ONE HUNDRED AND TWENTY-NINE YEARS OF EDITORIAL FREEDOM
Friday, April 3, 2020
Ann Arbor, Michigan
michigandaily.com
Students discuss impact of losing on-campus employment following coronavirus outbreak As most University operations shut down, employees leave work with no return date IULIA DOBRIN
Daily Staff Reporter
With businesses temporarily closing and Gov. Gretchen Whitmer’s Stay Home, Stay Safe Executive Order, many students’ on-campus jobs have been left in limbo. When the news of moving to remote learning broke on March 11, LSA freshman Zachary said he planned to stay on campus and continue working with MDining at South Quad Residence Hall. He has held this position since November and said he hoped to pick up extra hours in light of online classes and reduced social gatherings. Burton said he didn’t have too many concerns about staying on campus initially. “It was a little bit stressful, but I didn’t let it get to me that much,” Burton said. “After a certain point, you’re just like, ‘Okay, here we go again. Here’s another mess to deal with.’” However, as University of Michigan Housing encouraged people who are able to leave campus, Burton said he found himself feeling like one of the last people living in South Quad.
DESIGN BY CARA JHANG
“I know everyone in my friend group left before I did, because I was intending to stay on campus,” Burton said. “I decided to leave once I realized that it’s going to shut down soon anyway.” As for his job, MDining is allowing student employees to stop working if they leave campus while still being able to resume their job once they return to campus. According to Burton,
the University Housing refund covered what he would have been making had he not taken on any extra hours. Even so, Burton said he is still worried about not having an income at this time, especially since both of his parents had to stop working due to the pandemic. “I still would have liked to make more (money) because my family situation is not really the best at
the moment,” Burton said. “I want to help out with that but I can’t, really.” LSA freshman Katie Carroll also had an on-campus job she has held since last semester working as a student-teacher classroom aide at the North Campus Children’s Center. It was during one of her shifts at the Children’s Center that she got news of class cancellation.
MI virus response on par with other states Neighboring regions follow similar stay-at-home guidelines, allocate funds for crisis JULIA FANZERES Daily Staff Reporter
The Michigan state legislature passed two bills to appropriate $150 million in response to the coronavirus pandemic. On March 17, the House unanimously passed House Bill 4729. The bill appropriated $50 million to the Health and Human Services Department, which requires the funds to be distributed to critical health care providers in order to expand the state’s response to the coronavirus. It also allocated $75 million to the Department of Technolog y, Management and Budget and those funds are authorized for public health emergencies and related economic responses to
GOT A NEWS TIP? Call 734-418-4115 or e-mail news@michigandaily.com and let us know.
DESIGN BY LIZZY RUEPPEL
various departments. On March 30, the Michigan Senate passed Senate Bill 151, which created and distributed an additional $15 million into the Coronavirus Response Fund along with $10 million to other various departments,
Follow The Daily on Instagram, @michigandaily
totaling state funding for the coronavirus pandemic to $150 million. In a joint statement, Gov. Gretchen Whitmer and legislative leaders addressed the signing of the supplemental bills. The statement noted
For more stories and coverage, visit
the funding will allow for the purchasing of medical supplies essential for Michigan to slow the spread of the virus. “Today’s signing of two supplemental budget bills will provide new state funding of $150 million to bolster response efforts,” the statement reads. “To date, the state has already expended more than $130 million to secure more than 20 million masks, more than 2,000 ventilators, nearly 9 million ounces of hand sanitizer, more than 255,000 boxes of gloves, 2.4 million gowns, more than 2,000 beds, 210,000 testing supplies, 3,000 thermometers, 185,000 face shields, 22,000 cartons of disinfecting wipes, as well as other needed supplies.” See MICHIGAN, Page 3
michigandaily.com
INDEX
Vol. CXXIX, No. 98 ©2020 The Michigan Daily
“It was a little nerve-wracking — the fact that our classes had been canceled and the University basically shut was emailed to us during my shift,” Carroll said. “The Children’s Center still couldn’t get permission to close for like five days beyond that, even though they’re part of the University … so a lot of the teachers were nervous about that.” See EMPLOYMENT, Page 3
CAMPUS LIFE
Future of internships uncertain Students’ summer plans face threat of cancellation SARA ZHAO For The Daily
For many students at the University of Michigan, summer is a time to gain experience in the real world through jobs and internships. However, as the number of COVID-19 cases in the United States and worldwide has continued to rise, many summer internships and jobs have been canceled, leaving some students scrambling to find other plans. See SUMMER, Page 3 NEWS.........................2 OPINION.....................4 A R T S . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5 SPORTS.........................7
News
2 — Friday, April 3, 2020
The Michigan Daily — michigandaily.com
Stanford Lipsey Student Publications Building 420 Maynard St. Ann Arbor, MI 48109-1327 www.michigandaily.com
ELIZABETH LAWRENCE Editor in Chief 734-418-4115 ext. 1251 esla@michigandaily.com
ANITA MICHAUD
Business Manager 734-418-4115 ext. 1241 ammichau@michigandaily.com
NEWS TIPS
news@michigandaily.com
LETTERS TO THE EDITOR tothedaily@michigandaily.com
EDITORIAL PAGE
opinion@michigandaily.com
PHOTOGRAPHY SECTION
ARTS SECTION
photo@michigandaily.com
arts@michigandaily.com
NEWSROOM
SPORTS SECTION
734-418-4115 opt. 3
sports@michigandaily.com
CORRECTIONS
ADVERTISING
corrections@michigandaily.com
DOMINICK SOKOTOFF/Daily Ian Shackelford, assistant distiller at the Ann Arbor Distilling company, mixes ingredients together to make hand sanitizer Thursday in response to the COVID-19 pandemic.
Annual rally, march against sexual violence moves online Forty-second year of ‘Take Back the Night’ features local activists, performances including spoken word poetry also to take place JENNA SITEMAN Daily Staff Reporter
The Take Back The Night rally, usually held every year in Ann Arbor, was broadcasted on Thursday in a 29-minute YouTube video, including clips from keynote speaker Jaclyn Friedman, an activist for sexual violence awareness. Presented by the Standing Tough Against Rape Society and the University Students Against Rape, the video contained messages from student organizers as well as from Pam Swider, STARS executive director and founder. The rally began with a message from Swider addressing the different format of the event. She said she hoped the video would uplift survivors and others tuning in. “Things are a bit different this year,” Swider said. “And though we’re not in the Michigan Leag ue ballroom like we planned, we are still here to come together to raise awareness about sexual violence, and most importantly, to uplift survivors and give them and you all watching hope during this time.” Friedman acknowledged the fearful feelings of many in the public right now due to the current COVID-19 health crisis. She said the situation may be reminiscent of trauma to some viewers. “This is probably rhyming
with trauma, right?” Friedman said. “A lot of us feel out of control; we feel like men we don’t trust have a lot of control over our lives. It’s scary; it’s really scary. Some of us are in close quarters and can’t live with people who are not safe to us. So I don’t in any way want to minimize what we’re all going through right now.” Friedman said survivors can utilize streng th gained from past events during this time of stress. “We are survivors, and that means we know how to survive,” Friedman said. “So I want to really encourage you to spend some time taking care
affects certain groups, such as those from minority groups. “Sexual violence pervades specific communities at higher rates,” Mullapudi said. “People in the LGBTQ+ community, people of color, people with disabilities, Native Americans, students in Greek life and many other people who sit at an intersection of these identities have a disproportionately higher risk of experiencing sexual violence in their lives.” Additionally, the video featured a poetry reading from a volunteer member from USAR and a performance from the Detroit Women’s Chorus. Art & Design senior Ariel Friedlander, senior student leader of USAR, thanked the sponsors of the event including Planned Parenthood, Drifter Coffee, Ann Arbor Tortilla Factory and Literati Bookstore. Friedlander also acknowledged Swider and her husband Tom Swider for founding this event 12 years ago. “They have been such an incredible resource when it comes to knowledge, inspiration, courage, and just overall emotional support,” Friedlander said. “They’ve allowed us to hold this event and also so many others and they are the glue that keeps Take Back The Night Ann Arbor together, and we just cannot appreciate them enough.”
