Issuu

This book belongs to

Name Address Telephone School Teacher Grade

Layout Mirko Zunic

Program Director Akiva Leitner

Dear Student, Welcome to Business Smarts. Every business begins with a problem someone notices, a promise someone keeps, or an idea someone improves. In this book, you will meet the people and companies behind familiar products and services and learn how they earned trust, found customers, handled risk, and made money. Each lesson asks you to read closely, think carefully, discuss both sides, and apply the idea to a business of your own. The goal is not simply to memorize business terms. It is to learn how to recognize useful ideas, make responsible decisions, and understand the work behind a successful business. We hope this book helps you become more observant, creative, dependable, and thoughtful about the value you can create for others.

Sincerely, Lighthouse Curriculum Team

Business Smarts

ISBN 978-1-972340-15-8

Lighthouse Curriculum 718.285.7100 • info@lighthousecurriculum.com For more information visit www.lighthousecurriculum.com © 2026 Lighthouse Curriculum Inc. All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, stored in a database and/or published in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, without the prior written permission of the publisher. To obtain permission to use portions of material from this publication, please contact Lighthouse Curriculum.

Welcome

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

TA B L E O F C O N T E N T S

WHAT A BUSINESS IS

01 WD-40 The fortieth try

02 Post-it Notes The glue that failed its way to success

03 Band-Aid The bandage you could put on yourself

04 1-800-GOT-JUNK Doing a dirty job the clean way

End of Unit 1

Unit 2

PRODUCT BUSINESSES

05 LEGO Only the best is good enough

06 Crayola From tire pigment to a childhood staple

07 John Deere The plow that had to be better

08 Dyson Five thousand tries before it worked

End of Unit 2

Unit 3

60 © Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

Unit 1

SERVICE BUSINESSES

09 UPS Two bicycles and a promise

10 FedEx The idea that got a C

11 Southwest Airlines Doing one thing, cheaply and happily 76 12 GEICO Selling a promise, and the math behind it End of Unit 3

Table of Contents

82 88

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

TA B L E O F C O N T E N T S

Unit 4

SELF-EMPLOYED VS. EMPLOYEE

13 The Self-Employed Path: Yvon Chouinard Working for yourself means keeping the reward and the risk

14 The Employee Path: Doug McMillon Rising from the loading dock to the top

15 The Third Path: Franchising Renting a proven idea, for a price and some rules

104

End of Unit 4

110

Unit 5

HOW A BUSINESS IS BUILT

16 The Partnership Path: Procter & Gamble Two trades, one business

114

17 The Corporation and Going Public: Ford How a company can be owned by thousands of strangers

120

18 When a Company Grows Too Big: Standard Oil The giant the government broke apart

126

End of Unit 5

132

Unit 6 19

GETTING CUSTOMERS

Coca-Cola A name, a script, and a secret

136

20 De Beers How four words sold the world a diamond

142

Goodyear The most famous thing in the sky

148

Walmart One promise, repeated everywhere

154

End of Unit 6

160

Table of Contents

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

Unit 7

MAKING MONEY & STAYING ALIVE

23 Thin Margins, Big Trust: Costco Making almost nothing on each sale, on purpose

164

24 The Comeback: Fender How a beloved brand almost died, then rebuilt itself

170

25 The Giant That Stopped Changing: Sears The biggest store in the world, until it was not

176

26 Too Much, Too Fast: Target in Canada A strong company that grew itself to death

182

End of Unit 7

188

Unit 8 27

ASSETS & OWNERSHIP

The Asset That Earns for a Century: Union Pacific Build it once, collect for a hundred years

192

28 The Boxes That Move the World: Maersk Owning the ships and boxes that carry everything

198

Why throwing away a rocket was the strangest waste in business

204

30 Own It or Rent It? The choice every business has to make

210

End of Unit 8 Unit 9 31

29 The Asset You Use Once, or Again and Again: SpaceX

216

PUTTING IT ALL TOGETHER

The Whole Story: American Express One company, every idea in this book

220

End of Unit 9

228

Table of Contents

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

Unit

What a Business Is

WD-40

WORDS TO KNOW

The fortieth try

MEET THESE BEFORE YOU READ

• Revenue - the money a business takes in by selling something. • Customer - the person or group who pays for what a business offers. • Product - the thing a business makes and sells. • Market - all the people who might want to buy a certain product.

Watch for these four words as you read. Each one shows up in the story below, doing real work. Notice them in action, and they will make a lot more sense than any definition can.

STO P & TH I NK Why was rust a far bigger danger on the Atlas missile than on most metal objects?

R E A D T HE S T ORY Thirty-nine times the little team mixed a batch, tested it, and watched it fail. They were not making a toy or a cleaning spray. They were trying to keep a nuclear missile from rusting itself to pieces, and they were running out of tries. Then came the fortieth.

n 1953, a small company called the Rocket Chemical Company opened in San Diego, California. It had a staff of just three people and one goal: to make products that stopped rust and grease from ruining metal parts in the aerospace industry. Their first big job was a serious one. A company called Convair was building the Atlas missile, the first missile of its kind in the American arsenal, and the thin metal skin of that missile had to be protected from rust. Rust was no small worry here. Metal left in the open air slowly reacts with water and breaks down, and the Atlas was built so light that its outer skin doubled as the wall of its fuel tanks. There was almost no room for error. The Rocket Chemical team needed a liquid that would push water away from the metal and leave behind a thin, protective coat. Chemists call that idea water displacement, which simply means moving the water out of the way. Getting the formula right was not easy. The team mixed a batch, tested it, and wrote down the result. Then they adjusted the recipe and tried again, numbering each attempt so they would never repeat a mistake. The first try did not work. Neither did the next, or the one after that. They kept going, batch after batch, until the 40th

Unit 1

| Lesson 1

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

finally did the job, and it did it so well that the same secret formula is still used today. That is how the product got its name. WD-40 stands for Water Displacement, 40th formula, taken straight from the lab notebook. WD-40 did its job on the Atlas missile, but then the company noticed something it had not planned. The workers who used it at the plant started taking cans home for themselves.

Unit 1

| Lesson 1

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

WD40.COM

STOP & TH I N K Why was rust a far bigger danger on the Atlas missile than on most metal objects?

Unit

What a Business Is

WD40COMPANY.COM

STO P & TH I NK

Who was WD-40’s first customer, and who turned out to be the much bigger one?

They had discovered it was useful for all sorts of ordinary things, like quieting a squeaky hinge, freeing a stuck lock, or loosening a rusted bolt. The product built for missiles turned out to be perfect for everyday life, and people wanted it in their own homes. The company’s president, Norm Larsen, paid attention to that. He realized that ordinary people might buy WD-40 for their homes, not just aerospace companies, and that there were a great many more homes than missile factories. So the team put WD40 into an aerosol spray can that anyone could use, and in 1958 it reached store shelves in San Diego for the first time. By 1960 the company had grown to seven employees who sold about 45 cases a day, often straight out of the trunks of their cars to nearby hardware and sporting goods stores. From there the little product kept climbing. It proved itself in dramatic ways, too: after a hurricane flooded the Gulf Coast in 1961, WD-40 was used to dry out and rescue water-damaged machines, and around 1962 NASA used it to help protect the spacecraft that carried astronaut John Glenn into orbit. The company eventually took the name of its most famous product, and in

WD40COMPANY.COM

Unit 1

| Lesson 1

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

1973 the WD-40 Company became a public company, which means anyone can buy a small share of it on the stock market, where it still trades under the symbol WDFC.

DID YOU KNOW?

• The exact WD-40 formula has never been patented. The company decided a patent would mean publishing the recipe for everyone to see, so instead they keep it a secret, the same way Coca-Cola guards its formula. The original is reportedly locked in a bank vault. • Fans have sent in thousands of

Unit 1

| Lesson 1

STOP & TH I N K The product stayed almost the same the whole time. So why did the business grow so enormously?

Today WD-40 is sold in more than 170 countries, and in 2025 the company brought in about $620 million in revenue. The blue and yellow can that started in a three-person lab now sits in garages and kitchen drawers all over the world. The product itself barely changed along the way. What changed was the company realizing how many people, far beyond a few missile builders, wanted exactly what it had already made.

uses for WD-40 over the years, from freeing stuck rings to quieting squeaky toys to protecting tools from rust. • WD-40 stands for nothing fancier than “Water Displacement, 40th formula,” the note in the lab book recording that the recipe worked on the fortieth try.

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

Unit

What a Business Is

THE LESSON The price is not the cost. The gap between them is where a business lives or dies. Almost everybody has ideas. The minute it rains, someone wishes for a better umbrella. But an idea sitting in your head is not a business, and it never will be on its own. A business begins the exact moment someone is willing to hand over money for what you made. That money coming in has a name. It is called revenue. WD-40 started by solving one narrow problem, rust on a missile. It was a real problem with a real solution, but only a few aerospace companies needed it, so the business stayed small. The company got much larger when Norm Larsen realized that a far bigger group of people, a far bigger market, shared a version of the same problem. Almost everyone owns something

WD40COMPANY.COM

made of metal, and metal gets stuck, squeaky, or rusty. Same exact product, many more customers, far more revenue. The clue was hiding in those take-home cans the whole time, and it points to a quietly important truth. Sometimes your biggest customer is not the one you set out to serve.

Who really kept trying? © Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

TAKE IT TO THE CLASS

Here is the question for the room. The Rocket Chemical team tried 39 times before the 40th formula worked. Imagine you were on that team after attempt number 30. Would you have kept going, or argued that the company should give up and try something else? Split the room out loud. Some of you defend “keep mixing,” some defend “cut our losses.” Both sides have a real point. Listen for this question as you argue: how do you actually know the difference between not quitting and wasting time and money? There is no clean answer, and that is exactly what makes it worth arguing about.

Unit 1

| Lesson 1

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

The Work Check your understanding 1. What was the Rocket Chemical Company originally trying to make, and for whom?

2. Where does the name “WD-40” come from? 3. H ow did the company first discover that ordinary people wanted the product?

Think harder 1. The team tried 39 times before the 40th formula worked. Why might careful, numbered records of each failure have helped them more than starting fresh every time?

2. The product never changed when WD-40 went from missiles to garages, yet the business grew enormously. So what did change?

Try it yourself

BUSINESS RULE

Pick a product you own that costs more than the materials in it seem to be worth, like a good backpack or a sturdy water bottle. List three things, besides the raw materials, that you think you are paying for when you buy it.

Unit 1

3. Explain in your own words why an idea is not a business until someone pays for it.

| Lesson 1

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

“The price is not the cost. The gap between them is where a business lives or dies.”

Unit

What a Business Is

POST-IT NOTES

WORDS TO KNOW MEET THESE BEFORE YOU READ

• Invention - a new thing someone creates.

The glue that failed its way to success

• Value - how useful or worth paying for something is to a customer. • Market - all the people who might want to buy a certain product. • Patent - a legal right that protects an inventor’s idea from being copied.

Watch for these words as you read. The Post-it story is really about value, and how the same thing can be worthless for one purpose and priceless for another.

STO P & TH I NK Silver set out to make the strongest glue possible and got the weakest. Why would he treat that as a failure? Why might a company let an invention sit unused for years, even after patenting it?

R E A D T HE S T ORY A scientist was handed one job: invent the strongest glue in the world. Instead he made one of the weakest glues anyone had ever seen, a glue that barely held on. His company called it useless. It would take twelve years and a frustrated man losing his place in a book to discover that this failure was worth a fortune.

n 1968, a chemist named Spencer Silver was working at a large American company called 3M. His job was to invent new glues, and 3M wanted them strong. The goal was a powerful adhesive that could hold heavy materials together and never let go. Silver mixed his chemicals, ran his tests, and studied the result. It was the opposite of what he had been asked to make. The glue was weak. It stuck lightly to a surface, peeled off cleanly without leaving any mark, and, oddly, it could be used again and again. Under a microscope, the secret was visible: the glue was made of tiny sphere-shaped particles that touched a surface at only a few points, so it gripped just enough to hold, but never enough to bond for good. For a chemist trying to build the world’s strongest glue, this looked like a failure. But Silver could not stop thinking about it. He was sure his strange weak glue had to be good for something, even if he could not say Unit 1

| Lesson 2

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

Spencer Silver and Art Fry

WIKIPEDIA .COM

Unit 1

| Lesson 2

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

WIKIPEDIA .COM

Unit

What a Business Is

WIKIPEDIA .COM

what. He went so far as to patent it, and for about five years he showed it to coworkers across 3M and gave talks about it, hoping someone would dream up a use. Nobody did. He later called his invention “a solution waiting for a problem.” The idea simply sat, unused.

WIKIPEDIA .COM

STO P & TH I NK Fry had a small, ordinary, everyday annoyance. How did it turn out to be exactly the problem the glue was waiting for?

Then, in 1974, another 3M employee named Art Fry found the problem that fit. Fry sang in his spare time and read a great deal, and he used small slips of paper to mark his place in his books. The slips kept sliding out and falling to the floor, so he kept losing his page. Fry had heard about Spencer Silver’s weak glue, and an idea struck him. What if he put a little of that glue on his paper bookmarks? It worked perfectly. The bookmarks stuck to the page, stayed put, and peeled off later without tearing the paper. Best of all, they could be moved and reused. The two ideas fit together at last: a glue that no one wanted, and a small problem that no one had solved. Soon people inside 3M were using the sticky slips to leave notes for each other, and the company realized the bookmark was only the beginning. Even then, success did not come instantly. 3M first sold the product in 1977 under the name Press ‘n Peel, and it flopped, because shoppers picked it up and could not tell what it was for. Instead of giving up, the company tried again, flooding one test city with free samples so people could feel for themselves how useful the

Unit 1

| Lesson 2

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

Spencer Silver INDEPENDENT.CO.UK Art Fry

WIKIPEDIA .COM

Today 3M makes tens of billions of Post-it Notes every year and sells them in more than 100 countries. 3M is a public company, traded on the stock market, and the glue once written off as a failure became one of the most famous office products ever made. Spencer Silver stayed at 3M for the rest of his career, earning more than 20 patents before he passed away in 2021, more than fifty years after he first made the weak glue that became the Post-it Note.

DID YOU KNOW?

• Spencer Silver’s glue is made of millions of tiny springy spheres. They touch a surface in only a few spots, which is exactly why it sticks lightly and peels off without leaving a mark. • 3M lets its scientists spend part of their work time on their own experimental ideas. That freedom

Unit 1

| Lesson 2

STOP & TH I N K The exact same product flopped in 1977 but became a hit in 1980. What did 3M change?

notes were. Once people used them, they wanted more. In 1980 the product was renamed the Post-it Note, launched again, and this time it took off.

is part of how the Post-it Note was born. • The product flopped under the name Press ‘n Peel in 1977. The very same notes, given away free so people could try them, came back as a hit under the name Postit in 1980.

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

Unit

What a Business Is

THE LESSON A weak point can become a strong product if you find the right problem. Spencer Silver made a glue that was bad at the one job it was designed for. By every normal measure, it was a failure. But a failure is only a failure for a particular purpose. The weak glue was useless for holding heavy things together, yet it was perfect for something nobody had thought of yet: a note you could stick, peel off, and stick again. This is an invention that had to wait years to find its purpose. This points to one of the most useful ideas in all of business. The value of something is not fixed. It depends entirely on the problem you match it to and the market of people who have that problem. The glue did not change between being a failure and being a hit. What changed was finding the right problem for it, and then

helping customers understand why they wanted it. A great invention can sit useless for years, not because it is bad, but because no one has connected it to the people who need it.

Is a failure ever really a failure? © Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

TAKE IT TO THE CLASS

Here is the debate. Spencer Silver’s glue failed at its job, but that failure became a product sold in more than 100 countries. Does that mean there is no such thing as a failed invention, only inventions waiting for the right use? Or are most failures just failures? Argue both sides. One side says almost anything could be useful for something, so you should never throw away a “failed” idea. The other side says that is wishful thinking, and most failures really are dead ends that waste time and money. As you argue, think about how you would decide whether to keep a strange, useless idea around or move on. That judgment is a real business skill.

Unit 1

| Lesson 2

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

The Work Check your understanding 1. What was Spencer Silver originally trying to make?

2. About how many years did the weak glue sit with no use for it?

3. What everyday problem finally gave the glue a purpose, and who found it?

Think harder 1. The glue did not change between being a failure and being a success. In your own words, what made the difference?

2. The product failed as Press ‘n Peel in 1977 but succeeded as the Post-it Note in 1980. What does that tell you about how a product is sold, not just what it is?

Try it yourself

BUSINESS RULE

Think of something you own that most people would call useless or broken. Imagine a totally different problem it could actually solve. Describe the object and the surprising new use you invented for it.

Unit 1

3. Can something be a great invention but a poor business at first? Use this story to explain.

| Lesson 2

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

“A weak point can become a strong product, if you find the right problem.”

Unit

What a Business Is

BAND-AID

WORDS TO KNOW

The bandage you could put on yourself

MEET THESE BEFORE YOU READ

• Need - a problem strong enough that someone will pay to fix it. • Demand - how many people want a product and are willing to pay for it. • Convenience making something easier or faster, which customers will pay for. • Sample - a free example or small amount of a product given to customers to try.

Watch for these words as you read. The Band-Aid story shows how a problem people had quietly accepted became a product found in nearly every home.

STO P & TH I NK Why is it so hard to bandage one of your own hands using loose gauze and a separate roll of tape?

R E A D T HE S T ORY A new product reached store shelves and, in a whole year, sold just three thousand dollars worth, a flop by any measure. The company could have quietly killed it. Instead it kept going, and that nearly forgotten flop became one of the most common objects on earth, found in almost every home you have ever been in.

n the early 1920s, a man named Earle Dickson worked as a cotton buyer for Johnson & Johnson, a company in New Jersey that made medical supplies like surgical tape and gauze. Because of his job, Dickson thought a lot about wounds and how people treated them, and he noticed a real problem with how small cuts were bandaged at home. In those days, bandaging a cut took two hands and some skill. You placed a square of cotton gauze on the wound, held it there, and then wound a strip of surgical tape around it to hold it in place. That worked fine when someone else could help. But people at home often hurt themselves on knives, tools, or hot pans when no one else was around, and trying to bandage your own hand with two separate pieces was clumsy and slow. Dickson set out to design a bandage a person could put on quickly, by themselves, with one hand. His goal, as he later described it, was “a system of bandage that would stay put and be easily applied.”

Unit 1

| Lesson 3

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

BAND - AID.COM

WIKIPEDIA .COM

Unit 1

| Lesson 3

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

Earle Dickson

WIKIPEDIA .COM

Unit

What a Business Is

BAND - AID.COM

STO P & TH I NK What was the key difference between Dickson’s bandage and the old way of using gauze and tape separately?

The first Band-Aid sold poorly. What about the early version do you think confused customers?

BAND - AID.COM

Around 1920, he laid out a long strip of surgical tape with the sticky side facing up. Every few inches he placed a small square of folded gauze. Then he covered the whole strip with a stiff fabric called crinoline, so the tape would not stick to itself when it was rolled up. Now the bandage was already built: a person could cut off a piece, peel away the cover, and wrap it around a cut with one hand. Dickson showed his idea to the people at Johnson & Johnson, and the story goes that the company president was won over after watching how easily a person could bandage their own finger with it. The company decided to sell it, and in 1921 the Band-Aid went on sale for the first time. The early version was strange by today’s standards. It came as a strip 18 inches long and two and a half inches wide that customers had to cut to size themselves. People did not really understand it, and sales were slow. In its entire first year, the Band-Aid earned only about $3,000. Johnson & Johnson did not give up. In 1924 the company built machines that made ready-to-use Band-Aids in small, even sizes, much closer to the ones we know today, and the product slowly caught on. The company also leaned on a clever idea: it gave Band-Aids away by the thousands to groups that would use them BAND - AID.COM

Unit 1

| Lesson 3

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

BAND - AID.COM

and spread the word, from the military to outdoor organizations. Free samples let the product prove itself, and over time the Band-Aid became a basic item in nearly every home’s medicine cabinet.

BAND - AID.COM

DID YOU KNOW?

• The very first Band-Aids were made completely by hand and came in 18-inch strips you had to cut yourself. Pre-cut, ready-to-use sizes did not arrive until 1924. • Band-Aid sales totaled only about $3,000 in 1921. That would equal roughly $50,000 today. Even after adjusting for inflation, it was a

Unit 1

| Lesson 3

STOP & TH I N K Why might giving away free samples work better than just telling people about the bandage?

The story had a good ending for Earle Dickson, too. He rose to become a vice president at Johnson & Johnson and stayed with the company until he passed away in 1961, by which time BandAid sales had grown to tens of millions of dollars. Today Johnson & Johnson is a public company traded on the stock market, and over the years more than 100 billion Band-Aids have been made. The simple design Dickson sketched a hundred years ago has barely changed.

small beginning for a product that has now been made more than 100 billion times. • The name Band-Aid became so familiar that many people began using it to refer to any small adhesive bandage, even one made by another company.

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

Unit

What a Business Is

THE LESSON The best products often fix a problem people had quietly accepted. Before the Band-Aid, people did not think bandaging a small cut was a “problem.” It was just an annoying thing you put up with, the way things had always been done. That is exactly what makes Earle Dickson’s thinking so smart. He noticed a need that people had stopped even noticing, because they assumed there was no better way. Many of the best businesses are built this way. They do not invent a brand-new desire. They spot an everyday hassle that everyone has quietly accepted, and they fix it. The key is that the problem has to be common. One person’s rare annoyance is not a business. But almost everyone gets small cuts, so almost

BAND - AID.COM

everyone could use an easy bandage. When a quiet, accepted hassle turns out to be shared by millions of people, the demand can build a company. The trick is noticing the problem in the first place, when everyone around you has stopped seeing it.

Which problem is bigger than it looks? © Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

TAKE IT TO THE CLASS

Try this as a class. One student names a small, everyday hassle that people just put up with, something so normal nobody complains about it. Then, as a group, count how many people probably share that exact hassle. Here is the thing to notice. Almost every “that is just how it is” annoyance is actually shared by a huge number of people. Earle Dickson started with a problem everyone ignored and ended up serving the whole world. Discuss which hassles are truly common and which are actually rare, because telling those two apart is exactly what decides whether fixing one could become a real business.

Unit 1

| Lesson 3

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

The Work Check your understanding 1. What was Earle Dickson’s job, and how did it lead him to the idea?

2. Describe how Dickson put his bandage together.

3. What was wrong with the very first Band-Aid that made it sell poorly?

Think harder 1. Dickson fixed a problem people had quietly accepted. Why are those kinds of problems easy to miss but valuable to solve?

2. Why does a problem have to be common, not rare, for it to become a real business?

Try it yourself

BUSINESS RULE

Find one small, everyday hassle in your own life that you have just gotten used to, something you never really thought of as a fixable problem. Describe it, and sketch one idea for a product that would fix it.

Unit 1

3. The first Band-Aid earned only about $3,000 in a year. Why do you think Johnson & Johnson kept going instead of giving up?

| Lesson 3

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

“The best products often fix a problem people had quietly accepted.”

Unit

What a Business Is

1-800-GOT-JUNK Doing a dirty job the clean way

WORDS TO KNOW MEET THESE BEFORE YOU READ

• Reliable - can be counted on to do what was promised, every time. • Reputation - what people generally believe and say about a business. • System - a set way of doing something so it turns out the same each time. • Brand - the name and image that make a company recognizable and trusted.

Watch for these words as you read. This is a story about how doing an ordinary job in a reliable, professional way can beat everyone else doing it carelessly.

STO P & TH I NK Brian started with about a thousand dollars and one used truck. What does that tell you about how much money it takes to start some businesses?

R E A D THE S T ORY A nineteen-year-old sat in a drivethrough line, broke and trying to figure out how to pay for college. Then he noticed a battered old truck hauling junk, and thought four words that would eventually build the biggest junk-removal company on earth: “I can do that.”

n 1989, a nineteen-year-old named Brian Scudamore was sitting in a drive-through line in Vancouver, Canada. He needed money to pay for college, and he was looking for a way to earn it. Ahead of him in line was an old, beat-up pickup truck with a sign advertising a junkhauling service. Most people would not have looked twice. Brian thought, “I can do that,” and a business was born. He put about $1,000 of his savings into the idea. He spent $700 on a used pickup truck and used the rest for flyers and business cards. He called his one-man company The Rubbish Boys, because, as he later said, he wanted it to sound bigger than it was. Then he went looking for customers, knocking on doors and asking people if they had junk they wanted hauled away. In his first year, he earned about $1,700 in profit, just enough to help pay his tuition. As the company grew, its annual revenue eventually reached about $1 million. But Brian was not satisfied with how it ran. The trucks and workers did not look as clean and professional as he wanted, and customers complained. In 1994, five years after he started the company, he made a bold and painful decision.

Unit 1

| Lesson 4

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

WIKIPEDIA .COM

Brian Scudamore

WIKIPEDIA .COM

Unit 1

| Lesson 4

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

Unit

What a Business Is

THEHUSTLE .CO

STO P & TH I NK Brian let go of all eleven employees while the company was already making a million dollars a year. Why would someone risk that?

So in 1994 he made a bold and painful decision. He let go of all eleven of his employees at once and started rebuilding the company around a single idea: junk removal that did not feel like junk. That idea changed everything. Brian made his trucks clean and freshly painted. His workers wore uniforms. They told each customer an exact time they would arrive, and then they actually arrived on

Why would clean trucks and arriving on time matter so much for a business as ordinary as hauling junk? Why did writing down his “system” make it possible for the company to grow into many cities?

1800GOTJUNK .COM

Unit 1

| Lesson 4

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

time. They answered the phone politely, every time. This mattered more than it sounds. People had always expected junk haulers to be late, messy, and rude, so a company that was clean, on time, and friendly felt like a small miracle. Surprised and relieved customers told their friends.

The single truck Brian spotted from a drive-through line grew into the largest junk-removal company in the world, operating in the United States, Canada, and Australia. Unlike WD-40 and Johnson & Johnson, it is a private company, which means its shares are not sold on the stock market. It is owned by Brian’s larger company, O2E Brands, and brings in around $300 million a year. Brian never invented hauling. He simply did an ordinary job in an organized, trustworthy way, and that turned out to be worth a fortune.

DID YOU KNOW?

• Brian’s first $1,000 in 1989 would be worth roughly $2,700 in today’s money, and the truck itself, at $700, about $1,900 today. A tiny start for a company that now earns hundreds of millions a year. • Brian called his one-man company “The Rubbish Boys” on purpose,

Unit 1

| Lesson 4

1800GOTJUNK .COM

STOP & TH I N K Brian invented nothing new, yet built a huge company. How was that possible?

In 1997, Brian gave the company a name that was easy to remember and a phone number that spelled it out: 1-800-GOT-JUNK. Just as important, he wrote down clear rules for exactly how every truck should look and how every worker should treat a customer, so a person calling in one city got the same clean, on-time service as a person in another. That written system is what let the company grow into many locations without falling apart, because other owners could run their trucks exactly the way Brian ran his.

because he wanted it to sound like a big operation rather than a single teenager with one used truck. • The whole idea began in a drivethrough line, when Brian saw one beat-up junk truck and thought, “I can do that.”

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

Unit

What a Business Is

THE LESSON You do not need a new idea. You can win by doing an old job better. Brian Scudamore did not invent anything. People had hauled away junk for as long as there had been junk. He had no special product and no secret formula. What he had was a better way of doing a job everyone else did carelessly. He made it reliable, clean, and pleasant, and that was enough to beat everyone else and build a strong reputation. This is worth slowing down on, because it goes against what people expect. You do not always need a brand-new invention to build a business. Sometimes the opportunity is an ordinary job that everyone does badly. If customers have low expectations because the service is usually unpleasant, then simply being trustworthy and professional makes you stand out enormously.

Brian also did something clever: he wrote down his system, the exact rules for how every job should be done, so the company could grow to many cities while every customer still got the same good experience. A good idea done reliably, again and again, can be worth more than a flashy idea done sloppily.

New idea, or old job done better? © Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

TAKE IT TO THE CLASS

Here is the debate. To build a successful business, do you need a brand-new idea nobody has thought of, or can you succeed just by doing an ordinary, boring job better than everyone else? Brian got rich hauling junk, something thousands of people already did. Argue both sides. One side says the big money is in new inventions and original ideas. The other side says, like Brian, that there is huge opportunity in fixing ordinary jobs that everyone does poorly. As you debate, look around your own town for services that are usually slow, rude, or messy. Each one might be a business waiting for someone to do it better.

Unit 1

| Lesson 4

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

The Work Check your understanding 1. How much did Brian spend to start his company, and what did he spend it on?

2. What was the company first called, and why did he choose that name?

3. What bold decision did Brian make in 1994, and why?

Think harder 1. Brian invented nothing new, yet built a huge company. Explain in your own words how that was possible.

2. Why does an ordinary job that everyone does badly make an especially good business opportunity?

Try it yourself

BUSINESS RULE

Think of a service in your area that is often slow, messy, or unfriendly. Describe how you would do that exact same job better, and what would make customers choose you over the others.

Unit 1

3. Why was writing down his “system” so important for letting the company grow to many cities?

| Lesson 4

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

“You do not need a new idea. You can win by doing an old job better.”

End of Unit 1 CHAPTER SUMMARY

What a Business Is A look back at the four stories and the big ideas behind them.

