Table of Cases
CJEU
Case C-9/93 IHT Internationale Heiztechnik GmbH and Uwe Danzinger v Ideal-Standard GmbH and Wabco Standard GmbH EU:C:1994:261 165n19
Case C-251/95 SABEL BV v Puma AG, Rudolf Dassler Sport (CJEU) EU:C:1997:528 2n7, 5n25, 6–7, 6n30, 8n43, 17, 17n2, 32n111, 65n322, 66, 67n8, 68, 68n10, 87–88, 88n79, 134n1, 135, 135n4, 135n8, 147n71, 157, 157n140, 160n1, 161, 161n5, 164, 164n15, 164n16, 164n17, 166n23, 181n107, 198n208, 246n66
Case C-210/96 Gut Springenheide GmbH v Oberkreisdirektor des Kreises Steinfurt
EU:C:1998:369
172n55, 186n141, 215n50
Case C-39/97 Canon Kabushiki Kaisha v Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer Inc. (CJEU)
EU:C:1998:442 . . . . . .
. 5n21, 6, 6n27, 7, 9, 10, 10n46, 17n10, 104n2, 106, 106n10, 107n15, 114, 124, 124n141, 125n154, 127, 133, 136, 136n11, 136n12, 137n13, 147n71, 147n73, 157n141, 160n4, 162–63, 162n7, 183n119, 198n208
Case C-39/97 Canon Kabushiki Kaisha v Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer Inc. (AGO)
EU:C:1998:159
106n12, 107n15
Case C-108/97 Windsurfing Chiemsee Produktions-und Vertriebs GmbH (WSC) v Boots-und Segelzubehör Walter Huber and Franz Attenberger EU:C:1999:230 139–40, 140n30, 147
Case C-342/97 Lloyd Schuhfabrik Meyer & Co GmbH v Klijsen Handel BV (CJEU)
EU:C:1999:323 17, 17n5, 19, 68n10, 137, 137n16, 139–40, 140n29, 140n31, 141–42, 141n38, 147, 147n69, 147n70, 147n72, 148, 172n55, 178n88, 198n208
Case C-342/97 Lloyd Schuhfabrik Meyer & Co GmbH v Klijsen Handel BV (AGO)
EU:C:1998:522 184n122
Case C-425/98 Marca Mode CV v Adidas AG (CJEU) EU:C:2000:339 7n32, 137, 137n17, 147n71, 147n73, 183, 183n117, 225, 225n102
Case C-425/98 Marca Mode CV v Adidas AG (AGO) EU:C:2000:56 . . . . 183n119, 184n123, 225n103
Case C-291/00 LTJ Diffusion SA v Sadas Vertbaudet SA EU:C:2003:169
Case C-292/00 Davidoff & Cie SA and Zino Davidoff SA v Gofkid Ltd EU:C:2003:9
Joined Cases C-53/01 to C-55/01 Linde AG, Windward Industries and Rado Uhren AG EU:C:2003:206
Case C-104/01 Libertel Groep BV v Benelux-Merkenbureau (AGO) EU:C:2002:650 [2003] ECR I-3793 .
Case C-191/01 P Wrigley v OHIM EU:C:2003:579
Case C-206/01 Arsenal Football Club v Reed EU:C:2002:651
3n11, 17n1
3n10
146n61
233n10, 234, 234n16, 241n49
42n180
2n6, 3n9, 193n189, 219n72, 226–28, 226n111, 237n32
Case C-408/01 Adidas v Fitnessworld (AGO) EU:C:2003:404, [2003] ECR I-12537 17n3, 246n67
Case C-136/02 P Mag Instrument Inc. v OHIM EU:C:2004:592 241n49
Case C-245/02 Anheuser-Busch Inc. v Budĕjovický Budvar np EU:C:2004:717 3n9, 190n168, 227, 227n114, 228
Case C-404/02 Nichols v Registrar of Trade Marks EU:C:2004:538 144, 144n50
Case C-3/03 P Matratzen Concord v OHIM EU:C:2004:233 69n12
Case C-106/03 Vedial v OHIM EU:C:2004:611 163n8
Case C-228/03 The Gillette Company and Gillette Group Finland Oy v LA-Laboratories Ltd Oy EU:C:2005:177 .