We are survivors, and that means we know how to survive. So I want to really encourage you to spend some time taking care of yourself, and reflecting on what got you through the things you’ve survived already? What are the lessons you learned from that, that you can apply now?
of yourself, and ref lecting on what got you through the things you’ve survived already? What are the lessons you learned from that, that you can apply now?” The event also included informational clips recorded by members of USAR meant to inform the audience on the different forms of sexual violence, such as trafficking, indecent exposure or sexual abuse. LSA junior Shreya Mullapudi, USAR’s grants writer, said sexual violence disproportionately
dailydisplay@gmail.com
Editorial Staff ERIN WHITE Managing Editor
ekwhite@michigandaily.com
SAYALI AMIN and LEAH GRAHAM Managing News Editors
news@michigandaily.com
Senior News Editors: Barbara Collins, Claire Hao, Alex Harring, Ben Rosenfeld, Emma Stein, Liat Weinstein Assistant News Editors: Francesca Duong, Julia Forrest, Brayden Hirsh, Jasmin Lee, Hannah Mackay, Parnia Mazhar, Alyssa McMurtry, Emma Ruberg, Julia Rubin, Michal Ruprecht, Arjun Thakkar
EMILY CONSIDINE and MILES STEPHENSON
Editorial Page Editors tothedaily@michigandaily.com Senior Opinion Editors: Alanna Berger, Brittany Bowman, Zack Blumberg, Timothy Spurlin, Joel Weiner
THEO MACKIE and ETHAN SEARS Managing Sports Editors
sportseditors@michigandaily.com
Senior Sports Editors: Aria Gerson, Bailey Johnson, Ben Katz, Jacob Kopnick, Anna Marcus, Rian Ratnavale Assistant Sports Editors: Connor Brennan, Lily Friedman, Lane Kizziah, Brendan Roose, Kent Schwartz, Molly Shea
JOHN DECKER and JULIANNA MORANO Managing Arts Editors
arts@michigandaily.com
Senior Arts Editors: Jo Chang, Elise Godfryd, Zoe Phillips, Jonah Mendelson, Ally Owens Arts Beat Editors: Samantha Cantie, Dana Pierangeli, Andrew Pluta, Cassandra Mansuetti, Anish Tamhaney, Sophia Yoon
SHERRY CHEN and CHRISTINE JEGARL
Managing Design Editors design@michigandaily.com Senior Design Editor: Lizzy Rueppel
ALLISON ENGKVIST and ANNIE KLUSENDORF Managing Photo Editors
photo@michigandaily.com
Senior Photo Editors: Keemya Esmael, Asha Lewis, Miles Macklin Assistant Photo Editors: Olivia Cell, Ryan Little, Emma Mati, Alexandria Pompei, Alexis Rankin
MAGDALENA MIHAYLOVA Managing Statement Editor
statement@michigandaily.com
Deputy Editors: Emily Stillman, Marisa Wright
MADISON GAGNE and SADIA JIBAN Managing Copy Editors
copydesk@michigandaily.com
Senior Copy Editors: Olivia Bradish, Sophie Kephart, Silas Lee, Olivia Sedlacek, Ellie Scott
TIM CHO and SIMRAN PUJJI
Managing Online Editors webteam@michigandaily.com Senior Web Developers: Parth Dhyani, Abha Panda, Rohan Prashant, Jonathan Liu
ALEC COHEN and ELI SIDER
Managing Video Editors Senior Video Editors: Joseph Sim
video@michigandaily.com
MAYA MOKH and ANA MARIA SANCHEZ CASTILLO Michigan in Color Editors
michiganincolor@michigandaily.com
Senior Michigan in Color Editors: Zoha Bharwani, Lora Faraj, Ayomide Okunade, Gabrijela Skoko Assistant Michigan in Color Editors: Cheryn Hong, Anamkia Kannan, Vaishali Nambiar, Sean Tran, Angela Zhang
SAMANTHA SMALL and SONYA VOGEL Managing Podcast Editors
JOHN GRIEVE and BEN KORN
Managing Social Media Editors Senior Social Media Editors: Jessie Norris, Mya Steir, Kristina Zheng
Business Staff MOLLY WU
Creative Director
RYAN KELLY Sales Manager
LILLY HANSON
Senior Account Executive
ANALISE DOORHY Senior Account Executive
TARA MOORE
Senior Account Exeucutive
The Michigan Daily (ISSN 0745-967) is published Monday through Friday during the fall and winter terms by students at the University OF Michigan. One copy is available free of charge to all readers. Additional copies may be picked up at the Daily’s office for $2. Subscriptions for September-April are $250 and year long subscriptions are $275. University affiliates are subject to a reduced subscription rate. On-campus subscriptions for fall term are $35. Subscriptions must be prepaid.
The Michigan Daily — michigandaily.com
EMPLOYMENT From Page 1 When the Children’s Center closed, Carroll said she and other employees were offered the option to work directly with the children at the Children’s Center as nannies. However, since she lived in a residence hall, she left campus and was unable to utilize this option. Besides the financial hit, Carroll said there was an emotional toll of having to leave her job.
MICHIGAN From Page 1 LSA junior Isabelle Bogojevic, communications chair for the policy group U-M Roosevelt Institute, said she appreciated Michigan’s localized efforts to the outbreak. “In regards to that $2 trillion that was passed, we know that it’s not being distributed to most college-age students and there’s a bunch of other shortcomings in that bill as well,” Bogojevic said. “While I think that the stimulus bill is going to be helpful for many … it seems to be a very short-sighted plan to me. So I think Gretchen Whitmer, like early on, did a good job of
SUMMER From Page 1 Besides being a valuable experience for learning, internships are often stepping stones to full-time job offers. In a survey conducted by the National Association of Colleges and Employers (NACE) in 2019, 57.5 percent of graduates in the class of 2019 who had internship experience received full-time job offers. LSA senior Nissa ThodesenKasparian had planned for an internship at Estrel Berlin in Germany since October, with hopes of finding a full-time job in Berlin at the conclusion of her internship. “My original plans for postgraduation were to continue searching for a full-time job while in Berlin (through May and June) so that I could move onto this position immediately after I left the Estrel,” Thodesen-Kasparian said. Now, she’s struggling to find alternative plans. “The most jarring thing about this process then has been that now I am scrambling a bit to find another summer internship or full-time job, which is a bit difficult because a lot of deadlines have already passed and there’s still a chance summer internships even in Michigan might be pushed back,” ThodesenKasparian said. Other students, like LSA sophomore Josh Bauman, expressed worry about
News
Friday, April 3, 2020 — 3
“I wasn’t expecting that I was going to get a job at a place that I love so much,” Carroll said. “It’s hard to not see those kids a couple times a week because I really did love my job … one of the favorite parts of my week is gone until further notice.” LSA sophomore Trenten Ingell has continued his job as an organization peer advisor with the Center for Campus Involvement remotely. He recognizes he is in a better position than most students. In light of the situation, Ingell has worked on a number
of petitions, including a call to stop on- and off-campus rent payments. According to the petition, these efforts hope to help students faced with the choice of staying on campus to work despite health concerns or going home and risking not being able to pay rent. “A lot of people have lost their ability to work and provide at least some sort of income for themselves,” Ingell said. “I think that’s certainly been an issue for a lot of people.” Ultimately, while Burton said losing his job temporarily
has been difficult, he said he believes he can get through this challenging time. “Even though it’s a mess I’ve never dealt with before, it’s still a mess I can deal with,” Burton said. “We’ll get through it somehow.”
