Prime Brokerage IN FOCUS 2021
INDUSTRY OUTLOOK Buoyancy in hedge funds bodes well for PB business
BOUTIQUE PRIME BROKERS Client relationships key to rise of boutique PBs
OUTSOURCED TRADING Extensive capabilities deliver in challenging times
Featuring Cowen | IG Prime | Jefferies | Lazarus Capital Partners | Triad Securities
World-class integrated prime brokerage solutions Dedicated client service & dealing capabilities
Simplified prime structure
Unrivalled market access
Online reporting & portal
Execution, custody & financing
Multiple asset class coverage
Full service global markets execution with dedicated dealer representative Industry leading rules-based margining across all asset classes Flexible account structures and reporting capabilities fully tailored to the specific needs of each client
Institutional grade Prime Services for hedge funds, family offices and HNW private clients www.lazaruscapitalpartners.com
Australia | Hong Kong Contact us for a confidential discussion primeservices@lazaruscapitalpartners.com
CONTENTS
06 INSIDE THIS ISSUE… 04 HIGHER SCRUTINY WELCOMED BY THE INDUSTRY
By A. Paris
06 THE IMPORTANCE OF BEING VISIBLE
Interview with Barsam Lakani & Leor Shapiro, Jefferies
09 STRONG CLIENT RELATIONSHIPS SUPPORT RISE OF BOUTIQUE PRIME BROKERS
Interview with Dale Klynhout, Warren Goward & Nicholas Stotz, Lazarus Capital Partners
12 INDUSTRY SUPPORTIVE OF PRIME BUSINESS DESPITE HURDLES
09
Interview with Jack Seibald, Cowen Prime Services
14 KEEPING STRONG IN A STORM: EXTENSIVE TRADING CAPABILITIES DELIVER
Interview with Larry Goldsmith & Michael Bird, Triad Securities
17 DIRECTORY
12 Published by: Hedgeweek, 8 St James’s Square, London SW1Y 4JU, UK www.hedgeweek.com ©Copyright 2021 Global Fund Media Ltd. All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted, in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, without the prior permission of the publisher. Investment Warning: The information provided in this publication should not form the sole basis of any investment decision. No investment decision should be made in relation to any of the information provided other than on the advice of a professional financial advisor. Past performance is no guarantee of future results. The value and income derived from investments can go down as well as up.
PRIME BROKERAGE IN FOCUS | May 2021
www.hedgeweek.com | 3
OV E RV I E W
Higher scrutiny welcomed by the industry By A. Paris
J
ust four months into 2021 and the hedge fund industry has already experienced two major events affecting prime brokerage – the GameStop run and the Archegos collapse. Though these incidents may have rocked some firms, others have held strong and are almost appreciative of the greater scrutiny resulting from such episodes. “As a result of the GameStop experience, prime brokers have been forced to be far more vigilant with their clients’ exposure to names they were trading,” notes Jack Seibald, Managing Director and Global Co-Head of Prime Brokerage & Outsourced Trading, Cowen. “We changed our margin and risk rules almost on a daily basis to protect the clients and the firm, fully understanding that if clients blow themselves up, our capital is next in line for collapse.” The jury is still out on whether it was amateur trades who drove the GameStop run or whether Wall Street infiltrated the online chatter and sought to take advantage of the circumstances. Whatever the cause, the incident almost put hedge fund Melvin Capital out of business and prime units across the industry saw a large pile of unwound bets. However, although this event has had reverberations 4 | www.hedgeweek.com
across the prime brokerage industry, the resulting increased scrutiny is being welcomed. Barsam Lakani, Global Head of Prime Services Sales, Jefferies says: “Redirecting the spotlight on the importance of risk, liquidity, and margin management is a good thing. It’s healthy for the entire industry. Ultimately, it’s certainly beneficial for the hedge fund players, their prime brokers and the end investor. The entire ecosystem benefits.” Reputational damage The second episode to hit the headlines was the collapse of Archegos Capital Management – a family office run by hedge fund manager Bill Hwang. Evidence shows the organisation collapsed following the overuse of leverage, in a bid to chase higher returns. Several large prime brokers, most notably Credit Suisse and Nomura, were badly hit by this collapse, haemorrhaging money as a result. Seibald outlines: “The Archegos collapse raised some bigger questions related to counterparty risk. There were prime brokers relying on their clients to be truthful and PRIME BROKERAGE IN FOCUS | May 2021
OV E RV I E W
The Archegos collapse raised some bigger questions related to counterparty risk. There were prime brokers relying on their clients to be truthful and disclose their full exposure to certain securities. Jack Seibald, Cowen