This unit answered one question four different ways. WD-40 was a chemical built for missiles that ended up in millions of kitchen drawers. Post-it Notes started as a glue that did its job badly. The Band-Aid fixed a problem people had stopped noticing. And a teenager with one beat-up truck built the biggest junk-hauling company in the world. Four very different companies, one shared lesson about where a business actually comes from.

WD-40

The product barely changed for 70 years. What grew was the number of people who wanted it. Same thing, far bigger market.

Post-it Notes

A glue that failed at sticking things permanently was perfect for notes you peel off. A weakness became the whole product.

Band-Aid

Bandaging a cut used to take two hands. One man noticed the hassle everyone had accepted, and fixed it.

THE BIG QUESTION

What turns an idea into a real business?

An idea becomes a business the moment someone is willing to pay for it. Everything else in this unit, price, value, trust, doing a job well, is really about one thing: getting people to pay, and then getting them to come back.

1-800-GOT-JUNK Hauling junk was nothing new. Doing it clean, on time, and friendly was, and that alone built a giant.

THE FOUR RULES YOU COLLECTED 1. The price is not

the cost. The gap between them is where a business lives or dies.

2. A weak point can

become a strong product, if you find the right problem.

End of Unit 1

3. The best

products often fix a problem people had quietly accepted.

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

4. You do not need

a new idea. You can win by doing an old job better.

BRING IT TOGETHER

Put It All Together Three ways to prove you really own these ideas. 1. Match The Idea Draw a line from each situation on the left to the unit idea on the right that fits it best. A water bottle sells for $20 but holds $2 of plastic. Joe cuts lawns faster and neater than anyone in town. A clip is invented that solves a small daily annoyance. A glue that failed at one job turns out perfect for another.

Doing an old job better The price is not the cost A weak point becomes a product Fixing a quietly accepted problem

2. Key Words Check Fill in each blank with the right word: revenue, market, reputation. The money a business takes in by selling something is its

All the people who might want to buy a product are its What people generally believe about a business is its

. .

3. Your Turn: Joe’s Cold Drinks

The Situation Joe noticed that people leaving the park on hot afternoons were thirsty, and the nearest store was a long walk away. So he set up a small stand selling cold drinks near the park gate on weekends. He is not selling anything new, anyone can buy a drink somewhere. To win, Joe has to use the ideas from this unit. Answer in your own words: a. What problem did Joe notice that people had quietly accepted? b. His drinks cost more than the drinks themselves. What is the customer really paying for? c. Name one way Joe could do this ordinary job better than anyone else.

End of Unit 1

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

End of Unit 1 PRACTICAL FORM

Meet the Form: The DBA The form that gives a business its name.

A business may use a public name that is different from its owner’s legal name or its company’s formal name. In many places, the owner registers that name as a DBA—short for Doing Business As. A DBA filing connects the public business name to the person or company behind it. Requirements vary by state, county, and city.

WHAT EACH LINE IS FOR FICTITIOUS BUSINESS NAME STATEMENT (DBA)

Arthur ’s Squeak Stoppers Business name

Arthur Kane

148 Maple Street, Springfield

Owner’s name

Business addres

Fixing squeaky doors, hinges, and locks

Type of business

Business name The name customers will see. Registering a DBA may be required, but it does not by itself create trademark rights or stop another business from using a similar name. Owner’s name Says who is really behind the business, so customers know who stands by the work. Type of business

Arthur Kane

June 3

A short, plain description of what the business actually does.

Owner’s signature

Date

Signature & date Makes it official, and marks the day the business name became real.

WHY IT MATTERS A DBA helps the public identify who operates under a business name. It does not create a separate company or prove that the idea will make money. Depending on local rules and bank requirements, a business owner may use the DBA filing, together with other documents, to open an account and conduct business under that name.

End of Unit 1

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

PRACTICAL FORM

Your Turn: File a DBA Invent a business, then make it official. Now it is your business. Think of a small business you would actually want to run. It can be a service, like Arthur’s, or something you make and sell. Plan it out first, then fill in the DBA to make it real.

First, Plan It Out What will your business do? Keep it to one clear sentence. Who are your customers, the people who would actually pay for it?

Now File Your DBA

FICTITIOUS BUSINESS NAME STATEMENT (DBA)

Business name

Business addres

Owner’s name

Type of business

Owner’s signature

Date

Last Question Why did you choose that name? What does it tell a customer before they ever talk to you?

End of Unit 1

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

Unit

Product Businesses

LEGO

WORDS TO KNOW

Only the best is good enough

MEET THESE BEFORE YOU READ

• Cost - the money a company spends to make and sell a product. • Price - the money a customer pays to buy the product. • Profit - what is left when you subtract the cost from the price. • Quality - how well a product is made and how well it lasts.

Watch for these words as you read. The LEGO story is about why a customer will pay far more for a product than the materials in it seem to be worth.

STO P & TH I NK Why would toys keep selling during a depression, when furniture did not?

R E A D T H E S T ORY A carpenter had just laid off nearly every worker he had. His shop had burned down, the whole country was broke, and furniture was not selling. So he bet what little he had left on something almost laughably small: toys. That desperate little gamble became the biggest toy company on earth.

n 1916, a carpenter named Ole Kirk Christiansen bought a small woodworking shop in the village of Billund, Denmark. He built furniture and houses for people in his town. He was skilled and hard-working, but the years that followed were brutally difficult. His workshop burned down, and he rebuilt it. Then, in the 1930s, a worldwide economic crisis called the Great Depression hit. People stopped buying furniture, and Christiansen had to let go of his workers one by one until almost no one was left. Desperate for something cheaper to make, Christiansen turned to toys. He had been making tiny wooden models of his furniture as samples, and those small objects gave him the idea. In 1932 he began making simple wooden toys: cars, animals, and a now-famous pull-along duck. It was a shrewd choice. Toys cost less to make than furniture, and even in hard times, families would still find a few coins for something to keep a child happy.

Unit 2

| Lesson 5

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

WIKIPEDIA .COM

The biggest change came in 1947, when Christiansen bought the first plastic molding machine in Denmark. It was a huge gamble; the machine cost more than the company’s entire profit from the year before, and many people doubted that plastic toys would ever sell. But he believed WIKIPEDIA .COM

Unit 2

| Lesson 5

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

Ole Kirk Christiansen WIKIPEDIA .COM © Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

In 1934 he gave the company a name, combining the Danish words leg godt, meaning play well, into the word LEGO. He also adopted a motto that would guide the company forever: only the best is good enough. He meant it literally. There is a famous true story about his son Godtfred, who proudly told his father he had saved money by giving a shipment of wooden ducks two coats of varnish instead of the usual three. Christiansen made him take the whole shipment back and add the third coat. Quality came before saving a little money.

STOP & TH I N K Why would Christiansen pay for a third coat of varnish that a customer might never notice?

Unit

Product Businesses

WIKIPEDIA .COM

STO P & TH I NK Why would the exact way two bricks grip each other matter so much to the whole business?

in it, and the company began making plastic toys, including an early connecting brick. The first bricks did not sell well and had a flaw: they did not lock together firmly enough. So the company kept improving the design. In 1958 it patented the brick we know today, with round studs on top and hollow tubes underneath that grip just tightly enough to hold firm, yet pull apart easily. That precise design was the heart of everything. Because the bricks were made so exactly, a brick made decades ago still locks perfectly onto a brick made today. Christiansen’s son had already

WIKIPEDIA .COM

Unit 2

| Lesson 5

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

WIKIPEDIA .COM

seen the bigger idea: LEGO would sell a system, where every set worked with every other set, so a child could keep building forever.

Today the LEGO Group, still based in Billund, is the largest toy company in the world. It is a private company, which means its shares are not sold on the stock market, and it is still owned by the founder’s family, now into its fourth generation. In 2024 it brought in roughly $10 billion. The carpenter who once had to lay off all his workers built a company that now makes tens of thousands of bricks every minute, each one made so well it will still fit the next.

DID YOU KNOW?

• LEGO bricks are made so precisely that only about 18 out of every million come out faulty. That is why a brick made decades ago still snaps perfectly onto a brand-new one. • Six standard eight-stud LEGO bricks of the same color can be

Unit 2

| Lesson 5

BOOZT.COM

STOP & TH I N K Why might LEGO’s choice to stay a private, familyowned company fit a business built on long-term quality?

That precision is not free. LEGO bricks are made to such exact measurements that only a tiny fraction ever come out faulty, which is exactly why they fit so perfectly and last so long. The careful, expensive quality that Christiansen demanded over a third coat of varnish is the same quality that lets a customer trust that any LEGO brick will fit any other. People pay for that trust.

combined in more than 915 million different ways. • The name LEGO comes from the Danish words “leg godt,” meaning “play well.” Much later, people noticed that in Latin, “lego” can mean “I put together,” a fitting accident.

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

Unit

Product Businesses

THE LESSON People pay for quality they can trust, not for the materials inside. A small bag of plain plastic costs very little. So why does a box of LEGO cost what it does? Because the price of a product covers far more than its raw materials. It covers the machines, the factory, the workers, the years of design, the testing, and the careful quality that makes every brick fit perfectly. The money a company spends to make and sell a product is its cost. The money a customer pays is the price. The gap between them is the profit. Profit is not a bad word. It is what a company keeps after paying for everything, and it is what lets it pay workers, improve products, and survive a hard year. LEGO can charge well above the cost of the plastic because customers believe the quality and the connecting system

WIKIPEDIA .COM

are worth it. Christiansen’s motto, “only the best is good enough,” was not just a nice saying. It was a business decision. By making a product people trusted to last and to fit together perfectly, LEGO earned the right to charge a price far above its cost. That is the difference between selling plastic and selling LEGO.

Is a box of LEGO worth the price? © Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

TAKE IT TO THE CLASS

Here is the debate. A bag of plain plastic pieces costs very little to make. A box of LEGO costs much more to buy. Is LEGO charging a fair price, or charging too much for some plastic? Split the room. One side argues that customers are paying for quality, precise design, and a system that lasts for decades, so the price is fair. The other side argues that plastic is plastic and the price is too high. As you argue, try to name exactly what a customer is really paying for beyond the material. That question, what am I actually paying for, is one every smart shopper and every business owner has to answer.

Unit 2

| Lesson 5

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

The Work Check your understanding 1. What hard events nearly stopped Christiansen’s business before LEGO succeeded?

3. What was special about the 1958 brick design with studs and tubes?

2. What gamble did Christiansen take in 1947, and why did people doubt it?

4. Is LEGO a public or a private company today, and who owns it?

Think harder 1. A bag of plastic is cheap, but a box of LEGO is not. Explain why the price is so much higher than the cost of the plastic.

2. Christiansen made his son re-varnish the ducks. How could insisting on high quality, even when it costs more, actually help a company make more profit in the long run?

Try it yourself

BUSINESS RULE

Think of two versions of the same kind of thing you own or have used, a cheap one and a well-made one, like two backpacks or two pens. Describe what made the better one worth more, and whether you would pay extra for that quality again.

Unit 2

3. LEGO sells a system where every set works with every other set. Why is that smarter for the business than selling separate, unconnected toys?

| Lesson 5

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

“People pay for quality they can trust, not for the materials inside.”

Unit

Product Businesses

CRAYOLA

WORDS TO KNOW

From tire pigment to a childhood staple

MEET THESE BEFORE YOU READ

• Pigment - the material that gives color to a product. • Value - how useful or worth paying for something is to a customer. • Raw materials - the basic stuff a product is made from before it is finished. • Brand - the name and reputation that make a product recognizable and trusted.

Watch for these words as you read. Crayola shows how the same cheap materials can be nearly worthless or quite valuable, depending on what you turn them into.

STO P & TH I NK What did making pigment for tires and barns have in common with making crayons?

R E A D THE S T ORY The same company that made the black pigment for car tires and the red paint for barns made one more thing out of color and wax. It cost a nickel, it was meant for the hands of small children, and it would end up in almost every classroom in the country.

n 1885, two cousins named Edwin Binney and C. Harold Smith took over a pigment business that had belonged to Edwin’s father, and named it Binney & Smith. A pigment is the material that gives color or darkness to other products, and the company’s early work was about as far from a children’s toy as you can imagine. They made carbon black, a deep black pigment used in ink and car tires, and a red pigment used to paint barns. Their pigments went into serious industrial products. The carbon black was so good that in 1911 a tire company ordered a million pounds of it a year, because the pigment did more than make tires black; it actually made the rubber stronger and last longer. Binney and Smith were experts at two things: understanding color pigments, and working with wax. They had even won a gold medal for a dustless chalk at a World’s Fair. Then they noticed a problem in schools.

Unit 2

| Lesson 6

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

WIKIPEDIA .COM

Children needed crayons, but the ones available were either expensive, imported, or made with materials that were not safe for kids to handle. The cousins realized they were already experts at exactly what a good crayon needed: safe color pigments and shaped wax. So they combined paraffin wax with safe pigments and made a crayon meant for children instead of for labeling crates. In 1903, the first box of eight Crayola crayons went on

Unit 2

| Lesson 6

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

C. Harold Smith

WIKIPEDIA .COM

Edwin Binney

STOP & TH I N K The company noticed a problem in schools. Why was that a business opportunity and not just an observation?

Unit

Product Businesses

sale for a nickel, in red, orange, yellow, green, blue, violet, brown, and black.

STO P & TH I NK The crayons cost only a nickel. How might such a low price have helped the product spread quickly?

The name Crayola was created by Alice Binney, Edwin’s wife and a former schoolteacher. She joined the French word craie, meaning chalk, with ola, taken from a word meaning oily, since the crayons were made from wax. The crayons were an instant hit. Here is what makes the story so striking. The company did not invent a brandnew skill to make them. It took the exact same knowledge it used for industrial tire black and barn paint, and pointed it at a completely different customer: schoolchildren and their parents. The cheap raw materials, wax and color, became valuable not because the materials changed, but because of what the finished product could do, which was let a child draw safely in eight bright colors. The pigment that colored tires was worth a certain amount to a tire company. The same kind of pigment, shaped into a safe crayon, was worth a nickel a

WIKIPEDIA .COM

Unit 2

| Lesson 6

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

WIKIPEDIA .COM

box to millions of families, and far more in total than the raw materials alone. A smart company asks not just what something is made of, but what it can do for someone, and who will pay for that.

DID YOU KNOW?

• That first box of eight crayons cost a nickel in 1903. Adjusted for inflation, five cents back then is worth only about $1.70 today, so the crayons were inexpensive even by modern standards. • In a Yale University study of the most recognizable scents, the smell of a Crayola crayon ranked

Unit 2

| Lesson 6

STOP & TH I N K Why might the company have eventually renamed itself after Crayola rather than keeping the founders’ names?

Today Crayola still makes crayons, markers, and art supplies, and it is one of the most recognized brands in the world. It became part of the greeting-card company Hallmark in 1984, and the company once called Binney & Smith renamed itself Crayola in 2007 after its most famous product. It remains a private company and makes around 3 billion crayons a year. A business built on black tire pigment became one of the most colorful companies on earth.

among the most familiar of all, with everyday smells like coffee and peanut butter at the very top. • Under the Crayola name, the company has made more than 100 billion crayons, roughly two billion a year, or about five million every single day.

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

Unit

Product Businesses

THE LESSON People pay for what a product does for them, not for what it is made of. A Crayola crayon is mostly wax and a little color pigment, cheap materials. Yet families happily paid for a box in 1903, and still do today. Why? Because customers are not really buying wax and pigment. They are buying what the crayon does: it lets a child draw safely, in bright colors, without danger or mess. That usefulness is what gives the product its value. This is one of the most important ideas about product businesses. The same cheap raw materials can be nearly worthless or quite valuable, depending on what you turn them into and who needs it. Binney & Smith proved it twice over: the same pigment skill that colored tires and barns became something parents would buy

WIKIPEDIA .COM

for their children, simply by being shaped into a safe, useful product for a new customer. The lesson is to stop asking only what something is made of, and start asking what it can do for someone, and who will pay for that.

Same stuff, different value © Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

TAKE IT TO THE CLASS

Try this as a class. Crayola turned cheap wax and pigment into a product families pay for. Can you think of other examples where ordinary, cheap materials become valuable once they are turned into the right product? Sand into glass. Flour into bread. Cotton into clothing. Discuss what actually adds the value in each case. Is it the skill, the design, the safety, the convenience, or something else? There is no single answer, and different students will weigh these differently. The goal is to see clearly that value comes from what a product does for someone, not just from what it is made of.

Unit 2

| Lesson 6

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

The Work Check your understanding 1. What was Binney & Smith’s business before they made Crayola crayons?

2. What two skills did the company already have that made crayons a natural product for them?

3. How much did the first box of Crayola crayons cost, and how many colors did it have?

Think harder 1. The materials in a crayon are cheap, yet people pay for crayons. Explain why, using the idea of what a product does for a customer.

2. Binney & Smith used the same pigment knowledge for tires and for crayons. Why is it smart for a company to find a new customer for skills it already has?

Try it yourself

BUSINESS RULE

Think of a cheap material you could turn into something more valuable, like turning paper into greeting cards or string into bracelets. Describe the cheap material, the finished product, and who would pay for it.

Unit 2

3. Crayola crayons were safe for children when many crayons were not. How could safety alone make a product more valuable than a cheaper, less safe one?

| Lesson 6

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

“People pay for what a product does for them, not for what it is made of.”

Unit

WORDS TO KNOW MEET THESE BEFORE YOU READ

Product Businesses

JOHN DEERE The plow that had to be better

• Blacksmith - a person who shapes metal tools and objects by hand. • Quality - how well a product is made and how well it does its job. • Continuous improvement - always making a product a little better instead of leaving it the same. • Competitor another business trying to win the same customers.

Watch for these words as you read. John Deere’s story is about making a product that truly works, then never letting it stay the same.

STO P & TH I NK Deere arrived nearly broke and became the only blacksmith in town. Why was that a good position for a new business?

R E A D T HE S T ORY A blacksmith arrived in a frontier town with seventy-three dollars and a mountain of debt. Every farmer near him was fighting the same losing battle against sticky soil that glued itself to their plows. Then he spotted a broken, discarded sawmill blade, and saw in it the tool that would build one of the biggest companies in America.

ohn Deere was born in Vermont in 1804 and trained as a blacksmith, a person who shapes metal tools by hand. By his early thirties his life had become very hard. His blacksmith shop had burned more than once, he was deep in debt, and he had a growing family to support. In 1837 he headed west to the frontier and arrived in the small town of Grand Detour, Illinois, reportedly with just over $73 to his name. He became the only skilled blacksmith in the area. He was busy within days, and as he worked he kept hearing the same complaint. Farmers had brought iron and wooden plows from the eastern states, but those plows did not work in the thick, sticky black soil of the prairie. The rich dirt clung to the plow so badly that a farmer had to stop every few feet and scrape it off by hand. Plowing a single field took forever. When many different people share the exact same problem, that is a powerful clue for a business.

Unit 2

| Lesson 7

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

John Deere

WIKIPEDIA .COM

SMITHSONIANMAG.COM

Unit 2

| Lesson 7

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

Unit

Product Businesses

WIKIPEDIA .COM

STO P & TH I NK © Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

Deere built his first steel plow from a broken sawmill blade. What does that tell you about solving problems with whatever you have? Building plows before anyone ordered them was risky. Why might Deere have taken that risk?

WIKIPEDIA .COM

Deere thought there had to be a better way. He reasoned that a blade made of smooth, polished steel, instead of rough cast iron, might let the sticky soil slide right off. Steel was scarce on the frontier, so in 1837 he found a broken steel sawmill blade, cut off its teeth, shaped it over a log, and polished the surface smooth. When a farmer tried it, the soil slid off cleanly and the plow cut through the prairie without stopping. It worked so well it earned a nickname, the singing plow, for the zing it made slicing through the earth.

Word spread fast, and the sales numbers tell a remarkable story. Deere made just one plow in 1837, then two in 1838, ten in 1839, and forty in 1840. By 1846 he was selling nearly a thousand a year, and after he moved the company to Moline, Illinois, more than thirteen thousand a year by the mid-1850s. He also made an unusual choice for his time: instead of building a plow only after a customer ordered it, he believed in his plow so strongly that he built them in advance and went out to sell them. Most important of all, Deere never treated his plow as finished. He kept searching for better steel and better shapes and kept improving the design, much to the frustration of business partners who would rather have settled on one version and simply sold it. His belief was that a product must keep getting better, or a competitor would build Unit 2

| Lesson 7

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

WIKIPEDIA .COM

something better and take the customers. He understood that quality is not a finish line you cross once. It is a race that never ends.

DID YOU KNOW?

• John Deere’s steel plow was nicknamed the “singing plow” for the zinging sound it made slicing cleanly through the sticky prairie soil. • Deere’s sales grew astonishingly: just 1 plow in 1837, then 2, then

Unit 2

| Lesson 7

STOP & TH I N K How did both ideas, making a better plow and always improving it, work together to build the company?

Today Deere & Company is the largest farm equipment maker in the world. It is a public company, traded on the stock market under the symbol DE, so anyone can buy a share of it. In 2025 it brought in around $45 billion, making giant tractors and harvesters that still carry a leaping-deer logo. It all grew from one blacksmith who refused to accept that a plow could not be better, and then refused to stop making it better.

10, then 40, reaching about a thousand a year by 1846. • The leaping-deer logo has been part of the company for about 150 years. It has been redrawn many times, but a jumping deer has appeared on every version.

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

Unit

Product Businesses

THE LESSON Make the thing that actually works, then keep making it better. John Deere did not invent the plow. Plows had existed for thousands of years. What he did was make a plow that actually worked where the old ones failed. That alone is a powerful business idea: a product that truly solves the customer’s problem will sell, even in a crowded field, because it does the job better. There were thousands of plow makers; Deere’s won because it worked. But Deere added a second idea that mattered just as much. He never treated his plow as finished. He kept hunting for better steel and better shapes, always improving, even when partners wanted him to stop and just sell. This is called continuous improvement, and it

WIKIPEDIA .COM

protects a business. If you stop improving, a competitor will make something better and take your customers. Deere understood that quality is not a finish line you cross once. It is a race that never ends, and staying in front is how a company stays alive.

Better, or just cheaper? © Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

TAKE IT TO THE CLASS

Set up the debate. Imagine you sell a good, well-made product, and a competitor starts selling one that is lower in quality but cheaper. Do you lower your price to compete, or keep your quality high and charge more? Argue both sides. The “compete on price” side says customers care most about saving money. The “compete on quality” side says, like John Deere, that a clearly better product wins in the long run. As you argue, think about which products people choose mainly by price and which they choose mainly by quality. The answer is different for different things, and figuring out which is which is a real business skill.

Unit 2

| Lesson 7

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

The Work Check your understanding 1. Why did John Deere leave Vermont and move to Illinois?

2. How did Deere make his first steel plow when steel was scarce?

3. What did Deere do differently from other blacksmiths when it came to making plows before they were ordered?

Think harder 1. Plows already existed for thousands of years. So why was Deere’s plow able to build a huge company?

2. Why is “continuous improvement” important even after a product is already successful?

Try it yourself

BUSINESS RULE

Think of a product you use that you wish worked better in some way. Describe the product, the exact thing that annoys you about it, and one improvement that would make you choose it over a competitor.

Unit 2

3. Deere’s partners sometimes wanted him to stop improving the plow and just sell it. Whose side would you take, and why?

| Lesson 7

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

“Make the thing that actually works, then keep making it better.”

Unit

Product Businesses

DYSON

WORDS TO KNOW

Five thousand tries before it worked

MEET THESE BEFORE YOU READ

• Prototype - an early test version of a product, built to see what works. • Development - the work of turning an idea into a product that actually works. • Persistence continuing to try even after many failures. • License - to let another company use your invention in exchange for payment.

Watch for these words as you read. Dyson’s story is about the enormous, mostly invisible work that goes into a product before a customer ever sees it.

STO P & TH I NK Dyson borrowed an idea from sawmills and used it somewhere completely different. Where else might good ideas come from?

R E A D TH E S T ORY He built it, and it failed. He built it again, and it failed again. He kept going past a hundred tries, past a thousand, sliding deeper into debt with each one. By the time the machine in his hands finally worked, he had built it five thousand one hundred and twenty-seven times.

n the late 1970s, a British designer and engineer named James Dyson was simply annoyed. He had bought what was supposed to be a powerful vacuum cleaner, but it kept losing suction. The problem, he realized, was the bag. As the bag filled with dust, its tiny holes clogged, and the vacuum could no longer pull in air properly. The bag was not just collecting dust; it was strangling the machine. He thought there had to be a way to clean without a bag at all. Dyson had seen large sawmills use a device called a cyclone, a tall cone that spins air fast enough to fling dust out of it, with no bag and no filter to clog. He wondered if the same idea could work inside a vacuum cleaner. He rigged up a rough first version using cardboard and

Unit 2

| Lesson 8

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

James Dyson

What followed is one of the most famous stories of persistence in business. Working mostly alone, Dyson built one prototype, studied how it failed, changed a single detail, and built another. He did this over and over, for years, often deep in debt, with his family making real sacrifices to keep the project alive. By the time he had a design that

WIKIPEDIA .COM

tape, and it showed promise. But turning a rough idea into a product that truly worked was another matter entirely, and the gap between the two turned out to be enormous.

WIKIPEDIA .COM

STOP & TH I N K Dyson failed more than five thousand times before succeeding. How would you decide whether to keep going or to quit?

DYSON.COM

Unit 2

| Lesson 8

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

Unit

Product Businesses

truly worked, he had built 5,127 prototypes. In other words, more than five thousand failures came before the one success. STO P & TH I NK

How can a failed attempt still be valuable, even though it did not work?

Years later, asked about all those failures, Dyson said, “I didn’t see them as failures. Each one taught me something I didn’t know before.” Every failed prototype was information that pointed toward the next try. But even with a working vacuum, his troubles were not over. He took his invention to the big established vacuum companies, expecting them to be eager. They turned him down.

DYSON.COM

Unit 2

| Lesson 8

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

The reason was simple and, from their point of view, logical: those companies made a great deal of money selling replacement bags, and a bagless vacuum would destroy one of their most profitable products. Unable to sell his idea at home, Dyson licensed it to a Japanese company, which sold his bagless vacuum for a very high price and even won a design prize. That proved something important: people genuinely wanted the product. So Dyson made a bold decision. If no one would build and sell his invention properly, he would do it himself.

DYSON.COM

STOP & TH I N K

DID YOU KNOW?

• It took James Dyson about five years and 5,127 prototypes to get his vacuum right, an average of multiple new test versions every week for years. • Because no company would license his idea fairly at home, Dyson eventually built his own

Unit 2

| Lesson 8

The big companies saw the missing bag as a weakness. Why did it become Dyson’s greatest strength?

In 1993, he launched his own vacuum in the United Kingdom, and he turned the very thing the big companies had hated, the missing bag, into his selling point. Customers, just as tired of clogging bags as Dyson had been, loved it, and it quickly outsold the older bagged machines. His 5,127 prototypes were not wasted; each failure had taught him something the next version needed. Today Dyson is a large, successful private company, owned by the Dyson family, that makes vacuums, fans, and hair dryers sold around the world.

The big companies rejected a better product on purpose. Why would a company resist an invention that was clearly good?

company to make it. Owning the whole business is a big reason he became so wealthy. • Dyson’s first working machine was sold in Japan for a very high price and won a design prize, proving customers really wanted it before he ever built his own factory.

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

Unit

Product Businesses

THE LESSON Most of the cost of a product is the failures nobody sees. When you see a finished product on a store shelf, you see only the final version. You do not see the dozens, hundreds, or even thousands of attempts that did not work. Those attempts cost real time and real money. The work of turning an idea into a product that actually works is called development, and a prototype is an early test version built to learn what works and what does not. This is why products often cost more than their materials seem to be worth. Part of the price pays back all the development that came before, including the failures. Dyson’s 5,127 prototypes are an extreme example, but every real product has some version of this hidden cost. It also

YAHOO.COM

explains a puzzle from earlier in this unit: why a finished product is worth so much more than the raw stuff inside it. You are also paying for everything it took to figure the product out, all the persistence that happened long before the product reached the shelf.

When should you quit? © Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

TAKE IT TO THE CLASS

Here is a genuinely hard question. James Dyson built 5,127 prototypes before one worked. That is incredible persistence. But imagine a friend who has tried something 5,000 times and it still does not work. Would you tell them to keep going, or to stop and try something else? Argue it out. One side admires Dyson’s refusal to quit. The other side points out that for every Dyson who succeeds, there are people who keep going far too long on an idea that will never work. How do you tell the difference between brave persistence and stubbornly wasting time? Nobody knows for sure, which is exactly why this is worth debating.

Unit 2

| Lesson 8

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

The Work Check your understanding 1. What problem with his vacuum cleaner set Dyson off on his invention? 2. Where did Dyson get the cyclone idea, and about how many prototypes did it take? 3. Why did the big vacuum companies turn down his invention?

Think harder 1. The customer only sees the final vacuum on the shelf. What hidden costs went into it that the customer never sees?

2. How does Dyson’s story help explain why a finished product can cost much more than its raw materials?

Try it yourself

BUSINESS RULE

Think of something you once had to try many times before you got it right, like a skill, a recipe, or a project. Describe roughly how many tries it took and what each failure taught you that helped you finally succeed.