tackling this crisis. So I think that the state legislators’ action is just another way that the state of Michigan is responding.” The Daily analyzed neighboring states’ plans to see how they stack up to Michigan’s. OHIO: The state of Michigan’s reaction to the coronavirus comes on the heels of Ohio Gov. Mike DeWine, who has been applauded for his proactive efforts in combating COVID19. On March 12, DeWine was the first governor to call for a statewide closure of public schools, even though Ohio had yet to suffer a major outbreak of COVID-19. Both DeWine and the Ohio
state legislature have worked together to enact House Bill 197 providing emergency relief to Ohioans during the COVID-19 pandemic. The bill amends several codes to expand unemployment benefits for individuals out of work due to COVID-19, prohibit water shutoffs, move the state tax deadline from April 15 to July 15 and extend absentee voting for the Ohio primary to April 28. INDIANA: In Indiana, the state legislature has not passed any relief for COVID-19. In an interview with TV station WXIN , state Rep. Jim Banks, R-Ind., said he is waiting to see how the $2-trillion federal relief
package will impact the state before allocating more aid. “I really do believe we need to let those three aid packages play out, then we can go back after that and see what needs to be done,” Banks said. ILLINOIS: The state of Illinois has paired up with the nonprofit United Way of Illinois and the Alliance of Illinois Community Foundations to launch a statewide fundraising effort to support nonprofits. Other than the partnership, the new fund would be separate and independent from the state as they hope to fundraise for providing emergency food and basic supplies, interim housing
how the loss of summer opportunities would affect how graduate and medical schools evaluated applications. As a pre-med student, undergraduate research is often considered important for prospective medical and graduate school applicants. “I was going to continue a (research) internship that I had from last year,” Bauman said. “I’d say I feel like some of my competitive advantage is being taken away against my will. Who is to say that my med school application might look weaker than it would have with a blank spot in the junior year summer slot where other students may have completed internships, published papers, studied abroad.” For LSA sophomore Lena Vushaj, the cancellation of her summer internship working with the National Security of Albania to research archives from the communist regime was not only a loss of an educational experience but also a missed opportunity to explore her family heritage. “My parents were from Albania and they experienced communist Albania, so I g uess it was not only an educational experience, but it was more of an experience of personal growth,” Vushaj said. “And in the future I want to be a law yer — maybe an immigration law yer — so knowing what people went through and what made them the way they are today
would’ve helped me better understand them.” Furthermore, the lack of communication between internships and students have left many frustrated. LSA sophomore Louie Orleans has yet to receive an official statement on the cancellation of his planned internship in Washing ton, D.C. through the University’s Public Service Intern Program. He said this uncertainty is hindering him from committing to alternative summer plans. “Lots of the jobs and internships have gotten delayed or are unresponsive … I don’t have a summer job at this point, but I’m still uncertain if I can even take summer classes without knowing what’s happening with the program,” Orleans said. Thodesen-Kasparian expressed similar thoughts. After receiving a mass email from her program coordinator, ThodesenKasparian said she hasn’t received any further contact from anyone — including Estrel Berlin — addressing her individual situation. “The most frustrating part of the whole process was the fact that I felt like I wasn’t really consoled individually about my internship,” Thodesen-Kasparian said. “I understand that there are limits to what the University can do and it made sense to cancel all internships en masse early on, but it was
In an interview with The Daily March 27, University President Mark Schlissel said students who are not longer working won’t be paid, but noted the University is working to find a job for students who stayed on campus and wish to continue to
work. “Work study is a work program, so if they’re not working I don’t believe we can pay them at home for not working,” Schlissel said. “But the students that are, we’ve endeavored to keep employed, because we’ve realized that many of the students rely on that income and a lot of it’s being done on a case-by-case basis.” Daily Staff Reporter Iulia Dobrin can be reached at idobrin@umich.edu.
and shelter, primary health care services and other essential needs. While Gov. J.B. Pritzker has filed for a waiver to expand Medicaid coverage and announced new measures to help small businesses struggling financially, the Illinois legislature has not passed any laws allocating funding for the coronavirus pandemic. All four states are under stayat-home or shelter-in-place orders. Daily Staff Reporter Julia Fanzeres can be reached at julfan@umich.edu.
DESIGN BY ERIN RUARK
honestly frustrating to me that my internship and plans for my future were up and canceled on my behalf before I could really even consider alternative options.” Despite the current environment, ThodesenKasparian said she is thankful for her resources. “The whole situation was
upsetting, but more than anything right now I’m just grateful that I’m back home with my family where I feel safe during these uncertain times because by no means is that everyone’s situation,” Thodesen-Kasparian said. Reporter Sarah Zhao can be reached at srahzhao@umich. edu
Opinion
4 — Friday, April 3, 2020
The Michigan Daily — michigandaily.com
KIANNA MARQUEZ | COLUMN
We should face climate change like we face the pandemic
Edited and managed by students at the University of Michigan since 1890. Stanford Lipsey Student Publications Building 420 Maynard St. Ann Arbor, MI 48109 tothedaily@michigandaily.com
ELIZABETH LAWRENCE EMILY CONSIDINE AND MILES STEPHENSON Editor in Chief Editorial Page Editors
ERIN WHITE Managing Editor
EDITORIAL BOARD MEMBERS Alanna Berger Zack Blumberg Brittany Bowman Emily Considine Jess D’Agostino
Jenny Gurung Cheryn Hong Krystal Hur Ethan Kessler Zoe Phillips Mary Rolfes
Michael Russo Timothy Spurlin Miles Stephenson Joel Weiner Erin White
Unsigned editorials reflect the official position of The Daily’s Editorial Board. All other signed articles and illustrations represent solely the views of their authors.