Case C-353/03 Societe des Produits Nestle SA v Mars UK Ltd EU:C:2005:432
Case C-120/04 Medion AG v Thomson multimedia Sales Germany & Austria GmbH EU:C:2005:594
12–13
67n5
67n2, 70, 70n14, 74, 74n36, 99, 100–1, 155–56, 156n134
Case C-206/04 P Mülhens v OHIM EU:C:2006:194
Case C-361/04 P Ruiz-Picasso v OHIM (CJEU) EU:C:2006:25 .
19n14, 47n202
46n199, 62–63, 62n305, 154n123, 154n126, 210–11, 211n28, 218, 218n68, 219–20, 227, 227n116, 228n118, 229n124
xiv Table of Cases
Case C-361/04 P Ruiz-Picasso v OHIM (AGO) EU:C:2005:531 . .
Case C-416/04 P Sunrider v OHIM EU:C:2006:310 .
Case C-24/05 P August Storck v OHIM EU:C:2006:421 . .
218n70
108n21
218n67
Case C-48/05 Adam Opel AG v Autec AG EU:C:2007:55 3n9
Case C-145/05 Levi Strauss & Co. v Casucci SpA EU:C:2006:264 156n137
Case C-214/05 P Rossi v OHIM EU:C:2006:494 117n89, 117n90, 117–18, 118n95, 121, 121n117, 122n129
Case C-235/05 P L’Oréal v OHIM EU:C:2006:271 73n31, 143n46, 143n48, 157n147, 162n7, 198n209, 199n214
Case C-334/05 P OHIM v Shaker EU:C:2007:333 71, 71n19, 74, 74n37
Case C-412/05 P Alcon Inc v OHIM (CJEU) EU:C:2007:252 170n46, 176n74, 179n94, 182n109, 219n73
Case C-412/05 P Alcon Inc v OHIM (AGO) EU:C:2006:687 219n73, 219n74
Case C-16/06 P Les Éditions Albert René Sarl v OHIM EU:C:2008:739 . . . . . . . . . . . . . 23n49, 46n200
Case C-17/06 Céline SARL v Céline SA EU:C:2007:497 . . .
Case C-171/06 P T.I.M.E. ART v OHIM EU:C:2007:171. . . . .
10, 10n50
48n216, 129–30, 130n195, 143, 143n45, 157n145, 190n166, 198n210
Case C-193/06 P Nestlé v OHIM EU:C:2007:539 . . . . .
Case C-196/06 P Alecansan v OHIM EU:C:2007:159 .
Case C-234/06 P Il Ponte Finanzaria v OHIM EU:C:2007:514 .
Case C-488/06 P L&D v OHIM EU:C:2008:420 .
74n36
120n112
163n8, 165n21, 194, 194n192
.80n52, 80n53
Case C-533/06 O2 Holdings Ltd v Hutchison 3G UK Ltd EU:C:2008:339 188n156, 189n159, 190n168, 209, 209n18
Case C-102/07 Adidas AG v Marca Mode (CJEU) EU:C:2008:217 30n92, 163n13
Case C-252/07 Intel Corp Inc v CPM United Kingdom Ltd EU:C:2008:655 221n84, 221n85
Case C-398/07 P Waterford Wedgwood v Assembled Investments (Proprietary) and OHIM EU:C:2009:288 119n108
Case C-487/07 L’Oréal SA v Bellure NV EU:C:2009:378 3n9, 4n20
Case C-495/07 Silberquelle GmbH v Maselli Strickmode GmbH (AGO) EU:C:2008:633 219n75
Case C-498/07 P Aceites del Sur-Coosur SA v Koipe Corporación SL, OHIM EU:C:2009:503 .
179n90, 185n133, 218n63
Joined Cases C-236/08, 238/08 & C-237/08 Google France Sarl v Louis Vuitton Malletier (CJEU) EU:C:2010:159
3n9, 4n14, 6, 6n28, 181n105, 209–11, 210n22, 211n26, 213, 224n100
Joined Cases C-236/08 to C-238/08, Google France SARL v Louis Vuitton Malletier SA (AGO) EU:C:2009:569
Case C-278/08 Die BergSpechte Outdoor Reisen und Alpinschule Edi Koblmüller GmbH v Günther Guni and trekking.at Reisen GmbH EU:C:2010:163 .