Unit 2

3. Dyson decided to manufacture his vacuum himself after companies refused to sell it fairly. What did he gain, and what did he risk, by doing that?

| Lesson 8

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

“Most of the cost of a product is the failures nobody sees.”

End of Unit 2 CHAPTER SUMMARY

Product Businesses A look back at the four makers and the value hidden inside what they sell.

This unit was about businesses that make a physical product, something you can hold. A box of LEGO, a crayon, a steel plow, a vacuum cleaner. In every story the same surprising idea showed up: people pay far more for a finished product than the materials inside it are worth. The question this unit answered is why, and where that extra value comes from.

THE BIG QUESTION

Why do people pay more for a product than its materials are worth?

Because a finished product is much more than its materials. You are paying for the quality, the design, the work that went into it, and all the failed attempts you never see. The raw materials are cheap. Turning them into something people trust is what costs money, and what customers are really paying for.

LEGO

A bag of plastic is cheap. People pay for LEGO because the bricks are made so precisely they always fit, and that trust is worth far more than the plastic.

Crayola

The same wax and color used in factories became crayons. The materials were cheap. What made them valuable was everything a child could do with them.

John Deere

A blacksmith built a plow that actually worked in heavy prairie soil, then never stopped improving it. A product that truly works will win.

Dyson

It took 5,127 tries to build a vacuum that worked. Most of a product’s cost is the long string of failures nobody ever sees.

THE FOUR RULES YOU COLLECTED 1. People pay for

quality they can trust, not for the materials inside.

2. People pay for what

a product does for them, not for what it is made of.

End of Unit 2

3. Make the thing

that actually works, then keep making it better.

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

4. Most of the cost

of a product is the failures nobody sees.

BRING IT TOGETHER

Put It All Together Three ways to prove you really own these ideas. 1. Match The Idea Draw a line from each situation on the left to the unit idea on the right that fits it best. A crayon is mostly cheap wax, yet families gladly pay for it. A vacuum took thousands of failed tries before it worked. Two bricks snap together perfectly every single time. A plow keeps getting better year after year.

Pay for what it does, not what it’s made of Most of the cost is the failures you don’t see Pay for quality you can trust Make it work, then keep improving it

2. Key Words Check Fill in each blank with the right word: profit, prototype, quality. What is left after you subtract costs from the money you take in is

An early test version of a product, built to see what works, is a How well a product is made and how well it lasts is its

. .

3. Your Turn: Ben’s Phone Stands

The Situation Ben builds wooden phone stands in his garage and sells them. The wood for each one costs him about $2, but he sells them for $15. His friend says he is overcharging. Ben says the price is fair. Use what this unit taught you to settle it. Answer in your own words: a. Besides the $2 of wood, name two things Ben’s price is really paying for. b. Ben’s first few stands wobbled before he got the design right. How do those failures fit into the cost of the good ones? c. Is $15 fair for a $2 piece of wood? Defend your answer using a unit idea.

End of Unit 2

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

End of Unit 2 PRACTICAL FORM

Meet the Form: The Profit and Loss Statement The form that shows whether a business actually made money.

Making and selling a product is exciting, but a business owner has to answer one cold question: did I actually make money? The form that answers it is the Profit and Loss Statement, often just called a P&L. It lines up the money that came in against the money that went out, and shows what is left. Here is one for Ben, who also builds and sells birdhouses.

WHAT EACH LINE IS FOR

PROFIT AND LOSS STATEMENT

Revenue

Ben’s Birdhouses

All the money that came in from selling the product.

Business Money in: 24 birdhouses sold at $15

$360

Money out: wood and supplies

$80

Money out: paint and brushes

$40

Total costs

$120

Profit (revenue minus costs)

$240

Costs Everything spent to make and sell it, like materials and supplies. Profit What is left when you subtract costs from revenue. This is the number that really matters.

WHY IT MATTERS A business can be busy and still lose money. Ben could sell a hundred birdhouses and still come out behind if each one costs more to make than he charges. The P&L is how he finds out the truth. Based on the costs listed here, Ben has $240 remaining. In a real Profit and Loss Statement, every business expense must be included—such as labor, rent, delivery costs, advertising, fees, and other operating expenses—before final profit is known.

End of Unit 2

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

PRACTICAL FORM

Your Turn: Run a P&L Pick a product, then see if it makes money. Now run the numbers for a small product business of your own. Pick something simple you could make and sell, then fill in the P&L to find out if it would actually make money.

First, Plan It Out What product will you make and sell, and what will you charge for one? What will you have to buy to make it? List the main costs.

Now Fill In Your P&L

PROFIT AND LOSS STATEMENT

Business Money in (revenue)

Money out: first cost Money out: second cost Total costs Profit (revenue minus costs)

Last Question Did your product make a profit? If your costs were higher than your revenue, what could you change?

End of Unit 2

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

Unit

Service Businesses

UPS

WORDS TO KNOW

Two bicycles and a promise

MEET THESE BEFORE YOU READ

• Service business a business that sells useful work or help instead of a physical product. • Reliability - doing what you promised, correctly, every single time. • Reputation - what people generally believe and say about a business. • Competitor another business trying to win the same customers.

Watch for these words as you read. A service business does not sell you an object. It sells you a promise, and UPS shows what it takes to keep one.

STO P & TH I NK Casey and Ryan were the smallest of ten competitors. If you cannot win by being the biggest, how else can a business win?

R E A D T HE S T ORY Two teenagers borrowed a hundred dollars, set up shop in a cramped basement, and bought two bicycles. Nine bigger companies in town already did exactly what they planned to do. They had no way to win on size or money, so they bet everything on one thing their rivals overlooked, and built a company now worth billions.

n 1907, in the city of Seattle, a nineteen-year-old named Jim Casey and his friend Claude Ryan had an idea but almost no money. Back then very few people had telephones, so when someone needed to send a message across town, they often hired a messenger to carry it by hand. Casey and Ryan wanted to run a messenger service. To start it, they borrowed $100 from Ryan’s uncle and set up a tiny office in a basement. Their equipment was simple: a couple of telephones to take orders and two bicycles to make the deliveries. There was a problem. They were not the only messenger service in Seattle. There were already nine other companies doing the very same thing. For a brand-new business with a borrowed bicycle and a basement office, that was tough competition. Casey and Ryan could not win by being bigger, because they were the smallest. So they had to win another way.

Unit 3

| Lesson 9

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

Jim Casey

WIKIPEDIA .COM

Unit 3

| Lesson 9

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

Unit

Service Businesses

WIKIPEDIA .COM WIKIPEDIA .COM

WIKIPEDIA .COM

STO P & TH I NK Why would telling customers the honest delivery time, even when it was slower, actually help the business? Why is a reputation for keeping promises so valuable that it can beat bigger, older competitors?

Jim Casey decided their company would compete on something most of the others ignored: trust. He set strict rules. His messengers would be polite and neatly dressed. They would charge fair, low prices. And, unusually for the time, they would tell each customer the honest truth about when a message would actually be picked up and delivered, instead of promising whatever sounded good. Casey summed up his whole approach in a motto he repeated for the rest of his life: never promise more than you can deliver, and always deliver what you promise. That promise was the whole product. A customer handing over a message was really buying the certainty that it would arrive, on time, as promised. Because Casey kept that promise so reliably, his tiny company slowly earned a reputation other messengers could not match. Even small choices reflected his focus on doing things right. He wanted the delivery vehicles painted a color that would look clean and professional mile after mile, and he chose a shade of brown. That same brown is still on UPS trucks more than a century later, one of the most recognized sights on any street. Unit 3

| Lesson 9

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

WIKIPEDIA .COM

As the company grew, it expanded beyond carrying messages to delivering packages for stores, and in time it took the name United Parcel Service. The honest, reliable habits Casey built in that basement became the company’s identity. A service business cannot hand you something to inspect before you buy. You have to trust it in advance, and UPS won by being the company people could trust.

DID YOU KNOW?

• The $100 Casey and Ryan borrowed in 1907 would be worth only about $3,500 in today’s money. They built one of the world’s largest companies starting from the equivalent of a few thousand dollars. • UPS chose brown for its vehicles on purpose. The company felt

Unit 3

| Lesson 9

STOP & TH I N K How did a promise, rather than a product, grow UPS from two bicycles into a global giant?

Today UPS is one of the largest delivery companies in the world. It is a public company, traded on the stock market under the symbol UPS, delivering millions of packages a day to more than 200 countries, and bringing in nearly $90 billion a year. The company that started with two teenagers, a borrowed hundred dollars, and two bicycles grew into a giant, all on the strength of a simple promise kept again and again.

the color looked clean, dignified, and professional, and it has kept that exact brown for more than a hundred years. • Jim Casey’s motto, “never promise more than you can deliver, and always deliver what you promise,” still guides how delivery companies think about service today.

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

Unit

Service Businesses

THE LESSON In a service business, the promise is the product. When you buy a toy, you can hold it, test it, and see exactly what you are getting. But a service business sells something you cannot hold: useful work, or a promise to do something for you. When Casey’s messengers picked up a note, the customer was not buying an object. They were buying the promise that the note would arrive, on time, as agreed. WIKIPEDIA .COM

That is why reliability is the real product of a service business. Jim Casey understood this better than his nine competitors. He knew that if customers could count on UPS to do exactly what it said, the company would win even though it started smallest. This is also why a single broken promise can hurt a service

company so badly. The customer cannot return a late delivery the way you return a broken toy. They simply stop trusting you, and trust is the whole reputation a service is built on. Casey's motto is one of the most important rules in the service business.

Can you trust what you cannot hold? © Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

TAKE IT TO THE CLASS

Here is the question for the room. With a product, you can inspect it before you buy. With a service, you often pay first and trust the company to deliver. What makes you decide to trust a service you have never used, a barber, a repair shop, a delivery company? Talk it through. People will name things like reviews, recommendations from friends, a clean and professional look, or a clear promise. Notice how many of these are really about reputation, what others say and what the company has done before. That is exactly the thing Jim Casey spent years building, one kept promise at a time.

Unit 3

| Lesson 9

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

The Work Check your understanding 1. How did Casey and Ryan start their company, and with how much money? 2. Why could they not win by being the biggest messenger service? 3. What did Casey decide to compete on instead, and what was his motto?

Think harder 1. Casey said, “never promise more than you can deliver, and always deliver what you promise.” Why is this rule especially important for a service business?

2. Why can a single broken promise hurt a service business more than a single flaw can hurt a product business?

Try it yourself

BUSINESS RULE

Think of a service your family relies on and trusts, like a barber, a dentist, or a delivery company. Describe what they do that makes you keep trusting them, and one thing that would make you stop.

Unit 3

3. UPS started as the smallest of ten messenger services. Explain how focusing on trust let the smallest company win.

| Lesson 9

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

“In a service business, the promise is the product.”

Unit

Service Businesses

FEDEX

WORDS TO KNOW

The idea that got a C

MEET THESE BEFORE YOU READ

• Speed - how quickly a service gets something done for the customer. • Certainty - being sure something will happen, with no worry it will fail. • Hub - a central point that everything passes through to be sorted and sent on. • Feasible - actually possible to do in the real world, not just in theory.

Watch for these words as you read. FedEx began as a school paper that earned a poor grade, and became a company by making the supposedly impossible feasible.

STO P & TH I NK Why might sending every package through one central hub, even out of the way, actually be faster overall?

R E A D T HE S T ORY A college student turned in a paper describing a delivery company unlike any that existed. His professor handed it back with a C and a note: the idea would have to be possible in the real world to deserve a better grade. That C-graded idea became a company that now moves millions of packages around the world every night.

n 1965, a college student named Fred Smith was studying at Yale University. For one of his classes, he wrote a paper describing a bold idea. At the time, if you needed to send an urgent package across the country, there was no fast, dependable way to do it. Packages traveled in the spare cargo space of passenger planes, going wherever those planes happened to fly, which was slow and unreliable. Smith proposed something different. What if a company used its own fleet of cargo planes, flying every package overnight to a single central location, sorting everything there, and then flying it back out to its destination the next morning? Every package would pass through one central hub, even if that sometimes meant a package traveled a longer path. The whole system would be built for one purpose only: guaranteed overnight delivery.

Unit 3

| Lesson 10

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

Fred Smith

FEDEX.COM

Unit 3

| Lesson 10

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

Unit

Service Businesses

WIKIPEDIA .COM

STO P & TH I NK

The professor said the idea was “not feasible.” Why is “it sounds impossible” not always a good reason to give up?

His professor was not impressed. Smith reportedly received a grade of C. The professor’s comment, which has become famous, was that the concept was interesting and well-formed, but to earn a better grade, the idea had to be feasible, meaning actually possible to pull off in the real world. In other words, it was a nice theory that could never really work. Many people would have dropped the idea after that. Smith did not. After college, Smith served two tours in the Vietnam War as a Marine. When he returned, he decided to test his rejected idea in the real world. In 1971, he founded a company called Federal Express, choosing the word federal, hoping to attract the United States government as a customer. Building the system was breathtakingly expensive. It required buying planes, building a central sorting hub, and hiring people, all before earning a single dollar.

MEDIAPLAYNEWS.COM

Unit 3

| Lesson 10

The early years were brutal. The company nearly went bankrupt more than once, and at times could barely afford fuel for its planes. But the idea was sound, and slowly it caught on. Businesses discovered that being able to send something and know, for certain, that it would arrive

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

WIKIPEDIA .COM

the next morning was worth a great deal. They were not just paying for the trip. They were paying for the certainty, the freedom from worry, and they would pay much more for it than for ordinary slow shipping. Today the company, now called FedEx, is one of the largest delivery companies in the world. It is a public company, traded on the stock market under the symbol FDX, operating in more than 200 countries and bringing in tens of billions of dollars a year. The idea that earned a C in a college classroom became one of the most successful service businesses ever built. Its founder, Fred Smith, led it for decades until his death in 2025. As he later said of his school paper, feasibility is sometimes a matter of capital and will.

DID YOU KNOW?

• Fred Smith’s overnight-delivery idea reportedly earned a grade of C on his college paper. The professor said the concept was interesting but had to be feasible to earn more. • On its first real night of operation, the company delivered just 186 packages. Today FedEx handles

Unit 3

| Lesson 10

STOP & TH I N K The idea did not change from the day it earned a C. So what did Smith add that made it work?

WIKIPEDIA .COM

millions of shipments every single day. • FedEx invented the modern “hub and spoke” system, where packages funnel through one central hub. Many delivery and airline networks around the world copied the idea.

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

Unit

Service Businesses

THE LESSON People will pay more for certainty than for the thing itself. FedEx did not invent shipping. Packages had traveled across the country for a long time. What FedEx sold was something extra: certainty. With FedEx, a business did not just send a package and hope. It knew, for sure, that the package would arrive the next morning. That guarantee, that freedom from worry, was the real product.

WIKIPEDIA .COM

This is a key idea about how services are priced. The price of a service is not only about the work involved. It is also about how much the promise is worth to the customer. A package that simply needs to get there eventually is worth a low price. A package that must arrive tomorrow without fail is worth far more, because the customer is paying for the certainty and the speed, not just the trip. Fred Smith’s professor missed the fact that millions of people and businesses would happily pay more to never have to worry.

Was the professor a fool? TAKE IT TO THE CLASS

Here is a question worth arguing. Fred Smith’s professor gave the overnightdelivery idea a C, saying it would have to be feasible to earn more. Smith proved him wrong and built a giant company. So was the professor a fool? Argue both sides. One side says the professor failed to see a brilliant idea right in front of him. The other side says the professor was actually right, the idea really was not feasible yet, and it took enormous money and effort to make it work, which is a fair thing to point out. As you argue, think about the difference between a bad idea and a good idea that is simply very hard to pull off.

Unit 3

| Lesson 10

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

The Work Check your understanding 1. Where did the idea for FedEx first come from? 2. W hat grade did Fred Smith reportedly get on the paper, and what was the professor’s reason? 3. What is a “hub,” and how does the FedEx system use one?

Think harder 1. Why would a customer pay much more for guaranteed overnight delivery than for ordinary slow shipping?

2. Explain why the price of a service depends on how much the promise is worth to the customer, not just the work involved.

Try it yourself

BUSINESS RULE

Think of a time you would gladly pay extra to be certain something happens on time, like a gift arriving before a birthday. Describe the situation and explain what the certainty is worth to you.

Unit 3

3. Smith’s idea did not change from the day it got a C. What did he add that finally made it succeed?

| Lesson 10

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

“People will pay more for certainty than for the thing itself.”

Unit

WORDS TO KNOW MEET THESE BEFORE YOU READ

• Low-cost - keeping prices down by running a business simply and efficiently.

Service Businesses

SOUTHWEST AIRLINES Doing one thing, cheaply and happily

• Efficiency - getting more done with less waste, time, or cost. • Customer service how well a business treats the people it serves. • Employees first - the belief that treating workers well leads to happy customers.

Watch for these words as you read. Southwest competed against bigger airlines by doing less, but doing it cheaper and friendlier than anyone else.

STO P & TH I NK Why would bigger airlines spend years in court trying to stop one small new airline from flying?

R E A D T H E S T ORY A new airline wanted to fly between just three Texas cities, and the big airlines were so determined to stop it that they fought it in court for years, all the way to the top. The little airline won, took to the sky, and went on to do something almost no airline ever has: turn a profit for forty-seven years straight.

n 1967, in Texas, a businessman and pilot named Rollin King had an idea for a new kind of airline. Instead of flying everywhere, it would do one simple thing well: fly between three big Texas cities, Dallas, Houston, and San Antonio, many times a day, at low prices. King brought the idea to his lawyer, a sharp and funny man named Herb Kelleher. As the famous story goes, King sketched a triangle connecting the three cities on a napkin. Years later King admitted there may not really have been a napkin, but, as he put it, it made a great story. Getting the airline off the ground was a fight. Bigger airlines that already flew those routes did not want competition, and they used lawsuits to try to stop the new company before it ever flew. The legal battle dragged on for years and went all the way to the highest court in Texas. Kelleher, the lawyer, fought it the whole way, and finally won. Southwest Airlines flew its first flights in 1971.

Unit 3

| Lesson 11

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

Rollin King and Herb Kelleher

SOUTHWEST50.COM

Unit 3

| Lesson 11

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

Unit

STO P & TH I NK

Southwest kept its prices low through simple, smart choices. It flew only one type of airplane, which made training and repairs cheaper and easier. It turned its planes around at the gate in about ten minutes, far faster than other airlines, so each plane spent more time in the air earning money. And it skipped the fancy extras other airlines offered. By doing a few things in a simple, efficient way, Southwest could charge fares ordinary people could actually afford. But low prices were only half of it. Southwest also became famous for being fun and friendly. Flight attendants cracked jokes, the staff seemed genuinely happy, and flying Southwest felt cheerful instead of stressful. Behind that friendliness was a real belief held by Herb Kelleher, who led the company for years. He thought that if you treated your own employees well, they would treat customers well, and happy customers would keep the company strong.

Kelleher believed happy employees lead to happy customers. Do you think treating workers well really changes how they treat customers?

Service Businesses

SOUTHWEST50.COM

Unit 3

| Lesson 11

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

SOUTHWEST50.COM

He put his workers first, and in return they gave the kind of warm, cheerful service that made passengers choose Southwest again and again. The company even chose the stock market symbol LUV, a playful nod to its home airport in Dallas and to its friendly spirit. The result was unusual in a difficult industry: while many airlines lost money or went bankrupt, Southwest earned a profit for an astonishing 47 years in a row.

SOUTHWEST50.COM

Today Southwest is one of the largest airlines in the United States, a public company traded under the symbol LUV. It never became the fanciest airline, and it never tried to. It grew strong by doing a few simple things cheaply and treating people, both workers and passengers, in a way that made them want to come back. Sometimes the winning move is not doing more, but doing less, better.

DID YOU KNOW?

• Southwest earned a profit for 47 years in a row, an almost unheardof streak in an industry where many airlines lose money or go bankrupt. • Southwest flies essentially one type of airplane, the Boeing 737.

Unit 3

| Lesson 11

STOP & TH I N K Southwest stayed simple and friendly instead of fancy. Why did that work so well for so long?

WIKIPEDIA .COM

Using a single type makes training, repairs, and spare parts far simpler and cheaper. • The company’s stock market symbol is LUV, a nod to Love Field, its home airport in Dallas, and to the friendly spirit it is known for.

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

Unit

Service Businesses

THE LESSON Sometimes the smartest move is to do less, better. Most airlines tried to do everything: fly everywhere, offer fancy meals, and charge high prices to pay for it all. Southwest did the opposite. It chose to be low-cost, keeping prices down through simple, efficient choices like flying one type of plane and turning flights around fast. By doing a few things really well instead of many things expensively, it could offer fares ordinary people could afford.

WIKIPEDIA .COM

Herb Kelleher added an insight many companies miss. He believed the path to happy customers ran through happy employees, an idea called employees first. A worker who feels respected and enjoys their job will naturally give better customer service than one who feels mistreated. It sounds backward until you see the result: cheerful staff create loyal customers, and loyal customers keep the company alive. Southwest’s 47 straight years of profit suggest Kelleher was onto something real, and that doing less, but doing it cheaply and happily, can beat trying to do everything.

Fancy and expensive, or simple and cheap? TAKE IT TO THE CLASS

Set up the debate. Imagine two new airlines. One offers luxury, fancy meals, big seats, and high prices. The other offers none of that, just cheap, simple, friendly flights. Which would win more customers, and why? Argue both sides. One side says people will pay for comfort and luxury. The other side says, like Southwest, that most people just want a cheap, pleasant, reliable flight. As you argue, notice that both kinds of airlines exist in real life, which means there is no single right answer. The skill is knowing which customers you are trying to win.

Unit 3

| Lesson 11

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

The Work Check your understanding 1. How did Rollin King first describe his airline idea to Herb Kelleher? 2. Name one way Southwest kept its prices low and one way it made flying pleasant. 3. Is Southwest a public or a private company, and what is its stock symbol?

Think harder 1. Southwest treated friendly service as a main product, not an extra. Why might that work especially well for a service business?

2. Explain Kelleher’s belief that happy employees lead to happy customers. Do you think it is true?

Try it yourself

BUSINESS RULE

Think of a place you return to again and again because the people there are friendly, even if it is not the fanciest or cheapest option. Describe what keeps you coming back.

Unit 3

3. Many airlines lose money or go bankrupt, yet Southwest made a profit for 47 straight years. What does that suggest about its approach?

| Lesson 11

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

“Sometimes the smartest move is to do less, better.”

Unit

Service Businesses

GEICO

WORDS TO KNOW

Selling a promise, and the math behind it

MEET THESE BEFORE YOU READ

• Insurance - paying a little regularly so a company will cover a big cost if disaster strikes. • Premium - the regular payment a customer makes for insurance. • Risk - the chance that something bad, and costly, will happen. • Direct - selling straight to the customer, without a salesperson in the middle.

Watch for these words as you read. GEICO sells one of the strangest products in business: a promise you hope you never have to use.

STO P & TH I NK Why would choosing careful, low-risk drivers as customers let GEICO charge lower prices than its competitors?

R E A D THE S T ORY Here is a business that takes your money for years and, if all goes well, gives you nothing in return, and customers are glad to pay. One man figured out how to sell that strange promise more cheaply than anyone else, by being clever about two things at once, and built a company that now protects millions of drivers.

n 1936, during the hard years of the Great Depression, an experienced insurance man named Leo Goodwin started a company built on a clever idea. Leo had worked in insurance for years and had noticed something. Insurance was usually sold by agents, salespeople who met customers in person and earned a commission, a cut of every policy they sold. Those commissions made insurance more expensive. Leo wondered: what if he skipped the agents entirely and sold insurance directly to customers through the mail? To make the idea work even better, Leo decided to be careful about which customers he served. He targeted government employees, because they tended to have steady jobs and to be responsible, careful drivers. Careful drivers get into fewer accidents, which meant his company would have to pay out less money. With safer customers and no expensive agents, he could charge lower prices than other insurance companies and still make a profit. He named the company the Government Employees Insurance Company, which is where the short name GEICO comes from.

Unit 3

| Lesson 12

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

Leo Goodwin

Unit 3

| Lesson 12

WIKIPEDIA .COM

NSUWORKS.NOVA .EDU

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

Unit

STO P & TH I NK The company did not make a profit for several years. Why might a good idea still take years to pay off? Most people pay for insurance and never get anything back. So why is buying it still a smart thing to do?

Service Businesses

The early years were a grind. Leo and a tiny staff worked long days, doing much of the work themselves for little pay. By the end of the first year they had written 3,700 policies. It took until 1940 for the company to earn its first profit, but the idea was sound, and GEICO grew steadily from there. To understand GEICO, you have to understand what insurance actually is, because it is one of the strangest products in business. When you buy car insurance, you pay the company a small amount of money regularly, called a premium. In return, the company makes a promise: if you get into an accident, it will cover the potentially large cost of the damage. Most of the time, nothing happens, and you never collect anything. You are buying peace of mind, paying a little, steadily, so you are protected from a disaster you hope never happens.

This makes insurance a service built almost entirely on trust and on math. The customer trusts that the company will actually pay when something goes wrong. The company, meanwhile, carefully studies

ONEOFAKINDINC.COM

Unit 3

| Lesson 12

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

WIKIPEDIA .COM

INSURANCEJOURNAL .COM

the odds, collecting many small premiums from many people, knowing only a few will have accidents in a given year. As long as it chooses its customers wisely and prices its policies correctly, the money coming in covers the money paid out, with some left over as profit. GEICO’s whole edge was being smart about both: choosing careful customers and skipping costly agents.

DID YOU KNOW?

• By the end of its very first year in 1936, GEICO had sold 3,700 policies. Today it insures many millions of drivers across the United States. • The name GEICO comes from “Government Employees Insurance Company,” because Leo

Unit 3

| Lesson 12

STOP & TH I N K GEICO sells something you hope you never use. How did it turn that strange product into a giant company?

GEICO grew into one of the largest car insurance companies in the United States. In 1996 it was bought by Berkshire Hathaway, a famous company run by the investor Warren Buffett, who had admired GEICO since he was a young student. Today GEICO is owned by Berkshire Hathaway rather than being traded on its own, and it insures millions of drivers. A company built on a simple idea, skip the middleman and choose careful customers, became a giant by selling a promise it works hard to keep.

Goodwin first sold insurance to government workers, who tended to be careful, low-risk drivers. • The famous investor Warren Buffett admired GEICO so much as a young man that, decades later, his company Berkshire Hathaway bought all of it.

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

Unit

Service Businesses

THE LESSON Insurance sells peace of mind for a small, steady price. Insurance is one of the most unusual services there is, because most customers pay for it and hope they never have to use it. When you buy insurance, you make small, regular payments called premiums. In exchange, the company promises to cover a large cost if something bad happens, like a car crash. If nothing bad happens, you do not get your money back, and that is fine, because what you really bought was protection from disaster. How can a company make money by promising to pay for accidents? Through careful math about risk. An insurance company collects premiums from many people, knowing only a few will actually have accidents in a given year. As long as it chooses its customers wisely and

WIKIPEDIA .COM

prices its policies correctly, the money coming in from everyone covers the money paid out to the unlucky few, with some left over as profit. Leo Goodwin’s clever move was being especially careful about both: picking responsible drivers and cutting the cost of agents by selling direct, so GEICO could charge less and still keep every promise.

Is insurance worth it? TAKE IT TO THE CLASS

Here is a real debate that adults have all the time. You pay for insurance month after month, and most of the time you get nothing back because nothing bad happens. Is that a waste of money, or is it smart? Argue both sides. One side says paying for something you never use feels like throwing money away. The other side says insurance buys peace of mind and protection from a disaster that could cost far more than you could ever afford. As you argue, think about which risks are worth insuring against and which are not. Even adults disagree about exactly where that line is.

Unit 3

| Lesson 12

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

The Work Check your understanding 1. What clever idea did Leo Goodwin build his insurance company on? 2. Why did GEICO choose to sell to government employees in particular? 3. What does the customer actually receive when they buy insurance?

Think harder 1. Why would choosing careful, low-risk drivers let GEICO charge lower prices and still profit?

2. Explain, in your own words, how a company can promise to pay for accidents and still make money.

Try it yourself

BUSINESS RULE

Think of something valuable you would want to protect from an unlikely but expensive disaster. Explain whether paying a little every month to protect it would be worth it to you, and why.

Unit 3

3. Insurance is a product most people hope they never use. Why is that still worth paying for?

| Lesson 12

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

“Insurance sells peace of mind for a small, steady price.”

End of Unit 3 CHAPTER SUMMARY

Service Businesses A look back at four companies that sell a promise instead of a product.

This unit was about businesses that sell a service instead of a product. You cannot hold a delivery, a flight, or an insurance promise in your hand. When you buy a service, you are really buying a promise that the work will be done right. Every company in this unit won by being the one people could trust to keep that promise.

THE BIG QUESTION

How do you sell something a customer cannot hold or see in advance?

You sell trust. A service is a promise made before the work is even done, so customers have to believe you will deliver. The companies that win are the ones that keep their promise so reliably that people stop worrying and simply keep coming back.

UPS

Two teenagers with bicycles beat nine bigger rivals by doing one thing: telling the honest truth about delivery, and always keeping their word.