disclose their full exposure to certain securities. This was proven to be a sub-par risk management tool and some firms got hit quite hard. “For some of the worst hit firms it is a blemish which will be hard to overcome from a client relations perspective – if one of these prime brokers were one of your principal counterparties, you may wonder whether your assets are well protected.” Dale Klynhout, Managing Director, Lazarus Capital Partners, comments: “The well-publicised Archegos losses across a number of tier one prime brokers will further adjust the relationship dynamics. Prime brokers who had been proactive about risk mitigation and collateral management prior to the sell-off were better positioned to weather the unprecedented spike in volatility, which resulted in fewer clients being forced sellers prior to the recovery in equity markets. “We have found that our ability to guide clients through the crisis has led to new levels of trust and respect, which has enhanced our ability to uphold collateral and margin standards during a rising market where a client’s attitude towards risk becomes complacent towards the threat of a downturn.” In Seibald’s view: “As it relates to the large bulge bracket prime brokers, I think there will be a reassessment of the relationships they have with clients to which they’re extending enormous amounts of credit. The prime brokers are going to want greater transparency, as to the clients’ exposure to the underlying securities, that the bank is financing at that moment in time.” Prime brokers which are not heavily dependent on providing hedge funds with large amounts of leverage at PRIME BROKERAGE IN FOCUS | May 2021
cheap rates will largely be unaffected by this turn of events. Lakani observes: “We were having these conversations around diligence and risk management before this episode hit the news. It’s not new and clients are always monitoring this and asking questions related to the controls that exist in our industry, especially for us as a prime broker. Historically, at Jefferies, we’ve always been very transparent with clients. We are very clear and communicative around how we manage our prime brokerage business and how we intend to operate as a prime broker. “So, we welcome the increased level of questioning. We think these conversations are healthy and important. We have never shied away from these topics and certainly today we’re being even more vocal and engaged on these items.” Talent moves and career risk Events like this also have repercussions on talent and recruitment. Reportedly, several managing directors at Credit Suisse, one of the firms hardest hit by the Archegos collapse, have either left or are in the process of leaving. Seibald says: “It has definitely caused many talented people to consider their options since their careers were at risk of being ruined by poor decisions made somewhere else in the bank.” These moves are understandable, given that career risk is a significant concern among hedge fund managers. A study by State Street Global Advisors found 52 percent of industry professionals worry about career risk. Further compounding these worries, a research study by the Center for Studies in Economics and Finance at the University of Naples in Italy found that poor performance followed by fund liquidation can lead to high level employees suffering permanent career setbacks, including lower salaries for years. This paper, entitled Career Risk and Market Discipline in Asset Management, was first published in 2017 and re-issued in 2020. It studied the impact of fund liquidations on asset managers’ careers. n www.hedgeweek.com | 5
JEFFERIES
The importance of being visible Interview with Barsam Lakani & Leor Shapiro
A
lthough it ushered in a whole host of new challenges, when it came to client and audience engagement, the Covid-19 pandemic levelled the playing field between the big banks and smaller players in the prime brokerage market. It encouraged dialogue and boosted transparency. Further, in view of the expected growth in outsourced trading in Europe and Asia, ensuring a good fit between providers and clients has never been more relevant. “In a way, the pandemic helped us,” explains Leor Shapiro, Global Head of Capital Intelligence, Jefferies. “As it relates to my team in terms of events, it meant we could have the same reach as the big banks, without having to match their spend. We took the technological approach to make sure we had the best platform for events and we’ve seen attendance and engagement rise by 500 percent since the start of the outbreak.” Barsam Lakani, Global Head of Prime Services Sales, Jefferies comments: “Clients have moved beyond the initial shock of the pandemic, which had people adjusting 6 | www.hedgeweek.com
and unsure of how to engage. Now, especially as people are starting to see a light at the end of the tunnel, we’re starting to see that client engagement really pick up. And attendance is higher than it would have been in another period of time, so we’re very encouraged that we can operate efficiently and effectively within these circumstances.” Shapiro outlines how the Jefferies capital introduction events started out with people in three or four countries but now host attendees from around 13 or 14 different locations: “We’ve become more global very quickly.” The firm’s next event is focused on the consumer and technology sectors, with 20 managers who work in those specific verticals. There are already more than 250 groups signed up to attend from all around the world. In keeping with the firm’s desire to keep abreast of new developments, Jefferies has identified the growing popularity and strengthening of the healthcare hedge fund industry. “As a prime broker, we are closely aligned with these groups and the opportunities in the sector. Although healthcare may have recently slightly softened as a performing PRIME BROKERAGE IN FOCUS | May 2021
