International Research Journal of Engineering and Technology (IRJET) e ISSN: 2395 0056
Volume: 09 Issue: 06 | Jun 2022 www.irjet.net p ISSN: 2395 0072
![]()
International Research Journal of Engineering and Technology (IRJET) e ISSN: 2395 0056
Volume: 09 Issue: 06 | Jun 2022 www.irjet.net p ISSN: 2395 0072
Ar. Vatsalya Kaushal1 , Ar. Saurabh Verma2
11st Year, MURP, Faculty of Architecture & Planning, AKTU, Lucknow, Uttar Pradesh 226007 (India)
2Assistant Professor, Faculty of Architecture & Planning, AKTU, Lucknow, Uttar Pradesh 226007 (India) ***
Abstract Fuel shifting of vehicles in India is the idea or initiative or need that insists on switching the dependency on fossil /conventional fuels for transportation into an appropriate alternative that may have the potential to become the primary fuel of almost all vehicles of Road Transport from passenger to commercial segment. Here, the scenario and background for this idea are considered, followed by selective alternatives of conventional fuel and their comparison on various parameters, including the government's interest and people towards adopting a suitable option. Then, it results in the most appropriate fuel that can swap itself from conventional fuels. With all due consideration and analysis, electric energy is the most suitable fuel which can be shifted from traditional fuels in transportation systems.
Key Words: IndiaElectricVehicle(EV)Policy,FuelChange,SustainablefuelforTransport,BestFuelforFuture,alternative fuelvehicle
Theshiftingoffuelisthecaseof'change'whichshowsthechangingneedsanddemandsforbothEnvironmentandPeopleto changethefuelforthetransportationsystemswithtimeandpopulationandUrbangrowthofIndiancities.
The change in vehicles' fuel significantly impacts existing transportation systems because people, technology and infrastructure,andeconomyandpoliciesareadaptedaccordinglytoconventionalfuels.So,shiftingfuelisamacrosubjectand hashighconsequencesontheabovementioneddomains.Therefore,focusingprimarilyonthetopic'fuel'wouldgetchanged,and theenginetopullthedependentfieldsaccordingly.
Thisresearchaimstofindoutthemostappropriate'fuelofthefutureâfortransportationinIndia.Itprovesitselfatparover theotherfuelofthefuture,simultaneouslymaintainingtheadvantagesofconventionalfuels.
Here,thesubjectofshiftingoffuelisdiscussed,followedbyitsneed,withdueconsiderationofthescenarioofIndia.Then,list outthepotentialalternatefuelsthatcanreplacefossilfuelsandthoroughlydiscusstheirscopeandlimitations.Thencompare thesefuelsonexclusivelyselectedparametersfortheresearchandfinallyfindoutthemostsuitableenergythatcanbeswitched fromconventionalfuels.
Everyphysical mechanicalmachinerequiressomeenergytowork.Ourhumanbodyneedsfoodthatisultimatelyaraw sourceofenergythatourbodyprocessesandconvertsintoGlucoseorEnergyintheformofProcessedenergythatourbody uses.Hereinmechanicalmachines,theneedisforprocessedenergyintheformoffuelaspresent daymachinesarenotdesigned toconvertorprocesstherawsourceofenergyfromwheretheycangetProcessedpower.
Thesemachinesareofvariouscharacteristicsandaredesignedformultiplepurposes.Similarly,theMachinesmeantas transportareutilizedtoshiftpeopleorgoodsfromoneplacetoanother.Likeanyothermachine,thesetransportationmachines also need fuel to run; ultimately, the energy source of these machines creates the bigger picture because the need for transportationisincreasingdaybydayinthepresentwayofliving.
Earlier,thesemachinesgettherawfuellikecoalandultimatelyconvertitintoenergytoheat,whichproducessteamthat generatesthepressureandtheengineruns.Thingshadchangedfromtheindustrialeraandsoonaftertheinventionofinternal combustionengines(ICE)commercially.Therewasaneedforliquidfuel,soultimately,theshiftingoffuelhappenedfromSolid fueltoliquidfuel,i.e.,coaltopetroleum.Thenseveraltypesofresearchoccurred,whichledtobringingthefuelintheformofgas thatisNaturalgasanditsstorage.