FedEx

An idea that earned a C in college became a giant. People will pay far more to know, for certain, that a package arrives tomorrow.

Southwest

By flying one kind of plane, skipping the frills, and treating people well, one airline stayed profitable for decades straight.

GEICO

Insurance is a strange product: you pay, and hope you never use it. GEICO sold that promise cheaply by being careful with costs and customers.

THE FOUR RULES YOU COLLECTED 1. In a service

business, the promise is the product.

2. People will

pay more for certainty than for the thing itself.

End of Unit 3

3. Sometimes the

smartest move is to do less, better.

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

4. Insurance sells

peace of mind for a small, steady price.

BRING IT TOGETHER

Put It All Together Three ways to prove you really own these ideas. 1. Match The Idea Draw a line from each situation on the left to the unit idea on the right that fits it best. A company guarantees your package arrives tomorrow, or it’s free. A delivery service always gives you the honest arrival time. An airline flies one kind of plane and skips the frills. You pay a little each month in case something goes wrong.

Pay more for certainty The promise is the product Do less, better Peace of mind for a steady price

2. Key Words Check Fill in each blank with the right word: reliability, certainty, premium. Doing what you promised, correctly, every single time, is

Being sure something will happen, with no worry it will fail, is The regular payment a customer makes for insurance is a

. .

3. Your Turn: Levi’s Bike Repair

The Situation Levi started a bike-repair service. He is not the only one in town, and he is not the cheapest. But customers keep choosing him anyway. Using this unit, figure out how a service business like Levi’s can win without being the cheapest. Answer in your own words: a. Levi is not the cheapest, yet customers trust him. What is the real product Levi is selling? b. Name one promise Levi could make that would help a nervous customer choose him. c. Besides making a clear promise, what could Levi do after each repair to prove that customers can trust him and will want to return?

End of Unit 3

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

End of Unit 3 PRACTICAL FORM

Meet the Form: The Service Invoice The form that bills a customer for work, clearly and fairly.

When a service is finished, the customer cannot hold a product to show what they paid for. Instead, the business sends an invoice, a clear bill that lists each service, what it cost, and the total. A good invoice builds trust by showing exactly what was done. Here is one from Daniel’s yard and errand service.

WHAT EACH LINE IS FOR

INVOICE

Each service line

Daniel’s Yard & Errand Service 134/20

May 12. 2020.

May 30. 2020.

Invoice number

Invoice date

Payment due date

Names exactly what was done, so there are no surprises later. Rate

Mr. John Brown

What each visit or task costs, agreed on up front.

Customer name

Amount

Lawn mowing (6 visits at $12)

$72

The rate multiplied by how many times it was done.

Watering the garden (6 visits at $5)

$30

Total due

Bringing in the mail (6 visits at $2)

$12

Total due

$114

Everything added up, plus when and how to pay.

WHY IT MATTERS An invoice turns completed work into a clear request for payment. It records what the business says it provided, the agreed rates, the total due, and when payment is expected. A clear invoice helps the customer check the charges and helps the business track what it has billed and what is still unpaid. A confusing or padded bill damages the trust the service was built on.

End of Unit 3

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

PRACTICAL FORM

Your Turn: Write an Invoice Bill a customer for your own service. Think of a service you could offer, like Levi’s repairs or Daniel’s yard work. Imagine you just finished a week of work for one customer. Plan it out, then fill in the invoice to bill them clearly and fairly.

First, Plan It Out What service will you offer, and what will you charge for each visit or job? What three tasks did you do for this customer this week?

Now Write Your Invoice INVOICE

Invoice number

Invoice date

Payment due date

Customer name

Service and rate, line 1 Service and rate, line 2 Service and rate, line 3 Total due

Last Question How does a clear, honest invoice help a service business earn trust and repeat customers?

End of Unit 3

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

Unit

Self-Employed vs. Employee

THE SELF-EMPLOYED PATH:

WORDS TO KNOW MEET THESE BEFORE YOU READ

• Self-employed working for yourself, owning your own business rather than having an employer. • Risk - the chance that something will not work out, including losing money. • Reward - the benefit you gain, such as profit or freedom, when something works out. • Craftsman - a person who makes things skillfully by hand.

Watch for these words as you read. This is the story of a man who became a business owner almost by accident, and what he gained and risked by working for himself.

STO P & TH I NK Chouinard taught himself blacksmithing to solve his own problem. Why might the person who has a problem be the best one to solve it?

YVON CHOUINARD Working for yourself means keeping the reward and the risk

R E A D T HE S T ORY A teenager who loved to climb could not afford the metal spikes his sport required, so he taught himself to forge his own in a junkyard he could barely afford. He never meant to start a company. He just kept making gear he believed in, until one day he looked up and ran the biggest climbing-gear business in the country.

von Chouinard was born in 1938 and grew up loving the outdoors, especially rock climbing. As a teenager in the 1950s, he ran into a frustrating problem. The metal spikes that climbers hammered into cracks in the rock, called pitons, were made of soft iron. They could only be used once and then had to be left behind in the rock. For long climbs that needed hundreds of them, this was expensive and wasteful, and Chouinard could not afford it. Rather than accept the problem, Chouinard decided to solve it himself. In 1957 he went to a junkyard and bought a used coal-fired forge, a heavy anvil, and some hammers and tongs. Then he taught himself to be a blacksmith. Working in a small shop in his parents’ backyard, he made pitons out of strong steel instead of soft iron, so AMERICANALPINECLUB.ORG

Unit 4

| Lesson 13

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

Yvon Chouinard

PATAGONIA .COM

AMERICANALPINECLUB.ORG

PATAGONIA .COM

Unit 4

| Lesson 13

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

Unit

Self-Employed vs. Employee

they could be pulled out and reused again and again. They were better than anything else a climber could buy.

STO P & TH I NK Chouinard never set out to start a company. How can someone end up running a business without planning to?

Word spread among climbers, and soon Chouinard’s friends, and then strangers, wanted to buy his pitons. He could forge about two an hour and sold them for $1.50 each, often out of the trunk of his car between climbing trips. He was not trying to build a company. He was a craftsman making gear he believed in. But because the gear was so good, he was in business almost without meaning to be.

ALPINEMAG.COM

Being his own boss had a powerful upside. Chouinard answered to no one. He decided what to make, how to make it, and how good it had to be. He could insist on quality even when it cost more, because it was his company and his choice. By 1970 the business he had started in his parents’ backyard had become the largest maker of climbing gear in the United States. Everything good that came from it was his.

Unit 4

| Lesson 13

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

PATAGONIA .COM

But working for yourself also means carrying every risk. There was no steady paycheck and no boss to fall back on. If the pitons had not sold, Chouinard alone would have absorbed the loss. Later he founded a clothing company called Patagonia, and over the years he faced the hard parts of ownership too, including a stretch when the business grew too fast and nearly ran into serious trouble. When you own the business, the failures are yours just as much as the successes.

PATAGONIA .COM

STOP & TH I N K Chouinard kept all the reward of owning his business. What did he have to accept in exchange?

DID YOU KNOW?

• Chouinard sold his early pitons for about $1.50 each. Adjusted for inflation, that is roughly $17 in today’s money, a fair price for handmade climbing gear forged one at a time. • He could make only about two pitons an hour by hand at the

Unit 4

| Lesson 13

Today Patagonia is a large and successful private company, known around the world, and Chouinard became famous not only for his gear but for running his company entirely by his own rules. His story shows the heart of self-employment. He kept full control and full reward, and in exchange he carried full risk. For someone like him, who wanted to do things his own way, that trade was worth it.

forge, yet that slow, careful work grew into the largest climbing-gear maker in the country. • Chouinard never liked thinking of himself as a businessman. He often said he became one almost by accident, simply because he kept making gear he believed in.

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

Unit

Self-Employed vs. Employee

THE LESSON Work for yourself, and you keep both the reward and the risk. Being self-employed means you own your work. There is no boss handing you a paycheck. Instead, you keep whatever the business earns after costs, which can be a lot, a little, or nothing at all. Yvon Chouinard loved this. He got to decide everything, set his own standards, and keep the rewards of his good work. But the same coin has another side. When you are self-employed, there is no guaranteed income and no one to catch you if things go wrong. If sales dry up, you do not get paid. If the business loses money, that loss is yours. This is the central trade of working for yourself: you gain control and the chance at a big reward, and in return you take on risk, the chance that

PATAGONIABEND.COM

it does not work out. People who choose selfemployment usually do so because the freedom and the upside matter more to them than the safety of a steady paycheck.

Would you bet on yourself? © Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

TAKE IT TO THE CLASS

Here is the question for the room. Chouinard could have taken a safe job working for someone else. Instead he bet on himself, with no paycheck guaranteed and every loss landing on him. Would you make that bet, or would the lack of a steady paycheck worry you too much? Talk it through. Some of you will love the idea of full control and keeping all the reward. Others will want the safety of a guaranteed paycheck. Both are completely reasonable. As you argue, notice that the right answer depends a lot on the person, on how much risk they can handle and how much they value doing things their own way.

Unit 4

| Lesson 13

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

The Work Check your understanding 1. What problem with climbing pitons did Chouinard set out to solve? 2. How did he learn to make his own pitons, and what did he make them from? 3. Is Patagonia a public or a private company today?

Think harder 1. Chouinard said he never set out to be a businessman. How did he end up running a company anyway?

2. Explain the main trade a self-employed person makes compared to an employee.

Try it yourself

BUSINESS RULE

Think of something you are good at making or doing that someone might pay for. If you turned it into your own little business, name one reward you would enjoy and one risk you would have to accept.

Unit 4

3. Why might the freedom to insist on high quality matter so much to someone who owns their own business?

| Lesson 13

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

“Work for yourself, and you keep both the reward and the risk.”

Unit

Self-Employed vs. Employee

THE EMPLOYEE PATH:

DOUG MCMILLON

WORDS TO KNOW MEET THESE BEFORE YOU READ

• Employee - a person who works for a company in exchange for pay. • Salary - a steady, regular amount a company pays an employee. • Security - the safety of knowing your income will keep coming. • Promotion moving up to a more important job, usually with more pay.

Watch for these words as you read. This is the story of a teenager who started at the very bottom of a giant company and rose, step by step, all the way to the top.

STO P & TH I NK McMillon kept volunteering for more responsibility. Why might that habit matter more than the job you start in?

Rising from the loading dock to the top

R E A D T H E S T ORY A seventeen-year-old took a hot, hard job unloading trucks for six and a half dollars an hour. He only wanted to help pay for college and never expected to stay. Thirty years later, that same person was running the entire company, one of the largest businesses on earth.

n the summer of 1984, a seventeen-year-old named Doug McMillon took a job unloading trucks at a Walmart warehouse in Arkansas. The work was hot and hard, and the pay was $6.50 an hour. He was not planning a career. He just needed money to help pay for college. As he later put it, he did not mean to be there very long at all. McMillon left to attend college and earn a business degree, then a graduate degree. But in 1991 he came back to Walmart, this time at the company’s headquarters, in a job buying fishing tackle. A buyer decides which products a store will carry and orders them. It was a small role in a giant company, but McMillon was good at it, and he kept raising his hand for more responsibility.

Unit 4

| Lesson 14

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

CORP ORATE .WALMART.COM

Doug McMillon

WIKIPEDIA .COM

Unit 4

| Lesson 14

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

CORP ORATE .WALMART.COM

Unit

Self-Employed vs. Employee

CORP ORATE .WALMART.COM

STO P & TH I NK Chouinard owned his company; McMillon did not. What did McMillon gain by being an employee instead of an owner?

BRITANNICA .COM

Here is the key difference between McMillon and Yvon Chouinard. McMillon did not own Walmart. He was an employee, one of hundreds of thousands. He could not simply decide what the company would do. But in exchange, he had things Chouinard did not. He received regular pay while he remained employed, and he did not personally absorb every loss when the company had a bad month. However, employment does not guarantee that a job or a paycheck will continue forever. And he had the backing of an enormous, established company behind him.

McMillon climbed that ladder for decades. He moved from buyer to manager, then into bigger and bigger leadership roles. In 2005 he became head of Sam’s Club, a large part of the company, and in 2014 he became the chief executive officer, or CEO, of all of Walmart, the top job. He was the youngest person to hold it since Walmart’s founder. The teenager who unloaded trucks for $6.50 an hour was now leading one of the largest companies in the world and earning many millions of dollars a year.

CORP ORATE .WALMART.COM

100

Unit 4

McMillon often gave simple advice to other employees who wanted to rise: be willing to do more than your job asks, and volunteer to cover for your boss when you can, so you learn the next job up. He also pointed out that no one succeeds

| Lesson 14

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

WIKIPEDIA .COM

CORP ORATE .WALMART.COM

WIKIPEDIA .COM

alone, that a big company is a team. That is part of the appeal of the employee path. You are not carrying the whole risk by yourself.

DID YOU KNOW?

• McMillon’s starting pay of $6.50 an hour in 1984 would be roughly $20 an hour in today’s money. He began at the very bottom and rose all the way to the top job. • He went from unloading trucks to chief executive of Walmart over

Unit 4

| Lesson 14

STOP & TH I N K The next CEO also started as an hourly worker. Why does that make McMillon’s climb more than just luck?

McMillon led Walmart until he retired at the start of 2026. Notably, the person who took over after him also began as an hourly worker years earlier, which shows McMillon’s rise was not a fluke. The employee path is real. By working hard, learning constantly, and taking on more responsibility, a person with no ownership can sometimes rise through a company while enjoying more predictable income than a business owner during the years they remain employed.

about thirty years, an unusually long and steady climb up a single company’s ladder. • The person who became CEO after McMillon also started as an hourly worker, a sign the company really does promote from within.

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

101

Unit

Self-Employed vs. Employee

THE LESSON A steady paycheck is worth something real. Security has value. An employee works for a company and is paid a salary or an hourly wage. The employee does not own the business, so they do not keep its profits, and they cannot make all the decisions. But they get something valuable in return: a paycheck that comes steadily, whether the company has a great month or a terrible one. That steadiness is called security, and it is worth real money. Doug McMillon’s story shows the upside of the employee path. He never risked his own savings the way Chouinard did. If Walmart had a bad year, his paycheck still arrived. He had a clear path to climb, training, and the strength of a

CORP ORATE .WALMART.COM

huge company supporting him. The tradeoff is that he gave up the chance to keep all the rewards of ownership and the freedom to do things entirely his own way. Neither path is better for everyone. Chouinard wanted control and accepted risk. McMillon wanted to build something within a strong company and valued the security. Both succeeded enormously, in completely different ways.

Security or freedom? TAKE IT TO THE CLASS

Set up the debate, building on the last lesson. Chouinard bet on himself and kept full control. McMillon joined a big company and rose to the top with a steady paycheck the whole way. If both can lead to great success, which path would you rather take? Argue both sides. The “work for yourself” side values freedom and unlimited reward. The “work for a company” side values security, a clear ladder, and not risking your own money. Push on this question: does your answer depend on your personality, your family situation, or just luck? There is genuinely no single right choice, which is what makes this one of the most important decisions a working person ever makes.

102

Unit 4

| Lesson 14

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

The Work Check your understanding 1. How old was McMillon when he started at Walmart, and what was his pay? 2. What is a CEO, and when did McMillon become Walmart’s CEO? 3. What happened to McMillon at the start of 2026?

Think harder 1. McMillon did not own Walmart, yet he rose to lead it. What did the employee path offer him that ownership would not have?

2. Compare the risk McMillon took with the risk Chouinard took. Who risked more, and why?

Try it yourself

BUSINESS RULE

Think about a job you might want someday. Would you rather own that kind of business yourself or work as an employee for a company that does it? Explain your choice using the ideas of reward, risk, and security.

Unit 4

3. McMillon said no one succeeds alone and that a company is a team. How is that different from Chouinard working alone in his parents’ backyard?

| Lesson 14

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

“A steady paycheck is worth something real. Security has value.”

103

Unit

Self-Employed vs. Employee

THE THIRD PATH:

WORDS TO KNOW MEET THESE BEFORE YOU READ

• Franchise - a business where you pay to use an existing company’s name and system. • Franchisee - the person who buys the right to run a franchise location. • Royalty - a share of sales that a franchisee pays to the brand’s owner over time. • Brand - the name and reputation that make a company recognizable and trusted.

Watch for these words as you read. After the bold risk of Chouinard and the steady security of McMillon, this lesson is about a path that sits right in between.

STO P & TH I NK Why is starting a brand-new business from scratch riskier than opening a location of a company people already know?

104

FRANCHISING Renting a proven idea, for a price and some rules

R E A D T H E S T ORY You want to be your own boss, but starting a business where nobody has heard of you is frightening, and most new ones struggle. So here is a deal: pay to borrow a famous name that customers already trust, follow its rules, and skip much of the risk. Millions of business owners take exactly that deal.

o far you have seen two clear paths. Yvon Chouinard built his own business from nothing, keeping all the control and all the risk. Doug McMillon worked as an employee, trading ownership for a steady paycheck. But there is a third path that sits right in the middle, and millions of business owners choose it. It is called franchising. Imagine you want to own your own store, but you are nervous. Starting a brand-new business from scratch is risky. Customers have never heard of your name, you have to figure out everything yourself, and most new businesses struggle to get going. A franchise offers a different deal. Instead of inventing your own business, you pay to use the name, products, and proven system of a company that already exists and that customers already trust. Unit 4

| Lesson 15

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

NORTHALSTED.COM

ACEHARDWARE .COM WIKIPEDIA .COM

Unit 4

| Lesson 15

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

105

Unit

Self-Employed vs. Employee

SERVPRO.COM

STO P & TH I NK A franchisee must follow the brand’s rules. Why is that actually good for customers, even though it limits the owner’s freedom?

Here is how it usually works. The company that owns the brand is called the franchisor. A person who buys the right to run a location is called the franchisee. The franchisee pays an upfront fee to join, and then usually pays the franchisor a small share of sales over time, called a royalty. In return, the franchisee gets to use the trusted brand name, sells proven products, and receives training and support. The franchisee owns and runs their own location, but they must follow the brand’s rules so that every location feels the same to customers.

Consider a real example: SERVPRO, a restoration and cleaning company with independently owned franchise locations. A local franchise owner runs the business, hires workers, and serves customers in an assigned area. In return for fees and following the franchise system, the owner receives the benefit of the SERVPRO name, training, operating support, and national brand recognition. Customers see a familiar national brand, while the local business is owned and operated by a franchisee. VISITWICHITA .COM

106

Unit 4

| Lesson 15

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

The franchise path is a true middle ground. You are your own boss, like Chouinard, because you own and run your location. But you are not starting from zero, because the brand and the system already exist and already work. The cost of that safety is real: you pay fees, you share some of your sales, and you must follow the franchisor’s rules. You give up some freedom in exchange for a proven head start. Franchising is enormous in the modern economy. Many of the stores and service businesses you pass every day are franchises, each one owned by a local person who chose this middle path. They wanted the independence of owning a business with a tested system and a recognized name. That can reduce some startup uncertainty, but it does not remove the risk of losing money or failing.

DID YOU KNOW?

• Worldwide, a huge share of the stores and service shops you pass every day are franchises, each owned by a local person rather than by one giant company. • A franchisee usually pays two things: a one-time fee to join, and then a small slice of every sale,

Unit 4

| Lesson 15

REMAX.COM

STOP & TH I N K Franchising mixes owning a business with following someone else’s rules. What do you give up to get that safer head start?

WIKIPEDIA .COM

called a royalty, for as long as they use the brand. • Ace Hardware is unusual: its stores are owned by the local store owners together, who share buying power so a small shop can stock goods as cheaply as a giant chain.

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

107

Unit

Self-Employed vs. Employee

THE LESSON You can rent a proven idea, for a price and some rules. A franchise lets a person own and run their own business while using the name and system of a company that already exists. The owner, the franchisee, pays an upfront fee and usually an ongoing royalty, a share of sales, to the brand’s owner, the franchisor. In return, they get a trusted name, proven products, and a tested way of doing things. This is why franchising is a true third path. It mixes the two we already studied. Like the selfemployed person, the franchisee owns their business and keeps much of the reward. Like the employee, they get the safety of a system that already works, instead of risking everything on an

BOOKING.COM

untested idea. The price of that safety is the fees they pay and the freedom they give up, because they must run their store the brand’s way. For someone who wants to be their own boss but does not want to invent everything from scratch, a franchise can be the smartest balance of reward, risk, and security.

Is the safety worth the cost? TAKE IT TO THE CLASS

Here is the debate. Two people each open a sandwich shop. One starts her own brand-new shop with her own name and keeps every dollar of profit, but no one has heard of her. The other opens a franchise of a famous sandwich brand, so customers come right away, but he must pay fees and follow the brand’s rules. Who made the smarter choice? Argue both sides. The “own brand” side keeps all the profit and full freedom, but carries more risk. The “franchise” side has a head start and lower risk, but pays for it in fees and lost freedom. As you debate, think about which kind of person each choice fits. The answer depends on how much risk you can stomach and how much you value doing things your own way.

108

Unit 4

| Lesson 15

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

The Work Check your understanding 1. What is the difference between a franchisor and a franchisee? 2. In the Ace Hardware example, who actually owns most of the stores? 3. Name two things a franchisee gives up in exchange for using a known brand.

Think harder 1. Explain how franchising mixes the self-employed path and the employee path.

2. Why might a trusted brand name be worth paying fees for, especially for a brand-new business owner?

Try it yourself

BUSINESS RULE

Think of a well-known store or service in your area that has many locations. Imagine opening one as a franchise. List one big advantage of using their famous name and one thing you would dislike about having to follow all their rules.

Unit 4

3. A franchisee must follow the brand’s rules. Why is that good for customers, even if it limits the owner’s freedom?

| Lesson 15

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

“You can rent a proven idea, for a price and some rules.”

109

End of Unit 4 CHAPTER SUMMARY

Working for Yourself or Someone Else A look back at the three paths a working person can take.

This unit was about a choice almost every working person faces: work for yourself, or work for someone else. Yvon Chouinard built his own company and kept all the reward and all the risk. Doug McMillon rose from unloading trucks to running all of Walmart, trading ownership for a steady paycheck. And franchising offered a third path, right in the middle.

Yvon Chouinard

He taught himself to forge climbing gear and accidentally built a company. Work for yourself, and you keep both the reward and the risk.

Doug McMillon

He started unloading trucks for $6.50 an hour and rose to lead all of Walmart. A steady paycheck and a ladder to climb have real value.

Franchising

Buy the right to run a known brand’s store. You are your own boss, but you follow their rules and pay their fees. A proven idea, for a price.

THE BIG QUESTION

Is it better to work for yourself or to work for someone else?

Neither is better for everyone. Working for yourself means all the reward but all the risk. Working for someone else means a steady paycheck and security, but you give up control and the biggest rewards. Franchising sits in between: you own your business, but you rent a proven idea. The right choice depends on the person.

THE RULES YOU COLLECTED 1. Work for yourself, and you

keep both the reward and the risk.

110

2. A steady paycheck is

worth something real. Security has value.

End of Unit 4

3. You can rent a proven

idea, for a price and some rules.

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

BRING IT TOGETHER

Put It All Together Three ways to prove you really own these ideas. 1. Match The Idea Draw a line from each situation on the left to the unit idea on the right that fits it best. You own the business and keep every dollar of profit. You get the same paycheck even in a bad month. You run your own shop under a famous brand’s rules. If the business loses money, the loss is yours alone.

Self-employed: all reward, all risk Employee: security has value Franchise: rent a proven idea Self-employed: all reward, all risk

2. Key Words Check Fill in each blank with the right word: self-employed, employee, franchise. Working for yourself, owning your own business, is being A person who works for a company in exchange for pay is an

. .

A business where you pay to use an existing company’s name and system is a

3. Your Turn: Eli’s Three Choices

The Situation Eli is good at fixing bikes and wants to turn it into real work. He could start his own repair business, take a steady job at a big bike shop, or open a franchise of a known repair chain. Help Eli think through the three paths. Answer in your own words: a. If Eli starts his own repair business, what reward could he keep, and what risk would he have to carry himself? b. If Eli takes the steady job at the big shop, what does he give up, and what does he get in return? c. Which path would you choose for Eli, and why?

End of Unit 4

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

111

End of Unit 4 PRACTICAL FORM

Meet the Forms: The W-2 and Form 1099-NEC Two common tax forms that report different kinds of earnings. A W-2 generally reports wages an employer paid to an employee and the taxes withheld from those wages. Form 1099-NEC generally reports certain payments a business made to a worker it treated as an independent contractor. The working relationship—not the name of the form—determines whether someone is legally an employee or an independent contractor. A self-employed person must report all business income even if no 1099 is received.

WHAT EACH LINE IS FOR FORM W-2

FORM 1099-NEC

Who receives it

An employee, like Doug McMillon at Walmart

An independent contractor, such as a self-employed person

What it shows

Wages earned, with taxes already taken out

Nonemployee compensation, usually with no payroll tax withholding

The employer takes care of much of it for you

You handle your own taxes yourself

“I work for a company.”

“I work for myself.”

Who handles taxes

In one phrase

Who gets it Shows the type of earnings the payer reported; it does not by itself determine worker status. Who handles taxes Employees usually have payroll taxes withheld. Independent contractors generally calculate and pay their own taxes. In one phrase

WHY IT MATTERS

A quick comparison of how employee wages and nonemployee compensation are usually reported.

These forms report earnings; they do not create the working relationship. An employee generally works under an employer’s direction and receives a W-2. An independent contractor generally controls how the work is done, is self-employed, and may receive Form 1099-NEC. The facts of each job matter, so a worker or business should ask a qualified adult or tax professional when the classification is unclear.

112

End of Unit 4

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

PRACTICAL FORM

Your Turn: Which Form Would You Get? Imagine your own work, then decide. Imagine you did a job and got paid. Picture a specific gig, like Eli fixing a neighbor’s bikes for cash. Plan it out, then fill in the record of that payment below, the kind of information a 1099 would capture for self-employed work.

First, Plan It Out What work did you do, and who paid you for it? Who controlled how, when, and where the work was done—you or the person paying you?

Did you offer this service as your own independent business, or were you working as part of the payer’s business?

Record The Payment BASIC INFORMATION NEEDED TO RECORD THE PAYMENT Who paid you

For what work Amount you were paid Were taxes taken out? (yes / no)

Last Question Based on the actual working relationship, would the earnings generally be reported on a W-2 or might they be reported on Form 1099-NEC? Explain which facts led you to your answer.

End of Unit 4

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

113

Unit

How a Business Is Built

THE PARTNERSHIP PATH:

PROCTER & GAMBLE

WORDS TO KNOW MEET THESE BEFORE YOU READ

• Partnership - a business owned by two or more people together. • Sole proprietorship - a business owned by just one person. • Partner - one of the owners who shares a business with someone else. • Agreement - a written deal that sets the rules between people in a business. Watch for these words as you read. This is the story of two competitors who discovered they were far stronger together than apart.

Two trades, one business

R E A D T HE S T ORY Two strangers came to the same city from across an ocean, one making candles, one making soap. They were rivals fighting over the very same supplies, with no reason to trust each other. Then one wise relative pointed out something that would build a company still in millions of homes today: together, they would be unstoppable.

I STO P & TH I NK The two men were competing to buy the very same supplies. Why would that make joining forces especially smart?

114

n the 1830s, two men were building separate lives in the city of Cincinnati, Ohio. William Procter had come from England, where his shop had been destroyed by fire. He made candles. James Gamble had come from Ireland as a boy. He made soap. The two ran small, ordinary businesses in a city full of competitors, and at first they had no reason to work together at all. There was one thing that quietly connected them. Both candles and soap were made from the same raw materials, animal fat and oils, so the two men were actually competing to buy the same supplies, bidding each other’s prices up. They also happened to have married into the same family, which gave them a shared father-in-law. That father-in-law saw what the two

Unit 5

| Lesson 16

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

WIKIPEDIA .COM

William Procter and James Gamble

WIKIPEDIA .COM

Unit 5

| Lesson 16

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

WIKIPEDIA .COM

115

US.P G.COM

Unit

How a Business Is Built

US.P G.COM

younger men did not: as competitors they were weakening each other, but as partners they could be far stronger. He urged them to join forces. STO P & TH I NK

Why might writing down a formal agreement at the very start matter, even between two men who trusted each other?

They took the advice. On October 31, 1837, William Procter and James Gamble signed a formal agreement to become business partners. Each man put in about $3,500, and together they created a single company that made both candles and soap. They called it, simply, Procter & Gamble. Now, instead of two small shops fighting over supplies, there was one stronger business that shared costs, shared work, and shared profits. A partnership like theirs has real advantages. Two owners bring more money to start with, more skills, and more hands to share the load. Procter ran the store and the selling side. Gamble ran the manufacturing. Each did what he was best at, and the business was stronger than either man could have built alone. By combining, they could grow faster than their many competitors. WIKIPEDIA .COM

116

Unit 5

| Lesson 16

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

US.P G.COM

Of course, sharing a business is not always easy. Every big decision now needed two people to agree, and the profits had to be divided. If one partner made a poor choice, both would feel it. That is exactly why their written agreement mattered so much. By setting the rules at the start, while they were still friendly, they had a fair way to handle disagreements before any arose.

WIKIPEDIA .COM

DID YOU KNOW?