JEFFERIES sector in 2021, we believe there is still significant growth to be gained here,” Lakani observes. Healthcare is just one sector in which Jefferies has been able to leverage its best-in-class, global equities sales, trading and research platform to provide a holistic approach to healthcare and other sector and specialist managers, an approach that has proven to be highly effective. Providing relevant strategic content In the current environment, Lakani underscores the importance of being as visible and vocal as possible, providing clients with pertinent strategic content. Shapiro, who is leading the charge at Jefferies in this regard elaborates: “We are producing original, proprietary and differentiated content. So, we took a view to be very public about what we offer, despite being aware this information would get into our competitors’ hands. We want to show our clients that we’re thematic forward thinkers. There are dramatic trends and themes, and we want to be out in front of them and publish on these topics.” The team’s aim is to provide valuable knowledge for managers and their investors. “If we give them that information, we facilitate better dialogue and make people smarter. They will want to come back to us and build up trust over time,” Shapiro notes. He adds how his team has the advantage of being at the epicentre of the eco-system which connects the different parts of the Jefferies business, most notably across global equity sales, trading and research, with managers and the various vendors and advisers who service them: “We’re essentially in the hub of information and our ability to synthesise, repurpose and redistribute this information to our clients is really critical. It makes us stand out and builds a different type of relationship with clients.” Lakani says: “This has been a big focus area for us, especially in light of the pandemic with people working remotely and asking about growth opportunities and trends which we have observed in the market. We can help them visualise it through our content.”
Finding the right fit Encouraging this dialogue is critical to help clients find the right fit when it comes to their providers. Jefferies is always looking for cutting edge ways to be relevant, strategic and part of its clients’ thought processes. “Our goal is to align with our clients’ objectives – to help them build a successful business. We want to support them in scaling their business which will ultimately help them generate returns for their end investors,” Lakani outlines. Part of this involves responding to client demand. In view of this, Jefferies has built up an outsourced trading business which has been growing at pace. Lakani notes: “We see this as a huge growth opportunity for our platform, where we’re trying to target the right types of partners for the service.” He indicates that it’s key for the outsourced trading service to fit into a clients’ overall architecture: “It needs to make good business sense for them and for us. That then forms the foundation for us to have a meaningful conversation or partnership to explore the possibilities. “I don’t think that the industry has fully grasped how much of a growth area this is going to become, especially in geographies outside the US. We’ve seen a huge increase in popularity and uptake here. We think it’s going to grow in popularity as an operating model in other regions as well, namely Europe and Asia, where we’re just in the first innings.” This rise in demand will be driven by efficiencies and costs. However, Lakani stresses the approach may not be suitable for everyone. This is where the dialogue with potential clients is key once again: “Although we expect growth in this market, we’re not making a blanket statement that all of the industry is going to outsource their trading. This is a good operating model for a certain demographic of clients or funds. Our aim is to provide a model that finds operational efficiencies and cost which benefit the client and ultimately help the end investor.” n
Barsam Lakani Global Head of Prime Services Sales, Jefferies
Leor Shapiro Global Head of Capital Intelligence, Jefferies
Barsam Lakani is a Managing Director and the Global Head of Prime Services Sales at Jefferies. Barsam is responsible for Jefferies’ efforts to partner with clients around their traditional Prime Brokerage needs, spanning capital and business formation goals, outsourced trading and financing needs and other advisory services which Jefferies delivers to its institutional clients. With a focus ranging from start-up hedge funds through to wellestablished hedge funds, he oversees both traditional Prime Brokerage as well as outsourced trading sales and relationship management efforts. Prior to Jefferies Barsam was with Bank of America Merrill Lynch, working in the Prime Brokerage group.
Leor Shapiro is a Managing Director and the Global Head of Capital Intelligence within Prime Services at Jefferies with oversight of Capital Introductions, Strategic Content and Hedge Fund Consulting. Leor is responsible for working with both existing and start-up hedge fund managers to help them launch, grow and evolve their businesses as well as help them develop and implement their marketing strategies on a global basis. Leor also serves as co-Head of the Jefferies Woman’s Initiative Network for the Americas and sits on the firm’s Diversity and Inclusion Committee. Prior to Jefferies, Leor was the Americas Head of Business Consulting at UBS and spent the earlier part of his career allocating to hedge funds with an operational due diligence focus.