MARY ROLFES | COLUMN
Upholding health care as a human right during a health crisis
I
’m sure I’m not alone in feeling that it’s been difficult to focus on anything other than the coronavirus pandemic for the past two weeks. As much as I try to keep motivated, it’s almost impossible to stay present during a dragging Zoom lecture or a dense reading. My mind wanders and questions what these minor endeavors mean in the face of a worldwide crisis. Even my usual litany of distractions can’t offer refuge, with Twitter updating me on the death toll and Facebook bombarding me with coronavirus memes. For some, impacts have been far more severe than lack of motivation — they have lost jobs, homes, business and even loved ones to the pandemic. The most radical change for many of us is being abruptly forced into stagnancy. But just because our lives have effectively been halted does not meantheworldhascometoastandstill. The Democratic nomination process marchesonwithfrontrunnerJoeBiden notably absent, the worst locust plague in decades is swarming in East Africa and the oil price war between Russia andSaudiArabiacontinues.Eventsthat wouldtypicallypopulateheadlineshave become secondary to the coronavirus coverage. Clearly, COVID-19 has consumed our lives and our news cycle the past several weeks — and it’s about to do the same to our health care system. The situation in Italy provides a sobering glimpse of what could be in storefortheUnitedStatesinthecoming days. Hospitals are overwhelmed, medical equipment is limited and medical staff are being overworked. This devastating example may soon be ourreality,withtheU.S.rankingfirstin theworldforCOVID-19cases,anumber which will only continue to grow. Cases double every three days, a figure which is prompting hospitals to find as many beds as they can to prepare for an onslaught of critical patients. The 74,000 intensive care unit beds that operated in 2018 are insufficient to handle the coming crisis. And just as the world has not stopped turning, medical issues unrelated to COVID-19 havenotceased.Cardiacarrests,cancer and childbirth will not simply yield to theviralevent,andourmedicalsystem cannot divert all resources to fighting the virus without neglecting the needs of millions of Americans. Overwhelmed health care infrastructure is not the only thing threatening America’s health — with the country focused on COVID-19,
players with ulterior motives are presented an opportunity to discreetly alter health care for the worse. As difficult as it may be, we must remain vigilant and motivated in refusing to allow those in power to take advantage of this crisis by reducing health care accessibility for marginalized people. We cannot forget, even as we face a public health crisis, that health care is a human right we must always fight to protect. Just as many states, including Michigan, have ordered citizens to avoidallnonessentialsocialinteraction, U.S. Surgeon General Jerome Adams has urged that all “nonessential elective procedures” be canceled or delayedduringtheCOVID-19outbreak. However, typifying all non-urgent procedures as “elective” is a dangerous move for health care rights after the crisis. The first thing that comes to mind for many people when they think of an “elective” procedure are those that are medically unnecessary, such as cosmetic plastic surgery. But the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services’listofpostponableprocedures includes colonoscopies and other endoscopies,cataractsurgeryandeven low-riskcancersurgeries,allofwhichare rarely considered “unnecessary.” One supposedly “nonessential” branch of medical care will likely get little mention by the Trump Administration — gender-affirming surgeries for transgender and nongender conforming individuals. The pandemic has shed light on how these necessaryproceduresarestillconsidered “elective”bymanypractitioners,policymakers and medical institutions. Even in normal circumstances, these marginalized individuals often have theirhealthneedsinvalidatedandtheir procedures significantly postponed — sometimes for years — with devastating consequences. For trans patientsthatarealreadyfightingtohave theirproceduresconsideredmedically necessary, allowing those in power to conflate gender-related surgeries as “elective” could present a dangerous blow to trans health rights. We need to make it absolutely clear that the term“nonessential”onlyapplieswithin the limits of this crisis. And while we can acknowledge that delaying these procedures is a reasonable measure given the circumstances, we should also hold space for the anger and disappointment felt by those impacted and provide extra support during this difficult time. Most importantly, we must remain dedicated to
advocating for these procedures to be considered essential after the crisis is over; they must be attended to in a timely manner, covered by public or private insurance and treated as valid by health care providers and systems. Another already stigmatized medical issue exacerbated by the pandemicisabortionservices.Already, state officials in Ohio and Texas have capitalized on this crisis and the “nonessential” mandate to further their anti-choice agenda. They claim to act under the initiative to preserve medical resources for COVID-19 care, but their true motives are incredibly transparent given their recent efforts to severely limit and penalize the right to choose. Their categorization of abortionsasnonessentialgoesdirectly against a recent statement by the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists which deems abortion “an essential component of comprehensive health care,” one which must be maintained during this crisis. Moreover, these procedures use relatively few medical resources and are inherently time-sensitive. For now, Planned Parenthood is fighting back against these dangerous mandates. Unfortunately, Ohio and Texas are just two of several states which have been relentlessly chipping away at women’s rights, and more states may follow their example in the future. As such, we must be prepared to continue supporting Planned Parenthood and other abortion providers throughout the duration of the crisis, ensuring women have access to essential health care services and making it clear to lawmakers that their efforts to take advantageofacrisistodiminishhuman rightshavenotgoneunnoticed,norwill they continue without a fight. Facing the reality of a global health crisis can certainly make finding motivation difficult, but even as we are socially isolated, our interest in the common good can bring us together. Althoughwearephysicallyapart,wecan stand in solidarity for the right to health care.Theforcesworkingagainsthuman rights have not yielded to this crisis — in fact, many have found increased mobility as the global community is focused elsewhere. We, too, must mobilize, fighting against those who would take advantage of the crisis and workingtofixtheissuesrevealedbythis pandemic. The world has not stopped moving forward — neither should we. Mary Rolfes can be reached at morolfes@umich.edu.
I
n early March, Michigan Gov. Gretchen Whitmer declared a state of emergency in Michigan. Citizens are harboring unease and fear about the coronavirus pandemic. In an effort to flatten the curve, Whitmer enacted mandatory self-quarantine and social distancing for all people with nonessential jobs to try and limit the spread of the coronavirus. Since Gov. Whitmer’s order, Michigan has experienced 10,791 confirmed cases of the virus and 417 deaths as of April 2. While these numbers are substantial, it could have been much worse if the Michigan state government didn’t begin enacting these emergency measures to slow the spread of the virus. For good reason, state and federal governments have assumed the responsibility of overseeing public health and safety as the dangers of the pandemic affect our country. Similar precautionary emergency measures are being taken in other states as well, attesting to just how dangerous the virus is and just how important our response to it is. From my position of privilege, I have thought about how effectively we could address our climate emergency if we took the same prompt and drastic action. One cannot deny that global climate change is a risk to all people just as a pandemic is a risk to all people. Therefore, one should trust that drastic measures could lift mankind out of the climate crisis just as these drastic measures are working to lift us out of the coronavirus crisis. In upholding the law of the land, the United States Congress has recognized the severity of this pandemic. With limited internal gridlock, it has managed to pass legislation that addresses the drastic financial needs of this emergency. As a result, direct payments of $1,200 will initially be made to taxpayers with incomes up to $75,000 per year and overall unemployment benefits will grow substantially. It is commendable that our government is addressing the economic needs of the people who face massive upheaval as a result of unemployment. At the same time, I trust that if we all considered the climate emergency to be as urgent of an emergency as this pandemic, a provisional economic subsidy would, in fact, be feasible
for our government and therefore not an insurmountable task. Some people are reluctant to see the benefits of such emergency measures due to the compromises that they bring about for other circles of society, such as education, socialization and public security. Students everywhere are facing a sudden change in their academic landscape, with some institutions transitioning completely to online forms and some experiencing an abrupt pause altogether. As people continue to distance themselves from those they previously interacted with often, social media has become a necessary tool to socialize and maintain connection with others. In an effort to slow the spread of the virus nationwide and internationally, travel by way of any vehicle has been discouraged altogether until it becomes safer to gather in masses. While people are adapting and coping with these compromises, we still can’t ignore the fact that they are discomforting and inconvenient. For some, this is enough to argue that emergency measures should not be so restrictive or should not be taken, despite the obvious emergency. While it has become uncomfortable to make these economic, social and educational changes, this doesn’t justify ignoring the danger of the pandemic. In his daily news conference, New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo emphasized that he intends to prioritize saving lives over restarting the economy. Cuomo said, “If you ask the American people to choose between public health and the economy, then it’s no contest. No American is going to say, ‘accelerate the economy at the cost of human life.’ Because no American is going to say how much a life is worth.” None of us want to make these drastic adjustments to our lifestyles, but we are accepting that this is what we need to do for the greater good and for public health. Just as we accept that this is what needs to be done to persist through the pandemic, we should accept that we cannot ignore the emergency of climate change any
Read more at MichiganDaily.com Kianna Marquez can be reached at kmarquez@umich.edu.