• Each founder put in about $3,500 in 1837. Adjusted for inflation, that is roughly $120,000 each in today’s money, a serious investment for two small shopkeepers. • Procter & Gamble started by making just candles and soap.

Unit 5

| Lesson 16

STOP & TH I N K Two small competitors became one giant company. What did the partnership give them that neither had alone? © Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

Procter & Gamble survived and thrived. It grew far beyond candles and soap, and in 1890 it changed shape again by becoming a corporation, the structure you will read about next. Today P&G is one of the largest consumer-goods companies in the world, a public company traded on the stock market, making products found in homes everywhere. It all began because two competitors realized they would be far stronger as partners.

Today it makes hundreds of everyday products sold in homes all over the world. • The partnership was signed on October 31, 1837. The company has been in business, in one form or another, for nearly 200 years.

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

117

Unit

How a Business Is Built

THE LESSON Two owners can build what one cannot, if they agree on the rules first. A partnership is a business owned by two or more people together. It is one step up from a sole proprietorship, which is a business owned by just one person. Partnerships are powerful because partners combine their money, their skills, and their effort. Procter knew selling, Gamble knew making, and together they built something neither could have alone. But sharing ownership means sharing decisions, and that is where partnerships get tricky. Every big choice now needs agreement. The profits must be divided. And if one partner makes a bad decision, both partners can suffer for it. This is why smart partners do what Procter and Gamble did: they put their agreement in writing at the

US.P G.COM

very start, before any problems arise. A written agreement spells out who owns how much, who does what, and how profits and decisions are shared. It will not prevent every disagreement, but it gives the partners a fair way to settle them. The time to agree on the rules is at the beginning, while everyone is still friendly.

Go it alone, or take a partner? TAKE IT TO THE CLASS

Here is the debate. Imagine you have a business idea. You could own it entirely by yourself, keeping all the profit and all the control, or you could take on a partner who brings money and skills you lack, but who would share the profit and the decisions. Which would you choose? Argue both sides. The “go it alone” side keeps full control and all the reward. The “take a partner” side gains money, skills, and someone to share the work and risk. As you argue, think about what kind of partner would actually be worth sharing your business with, and why writing down the rules first matters so much.

118

Unit 5

| Lesson 16

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

The Work Check your understanding 1. What raw material did both Procter’s and Gamble’s trades depend on? 2. What did the two men each contribute to the partnership? 3. What shape did Procter & Gamble change into in 1890?

Think harder 1. Procter and Gamble were competitors before they were partners. Why were they stronger together than apart? 2. What is the biggest risk of owning a business with a partner instead of alone?

Try it yourself

BUSINESS RULE

Think of a project you might do better with a partner than alone, like running a stand or making something to sell. Describe what you would each be in charge of, and one rule you would want to agree on before you start.

Unit 5

3. Why is the best time to write down a partnership’s rules at the very beginning, before any trouble?

| Lesson 16

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

“Two owners can build what one cannot, if they agree on the rules first.”

119

Unit

How a Business Is Built

THE CORPORATION AND GOING PUBLIC:

FORD

WORDS TO KNOW MEET THESE BEFORE YOU READ

• Corporation - a legal business entity that is separate from its owners; ownership is represented by shares. • Share - a small slice of ownership in a company. • Go public - to sell shares of a company to anyone who wants to buy them. • Public company - a company whose shares the general public can buy and own.

Watch for these words as you read. This is the story of how a company can grow far beyond what any single owner could ever pay for.

STO P & TH I NK How is owning shares of a corporation different from owning a business all by yourself?

120

How a company can be owned by thousands of strangers R E A D T HE S T ORY An inventor in Detroit wanted to build cars, but cars cost far more money than he had. So instead of giving up, he sliced his company into a thousand little pieces and sold them to other people. That simple idea, ownership cut into shares, would let his company grow until it was owned by people he would never meet.

n 1903, in Detroit, Michigan, an inventor named Henry Ford wanted to build automobiles, but he had a problem that many founders face. Building cars took far more money than one person had. So Ford did something a sole owner or a simple partnership could not easily do. On June 16, 1903, he and eleven other investors formed a corporation called the Ford Motor Company. Together they put in about $28,000, and the company was divided into 1,000 shares, small slices of ownership, split among the twelve of them. This is the key idea of a corporation. The corporation is a legal entity separate from the people who own it, and its ownership is divided into shares. A corporation may have one shareholder or many. Whoever holds shares owns part of the company.

Unit 5

| Lesson 17

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

Henry Ford

WIKIPEDIA .COM

WIKIPEDIA .COM WIKIPEDIA .COM

Unit 5

| Lesson 17

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

121

Unit

How a Business Is Built

CORP ORATE .FORD.COM

Henry Ford held the most shares, so he had the most control, but he did not own it all. The others owned pieces too. A corporation can also keep existing even if an owner leaves or dies, because the shares can be passed on or sold to someone new. The company has a kind of life of its own, separate from any single person. STO P & TH I NK Why did pooling money from twelve owners let Ford do things a single owner could not?

Having many owners meant Ford had enough money to do big things. In 1908 the company introduced the Model T, a sturdy, affordable car for ordinary people. Demand was enormous. To make enough of them, Ford introduced the moving assembly line in 1913, where the car moved past workers who each did one task. This cut the time to build a car from many hours to about ninety minutes, and made cars cheap enough for millions of families. The corporation’s structure, with money pooled from many owners, helped make all of this possible.

For decades, the Ford family kept tight control of the company, owning the shares themselves. But in 1956, Ford did something that changed its shape once more. It decided to go public. This means it offered shares of the company for sale to the general public for the first time, so that ordinary people, not just the founders, could buy a piece of Ford. On the first day, more than ten million shares were sold. A company that sells its shares to the public this way is called a public company.

122

Unit 5

| Lesson 17

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

WIKIPEDIA .COM

Going public is one of the biggest moments in a company’s life. It can raise an enormous amount of money all at once, which a company can use to grow. The tradeoff is that the original owners must now share the company with all those new owners, and answer to them. It is a real decision with real costs, which is why some companies make the leap and others choose never to.

DID YOU KNOW?

• The twelve investors started Ford with about $28,000 in 1903. Adjusted for inflation, that is roughly $1 million in today’s money, a large sum, but tiny next to the giant company Ford became. • Ford’s moving assembly line cut the time to build a car from many

Unit 5

| Lesson 17

STOP & TH I N K How did the corporation structure let Ford grow from twelve owners into a company owned by millions?

Today Ford is a large public company, traded on the stock market under the symbol F. Anyone, including possibly your own family through a retirement account, can own a tiny slice of it. The company that started with twelve people and a thousand shares in 1903 is now owned by countless people around the world. That is the power of the corporation: it lets a business grow far beyond what any single owner could fund alone.

hours to about ninety minutes, which let the company sell cars cheaply enough for ordinary families. • When Ford went public in 1956, more than ten million shares were sold on the very first day, one of the largest stock sales of its time.

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

123

Unit

How a Business Is Built

THE LESSON A corporation lets a business be owned by many, and grow beyond any one person. A corporation is a company divided into shares, small slices of ownership. Whoever holds a share owns that slice of the company. This is a powerful idea, because it lets a business raise money from many people at once, far more than one owner or a few partners could provide. It also means the company can outlive its founders, since shares can be sold or passed on. Ford used this structure to raise the money to build cars on a massive scale. The biggest moment in many corporations’ lives is the decision to go public, which means selling shares to anyone who wants to buy them on the stock market. Going public can raise enormous amounts of money for growth, which is why Ford and so many companies have done it. The tradeoff is that the original owners now share

WIKIPEDIA .COM

their company with the public and must answer to all those new owners. Throughout this book you have seen this difference again and again. Some companies are public, meaning anyone can own a slice, like Ford, UPS, and Deere. Others stay private, owned by a family or a small group, like LEGO and Dyson. Now you know what that difference really means, and why a company chooses one path or the other.

Go public, or stay private? TAKE IT TO THE CLASS

124

Here is the debate. Imagine your company is growing fast and needs money to grow faster. You could go public, selling shares to raise a huge amount of money, but then you would have thousands of new owners to answer to. Or you could stay private, keeping full control but growing more slowly. Which would you choose? Argue both ways. The “go public” side wants the money and the chance to grow quickly. The “stay private” side values control and not having to answer to outside owners. Remember the real companies in this book: Ford went public, while LEGO chose to stay family-owned for nearly a century. Both can succeed. As you argue, think about what each company would have to give up to get what it wants.

Unit 5

| Lesson 17

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

The Work Check your understanding 1. How many people owned Ford when it was formed in 1903, and how was ownership divided? 2. What did Ford do in 1956 that changed who could own the company? 3. Is Ford a public or a private company today?

Think harder 1. Why was forming a corporation a smart way for Henry Ford to get enough money to build cars? 2. Explain why a corporation can keep going even after its original owners leave or die.

Try it yourself

BUSINESS RULE

Imagine you own a small business and want to grow. Describe one thing you could do with a large amount of money raised by selling shares, and one reason you might not want strangers as part-owners of your business.

Unit 5

3. What does a company gain, and what does it give up, when it decides to go public?

| Lesson 17

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

“A corporation lets a business be owned by many, and grow beyond any one person.”

125

Unit

How a Business Is Built

WHEN A COMPANY GROWS TOO BIG:

WORDS TO KNOW MEET THESE BEFORE YOU READ

STANDARD OIL The giant the government broke apart

• Monopoly - when one company controls nearly all of an industry, with little competition. • Competition when several businesses compete for the same customers. • Antitrust - laws meant to prevent unfair monopolies and protect competition. • Industry - all the companies that make or sell a particular kind of thing.

Watch for these words as you read. This is the story of a company that became so powerful the government decided it had to be broken apart.

STO P & TH I NK Rockefeller often bought out struggling competitors instead of just beating them. Why would owning your rivals be so powerful?

126

R E A D T HE S T ORY One man set out not just to win the oil business, but to swallow it whole. Rival by rival, he bought or beat nearly every competitor until he controlled ninety percent of all the oil in the country. He became one of the richest people who ever lived, and that is exactly when the government decided enough was enough.

n 1870, in Cleveland, Ohio, a sharp and determined businessman named John D. Rockefeller founded a company called Standard Oil. At the time, oil was becoming hugely important, mostly for making kerosene to light lamps. Rockefeller was brilliant at the oil-refining business, and also ruthless. He was determined not just to compete, but to win completely. Rockefeller used every method he could to grow. He made his refineries extremely efficient, which let him lower prices. He made secret deals with the railroads to ship his oil more cheaply than anyone else. And when a competitor was struggling, he often bought them out and folded them into Standard Oil. One by one, the rival oil companies disappeared into his. He was building something the business world had rarely seen. Unit 5

| Lesson 18

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

WIKIPEDIA .COM

BRITANNICA .COM

John D. Rockefeller

WIKIPEDIA .COM

BRITANNICA .COM

Unit 5

| Lesson 18

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

127

Unit

How a Business Is Built

By the 1880s, Standard Oil controlled about ninety percent of all oil refining in the United States. That is almost the entire industry. When one company controls nearly all of something, with no real competition left, it is called a monopoly. A company with lasting power to raise prices or exclude competitors may have monopoly power. Having that power is not automatically illegal. Antitrust laws protect competition by prohibiting certain conduct that unfairly creates or maintains monopoly power. In Standard Oil’s case, the government argued that the company used unlawful methods to restrain competition, and the Supreme Court ordered it broken into separate companies. WIKIPEDIA .COM

STO P & TH I NK

The fight went all the way to the Supreme Court, the highest court in the country. In 1911, the Court ruled that Standard Oil had become an illegal monopoly, and it ordered the giant company to be broken apart into many separate, smaller companies that would have to compete with one another. Standard Oil was split into more than

Why does it worry people when a single company controls almost an entire industry?

WIKIPEDIA .COM

128

Unit 5

| Lesson 18

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

BRITANNICA .COM

WIKIPEDIA .COM

thirty independent companies. Some of those pieces grew into major oil companies that still exist today under different names.

DID YOU KNOW?

• At its peak, Standard Oil controlled about ninety percent of all oil refining in the United States, one of the most complete monopolies in history. • When the company was broken up in 1911, some of its pieces grew into major oil companies that are still

Unit 5

| Lesson 18

The government forced one big company to split into many smaller ones. How could that actually help customers?

The Standard Oil story teaches a more precise lesson about the limits of competition. A company may grow very large by building better products, lowering costs, or serving customers well. The legal problem begins when a company uses unlawful exclusionary or predatory conduct to gain or maintain monopoly power. Antitrust law is meant to protect the competitive process so customers continue to have meaningful choices.

STOP & TH I N K

household names today, just under different names. • Rockefeller owned shares in all the smaller companies after the breakup. Their combined value actually rose, so the breakup made him even richer, an irony that still surprises people.

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

129

Unit

How a Business Is Built

THE LESSON A business may compete hard, but it may not use unlawful tactics to destroy competition. Monopoly power means having lasting power in a market—for example, the ability to raise prices or exclude competitors. Having monopoly power is not automatically illegal. Antitrust laws prohibit certain conduct that unfairly creates or maintains that power. Competition usually benefits customers by encouraging better prices, quality, service, and innovation.

WIKIPEDIA .COM

The breakup of Standard Oil in 1911 showed that size alone was not the issue. The legal concern was the company's use of unlawful methods to restrain competition and maintain monopoly power. A business may grow very large by competing fairly, but antitrust law can act when it uses exclusionary or predatory conduct that harms the competitive process.

Is being the only choice always bad? © Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

TAKE IT TO THE CLASS

Here is a genuinely tricky debate. A monopoly sounds bad for customers because there is no competition. But consider this: Standard Oil actually lowered the price of oil for many years because it was so efficient. So is a giant, efficient monopoly always bad, or can it sometimes be good for customers? Argue both sides. One side says competition is always better, because even a generous monopoly could turn around and raise prices once the competition is gone. The other side says a huge, efficient company can do things smaller ones cannot, sometimes lowering prices and improving products. As you debate, think about why the government finally decided that the dangers of Standard Oil’s power outweighed its benefits. Reasonable people have argued about this for over a century.

130

Unit 5

| Lesson 18

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

The Work Check your understanding 1. What did Standard Oil sell, and how much of the industry did it control by the 1880s? 2. What was the Sherman Antitrust Act meant to do? 3. How many companies was Standard Oil broken into?

Think harder 1. Explain why a monopoly can be dangerous for customers even if the company is efficient. 2. Why does competition tend to keep prices fair and products good?

Try it yourself

BUSINESS RULE

Think of something where you only have one choice of where to get it, maybe one store in town that sells a certain thing. Describe how having no competition might affect the price or the service, and whether more competition would help you.

Unit 5

3. The government allowed Ford to grow huge but broke up Standard Oil. What was the difference that mattered?

| Lesson 18

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

“A business may compete hard, but it may not use unlawful tactics to destroy competition.”

131

End of Unit 5 CHAPTER SUMMARY

How a Business Is Built A look back at the shapes a business can take, and who owns it.

This unit was about the shapes a business can take. Two rivals can join into a partnership, like Procter & Gamble. A company can split itself into shares owned by thousands of strangers, like Ford. And a business can gain enormous market power, as Standard Oil did, but antitrust law can act when unlawful conduct restrains competition.

THE BIG QUESTION

Procter & Gamble

Two rivals who made candles and soap realized they were stronger together, and signed a partnership that built a company still in millions of homes.

Ford

Henry Ford sliced his company into shares so many people could own a piece. That raised enough money to put a whole country on wheels.

Standard Oil

One company gained enormous market power. The government challenged the methods it used to restrain competition, and the Supreme Court ordered it broken apart. Antitrust law examines harmful conduct, not company size alone.

How is a business actually built and owned?

A business can be owned in different ways: one person alone, two or more partners who share it, or a corporation split into shares owned by many people. A company may grow large by competing fairly. The legal limit is not size alone: a business may not use unlawful methods to restrain competition or maintain monopoly power.

THE RULES YOU COLLECTED 1. Two owners can build

what one cannot, if they agree on the rules first.

132

2. A corporation lets a

business be owned by many, and grow beyond any one person.

End of Unit 5

3. A business may grow

large, but it may not use unlawful tactics to destroy competition.

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

BRING IT TOGETHER

Put It All Together Three ways to prove you really own these ideas. 1. Match The Idea Draw a line from each situation on the left to the unit idea on the right that fits it best. Two people share a business and split the profit. A company sells shares so thousands can own a piece. One company controls almost an entire industry. Partners write down the rules before any trouble starts.

Partnership Corporation Monopoly Partnership agreement

2. Key Words Check Fill in each blank with the right word: partnership, corporation, monopoly. A business owned by two or more people together is a

A company divided into shares, so it can be owned by many people, is a When one company controls nearly all of an industry, with little competition, it is a

. .

3. Your Turn: Aaron And Reuben’s Plan

The Situation Aaron is great at building things, and his friend Reuben is great at selling. They want to start a business together making and selling wooden games. Help them set up their partnership the smart way, before they begin. Answer in your own words: a. Why might Aaron and Reuben be stronger as partners than each working alone? b. What is one disagreement they should settle in writing before they start? c. How could they split the profit fairly, and why does writing it down early matter?

End of Unit 5

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

133

End of Unit 5 PRACTICAL FORM

Meet the Form: The Partnership Agreement The form that sets the rules between business partners. A partnership agreement records the most important rules the partners have accepted. It should explain ownership, contributions, responsibilities, profits and losses, decision-making, departures, and disputes. It cannot predict every problem, but it gives the partners a clear starting point when questions arise.

PARTNERSHIP AGREEMENT

Stein Brothers Wooden Games

Aaron Stein

Reuben Stein

Business name

Partner 1

Partner 2

$300 and all the tools

$300 and the workspace

What Aaron puts in

What Reuben puts in

Aaron builds the games; Reuben sells them Who does what

What each puts in Money, tools, or space, so it is clear what each partner gave. Who does what

All decisions

Conversation

Which decisions require both partners to agree

How disputes will be handled

50% / 50%

Ownership percentage for each partner

How losses and debts will be shared

Other partner continue with business What happens if a partner wants to leave, cannot work, or dies

WHAT EACH LINE IS FOR

Shared equally, half and half

Aaron Stein, Reuben Stein, June 5

How profit is split

Signatures and date

Splits the work so nothing important is left undone. How profit is split Settles the biggest question, the money, before it can cause a fight.

WHY IT MATTERS Most partnerships do not fall apart over the work. They fall apart over money and fairness, after the business is already running. The agreement is how Aaron and Reuben protect their friendship and their business at the same time. By deciding the rules while they still agree, they give themselves a fair way to settle any argument later. The best time to write the rules is before you ever need them.

134

End of Unit 5

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

PRACTICAL FORM

Your Turn: Write a Partnership Agreement Start a business with a partner, the smart way. Imagine starting a business with a friend who is good at something you are not. Plan it out, then fill in the partnership agreement so the two of you have clear, fair rules from day one.

First, Plan It Out What is the business, and who is your partner? What is each of you especially good at, and who will do what?

Now Write Your Agreement

PARTNERSHIP AGREEMENT

Business name

Partner 1

What Aaron puts in

Partner 2

What Reuben puts in Who does what

Ownership percentage for each partner

How disputes will be handled © Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

Which decisions require both partners to agree

How losses and debts will be shared

What happens if a partner wants to leave, cannot work, or dies How profit is split

Signatures and date

Last Question Why is it smarter to agree on these rules now, before the business starts, than to wait until a problem comes up?

End of Unit 5

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

135

Unit

WORDS TO KNOW MEET THESE BEFORE YOU READ

• Brand - everything that makes a company recognizable: its name, logo, colors, and the feeling people attach to it. • Logo - the special symbol or lettering that stands for a company. • Advertising - the work of telling people about a product and getting them to want it. • Trust - the belief that a company will give you what it promises.

Watch for these words as you read. Coca-Cola shows that what makes a product a giant is sometimes not the product at all.

STO P & TH I NK The bookkeeper never changed the recipe. So how did the name and the script help the business?

136

Getting Customers

COCA-COLA A name, a script, and a secret

R E A D T H E S T ORY A pharmacist mixed up a new fizzy drink and, in its first year, sold about nine glasses a day. It should have vanished like a hundred other forgotten sodas. Instead it became one of the most recognized names on the planet, and the reason had almost nothing to do with how it tasted.

n 1886, a pharmacist named John Pemberton in Atlanta, Georgia, mixed up a new flavored syrup. Combined with carbonated water, it became a drink sold at a pharmacy soda fountain for five cents a glass. In its very first year, the new drink sold only about nine glasses a day. It was a tiny, unknown product, one of many fizzy drinks competing for attention. What it had going for it was a clever friend. Pemberton’s bookkeeper, a man named Frank Robinson, did two things that mattered enormously, and neither had anything to do with the recipe. First, he gave the drink its name: Coca-Cola. He thought the two matching C sounds would look striking in advertising. Second, he wrote that name out in a flowing, fancy handwriting style. That swooping script became the drink’s logo, and remarkably, it is still written almost exactly the same way today, more than 135 years later. Pemberton did not live to see what his drink became. In poor health, he sold his interest in Coca-Cola and Unit 6

| Lesson 19

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

John Pemberton

WIKIPEDIA .COM

COCA - COLACOMPANY.COM

WIKIPEDIA .COM

Unit 6

| Lesson 19

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

137

Unit

STO P & TH I NK Candler could not improve the drink itself. What did he decide to build instead? Why would giving away the first glass for free turn out to be a smart way to grow the business?

Getting Customers

died in 1888. The rights ended up with another Atlanta businessman, Asa Candler, who paid only about $2,300 in total. Candler could not make the drink taste better than Pemberton already had. But Candler had a different genius. He understood, earlier than almost anyone, that a business could be built not just on a product, but on a brand. Candler poured his energy into getting the Coca-Cola name in front of people everywhere. He printed the swooping logo on signs, calendars, clocks, and trays. Most cleverly of all, he handed out coupons for a free first glass of Coca-Cola, betting that once people tried it, many would come back and pay. The bet worked. Under Candler, sales of Coca-Cola grew by thousands of percent. People were not just buying a drink. They were buying a name they recognized and trusted. Coca-Cola also became famous for guarding its recipe. The company turned its secret formula into part of the brand itself, telling the

WIKIPEDIA .COM

Asa Candler

WIKIPEDIA .COM

138

Unit 6

| Lesson 19

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

WIKIPEDIA .COM

public that only a tiny handful of people knew the exact ingredients, which were locked away. Whether or not the secrecy was truly necessary, it made the brand feel special and mysterious. The secret became part of the story customers were buying.

DID YOU KNOW?

• A glass of Coca-Cola cost five cents in 1886. Adjusted for inflation, that is only about $1.70 in today’s money, roughly what a soda costs now. • Coca-Cola kept that same fivecent price for more than seventy years, from 1886 all the way to

Unit 6

| Lesson 19

STOP & TH I N K How can a brand be worth more to a company than the actual product it sells?

Today Coca-Cola is one of the most recognized brands on earth, sold in nearly every country, and it is a public company traded on the stock market under the symbol KO. Here is the remarkable part. The thing that made Coca-Cola a giant was never only the syrup. It was the name, the script, the red signs, and the feeling people attached to them. A pharmacist invented the drink, but a brand is what conquered the world.

1959, an almost unheard-of run for any product. • The Coca-Cola script logo has barely changed in more than 135 years. The handwriting you see on a can today is essentially the one a bookkeeper sketched in 1886.

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

139

Unit

Getting Customers

THE LESSON A strong brand can be worth more than the product itself. A brand is everything that makes a company recognizable and shapes how people feel about it: its name, its logo, its colors, and what people believe about it. The Coca-Cola drink could have stayed an unknown pharmacy fizz forever. What made it enormous was that Frank Robinson and Asa Candler built a powerful brand around it: a memorable name, a unique script logo, and a feeling of trust spread everywhere through advertising. This is one of the most important ideas in business. Two products can be almost identical, but the one with the stronger brand will usually win, because customers reach for the name they know and trust. A brand is a kind of promise.

WIKIPEDIA .COM

When you see the familiar red script, you know exactly what you are getting, anywhere in the world. That certainty is worth real money, which is why companies spend so much building and protecting their brands. Coca-Cola proved that the feeling around a product can become even more valuable than the product itself.

Is the brand worth more than the drink? TAKE IT TO THE CLASS

Here is the debate. Many cola drinks taste similar, and in blind taste tests people often cannot even tell them apart. Yet Coca-Cola sells far more than most rivals. Is that fair and smart business, or are people paying extra just for a name and a feeling? Argue both sides. One side says the brand gives people real value: trust, recognition, and a guarantee of what they are getting. The other side says it is a little strange to pay more for nearly the same drink just because of the label. As you argue, think about other products you choose by brand name. Are you paying for something real, or just for the feeling the brand gives you?

140

Unit 6

| Lesson 19

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

The Work Check your understanding 1. How well did Coca-Cola sell in its very first year? 2. Where did the Coca-Cola name and its famous script come from? 3. Is Coca-Cola a public or a private company today?

Think harder 1. The drink barely sold at first. Explain how building a brand turned it into a giant. 2. Why will a product with a strong brand often beat a similar product with a weak one?

Try it yourself

BUSINESS RULE

Think of a brand you recognize instantly from just its logo or colors. Describe what feeling the brand gives you, and whether that feeling makes you more likely to buy it.

Unit 6

3. Coca-Cola made its secret recipe part of the brand. Why might a little mystery make customers more interested?

| Lesson 19

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

“A strong brand can be worth more than the product itself.”

141

Unit

6 20

WORDS TO KNOW MEET THESE BEFORE YOU READ

Getting Customers

DE BEERS How four words sold the world a diamond

• Advertising - the work of telling people about a product and persuading them to want it. • Demand - how much people want something and are willing to pay for it. • Desire - a strong wish to have something. • Slogan - a short, memorable phrase that captures a brand’s message.

Watch for these words as you read. This is the story of how a company used advertising not to describe a product, but to change what people wanted.

STO P & TH I NK Instead of advertising a specific diamond, De Beers set out to change how people felt about diamonds in general. Why is that a much bigger, bolder goal?

142

R E A D T HE S T ORY A company sat on a mountain of diamonds that almost no ordinary person wanted, or had ever even thought of buying. Then a tired copywriter scribbled four words before bed, and slowly, those four words convinced nearly the entire world that it wanted something it never had before.

y the 1930s, a company called De Beers controlled most of the world’s diamonds, mining and selling the great majority of them. But the company had a serious problem. During the hard years of the Great Depression, people stopped buying diamonds. In fact, most ordinary people had never bought one at all. Diamonds were seen as a rare luxury for the very wealthy, not something a normal household would ever spend money on. De Beers was sitting on a mountain of diamonds that most of the public simply did not want. So in 1938 the company did something bold. Instead of advertising a particular diamond, it hired an advertising agency with a much bigger goal: to change how people felt about diamonds altogether. The plan was not to sell one stone to one buyer. It was to convince the whole public that owning a diamond was something to wish for, a symbol of success and importance that an ordinary person should want, not just the rich. For years the agency placed diamonds in glamorous settings, linking them with success, importance, and lasting value. Then, in 1947, a

Unit 6

| Lesson 20

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

DEBEERS.CO.UK

WIKIPEDIA .COM

Unit 6

| Lesson 20

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

143

Unit

6 20

Getting Customers

WIKIPEDIA .COM

STO P & TH I NK

copywriter at the agency named Frances Gerety was working late and struggling to capture the whole idea in a single line. Tired, she scribbled four words on a piece of paper before going to bed: “A Diamond Is Forever.” The next morning her coworkers were not even sure about it. But those four words turned out to be some of the most powerful in the history of advertising. The slogan worked because it tied the product to an idea people already valued. A diamond is one of the hardest, most lasting things on earth, so it became a symbol of something permanent and important. The line appeared in De Beers advertising for decades, and it slowly reshaped what people believed a diamond was for. Over time, buying a diamond went from something almost no ordinary person did to something millions of people felt they were supposed to do.

The slogan tied a diamond to the idea of lasting value. Why is connecting a product to a feeling so powerful in advertising?

Think carefully about what happened here. De Beers did not invent a new product. Diamonds had existed forever. What the company did was use advertising to create a desire that had barely existed before, until millions of people felt they wanted something they previously had not. That is an astonishing amount of power, and it raises real questions worth thinking about, which is exactly why this story is in the book.

DEBEERS.CO.UK

144

DEBEERS.CO.UK

Unit 6

| Lesson 20

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

DEBEERS.CO.UK

WIKIPEDIA .COM

DID YOU KNOW?

• Before the De Beers campaign, most ordinary people had never bought a diamond. Within a few decades, diamonds had become one of the most desired luxury purchases in the world, almost entirely because of advertising. • The slogan “A Diamond Is Forever” ran in De Beers advertising for

Unit 6

| Lesson 20

De Beers remains a private company, not traded on the stock market. Its four-word slogan was later named the advertising slogan of the entire twentieth century. The lesson of De Beers is both impressive and a little unsettling: advertising, done brilliantly, can do more than tell you about a product. It can actually change what you want.

decades and was later named the advertising slogan of the entire twentieth century. • The copywriter who wrote it, Frances Gerety, reportedly scribbled the line late at night when she was tired and almost out of ideas.