PRIME BROKERAGE IN FOCUS | May 2021
www.hedgeweek.com | 7
Jefferies Prime Services A Gateway for Hedge Funds to Access the Firm’s Global Platform
By creating connectivity to Investment Banking, Research, Sales and Trading, and Corporate Access for our clients, we seek to help funds successfully build their business and create alpha over business cycles. Jefferies Prime Services provides a full service offering including securities lending, financing, swaps, outsourced trading, a best-in-class technology platform, and capital introductions and business consulting services for both start-up and existing managers. Our platform is fully self-clearing and provides global access to over 40 markets. In addition, Global Prime Services has achieved the SSAE Type II reporting standard. Find out more at Jefferies.com.
Clients First–Always
SM
INVESTMENT BANKING | EQUITIES | FIXED INCOME | ASSET MANAGEMENT | WEALTH MANAGEMENT | JEFFERIES.COM © 2021 Jefferies LLC. Member SIPC.
L A Z A R U S C A P I TA L PA R T N E R S
Strong client relationships support rise of boutique prime brokers Interview with Dale Klynhout, Warren Goward & Nicholas Stotz
T
ransparency, trust and a clear understanding of the prime broker’s risk management process can help managers build long-term sustainable relationships with their providers. This is especially critical among boutique and mini-prime brokers. These firms are meeting a growing need among emerging hedge fund managers as the traditional providers step further away from this part of the industry. “There is no one-size-fits-all solution for prime brokerage, as different fund managers and investment strategies have different needs. A boutique prime broker is best able to service hedge fund managers when they have a deep understanding of the manager’s investment strategy, trading needs, and operational pain points, meaning managers can expect their broker to invest significant time and resources during the onboarding process,” advises Dale Klynhout, Managing Director at Lazarus Capital Partners. The industry has witnessed the rise of boutique and mini-prime brokers, as these groups grow to be better suited to service smaller, less profitable managers. “The growth in the industry has been driven by customers demanding a better experience and traditional providers stepping away from the industry, and these trends are likely to accelerate in the near future. The attitudes of the tier one prime brokers to these managers will continue to tighten into the future where mini-primes will further be able to adequately service them with a more comprehensive service offering,” Klynhout outlines Hedge fund managers need rapid turnarounds for their service requests to operate smoothly, and boutique prime brokers are PRIME BROKERAGE IN FOCUS | May 2021
better positioned to promptly service their clients thanks to being free of administrative bureaucracy and legacy technology found in large investment banks and discount brokers. Managers often prefer boutique prime brokers due to their level of service and capabilities to take administrative headaches off their hands. Klynhout explains how the 2008 global financial crisis and subsequent regulations on the banking sector also created an opportunity for boutique prime brokers: “A tightening of bank balance sheets in conjunction with increasing compliance and onboarding costs has resulted in the major investment banks restricting their prime brokerage services to larger hedge funds (~USD100 million – USD200 million+). “This has created the opportunity for a comprehensive prime aggregation business model to service small-medium sized hedge funds who are not yet large enough to be a standalone client at a major investment bank, but still require high quality prime brokerage services.” Overcoming challenges The retreat of the major investment banks is a double-edged sword for boutique primes however, as major investment banks are requiring ever-increasing levels of due diligence and capitalisation in order for boutique primes to utilise their capabilities. Klynhout comments: “Changing liquidity requirements and the need for higher grade assets are further putting pressures on the viability of mini-prime brokers operating under the tier one prime brokerage umbrellas.” When selecting a prime broker, managers must be sure to gain an understanding of the broker’s risk management process. A broker www.hedgeweek.com | 9
