‘CPR’ [Catch, Photo, Release], you’ll get lambasted in the comments section,” says Zack Shattuck, FWP Native Species Program coordinator. But is being sautéed in butter really the worst fate to befall a fish? I’m not the only one wondering whether the catch-and-release ethic, even with all its accomplishments, has NOT WELCOME A sticker on a fishing raft in Helena sums up attitudes of a growing number of fly anglers toward those who harvest fish.
gone too far. “One question I constantly get at social gatherings is what’s my take on catch-and-release,” Shattuck says. “Older anglers especially, who’ve fought for stream protection and public access and consider themselves conservationists, are basically asking me if it’s still okay to kill a fish.” 10 pounds plus one fish It certainly has been for most of human history. Though fishing has always included some aspects of sport, relaxation, and nature appreciation, its main purpose most of the past 40,000 years has been to get food.
TOM DICKSON/MONTANA OUTDOORS
he fish leapt, made a strong run upstream, leapt again, then finally submitted as I led it into the shallows next to an island on the Missouri River upstream from Craig. Kneeling in the water, I cradled the trout in my hands and slipped the hook free. Then, looking to make sure no one was watching, I bashed the 19-inch rainbow in the head with a softball-size rock. Killing that big, beautiful fish was perfectly legal and biologically justifiable. But to a growing number of anglers, what I’d done ought to be a hangin’ offense. Which is why I was taking pains not to be seen. Game wardens weren’t the concern; I was well within the legal limit. What I dreaded was another angler drifting past and chewing me out for doing something that to many seems downright barbaric these days: taking a trout home to eat. “More and more we’re seeing bait fishing and trout harvest pushed underground. People are now embarrassed to admit they are keeping fish,” says Eric Roberts, Fisheries Management Bureau chief with Montana Fish, Wildlife & Parks. “Bait Fishermen Suck” stickers on fly-
PAT CLAYTON/ENGBRETSON UNDERWATER PHOTOGRAPHY
BEST MANAGEMENT PRACTICE? The act of releasing trout has become sanctified throughout most of the United States and Canada. But fisheries biologists warn that the practice isn’t all it’s cracked up to be. “In many cases,” says Eric Roberts, chief of the FWP Fisheries Management Bureau, “some of our trout fisheries would actually be better off with more harvest.”
That started changing after World War II, as income levels rose and fewer Americans needed fish to supplement their larders. Around the same time, anglers began to notice that fish populations were finite and that liberal harvest regulations, like the “10 pounds plus one fish” daily limit allowed on the Big Hole and other rivers until the mid1960s, were depleting fisheries. The idea of releasing fish was first widely promoted by fly angler and author Lee
I know they mean well, but fly anglers who scorn spin and bait anglers are just driving people away from fishing altogether.”
Wulff, who wrote in the late 1930s (about Atlantic salmon), “A good game fish is too valuable to be caught only once.” The practice of releasing fish to be caught another day slowly took off among trout anglers. Among the first Montana advocates was Don Martinez, a renowned West Yellowstone fly shop owner who, starting in the 1940s, began urging clients to let trout go. “Some of the best fishermen do not carry a basket or a net, releasing all of their catch MONTANA OUTDOORS | 27
except for an occasional very large specimen,” he wrote in his shop newsletter. Elsewhere, catch-and-release took off with largemouth bass anglers beginning in the 1970s. By the 2000s it was even being embraced by some anglers who fished for walleye and catfish, long considered food fish species. “Let ’em go, let ’em grow” became the mantra of anglers everywhere. Mostly it worked. Even after Montana switched from stocking rivers to managing for wild trout in the 1970s, the growing catch-and-release ethic helped conserve populations and maintain catch rates in the face of ever-increasing fishing pressure. That’s still the case. On crowded rivers especially, trout fisheries would be quickly depleted if every angler kept even one fish per outing. “It’s been vital for westslope cutthroat trout, which are gullible and can easily be overharvested,” says David Schmetterling, FWP Fisheries Research Program coordinator. For instance, FWP recently enacted a new regulation banning Tom Dickson is editor of Montana Outdoors. 28 | MAY–JUNE 2020 | FWP.MT.GOV/MTOUTDOORS
treble hooks on all three forks of the Flathead River to make it easier to release trout to protect low-density cutthroat populations. But over the past two decades, something unexpected has happened, causing fisheries managers to reconsider whether releasing fish is all it’s cracked up to be. “In many cases, we’ve reached a point where some of our trout fisheries would actually be better off with more harvest,” Roberts says. Increase harvest, increase size Every river, stream, lake, or reservoir has a limited amount of food that can support a
Catch-and-release has become so ingrained that we’ve lost our main tool for managing species composition, size structure, and population size.”
finite poundage of fish, known as its biological “carrying capacity.” Let’s say a theoretical river can grow 1,000 pounds of trout per mile. In most cases, that population could be represented by a pyramid, with large numbers of small trout, far fewer medium-sized trout, and relatively few large trout. If anglers want to catch more large trout in this river, they’d need to kill (“harvest”) many of the small trout at the base of the pyramid to free up food and space for the remaining fish to grow. “Those smaller two- and three-yearold trout feed like crazy and are far more aggressive than big trout,” Roberts says. In many waters where a trout population is at carrying capacity and few anglers keep fish anymore, the lack of harvest can actually reduce average trout size. That’s not true everywhere—the Missouri River below Holter Dam, for instance—but many fisheries could produce larger fish, though fewer fish overall, if anglers brought more small trout home to eat. “For a generation we have been convinced that catch-and-release is conservation, but that’s not necessarily the case these days,” Schmetterling says.