ANNA GETZINGER | CONTACT CARTOONIST AT GETZINGA@UMICH.EDU
Arts
The Michigan Daily — michigandaily.com
Friday, April 3, 2020 — 5
MUSIC REVIEW
Nicolas Jaar recorded ‘Cezinas’ for times just like this JIM WILSON
Daily Arts Writer
Just a few hours before the release of his highly anticipated album Cezinas, Nicolas Jaar took to his blog to provide listeners with some background info. He wrote: “The music comes from a desire to feel everything -- a few years ago, I stopped drinking alcohol, smoking, consuming caffeine, eating animals, etc., and, for a period of time, I also quarantined myself alone somewhere on the other side of the world to be able to work on music for months on end. I didn’t want to keep feeding the system. Its [the system’s] hunger, its past. I didn’t want to work from ambition. Where I would work to impress first, and love second. I wanted presence first. Love first. I thought that if I had this privilege and this luck, to be able to talk to people through sound, then I better work on myself & get rid of negative shards within me. I didn’t want to unwittingly throw [the shards] back into the world. Of course, this didn’t happen...the shards kept piling up and I had to accept the fact that the darkness that I was trying to get away from would always rear its head...Hopefully Cenizas only shows darkness so as to show a path out of it. I want this music to heal and help in thinking through difficult questions about one’s self, and one’s relationship to the state of things. We are living in a time of complete transformation, a metamorphosis— and the transformations are happening within as well. There is potential for great healing and great destruction. ... With love, Nico.” Well, now certainly does seem like the perfect time for him to release this album, doesn’t it? In short, for Jaar (and hopefully for his listeners), Cezinas is a way of processing the darkness and realizing there is always a way through, no matter how dark it seems.
The music, however opaque or murky, is a way of understanding why we have darkness and how it can transform us. It’s clear Cezinas is unlike anything Jaar has ever released. It’s unlike this year’s danceable but ominous 2017-2019, it’s unlike 2018’s 2012-2017, it’s unlike 2016’s political, vocal-focused Sirens, it’s unlike any of the multitudinous EPs and it’s certainly unlike his psychedelic, guitar-driven side project Darkside, yet somehow, it’s distinctly Jaar. Jaar is in total control on Cezinas, just like he is on his other projects. It’s undeniable. As always, he precisely executes his vision exactly as he envisions it, never compromising for the sake of accessibility. Like he said in his blog post, the album is dark, but it’s only dark as a means to show that the light is always present, regardless of how far off it seems. Opening track “Vanish” sets the tone of Cezinas (Spanish for “ashes”) in concrete. It begins with a droning, haunting instrumental that sounds like the sonic representation of darkness, but it eventually gives way to an airy, desperate chorus of Jaar’s voice that pleads, “Say you’re coming back / Say you’re coming back / Say you’re coming back / Say you’re coming back / Say you’re coming back.” It ends just as the final repetition rings out and then transitions to “Menysid,” an almost industrial instrumental filled with stinging whirrs and buzzes while a barely-there synth line trudges along in the background, like an ever-present, dim light. Title track “Cenizas” continues to build on the droning atmosphere, but Jaar establishes a sense of fear by questioning the fate of humanity as the world shrinks and crumbles, singing, “In the ashes / We are going to assemble / Knowing nothing / Is better.” The fear and uncertainty continues to manifest and eventually culminates with “Mud,” Cezinas’s crushing centerpiece. The darkness has reached its high point, made clear as Jaar repeatedly warns that “There’s something in the mud.” Once the vocals
WIKIMEDIA COMMONS
totally fade, the track becomes brighter and more vibrant, as if to say whatever it is in the mud is completely obscured, but still there regardless. All that needs to be done is to get it out. As Cezinas goes on, it slowly begins to fill with light, though the darkness still prevails. “Sunder” and “Hello, Chain” are the one-two punch that was needed to drive the album closer to its conclusion. “Sunder” features a hypnotizing repetition of ascending keys as Jaar begins to figure that his path through the darkness depends on no one other than himself. The same can be said of “Hello, Chain,” with its heavenly layered chants, patiently oscillating synthesizer and lyrics that suggest the only way to the light is patience. The final three tracks are like the final push out of the darkness. On “Garden,” the light, though still far away, makes its presence abundantly clear. “Xerox” is the last violent drag out of the darkness toward the gateway to the light, and “Faith Made of Silk” is the act of moving through the gateway and leaving the darkness behind. “Faith Made of Silk” comes as a sudden burst at the end of the album. It’s not a celebratory song, though. Instead, it’s a cautionary one. Jaar’s lyrics make it obvious that the act of
leaving the darkness is not about making sure that it never returns. He sings, “Look around not ahead / (You have nowhere to look) / A peak is just the way towards / A descent,” reminding listeners not to fall prey to any darkness that may lurk ahead because after every peak of light lies a descent filled with uncertainty. That is to say, it’s useless to look ahead. It’s more beneficial to recognize everything they’ve overcome and remember the people and events that eventually got them to the light, just in case they find themselves or anyone else trapped in the darkness somewhere down the road. Though not as danceable or accessible as Jaar’s previous releases, Cezinas is without a doubt his most powerful. Jaar manages to make darkness palpable in every song, yet somehow he is skilled enough to make sure the light is always present, no matter how obscured it may be. The album itself is a representation of the transformation we undergo as we deal with darkness in our lives. Each individual song is either a representation of the healing or the destruction that occurs during a hellish journey to the light. It goes without saying, Cezinas is the perfect album for the world today as humanity navigates through the seemingly ever-present darkness toward the light, wherever it may be.
FILM NOTEBOOK
A24 films streaming on Amazon Prime: A breakdown DAILY FILM WRITERS
The Michigan Daily Arts Section
In the absence of new theatrical releases, a few of us on the film beat decided to break down our favorite A24 films that are streaming on Prime Video. * “Venus, planet of love / Was destroyed by global warming / Did its people want too much too? / Did its people want too much?” go the lyrics of Mitski’s “Nobody.” Love may not be the reason for our environmental issues on Earth, but in Paul Schrader’s (“Dog Eat Dog”) “First Reformed,” love is a kind of answer to them. Not romantic, or even platonic love, but a spiritual kind. And the truth is, “First Reformed” is a love story. The love a particularly fraught priest of First Reformed Church (Ethan Hawke, “Juliet, Naked”) has for his drink, for a young environmentalist couple who seeks his help, for the finite bounty of the Earth. But that love comes at a harrowing cost, and “First Reformed” gracefully dives into all the vile, violent darkness it promises.
— Anish Tamhaney, Daily Film Editor
“High Life” sneaks up on you. It opens with Robert Pattinson (“The Lighthouse”) and a baby, living together in a tiny spacecraft. The baby is absolutely adorable, and things would be perfect if not for the endless, black silence pressing in against the ship’s walls, which director Claire Denis (“Let The Sunshine In”) takes great care to accentuate, and the look of devastation in Pattinson’s eyes. As the minutes tick by, one learns how these characters ended up lightyears away from Earth, all alone. It’s psychotic, horrific and deeply, gutwrenchingly human. Taking one-third of a movie to develop a sense of tranquility only to rip it away completely is the kind of audacious filmmaking that only comes from A24. — Andrew Warrick, Daily Arts Writer
It’s psychotic, horrific and deeply, gut-wrenchingly human
My resolution for 2020 was to not have a crush on unattainable people — and then “Little Women” had the audacity to come out at the end of December. It was a perfect storm of the Tik Tok For You page algorithm and my weakness for celebrities.