L A Z A R U S C A P I TA L PA R T N E R S with clear rules regarding margin maintenance and collateral requirements is more likely to have a quality balance sheet that can weather a full market cycle. “With asset prices at healthy valuations, it is becoming increasingly important for boutique prime brokers to employ robust risk management processes to manage their exposures. Many prime brokers were caught over their skis in the global financial crisis, having overextended financing with inadequate collateral. As the Archegos fallout illustrated, prime brokers who sacrifice lending quality and risk management in the pursuit of fees are exposing themselves and their clients to catastrophic risk,” advises Nicholas Stotz, Risk Analyst and Associate Dealer at Lazarus Capital Partners. In his view, increased regulation in conjunction with high profile situations like Archegos will further accelerate the trend of major investment banks reducing their prime brokerage operations, thereby increasing the pool of high-quality clients for boutique prime brokers to service. Klynhout expects there to be some segmentation in the boutique prime market as different firms tailor their value proposition to hedge funds of varying size: “A hedge fund with AUM of USD5 million often has different needs to a hedge fund with AUM of USD100 million. Within these segments, we will likely see consolidation as larger players look to gain market share and shore up their balance sheets.” Differentiation and operational efficiency Appointing a boutique prime broker can help improve an emerging hedge fund’s operational efficiency. This is an incredibly important advantage given that emerging managers have little room for error while building up a track record to retain current investors and attract new ones. “A key differentiator between a boutique prime broker and a discount broker is the level of operational support provided to the fund,” Klynhout observes. “Time intensive operational tasks such as outsourced trading/dealing, third-party trade settlements, capital raising allocations, customised reporting and dealing with external functions attached with the managers are handled by the miniprime broker. These additional support services further open up time and resources for emerging hedge
funds to allocate to portfolio management and business development.” Access to experienced dealers with intimate market knowledge is another key differentiator of boutique prime brokers. Suboptimal trade execution can significantly drag down returns, and the rise of high frequency and algorithmic trading means the market is often shallower than what appears on a trader’s screen. “By using a boutique prime broker, managers can leverage the expertise of their dealer to implement bespoke trading strategies that reduce price slippage and market movement,” suggests Warren Goward, Director of Prime Services at Lazarus Capital Partners and former institutional trader. Klynhout notes: “Managers should perform thorough due diligence when choosing to partner with a prime broker, including gaining insight into the broker’s service offering, risk management and compliance policies, and the capabilities of senior management. Time and effort invested in the early stages of a manager-broker relationship forms a solid foundation for future success, and often offers an added advantage of stability for both manager and prime broker during market downturns.” Klynhout concludes by stressing that transparency and trust are essential for a successful long-term partnership between a manager and a prime broker: “Over the course of the due diligence process, a fund should expect their prime broker to provide formalised documents detailing their internal processes as it relates to margining, maintaining client privacy, ensuring compliance, etc. “Managers should also be prepared for their prime broker to ask numerous questions regarding their business, to gain a high-level understanding of the firm’s investment strategy, current operations, and plans for the business in the near future.” n Warren Goward Director Prime Services Warren Goward has 18 years experience in financial markets advising both private and institutional accounts. He has specialist knowledge of the prime brokerage and equities financing industry and has extensive international equity markets experience. Warren worked for 12 years in the Prime division for Credit Suisse which included 4 years in London trading European Equities, and 3.5 years in Tokyo trading Japanese equities.
Dale Klynhout Managing Director
Nicholas Stotz Dealing Associate and Risk Analyst
Dale Klynhout is a Managing Director of Lazarus Capital Partners and is the founder of its prime brokerage business. Dale is actively involved in the management of all aspects of the firm’s operations, risk management, compliance and client development. As the leading member of the investment team, he is responsible for delivering on mandated investment management objectives that generate further value for Lazarus clients.
Nicholas Stotz started his career as an Investment Research Analyst for a leading private wealth firm in Sydney, analysing all major asset classes including global shares, bonds, real estate and private equity. At Lazarus Capital Partners Nicholas sits on the dealing desk servicing client portfolios, and has leveraged his professional experience in portfolio construction and education in quantitative finance to develop comprehensive risk management tools to help monitor and mitigate business risk.