LEFT TO RIGHT: PATRICK CLAYTON/ENGBRETSON UNDERWATER PHOTOGRAPHY; RICK CLARK; ALLEN HAY
SUCCESS STORIES Controversial at first, the idea of releasing fish began with Atlantic salmon and spread to largemouth bass and trout as anglers saw that fisheries across the United States were being overharvested. The practice was especially successful with Yellowstone (above) and westslope cutthroat trout, which readily take flies and lures and can be easily overharvested.
“As long as the habitat is in good shape and a fishery isn’t being overharvested, all catchand-release does in most cases is reconfigure the sizes of fish in a given population.” One example was the Bighorn River in the early 2000s, when anglers hooked abundant 13- to 15-inch browns and rainbows but rarely caught larger trout. “We don’t know for sure, but likely the best way for them to have seen more 16-plus-inch fish would have been to harvest more trout below 13 inches, but that wasn’t happening,” Schmetterling says. On the Beaverhead River, Dillon-based fisheries biologist Matt Jaeger says that during some years he could double or triple the number of 18-plus-inch trout per mile on the Clark Canyon Reservoir tailwater fishery. But that would take convincing unwilling anglers to harvest thousands of 10- to 16inchers. “They understand the science but aren’t comfortable harvesting fish,” Jaeger says. “Some have told me privately they’d prefer us to go in and electroshock those smaller fish and remove them ourselves.” In particular, biologists say they are frustrated they can’t convince anglers to harvest brook trout, browns, and rainbows to help protect westslope cutthroat trout, a species so vulnerable it has repeatedly been proposed for listing under the Endangered Species Act. Brookies and browns outcompete cutthroats, and rainbows hybridize with the native species, diluting genetics. “Catch-and-release has become so ingrained in angler behavior
BELLY UP? Most released fish live to fight another day. But roughly 8 percent of the trout that anglers catch and then release die from the stress of the fight and overhandling. Rates are even higher in late summer when water temperatures became dangerously warm.
that we’ve lost our main tool for managing species composition, size structure, and population size,” Schmetterling says. What’s the harm? Ironically, many fish that catch-and-release absolutists believe they are saving end up floating belly up downstream after release. FWP biologists estimate that this “incidental mortality”—caused by the stress of the fight or mishandling—accounts for an average of 8 percent of all released fish, depending mainly on water temperatures. “When temperatures are at lethal levels of over 72 degrees in July and August, fish caught and released are essentially dead,” says Roberts. Mortality rates increase every time a fish is captured. On the Madison River, each rainbow trout is caught an average of 4.5 times. Though the vast majority of released fish survive to fight another day, FWP biologists estimate that roughly 32,000 released rainbows die each year on that river alone. “Anglers can do a lot to increase surPROUD HARVEST Once common throughout Montana, the practice of keeping a few fish to bring home for supper has been pushed underground. FWP officials say some anglers have publicly shamed others for keeping trout.
vival, like playing a fish quickly and not to exhaustion, and reducing the time they handle the fish, especially out of the water,” Schmetterling says. “But the number one thing they can do is to not fish for trout when water is above 70 degrees.” Another misconception is that big trout need to be released so they can “fight another day.” “Every spring, we hear from anglers complaining about the ‘slaughter’ of big rainbows coming near shore on Helenaarea reservoirs,” says Adam Strainer, FWP biologist in Helena. “But those fish—like most big trout in other Montana reservoirs and rivers—are at the end of their life span. If released, they’d probably die before ever getting caught again.” Besides, “these are stocked fish that are meant to be harvested,” Strainer adds. Also lost in the always-release approach are the many benefits of harvesting organic, free-swimming protein. Wild fish are better for you and the environment than the farmraised, plastic-wrapped fish in a grocery store. Fattened on wild foods, wild trout taste better, too. Anglers who let fish go—and I count myself among them, releasing about 95 percent of my catch—might also want to reconsider MONTANA OUTDOORS | 29
the ethics of what growing numbers of people view as harassing fish for fun. For instance, in Germany, where catch-andrelease is considered inhumane, all sportcaught fish above certain sizes must be harvested. In The Founding Fish, best-selling author—and devoted shad angler who kills all his catch—John McPhee writes, “The idea of playing with things for your own enjoyment while they go through great anguish and suffering is fundamentally wrong.” It’s never been proved that fish feel pain or otherwise suffer as we humans understand it. But there’s no doubt a hooked fish struggles with all its might to escape. In fact, I’ll be the first to admit that that’s what makes fighting a fish so much fun. After conceding that unsettling truth and then factoring in the number of released fish that die anyway, it seems fair to ask which approach to fishing is more defensible: catching and releasing 30 fish in a day, or catching and killing two and then calling it a day? Something wrong Eileen Ryce remembers the moment she realized that catch-and-release might have
gone a bit overboard. “A few years ago we were at the Wolf Creek Bridge on the Missouri and watched a boy fishing from shore land a nice rainbow and put it on a stringer,” says the head of FWP’s Fisheries Division. “Two guys in a boat who were drifting past started giving him a hard time about keeping his fish, which was perfectly legal and biologically supported by our regulations. I thought: ‘Something is wrong with this picture.’” One problem is that many anglers now take it upon themselves to determine—and enforce through public shaming—which levels are appropriate. Ryce says that’s where FWP comes in. “Each year we combine angler input with fish population and creel surveys to determine just how much harvest each fishery can sustain,” she says. If you want to know if it’s okay to keep a fish, simply check the FWP regulations. Another concern with “harvest shaming” is that it assumes a moral hierarchy in the an-
BUMPER STICKER BACKLASH Harvest anglers have responded to perceived prejudice with slogans of their own. Wrote one fishing site blogger about displaying the sticker shown here: “I just want to piss off the out-of-state fishers wearing $2,000 of fly-fishing gear who look down on those of us who actually catch and eat trout.”
gling universe, with dry-fly purists on top and bait anglers on the bottom. “But no single group of anglers has a monopoly on conservation ethics,” Shattuck, the Native Species Program coordinator, says. “Everyone wants
CAMP TRADITION Eating fish remains popular among backcountry campers. But even on some high mountain lakes, anglers report feeling peer pressure to let all of their trout go, even though FWP stocks these waters specifically for harvest.
