Giovanni Mulè Designing Cities
Site in Old Kent Road Urban Context Bricklayers Place
THE MASTERPLAN
Brick
CRIMSCOTT STREET 760 Homes 1,400 Jobs layers
Arms
Southwark Park
MANDELA WAY 2,200 Homes 2,121 Jobs 1 Primary School
BRICKLAYERS ARMS
SOUTH BERMONDSEY & SPIL 2,106 Jobs
Ma
nd ela
W ay
Al
ba
ny
R
d
OLD KENT ROAD (NORTH) 191 Homes 140 Jobs
ST JAMES’S ROAD & STABLES 1,012 Homes 900 Jobs
Rd
w
th
Ro
te S
t
Verney Rd
Sa
ark
Rd
nd
ga
LB LEWISHAM
Asylum
Rd
Pec
kha
mP
Burgess Park
CANTIUM 4,200 Homes 3,100 Jobs 1 Primary School 1 Health Hub
e
ith
h er
Ne
SANDGATE STREET & VERNEY ROAD 3,787 Homes 2,852 Jobs 1 Secondary School 1 Indoor Sports Hall
HATCHAM, ILDERTON & OLD KENT ROAD (SOUTH) 3,900 Homes 2,196 Jobs
KEY Proposed New Bermondsey station Bakerloo Line Extension
0
0.5
2
Old Kent Road in London Growth Context THE GROWTH OF LONDON
OLD KENT ROAD
KEY Opportunity Area Housing Zone Green Belt OLD KENT ROAD Transport super hubs BAKERLOO LINE
0
1km
Approx Scale: 1:41,320
Fig 1: The Growth of London
3
Structural Dimension
Functional Economic Dimension
Socio - Cult. Dimension
Spatial Dimension
SWOT Analysis / Bricklayers Area
- Proximity to the center and Common WorkPlacesĂš
- Car dominated
- Unused building stocks to regenerate
- Disconnected public and private realm
- Create a new area brand identity
- GentriďŹ cation
- Part of GLA Action Plan
- Mixed ethnicity
- Highest population density in europe
- Higher community engagement
- Strong presence of local and independent business
- Quite and well looking residential areas
STRENGHTS
- Job scarsity
- Attract businesses and create jobs
- Scarse light during the evening in some areas
Placemaking and building for more walkability zoning
WEAKNESSES
OPPORTUNITIES
- Negative economic growth
- Lost of local identiy
TREATHS
4
Movement Pattern Analysis / Bricklayers Place Area ON FOOT
BY METRO , TUBE, TRAM FROM
Average
FROM
Tabard Gardens Walworth
Average
Tabard Gardens Walworth
TO
TO
Tower Hamlets City of London
345
Westminster
193
41
68
50
59
474
230
352
Tower Hamlets
173
37
City of London
49
34
274
167
115
108
73
26
Westminster
Lambeth
105 220.5
Southwark
Southwark Islington
UndeďŹ ned CITY
WESTM.
SOUTHW.
BY BYCICLE
Camden
49.5
TOW. HAM.
WESTM.
CAMDEN
CITY
WESTM.
SOUTHW.
BY BUS FROM
Average
FROM
Tabard Gardens Walworth
Average
Tabard Gardens Walworth
TO
TO
Tower Hamlets
Tower Hamlets
City of London
66
36
51
City of London
115
107
111
Westminster
92
58
75
Westminster
225
272
248.5
21
47
34
Lambeth Southwark
CITY
WESTM.
Lambeth
120
99
Southwark
128
179
SOUTHW.