216n56
. . . . . 3n9, 6, 6n29, 25–26, 26n77, 209–11, 209n20, 210n24, 213, 224n100
Case C-558/08 Portakabin Ltd v Primakabin BV EU:C:2010:416
210–11, 211n27, 213
Case C-23/09 ecoblue AG v OHIM EU:C:2010:35 78n44
Case C-48/09 P Lego Juris v OHIM EU:C:2010:516 14, 14n66, 234n19
Case C-51/09 P Becker v Harman International Industries EU:C:2010:368 67n4, 72n23, 102, 102n152
Case C-159/09 Lidl SNC v Vierzon Distribution SA (CJEU) EU:C:2010:696 222n87
Case C-159/09 Lidl SNC v Vierzon Distribution SA (AGO) EU:C:2010:499 222n87
Case C-254/09 P Calvin Klein Trademark Trust v OHIM, Zafra Marroquineros SL EU:C:2010:488 163n9
Case C-323/09 Interflora Inc and another v Marks and Spencer plc EU:C:2011:604 3n9
Case C-353/09 P Perfetti Van Melle v OHIM EU:C:2011:73
72, 72n26
Case C-482/09 Budějovicky Budvar, národní podnik, v Anheuser-Busch Inc, EU:C:2011:605 . . . . . 185n133
Case C-552/09 P Ferrero SpA v OHIM EU:C:2011:177
Case C-46/10 Viking Gas A/S v Kosan Gas A/S, previously BP Gas A/S (CJEU) EU:C:2011:485
Case C-46/10 Viking Gas A/S v Kosan Gas A/S, previously BP Gas A/S (AGO) EU:C:2011:222
.18n12, 163n9
194n190
194n190
Case C-119/10 Frisdranken Industrie Winters BV v Red Bull GmbH (AGO) ECLI:EU:C:2011:258 4n15
Table of Cases xv
Case C-216/10 P Lufthansa AirPlus Servicekarten v OHIM EU:C:2010:719 . . . . . . . . 31n103, 39n167
Case C 307/10 Chartered Institute of Patent Attorneys v Registrar of Trade Marks EU:C:2012:361 . . .
188n157
Case C-317/10 P Union Investment Privatfonds v UniCredito Italiano EU:C:2011:405 22n46, 195n196
Case C-370/10 P Ravensburger v OHIM EU:C:2011:149 96n121
Case C-388/10 P Muñoz Arraiza v OHIM EU:C:2011:185 126n163
Case C-532/10 P adp Gauselmann v OHIM EU:C:2011:433 31n104, 47n201, 101n147, 178n83
Case C-196/11 P Formula One Licensing v OHIM EU:C:2012:314 140n32, 202n228
Case C-198/11 P Lan Airlines v OHIM EU:C:2012:289 46n196
Case C-327/11 P United States Polo Association v OHIM EU:C:2012:550 21–22n36, 41, 48n222
Case C-354/11 P Maurice Emram v OHIM, Guccio Gucci SpA, EU:C:2012:167 190n167
Case C-406/11 P Atlas v OHIM EU:C:2012:136 106n8, 109n31, 118n99
Case C-655/11 P Seven for all mankind v Seven EU:C:2013:94 .
Case C-12/12 Colloseum Holding AG v Levi Strauss & Co EU:C:2013:253
Case C-42/12 P Hrbek v OHIM EU:C:2012:765 .
Case C-252/12 Specsavers International Healthcare Ltd v Asda Stores Ltd EU:C:2013:497 . .
146n65
67n6
157n145
130n198, 155, 155n132, 189n162, 189–90n164
Case C-268/12 P Cadila Healthcare v OHMI EU:C:2013:296. . .
125n148, 127n174, 186n139
Case C-281/12 Trento Sviluppo srl, Centrale Adriatica Soc. coop. arl v Autorità Garante della Concorrenza e del Mercato EU:C:2013:859 .