10 | www.hedgeweek.com
PRIME BROKERAGE IN FOCUS | May 2021
PRIME BROKERAGE
GLOBAL PRIME BROKERAGE SERVICES Comprehensive Solutions for Investment Managers
Cowen’s Prime Brokerage solution offers a comprehensive suite of brokerage and related services that provide investment managers with customizable and scalable solutions. Cowen offers turn-key solutions designed to mitigate operating responsibilities and allow clients to focus on their core competency. • US and International Prime Brokerage
• Middle- and Back-Office Support
• Electronic and High-Touch Execution
• Capital Introduction
• Commission Management
• Portfolio and Risk Analytics
• Global Swap & Synthetic Prime Brokerage
• Pre- and Post-Trade Compliance
• Outsourced Trading
• New Launch Consulting • Access to Cowen’s Institutional Platform
• Financing and Stock Loan
Learn more at: cowen.com COWEN.COM
COWEN
© 2021, Cowen Inc., All Rights Reserved
US | EUROPE | ASIA COWENRESEARCH
COWEN
COWEN PRIME SERVICES, LLC
C OW E N
Industry supportive of prime business despite hurdles Interview with Jack Seibald
B
uoyancy in the hedge fund industry, following a year of strong performance, bodes well for the prime brokerage business. Numerous new funds are being launched and prudent prime players are benefiting from the renewed interest in the asset class. “Hedge funds had been losing their lustre in the years leading up to the pandemic. At the height of the 2020 volatility however, they proved their worth by protecting against the downside while giving the opportunity to investors to participate in the upside,” Jack Seibald managing director and global co-head, prime brokerage & outsourced trading at Cowen observes. This positive performance revived institutional investors’ appetite for hedge funds, in turn leading to an increase in fund launches. These developments have been encouraging for the prime brokerage industry. From Cowen’s perspective, the last year represented a significant evolution. “2020 felt like a watershed for the firm’s international prime brokerage business. It really took off last year and set us on a completely different level, both in terms of revenue as well as profitability. This gave us the courage to be more aggressive in terms of our marketing efforts and we’re seeing the result of that strategy flowing through this year.” The international growth Cowen experienced was partly due to having inherited the Global Prime Partners business. In February 2020, the firm agreed to integrate the GPP business into its own. Although the book of business itself was a significant boost to Cowen, the
personnel obtained through the transaction was even more impactful. Cowen hired GPP’s prime brokerage team, including personnel from the sales, operations, client service, onboarding and trading teams. “We then made some strategic hires along the way and the resulting team has turned out to be very productive,” Seibald comments. He also reports the firm’s prime brokerage clients are getting larger as managers make the move from bulge bracket firms. In Seibald’s view, the reason for firms moving is down to client management: “Many clients feel they are not being paid sufficient attention by their existing primes This is a story we’ve heard many times. With a bulge bracket firm, unless you’re generating a large amount of revenue, you tend not to get a lot of attention and often have to ask twice or three times for something before getting it.” From a capabilities perspective, Cowen is a credible alternative to the bulge bracket firms.
12 | www.hedgeweek.com
PRIME BROKERAGE IN FOCUS | May 2021
Extending trading desks In addition to the reawakened demand for hedge funds, the pandemic also nudged forward the case for outsourced trading. This space is on an upward trajectory across the industry. Seibald explains: “Larger managers who found themselves operating from home realised they needed a bridge between the portfolio managers and their traders. In fact, we got many calls at the start of the pandemic asking us to act as an extension of the managers’ trading desk. “After a while, they realised the set up worked well
C OW E N and the historical belief that managers and traders had to be in close proximity no longer held. Therefore, larger sized managers started considering outsourced trading, either as an add-on or permanent solution. We’ve seen the uptake of this service broaden out to a much larger audience and consisting of much larger players.” This line of business has allowed Cowen to develop a new client base which historically it would not have had access to. In Seibald’s view: “Unless you’re a very large player, the cost of building, managing and maintaining your own trading desk is prohibitive. We have traders all over the globe, specialised in the various asset classes. So regardless of what book you’re trading and how broad it is in terms of asset classes, it is unlikely a firm will be able to build a trading team of the calibre they would have at their disposal through Cowen.” The relationships the firm built on the outsourced trading side has also contributed to growth in Cowen’s prime brokerage business. “As some clients get beyond a certain size, they start contemplating adding an additional prime broker to diversify their counterparty risk. In light of this we’ve had the opportunity to pitch and win some of this business on the prime brokerage side. In large part, these wins were driven by all the other services we were already providing these clients. Our offer to those clients can be far more competitive because they’re already generating a bunch of revenues with us.” Seibald doesn’t foresee the outsourced trading and prime brokerage businesses converging to a meaningful extent, but the firm is always looking to anticipate clients’ needs and build the capabilities to satisfy those requirements. Industry under the lens Recent news of high-profile events like the Archegos collapse and the GameStop run caused some retrenching in the prime brokerage world. Seibald addresses these two influential incidents: “GameStop forced prime brokers to be far more vigilant with their clients’ exposure to names they were trading. We changed our margin and risk rules almost on a daily basis to protect the clients and the firm, fully understanding that if clients blow themselves up, our capital is next in line. “Archegos raised some bigger questions PRIME BROKERAGE IN FOCUS | May 2021