International Research Journal of Engineering and Technology (IRJET) e ISSN: 2395 0056
Volume: 09 Issue: 06 | Jun 2022 www.irjet.net p ISSN: 2395 0072
TheconventionalformsoftransportfuelslikePetroleum/NaturalGashavebeenprovidedformorethanfivedecadesor maybemoreandarealsobeingusedtoday.Soonafter,Researchersandenvironmentalistsanalyzedthatduetoemissionsfrom thesefuels,thereisasignificantriseinGlobalWarming(Romm,2005),becauseofthegenerationofgreenhousegases(WOODS, 2020).Moreover,thesefuelsarenon renewablesourcesofenergy.Therefore,theneedaroseagaintochangethepowerof transportation.
InIndia,somepeoplestilluseancienttransportationlikeBullockCarts,HorseCarts,andothers.Similarlywithfuel,inIndia, everytypeoffuelisusedinsomeorotherwayfortransportationsystems.Here,whatismeantbythisisthatwhatevershift happensinvehicles'fuel,somepeoplewillstillusethepredecessorfuelorboth.Itisevidentfromthesocio culturalbehaviorof Indiansocietiesthatbringingouta'change'anditsadoptioninIndiaisnotasimpletask.
Presently,theprimaryfueldominatinginIndiaisPetrolorDieselandCompressedNaturalGas(CNG)astransportationfuels inUrbancontextsandPetrolandDieselinRuralIndia.CNGstillisnotacharminRuralIndiabecausethathadcomelater.Thisis whathappenswhena'changehappens.'Somemaychange,somemightnotchange.
Soonafterdecades,again,thesamesituationarousedtoshift(OâDELL,2022)fromFossilfuelstogreenfuelslikeElectricor HydrogenorevenLiquifiedNaturalGas(LNG)incommercialapplicationsorPetrolmixedwithEthanolorBio ethanolorany HybridCombination.
Anotherprimarytaskistoprovideinfrastructuretofacilitateandadopttheshiftinfuelwhichisagainatedioustask.Thisis alsowhytheobjectiveofFuelshiftingofvehicleswonâtgetfullyimplementedineverycornerofIndia.
(Alternative Fuels and Advanced Vehicles, 2022)
Itisaformofwidelyavailableenergyandcanbestoredinbatteries.Thesebatteriesarethuscanberechargedorswappedto âre fuelâthevehicles.TherearetwosignificantconcernswithElectricenergyasanoptionoffuel.Thefirstisthecapacityof batteries,whichdeterminesthetimeRangeforvehiclestoRun.Thesecondisthemethodbywhichthatelectricityisproduced.
Electricenergyistheonlyenergyavailableatbestincomparisonwithotherfuels,sosomewhatthefuelshiftingofvehicles maygetabetterextentifelectricenergyisadopted.
Theone timerumdistancewhenthevehicleisrechargedtoitstotalcapacitypushestheusersorbuyerstoswitchtoelectric cars.Limitedbatterycapacitiesgivealittleone timerundistance,thuscreatingfearordisabilityforthevehicletocoverlong distanceswithoutrecharging.Also,thetimeneedstorechargethebatterymakesitmorenuisance.Presently,itjusttakesafew secondsforthevehicletogetre fuel;however,inthecaseofbatteryrestoring,ittakeshalfanhouroronehourormoretogetit fullyrecharged.
Here, what matters is the loss of time in recharging the vehicles. Research is happening to develop mast methods of recharging,butstill,itiswaybehindthespeedofre fuelingthecars.Somehowthecharginginfrastructurecanbecreatedat everycorner,buttoextendthebatterycapacitiesandreductionintimeofrechargingissolelydependentontheextentof researchanddevelopingnewtechnologies.
Anotherprimaryconcernisthesourceofelectricenergytorechargethebatteries.Ifrenewablesourcesofenergyproduce electricalpower,thenitisfeasibleforpeopleandtheEnvironmentandjustifiestheobjectiveofshiftingfuel.However,ifNon renewablesourcesmaketheelectricalpower,thentherewouldbenomeaninglefttochangefromconventional(Logan,Nelson, &Hastings,2020)petroleumfuels.