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

145

Unit

6 20

Getting Customers

THE LESSON Advertising can do more than inform. It can create desire. Most advertising tells you about something that exists: here is our product, here is why it is good, please buy it. The De Beers story shows a deeper and more powerful kind of advertising, the kind that creates demand where almost none existed before. Before the campaign, most ordinary people did not want a diamond at all. After decades of brilliant advertising, millions of people felt they wanted one. The product never changed. What changed was what people wanted. This is one of the most important and most debated ideas in all of business. Advertising is not only a mirror that reflects what people already want. It can also be a tool that shapes what people want. That power can be used in

DEBEERS.CO.UK

ways that are harmless or even nice, and it can be used in ways that are worth questioning. A smart person—and a smart customer— understands that advertising may have taught us to need some of the things we now think are necessary. Knowing that does not mean advertising is bad. It means you should notice it, and think for yourself about what you truly want.

Did they create a need, or a trap? TAKE IT TO THE CLASS

146

Here is a genuinely deep debate. De Beers used advertising to convince the world that a diamond was something to want and buy, even though most people never had before. Was that a brilliant, harmless piece of marketing, or did it pressure people into spending money on something they were simply taught to want? Argue both sides honestly. One side says no one was forced, the diamonds make people happy, and creating desire is just what good advertising does. The other side says it is troubling to manufacture a “want” that costs people a lot of money and did not exist before. As you argue, think about other things people feel they must have today. Were some of those wants created the same way? There is no easy answer, and thoughtful people land on different sides.

Unit 6

| Lesson 20

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

The Work Check your understanding 1. What company controlled most of the world’s diamonds, and what problem did it face in the 1930s? 2. Who wrote the famous slogan, and how did it come about? 3. Is De Beers a public or a private company today?

Think harder 1. Explain the difference between advertising that informs you and advertising that creates desire. 2. De Beers changed what millions of people wanted without changing the product at all. Why is that such a powerful and surprising idea?

Try it yourself

BUSINESS RULE

Think of one thing you really want to own. Ask yourself honestly: did you want it before you ever saw it advertised, or did advertising help create that want? Write a few sentences exploring where your desire for it came from.

Unit 6

3. Why do you think the author says this story “raises real questions worth thinking about”?

| Lesson 20

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

“Advertising can do more than inform. It can create desire.”

147

Unit

WORDS TO KNOW MEET THESE BEFORE YOU READ

Getting Customers

GOODYEAR The most famous thing in the sky

• Brand awareness - how many people know and recognize a company’s name. • Marketing - all the ways a company works to make people want and remember its products. • Recognition - the feeling of already knowing a name when you see it. • Slogan - a short, memorable phrase that helps people remember a brand.

Watch for these words as you read. Goodyear shows why a company would spend a fortune on advertising that never sells a single thing on the spot.

STO P & TH I NK All tires look pretty similar. Why does that make it so hard for one tire company to stand out?

148

R E A D T HE S T ORY A tire is about the most boring thing a company can sell, and every tire looks like every other. So how did one company make sure you know its name? It did the strangest thing imaginable: it built a giant airship, floated it over your city, and never tried to sell you a tire at all.

n 1898, in Akron, Ohio, a man named Frank Seiberling started a rubber company with his brother Charles. They named it Goodyear, after Charles Goodyear, the inventor who had discovered how to make rubber strong and useful decades earlier. He was not a founder of the company and had died long before; the brothers simply admired him and borrowed his name. At first the company made bicycle tires, carriage tires, and even small rubber items. Soon, as automobiles arrived, it focused on car tires. Here is the challenge Goodyear faced, and it is one almost every company faces. A tire is not very exciting, and one company’s tire looks much like another’s. How does a tire maker get people to know its name and trust it, when tires are hard to tell apart? Goodyear’s answer became one of the most famous marketing ideas in history, and it involved looking up at the sky.

Unit 6

| Lesson 21

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

WIKIPEDIA .COM

Frank Seiberling

WIKIPEDIA .COM

GOODYEARFOOTWEAR.COM

CORP ORATE .GOODYEAR.COM

WIKIPEDIA .COM

Unit 6

| Lesson 21

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

149

Charles Goodyear

Unit

Getting Customers

ALLTHINGSMOTORINGINTERNATIONAL .COM WIKIPEDIA .COM

STO P & TH I NK

The answer is a powerful idea called brand awareness. The blimp made millions of people see and remember the Goodyear name, over and over, year after year. Then, later, when those same people needed to buy tires, a moment that comes rarely and is not very fun, one name already

The blimp never sold a tire on the spot. So what could possibly make it worth the huge cost?

In 1925, Goodyear built and flew its first advertising blimp, a giant airship that floated slowly over cities and events with the Goodyear name printed on its side. People could not help but look up at it. It was enormous, unusual, and unforgettable. The blimp did not sell a single tire directly. Nobody looked up, saw the blimp, and immediately bought tires. So why do it?

MOTORCITI ES.ORG

MOTORCITIES.ORG

150

Unit 6

| Lesson 21

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

WIKIPEDIA .COM

felt familiar and trustworthy: Goodyear. The blimp planted the name in people’s minds long before they were ready to buy, so that Goodyear was the name they reached for when the moment came.

Today Goodyear is a large public company, traded on the stock market, and one of the biggest tire makers in the world, bringing in many billions of dollars a year. It sells a product almost no one finds exciting, yet nearly everyone knows its name. That is the quiet power of brand awareness, and it floated over our heads the whole time.

DID YOU KNOW?

• Goodyear is named after Charles Goodyear, who discovered how to make rubber tough and useful. He never worked for the company and had died decades before it was founded. • The company has flown more than 300 blimps in its history. The blimp

Unit 6

| Lesson 21

STOP & TH I N K Why would people reach for a name they already recognize when it is finally time to buy something they rarely think about?

Goodyear has flown more than 300 blimps over the past century, and the blimp remains one of the most recognized advertising symbols anywhere. The company also chose a memorable logo, a winged foot, to make its name stick even further. None of these things are the tire. They are all about making sure that when you finally need a tire, you already know and trust the name Goodyear.

does not sell tires directly, yet it is one of the most recognized brand symbols in the world. • Goodyear’s logo is a winged foot, inspired by the sandals of a Roman messenger god, chosen to suggest speed and motion.

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

151

Unit

Getting Customers

THE LESSON Be the name people already know when they are finally ready to buy. Some products are bought rarely and without much excitement. Nobody wakes up thrilled to buy tires. The challenge for a company like Goodyear is that customers spend almost no time thinking about tires, until the sudden day they need them. So the goal is brand awareness: making sure your name is already familiar and trusted in people’s minds long before that day arrives. This is why a company will spend money on something like a blimp that sells nothing directly. The blimp is not trying to make a sale today. It is planting a seed. It makes the name Goodyear feel familiar and friendly through years of simply being seen. Then, when a customer finally needs tires and feels unsure, the familiar name wins,

CORP ORATE .GOODYEAR.COM

because people trust what they recognize. Much of marketing works exactly this way. It is not always asking you to buy right now. Often it is just making sure that when you are ready, one name is already waiting comfortably in your memory.

Is it worth it to advertise without selling? TAKE IT TO THE CLASS

152

Set up the debate. A blimp costs a fortune and never directly sells a tire. A skeptic might say that is a waste of money, and the company should spend it on lowering prices or making better tires instead. A believer says the blimp is worth every penny because it makes millions of people remember and trust the name. Who is right? Argue both sides. Push on the hard question: how would you even measure whether the blimp “works,” if it never makes a direct sale? This is a real problem businesses wrestle with. As you debate, think of advertisements you remember for products you have never bought. Did that advertising still do its job by making you remember the name?

Unit 6

| Lesson 21

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

The Work Check your understanding 1. What did Goodyear make when it first started, before car tires? 2. I n what year did the first Goodyear blimp fly? 3. Is Goodyear a public or a private company today?

Think harder 1. Explain why brand awareness matters most for products people buy rarely, like tires. 2. The blimp never sells a tire on the spot. In your own words, what job is it actually doing?

Try it yourself

BUSINESS RULE

Think of a product you would only buy once in a long while, like tires, a mattress, or a refrigerator. If you had to make people remember your brand for that product, what is one creative, attention-grabbing thing you could do, the way Goodyear used a blimp?

Unit 6

3. Why do people tend to choose a name they already recognize when they are unsure?

| Lesson 21

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

“Be the name people already know when they are finally ready to buy.”

153

Unit

6 22

WORDS TO KNOW MEET THESE BEFORE YOU READ

Getting Customers

WALMART One promise, repeated everywhere

• Positioning - the one clear idea a company wants to own in customers’ minds. • Focus - choosing one thing to be known for instead of many. • Slogan - a short phrase that sums up a brand’s promise. • Value - getting a good deal for the money you spend.

Watch for these words as you read. Walmart shows the power of standing for just one idea and never letting go of it.

STO P & TH I NK Most stores try to be many things at once. Why might choosing to stand for just one thing be more powerful?

154

R E A D THE S T ORY Big stores ignored the small towns, certain there was no money in them. One storekeeper in tiny Rogers, Arkansas, bet his whole future that they were wrong, by promising one thing and one thing only. That single, stubborn promise grew into the largest store in the world.

n 1962, a storekeeper named Sam Walton opened a shop in the small town of Rogers, Arkansas. He had already run other stores, and he had developed one strong belief: that if he sold everyday goods at the lowest possible prices, ordinary people in small towns would flock to him. The big retail chains mostly ignored small rural towns, thinking they were too small to bother with. Walton bet they were wrong. His idea was almost stubbornly simple. Many stores try to be many things at once: stylish, fancy, full of service, and also somewhat affordable. Walton chose to stand for just one thing, low prices, and to repeat that promise relentlessly. He named the store Walmart, and everything about it pushed the same message. He kept his own costs extremely low so he could keep prices low, and he passed the savings to customers. His promise to shoppers could be summed up in a few words: everyday low prices. Unit 6

| Lesson 22

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

CORP ORATE .WALMART.COM

WIKIPEDIA .COM

Unit 6

CORP ORATE .WALMART.COM

Sam Walton

CORP ORATE .WALMART.COM

| Lesson 22

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

155

Unit

6 22

Getting Customers

CORP ORATE .WALMART.COM

STO P & TH I NK

How does keeping the company’s own costs low connect directly to the promise Walmart makes to customers?

To make that promise real, Walton was relentless about cost. He bought goods cheaply in huge quantities, ran no-frills stores, and squeezed waste out of everything. He even famously studied competitors’ stores to learn how to do things better and cheaper. Every dollar he saved on costs let him lower a price, and every low price reinforced the one idea he wanted customers to believe about Walmart: that it was the place to save money.

CORP ORATE .WALMART.COM

156

Unit 6

| Lesson 22

This focus is called positioning, which means deciding the one clear idea you want to own in customers’ minds. Walmart’s position was “low prices,” and it owned that idea so completely that the words became almost automatic. When people thought of saving money on everyday goods, they thought of Walmart. The company did not confuse customers by trying to also be the fanciest or the most stylish. It picked one promise and hammered it home for decades.

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

WIKIPEDIA .COM

CORP ORATE .WALMART.COM

CORP ORATE .WALMART.COM WIKIPEDIA .COM

DID YOU KNOW?

• Walmart began as a single store in the small town of Rogers, Arkansas, in 1962. Today it is the largest retailer in the world. • Sam Walton was famous for visiting competitors’ stores with a notebook, studying how they

Unit 6

| Lesson 22

STOP & TH I N K Walmart has kept the same one promise for sixty years. Why does sticking with one idea for so long make a brand strong? © Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

That single, clear idea built an empire. From one store in a small Arkansas town, Walmart grew into the largest retailer in the entire world. It went public on the stock market in 1970, and today it trades under the symbol WMT. Its modern slogan, “save money, live better,” is just the same old promise in new words. Sam Walton died in 1992, but the one idea he chose still defines the company.

did things so he could do them cheaper. • Walmart’s promise has barely changed in sixty years. “Everyday low prices” simply became “save money, live better,” the same idea in new words.

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

157

Unit

6 22

Getting Customers

THE LESSON Own one clear idea in the customer’s mind. It is tempting for a business to try to be everything to everyone: the cheapest and the fanciest and the friendliest and the highest quality, all at once. The trouble is that a company that stands for everything ends up standing for nothing clear in customers’ minds. Sam Walton did the opposite. He picked one idea, low prices, and made Walmart own it completely. This is called positioning. Positioning means choosing the single thought you want to pop into a customer’s head when they hear your name. For Walmart, that thought is “save money.” For a different company it might be “safest,” or “fastest,” or “fanciest.” The power comes from focus and repetition. When

WIKIPEDIA .COM

a company picks one promise and keeps it for years, customers learn exactly what to expect, and the brand becomes a clear, simple idea instead of a fuzzy one. Walton proved that being famous for one thing can be far more powerful than being vaguely good at many things. Decide what you want to be known for, then prove it over and over.

Can you be the best at everything? TAKE IT TO THE CLASS

Here is the debate. Walmart chose to be known for low prices and nothing else. But a student might argue that the best business should try to be the cheapest and the highest quality and the friendliest, to win every kind of customer. Is it smarter to stand for one clear idea, or to try to be the best at everything? Argue both sides. One side says focus wins, because customers remember one clear promise, and trying to be everything makes a brand fuzzy and forgettable. The other side says why limit yourself, when being great at more things could attract more people. As you debate, think about real stores you know. Do the ones you remember best stand for one clear thing, or for everything at once?

158

Unit 6

| Lesson 22

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

The Work Check your understanding 1. Where and when did Sam Walton open the first Walmart? 2. What is Walmart’s one big promise to customers, in a few words? 3. Is Walmart a public or a private company today?

Think harder 1. Why can trying to be “everything to everyone” actually weaken a business? 2. Explain how Walmart’s focus on low costs and its promise of low prices fit together.

Try it yourself

BUSINESS RULE

Imagine you are opening a store. Pick the one idea you want to be known for (cheapest, fastest, friendliest, highest quality, or another). Write a short slogan for it, and explain why you chose that one idea instead of trying to be known for all of them.

Unit 6

3. Walmart’s old slogan was “everyday low prices” and its newer one is “save money, live better.” Why does keeping the same core idea for decades make a brand strong?

| Lesson 22

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

“Own one clear idea in the customer’s mind.”

159

End of Unit 6 CHAPTER SUMMARY

Getting Customers A look back at four companies that mastered making people want things.

This unit was about the hardest part of business: getting people to want what you sell. Coca-Cola built a giant out of a name and a script. De Beers used advertising to make people want something they had never wanted before. Goodyear floated a blimp to plant its name in your memory. And Walmart won by standing for one clear idea, low prices, and never letting go.

Coca-Cola

A drink that sold nine glasses a day became a giant, not because of the taste, but because of a name, a script, and a feeling people learned to trust.

De Beers

Almost no ordinary person used to buy diamonds. Advertising convinced the world it wanted them. Advertising can create desire, not just inform.

Goodyear

A blimp never sells a tire on the spot. It plants the name in your memory, so you reach for it when you finally need tires.

Walmart

Walmart stood for one idea, low prices, and never let go. Owning one clear idea beats being vaguely good at everything.

THE BIG QUESTION

How do you get people to want what you are selling?

You do more than make a good product. You build a brand people recognize and trust, you advertise to shape what they want, you make sure your name is the one they remember, and you stand for one clear idea instead of trying to be everything. Getting customers is its own skill, separate from making the product itself.

THE RULES YOU COLLECTED 1. A strong brand

can be worth more than the product itself.

160

2. Advertising

can do more than inform. It can create desire.

End of Unit 6

3. Be the name

people already know when they are finally ready to buy.

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

4. Own one

clear idea in the customer’s mind.

BRING IT TOGETHER

Put It All Together Three ways to prove you really own these ideas. 1. Match The Idea Draw a line from each situation on the left to the unit idea on the right that fits it best. People buy the drink they recognize, even when others taste the same Ads make people want something they never wanted before. A giant blimp makes you remember a name for years. One store is famous for low prices and nothing else.

A brand can be worth more than the product Advertising can create desire Be the name people already know Own one clear idea

2. Key Words Check Fill in each blank with the right word: brand, demand, positioning. The name, logo, colors, and feeling that make a company recognizable is its How much people want something and are willing to pay for it is Choosing the one clear idea you want to own in customers’ minds is

. . .

3. Your Turn: Max’s Pretzel Stand

The Situation Max bakes really good pretzels, but so do three other stands at the market. His pretzels are not selling any better than theirs. Using this unit, help Max get customers to choose his stand over the others. Answer in your own words: a. Max’s pretzels are as good as the others. Why isn’t simply being good enough to win? b. What is one clear idea Max could become known for, and how would he show it? c. Write a short slogan Max could put on his stand.

End of Unit 6

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

161

End of Unit 6 PRACTICAL FORM

Meet the Form: The Ad Planner The form that turns a product into a message customers remember.

Having a good product is not enough. You have to give people a reason to want it and to remember it. Before spending a dollar on advertising, smart businesses plan it out: what they are selling, who it is for, the one message they want to land, and a slogan to make it stick. Here is an ad planner filled out for Max’s pretzel stand.

AD PLANNER

Hot, fresh, hand-twisted pretzels Product

Hungry people walking through the market Who it’s for

The freshest pretzel here, never left sitting The one big message

A bright sign and the smell of baking © Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

How people will notice it

Fresh from the oven, every time.

WHAT EACH LINE IS FOR Who it’s for Knowing your customer keeps the message aimed at the right people. The one big message The single idea you want stuck in their head, not ten different ones. Slogan A short, memorable line that carries the whole message at once.

Slogan

WHY IT MATTERS A focused message is easier to remember than a long list of unrelated claims. Max’s plan centers on one thought—freshness—so every part of the ad supports the same promise. Other strengths can still matter, but the advertisement should make its main message unmistakable.

162

End of Unit 6

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

PRACTICAL FORM

Your Turn: Plan an Ad Make people want what you are selling. Pick a product or service you could sell, maybe the one you invented earlier in the book. Plan it out, then fill in the ad planner to turn it into one clear message customers will remember.

First, Plan It Out What are you selling, and who is the customer you want to reach? What is the one thing you most want people to remember about it?

Now Plan Your Ad AD PLANNER

Product

Who it’s for

The one big message

How people will notice it

Slogan

Last Question Why is one clear message stronger than trying to tell customers everything good about your product?

End of Unit 6

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

163

Unit

7 23

Making Money & Staying Alive

THIN MARGINS, BIG TRUST:

COSTCO

WORDS TO KNOW MEET THESE BEFORE YOU READ

• Margin - the amount of profit a business makes on each sale.

Making almost nothing on each sale, on purpose

• Volume - the total amount of product a business sells. • Membership - a fee customers pay regularly for the right to use a service. • Loyalty - when customers keep coming back to the same business.

Watch for these words as you read. Costco makes almost no profit on the things it sells, and that turns out to be the whole secret.

STO P & TH I NK Costco makes almost no profit on the products it sells. So how could it possibly survive as a business?

164

R E A D T HE S T ORY Imagine a store that refuses to make much money on anything it sells, and then charges you a fee just to walk through the door. It sounds backwards, even foolish. Yet that upside-down idea built one of the largest and most trusted stores in the entire world.

n 1983, in Seattle, Washington, two businessmen named Jim Sinegal and Jeffrey Brotman opened the first Costco warehouse. It did not look like a normal store. It was a giant, plain building with concrete floors and tall metal shelves, where goods were stacked in huge quantities. And there was a strange rule at the door: to shop there at all, you first had to pay a yearly membership fee. Why would anyone pay just for the right to spend money? The answer is the clever heart of Costco’s whole business. Most stores make their money by marking up products, buying something for ten dollars and selling it for fifteen or twenty. Costco refused to do that. It set a strict rule: it would never mark up a product more than about 14 percent above what it paid, far less than the 25 to 50 percent that normal stores charge. That meant rock-bottom prices for customers, but very little profit on each sale.

Unit 7

| Lesson 23

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

WIKIPEDIA .COM

Jim Sinegal and Jeffrey Brotman

WIKIPEDIA .COM

BRITANNICA .COM

Unit 7

| Lesson 23

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

165

Unit

7 23

Making Money & Staying Alive

STO P & TH I NK

This built something rare: deep trust. Costco shoppers learn that they do not need to hunt for sales or compare prices, because Costco’s price is always about as low as it gets. That trust shows up in the numbers. Around 90 percent of Costco members renew their membership every year, an astonishingly loyal customer base. The company

How does earning money from memberships instead of markups change what Costco wants to do with its prices?

Here is the trick. Costco does not really make its money on the products. It makes its money on the membership fees. Customers pay each year just to shop there, and that fee is where much of Costco’s profit comes from. This flips the usual store on its head. Because Costco earns from memberships, not markups, it actually wants to keep prices as low as humanly possible, so members feel they are getting such a good deal that they happily renew their membership year after year.

WIKIPEDIA .COM

166

Unit 7

| Lesson 23

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

WIKIPEDIA .COM

also keeps its costs low in every other way, selling a small number of products in huge quantities and skipping fancy displays.

DID YOU KNOW?

• Costco caps its markup at about 14 percent, while typical stores mark goods up 25 to 50 percent. The cap is enforced so strictly that the company will drop a product rather than raise the price too much. • Costco’s own brand, Kirkland Signature, became one of the

Unit 7

| Lesson 23

STOP & TH I N K Costco pays its workers more than most stores do. How could paying workers more actually help a low-price business?

Costco even treats its workers unusually well, paying wages well above what most stores pay, because loyal, experienced employees make the whole low-cost machine run smoothly. The approach works. Costco grew into one of the largest retailers in the world. Today it is a public company, traded on the stock market under the symbol COST, and brings in over $275 billion a year. It proved that you can build a giant by making almost nothing on each sale, as long as you make it up in loyalty.

largest consumer brands in the world, making up roughly a quarter of everything the company sells. • Around 90 percent of Costco members renew every year, one of the most loyal customer bases of any store on earth.

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

167

Unit

7 23

Making Money & Staying Alive

THE LESSON Thin margins and strong loyalty can beat higher margins when volume and membership revenue cover the business’s costs. The amount of profit a business makes on each sale is called its margin. A high-margin business makes a lot on each item but may sell fewer. A thin margin means you make very little on each sale. That sounds bad, but Costco shows it can be a powerful strategy. If your prices are so low that customers flock to you and stay loyal, you can sell enormous volume, the total amount of stuff you sell, and small profits on millions of sales add up to a fortune. What makes Costco brilliant is that it found a second way to make money, the membership fee, so it did not have to squeeze profit out of each product. This lined up the company’s interests with its customers’ interests perfectly.

BRITANNICA .COM

Costco genuinely wants to give you the lowest price, because its real goal is to keep you as a member. Most businesses face a tension between charging more and keeping customers happy. Costco cleverly removed that tension. The lesson is that thin margins are not automatically weak. Paired with high volume and real loyalty, thin margins can support a very strong business model.

Would you pay to shop somewhere? TAKE IT TO THE CLASS

Here is the debate. Costco makes you pay a yearly fee just to walk in the door. Some people think that is brilliant, because it pays for lower prices on everything inside. Others think paying for the privilege of shopping is ridiculous. Who is right? Argue both sides. One side says the membership pays for itself many times over if you shop there regularly, and it is why prices are so low. The other side says it is strange to pay before you have bought anything, and it only works if you shop there a lot. As you argue, think about who the membership is a good deal for, and who it is not. The answer depends a lot on the customer.

168

Unit 7

| Lesson 23

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

The Work Check your understanding 1. What unusual thing must you do before you can shop at Costco? 2. Where does most of Costco’s profit actually come from? 3. About what percentage of Costco members renew every year?

Think harder 1. Explain how Costco can charge such low prices and still make a large profit overall. 2. Why does earning money from memberships make Costco want to keep prices low, instead of raising them?

Try it yourself

BUSINESS RULE

Think of a store your family shops at often. Would paying a yearly fee be worth it if it meant everything inside was cheaper? Explain how you would decide whether the membership pays for itself.

Unit 7

3. How can thin margins, normally a weakness, become a strength for a business like Costco?

| Lesson 23

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

“Thin margins plus huge loyalty can beat fat margins every time.”

169

Unit

Making Money & Staying Alive

THE COMEBACK:

FENDER

WORDS TO KNOW MEET THESE BEFORE YOU READ

• Turnaround saving a failing business and making it healthy again.

How a beloved brand almost died, then rebuilt itself

• Quality - how well a product is made and how well it does its job. • Reputation - what people generally believe and say about a business. • Buyout - when a group buys a company, often to run it themselves.

Watch for these words as you read. This is the story of a famous guitar maker that nearly fell apart, and the people who bought it back to save it.

STO P & TH I NK Fender did not change its famous designs, yet its reputation collapsed. What had actually gone wrong?

170

R E A D TH E S T ORY It was one of the most loved guitar names in the world, played on countless famous stages. Then new owners chasing speed and savings let the quality slip, until musicians who once adored it would say they hated it. The only people who could save it were the workers who still believed in it, and they had to buy the company back to try.

n 1946, a man named Leo Fender started building electric guitars in Fullerton, California. His guitars, with names like the Telecaster and the Stratocaster, became some of the most loved instruments in the world. Musicians everywhere played them. The Fender name stood for quality, and for decades the company was a giant of the music world. Then, in 1965, Leo Fender sold the company to a large corporation for $13 million. Under its new corporate owner, Fender began to slip. To save money and make more guitars faster, the new managers cut corners on how the instruments were built. The guitars that came out of the factory were no longer as good as the ones musicians remembered. Word spread among players, and Fender’s reputation,

Unit 7

| Lesson 24

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

FENDER.COM

WIKIPEDIA .COM

Unit 7

| Lesson 24

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

171

Unit

Leo Fender

Making Money & Staying Alive

GUITAR.COM

TRIPADVISOR.COM

built up over many years, started to crumble. As one person who later helped rescue the company put it, by the 1980s “everybody hated Fender.”

STO P & TH I NK

The new owners bought the Fender name but not its factory. Why would that make saving the company so much harder?

By the mid-1980s, the corporation had had enough of the struggling guitar business and wanted to sell it. In 1985, a group of Fender’s own managers and employees, led by a man named Bill Schultz, bought the company back for $12.5 million. But there was a catch that made their job terrifying: the deal did not include the factory. The buyers got the famous name and the designs, but no place to make guitars. For about eight months, there was no Fender guitar factory in America at all. Instead of panicking, Schultz and his team treated the fresh start as a chance to fix what had gone wrong. Their whole plan came down to one word: quality. They set out, in their own words, to restore the confidence of the dealers and the players. They built a new factory in Corona, California, and they essentially retaught everyone how to make a Fender guitar the way musicians had always wanted it, carefully and well, rather than fast and cheap. WIKIPEDIA .COM

172

Unit 7

| Lesson 24

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

TRIPADVISOR.COM

It worked. As the quality climbed back up, so did Fender’s reputation. Musicians began to trust the name again. The careful, well-made guitars won back the players who had drifted away, and slowly the company grew strong once more. The turnaround was complete: a brand that had nearly been ruined was healthy again, all because its new owners understood that the quality of the product was the whole point. Today Fender is a private company and the leading maker of electric guitars in the world, bringing in hundreds of millions of dollars a year. The instruments that nearly lost their good name are once again the choice of beginners and famous musicians alike. Fender’s comeback is a classic turnaround story, and its lesson is simple: when a business built on quality starts to fail, the way back is almost always to return to the very thing that made it great.

DID YOU KNOW?

• Leo Fender, who started the company, could not actually play the guitar himself. He was an inventor and tinkerer who designed instruments by listening closely to what musicians told him they needed. • For about eight months in 1985, after the buyback, there was no

Unit 7

| Lesson 24

STOP & TH I N K What does Fender’s recovery teach about the fastest way to fix a struggling, qualitybased business?

WIKIPEDIA .COM

Fender guitar factory in the United States at all. The company had the famous name but nowhere to make its guitars. • Fender’s Telecaster and Stratocaster designs are so good that they have been made, almost unchanged, for more than seventy years.

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

173

Unit

Making Money & Staying Alive

THE LESSON

When a quality business starts to fail, the way back is to return to quality. A turnaround is the work of saving a failing business and making it healthy again. Fender’s troubles began when its corporate owner chased speed and cost savings by cutting quality. That is a tempting trap, because cheaper, faster production saves money right away. But for a company whose whole reputation was built on being excellent, cutting quality quietly destroyed the one thing customers valued most. The damage did not show up immediately, but it was deadly. The comeback teaches the other half of the lesson. When the employees bought the company back in a buyout, they did not try some flashy new gimmick. They went back to basics and rebuilt the quality that had made Fender great in the first place. That is often how

TAKE IT TO THE CLASS

174

SLOANSCHOO LOFMUSIC.COM

real turnarounds work. A struggling company is usually tempted to do something dramatic and new, but frequently the answer is to return to the core strength it abandoned. Fender reminds us that a great reputation takes years to build, can be lost shockingly fast, and is won back only by once again being genuinely good.

Cut quality to save money, or protect it at all costs? Here is the debate. Imagine you run a company famous for quality, and times get tight. You could quietly cut a few corners to save money, and most customers might not notice at first. Or you could protect the quality no matter what, even though it costs more. Which is the wiser choice? Argue both sides. One side says small savings add up and a business has to survive the hard times somehow. The other side says, like Fender learned the hard way, that cutting the quality of a quality brand destroys the one thing that made it special. As you argue, think about how a customer’s trust is built and how easily it can be lost. Once people stop trusting a name, how hard is it to win them back?