30 | MAY–JUNE 2020 | FWP.MT.GOV/MTOUTDOORS
to do the right thing.” The right thing, suggest FWP fisheries biologists, might be spending more time helping them protect trout habitat (contact your local fisheries office for suggestions) and less time worrying about whether someone keeps a few fish for the smoker. “I know they mean well,” Schmetterling says, “but fly anglers who scorn spin and bait anglers are just driving people away from fishing altogether. When you consider actual threats like aquatic invasive species, chronic dewatering, and climate change, that’s the last thing our streams and rivers need.” A certain amount of catch-and-release definitely remains essential for sustaining Montana’s renowned trout fisheries. Rivers can’t support harvest levels like they did when Granddad and his pals filled their wicker baskets every weekend. But not every trout needs to go back in the water. In fact, some fisheries could even benefit from additional harvest. With that in mind, anglers who follow regulations set by FWP fisheries professionals and keep a few trout can feel just as good about their actions as those who let theirs swim away.
SHARED PASSION Whether using a size 18 PMD emerger, a #3 Mepps spinner, or a piece of night crawler, all trout anglers love to catch fish. Some may differ on what to do with a trout after it’s in the net, but all can agree that hooking a big rainbow, brown, or cutthroat is one of the great thrills of fishing in Montana.
CLOCKWISE FROM LEFT: JOHN LAMBING; LUKE DURAN; JAKE PETERSON; ARNIE GIDLOW
Walleye start receiving the catch-and-release treatment The walleye’s sweet, bone-free fillets have long made it a food fish favorite. So it may come as a surprise that more and more walleye anglers are releasing some of their catch—and demanding others do, too. “I’ve seen it at the cleaning station when someone is filleting a 24-inch walleye and they start getting the stink-eye from other anglers or have rude comments thrown their way—even though there’s no biological justification for letting that fish go,” says Heath Headley, FWP fisheries biologist at Fort Peck Reservoir. Headley says many walleye anglers commonly release large fish to “protect the prime spawners.” In fact, reservoirs have plenty of eggs each spring from the tens of thousands or even millions of walleye swimming there. “What usually limits walleye numbers and average size is spawning habitat and decent water levels, not the lack of eggs,” Headley says. Canyon Ferry’s walleye population could benefit from far more harvest, though of small fish, not big ones, says Adam Strainer, FWP fisheries biologist in Helena. The reservoir is swarming with 10- to 13-inchers. “If anglers want to see more fish over 20 inches, they’ll have to start keeping a lot more of those little guys,” Strainer says. The rate of released walleye has increased from 10 percent to 60 percent over the past two decades, while the average length has dropped from 18 inches to 13 inches. “If anglers don’t start taking more small fish home over the next two years, there won’t be enough food for fish to get bigger.” Strainer and Headley point out that the effects of walleye harvest differ from one reservoir to the next. For instance, Canyon Ferry is small enough and has enough fishing pressure for harvest to affect average fish size. “But Fort Peck is such a large system and fishing pressure is so limited that harvest isn’t a factor,” Headley says. “If some anglers want to release a big walleye there, by all means, LET IT GO? A walleye this size is so old that, if released, it go ahead. But if you want to keep a big Fort Peck walleye to eat or have mounted, would likely die before another angler could ever catch it. you shouldn’t be ashamed. In no way will that harvest affect the fish population As for egg production, most reservoirs don’t need more or what anyone else catches down the road.” n walleye eggs; they need more walleye spawning habitat. MONTANA OUTDOORS | 31
32 | MAY–JUNE 2020 | FWP.MT.GOV/MTOUTDOORS
Revisiting the ever-changing geological wonders of Lewis & Clark Caverns, Montana’s first state park. BY JULIE LUE I PHOTOS BY BRADEN GUNEM
LEAVING PARADISE A visitor exits the Paradise Room, the largest and most spectacular room in the caverns. With its great density of fanciful rock formations, Lewis & Clark Caverns is considered one of the most decorative caves in the United States. MONTANA OUTDOORS | 33
over six feet, sometimes looks 500 stairs and ascending nearly 100. like he is folded in half. A nimble, Toward the tour’s end, in the Paradise gray-haired woman in front of Room, the largest and most spectacular in me says, “I’m glad I didn’t wait the caverns, I stand in a spot that feels until I was older to do this.” strangely familiar and stare at wonders Minutes ago, we were hiking I know I’ve seen before. through groves of juniper and Some caves are jewel boxes, but this one limber pine outside the moun- is a candy shop, packed with fanciful stone tain. Now we are inside a still, shapes in shades of cream and caramel and quiet world where the only sound cocoa. While many retain the classic icicle is our hushed voices—kept low so appearance associated with stalactites and we don’t disturb the bats—and stalagmites, others look like massive wedthe scrape of our shoes on stone. ding cakes, milk chocolate fountains, On a stormy summer day, or half-melted ice cream sundaes. Nearly my sons and I are taking the every patch of rock is decorated as if by cake Classic Cave Tour at Lewis & icing squeezed from a giant pastry tube. Clark Caverns State Park. This is In the 20 years I’ve lived in Montana, a first visit for my kids and a sec- I have driven I-90 between Missoula and ond for me; I toured the cave as a Bozeman countless times without taking the child on my first trip to Montana. turnoff for Lewis & Clark Caverns. Standing But I remember nothing. My only WATCH YOUR STEP Above left: FWP caverns guide Kirsten Rothenbucher shines her flashlight on a potential stumbling memories of a cave formation as visitors enter the Cathedral Room, the second are from one in the largest in the caverns. Below: A family descends deep into Ozarks. Or so I believe. the caverns using the newly installed handrails