I was hooked on Timothee Chalamet. And, as I made my way through his repertoire, I discovered the gem that is “Hot Summer Nights.” At peak brooding nerd status, Chalamet embodies the best kind of protagonist — his confidence grows as he finds something he’s good at and he f lirts his way through the summer. Saturated within an inch of its life, “Hot Summer Nights” is a film that made me nostalgic for the summer days filled with carnivals and a booming weed business that I never had. — Emma Chang, Daily Arts Writer “The Killing of a Sacred Deer” is a wonderfully, unsettlingly bizarre time. Helmed by the absurdist indie director Yorgos Lanthimos (“The Favourite”) and starring Colin Farrell (“In Bruges”), it
presents a deeply strange psychological thriller about a cardiologist and the peculiar relationship he has with the son of a patient that died on his operating table. Like Yorgos’s 2015 dystopian black comedy “The Lobster” (which is on Netf lix and would make for a wickedly-weird Colin Farrell double feature), all the characters in the world of “The Killing of a Sacred Deer” speak with a deadpan, utilitarian directness that should be antithetical to the profession of the actor. It’s quite an acquired taste, but once you learn to listen the film is unlike many other thrillers. It’s got uncanny creepiness in spades and plays with uncomfortable themes of power, culpability, and justice, leaving one wondering what the hell they just watched. — Jacob Lusk, Daily Arts Writer
A24
The Michigan Daily — michigandaily.com
Arts
Friday, April 3, 2020 — 6
FILM REVIEW
COMMUNITY CULTURE NOTEBOOK
Be sure to stay away from Back home, on recreating ‘Spenser Confidential’ my freshman year dorm get involved in Spenser’s investigation? I’m not really sure. It doesn’t make any sense. Frankly, I was counting down the minutes until this movie finished. I spent the first “Spenser Confidential” is a terrible movie. bit trying to pay attention, actually slightly Or, it’s perfect if you’re looking for a movie you interested in the back-and-forth, present-andcan have on in the background while you scroll past scenes, but eventually, I got bored. There mindlessly through your phone. As much as isn’t enough that happens in the beginning to I tried to understand what was going on, the grab your attention, and there’s nothing exciting entire film is a mess. Spenser (Mark Wahlberg, that happens later on to make you pay attention “Daddy’s Home”) is an ex-convict and ex-cop then. There isn’t a single character in this who is trying to track down the killer of the film that I actually liked. I didn’t hate anyone man who Spenser had been sent to prison for either, though. I barely felt anything. If I’m attacking. It sounds alright, if a little confusing, being honest, the only real emotion I felt while but in reality, it’s so watching this film was convoluted and hard to astonishment because, for follow that you end up some reason, Post Malone on your phone instead. was in it. As much as I love The biggest action-packed fight problem with “Spenser “Spenser Confidential” scenes, I’ll go out on a Confidential” is that even Netflix limb and say “Spenser when it’s on, it doesn’t Streaming Now Confidential” is more feel like you’re watching fighting than anything anything. It’s background else. There is so much noise, something to have fighting that the plot on while you complete gets lost amid scenes of a Canvas quiz (yes, I’m Mark Wahlberg getting speaking from experience). beat up. Along with the You don’t grow overabundance of fighting is an overabundance emotionally attached to anyone or anything in of characters, too many to really understand any the film; so little happens that eventually you one person’s role in the film. forget you’re even watching it. The main character besides Wahlberg’s Unless you really don’t want to watch a Spenser is Hawk (Winston Duke, “Black movie and just need something on to make Panther”). If I could, I would tell you what background noise while you’re doing something purpose his character serves. But I can’t, else, I would without a doubt classify this movie because in all honesty, I’m not sure there is as a ‘skip.’ one. Spenser lives with his friend Henry (Alan Unless you really don’t want to watch a movie Arkin, “Argo”) who took on Hawk, a boxer who and just need something on to make background somehow can’t throw a punch, as a roommate noise while you’re doing something else, I would while Spenser was in prison. How does Hawk without a doubt classify this movie as a ‘skip.’ SABRIYA IMAMI Daily Arts Writer
CAROLINE ATKINSON Daily Arts Writer
In these uncertain and lonely times, I find joy in my photos and string lights. When I packed up my dorm room and f lew home to Seattle, I was aware that I would not be returning to freshman year as I knew it. Waiting for me was my childhood bedroom, nightly dinners with family instead of friends and a three-hour time difference. As I stared at the blank pink walls of my room on my first night home, I attempted to mentally prepare for my first online class the next day. Regaining a feeling of normalcy might actually be pretty difficult. I decided the first step to feeling motivated to finish out the semester was to make the place where I grew up feel a little closer to my room back in South Quad. Aside from the fact that I definitely have a little more closet space here and no longer share my space with another student, I figured my room at home didn’t have to be all that different from my dorm. I could hang some command hooks, find an outlet for my Christmas lights, and put up the obligatory freshman dorm tapestry; I could even put my name tag on the outside of my door. My favorite part of the decorating process
was spending a considerable amount of time picking my favorite photos from my first year of college to print out. In my rush to pack up everything and leave campus, it was hard to make time to actually ref lect on my experiences and why I was so sad to leave. Now that I’m back in my eerily quiet house, though, that’s pretty much all I think about. Looking back at photos from the fall and winter was such a great way to remember all of the fun adventures from before the pandemic. At school, I had taped photos of my friends from high school on my wall to remind me of home. Now these are mixed in with new ones that remind me of Ann Arbor. It makes me so happy to sit at my desk and glance up at photos of my new friends smiling in the Big House hanging next to photos from high school graduation and prom. When I fall asleep now it is to the sound of rain on my roof instead of the music and footsteps of the people in the room above me. Every morning I slowly make my way downstairs to a quiet breakfast with my siblings instead of the laughter and gossipfilled morning meals with friends in the big orange booths of the dining hall that I had grown so accustomed to. But when I walk back up to my room and open my laptop to listen to my 1 p.m. philosophy lecture, I am comforted by the fact that at least my walls look a little like how they did in Michigan.