Unit 7

| Lesson 24

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

The Work Check your understanding 1. Who started Fender, and what happened to the company in 1965? 2. Why did Fender’s reputation fall apart under its corporate owner? 3. Who bought the company back in 1985, and what was missing from the deal?

Think harder 1. Fender’s designs never changed, yet its reputation collapsed. Explain what actually went wrong. 2. Why did the new owners choose to rebuild around quality instead of, say, low prices?

Try it yourself

BUSINESS RULE

Think of a brand or a place you stopped trusting after it let you down, even once. Describe what happened, and what it would take for them to win back your trust.

Unit 7

3. Why is a damaged reputation so much harder to rebuild than it was to lose?

| Lesson 24

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

“When a quality business starts to fail, the way back is to return to quality.”

175

Unit

Making Money & Staying Alive

THE GIANT THAT STOPPED CHANGING:

SEARS

WORDS TO KNOW MEET THESE BEFORE YOU READ

• Adapt - to change in response to a changing world.

The biggest store in the world, until it was not

• Competitor another business trying to win the same customers. • Complacency - being so comfortable with success that you stop trying to improve. • Decline - a slow fall from success over time.

Watch for these words as you read. Sears was once the most powerful store in America, which is exactly what makes its fall so important to understand.

STO P & TH I NK The Sears catalog let rural families order almost anything by mail. Why was that such a powerful idea in a time before cars were common?

176

R E A D T H E S T ORY Two out of every three Americans once shopped there. It sold everything from socks to entire houses delivered by train, and it had practically invented the idea of shopping from home. It looked unstoppable, permanent, too big to ever fail. Then it failed, brought down by newer companies doing the very thing it had invented.

t is hard to imagine today, but for much of the twentieth century, Sears was the most powerful store in America. It began in the 1880s when a railway worker named Richard Sears started selling watches, then teamed up with a watch repairman named Alvah Roebuck. Their company, Sears, Roebuck and Co., had a brilliant idea for its time: a giant mail-order catalog. The catalog was the wonder of its age. Families in faraway rural towns, who could only buy from one small local store, could suddenly order almost anything from a thick Sears catalog: tools, clothing, toys, even entire build-it-yourself houses delivered by train. It brought a huge selection of goods directly to people’s homes at a time when most people could only shop at whatever happened to be nearby.

Unit 7

| Lesson 25

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

WIKIPEDIA .COM

Richard Sears

WIKIPEDIA .COM

Alvah Roebuck

WIKIPEDIA .COM

SEARS.COM

Unit 7

| Lesson 25

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

177

Unit

Making Money & Staying Alive

WIKIPEDIA .COM

STO P & TH I NK

But the world kept changing, and Sears slowly stopped changing with it. New kinds of stores appeared. Discount chains like Walmart and Target sold things cheaper. Specialty stores dominated single categories like tools or hardware. Then, most painfully of all, a new generation of sellers grew up that delivered a huge selection of goods straight to people’s doors, offering exactly what the Sears catalog once had. Sears, which had practically invented that idea, failed to seize it. Year after year, Sears reacted too slowly. It underinvested in its stores, which grew tired and unappealing. It missed chance after chance to lead the changes happening in retail, the very industry it had once ruled. Customers drifted away to faster, cheaper, fresher competitors. The giant did not collapse in a day. It shrank slowly, over decades, like a great structure crumbling one piece at a time.

Sears basically invented shopping from home. Why is it so striking that it lost to newer sellers doing the very same thing?

Sears grew almost unimaginably large. By 1945 it passed a billion dollars in sales. At its peak around 1969, Sears was so dominant that its sales equaled about one percent of the entire United States economy, and roughly two out of every three Americans shopped there. It employed hundreds of thousands of people and ran thousands of stores. It seemed permanent, the kind of company that could never fall.

WIKIPEDIA .COM

178

Unit 7

| Lesson 25

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

WIKIPEDIA .COM

DID YOU KNOW?

• At its peak, about two out of every three Americans shopped at Sears, and its sales equaled roughly one percent of the entire U.S. economy. • The Sears catalog once sold entire houses. You could order a complete kit by mail, delivered by

Unit 7

| Lesson 25

STOP & TH I N K Sears was the largest retailer in the world and still failed. What does that tell you about whether any company is ever truly safe? © Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

In 2018, after more than 125 years in business, Sears filed for bankruptcy, owing billions of dollars. Today only a tiny handful of Sears stores remain, a faint shadow of the colossus it once was. Its fall is one of the most studied cautionary tales in business. The lesson is humbling: being the biggest and most dominant company in the world guarantees nothing. A business that stops changing, even a giant, can slowly die.

train, and assemble it on your own land. • Sears invented shopping from home by catalog, the same basic idea that newer home-delivery sellers later used to help drive Sears out of business.

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

179

Unit

Making Money & Staying Alive

THE LESSON No company is too big to fail. Stop changing, and the world will pass you by. Sears did almost everything right for nearly a century, which makes its story so important. It was not a small company that never figured things out. It was the biggest, most successful retailer in the world, and it still died. The reason was a failure to adapt, to keep changing as the world around it changed. Here is the trap Sears fell into. When a company is hugely successful, it becomes comfortable, and change feels unnecessary and risky. Why fix what is making so much money? But the world never stops moving. Competitors try new things, technology shifts, and customers’ habits change. A company that rests on past success slowly falls behind without noticing, because the decline is gradual. By the time the danger is obvious, it

WIKIPEDIA .COM

is often too late to catch up. The painful irony of Sears is that it pioneered shopping-fromhome by catalog, then lost to newer sellers doing the very same thing. The lesson for any business, large or small, is that staying alive requires constant change. Past success is never a guarantee of a future.

Can a company be too big to fail? TAKE IT TO THE CLASS

Here is the debate. Some people believe that if a company gets big and dominant enough, it becomes unstoppable and will always survive. The story of Sears suggests the opposite. So is any company ever truly safe, or can even the mightiest fall? Argue both sides. One side points to giant companies that have lasted a very long time as proof that size brings safety. The other side points to Sears and argues that no size protects a company that stops adapting. As you debate, try naming companies that seem unbeatable today, and ask honestly whether they could ever end up like Sears. It is harder to be sure than you might think.

180

Unit 7

| Lesson 25

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

The Work Check your understanding 1. How did Sears first reach customers in faraway rural towns? 2. How dominant was Sears at its peak around 1969? 3. What new kinds of competitors did Sears fail to keep up with?

Think harder 1. Sears was the largest retailer in the world and still failed. What does that tell you about whether any company is ever truly safe? 2. Explain the irony that Sears pioneered shopping from home but lost to newer sellers doing the same thing.

Try it yourself

BUSINESS RULE

Think of something that used to be popular but got replaced by something newer and better. Describe the old thing, what replaced it, and what its makers might have done to keep up.

Unit 7

3. Why is a slow decline over many years especially dangerous, compared to a sudden crisis?

| Lesson 25

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

“No company is too big to fail. Stop changing, and the world will pass you by.”

181

Unit

7 26

Making Money & Staying Alive

TOO MUCH, TOO FAST:

WORDS TO KNOW MEET THESE BEFORE YOU READ

• Operations - the everyday systems and work that actually run a business. • Supply chain - the path a product travels from where it is made to the customer. • Expansion growing a business into new places or markets. • Inventory - the goods a store has on hand to sell. Watch for these words as you read. Target was a strong, healthy company, which makes the way it failed in Canada all the more surprising.

TARGET IN CANADA

A strong company that grew itself to death R E A D T H E S T ORY A strong, healthy company walked into a friendly new country where shoppers already liked its brand and expected an easy victory. Two years later it had lost about two billion dollars and shut down every single store. Nothing was wrong with the brand or the products. It had simply tried to grow too much, too fast.

T STO P & TH I NK Target planned to open over a hundred stores in under two years. Why might moving that fast be dangerous, even for a strong company?

182

arget is a large, successful, and well-respected store chain in the United States, known for stylish products at reasonable prices. In 2011, riding high on its success at home, Target decided to expand into Canada, the neighboring country just to the north. Canadians already knew and liked the Target brand, and the company expected an easy win. Instead, it created one of the most famous failures in modern business. Target’s plan was enormous and fast. It took over about 220 store locations from a failed Canadian chain and announced it would open well over a hundred Target stores across Canada in under two years. That is a Unit 7

| Lesson 26

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

WIKIPEDIA .COM

Unit 7

| Lesson 26

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

183

Unit

7 26

Making Money & Staying Alive

WIKIPEDIA .COM

breathtaking pace. Opening even one store well takes careful work. Target was trying to open scores of them at once, across an entire country it had never operated in before. STO P & TH I NK Why would empty shelves, more than almost anything else, drive customers away from a brandnew store?

The speed broke the most important part of any store: getting products onto the shelves. Target rushed in a brand-new computer system to track its inventory, the goods coming in and going out. But the system was set up in a hurry and filled with errors. The result was a disaster. Trucks could not get products to the right stores. Warehouses overflowed with goods while store shelves sat empty.

WIKIPEDIA .COM

184

Unit 7

| Lesson 26

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

WIKIPEDIA .COM

Canadian shoppers, curious and excited at first, walked into the new Target stores and found bare shelves and a confusing experience. Cash registers froze. Prices rang up wrong. The very customers who had been eager to love Target were quickly disappointed, and they stopped coming back. A store with empty shelves cannot win, no matter how good its brand is, because it is failing at the one thing a store must do: have the product the customer came for.

WIKIPEDIA .COM

DID YOU KNOW?

• At one point, Canadian warehouses were overflowing with products while the store shelves

Unit 7

| Lesson 26

STOP & TH I N K Target’s brand and products were fine. So what, exactly, killed its Canadian expansion? © Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

Target’s leaders kept opening more stores even as these problems screamed for attention, instead of slowing down to fix the basics. The losses piled up with terrifying speed. In early 2015, less than two years after opening, Target gave up completely. It closed all of its Canadian stores, put about 17,000 people out of work, and lost roughly $2 billion on the whole adventure. A strong, profitable company had turned a huge expansion into a costly failure—not because its idea was bad, but because it grew too much, too fast.

• Target opened well over a hundred stores in Canada in under two years, then shut every one of them down less than two years after that.

WIKIPEDIA .COM

sat empty, all because of a rushed, error-filled inventory system. • Target lost roughly $2 billion on its Canadian expansion, one of the costliest store failures in recent memory, despite being a healthy company at home.

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

185

Unit

7 26

Making Money & Staying Alive

THE LESSON Growing too fast can kill a business as surely as not growing at all. Most people assume that growth is always good and faster growth is always better. The Target Canada disaster shows this is dangerously wrong. The company failed not because it grew, but because it grew faster than its operations, the everyday systems that actually run the business, could handle. Its supply chain, the path products travel from factory to shelf, simply could not keep up with the breakneck pace. This is one of the most important and least obvious lessons in business. A company can be killed by growing too fast just as surely as by not growing at all. When you expand faster than your systems, your people, and your supply chain can support, everything breaks at once, and customers see the mess. Target had a strong brand and products people wanted, but none

WIKIPEDIA .COM

of that mattered when the shelves were empty. The wiser path—the one Costco and the revived Fender followed—is to grow at a pace your operations can actually support, making sure the basics work before reaching for more. Speed feels exciting, but in business, growing carefully is often what keeps you alive.

Is fast growth worth the risk? TAKE IT TO THE CLASS

Here is the debate. Target could have entered Canada slowly, opening a few stores, getting them right, and then expanding. Instead it opened over a hundred at once and collapsed. Was the fast approach a reasonable bet that simply went wrong, or was it obviously too risky from the start? Argue both sides. One side says moving fast can let a company grab a new market before competitors react, so the ambition was understandable. The other side says no brand can survive empty shelves, and the basics must work before you scale up. As you debate, think about how a company should decide how fast to grow. There is real tension between seizing an opportunity and being ready for it.

186

Unit 7

| Lesson 26

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

The Work Check your understanding 1. Why did Target expect its move into Canada to succeed? 2. What broke when Target tried to open so many stores so fast? 3. How did the Canadian expansion finally end?

Think harder 1. Target had a strong brand and products people wanted. Explain why those were not enough to save it. 2. Why can growing too fast be just as dangerous as not growing at all?

Try it yourself

BUSINESS RULE

Imagine you run a small business that suddenly becomes popular, and you are tempted to expand quickly. List two things you would want to make sure were working perfectly before opening a second location.

Unit 7

3. Compare Target’s approach to the patient approach of Costco or the rebuilt Fender. What did they understand that Target forgot?

| Lesson 26

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

“Growing too fast can kill a business as surely as not growing at all.”

187

End of Unit 7 CHAPTER SUMMARY

Making Money and Staying Alive A look back at four companies that lived, or died, by the numbers.

This unit was about the hardest part of all: staying alive. Costco makes almost nothing on each sale and wins on loyalty. Fender nearly died, then came back by returning to quality. Sears was the biggest store in the world and still failed by refusing to change. And Target grew so fast in Canada that it collapsed in barely two years.

Costco

Costco makes almost no profit on what it sells, and charges a membership fee instead. Thin margins and strong loyalty can beat higher margins when sales volume and membership revenue cover the business's costs.

Fender

A famous guitar maker lost its quality under a new owner, then employees bought it back and saved it by returning to quality.

Sears

Once two out of three Americans shopped there. It stopped changing, and the world passed it by. No company is too big to fail.

Target Canada

A strong company opened over a hundred stores in two years, broke its own supply chain, and lost about $2 billion. Growing too fast can kill you.

THE BIG QUESTION

How does a business make money and stay alive?

Making money is not the same as staying alive. A business has to cover its costs, keep its customers loyal, and keep changing as the world changes. The companies that last watch their costs and their customers carefully. The ones that fail either stop changing, like Sears, or grow faster than they can handle, like Target Canada.

THE RULES YOU COLLECTED 1. Thin margins plus

huge loyalty can beat fat margins every time.

188

2. When a quality

business starts to fail, the way back is to return to quality.

End of Unit 7

3. No company is

too big to fail. Stop changing, and the world will pass you by.

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

4. Growing too fast

can kill a business as surely as not growing at all.

BRING IT TOGETHER

Put It All Together Three ways to prove you really own these ideas. 1. Match The Idea Draw a line from each situation on the left to the unit idea on the right that fits it best. A store makes pennies per sale but customers never leave. A brand that lost its way fixes its quality and comes back. The biggest company in its field refuses to change, and fades. A company opens too many stores too fast and collapses.

Thin margins plus loyalty Return to quality Too big to fail is a myth Growing too fast can kill you

2. Key Words Check Fill in each blank with the right word: margin, turnaround, adapt. The amount of profit a business makes on each sale is its

Saving a failing business and making it healthy again is a To change in response to a changing world is to

. .

3. Your Turn: Carlos’s Candle Stand

The Situation Carlos sells handmade candles at a weekend market. He pays $40 to rent his table each weekend, and each candle costs him $2 to make. He sells them for $6. Before the market opens, Carlos wants to know how many candles he must sell just to break even. Answer in your own words: a. Each candle sells for $6 and has a $2 variable cost. How much does each sale contribute toward the $40 table rental and then toward profit? b. Divide the $40 fixed cost by the $4 contribution from each candle. How many candles must Carlos sell to break even?

End of Unit 7

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

189

End of Unit 7 PRACTICAL FORM

Meet the Form: The Break-Even Worksheet The form that shows how much you must sell just to cover your costs.

Before a business earns a profit, sales must cover both variable costs and fixed costs. The contribution margin from each sale—the selling price minus that item’s variable cost—first helps pay the fixed costs. Break-even is the number of items the business must sell before total contribution margin equals total fixed costs.

WHAT EACH LINE IS FOR

BREAK-EVEN WORKSHEET

Fixed cost

Fixed cost (table rental for the day)

$40

Selling price for one candle

Variable cost of making one candle

The price minus what each one costs you to make.

Contribution margin per item (price minus cost)

Break-even number

Break-even quantity = fixed costs ÷ contribution margin per item

$40 ÷ $4 = 10 candles

What you must pay no matter how many you sell, like the table rental. Contribution margin per item

Fixed cost divided by contribution margin per item. Sell this many just to reach zero.

WHY IT MATTERS The break-even number turns a guess into a plan. After the tenth candle covers the fixed table cost, each additional candle adds another $4 toward profit, assuming no other costs change. Costco, Fender, and Target all lived or died on this kind of math. A business that does not know its break-even number is flying blind, and that is exactly how good companies quietly lose money without noticing.

190

End of Unit 7

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

PRACTICAL FORM

Your Turn: Find Your Break-Even Figure out how much you must sell to survive. Imagine you run a small stand like Carlos’s. Pick something you would sell and what it costs you. Plan it out, then fill in the worksheet to find the number you must sell just to break even.

First, Plan It Out What will you sell, what does each one cost you, and what will you charge? What is your fixed cost, the amount you must pay no matter how many you sell?

Now Find Your Number BREAK-EVEN WORKSHEET Fixed cost

Selling price

Variable cost of making one

Contribution margin per item (price minus cost)

Break-even quantity = fixed costs ÷ contribution margin per item

Last Question Once you pass your break-even number, what does every extra sale become? Why does that make the number so useful?

End of Unit 7

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

191

Unit

8 27

Assets & Ownership

THE ASSET THAT EARNS FOR A CENTURY:

UNION PACIFIC

WORDS TO KNOW MEET THESE BEFORE YOU READ

• Asset - anything a business owns that helps it make money.

Build it once, collect for a hundred years

• Infrastructure - large, costly structures like railroads, roads, and bridges that many people rely on. • Advantage something that lets one business do better than its competitors. • Investment money spent now in the hope of earning much more later.

Watch for these words as you read. A railroad shows the pattern behind every great asset: painful and costly to build once, then earning for generations.

STO P & TH I NK A railroad costs a fortune and takes years to build before earning a cent. Why would anyone make such an enormous bet?

192

R E A D T HE S T ORY In the middle of a civil war, the country set out to build a railroad across an entire continent, through mountains and deserts, by hand. It cost a fortune and took years before it earned a single dollar. But once those rails were down, they kept earning money for the next hundred and sixty years, and they still do today.

n 1862, the United States was in the middle of the Civil War, yet President Abraham Lincoln signed a law to begin one of the largest building projects the country had ever attempted: a railroad stretching all the way across the continent. The law created a company called Union Pacific and gave it the job of building the eastern portion, laying track westward from Omaha, Nebraska, toward the distant Pacific coast. The work was brutally hard. Thousands of laborers, many of them immigrants who had just arrived in the country, laid heavy iron rails across prairies, rivers, and mountains, mile after mile, in burning heat and freezing cold. Building a railroad was staggeringly expensive and slow. It took years of backbreaking effort and enormous sums of money before a single paying customer could use the finished line.

Unit 8

| Lesson 27

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

UP.COM

WIKIPEDIA .COM

Abraham Lincoln

UP.COM

Unit 8

| Lesson 27

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

193

Unit

8 27

Assets & Ownership

UP.COM

STO P & TH I NK Why is a finished railroad track such a powerful moneymaking asset, even long after it was built?

On May 10, 1869, Union Pacific’s track finally met the track of the Central Pacific, which had been built eastward from California. At a spot in Utah, a final ceremonial spike joined the two lines, and for the first time, a person could travel across the entire United States by train. A journey that once took months of dangerous travel by wagon now took about a week. Once the line was built, it could generate revenue for decades. But the asset did not earn by itself: Union Pacific still had to operate trains, pay workers, maintain and replace track and equipment, improve safety, and serve customers. The advantage was that competitors could not easily recreate the entire network, not that the railroad required no continuing work.

The same steel rails laid in the 1860s carried goods and earned money for generation after generation. A business that owns an asset like this holds something competitors cannot easily copy, because no one wants to build a second railroad right next to the first.

WIKIPEDIA .COM

194

Unit 8

| Lesson 27

Today, more than 160 years after Lincoln signed that law, Union Pacific is still one of the largest

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

UP.COM

WIKIPEDIA .COM

railroads in North America. It is a public company, traded on the stock market, operating tens of thousands of miles of track and earning around $24 billion a year. The asset that thousands of laborers built by hand in the 1800s is still hard at work, still earning, long after everyone who built it is gone.

DID YOU KNOW?

• The first transcontinental railroad was joined in Utah in 1869 with a ceremonial final spike. A trip across the country dropped from months by wagon to about a week by train. • Union Pacific was created during the Civil War, in 1862, and is still operating more than 160 years

Unit 8

| Lesson 27

STOP & TH I N K How can an asset built in the 1860s still be earning money today?

UP.COM

later, one of the longest-earning assets in American business. • No one builds a second transcontinental railroad right beside the first, which is part of why owning the original track is such a lasting advantage.

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

195

Unit

8 27

Assets & Ownership

THE LESSON A great asset is expensive to build once, then earns for a very long time. An asset is anything a business owns that helps it make money. A railroad is one of the most striking assets there is, because it shows a powerful pattern: a huge cost up front to build it, followed by many years of earning money. The track was painful and expensive to lay, but once it existed, it kept earning money for over a century with far less ongoing effort than its construction required. This is why owning the right asset can be so powerful. The best assets have two qualities. First, they keep earning money long after you pay for them, like a railroad collecting fees for generations. Second, they are hard for

UP.COM

competitors to copy. No one is going to build a second transcontinental railroad right beside the first, so the company that owns the track has something close to a lasting advantage. When you understand this pattern, you start to see assets everywhere: the things a business owns that quietly earn money long after the hard work of building or buying them is finished.

TAKE IT TO THE CLASS

Here is the debate. Imagine your town needs a bridge across a river. You could spend a fortune to build the bridge yourself and then charge everyone a small fee to cross it for the next hundred years. Or you could save your money and just pay to cross someone else’s bridge whenever you need to. Which is the smarter position to be in? Argue both sides. One side says owning the bridge is the dream, because you collect fees forever from everyone who needs to cross. The other side points out that building it costs a fortune up front and is risky, and maybe not enough people will cross to make it worth it. As you argue, notice that this is the exact bet Union Pacific made. Owning a great asset is powerful, but only if enough people end up needing it.

196

Unit 8

| Lesson 27

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

The Work Check your understanding 1. What job was Union Pacific created to do in 1862? 2. What happened on May 10, 1869? 3. How long has Union Pacific been earning money from its railroad, roughly?

Think harder 1. Explain the pattern of a great asset: what is hard at the start, and what is easier later? 2. Why is a railroad an asset competitors find very hard to copy?

Try it yourself

BUSINESS RULE

Think of an expensive thing that keeps earning or saving money long after you pay for it, like solar panels on a roof or a bicycle that saves bus fare. Describe the big upfront cost and how it pays off slowly over time.

Unit 8

3. Why does owning an asset that everyone must pay to use give a company lasting power?

| Lesson 27

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

“A great asset is expensive to build once, then earns for a very long time.”

197

Unit

8 28

Assets & Ownership

THE BOXES THAT MOVE THE WORLD:

MAERSK

WORDS TO KNOW MEET THESE BEFORE YOU READ

Owning the ships and boxes that carry everything

• Asset - anything a business owns that helps it make money. • Standard - an agreed way of doing something so everyone’s parts fit together. • Efficiency - getting more done with less waste, time, or cost. • Global trade - the buying and selling of goods between countries.

Watch for these words as you read. Maersk shows that the asset pattern works at sea too, and that sometimes the most powerful idea is a plain metal box.

STO P & TH I NK Why would loading goods by hand, in all different shapes and sizes, make shipping slow and expensive?

198

R E A D T HE S T ORY A sea captain and his son started with one secondhand steamship in a small Danish town. The company they built would grow to carry a large share of the world’s containerized ocean trade, and the secret behind it was partly a fleet of giant ships, and partly the most boring object you can imagine: a plain metal box.

n 1904, in the small Danish town of Svendborg, a sea captain named Peter Maersk Moller and his son Arnold started a shipping company. They began with a single secondhand steamship. Their business was simple to describe and hard to do: own ships, and use them to carry other people’s goods across the sea for a fee. More than a century later, that small family company had grown into Maersk, one of the largest shipping companies in the world. To understand Maersk, you have to understand the most boring-looking yet world-changing object in modern business: the shipping container. It is just a giant standardized metal box. Before these boxes existed, loading a ship was slow chaos. Goods of every shape and size were packed by hand, which took days and often led to damage and

Unit 8

| Lesson 28

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

MAERSK .COM

Peter Maersk Moller

Arnold Maersk Moller MAERSK .COM

APMOLLER.COM

Unit 8

| Lesson 28

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

199

Unit

8 28

Assets & Ownership

theft. Then the world agreed on a standard container, a box of fixed sizes that any ship, train, or truck could carry.

STO P & TH I NK How is a container ship like the Union Pacific railroad as a money-making asset?

With standardized boxes, everything changed. A container could be packed once, then lifted smoothly from truck to ship to train without ever being unpacked, using cranes built to fit that exact size. What once took days now took hours. Shipping became dramatically cheaper and faster, and that lower cost is a big reason you can buy goods from all over the world today. For a company like Maersk, the ships and the containers are its great assets. A single large container ship costs an enormous amount of money to build, much like a railroad. But once Maersk owns it, that ship can earn money every single day for decades, carrying thousands

APMOLLER.COM

WIKIPEDIA .COM

200

Unit 8

| Lesson 28

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

WIKIPEDIA .COM

of containers across the ocean on voyage after voyage. The huge upfront cost turns into a steady stream of earnings, the same pattern you saw with the railroad. There is another lesson hidden in Maersk’s story. The shipping container only works because everyone agreed to the same standard sizes. That cooperation, a shared standard, made global trade vastly more efficient for every company, not just Maersk. Sometimes the most powerful business ideas are not flashy inventions, but simple agreements that let the whole world work together more smoothly.

DID YOU KNOW?

• Maersk began in 1904 with a single secondhand steamship. Today it carries close to a fifth of all the world’s container trade. • Before standardized containers, loading a ship by hand could take days. With the boxes and matching

Unit 8

| Lesson 28

STOP & TH I N K Why is owning a large share of the world’s container ships such a powerful position to be in?

Today Maersk is a public company, traded on the stock market in Denmark, earning over $50 billion a year and carrying close to a fifth of the world’s container trade. Its enormous ships, stacked high with identical metal boxes, are a floating example of how owning the right assets, combined with a smart shared standard, can move not just goods, but the entire global economy.

cranes, the same work takes hours. • The plain metal shipping container, not any fancy invention, is considered one of the biggest reasons global trade became cheap enough to send goods worldwide.

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

201

Unit

8 28

Assets & Ownership

THE LESSON Owning the thing that carries everything is a powerful position. Maersk repeats the asset pattern from the railroad, but at sea. A container ship is hugely expensive to build, yet once owned, it earns money every day for decades. The ships are Maersk’s great assets, and owning them puts the company in a powerful spot: a large share of the world’s goods travels on ships, and Maersk owns a lot of those ships. But the deeper lesson is about the humble container. It works only because the whole world agreed on the same standard sizes, so any ship, crane, train, or truck can handle any box. That shared agreement created enormous efficiency for everyone, and made modern global trade possible. It is a surprising business

WIKIPEDIA .COM

truth: sometimes the most powerful idea is not a flashy invention but a simple standard that lets everyone work together. Owning great assets made Maersk strong, but a plain metal box, agreed upon by everyone, helped change the entire world.

The mighty ship, or the humble box? TAKE IT TO THE CLASS

Here is a debate worth having. Maersk owns gigantic, impressive ships. But some people argue the real genius was not the ships at all, it was the plain, boring, standardized metal box. Which mattered more: owning the mighty ships, or the simple idea of a standard container that everyone agreed to use? Argue both sides. One side says the ships are the real asset, since they cost a fortune and do the actual carrying. The other side says the container was the true breakthrough, because without an agreed standard, even the biggest ship would still be loaded slowly by hand. As you argue, think about how often a simple, shared agreement quietly makes everything else possible.

202

Unit 8

| Lesson 28

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

The Work Check your understanding 1. How did Maersk begin in 1904? 2. What was loading a ship like before standardized containers existed? 3. About how much of the world’s container trade does Maersk carry today?

Think harder 1. Explain how a container ship follows the same asset pattern as a railroad. 2. Why did the world agreeing on one container size make trade cheaper for everyone, not just Maersk?

Try it yourself

BUSINESS RULE

Think of a standard that lets things work together, like how any phone charger with the same plug fits any matching socket. Describe one standard you rely on, and what would go wrong if everyone used a different size.

Unit 8

3. Why might a simple shared standard sometimes be more powerful than a flashy invention?

| Lesson 28

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

“Owning the thing that carries everything is a powerful position.”

203

Unit

8 29

Assets & Ownership

THE ASSET YOU USE ONCE, OR AGAIN AND AGAIN:

SPACEX

WORDS TO KNOW MEET THESE BEFORE YOU READ

• Asset - anything a business owns that helps it make money. • Reusable - able to be used more than once instead of thrown away. • Investment money spent now in the hope of earning much more later. • Cost - the money a business spends to make or do something.

Watch for these words as you read. SpaceX took one of the most expensive machines ever built and asked a question no one else had seriously asked: why use it only once?

STO P & TH I NK After three failures, SpaceX had money for just one more rocket. How would you feel building that fourth one?