228n122
Case C-422/12 P Industrias Alen v The Clorox Company EU:C:2014:57 20n21
Case C-558/12 P OHIM v riha WeserGold Getranke GmbH EU:C:2014:22 163n8
Case C-591/12 P Bimbo v OHIM EU:C:2014:305 67n3, 72, 72n28, 90n97, 142n42
Case C-597/12 P Isdin v Bial-Portela EU:C:2013:672 106n9
Case C-205/13 Hauck GmbH v Stokke (AGO) EU:C:2014:322 233n11
Joined Cases C-581/13 P and C-582/13 P Intra-Presse SAS v OHIM, Golden Balls Ltd EU:C:2014:2387 60n297, 177n81
Case C-670/13 P The Cartoon Network Inc v OHIM, Boomerang TV SA EU:C:2014:2024 171n53, 185n132
C-20/14 BGW Marketing - & Management- Service GmbH v Bodo Scholz EU:C:2015:714 . . . . . 64n314
Case C-142/14 P Sunrider v OHIM EU:C:2015:371 .
Case C-270/14 P Debonair Trading Internacional v OHIM EU:C:2015:688
Case C-579/14 P Junited Autoglas Deutschland v OHMI EU:C:2015:374
Case C-603/14 P El Corte Inglés v OHIM EU:C:2015:807
Case C-43/15 P BSH Bosch und Siemens Hausgeräte GmbH v EUIPO, LG Electronics Inc EU:C:2016:837 .
Case C-190/15 P Fetim v OHIM EU:C:2015:778
113n60, 113n65
29, 195n198
59n285
18n12, 60n298
198n212
157n142, 198n211
Case C-223/15 Combit Software GmbH v Commit Business Solutions Ltd EU:C:2016:719. . . . . .178n87
Case C-278/15 P Royal County of Berkshire Polo Club v OHIM EU:C:2016:20 21–22n36
Case C-562/15 Carrefour Hypermarchés SAS v ITM Alimentaire International SASU (CJEU) EU:C:2017:95 222, 222n88, 222n90
Case C-562/15 Carrefour Hypermarchés SAS v ITM Alimentaire International SASU (AGO) EU:C:2016:781 222n90
Case C-84/16 P Continental Reifen Deutschland v Compagnie générale des établissements Michelin and EUIPO EU:C:2017:596 65n316, 65n318
Case C-93/16 Ornua Co-operative Limited v Tindale & Stanton Ltd España, SL EU:C:2017:571 185n133
Case C-163/16 Christian Louboutin SAS v Van Haren Schoenen BV EU:C:2018:423 . . . . . . . 254n110
Case C-361/16 P Franmax v EUIPO EU:C:2016:834
Case C 395/16 DOCERAM GmbH v CeramTec GmbH EU:C:2018:172
Case C-402/16 P Market Watch v EUIPO EU:C:2016:924 .
Case C-437/16 P Wolf Oil v EUIPO EU:C:2017:737
Case C-224/17 P Hernández Zamora v EUIPO and Rosen Tantau EU:C:2017:791
49n233, 55n260
234n19
36n150
47n207
104n2
Case C-726/17 P Tetra Pharm (1997) Ltd v EUIPO, Sebapharma GmbH EU:C:2018:561 .
Case C-371/18 [2018] OJ C 276 (6 Aug 2018) . . .
177n81
171n51
Case C-449/18 P [2018] OJ C 392/3 (29 Oct 2018) 169n40
GENERAL COURT
Case T-6/01 Matratzen Concord v OHMI EU:T:2002:261 69, 69n11, 69n13, 71, 73, 73n34, 77, 93n112, 94
Case T-99/01 Mystery Drinks GmbH v OHIM EU:T:2003:7 .
Case T-104/01 Oberhauser v OHIM EU:T:2002:262 .
Case T-129/01 José Alejandro v OHIM EU:T:2003:184 .
Case T-292/01 Phillips Van Heusen Corp v OHIM EU:T:2003:264
Case T-317/01 M+M v OHMI EU:T:2004:195 . . . . . . . .
Case T-115/02 AVEX v OHIM EU:T:2004:234 .