Thiscategoryoffuelsismainlyproducedasaby productofAgricultural(Zhang,2015)wasteorBio wasteHumanwaste,or preciselyanybiodegradablewaste.Thereisalwaysanaturalbenefitinthesetypesofwaste;i.e.,theycontaincarbonelement,a fuelfollowedbyoxygen,thepromoterofburning,whichiswidelyavailable.Soduetothisexothermicchemicalreaction,thereis alwaysareleaseofenergy/heatwhichcanbeutilizedasfuelforvehicularneeds.
2022, IRJET | Impact Factor value: 7.529 | ISO 9001:2008 Certified Journal
International Research Journal of Engineering and Technology (IRJET) e ISSN: 2395 0056
Volume: 09 Issue: 06 | Jun 2022 www.irjet.net p ISSN: 2395 0072
Thisisthemostsuitablefuelasitisaâwasteconsumerâ,butontheotherside,itcreatespollutionsimilarlytootherpetroleum fuelsthatarenotdesirableinthepresentcontext.
Otherthanthat,itmaybeusedasanadditivetoPetrolanddecreasetheconsumptionofrawPetrol,aNon renewablesource; italsogeneratesrevenueemploymentandeatswasteasahealthydiet.
LiquifiedNaturalGas(LNG)isanon pollutingnaturalgas;however,itisanon renewablesourceofenergy.Itisbetterthan Compressed Natural Gas (CNG) because it provides a more extended range once re filled, which significantly benefits commercialapplications.Italsocreateslesspollutionandmoremileage,sorunningcostsarearelativelyloweconomicbenefit.
ThisLNGissuitableasanalternativefuel,butstill,itdoesnotfulfillallthecriteriaofFuturedemand,asitisanon renewable sourceofenergy.
Hydrogenisaverywell testednon pollutingfuelbecause,ultimately,thesmokefromvehiclesisnothingbutwatervapor. ThoughHydrogen(Mansuri,Saxena,&Mishra,2021)ismuchbetterthanallotheroptions,ithasasignificantflaw:theextraction ofcommercialHydrogenisquiteanexpensiveprocess.Itdoesprovetobeextravagantfortheordinarypersontobuyandfillitin vehicles.
Somehow, if researchers evolve and can produce commercial hydrogen is feasible rates, then it would be a Gem. Any alternativefuelmustbeselectedtogetaâshiftâinvehiclesâfueluntilthen.
The demand for future fuel depends upon several parameters that power needs to qualify. For instance, to list down parameters,itisessentialtofigureouttheprobabledemandsofthefuturethatenergymustfulfill.Fuelforfutureneedstobe likegreenfuel,thevitalneed,thenreadilyavailabletotheuserendinlargeamounts,easytoproduceinlargequantitiesfor unlimitedtime,underthepurchasablelimitforanordinaryperson,abletogeneraterevenueforserviceproviders,abilitytorun everykindofvehicleswhetherinpassengersegmentorlogistics.
Onthisbasis,theparameterscanbederivedforcomparativeanalysisforvariousfuels,like:
⢠Eco friendly
⢠Convenient
⢠Renewable
⢠Cost effective/feasible
⢠FinancialGenerator
⢠Suitableforallvehicles
⢠Adequateforprolongeduse
⢠Technologyavailable
⢠GovernmentâsInterest
⢠PeopleâsInterest
Governmentplaysacrucialroleinmakingfinaldecisionsorpoliciesthatlicenseaparticularfuelanditsvehiclestolegally run onstreets.ThegovernmentofIndiahasacceptedmultipleenterprisestopromotethemanufacturingandrelinquishmentof electriccarsinIndia.ElectriccarshavebegunweavingtheIndianmarketwithencouragementfromthegovernmentside.
However,thedreamofelectricmobilityinIndiawonâtbecomearealityunlessthecharginginfrastructureforelectricvehicles fulfillsitsadequacy.
2022, IRJET | Impact Factor value: 7.529 | ISO 9001:2008 Certified Journal
International Research Journal of Engineering and Technology (IRJET) e ISSN: 2395 0056
TheMinistryofPowerhasmadespecificlawsandguidelinestolayoutcharginginfrastructureforelectricvehicles.The MinistryhasallottedthecentralNodalAgencytotheBureauofEnergyEfficiency(BEE)astheNationalbodyforguidingthe developmentandlayingofcharginginfrastructure.