204

Why throwing away a rocket was the strangest waste in business R E A D T HE S T ORY Three rockets had already failed, and the company had money left to build just one more. If this last launch failed too, it was all over. Some earlier space systems had reused parts, but most orbital rockets still discarded major stages after launch. SpaceX set out to land and fly an orbitalclass first-stage booster repeatedly, making reuse a routine part of launch operations.

n 2002, a small new company called SpaceX set out to do something almost no private company had ever managed: build rockets and launch them into space. Its founder put a large amount of his own money into it, and its dream was bold, to make space travel far cheaper so that much more of it could happen. But rockets are among the hardest and most expensive machines on earth to build, and the young company was about to learn just how hard, the painful way. SpaceX built a rocket called the Falcon 1 and tried to launch it. It failed. They built another and tried again. It failed too. A third attempt also ended in failure, the rocket lost before reaching orbit. Each failed launch destroyed a rocket that had cost an enormous amount of money to build, and after three failures, the company was nearly out of money. There was only enough left for one more try. If the fourth launch failed, SpaceX would almost certainly be finished. During those desperate months, employees worked almost around the Unit 8

| Lesson 29

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

WIKIPEDIA .COM

Having barely survived, SpaceX focused on a major source of launch cost: most orbital rockets still discarded their first stages after one flight. After launching, the giant lower section, called the booster, would fall away and crash into the ocean, destroyed. The next launch needed a brand-new rocket. Imagine

clock, sometimes sleeping at the workshop, fixing the small mistakes that had doomed each earlier flight. Everything the company had was riding on the next rocket. On September 28, 2008, the Falcon 1 lifted off for the fourth time, and this time everything worked. It reached orbit, becoming the first privately built liquidfueled rocket ever to do so. The last-chance launch had saved the company, and soon after, a huge government space contract put SpaceX on solid ground at last. STOP & TH I N K Why might surviving that near-failure have made the company stronger and bolder afterward?

WIKIPEDIA .COM

Unit 8

| Lesson 29

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

205

Unit

8 29

Assets & Ownership

WIKIPEDIA .COM

Why would a company that nearly died from losing rockets be especially determined to make them reusable?

206

WIKIPEDIA .COM

buying a car, driving it one time, and then throwing the whole thing away. That is essentially how the rocket business worked, and everyone simply accepted it. SpaceX became convinced the key to cheaper space travel was hiding in plain sight: what if a rocket, like an airplane, could be used again and again? The idea was simple to say and brutally hard to do. After lifting its cargo, the booster would have to turn around, fly back down, and land itself gently and upright, ready to fly again. The early attempts failed too. Boosters came down too hard and exploded. One tipped over on its landing platform. Then, on December 21, 2015, it finally worked: a booster flew back and landed upright, whole and reusable. In 2017, SpaceX did the thing it had been building toward, launching a booster that had already flown once. Unit 8

| Lesson 29

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

WIKIPEDIA .COM

DID YOU KNOW?

• SpaceX’s first rocket, the Falcon 1, failed its first three launches. The company had money for only one more attempt, and the fourth launch, on September 28, 2008, finally reached orbit and saved the company. • During the hardest months, SpaceX employees sometimes

Unit 8

| Lesson 29

WIKIPEDIA .COM

STOP & TH I N K How did reusing its rockets help SpaceX launch far more often than competitors who threw theirs away?

That changes the entire money picture. A rocket is one of the most expensive machines humans build. If you use it once and destroy it, that gigantic cost is gone forever, paid again for every launch. But if you can land it and fly it again, the same enormous asset is spread across many flights, and the cost of each launch drops dramatically. By late 2025, SpaceX boosters had landed and been reused hundreds of times, with a single booster flying more than thirty times. The company, still privately owned, became the busiest launch company in the world, largely because reusing its rockets made each flight so much cheaper. The company that almost died for lack of one more rocket survived by refusing to throw its rockets away.

slept at the workshop, working almost nonstop to fix the rocket between launches. • By late 2025, SpaceX had landed boosters hundreds of times, and one booster had flown more than thirty separate missions, the same costly asset earning its keep over and over.

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

207

Unit

8 29

Assets & Ownership

The Lesson

THE LESSON

An asset you can use again and again is worth far more than one you use once. This whole book has shown a pattern: a great asset costs a lot to build, then earns money for a long time afterward. Think of a railroad or a fleet of ships. SpaceX reveals the flip side of that idea in the most dramatic way possible. For decades, the rocket industry built one of the most expensive machines on earth and then destroyed it after a single use. The huge cost had to be paid again, in full, for every single launch. Nothing kept earning money for the long term because nothing survived. SpaceX’s breakthrough was making the rocket reusable. Suddenly the gigantic investment of building a booster could be spread across many flights instead of thrown away on one. That is exactly why owning a reusable asset is so powerful: the more times you use it, the cheaper each use becomes, and the more the original

WIKIPEDIA .COM

cost pays off. It is the same reason a family that buys a sturdy bicycle and rides it for years gets far more value than one that buys a new bike for every trip and throws it away. The lesson reaches well beyond rockets. Whenever you can turn a one-time cost into an asset you use again and again, you have found one of the most powerful ideas in all of business.

Build it to last, or build it cheap? TAKE IT TO THE CLASS

208

Here is the debate. To make a rocket reusable, SpaceX had to spend years and a fortune engineering it to survive the trip back and land safely, which made each rocket more expensive and harder to build. A competitor might argue it is smarter to build cheap, simple rockets and just accept losing each one. Who has the better strategy? Argue both sides. One side says a reusable asset wins in the long run, because spreading the cost over many flights eventually makes each launch far cheaper. The other side says building something that fancy and durable is risky and expensive up front, and might never pay off if it does not get used enough. As you argue, notice this is the same own-it-for-the-long-haul bet that Union Pacific and Maersk made, just pointed at the sky.

Unit 8

| Lesson 29

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

The Work Check your understanding 1. What happened on the first three launches of the Falcon 1, and why was the fourth launch so important? 2. What did SpaceX first manage to do on December 21, 2015? 3. About how many times had a single SpaceX booster flown by late 2025?

Think harder 1. Explain why using a rocket only once made space launches so extremely expensive. 2. How does reusing the same rocket change the cost of each launch over time?

Try it yourself

BUSINESS RULE

Think of something your family could either buy once and reuse for years, or keep buying cheaply and throwing away. Describe both options, and explain which one you think is the smarter long-term choice and why.

Unit 8

3. SpaceX nearly went out of business after three failed rockets. Why might that near-failure have made the company more determined to stop wasting rockets?

| Lesson 29

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

“An asset you can use again and again is worth far more than one you use once.”

209

Unit

8 30

WORDS TO KNOW MEET THESE BEFORE YOU READ

• Own - to fully possess something after paying for it, making it your asset.

Assets & Ownership

OWN IT OR RENT IT? The choice every business has to make

• Rent (lease) - to pay regularly to use something that someone else owns. • Flexibility - the freedom to change what you do as your needs change. • Tradeoff - giving up one good thing to gain another.

Watch for these words as you read. After three giant assets, this lesson brings the idea home to a choice every business owner, even the smallest, has to make.

R E A D TH E S T ORY A young baker is about to open her shop, and she has barely enough money. Should she pour it all into buying her own building and oven, or rent them and keep her cash free? It turns out she is facing the very same question that railroads, shipping giants, and rocket companies all had to answer.

he last three lessons were about giant assets: a railroad, a fleet of ships, and a reusable rocket, owned by huge companies. But the idea of owning an asset is just as real for the smallest business. Imagine a young baker named Sofia who is opening a small bakery. She faces two big decisions that every business owner faces, and they both come down to a single question: should she own it, or rent it?

STO P & TH I NK Why might a brand-new business owner like Sofia not be able to simply buy everything she needs?

210

First, the building. Sofia could buy a small shop, which would cost a huge amount of money up front, probably more than she has, requiring a big loan. Or she could rent a shop, paying a smaller amount every month to a landlord who owns the building. Second, her equipment. A large professional oven is expensive. She could buy one and own it outright, or she could lease it, making smaller monthly payments to use an oven someone else owns. Unit 8

| Lesson 30

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

Unit 8

| Lesson 30

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

211

Unit

8 30

STO P & TH I NK

Owning has real advantages. If Sofia buys her oven, it becomes her asset. Once she finishes paying for the oven, she owns it and no longer has loan or lease payments. She will still have operating, maintenance, repair, insurance, and replacement costs. She can change it however she likes, and one day she could even sell it. Owning the building would be even bigger: instead of paying rent forever, she would slowly build up something valuable that is hers, the way you saw great assets earn for their owners over many years. But renting has real advantages too. Renting costs far less up front, which matters enormously when you are just starting and short on cash. If Sofia rents, she does not need a giant loan, and she keeps her money free for other needs. Renting is also flexible. If her bakery grows and she needs a bigger space, she can simply move when the lease ends, instead of being stuck with a building she owns. And if her fancy oven breaks, the company she leases it from may handle the repair.

Why might renting actually be the smarter choice for a brand-new business, even though you never own anything?

Assets & Ownership

212

Unit 8

| Lesson 30

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

Notice how this connects to the giant assets in this unit. Union Pacific, Maersk, and SpaceX all chose to own their great assets, because they were certain those assets would be used heavily for a very long time, and the payoff of owning was enormous. Sofia faces the very same choice at her own small scale. Whether you are running a bakery or launching rockets, deciding what to own and what to rent is one of the most important judgments in business.

DID YOU KNOW?

• Owning something expensive usually costs more up front but less over many years. Renting costs less up front but can cost more in the long run, the classic tradeoff every business weighs. • When you rent or lease equipment, the company you rent from often

Unit 8

| Lesson 30

STOP & TH I N K How is Sofia’s choice about her oven really the same choice Union Pacific and SpaceX made about their assets?

So which is better? The honest answer is that it depends, and learning to weigh the tradeoff is a real business skill. Owning is usually better when you are sure you will use something for a long time and you can afford the upfront cost. Renting is usually better when you are short on cash, when you are not sure how long you will need something, or when the thing might soon be out of date and you will want to upgrade.

handles repairs, which can save a small business a lot of worry and money. • Even huge companies rent some things and own others. The skill is not always owning or always renting, but knowing which choice fits each situation.

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

213

Unit

8 30

Assets & Ownership

THE LESSON Own what you will use for a long time. Rent what you might outgrow. Every business, from a tiny bakery to a giant railroad, must decide what to own and what to rent. Owning something means paying a large cost up front, but then it is yours: it becomes an asset, it keeps working for you with no more payments once it is paid off, and you can change or sell it. Renting, also called leasing, means paying a smaller amount regularly to use something someone else owns. You never own it, but you spend far less up front and you stay flexible. There is no single right answer, only a tradeoff to weigh. Owning tends to win when you are confident you will use the thing for a long time and you can handle the big upfront cost, because over many years, owning is usually cheaper than renting forever, and you end up with a valuable asset. Renting tends to win when cash is tight, when your

needs might change, or when the thing could soon become outdated. The giant companies in this unit owned their assets because they were sure those assets would earn for decades. A brand-new bakery might wisely rent at first, staying flexible until it knows what it really needs. Learning to judge which situation you are in is one of the most valuable skills a business owner can have.

Should Sofia buy the building? TAKE IT TO THE CLASS

214

Here is the debate, and it is a real one that business owners argue about constantly. Sofia’s bakery is brand new. Should she take out a big loan to buy her own shop, or rent a shop for now and keep her cash free? Make the strongest case you can for each choice. Argue both sides. The “buy” side says rent is money gone forever, while buying builds something valuable that is hers, and one day she will have no payments at all. The “rent” side says a brand-new bakery cannot afford a giant loan, needs flexibility in case it grows or struggles, and should not gamble everything on owning too soon. As you argue, think about what you would need to know about Sofia’s future to give her good advice. The right answer truly depends on her situation.

Unit 8

| Lesson 30

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

The Work Check your understanding 1. What two own-or-rent decisions does Sofia face in opening her bakery? 2. Name one big advantage of owning her oven and one big advantage of renting it. 3. When is owning usually the better choice, and when is renting?

Think harder 1. Explain why renting can be the smarter choice for a business that is brand new or short on cash. 2. Why does owning tend to win when you are sure you will use something for a very long time?

Try it yourself

BUSINESS RULE

Think of something your family owns and something your family rents or subscribes to. For each one, explain why owning or renting makes sense for that particular thing.

Unit 8

3. How is Sofia’s choice about her oven the same kind of decision Union Pacific made about its railroad?

| Lesson 30

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

“Own what you will use for a long time. Rent what you might outgrow.”

215

End of Unit 8 CHAPTER SUMMARY

Assets and Ownership A look back at the valuable things businesses own, and why they matter.

This unit was about assets, the valuable things a business owns that earn money over time. A railroad built once earns for a century. A fleet of ships carries the world’s goods. A reusable rocket flies again instead of being thrown away. And every business, large or small, has to decide what to own and what to rent.

Union Pacific

A railroad built by hand in the 1860s still earns money today. A great asset is expensive once, then earns for a very long time.

Maersk

Giant ships and a plain metal box carry nearly a fifth of the world’s goods. Owning the thing that carries everything is a powerful position.

SpaceX

Rockets used to be thrown away after one flight. SpaceX learned to land and reuse them. An asset you use again and again is worth far more.

Own or Rent

From a railroad to a bakery oven, every business must choose: own it, or rent it? Own what you’ll use for a long time; rent what you might outgrow.

THE BIG QUESTION

Why is owning the right thing so powerful in business?

A great asset is expensive to build or buy once, then earns money for years afterward, and it is hard for competitors to copy. That is why owning the right thing, a railroad, a ship, a reusable rocket, gives a business lasting power. But owning is not always best. Sometimes renting is smarter, when cash is tight or your needs might soon change.

THE RULES YOU COLLECTED 1. A great asset is

expensive to build once, then earns for a very long time.

216

2. Owning the

thing that carries everything is a powerful position.

End of Unit 8

3. An asset you can use

again and again is worth far more than one you use once.

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

4. Own what you will

use for a long time. Rent what you might outgrow.

BRING IT TOGETHER

Put It All Together Three ways to prove you really own these ideas. 1. Match The Idea Draw a line from each situation on the left to the unit idea on the right that fits it best. A railroad built long ago still collects money today. A company owns the ships that carry the world’s goods. A rocket lands and flies again instead of being scrapped. A new bakery rents its oven instead of buying it.

Expensive once, earns for years Own what carries everything Reuse beats single use Rent what you might outgrow

2. Key Words Check Fill in each blank with the right word: asset, reusable, tradeoff. Anything a business owns that helps it make money is an

Able to be used more than once instead of thrown away is Giving up one good thing to gain another is a

. .

3. Your Turn: Nate’s Printing Business

The Situation Nate is starting a small printing business. He needs a big, expensive printer and a place to work. He could buy the printer or rent it, and buy a small shop or rent one. Help Nate decide what to own and what to rent. Answer in your own words: a. Nate will use the printer every day for years. Should he own it or rent it? Why? b. Nate isn’t sure how fast he will grow. How does that affect whether he should buy or rent his shop? c. What is the main tradeoff between owning something and renting it?

End of Unit 8

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

217

End of Unit 8 PRACTICAL FORM

Meet the Form: The Lease and Asset List The form that sorts out what a business owns and what it rents.

Every business has to decide what to own and what to rent, and then keep track of both. A lease is an agreement to rent something, like a workspace. An asset list is a record of what the business owns outright. Together they show what a business controls, and how. Here is one for Nate’s printing business.

LEASE & ASSET LIST

Rented: small shop, $200 a month, 12-month lease Workspace

Owned: will be used every day for years Printer

Owned: bought once, used constantly Work table and tools

Delivery van

WHAT EACH LINE IS FOR Lease The agreement to rent something, with the rent and how long it lasts. Owned assets Things the business buys and keeps, that earn or save money for years. Rented items Things used only sometimes, or that might be outgrown, where renting is smarter.

WHY IT MATTERS Notice the logic in Nate’s choices. He owns the printer because he will use it every day for years, which is exactly when owning pays off, just like Union Pacific owning its railroad. He rents the shop and the van because his needs might change, and renting keeps him flexible. The same thinking guides a giant shipping company and a one-person print shop: own what you will use for the long haul, rent what you might outgrow.

218

End of Unit 8

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

PRACTICAL FORM

Your Turn: Own It or Rent It? Decide what your business should own and rent. Think of a small business you could run. List the main things it would need, then decide for each one whether you would own it or rent it, and why. There is no single right answer, only smart tradeoffs.

First, Plan It Out What is your business, and what are the most expensive things it needs? Which of those will you use constantly, and which only once in a while?

Now Sort Yours Out

Own or Rent?

Why

Thing my business needs

Last Question Look at your choices. What is the rule you used to decide when to own and when to rent?

End of Unit 8

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

219

Unit

Putting It All Together

THE WHOLE STORY:

AMERICAN EXPRESS

WORDS TO KNOW MEET THESE BEFORE YOU READ

• Network - a large, connected group, such as all the people and businesses that use a company’s cards.

One company, every idea in this book

• Adapt - to change in response to a changing world, which keeps a business alive. • Reinvent - to change a business so completely that it becomes something new. • Asset - anything a business owns that helps it make money.

Watch for these words as you read. This final story is special: see how many ideas from the whole book you can spot inside one company.

STO P & TH I NK American Express began as a delivery company. Why would the trust it earned hauling gold matter long after it stopped hauling freight?

220

R E A D T H E S T ORY It began by hauling crates of gold across the country on the railroads, and it could have ended there: in 1918 the company was thrown out of the very delivery business it was founded on. Instead, the company that started with gold and wagons reinvented itself again and again, until it moved trillions of dollars a year, by quietly using every single idea in this book.

n 1850, three rival delivery businessmen in New York, Henry Wells, William Fargo, and John Butterfield, did something you read about in the unit on how businesses are built: they stopped competing and combined into one company. They called it American Express, and at the start it had nothing to do with money or cards. It was a delivery company. Using the new railroads, it carried packages, important documents, and valuable cargo like gold and cash across long distances, quickly and safely. From the very beginning, the company’s real product was trust, exactly like the service businesses you studied. When Unit 9

| Lesson 31

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

P OSTALMUSEUM.SI.EDU

Henry Wells, William Fargo, and John Butterfield

WIKIPEDIA .COM

BANKOFGEORGIA .GE

P OSTALMUSEUM.SI.EDU

Unit 9

| Lesson 31

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

221

Unit

Putting It All Together

P OSTALMUSEUM.SI.EDU

you handed American Express a crate of gold to deliver, you were buying a promise that it would arrive safely. The company built its whole reputation on being reliable with people’s most precious things. That trust, earned hauling freight, would turn out to be the most valuable thing the company owned, worth far more than any wagon or office.

As the company carried money around the country, its leaders noticed a problem people had, the kind of everyday problem that becomes a business. Sending cash through the mail was dangerous, and traveling with lots of money was risky. So American Express invented new products to solve it. First came the money order in 1882, a safer way to send money. Then, in 1891, an employee named Marcellus Berry created the Travelers Cheque, a kind of money that travelers could use far from home but that was protected if it was lost or stolen. P OSTALMUSEUM.SI.EDU

222

Unit 9

| Lesson 31

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

WIKIPEDIA .COM P OSTALMUSEUM.SI.EDU

Notice what happened. The company used the trust and the network it had built as a delivery business to launch something completely new. It was changing what it sold while keeping the reputation that made customers believe in it. This is the opposite of the mistake that killed Sears. Where Sears refused to change and slowly died, American Express kept adapting, again and again, as the world changed around it.

STOP & TH I N K Sears refused to change and died. How was American Express doing the opposite here?

Then came the biggest change of all. After the First World War, the United States government took over the express delivery industry, and in 1918 American Express was forced out of the very business

P OSTALMUSEUM.SI.EDU

Unit 9

| Lesson 31

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

223

Unit

Putting It All Together

it had been founded on. Imagine that: the company lost its original purpose entirely. But because it had already built trusted financial products, it survived by becoming something new. It let go of delivery and reinvented itself as a travel and financial company. A business that could have died instead transformed. In 1958, American Express made its most famous move. It introduced a charge card, a single card a person could use to pay at many different places, then settle the whole bill at the end of the month. The idea took off astonishingly fast. The company used the same strengths it always had: a trusted name and a wide network, now of stores and restaurants that accepted the card instead of railway routes. It also positioned the card as something special and premium, building a brand the way you saw companies do in the unit on getting customers.

P OSTALMUSEUM.SI.EDU

STO P & TH I NK

Here is the deepest idea of all, the one that ties the whole book together. American Express’s real treasure today is its network: the millions of customers who carry its cards and the millions of businesses that accept them. That network is its great asset, like a railroad or a reusable rocket, because it is enormously valuable and very hard for a competitor to copy. A new company cannot simply

Why is American Express’s network of cardholders and stores like the great assets you studied in the unit on ownership?

P OSTALMUSEUM.SI.EDU

224

Unit 9

| Lesson 31

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

WIKIPEDIA .COM

invent millions of cardholders and accepting stores overnight. The network protects American Express the way a moat protects a castle.

DID YOU KNOW?

• American Express was founded on March 18, 1850, as a delivery company. It did not issue its famous charge card until 1958, more than a hundred years later. • In 1918 the company was pushed out of the delivery business it was founded on, yet it survived

Unit 9

| Lesson 31

STOP & TH I N K How did combining many different ideas, rather than just one, keep American Express alive for over 170 years?

Today American Express is a global payments company, a public corporation traded on the stock market under the symbol AXP, operating in more than 130 countries. The delivery company that carried gold by rail in 1850 now moves trillions of dollars through its network every year. Across more than 170 years, it survived by doing everything this book has taught: earning trust, solving real problems, building a brand, adapting when its world changed, and owning an asset no one could copy. That is not one idea. That is all of them, woven together over a very long time.

by reinventing itself around the financial products it had already built. • Today the company that once hauled gold by railway moves trillions of dollars a year through its card network, operating in more than 130 countries.

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

225

Unit

Putting It All Together

THE LESSON A great business is not one idea. It is many ideas, combined and renewed over time. Look back at how much of this book lives inside one company. American Express began as a service business built on trust, like the companies in Unit 3. It combined three businesses into one, an ownership-structure idea from Unit 5. It spotted everyday problems and invented products to solve them, the very heart of Unit 1. It built a premium brand and got customers, like Unit 6. It adapted instead of dying when its world changed, a lesson Sears failed to learn in Unit 7. And its greatest treasure is a hard-to-copy network asset, just like the railroad and the reusable rocket of Unit 8. That is the real lesson of the whole book, and it is worth carrying with you. A successful business is almost never about a single clever idea. It is about weaving many ideas together, and then

WIKIPEDIA .COM

doing it again and again as the years pass and the world changes. The company that started by hauling gold on trains is now a payments giant, because it never stopped combining what it knew with what the world needed next. Every concept you have studied this year is a thread. Real businesses, like American Express, are what you get when someone weaves those threads together, patiently, over a very long time.

What will you build? TAKE IT TO THE CLASS

226

Here is the final discussion, and it points forward instead of back. You have spent this book studying other people’s businesses. Now think about your own future. If you started a business someday, which of the ideas in this book do you think would matter most for it, and which would be hardest to get right? Talk it through as a class. There is no wrong answer, because different businesses lean on different ideas. A repair shop might live or die on trust and reliability. A new invention might depend on getting the product right and building a brand. A delivery service might be all about owning the right assets. As you discuss, notice that you now have a whole toolkit of ideas to think with, the same toolkit real business owners use every day. That toolkit, more than any single fact, is what you are taking with you.

Unit 9

| Lesson 31

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

The Work Check your understanding 1. What kind of company was American Express when it began in 1850? 2. What forced American Express out of its original delivery business in 1918, and what did it do instead? 3. What is American Express’s most valuable asset today, and why is it hard to copy?

Think harder 1. Choose any three ideas from earlier units and point to exactly where each one appears in the American Express story. 2. Explain how American Express did the opposite of the mistake that killed Sears.

Try it yourself

BUSINESS RULE

Pick any business you know well, a local shop, a famous company, anything. In a short paragraph, point out at least three different ideas from this book that you can see at work in that one business.

Unit 9

3. Why is the company’s network of cardholders and stores like the great assets from the unit on ownership?

| Lesson 31

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

“A great business is not one idea. It is many ideas, combined and renewed over time.”

227

End of Unit 9 CHAPTER SUMMARY

Putting It All Together A look back at one company that used every idea in the book.

This final unit told one company’s whole story, American Express, and showed every idea from the book living inside it. It began as a delivery company built on trust, combined rivals into one business, invented products to solve real problems, built a premium brand, adapted instead of dying, and today its greatest asset is a network no one can copy.

THE BIG QUESTION

What does it really take to build a business that lasts?

Not one clever idea, but many ideas woven together and renewed over time. American Express earned trust, solved real problems, built a brand, adapted when its world changed, and came to own an asset no one could copy. A business that lasts keeps combining what it already knows with what the world newly needs.

Trust (Unit 3)

It began carrying gold by rail. Its real product was always trust, the same idea behind every service business.

Combining (Unit 5)

Three rival delivery businesses combined into one company, exactly the kind of structure choice this book studied.

Brand (Unit 6)

It built a premium card people felt proud to carry, turning a service into a brand.

Adapting (Unit 7)

Forced out of the delivery business it was founded on, it reinvented itself instead of dying, the opposite of Sears.

Asset (Unit 8)

Its real treasure today is a network of cardholders and stores that no rival can copy.

THE BIG IDEAS YOU’RE TAKING WITH YOU 1. A business begins

the moment someone is willing to pay for what you offer.

228

2. In a service

business, the promise is the product.

3. A strong

End of Unit 9

brand can be worth more than the product itself.

4. No company

is too big to fail. The ones that last keep adapting.

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

5. A great business

is not one idea. It is many ideas, combined and renewed over time.

BRING IT TOGETHER

Put It All Together Pull the whole book into one last challenge. 1. Match The Idea Draw a line from each situation on the left to the unit idea on the right that fits it best. Carrying gold safely, keeping every promise. Three rivals becoming a single company. A card people are proud to carry. Reinventing itself when forced out of delivery.

A service is a promise (Unit 3) Combining to build (Unit 5) A brand gets customers (Unit 6) Adapt or die (Unit 7)

2. Key Words Check Fill in each blank with the right word: network, reinvent, asset. A large, connected group, like all the people and businesses that use a company’s cards, is a To change a business so completely that it becomes something new is to Anything a business owns that helps it make money is an

. .

3. Your Turn: Jack Designs A Business

The Situation This is your moment. Jack is going to design a business of his own using everything from the whole book, and so are you. Start by thinking it through here. On the next page, the one-page business plan will pull all of your ideas together into a single sheet. Answer in your own words: a. What will your business do, and what one problem does it solve? b. Who are your customers, and what is the one idea you want them to remember? c. What will you own, and how will you make your money?

End of Unit 9

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

229

End of Unit 9 PRACTICAL FORM

Meet the Form: The One-Page Business Plan The form that pulls the entire book onto a single sheet.

This is the last and biggest form, and it gathers nearly every idea from the whole book onto one page. A business plan is a short description of an entire business: what it does, who it serves, how it makes money, and where it is going. Many founders use a business plan before launching to test how the pieces fit together. They revise it as they learn more about customers, costs, competition, and what is or is not working.

ONE-PAGE BUSINESS PLAN

WHAT EACH LINE IS FOR Problem & customers

The business

Sam’s Repair Workshop, a service that fixes bikes and small machines

The problem we solve

People own things that break and want a trusted place to fix them

From Unit 1: every business starts with a real problem that real people will pay to solve.

Our customers

Families and neighbors who want repairs done right

Our one clear idea

The most trustworthy, on-time repair shop around

How we make money

A fair price per repair, set above the cost of parts and time

Staying alive

Keep quality high, keep customers loyal, add skills as needs change

What we own vs rent

Own the tools; rent the workshop space at first

Who runs it

Start self-employed, then hire a helper as the work grows

From Unit 6: own one clear idea in the customer’s mind. Money & staying alive From Units 2 and 7: charge above your costs, and keep adapting to survive. Own vs rent, who runs it From Units 8 and 4: own what lasts, and choose your own path.

WHY IT MATTERS Look closely and you will see almost the whole book on this single page: the problem, the customers, the brand, the money, the assets, and how it all fits together. That is the point of a business plan. It forces you to think through every piece at once. A founder who can fill this page in thoughtfully has learned to think like a business owner, and that is exactly what this book set out to teach.

230

End of Unit 9

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

PRACTICAL FORM

Your Turn: Design Your Own Business The whole book, on one page, in your hands. This is the final challenge of the book. Using everything you have learned, design a business of your own and write its one-page plan. There is no wrong answer, only a plan you can defend. Take your time, and make it yours.

First, Plan It Out In one sentence, what is your business and what problem does it solve? What is the one clear idea you want customers to remember about it?

Now Write Your Plan ONE-PAGE BUSINESS PLAN The business The problem we solve Our customers Our one clear idea

How we make money Staying alive What we own vs rent Who runs it

Last Question Look back at your plan. Name three different ideas from this book that you can see at work in the business you just designed.

End of Unit 9

| Lighthouse B U S I N E S S S M A RTS

231

www.lighthousecurriculum.com

Mastering Bright Ideas ™

Lighthouse Business Smarts • 718.285.7100 • info@lighthousecurriculum.com For more information visit www.lighthousecurriculum.com