related to counterparty risk. There were prime brokers relying on their clients to be truthful and disclose their full exposure to certain securities. This was proven to be a sub-par risk management tool and some firms got hit quite hard. As it relates to the bulge bracket prime brokers, I think there will be a reassessment of the relationships they have with clients to which they’re extending enormous amounts of credit. The prime brokers are going to want greater transparency, as to the client exposure to the underlying securities the bank is financing at that moment in time.” He underscores that this doesn’t apply to the Cowen business as its prime brokerage business was not built to, and is not dependent on, providing hedge funds with inordinately large amounts of leverage at excessively cheap rates. n Jack Seibald Managing Director and Global Co-Head, Prime Brokerage & Outsourced Trading, Cowen Jack Seibald is Managing Director and Global Co-Head of Prime Brokerage & Outsourced Trading. Jack co-founded Concept Capital Markets, LLC, and until its acquisition by Cowen, served as a Managing Member of the firm. During his tenure with Concept Capital, Jack was involved in the management of all aspects of the firm’s operations, with a particular emphasis on business and client development and legal matters. Jack also served as a member of the Board of Managers of Concept Capital Holdings, LLC, the company’s former parent, Concept Capital Administration, LLC, which provided administrative services to the company and its affiliates, and ConceptONE, LLC, which provided risk and performance analytic solutions, middle and back office support services, and regulatory reporting services to investment managers. Jack has been affiliated with the firm and its predecessors since 1995 and has extensive experience in prime brokerage, investment management, and investment research dating back to 1983.
www.hedgeweek.com | 13
TRIAD SECURITIES
Keeping strong in a storm: extensive trading capabilities deliver Interview with Larry Goldsmith & Michael Bird
M
arket volatility and high volume have exposed weaknesses in trading systems and technology offerings. This has led to reductions in service and increased down time in trading offerings. Providers with the ability to overcome these challenges have stood in good stead with clients. “Our extensive trading system redundancies and trading desk availability means we perform even when other systems and desks fail,” explains Michael Bird, senior managing director, Triad Securities Corp. “Market conditions and low-cost self-service technology platforms have increased the amount of time advisors spend managing day-to-day business needs instead of focusing on generating investment return for their clients.” 14 | www.hedgeweek.com
Time is money or lost opportunity, he says, and Triad aims to help make its clients more efficient. This allows them to spend less time running their business and more time servicing their clients: “We like to tell clients that we are an extension of their business. “As volume and volatility increased last year it became apparent that investment advisors had to spend more time on investment strategies and less time on running their day-to-day business,” Bird says. “We have always stayed true to our belief in high touch service with direct human interaction; this approach allows our clients more time to focus on alpha generation.” In addition, being a smaller firm, Triad prides itself on responding to clients swiftly. Larry Goldsmith, Triad’s President and Director of PRIME BROKERAGE IN FOCUS | May 2021
TRIAD SECURITIES
Operations, emphasises: “We’re nimble and agile because we’re a 35-person shop and therefore clients can get questions answered quickly – we reply in minutes, rather than days. Even during the height of the pandemic customers often commented on our quick response time, without realising all of our employees were working from home. We cut through a lot of red tape and refuse to let our clients get bogged down in mundane tasks. Our model allows clients to be more efficient while we take care of the operational side of things, all at a reasonable cost.” Unconflicted trading solutions Triad is also experiencing an increased interest in how one executes orders with clients asking whether their broker sells order flow or trades principal against that order flow. The firm has always been an agency only trading firm, offering unconflicted trading solutions to clients. For example, firms with one trader might be looking to grow their team and Triad can act as that second or third trader. Managers can choose to do this initially to save money but there are other efficiencies they can gain from outsourcing their trading capabilities. Bird comments: “They can feel comfortable dealing directly with our desk for trading. We work with them to reduce their workload as much as possible. This will give them more time to focus on their clients and highlight their unique value proposition. We will allow them to spend as much time as they can delivering on that.” Nuanced service Triad clients may have less than USD100 million AuM and for these types of firms cost control can be a real concern. PRIME BROKERAGE IN FOCUS | May 2021
Managers on a growth path can benefit from the additional support a provider like Triad can offer. For example, smaller firms with USD10 million in assets might need to hire a back office person. Larger shops may already have a back-office professional but may need a second to bolster their team. Using Triad’s service means managers of all sizes can save salary costs and access seasoned experts without needing to onboard them directly. Although technology solutions play a key role in delivering this service, technology needs to be supported by a human touch. For clients who are looking for a more nuanced offering, a one-size-fits all, off-the shelf technology provider will not work. Bird homes in on the firm’s approach in this regard: “We have maintained our belief that some clients will always want and demand direct person to person interaction coupled with robust technology. We think that the last 12 months just reinforced that belief.” “Technology can never be a complete replacement for personal interactions. Our business model has always been focused on developing and maintaining long term relationships with our clients. Remember we are not trying to be the solution for everyone, just those who share in our business beliefs,” says Goldsmith. Triad’s partnerships currently include Active/Professional traders, RIAs, Hedge Funds, Syndicate Traders and Family Offices. “We are looking for clients who value superior customer service,” Bird underscores. n
Larry Goldsmith President, Triad Securities Larry Goldsmith is the President of Triad Securities Corporation. Prior to becoming President in 2011, Larry served as Triad’s Director of Operations. Larry has more than 30 years of experience in the securities industry, where he has focused on operations, custody, administration and customer service. Larry played a key role in developing the firm’s Prime Broker Clearing operations and remains at the centre of these operations.