Case T-183/02 El Corte Inglés v OHMI (MUNICOR) EU:T:2004:79
19–20, 20n16
. 84–85, 84n64, 84n66, 105n4
49n229, 86n76
47n203
106n8
95n117
32n112, 47n211
Case T-185/02 Ruiz-Picasso v OHMI EU:T:2004:189 154n122
Case T-186/02 BMI Bertollo v OHIM EU:T:2004:197 143n43
Case T-194/03 Il Ponte Finanziaria v OHMI EU:T:2006:65 22n46, 22n48, 165n21, 195n195
Case T-286/02 Oriental Kitchen v OHMI EU:T:2003:311 74n38, 77n40
Case T-356/02 Vitakraft-Werke Wührmann v OHIM EU:T:2004:292 91n105, 93n111
Case T-359/02 Chum v OHIM EU:T:2005:156 85n70, 86n74
Case T-112/03 L’Oréal v OHIM EU:T:2005:102 143n46, 157n145
Case T-117/03 New Look v OHIM EU:T:2004:293 27, 86n76, 89n88
Case T-126/03 Reckitt Benckiser (España), SL v OHIM EU:T:2005:288 111n43, 154n128, 171n54
Case T-153/03 Inex v OHIM EU:T:2006:157 95n117
Case T-169/03 Sergio Rossi v OHMI EU:T:2005:72
Case T-312/03 Wassen International v OHMI EU:T:2005:289
117, 117n89, 122n129, 129, 129n193
78n46
Case T-385/03 Miles Handelsgesellschaft International mbH v OHIM EU:T:2005:276. . . . . 49n228, 89n87
Case T-389/03 Dainichiseika Colour & Chemicals Mfg Co Ltd v OHMI EU:T:2008:114
30, 30n94, 52n250
Case T-418/03 La Mer Technology Inc v OHIM EU:T:2007:299 . . . . .111n44, 115n74, 125n149, 128n179
Case T-3/04 Simonds Farsons Cisk v OHMI EU:T:2005:418
Case T-7/04 Shaker v OHMI EU:T:2008:481 .
.80n52, 81n56
157n147
Case T-29/04 Castellblanch SA v OHIM EU:T:2005:438 132n208
Case T-34/04 Plus v OHMI EU:T:2005:248 50n240
Case T-150/04 Mülhens v OHMI EU:T:2007:214 122n130
Case T 202/04 Madaus v OHIM, Optima Healthcare ECLI:EU:T:2006:106 182n111
Case T-256/04 Mundipharma v OHMI EU:T:2007:46 47n213, 183n115
Case T-333/04 House of Donuts v OHMI EU:T:2007:105 58n277, 77n41
Case T-346/04 Sadas SA v OHIM, LTJ Diffusion EU:T:2005:420 184n126
Joined Cases T-350/04 to T-352/04 Bitburger Brauerei v OHIM EU:T:2006:330 20n17
Case T-363/04 Koipe Corporación SL v OHIM, Aceites del Sur SA EU:T:2007:264 179n90
Case T-88/05 Quelle AG v OHMI EU:T:2007:45
Case T-105/05 Assembled Investments (Proprietary) v OHMI EU:T:2007:170
Case T-133/05 Meric v OHMI EU:T:2006:247
Case T-328/05 Apple Computer v OHIM, TKS-Teknosoft EU:T:2008:238
19n15, 22n45, 26
119n108
90n89
171n53
Case T-443/05 El Corte Inglés SA v OHIM EU:T:2007:219 . . . . 109n30, 121n125, 122n132, 124n142
Case T-48/06 Astex Therapeutics Ltd v OHIM EU:T:2008:329 . . .112n55, 114n68, 119n104, 182n111
Case T-112/06 Inter-Ikea v OHMI EU:T:2008:10
Case T-116/06 Oakley v OHMI EU:T:2008:399 .
Case T-134/06 Xentral LLC v OHIM EU:T:2007:387. .