153.5
A.A. = Average Area
By Bicycle By Underground By Foot By Bus
34 49.5
51 59 352
75
105 111 153.5 193 220.5 248.5
Scale 1:20000 0
200
400
600
800
1000
1200
1400
1600
1800
2000 m
Projection: British National Grid
5
Bricklayers Place Site Boundaries
6
Air Pollution Map in proximity to Bricklayers Place
7
Challenges and considerations pre-design
KeyWords :
Accessibility Permeability Green Space Open Space Walkability Pedestrian Flows Air Pollution Resistent Expanding Multi Functional Future Proof Blended with Surroundings Sound Inviting Sensory Pleasant Interactive Legibility Adaptability Sustainable Integrated Respectful
Visual Intentions : Modern Sexy Natural Innovative Liveable Healthy
Challenges : Air Pollution Permeability
Process :
Trying to envision beauty and organic forms with sacred geometry and proportions concepts Balance between individual stakeholders interest and hierarchies Pedestrian 1st
“Non-negotiables�: Access to sunlight 1st Private open amenities Walkability and site pedestrianisation Permeability and Accessibility to the site
8
Precedents and Design Guidance
Asker Square by Super Union Architects
9
Precedents and Design Guidance Marylebone Square
Sense of revival and respectful modernisation of Georgian architecture to maintain the sense of identity with nearby current development and listed buildings in Marylebone’s most prestigious heritage area.
Broadgate Circle
Use of public square with a piazza setting is what inspires me the most from this development. Its strategic use of retail is remarkable as a perfect match with the area need for a great combination of food and free open space.
Rathbone Square
Two main elements catched my attention in this development, now hosting Facebook headquarters. The use of the tunnel shaped access and the use of green and blue spaces. Accessible fountains and abundant green space characterise the experience of the site.
10
Creative Process Genesis with Virtual Reality The creative urban design process started with very sketchy massing using Virtual Reality immersive cexperience from GooglerBlocks at Westminster’s Marylebone Campus Fablab. To simplify and create some as realistic as possible scaled design, I uploaded on the VR software the map (not scaled) of the site and its surroundings. Following professor’s feedback, I also tried to move the development at the edges of the site, immediately generating a genesis of ideas that at the end guided me to the final design outcome. In fact, the central space left, quickly reminded me of the public squares in city centres (or plazas) importance for social cohesion and interaction.
11
Early Site Prototype with Business Cards and Sicilian Game Cards to Test Light and Scales
12
Initial Iterative Urban Design Guided by Sunlight Study
2.6m 2.6m
3 .4m 2 .2m
2 .1m
2.6m
2 .1m
2.6m
2 .4m
2 .7m 2 .7m 2 .5m
1 .8
m
2 .5m
Giovanni Mule’ | Designing Cities
13
Architectural Scheme Outline
14
Initial 3D Site Visualisation
15
Permeability and Pedestrian Flow Design
site where is located
16
Detailed Masterplan The site is almost one Kmsq large and resides at the edge of London’s identified Action Area in Southwark, representing the introduction to the Old Kent Road regeneration area. The main features and challenges are represented by both the future plans for the entire area but as well as current functions. In fact, the site is at the north edge of The masterplan emphasises four main blocks and areas corresponding to: the private residential area which refers to the Bricklayers Residence on the north-west side of the identified area for a station of the Bakerloo Line extension. Currently occupied by a large roundabout with a green area in his center and an overpass on his southern end, which in this exercise has been envisioned to be transformed into a pedestrian only bridge. Independently from the former assumption, Bricklayers Place (renamed after the Bricklayer Station identified by TFL) has been planned from scratch, assuming for this exercise that the area was identified as a brownfield ready to break ground.