When I fall asleep now it is to the sound of rain on my roof instead of the footsteps of the people in the room above me
TV REVIEW
‘Keeping Up With the Kardashians’ is not worth watching MAXWELL BARNES Daily Arts Writer
Probably the most easily recognizable title of the reality TV era, “Keeping Up With The Kardashians” recently began its 18th consecutive season. If you are a nonregular to reality shows but are aware of its campy tropes, you might already fully know what to expect from the Kardashian family’s boring and sometimes controversial livelihoods as socialites of the celebrity world. In the midst of crowded parties and fashion shows of New York, Kim, the show’s de-facto mascot of sorts, appears to feel at home in such a fast-paced environment. She’s mingling around and promoting the launch of her new slimwear line, SKIMS. As an audience, we’re given just enough detail about the progressive, body-positive message of the new clothing line to assume that Kim is rebranding herself as a reformist entrepreneur. However, little attention is given to the product after its singular mention when Kim receives a call from NBA player Tristan Thompson, her sister Khloe’s “baby daddy.” Kim invites Tristan to dinner and much to Khloe’s annoyance, and the two reconcile their broken friendship. This is a common trope throughout the series as the ongoings of the Kardashian brands are mentioned, but are overshadowed by the petty drama that viewers prefer. For example, Kylie Jenner, the world’s youngest “self-made” billionaire, is shown preparing to travel to Paris to promote her
cosmetics brand. The show then cuts to Kourtney and her newly formed bad attitude, which she adolescently uses to torment her sisters through her own laziness and apathy. Cut back to New York, where Kim and Tristan are having dinner at a lavish fivestar restaurant. Amongst all this, the family’s matriarch and publicist, Kris Jenner, checks in on each of her daughters. I wish I could say I’m merely summarizing these events in lieu of explaining them in full detail, but I can’t. There’s virtually no other information than what’s shown on the surface. Amongst the constant bopping of background music and cuts between cameras, It’s aggravating to stay tuned with regard to how little actually happens amongst all the sisters’ individual plotlines. While Kourtney’s egocentrism builds tension amongst the sisters, Kim eventually takes it upon herself to physically assault Kourtney in a less-than-convincing catfight. Khloe, who is present, does little to break up the altercation. The highest point of drama occurs when Kylie, who has fallen ill, alerts her mother that she can’t attend the fashion show in Paris to promote her brand. The audience might be eager to find out how this problem will be resolved, but we are left to “tune in next week” to find out. Perhaps this is why people watch. To an outsider, family quarrels existing at the richest level of American society might seem reassuring that life might not be so perfect in the highest tax bracket. The relationships among the main Kardashian trio of daughters appear to be rooted in
their outright pettiness to each other. They act childish despite the vast monochromatic wardrobes and mansions they have at their disposal. But even if that mode of thinking was the case for viewership, would someone even want to watch 18 consecutive seasons of consistent feuding? It’s because “Keeping Up” feels like junk food for the eyes. It’s mindlessly entertaining. It mainly continues to exist purely as the central platform for the Kardashian brand, whether it be SKIMS or Kylie Cosmetics or for general clout when Kim needs to promote a fashionable Judy crisis kit in the midst of a global pandemic. Season 18 takes a shift to look at each of Kris Jenner’s five daughters as entrepreneurs and activists in their own right. Just last month, Kim was being praised for her endeavors in criminal justice reform, for which she advocated in a visit to the White House. As long as “Keeping Up” endures, so too
will the Kardashian’s relevancy. In season 18, that relevancy will depend on how well a new, enterprising slant is received by audiences. And if seeing one reality TV star behind the white house podium wasn’t already enough for you, maybe try to keep up with the Kardashians a little less.
“Keeping Up With the Kardashians’’ Season 18 Premiere E! Thursdays @ 8 p.m.
Sports With vision in place, Gattis’s offense ready for next step in 2020
7 — Friday, April 3, 2020
DANIEL DASH
Daily Sports Writer
At this time last year, Josh Gattis fielded questions for the first time since joining the Michigan football team two months earlier. As the Wolverines’ newly-minted offensive coordinator leaned on a glass timeline of the program’s history at the Towsley Museum, he prepared to speak to reporters about modernizing Michigan’s traditional offense. But before unveiling his plans to revamp the Wolverines’ system, Gattis told of a different assignment. After luring Gattis away from his previous role as a co-offensive coordinator and wide receivers coach at Alabama in January 2019, Michigan coach Jim Harbaugh brought him on a two-week road trip. “That (trip) was really valuable,” Gattis said in March 2019. “That really developed our relationship. ... It was just two guys in a rental car going across the country to see recruits.
The Michigan Daily — michigandaily.com
In that time, we were just sitting back in the car, joking, and it really enabled us to develop a friendship and really gave us a chance to get to know who we are from a personality standpoint.” More importantly, it was during that trip when Harbaugh handed Gattis the keys to Michigan’s offense, relinquishing control to a full-time offensive play-caller for the first time since returning to Ann Arbor in 2015. Even with a clear vision in place, Gattis’s first season calling the shots was anything but a smooth go-around. There were kinks to work through and an identity to find, and Gattis needed to experience the ups and downs to figure them out. After it took his unit 43 minutes to score in a threepossession blowout loss at Wisconsin, he moved down from the coaches box to the sideline the next week. For him, calling the shots from there felt more natural than watching through a glass panel overhead.
But by now, that learning curve is in the rearview mirror. And coming off a season in which Michigan finished seventh in the Big Ten in total offense, there’s reason to believe the 2020 Wolverines can take a step forward in that department. With a system now firmly in place, the roster has taken upward of a year’s worth of reps and the focus on the recruiting trail has shifted toward bringing in speedy players that fit Michigan’s new mold, such as incoming freshman receiver A.J. Henning. And even while learning new dimensions of the offense on the f ly a season ago, the Wolverines showed f lashes. In the four games leading up to Thanksgiving, Michigan averaged 41.5 points and over 400 yards of total offense in blowout wins over Notre Dame, Maryland, Michigan State and Indiana. Now that Gattis has a feel for play-calling, he’s more equipped to ensure his weapons are optimized. Proof of that lies in the evolution of how Gattis
MILES MACKLIN/Daily
Offensive coordinator Josh Gattis will be in his second year at Michigan in 2020 after an up-and-down 2019.
used pieces like sophomore receiver Giles Jackson, whose progression from kick returner to downfield threat unlocked a new dimension of the offense. By November, Gattis had designed jet sweeps and wheel routes specifically for Jackson’s open-field speed. This fall, Gattis will have a speedster in Jackson, vertical threat in senior
wideout Nico Collins and junior slot receiver Ronnie Bell at his disposal to break defenses down in different ways. In the backfield, he’ll look to maximize two proven returners in sophomore Zach Charbonnet and redshirt sophomore Hassan Haskins, while mixing in senior Chris Evans’s passcatching ability. The Wolverines have not yet named a starting
quarterback for 2020, and with all spring practices canceled due to the COVID19 outbreak, it’ll be a long time before they do. But redshirt junior Dylan McCaffrey and redshirt sophomore Joe Milton will both be duking it out for the right to lead a unit that’s more than capable of breaking through. At the center of it all lies the man with the keys.
Breaking down Michigan football’s 2021 recruiting class ARIA GERSON
Daily Sports Editor
Sports are on hold for the foreseeable future. The NCAA has established a recruiting dead period, banning both campus visits for recruits and in-home or school visits for coaches until May 31. Yet, the uncertainty surrounding COVID-19 hasn’t stopped recruits from committing to their preferred schools. In the past two weeks, Michigan has secured four commits in the class of 2021 — defensive lineman Dominick Guidice, offensive lineman Greg Crippen, tight end Louis Hansen and punter Tommy Doman — giving the Wolverines a total of six in the class. The Daily breaks down Guidice, Crippen and Hansen and how they could add to the team. Defensive lineman Dominick Guidice Guidice, a three-star defensive end from New Jersey, was a bit of a surprise. Most of his previous offers were from service academies, the Ivy League and MAC schools. Competing for Mater Dei Prep, a small school in Monmouth County, Guidice is the current New Jersey sack leader. However, Guidice told Rivals that Michigan sees him as a likely three-technique at the next level. According to Rivals, Guidice grew up a Michigan fan but has not yet taken an
official visit. Last Tuesday, he was offered a scholarship on a group FaceTime call with head coach Jim Harbaugh, defensive coordinator Don Brown and defensive line coach Shaun Nua. After a brief discussion with his parents, Guidice committed that same night. “I was really happy because Michigan was my dream school,” he told Rivals. It is unclear how much playing time Guidice will get with the Wolverines given the presence of better defensive line prospects on the roster, but Michigan has a good history of finding
underrated East Coast players, and presumably its coaches think Guidice is next. Offensive lineman Greg Crippen Crippen is a four-star offensive lineman from IMG Academy in Florida. He was previously committed to Notre Dame before re-opening his recruitment on Mar. 4. Crippen is a big get for the Wolverines, having
held offers from Alabama, Auburn, Ohio State and USC among others. He is likely a guard or center in college and is ranked as the No. 11 guard in the country by 247Sports. According to 247Sports, Crippen has already been on campus, visiting for last year’s Middle Tennessee game while still committed to the Fighting Irish. He appears to have been swayed by offensive line
I was really happy because Michigan was my dream.