and lighting on’t think about it When our group reaches the system to maintain steady footing. Opposite bottom: Early and you’ll be fine,” Beaver Slide, the boys and I wait explorers and visitors navigated the caverns with candles and lanterns, found in the upper visitor center museum. our guide, Erin Young- as the others, one by one, sit on During the park’s special holiday candlelight tours each the damp rock and glide out of December, modern visitors can share the eerie experience. Dahl, reassures us after exsight. The slide’s brown, marbled-looking surface is buffed to plaining that the shadowy a gloss by the behinds of countabyss to our left is a 90-foot- less cave visitors. Its grade is gentle. At a playground, a slide deep pit. No doubt she’s like this probably would be conright, but I still clutch the sidered suitable for preschoolhandrail as I follow my sons ers, if the preschoolers didn’t mind sliding into the unknown. down the stairs into Cave Peering around the bend, my Mountain. At least the pit younger son asks if we’ve taken the more adventurous tour has caught the attention of option by mistake. my 14-year-old, who looks Suddenly I realize I know back at me with wide eyes what’s at the bottom of the slide. This is the cave I remember, not and a nervous smile. As we wind our way into the chilly cav- the one in the Ozarks. Decades erns, bare walls, ceilings, and floors give way ago, I surely polished this same to surfaces that appear to be dripping with patch of rock with my own limestone. At times, “headache” rocks and backside. From then on, a feeling of other overhanging formations require us to déjà vu accompanies me as we stoop, duck, or waddle. My 17-year-old, at just twist and turn through the Julie Lue is a writer in Florence. Braden Gunem cave’s rooms and passages— is a photographer in Crested Butte, Colorado. descending a total of more than 34 | MAY–JUNE 2020 | FWP.MT.GOV/MTOUTDOORS
FREAKY FORMATIONS From left to right: “Cave popcorn,” or globulites, are formed as water seeping from walls flows over preexisting calcite, aragonite, or gypsum crystals, rounding them off into globular clusters; stalactites hang from the cave ceiling next to stalagmites growing up from the floor; “cave bacon,” or layered flowstone, is created by deposits of waterborne minerals flowing along the same route for eons.
here in the Paradise Room, I have to ask myself: What took me so long? JUST ADD WATER Of course, what qualifies as a long time in my mind is a mere blip in the cave’s lifetime. The caverns are an estimated 2.5 to 3 million years old, and the Mission Canyon limestone in which they have formed dates back hundreds of millions of years. Along the trail to the cave, my boys and I find clues to the limestone’s origins. Fossils of marine creatures like crinoids, brachiopods, and corals testify to an ancient shallow sea. Their shells and exoskeletons, rich in calcium carbonate, accumulated on the bottom of the sea and eventually cemented together to form limestone. As the Rocky Mountains rose, the limestone was pushed and folded, creating countless cracks and fissures. Once it was exposed to the surface, the stage was set for cave building. Limestone, which harbors most of the world’s caves, is easily soluble in water that has been slightly acidified, a process that occurs naturally from contact with carbon dioxide in the air and soil. When acidified rainwater and snowmelt seeped down from above, it filled cracks in the Mission Canyon limestone, dissolving the rock bit by bit, scouring out a maze of passages and rooms. As the nearby Jefferson River cut 1,400 feet into its canyon, the water table
dropped and the caverns drained. Water still found its way into these air-filled spaces, carrying with it dissolved calcium carbonate and redepositing it, ever so slowly, in weird and wonderful shapes called speleothems. Dripping water created stalactites (which hang from a cave ceiling), stalagmites (growing up from the cave floor), and columns. Flowing water formed stone waterfalls and fragile drapes of “cave bacon.” Seeping water produced lumpy custers of “cave popcorn,” also known as globulites, and delicate helictites, which curve like the arms of a sea anemone. Even now, where fed by water, these cave formations continue to grow.
OUT OF THE DARK As far as we know, this spectacular array of speleothems developed in darkness until the end of the 19th century. Native Americans probably were aware of the cave, because on cold days water vapor rises like smoke from its mouth. Yet there’s no sign they entered. And despite the cave’s name, Meriwether Lewis and William Clark knew nothing of the cave when they traveled past while making their way up the Jefferson River in 1805. But the caverns could not remain secret forever. Ranchers Tom Williams and Bert Pannell found the entrance in 1892. The explorations of Williams and others six years later encouraged miner and investor Dan Morrison to turn the cave into a tourist attraction. Wonders concealed by darkness for millions of years were now revealed by candlelight. Unfortunately for Morrison, he held no claim to the cave; the General Land Office determined it was property of the Northern Pacific Railway, which donated it to the federal government for preservation. In 1908, the caverns became the United States’ 12th national monument—though with no appropriated funds for development and management and no plan to open the cave to the public (even as Morrison continued to lead unauthorized tours). Eventually, the federal government gave the land to the state of Montana and agreed MONTANA OUTDOORS | 35
GAZE IN THE MAZE Top: Visitors descend into the Brown Waterfall Room, where a cascade of rock appears to spill from a ledge like a river torrent. In addition to flowing water, limestone formations in Lewis & Clark Caverns resemble flowing lava, melted ice cream sundaes, fountains of molten chocolate, and wedding cakes. Above: Using a fluorescent light to see minerals in a cave rock. Right: A family pauses to photograph the Grand Finale Room toward the end of the tour. The popular spot is part of both the two-hour Classic Cave Tour and the easier hour-long Paradise Tour. Tours run from May 1 until September 30.