Michael Bird Senior Managing Director, Triad Securities Michael Bird is the Senior Managing Director of Triad Securities Corporation, responsible for the firm’s sales, operations, finances and new business development. Prior to Triad Securities, Michael spent 13 years a senior executive with Bank of America Merrill Lynch in New York. Most recently, as Managing Director, he headed and successfully grew two profitable divisions: Broadcort (trade clearing services) and Global Commission Management. Michael oversaw all aspects of both businesses including profitability, strategy, sales, technology, and client relationships. He was also active in a corporate-wide leadership and oversight capacity, as a member of the Firm’s Client Profitability Committee, Market Structure Committee, Alternative Payment Committee, and Senior Mentor Committee.
www.hedgeweek.com | 15
YOUR GROWTH OUR PRIORITY For institutional clients only. Losses can exceed deposits.
D I R E C TO R Y
COWEN INC Cowen Inc (“Cowen” or the “Company”) is a diversified financial services firm offering investment banking services, equity and credit research, sales and trading, prime brokerage, global clearing, commission management services and actively managed alternative investment products. Cowen focuses on delivering value-added capabilities to our clients in order to help them outperform. Founded in 1918, the Company is headquartered in New York and has offices worldwide.
www.cowen.com
Contact: Jack Seibald | jack.seibald@cowen.com | +1 516 746 5718
JEFFERIES Jefferies Group LLC is the largest independent, global, full-service investment banking firm headquartered in the US. Focused on serving clients for nearly 60 years, Jefferies is a leader in providing insight, expertise and execution to investors, companies and governments. Our firm provides a full range of investment banking, advisory, sales and trading, research and wealth management services across all products in the Americas, Europe and Asia. Jefferies Group LLC is a wholly-owned subsidiary of Jefferies Financial Group Inc. (NYSE: JEF), a diversified financial services company.
www.jefferies.com
www.lazaruscapitalpartners.com
Contact: Barsam Lakani | blakani@jefferies.com | +1 212 284 1783 Leor Shapiro | lshapiro@jefferies.com | +1 212 336 6267
Lazarus Capital Partners provides comprehensive prime brokerage solutions for our institutional and sophisticated investor clientele. Our integrated model supports a wide range of investment approaches across multiple asset classes and styles allowing our clients to execute their strategies with efficiency, optimise their portfolios and generate further alpha. By utilising our range of margin financing solutions, our clients accelerate their business growth through portfolio enhancement and reduced administrative burden. Lazarus Capital Partners meets clients evolving needs by offering dynamic solutions, a full product suite of services, superior client services, centralised dealing and execution across multiple avenues, and the market leading capabilities of our entire firm. The Lazarus difference extends beyond prime brokerage, with our clients benefiting from market-leading capabilities extending across execution, financing, custody, and asset servicing solutions. Contact: Nicholas Stotz | primeservices@lazaruscapitalpartners.com | + 61 2 9169 2950
TRIAD SECURITIES Clients have benefited from our boutique prime brokerage service for over 25 years. Our select client partnerships are founded on communications, availability and diligence, and we become a trusted extension of your business. Working with us frees up time and resources, which you can deploy developing strategies, creating alpha, or whatever best suits your business.
www.triadsecurities.com
Contact: sales@triadsecurities.com | +1 212 349 2889
PRIME BROKERAGE IN FOCUS | May 2021
www.hedgeweek.com | 17