2.5.1. Central government incentives to Electric Vehicle owners (Bureau of Energy Efficiency, 2022)
FasterAdoptionandManufacturingof(Hybrid&)ElectricVehiclesinIndia,(FAMEIndia)SchemePhaseII
2.5.2. National / State Electric Vehicle Policies and Regulations (Bureau of Energy Efficiency, 2022)
⢠RegulationsissuedbyMinistryofPower,GovernmentofIndia
⢠ChargingInfrastructureforElectricVehicles RevisedGuidelinesandStandardsOctober2019
⢠AmendmentintherevisedGuidelinesandStandardsforChargingInfrastructureforElectricVehiclesJune2020
⢠RegulationregardingdelicensingthesaleofelectricityatchargingstationsApril2018
⢠CentralElectricityAuthority(MeasuresrelatingtotheSafetyandElectricSupply)RegulationsJune2019
2.5.3 Regulations issued by other Ministries (Bureau of Energy Efficiency, 2022)
⢠GuidelinesissuedbytheMinistryofHousingandUrbanAffairs(MoHUA),2016
Apartfromthis,variousstatepoliciesonEVandincentivepoliciesonEVpushEVintotheIndianscenario.
2.6.
Choiceofpeopleishighlysignificantastheordinarypersonwouldbethelargestuser,simultaneouslywillhaveasubstantial impactonthemandtheirdailyrides,expenses,maintenance,andothers.Anotherconcernissocialacceptance.Noonecandare forcepeopletoacceptthefueltheydonâtwanttobuy.Also,participatoryplanningisamustmethodthatneedstobefollowed. ThisisstakeholdersâConsultation.
Chart 11: Pie chartshowingtheinterestofpeopletowardsaparticularfueltobeadoptedforfuturetransportsystems
Morethan50%weightage,evenhighestgoestoElectricenergyasthechoiceofappropriatefuelwhichcantakeplacethe conventionalfuels.
1 Source:Author; TofigureoutthechoiceofPeople,aPrimarysurveywascarriedoutthroughonlinesurveywithGoogleForms,where choice basedselectionisrecordedwhichpeoplecanselecttheirinterests.Limitationinthissurveywasimposedtorecordthedatafrom random100peopleirrespectiveofQualification/experience/technicalexpertise/region/caste/age/profession/etc.
Volume: 09 Issue: 06 | Jun 2022 www.irjet.net p ISSN: 2395 0072 Š 2022, IRJET | Impact Factor value: 7.529 | ISO 9001:2008 Certified Journal |
International Research Journal of Engineering and Technology (IRJET) e ISSN: 2395 0056
Volume: 09 Issue: 06 | Jun 2022 www.irjet.net p ISSN: 2395 0072
Thecostsaredifferentfordifferenttypesoffuels;comparingeachalternativefuelwithconventionalfuel,itcanbeconsidered aselectricvehiclesrunningcostisabout60%less(SHAH,2021)thantraditionalfossilfuels.Moreover,LiquifiedNaturalGas (LNG)costslessthanconventionalfuelslikePetrolorDieselbutisMoreExpensivethanCompressedNaturalGas(CNG).
Similarly, Bio fuels are sometimes cost free or negligible if in house production occurs or less than fossil fuels as transportationcostforBio fuelsisless.
Hydrogenproductionisexpensive,sotherunningcostisalmostdoublethepriceofpetroleumfuels.Withthiscomparison, Bio fuelsorElectricisaleftovereconomicaloptiontoreducefuelexpenses.Atthesametime,LNGforacommercialpurposeis alsosuitablebecauseitsrunningcostislessthanDiesel.However,cheaphydrogenisstillbehindintherace.
Thereare,ofcourse,specificparametersonwhichthefuelforthefutureneedstoqualify.However,amongthem,themost importantonetobeconsideredtomitigateEnvironmentalimpacts(Khurana,RaviKumar,&Sidhpuria,2019)orreducetheAir QualityIndex(AQI)ofUrbanCitiesorPreventtheozonedepletionanditsconsequencesistofollowtoadoptâGreenFuel.â
Here,exceptforthebiofuels,therestcanbeconsideredgreenfuels.Electricwillbeahighlygreenfuelwhenproducedfrom renewablesourcesofenergy.
Table 12:Comparisonofthevariousparametersfortheâfuelofthefuture.