coach Ed Warinner’s recent work in developing his unit. “You can see from this year’s (NFL) combine for Michigan, he will get you there with hard work and dedication,” Crippen told 247Sports. Crippen is the Wolverines’ second offensive line commit for 2021, joining four-star tackle Giovanni El-Hadi of Sterling Heights. Both could be big contributors at a position group that appears to be stacked for the near future. Tight end Louis Hansen Hansen is a four-star tight end from Needham, Mass.,
ALLISON ENGKVIST/Daily
Michigan coach Jim Harbaugh has five commits in his 2021 recruiting class, with three committing this week. By contrast, Ohio State has 15.
a suburb of Boston. He is ranked as the No. 8 tight end overall and the No. 2 prospect in Massachusetts by 247Sports. He chose Michigan over offers from Florida, Georgia, LSU and a host of Big Ten foes. “Something I like about the offense is the way they utilize the tight ends,” Hansen told 247Sports. “They often have multiple (tight ends) on the field at once, which provides an opportunity for early playing time. And they do a good job getting them the ball in space and allowing them the chance to make plays. … They have a great chance at being a very dynamic offense.” Both Hansen and Crippen cited wanting to study in the Ross School of Business as playing a role in their decisions. Hansen is just the latest big New England pickup by Brown, who is well known for his prowess at recruiting the area. Additionally, tight ends coach Sherrone Moore assisted with Hansen’s recruitment. With the graduation of fifth-year senior tight end Nick Eubanks after the 2020 season, the Wolverines will need new contributors at the position. Hansen likely won’t get immediate playing time given the presence of sophomore Erick All and redshirt sophomore Luke Schoonmaker, but he has all the tools to step into a starting role later on.
8
OLIVIA CARTER: MOVING THE WATER
Michigan swimmer adjusts to being unable to train
Jack Whitten Daily Sports Writer
FRIDAY, APRIL 3, 2020
Photo courtesy of U-M Photography Design by Jack Silberman
Olivia Carter’s swimming career has been studded with peaks and relatively free of valleys. The sophomore’s record shows no shortage of first-place finishes and recordsetting times. She’s represented two toptier collegiate programs, as well as her country, in competition. But any discussion of winning or losing overlooks her love of swimming. “I love the feeling of being in the water, and having so much power to move that water,” Carter said. “It’s an unreal feeling.” That’s why the lowest point in her career is right now. She’s been out of the water for more than two weeks — the second-longest such break since she was five. Without the dependable structure of practice and competition, Carter feels rudderless. COVID-19 took away her chance at a national championship last March and cut her first semester at Michigan short. For one of the first times in her life, Carter is staring down an obstacle she cannot overcome. *** Carter joined her second swim team the same way she joined her most recent one: by having the confidence to go for it. She began swimming in the summer of 2004 in her hometown of Cary, N.C. At a meet that summer, an opportunity to swim on a year-round team presented itself in the form of a tent handing out gear. “I grabbed a free cap,” Carter said. “And I ran up to my mom like ‘Look, I’m on the team! They accepted me, I’m on the team!’” It wasn’t as easy as Carter thought; she still had to try out. But she made the team, securing the spot entirely of her own volition. The other constant in Carter’s pre-college life — homeschooling— also began around this time. “When I was in it, and actually doing the work, I think I might have had a different opinion on it,” Carter said. “But looking back on it, it really did shape who I am today.” For Carter, the benefits of a homeschool education lay particularly in the extracurricular activities that it allowed. She accrued physical education credits by going flying with her father, a professional pilot. Trips to the zoo were frequent. But the fun stuff only happened when Carter made the deadline on her work — a responsibility she held. “It was really good for me to understand how to manage my time and manage my studies so that I could open up free time to do things that I wanted to do,” she said. When her family moved from Cary to Greensboro in 2016, Carter began swimming at the Enfinity Aquatic Club. Training under Enfinity coach Korey McCulley, she shed more than five seconds off her 200-yard butterfly time and wound up as the No. 11 recruit for the class of 2018 on collegeswimming.com.
“With that team, and with that new coach, I was really, really able to achieve my dreams,” Carter said. “I had always had the dream, since 2008, 2012, of being on the Olympic team. … Once I started swimming with Enfinity … I started realizing that those dreams could actually come true.” She committed to Georgia, along with three other swimmers ranked inside the top 25. Carter more than held her own in the deep SEC; she won SEC Freshman of the Year, was named to the All-SEC first team and placed seventh in the 200-yard butterfly at the NCAA championships. But Carter had committed as a junior in high school — the decision, which was the right choice for her then, didn’t age well. Academics weren’t the issue; while the more structured schedule and classroom
For one of the first times in her life, Carter is staring down an obstacle she cannot overcome.
environments were new to her, her prior education left her well-equipped for the challenge of college courses. It was something harder to quantify. “Over the course of my freshman year, I didn’t quite feel like I fit,” she said. “The hardest part for me was admitting the fact that I didn’t feel like I fit. It’s one thing to sense it, but it’s another thing to come out and tell my parents, ‘I don’t feel like I fit here.’ I can’t say anything bad about the team; it was a totally personal decision.” So Carter grabbed the bull by the horns once again, announcing her intent to transfer. Her original plan was to take an Olympic redshirt for the following season and train for Olympic Trials at Enfinity, but by early October 2019, she committed to Michigan. *** Before she stepped foot in Ann Arbor as a student for the first time, Carter had already made a strong first impression.
She joined the Wolverines on their winter break training trip to Key Largo, Fla. In her Michigan debut at the Orange Bowl Classic, Carter set the meet record for the 100-meter butterfly. A performance like that appeared par for the course considering the high expectations of the Wolverines’ coaching staff. “She swims a lot of different events, so she will be scoring a lot of points in different places,” Michigan coach Mike Bottom said after the meet. Carter made good on these expectations by helping Michigan to a win in each of the season’s remaining dual meets. The Wolverines went on to take second place at the Big Ten championships, where Carter’s win in the 200-yard butterfly, fastest in conference history, fell short of the mark she wanted: a personal best. “We had so much more to give,” she said. “So much more to give. It was really a big disappointment that we couldn’t win Big Tens, so I know that just added to the fire that we were going to put on at NCAAs. I am 100 percent confident that we could have gone in there and absolutely dominated.” Another personal goal — competing at the Olympic trials — was put on hold when the summer Olympics were moved to 2021. She is aware of the kind of work required to make that dream come true: increased attention to detail in the water, as well as weightlifting to strengthen her upper body. But right now, the quarantine is preventing Carter from getting back to work. “(This) doesn’t feel temporary,” she said. “It feels like the end of the world.” *** After a dual-meet win over Ohio State in January, in which Carter won the 200-yard butterfly, Michigan associate head coach Rick Bishop paid her the ultimate compliment. “Obviously we’re better because of her performances in the pool,” Bishop said. “... but we’re just better because she’s a great contributing athlete and a great Michigan woman.” Carter recognized the profundity of the ‘Michigan woman’ title. She’s been a Wolverine long enough to know that, but not long enough to feel comfortable attaching it to herself. “I’m incredibly honored to have that title already,” Carter said. “I feel like I haven’t been there long enough to deserve that.” It’s impossible to say when Carter will feel that she deserves it. But when she can get back to training, there is no doubt that she’ll begin attacking her long list of goals — setting a new personal best in the 200-yard butterfly, scoring points for Michigan at national championships and making the Olympic team — with at least equal, if not increased, drive. She just needs a chance to move the water again.