36 | MAY–JUNE 2020 | FWP.MT.GOV/MTOUTDOORS
to develop the site using the Civilian Conservation Corps (CCC), a Great Depression–era work program for young men. The land was officially transferred in 1937, and a year later Montana’s first state park was born. A NEW LIGHT At the main visitor center, I catch up with Rhea Armstrong, manager of Lewis & Clark Caverns State Park—one of Montana’s 55 state parks. Armstrong, who grew up in nearby Cardwell, has worked at the caverns since she was in college studying to become a teacher. Her family connections to the cave go back two generations. As we talk, a steady stream of people pass through the doors of the visitor center, built in 2010. This is peak season at one of the West’s most notable caves; 70,000 people visit the park each year, and 60,000 of them tour the caverns. “I think that we’ve grown faster than we can fully accommodate, but we still want everyone to have the best experience ever,” Armstrong says. To that end, she and her team have been working to improve electrical, sewer, and other infrastructure and services both inside and outside the caverns. The most visible improvement is a new lighting and handrail system, installed in the Paradise Room in 2007 and the rest of the cave during the winter of 2018-19. This $1.75 million project replaced potentially hazardous electrical cables and fixtures from the early 1940s, as well as old handrails made of metal pipe. Incandescent lights were replaced with more efficient, cooler LEDs that are less likely to cause algal growth or dry out sensitive cave formations. The new lights also more clearly illuminate the rock formations, including many previously hidden in shadow. LEDs along the underside of the new stainless steel handrails create enhanced safety and comfort for people touring the cave, according to Armstrong. “The light’s not in your eyes, it’s down at your feet,” she says. “And with more light in the rooms, you’re seeing better.” The new handrails have been carefully designed to provide the best grip for each location, she adds. “When you’re ducking, you need a shorter handrail.” Another major consideration in the light-
DECORATIVE DRIPSTONE Named for its two-toned coloration, Half-and-Half Column rises 30 feet from the floor, making it the tallest column in the caverns.
ing project: aesthetics. Armstrong recalls how the electrical contractor patiently adjusted lighting behind strips of cave bacon until she and park ranger Julia Smit reacted with a “wow.” It’s a word my sons and I hear frequently from our group. Like my family, most visitors take the twohour, two-mile Classic Cave Tour, which includes 600 stairs. (In late December, the park offers a candlelight version.) People with very young children or physical limitations may
instead opt for the hour-long Paradise Tour, which requires only a mile of walking and a dozen steps inside the cave. Those looking for more adventure can take the lights-off, reservation-only Wild Tour, which entails strapping on a headlamp and crawling through tight spaces. There’s also a world to discover outside the caverns. “Because the cave is such a draw, I don’t think people realize this is a 3,000-acre park,” Armstrong says. MONTANA OUTDOORS | 37
FAMILY FRIENDLY The state park’s popular campground fills up early throughout the summer. In addition to 40 campsites, the park offers three cabins and a tipi for rent as well as picnic tables, a playground, and, in summer, guided nature day tours and evening interpretive talks.
BEYOND THE CAVE Most visitors know about the park’s popular campground, with its 40 sites (about half with electrical hookups), three cabins, and a tipi. And many take advantage of the 10mile trail system, used primarily by hikers in summer and mountain bikers during shoulder seasons (these trails are often snow-free when other area trails at higher GOOD BOY Growing numbers of visitors are taking to the park’s 10-plus miles of hiking and mountain biking trails. Though not allowed in the caverns, dogs are welcome on the trails year-round if leashed.
38 | MAY–JUNE 2020 | FWP.MT.GOV/MTOUTDOORS
elevations are impassable). But fewer may be aware of the park’s historic district, recognized in 2018 under the National Register of Historic Places. The district features projects constructed by the CCC from 1935 to 1941. Inside the cave, crews carved hundreds of stone steps and blasted a 538-foot exit tunnel. Outside, they built the road, cave access trails, an over-
look, and the upper visitor center, designed in the era’s rustic “Parkitecture” style. The workers’ skill is especially visible in the closely fitted stonework that makes up several culverts and a beautifully arched keystone bridge (ask park staff for directions). Their attention to detail also shows in the first building constructed for Montana’s first state park, a small stone latrine perched above the upper picnic area. Built in 1938, it’s a communal outhouse with “doubleseaters on both sides but no stall in between,” in Armstrong’s words. WILD THINGS A trip to the caverns is “really about taking the small moments to enjoy the park and the natural world that we have here, both inside and outside the cave,” say Smit, the park ranger. To help people appreciate these moments, interpreters lead programs on geology, history, and the area’s diverse plants and wildlife. Thanks to a broad range of elevations, from 4,200 feet at the Jefferson River to almost 6,000 feet atop Cave Mountain, the park supports an impressive variety of habitats. Assistant park manager Tom Forwood, who leads birding field trips, says roughly
140 bird species have been identified at the park, including two—the black-throated gray warbler and the Virginia’s warbler— rarely seen in Montana. But the park’s 10 species of bats are clearly the wildlife stars, featured in talks and tours during Bat Week each August. Seven species have been found in the cave, where guides are careful to ensure that no one is wearing or carrying anything that has been in a mine or another cave. The measures prevent introduction of white-nose syndrome, a fungal disease that has devastated bat populations in dozens of states east of Montana. During our time in the caverns, my boys and I catch a glimpse of a maternity colony of Townsend’s big-eared bats: What looks like a clump of silky brown “puppies” are clinging upside down from the cave wall.
