news A9
July 2, 2026
O
P
I
N
I
O
N
VOICES ON
FREEDOM MARTHA’S VINEYARD SPEAKS OUT • JULY 2, 2026 •
to prove your worth, your humanity, or your right to be here. To dream beyond survival. As a third-generation Islander, I have often thought about the role Martha’s Vineyard has played in that pursuit. For so many communities, this Island has represented something larger than a destination. It has been a place to gather, to celebrate, to preserve traditions, to reconnect with family, and, for many, to experience a sense of belonging that can feel elusive elsewhere. The responses that follow are thoughtful, honest, and deeply personal. Together, they remind us that freedom is not experienced in the same way by everyone. It is shaped by history, identity, culture, opportunity, and lived experience. That is precisely why this conversation matters. No single voice can define freedom for an entire community. We understand ourselves more fully when we listen across generations, cultures, experiences, and identities. As the curator of this section, my hope
DENA PORTER
T
wo hundred and fifty years ago, a group of 56 white men signed a Declaration of Independence in Philadelphia and declared that all men are created equal and entitled to life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness. Yet for many women and people of color, those promises remained out of reach. For indigenous communities, freedom came alongside displacement and the continued fight to preserve culture, land, and sovereignty. For African Americans, freedom was delayed by generations of enslavement, segregation, and systemic barriers. For immigrants, freedom often arrived hand in hand with uncertainty, sacrifice, and the challenge of building a new life. For countless others, the meaning of freedom has continued to evolve with each generation. And yet, despite our different histories, freedom remains one of the most enduring and powerful ideas in American life. As the nation prepares to commemorate the 250th anniversary of its founding, I invited members of Martha’s Vineyard’s diverse communities to reflect on a simple but profound question: What does freedom mean to you and your community? Before sharing their responses, I found myself sitting with the question myself. The truth is, freedom has never felt simple to me. As a Black woman, I have spent much of my
life searching for belonging. Not because I lacked community, but because belonging often felt conditional — dependent on where I was, how I spoke, how I dressed, how much space I took up, or whether I made others comfortable. I have watched my family be free on paper, yet constrained by the realities of what it means to be Black in America. I have watched hard-working people do everything they were told would lead to success, only to encounter barriers they did not create. I have watched generations carry burdens that freedom alone did not erase. And yet, I have also witnessed something remarkable. I have watched my people build lives anyway. I have watched my grandparents create community. I have watched families create traditions. I have watched people transform houses into legacies, gatherings into institutions, and ordinary moments into something sacred. Perhaps that is why freedom, to me, is
Sharisse Scott-Rawlins not simply the absence of chains. It is the presence of possibility. It is the ability to exist fully and authentically. To belong without explanation. To move through the world without constantly having
Perhaps that is why freedom, to me, is not simply the absence of chains. It is the presence of possibility. is not to offer one answer, but to create space for many — to preserve these reflections as part of Martha’s Vineyard’s living history, and to remind us that every community is stronger when every voice has the opportunity to be heard. On an Island shaped by Wampanoag ancestry, Colonial history, Black legacy and waves of immigration and seasonal migration there are generations upon generations of families who have called this place home. These reflections offer a glimpse into the many ways freedom continues to be understood, challenged, celebrated, and pursued here on our Island. Because 250 years later, perhaps the question is not simply whether America is free. Perhaps the question is what freedom asks of us now. Sharisse Scott-Rawlins is a storyteller, fashion designer, and creator of Voices bySharisse, dedicated to preserving the stories, histories, and cultural legacies that define Martha’s Vineyard for generations to come.
EDITORIAL NOTE No single publication could capture every perspective on freedom, nor should it. These reflections are only the beginning. Throughout the summer, Voices on Freedom will continue inviting Islanders from every corner of our community to share their opinions on this question, because the story of freedom is still being written — and every voice helps shape its legacy.