47n204, 81n54
120, 120n114
. .95n118, 143n46, 157n146, 199n215
Case T-149/06 Castellani SpA v OHIM EU:T:2007:350 21n33
Case T-175/06 Coca-Cola v OHMI EU:T:2008:212 108n24, 109n29, 119n107, 127n171
Case T-205/06 NewSoft Technology v OHMI EU:T:2008:163 78n46
Case T-221/06 Hipp & Co KG v OHIM EU:T:2009:330 31n101, 31n102, 47n212, 157n142
Case T-228/06 Giorgio Beverly Hills v OHMI EU:T:2008:558 90n95
Case T-246/06 Redcats v OHMI EU:T:2008:141 48n217
Case T-303/06 UniCredito Italiano v OHMI EU:T:2010:160 22n46, 195n196
Case T-303/06 RENV UniCredito v OHMI EU:T:2014:988 22n46, 195n197
Case T-340/06 Stradivarius Espana SA v OHIM EU:T:2008:241 61n302
Case T-363/06 Honda Motor Europe Ltd v OHIM EU:T:2008:319 . . . . . . . 65n315, 130n195, 157n142
Case T 95/07 Aventis Pharma v OHIM, Nycomed EU:T:2008:455 . . .
Case T-106/07 Alcon v OHMI EU:T:2008:340 . . . . . .
Case T-109/07 L’Oréal SA v OHIM, Spa Monopole EU:T:2009:81 . .
Table of Cases xvii
182n113
183n115
166n26
Case T-118/07 PPTV v OHIM EU:T:2011:58 76, 94n115, 106n8, 123n134
Case T-290/07 MIP Metro Group Intellectual Property GmbH & Co KG v OHIM
EU:T:2008:562 83n61
Case T-316/07 Commercy v OHMI EU:T:2009:14 116n81, 117n88, 123n133
Case T-321/07 Lufthansa AirPlus Servicekarten v OHIM EU:T:2010:64 31n103
Case T-357/07 Focus Magazin Verlag v OHMI EU:T:2008:581 92n106
Case T-366/07 Procter & Gamble v OHMI EU:T:2010:394 90n90
Case T-386/07 Peek & Clopenburg v OHIM EU:T:2009:420 25n75
Case T-413/07 Bayerische Gesellschaft fur Innovation und Wissenstransfer mbH v OHIM EU:T:2009:34 27n81
Case T-435/07 New Look v OHIM EU:T:2008:534 .
Case T-486/07 Ford Motor Company v OHIM EU:T:2011:104
Case T-502/07 Intersport International Corp. GmbH v OHIM EU:T:2011:223. .
Case T-5/08 Nestle v OHIM EU:T:2010:123
Case T-24/08 Weldebräu v OHIM EU:T:2010:71 .
Case T-33/08 Bastos Viegas v OHIM EU:T:2009:197 .
Case T-80/08 CureVac GmbH v OHIM EU:T:2009:416
Case T-84/08 Intesa Sanpaolo SpA v OHIM EU:T:2011:144. .
178n86
179n92, 220n80
21n32, 62n303
37n159, 38
145, 145n59, 235, 235n20, 246n68
132n207
21n30
. 24n56, 31n105, 32n110, 85n72
Case T-148/08 Beifa Group Co. Ltd v OHMI EU:T:2010:190 63, 235–36n22
Case T-149/08 Abbott Laboratories v OHIM, aRigen Inc, EU:T:2010:398 183n116
Case T-162/08 Frag Comercio Internacional v OHMI EU:T:2009:432 74, 95n120
Case T-201/08 Market Watch v OHMI EU:T:2010:408 23n55, 35n143
Case T-243/08 Ravensburger v OHIM EU:T:2010:210 96n121
Case T-260/08 Indo Internacional v OHMI EU:T:2012:23 25n70, 33n126, 59n281
Case T-277/08 Bayer Healthcare v OHIM EU:T:2009:433 128n175
Case T-288/08 Cadila Healthcare v OHMI EU:T:2012:124 125n148
Case T-292/08 Inditex v OHIM EU:T:2010:399 31n102, 36n145
Case T-331/08 REWE-Zentral v OHIM EU:T:2010:23