According to Forwood, roughly 25 to 150 bats cluster in the maternity colony in June. In September, most disperse to parts unknown from their summer refuge. SAFE FROM THE STORM As long as the lights are on, I feel a sense of refuge in the cave myself. Near the end of our tour, a radio call warns our guide, Young-Dahl, of a dangerous thunderstorm outside. But we hear nothing from the Paradise Room; no crack of lightning or rumble of thunder can reach us. I find myself imagining how rainwater from the storm will eventually trickle down into the cave, each drop making a tiny revision to its architecture. Young-Dahl gives us a refresher on lightning safety while we wait for the storm to
pass. When another radio call gives us the all-clear, our group hurries down the exit tunnel and into the light. As we jog down the trail, splashing through puddles, I wonder if my sons will return someday, years from now, possibly bringing children of their own. If we continue as careful stewards of this underground wonderland, I know it will still be here, filled with shapes, spaces, and formations that remind us how nature is both timeless and ever-changing. And that we can find life and beauty in some of the world’s darkest places. Due to the coronavirus outbreak, Lewis & Clark Caverns and other Montana state parks may be closed in 2020 for indeterminate periods of time. Visit stateparks.mt.gov for updates, or call the park at (406) 287-3541.
WONDERS ABOVE AND BELOW Above left: The park’s original visitor center was built by the CCC in the 1930s. It and several other structures were designated in 2018 as a national historic district. Known today as the upper visitor center, it houses a small museum and serves as the park’s base for cave tours. Lower left: Taking a selfie at the Grand Finale Room. Above: Heading out the 538-foot-long exit tunnel carved by the CCC. MONTANA OUTDOORS | 39
BLAMING THE
BIRDS
Are pelicans, cormorants, and other winged piscivores harming game fish populations?
ast September, game wardens with Canyon Ferry Reservoir. In addition to peliMontana Fish, Wildlife & Parks dis- cans, anglers are expressing concern about covered roughly a dozen dead peli- double-crested cormorants, another federally cans along a stretch of the protected piscivore whose numbers have Bighorn River a few miles increased over the past 50 years after plumdownstream from Yellowtail Dam. The tail- meting due to widespread DDT application in water below the dam is considered one of the mid-1900s. Fingerlings and adult fish the nation’s top trout waters, though in in Montana lakes and streams fall prey to recent years fish numbers have declined sig- great blue herons and ospreys, too. nificantly. Game wardens said the pelicans, In short, there’s no scarcity of fishprotected under federal law, were killed with eating birds. And sometimes they eat trout. a shotgun, and dozens more may have been “Trout are especially delectable,” says David shot and killed in the same area. Schmetterling, FWP Fisheries Research FWP officials know that many anglers Program coordinator in Missoula. “They blame the fish-eating birds for depressed don’t have a lot of bones or spines on the body, trout numbers and suspect that some so they go down easy.” anglers are dishing out vigilante “justice.” Yet Schmetterling points out that the In Montana, the American white pelican diet of most fish-eating birds is mostly population has grown steadily during the species other than trout and other game 20th and early 21st centuries, according to fish. Carp, suckers, and small nongame Birds of Montana. What’s more, there’s no dis- fish—abundant in all of Montana’s river puting that pelicans eat fish. An adult pelican and reservoir sport fisheries—account for ingests from 20 to 40 percent (3 to 6 pounds) most of what pelicans and cormorants conof its 15-pound body weight in fish every day. sume. For instance, a 2006 FWP study on In addition to the Bighorn, FWP biologists Canyon Ferry Reservoir, stocked with tens report bird-related complaints from anglers of thousands of eight-inch rainbow trout on the Missouri and other trout rivers, and on each year, looked at stomach samples from 12 pelicans. Researchers found only a sinJack Ballard of Red Lodge is the author gle trout among mostly carp and crayfish. of several books, most recently Large The study also looked at stomach contents Mammals of the Rocky Mountains. from 52 cormorants and found that the 40 | MAY-JUNE 2019 | FWP.MT.GOV/MTOUTDOORS
birds were eating stonecats, a thumb-size member of the catfish family, far more than any other fish species. Though the study is 14 years old, biologists say that there’s no reason to think that bird diets have changed since then. A research project on Pathfinder Reservoir in Wyoming found that 77 percent of pelicans’ diet (by weight) consisted of common carp and white suckers. The big-billed birds also scooped up Iowa darters (a fingerlong member of the perch family), tiger salamanders, crayfish, and fathead minnows. “Predatory birds take the most available fish species,” says Schmetterling. “And in almost every reservoir and river, those aren’t game fish species.”
SHUTTERSTOCK
BY JACK BALLARD
COMEBACK A double-crested cormorant spreads its wings to dry after diving for fish. Numbers have increased on large rivers and reservoirs after the banning of DDT, which devastated populations. Though they eat fish, cormorants prefer smaller nongame species like stonecats rather than trout.
Predatory birds take the most available fish species, and in almost every reservoir and river, those aren’t game fish species.” MOSTLY SHALLOW Each bird species has a different method of nabbing fish. Double-crested cormorants— dark, streamlined birds often mistaken for ducks—dive into the water and pursue fish
with the powerful propulsion of their webbed feet. Cormorants’ powerful bills are hooked at the tip, enabling them to easily control wriggling fish. They tend to work the shallows but can dive to 25 feet when fishing. Pelicans use the pumpkin-colored pouch on their bill similar to how an angler scoops fish with a hand net. Groups of pelicans, known as squadrons, often hunt cooperatively, “herding” schools of minnows and other fish into shallow water less than six feet deep where they’re more easily scooped up. The big birds capably handle surprisingly large fish, too. At Pyramid Lake, Utah, researchers have documented pelicans occasionally taking carp and trout weighing up to 10 pounds. Pelicans sometimes feed at night, when crawfish and
certain fish species are more abundant in shallow water than during the day. Great blue herons stand motionless at the edges of rivers and reservoirs waiting for passing fish, which they catch with a swift, powerful thrust of their bill. The long-legged birds are limited to hunting in water no deeper than two feet and usually stick to even shallower water along the shoreline. Small fish make up most of a great blue heron’s diet, though the birds are known to spear frogs, snakes, and even ducklings and small mammals. Ospreys capture fish by diving into water after spotting them from overhead. The raptors are uniquely equipped for fishing. Their feathers are dense and oily like those
MONTANA OUTDOORS | 41
ROUGH FISH ROUNDUP White pelicans often feed in groups, herding smaller fish into the middle before scooping them up in their oversize bill. In one FWP study, nongame species like carp, along with crayfish, were the most common food item found in the birds’ stomachs.