Electric Energy Bio Fuels LNG Hydrogen
Eco friendly Yes No Yes Yes Convenient Yes Yes Yes Yes Renewable Yes Yes No Yes Cost effective/feasible Yes Yes Yes No Financial Generator Yes Yes Yes Yes Suitable for all vehicles Yes Yes No No Adequate for prolonged use Yes No No Yes Technology available Yes Yes Yes No
Governmentâs Interest Yes Yes Yes No
Peopleâs Interest High Medium Verylow Low
BasedonComparativeanalysis,itisfoundthatonlyelectricenergyisthefuelthatsatisfiestheneedsforâfueloffuture.â
Consideringallfactorsoffuturedemandandmaintainingoverallsustainability,theselectionislefttoadoptâElectricenergyâ asanappropriatealternativeforâfuelshiftingofVehicles.â
2 Source:Author;Thecomparativeanalysistomarkthepotentialsandconsofvariousfuelsavailabletobeadopted.Theparametersare exclusivelyselectedtothoroughlycomparethefuelswitheachotherandfigureoutthenumberofâYesâasacceptedandâNoâtoberejected.The fuelwhichgetsthehighestNumberofâYesâwouldbeconsideredasmostappropriatefueltobeselectedforfuturetransportsystems.
International Research Journal of Engineering and Technology (IRJET) e ISSN: 2395 0056
Through this research, it has also been found out that, apart from electric energy, the second most fuel which can be consideredforfuelshiftingareBio fuels.However,theonlyconcernsaredevelopingpollution free/negligibletypesofBio fuels, whichsomewhatfulfillallthecriterialrequirementsofthefuelthatwouldreplacetheconventionalpower.Anothersignificant outcomefromthisresearchisthatalthoughelectricenergyisthemostsuitablefuel,otherfuelslikeBiofuels,Hydrogen,oreven LNGcannotbeneglectedordiscouraged.Thesefuelsarebehindintherace,butnotsofar,tobedisqualifiedintheselectionof âFuelofFutureâinIndia.
ElectricenergyhasprovenitselfsuperiortootherfuelsintheoverallimprovementsinachievingEco friendly,Convenient, Renewable, Cost effective/feasible, Financial Generator, Suitable for all vehicles, Adequate for prolonged use, Technology available,GovernmentâsInterest,andPeopleâsInterestrequirementsofModernIndiaTransport.Electricenergywouldhavean overallpositiveimpactonalltheseparameters.
Amongallparameters,theCost effectiveparameterforElectricEnergyproventoprovidelargeeconomicbenefitsfrom60% savingsifelectricityispurchased,to100%savingsifelectricityisgeneratedfromrenewablesourcesatpremiseslikesolar energyorWindenergy.Thisisdominatingbenefitofadoptingelectricenergyoverotherfuels.
Efforts can be made to promote fuel shiftingand subsequent planning of its infrastructure, simultaneously locking the estimatedtimelinetoachievetheaimofâfuelshiftinginIndia.â
Thisresearchislimitedtoonly100peopleintheprimarysurvey,whichisalso basedonrandomselection.Thiscanbe furtherbeextendedtotaketheprimarystudyfromthewholepopulationofIndia,makingitmorejustifiableforinclusive planning.
Electric Vehicle (EV): Vehiclewhichuseselectricalenergyasitsfueltorun
Internal Combustion engine: EnginewhichrunsonGas/fuelwithinternalcombustionprocessinsideenginecylinders
Liquified Natural Gas (LNG): NaturalGasintheformofLiquidstatestoredinCylinders
Waste Consumer: Bio fuelsaremainlyproducedfromBiodegradablewaste,henceregardedaswasteconsumers
Theauthordeclarethatnofunds,grants,orothersupportwerereceivedduringthepreparationofthismanuscript.
Thisresearchdidnotreceiveanyspecificgrantfromfundingagenciesinthepublic,commercial,ornot for profitsectors.The authorsdeclaresthatthecontentsofthisarticlehavenotbeenpublishedpreviously.Authorhavecontributedtothework described,read,andapprovedthecontentsforpublicationinthisjournal.Theauthorshavebeencertifiedbytheirrespective organizationsforhumansubjectresearch.
[1] AlternativeFuelsandAdvancedVehicles.(2022,Feb03).AlternativeFuelsandAdvancedVehicles.RetrievedfromEnergy Efficiency&RenewableEnergy:https://afdc.energy.gov/fuels/M.Young,TheTechnicalWriterâsHandbook.MillValley,CA: UniversityScience,1989.