17
Land Use and Landscape Program
Private Housing Site
Commercial & Cultural Space
OfďŹ ce Space Green Space
Social Housing City Centre
18
Landscape Design and Materials Inspired by Asker Square by Superunion Architects, in a city centre near Oslo, with an oval plaza that intimately creates a not only a site gathering space but, but orientates and invite movement inside the Bricklayers Place. It is designed to be flexible and multi purpose so that during hot days in the summer can spring water with a set of fountains, and during the winter become an illuminated ice rink. Of course there can be several other rearrangements between these two scenarios, where art installations can take place, group meditations or perhaps a little concert. From the “oval square“ almost imperceptible the pedestrian areas and the green between the buildings slope toward the outer boundaries of the site. Between the routes moving throughout Bricklayers Place, vegetation and informal space is set to be abundant. In fact, ( as would normally occur in nature ) an inverse process where routes were created after the vegetation has been adopted, making the circulation from building to building, or just transitory, more pleasant, refreshing and memorable. While most of the voids have been replaced with natural landscape, another void has been also generated to allow a more private sense of green and open space. In fact the C House, designed to accommodate __ family will also host in his “stomach” a more private and engulfed green space where parents can see their kids playing and at the same time foster community sense and collaborations. Another important element of the masterplan and the landscape design is the introduction of green walls and “barriers” along the roundabout face of the site. In fact researchers demonstrate how certain arrangements of both green walls, bushes and trees can drastically reduce the air pollution contamination to pedestrians in proximity to trafficked roads. Therefore a planting strategy is to be adopted accordingly, along with free water stations to mitigate the potential risks of dehydration due to air pollution, creating a healthier and integrated site. The former will be useful if not essential for the surrounding area residents and users, seeing the presence of elderly care homes and schools, taking in consideration bikers too with an additional one on the north-west boundary close to the bike shelter.
Finally the use of Prosolve76 will be implemented mostly in the southern area of the site, which as visibible on pag 7 is the part of the site most exposed to traffic with higher air pollution rates. Prosolve will be used both as a decorative setting and as fuctional, thanks to its modular organic shapes that “dissolve” air pollutants to its touch and sun ray combination. It has already been used in several worldwide projects and facade buildings. In this case represented at the center of Bricklayers oval Square as an inspiring public art installation.
19
Elevations of the Site
20
Sections of the Site
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
Footbridge Design Speculation
38
KNOWLEDGE
HIERARCLY
WORDS
MEANINGS LETTERS
FRESHGEOMETRY FORM
TIME COMBINATIONS
NATURE
SPACE
SYMBOLS
ARCHITECTURE
DESIGN
?! MATERIALS
TECHNOLOGY
LEADERSHIP
POLITICS URBAN THEFUTURE
BUSINESS
HUMANS
EMOTIONS 39
4011
First Bricklayers Residence Massing and Shape Modeling
41
Bricklayers Residence Design Evolution and Units
Commercial Square base 15m x 15m
Floor Shape
Elevator Shaft
Community Space
Square + Sacred Geometry 42
Bricklayers Residence and Section
The FloorPlans
The facade attempts to reflect the local character with the use of materials and colors widely used in the proximate surrounding areas with state-of-the-art brick walls and fenestrations. During the analysis several “inspirational tools” have been adopted, one is surely the golden color elements among the typical red bricks, which highlights the contrasts and emanates a sense of diversity and at the same time precious integration. Another color and material inspiration comes from the latest built detached houses on Alice Street which features a compact yet spacious use of open air private space and another house at the intersection between Rothsay St and Alice St. The former is the Capacity House, a beautifully designed four storeys brick building featuring transparent glass perimetered balconies.
Upper Floor + Innovation
The upper floor, fifteen storeys above ground, at an altitude of __ is a resident community space with a flexible and open space program. It is designed and added to the compacted residential floors below, to create value and space for the residents of the building. With a __ sq meters wide triangular shaped open space where rosemary and others are growed, also allowing the residents with less balcony floor to experience the openair without leaving the building. At the same time, this wide open space has been outlined to have two main areas: One where noise is reduced to allow users like young students to rest and/or concentrate around a shared library and comfortable armchairs. And another more dynamic and active place where games and recreational activities can take place freely, not far from some vending machines or eventually open bars with similar technologies to Amazon Go, adding the payment of a water bottle to the rent with face recognition cameras.