. BIG GULP Great blue herons stand motionless in the shallows of rivers and reservoirs. Normally they kill small fish with a thrust of their swordlike beak, but occasionally the tall wading birds take larger specimens like adult common carp.
42 | MAY–JUNE 2020 | FWP.MT.GOV/MTOUTDOORS
ARTIFICIAL CONCENTRATIONS In natural environments with native fish populations, pelicans, cormorants, and herons similarly have little effect on game fish populations. That’s how piscivores and fish have coexisted for eons. But effects are different in manmade environments. “Bird predation tends to concentrate in places altered by humans where fish
ALL PHOTOS: SHUTTERSTOCK
of ducks and geese, allowing them to shed water. Unlike bald eagles, which only pluck fish from the water surface, ospreys may fully submerge when diving feet-first in pursuit of prey. Valves on their nostrils seal shut to prevent the bird from breathing water. Their opposable hind talons aid in grasping wriggling fish, as do tiny spines on the bottom of their feet known as “spicules.” For centuries, ospreys worldwide were maligned by commercial and recreational fishermen as pests thought to significantly reduce the number of fish available for humans. While it’s true that ospreys take mostly trout, studies indicate the raptors remove only a tiny percentage from a population and have no effect on recreational angling.
FISH HAWK Ospreys dive for trout and other game and nongame species, using their specially engineered talons to grasp the slippery prey. Studies show that no game fish populations have ever been significantly reduced from osprey predation.
We know that pelicans are not the reason that trout numbers are down on the Bighorn.” numbers are artifically concentrated,” Allison Begley, FWP avian conservation biologist, says. If not protected by nets, commercial catfish ponds in the South and hatchery ponds in other states can see substantial losses. Stocked trout ponds concentrate fish in ways that practically invite avian predators. Although pelicans and cormorants are protected by the 1918 Migratory Bird Treaty Act, many states have been granted permission by the U.S. Fish & Wildlife Service to kill both species. According to Schmetterling, Montana has resisted such extreme measures. “Many people don’t think it’s right to create fish-rich conditions that attract species like cormorants and pelicans, and then go out and shoot the birds,” he says. In Montana, tailwater fisheries below dams create human-altered, fish-dense
environments where piscivores gather in bow and brown trout. “We know that pelicans unnaturally high numbers. Trout and other are not the reason that trout numbers are fish may be stunned or injured when passing down on the Bighorn,” Ruggles says. through hydroelectric turbines or after tumBrian Scott, a native Montanan, has been bling down a spillway, making them easy a fly-fishing guide on the Missouri River for pickings. “Like human anglers, pelicans love more than 30 years and sees pelicans every tailwaters for the water clarity and high fish day. “They sometimes shut the fishing down densities,” says Begley. to a degree, but I’ve also seen trout rising It can be especially frustrating for anglers right next to where pelicans are swimming,” who aren’t catching fish to see pelicans pad- he says. One time Scott watched two pelicans dling nearby. “Pelicans can temporarily de- nab a couple of healthy adult trout when the crease fishing opportunities by putting trout fish were on the surface chasing bugs. But ‘down.’ But we track trout numbers each he’s observed many more instances where year on all the major rivers, and there’s no the opportunistic birds preyed on exhausted evidence that pelicans or any other bird pis- fish released by anglers. “I’ve been a vocal civores harm game fish populations any- defender of pelicans,” says Scott. “When I where,” Schmetterling says. was a kid, there really weren’t any around. That’s true even on the Bighorn, where I like to see them on the river.” 2019 trout numbers were the lowest on So do others who frequent rivers and record. Mike Ruggles, FWP regional fisheries reservoirs. “A squadron of white pelicans manager in Billings, says the population crash soaring overhead is one of the great wildlife is due to water releases from Yellowtail Dam, sights in Montana,” Schmetterling says. operated by the Bureau of Reclamation. The “I’m not the only one who considers it odd releases have either been too high or too low that someone would actually shoot those for adequate trout reproduction downstream. majestic birds, especially when doing so is In some cases, ill-timed flows have nearly a federal offense and wouldn’t improve wiped out all the eggs or fry of the river’s rain- their fishing one bit.” MONTANA OUTDOORS | 43
SKETCHBOOK
aybe there’s been a time when the natural world and outdoor recreation were more important to our collective psyche than they are right now. But I can’t recall when. We’re all a bit jittery, as local and world events change from day to day or even by the hour. Nothing seems certain. The air hums with a nervous vibe. Which is why I’m yearning, even more than usual, to get outside. I need to see that some things aren’t being upended by the latest press conference, overseas bulletin, or Dow Jones update. I suspect you are, too. Fortunately, it’s May in Montana, with the entire summer ahead of us. Excuse me while I let out a sigh of relief. How reassuring it will be to drive past rivers and see trout dappling the surface. To pass pickups parked along streamside pulloffs, license plates covered in mayflies and caddis. Already, yellow warblers are announcing spring from the tops of streamside cottonwoods. In mature conifer forests, western tanagers are flitting from tree to tree. Atop fence posts, meadowlarks are welcoming the warming weather with their amplified anthems. Wildflowers are blooming everywhere. Walleye are still shallow right now and will be for a few more weeks, before moving deeper as the water warms. That’s how it has always been with walleye, and this summer will be no different. Mountain biking trails have begun drying out, and soon riders will be whizzing through forests, looking down for rocks and up ahead for bears. Rivers are running high with spring runoff, making for dangerous (or exhilarating, dependTom Dickson is editor of Montana Outdoors.