[2] Bureau of Energy Efficiency. (2022, Feb 03). E Mobility. Retrieved from Bureau of Energy Efficiency: https://beeindia.gov.in/content/e mobilityK.Elissa,âTitleofpaperifknown,âunpublished.
[3] AlternativeFuelsandAdvancedVehicles.(2022,Feb03).AlternativeFuelsandAdvancedVehicles.RetrievedfromEnergy Efficiency&RenewableEnergy:https://afdc.energy.gov/fuels/
Volume: 09 Issue: 06 | Jun 2022 www.irjet.net p ISSN: 2395 0072 Š 2022, IRJET | Impact Factor value: 7.529 | ISO 9001:2008 Certified Journal
International Research Journal of Engineering and Technology (IRJET) e ISSN: 2395 0056
Volume: 09 Issue: 06 | Jun 2022 www.irjet.net p ISSN: 2395 0072
[4] Bureau of Energy Efficiency. (2022, Feb 03). E Mobility. Retrieved from Bureau of Energy Efficiency: https://beeindia.gov.in/content/e mobility
[5] Khurana,A.,RaviKumar,V.,&Sidhpuria,M.(2019).AStudyontheAdoptionofElectricVehiclesinIndia:TheMediating RoleofAttitude.SAGE,1 12.
[6] Logan,K.G.,Nelson,J.D.,&Hastings,A.(2020).ElectricandHydrogenbuses;ShiftingfromConventionallyfuelledcarsin theUK.TransportationResearchPartD,1 18.
[7] Mansuri,M.F.,Saxena,B.K.,&Mishra,S.(2021).ShiftingfromFossilFuelVehiclestoH2basedFuelCellElectricVehicles: CaseStudyofaSmartCity.IEEE,1 6.
[8] OâDELL, J. (2022, Feb 03). FUEL OF THE FUTURE. Retrieved from The Years Project: https://theyearsproject.com/learn/news/fuel of the future/#:~:text=Electricity%20is%20the%20transportation%20fuel,as%20gasoline%20vehicles%20are%20today.&text =Consumer%20acceptance%20of%20electric%20cars,companies%20roll%20out%20more%20models.
[9] Romm,J.(2005).Thecarandfuelofthefuture.EnergyPolicy,1 6.
[10] SHAH,A.(2021,May29).Risingfuelprices:Anotherreasontoshifttosustainabletransport.RetrievedfromObserver ResearchFoundation:https://www.orfonline.org/expert speak/rising fuel prices another reason to shift to sustainable transport/
[11] WOODS,C.R.(2020,Jan30).Fuel switching?Whatyouneedtoknowaboutelectricvehicles.RetrievedfromCharlottesville Tomorrow:https://www.cvilletomorrow.org/articles/fuel switching what you need to know about electric vehicles/
[12] Zhang,T.(2015).PossibilitiesofAlternativeVehicleFuels .Gavle:UniversityofGavle.
Ar. Vatsalya Kaushal: He is an Architect, aspiring Urban Planner, and GATE Scholar from Faculty of ArchitectureandPlanning,AKTU,Lucknow,Uttar Pradesh226007(India). Hisresearchinterestismainlyin Transportation Planning and Urban planning along with utopian ideas in Architecture . He is an active participantinvariousworkshopsorganizedbytheStatebodiesinArchitectureandGreenBuilding.
Ar. Saurabh Verma: HeisalecturerintheDept.ofPlanninginFOAP,AKTUandanAssistantprofessorinthe department ofUrban PlanningBBDULucknow. He isan Architect, Planner,andspecializesinTransport planningandlogisticsmanagementfromSPABhopal.Duringhisacademiccourses,heworkedwithGIZon CoimbatoreregionalPlanfor2038.Hediligentlyworkedonthetopic"Impactoflandslidesinthehillyroad network" in his thesis during his master's program. He guided numerous students for thesis projects, publishedarticlesandpapersonpublictransport.HedidhissummerInternshipwithRITES,NewDelhialso workedwithRCUES,LucknowresearchfortheenhancementofridershipinLucknowMetro.
`
2022, IRJET | Impact Factor value: 7.529 | ISO 9001:2008 Certified Journal