Case T-361/08 Peek & Cloppenberg and van Graaf v OHIM EU:T:2010:152
Case T-364/08 2nine v OHIM EU:T:2010:115
Case T-407/08 MIP Metro v OHIM EU:T:2010:256
Case T-466/08 Lancome Parfums et Beaute & Cie v OHIM EU:T:2011:182
Case T-472/08 Companhia Muller de Bebdias v OHIM EU:T:2010:347
Case T-477/08 Mundipharm v OHIM EU:T:2010:72
.23n54, 25n76
. 32n107, 37, 37n158, 40n170, 47n210
121n119, 124n142
157n142
21n35, 25n72, 50n241
20n17, 49n235, 65n320, 97n127
21n26, 123n135
Case T-483/08 Giordano Enterprises Ltd v OHMI EU:T:2009:515 117n91, 121n120, 122, 122n131
Case T-487/08 Kureha Corp v OHIM EU:T:2010:237 20n19
Case T-488/08 Galileo International Technology LLC v OHIM EU:T:2011:574 41n174
Case T-490/08 CM Capital Markets v OHMI EU:T:2010:250 88, 88n80, 88n83
Case T-501/08 NEC Display Solutions Europe v OHIM EU:T:2011:527 39n169, 40–41, 57n268, 118n96, 157n142
Case T-557/08 mPAY24 v OHIM EU:T:2010:287 157n142
Case T-580/08 PJ Hungary v OHIM EU:T:2011:227 21n27, 33n123, 151n101, 153n112
Case T-10/09 Formula One Licensing v OHMI EU:T:2014:1061 34n129
Case T-30/09 Engelhorn v OHIM EU:T:2010:298
Case T-41/09 Hipp v OHIM EU:T:2012:163 .
Case T-76/09 Mundipharma v OHMI EU:T:2011:298 .
Case T-106/09 adp Gauselmann v OHMI EU:T:2010:380
Case T-129/09 Bongrain v OHIM EU:T:2011:193
Case T-131/09 Farmeco v OHMI EU:T:2010:458
Case T-138/09 Munoz Arraiza v OHMI EU:T:2010:226
Case T-189/09 Poloplast v OHIM EU:T:2011:611
27n79, 67n7, 144n51
33n119, 146n67
120n113
31n104, 36n156, 101n147
115n77, 126n164, 126n168
74, 85n70, 85n71
126n163
65n315
Case T-194/09 Lan Airlines v OHIM EU:T:2011:34 46n196
xviii Table of Cases
Case T-203/09 Olymp Bezner GmbH & Co. KG v OHIM EU:T:2011:195 . . . . . . . . . . . 40n170, 85n73
Case T-209/09 Alder Capital Ltd v OHIM EU:T:2011:169 . . . .
. 22n39, 36n151
Case T 220/09 Ergo Versicherungsgruppe v OHIM, Société de développement et de recherche industrielle EU:T:2011:392 176n75
Case T-228/09 United States Polo Association v OHMI EU:T:2011:170 21–22n36
Case T-244/09 Accenture Global Services v OHIM EU:T:2010:430 157n144
Case T-274/09 Deutsche Bahn v OHMI EU:T:2011:451 30n99, 64n312, 148n76, 150n89, 150n93, 153n114, 157n142
Case T-276/09 Kavaklidere-Europe v OHMI EU:T:2012:313 36n147, 108n22
Case T-301/09 IG Communications Ltd v OHIM EU:T:2012:473 24n65
Case T-307/09 Earle Beauty v OHIM EU:T:2010:509 178n86
Case T-344/09 Hearst Communications v OHMI EU:T:2012:324 45n195, 46n198, 47n205
Case T-365/09 Michalakopoulou Ktimatiki Touristiki AE v OHIM EU:T:2010:455 111n47
Case T-376/09 Glenton España v OHMI EU:T:2011:225
Case T-385/09 Annco Inc v OHIM EU:T:2011:49
38–39, 38n161, 49n223
Case T-415/09 New Yorker SHK Jeans GmbH & Co KG v OHIM EU:T:2011:550.