44 | MAY–JUNE 2020 | FWP.MT.GOV/MTOUTDOORS
ing on your skill level) whitewater rafting and kayaking. Peak baggers have their maps spread out on kitchen tables, planning which summits to tackle next. State parks are preparing for the summer rush, with maintenance crews finishing a paint job here, a cleanup there, making everything shipshape for guests. People are breaking out their camping gear, smelling wood smoke in sleeping bags pulled from storage. They’re checking tents for holes, seeing if the pop-up camper still pops up, buying spare mantles for the propane lantern. Turkey hunters are out in the woods at sunup, as they always are this time of year, listening for the gobbles of lovelorn toms. A friend emails to say she’s planning a four-day canoe trip along the Missouri’s White Cliffs area. Another calls to say he drew a permit to float the Smith. It’s almost summer in Montana. I can hardly wait. Earlier this spring I was walking the dog
after dark and heard hundreds of snow geese passing over Helena. Illuminated by the city lights, they appeared as ghostly squadrons overhead, making their way north to Freezeout Lake as they have for eons. I thought how fortunate we are, those of us who live in places like this, where we can regularly restore our faith that the natural world still marches on, even during these unsettling times. Where we can step outside and witness timeless rituals that continue whether we see them or not. I find reassurance in nature’s relentless reliability. Several weeks ago, a red-winged blackbird’s scratchy conk-a-leeee signaled his springtime arrival at the pond outside my office window, just as he does every year. Welcome back, I wanted to tell him. Thanks for always coming back.
ILLUSTRATION BY STAN FELLOWS
Reassurance M
MONTANA OUTDOORS PORTRAIT
American Avocet Recurvirostra americana
By Lex Hames
D
TOP TO BOTTOM: CRAIG & LIZ LARCOM; STEVEN AKRE
uring a previous incarnation as a video producer of TV segments on waterfowl and wetlands, I spent countless days walking and even crawling around prairie marshes. Although my job was to film ducks and geese, I grew increasingly fond of those other fascinating denizens of shallow water: shorebirds, especially the American avocet. To my mind, the avocet is the most elegant and stylish of wading birds. Dressed in a finely tailored suit of white, black, and soft cinnamon, this stately, statuesque bird strides along the shorelines of shallow lakes and marshes like a member of England’s royal family out for a stroll. Except that sometimes, when resting, it stands on one leg, which nobility rarely do. APPEARANCE With their black-and-white striped wings, cinnamon head carried high, and long legs as trim as walking sticks, male and female avocets cut an elegant appearance. Standing about 18 inches tall, they are one of Montana’s larger wading birds. Avocets change their outfit twice each year. In winter plumage, they lose the rusty shade on the head and breast, and sport strictly black-and-white attire. A flock of winter avocets resembles a herd of tiny flying zebras. The black-and-white stripes, moving with rapid wingbeats, create a dizzying zigzag pattern of dark and light sweeping Lex Hames is a writer and video producer in Helena.
through the sky. In spring, the cinnamon head coloring returns. The slender, sharply pointed bill of both sexes curves slightly upward, the female’s a bit more than the male’s. SOUND An avocet produces a series of SCIENTIFIC NAME Recurvirostra comes from the Latin notes that have a Doppler-like recurvus, “curved backwards,” and rostrum, “bill.” The effect. They rise in pitch as they avocet’s common name derives from the Italian name for come closer, creating the same a similar bird found in Europe and Eurasia: avosetta. impression as when a train rushes toward you with its whistle blowing, the whistle’s blast rising in pitch as it simple structures. Either the female or draws nearer. As the avocet approaches a male creates a scrape in the ground with its ground predator, it raises the pitch of its call, breast and feet, then lines the shallow creating the impression that it is approaching depression with grass, feathers, pebbles, or faster than it is—a neat trick for a bird defend- other small objects. A mating pair engages ing its nest. in elaborate “cross-bill” displays before and after mating—think of crossed swords FOOD held high. Both parents incubate the eggs. For all their delicacy and beauty, avocets If the eggs get too warm, one parent dips make their living in the muck. They’re its belly feathers in the water and returns “mudders,” working shallow marshes and to cool the nest. thin sheets of open water, waving their long, thin bill back and forth like a rapier to HABITAT nab minnows, crustaceans, and aquatic in- Avocets require shallow marshes and mud sects. Like all wading birds, they have long flats submerged a few inches where they can stilt-like legs that hold their body above the stroll and forage for aquatic invertebrates water. When walking, the avocet’s legs and small fish. move swiftly up and down, carrying the bird forward in a determined, high-step- CONSERVATION STATUS ping manner. Though avocet numbers have diminished across parts of North America, due mainly REPRODUCTION to wetland loss, they’re still abundant in Avocets nest on flat ground near water in Montana and other northern Great Plains states. This prairie bird has been here for a long time, making it an important part of our state’s natural heritage. WHERE TO WATCH Avocets usually arrive at their breeding grounds from late April to late May. Look for them in eastern and central Montana marshes, ponds, and alkaline lakes throughout spring and summer. Avocet-watching hot spots include Freezeout Lake, Benton Lake, and Lake Bowdoin. MONTANA OUTDOORS | 45
THE OUTSIDE IS IN US ALL.
OVERLOOKING TWO MEDICINE VALLEY, BY CHUCK HANEY
Whether it’s by hunting, fishing, camping, boating, mountain biking, wildlife watching, or hiking to a ridge in Glacier National Park, Montana is a state where everyone can find their own special way to connect with the natural world. Around here, the outside is in us all.
MONTANA OUTDOORS
On-line: fwp.mt.gov/mtoutdoors Subscriptions: 800-678-6668 Montana Outdoors Magazine
$3.50