PLAN where is located
43
Bricklayers Residence Exploded and Section
44
Bricklayers Residence Vignette, Last Floor Interiors and Balcony View
Private Community Space The upper floor, fifteen storeys above grround I designed a resident’s community space with flexible and open space program, It is designed and added to the floors below to create value and space for the residents of the building. With open space on the northen-west corner where to perhaps grow Rosemary and other essential plants. This allows residents to experience open air without leaving the building , very usefulin extreme cases like pandemies. At the same time this wide interior space has been outline to have two man areas: Onr where noise is reduced to allow users like young students to rest and/or concentrate around a shared library and comfortable chairs, on the eastern wing. Another more dynamic and active space where table games and recreational activities can take place freely on the western wing. Innovation: An interesting idea could be to create virtual governance inside the space and installvending machines or eventually open bars with similar technology to Amazon Go, adding payment of water and chips to the individual’s rent with face recognition cameras.
45
The Lobby With a space dedicated to the circulation of residents, dedication of portmen and their office (along with restroom and changing room amenities) the residential podium level features indoor planting and comfortable seatings for guests. The space has been set to intuitively and easily stimulate movement through the space, while creating interaction and care spaces where residents can randomly meet and interact on the way in or out. At the same time for both privacy reasons (and potentially social distance ones) the front desk for the portmen is designed to separate confidential or private service requests of a resident to the portman on one side (closer to the elevators lobby) and general enquiries of guests or deliveries on the more colloquial and open one.
Commercial / Public Facility
Reflective : Overall the idea was to create a space that would be efficient circulation in events of fire yet offer pleasant surprises like indoor planting and vistas, as well as more intimate and short privacy concerning conversations, now you can ask your trusted portman to let your secretary in without signing her in or letting your wife know it
D es
N
th r o
k
Office
Service
Prioress Street
46
Foundation and Structures Not to be considered engineered but rather sketched to provide a dimentional framework to facilitate planning. The shape of the building facilitate the sunlight to cover at least 60 % of the building facade. A concrete core positionated on the north edge would hold the elevators and staircases while 17 perimitral pillars and 9 internal would hold this 15 storeys building.
47
48
Cad Initial Elevations
49
Final Elevations and Parallel Projections of Bricklayers Residence
501
Bricklayers Residence Interiors Speculation
51
Bricklayers Residence Fenestration Study
52
Bricklayers Residence Quoted Plan The typical oor plans are envisioned to maximise residential comfort , space use accessibility to open air and sunlight. There are four ats on the oor, different sizes and shapes yet all of them with interaction and privacy at their core. In fact the kitchen plans, with maximum exposure to sunlight and air to stimulate positive familiar behavior and at the same time an almost natural movement between daytime/recreative common areas with the more private and intimate zones of the house. Bathrooms and bedrooms are placed and planned to minimise sound or noise disturbance from the rest of the rooms and/or neighbours.
53
Bricklayers Residence Plan
Bricklayers Place \ SE1
Balc.
Balc.
Be.1 Be.1
L. & D.
Balc.
L. & D. Balc. Ba. 2
K.
K.
Be.1
Ba. 2
M. Be. Ba.1
K. L. & D.
Ba. 1
Be.1
Ba.1 M. Be.
M. Be.
M. Be.
Be.1
L. & D. Be.1
Balc.
Ba.1 K. Balc. Be.1
Prioress Street
Bricklayers Residence Plan and Unit Informations
Apartment 1 99 Sq Meters
Apartment 2 86 Sq Meters
Balc.
Balc.
Be.1
Apartment 3 52 Sq Meters Be.1
L. & D.
Balc.
L. & D. Balc. Ba. 2
K.
K.
Be.1
Ba. 2
M. Be. Ba.1
K. L. & D.
Ba. 1
Be.1
Ba.1 M. Be.
M. Be.
M. Be.
Be.1
L. & D. Be.1
Balc.
Ba.1 K. Balc. Be.1
Prioress Street
Apartment 4 72 Sq Meters
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
6211