Case T-425/09 Honda Motor v OHMI EU:T:2011:576
Case T-437/09 Oyster Cosmetics SpA v OHIM EU:T:2011:23
Case T-39/10 El Corte Inglés SA v OHIM EU:T:2012:502
Case T-60/10 Jackson International v OHMI EU:T:2012:348
Case T-74/10 Flaco-Geräte GmbH v OHIM EU:T:2011:207
58n272, 101n142
58n280
128n176, 142n42, 143n49
21n25
122n126
78n45
218n66
Case T-77/10 Certmedica International v OHMI EU:T:2012:95 24n58, 34n137, 112n56, 114n73
Case T-88/10 Inter IKEA Systems v OHMI EU:T:2011:368 25n75, 40–41, 40n172
Case T-107/10 Procter & Gamble Manufacturing Cologne v OHMI EU:T:2011:551 34n135, 34n139
Case T-150/10 Telefónica O2 Germany v OHMI EU:T:2011:552 119n102, 125n152, 128n185
Case T-157/10 Barilla v OHIM EU:T:2012:148 36n152, 143n47, 157n142, 158n151
Case T-161/10 Longevity Health Products v OHMI EU:T:2011:244 24n61, 33n120, 109n34, 112n51, 115n75, 125n147, 132n207
Case T-204/10 Lancôme v OHMI EU:T:2012:523 146n64
Case T-216/10 Monster Cable Products v OHMI EU:T:2011:691 48n215
Case T-238/10 Stephanie Scatizza v OHIM EU:T:2011:613
Case T-244/10 Tsakiris-Mallas v OHMI EU:T:2012:219
Case T-273/10 Olive Line International v OHMI EU:T:2012:246
Case T-304/10 dm-drogerie markt v OHMI EU:T:2011:602
Case T-342/10 Hartmann v OHMI EU:T:2012:290
Case T-356/10 Nike International v OHMI EU:T:2011:543
Case T-357/10 Kraft Foods Schweiz v OHMI EU:T:2012:312.
Case T-377/10 Preparados Alimenticios v OHMI EU:T:2013:600
39n165
39n164, 49n227, 89n86, 97n126, 144n54, 157n142
52n250, 88n81, 157n142
31n100, 39n168
24n59, 36n146, 111n41, 119n105
33n124
34n139, 59n283, 76, 84n67
39n166, 84n67, 150n86, 152n104, 152n108
Case T-424/10 Dosenbach-Ochsner v OHMI EU:T:2012:58 28, 28n85, 29n90, 30, 54n257, 55
Case T-444/10 ESGE v OHMI EU:T:2013:89 45n194
Case T-483/10 The Pukka Luggage v OHMI EU:T:2011:692 108n28, 128n178
Case T-500/10 Dorma v OHIM EU:T:2011:679 19n14
Case T-517/10 Pharmazeutische Fabrik Evers v OHMI EU:T:2012:372 39n168, 40–41, 40n171, 59n291, 60n300
Case T-519/10 Seikoh Giken v OHMI EU:T:2012:291 35n141, 48n219
Case T-522/10 Hell Energy Magyarország v OHMI EU:T:2012:9 25n75, 32n114
Case T-549/10 Natura Selection v OHMI EU:T:2014:949
Case T-569/10 Bimbo v OHMI EU:T:2012:535
Case T-584/10 Yilmaz v OHMI EU:T:2012:518
Case T-585/10 Aitic Penteo v OHMI EU:T:2012:251
Case T-586/10 Aktieselskabet af 21. november 2001 v OHMI EU:T:2011:722
120n114
142n42
.108n23, 114n67, 119n107, 126n160
22n40, 130n195
63n310, 115n77, 154n127
Case T-66/11 Present-Service Ullrich GmbH & Co. KG v OHIM EU:T:2013:48
. 25n76, 36n155, 39n168, 59n288
Case T-89/11 Nanu-Nana Joachim Hoepp v OHMI EU:T:2015:479 118n97, 120n114
Table of Cases xix
Case T-97/11 Rovi Pharmaceuticals GmbH v OHIM EU:T:2013:474 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 110n35, 112n50, 125n148, 127n174
Case T-135/11 Clorox v OHMI EU:T:2012:356 . . . . . . . .
20n21
Case T-143/11 Consorzio vino Chianti Classico v OHIM EU:T:2012:645 44n186, 84n66, 84n67
Case T-179/11 Sports Eybl & Sports Experts GmbH EU:T:2012:254 33n125, 144n53
Case T-227/11 Wall v OHMI EU:T:2012:375 129n192
Case T-237/11 Lidl Stiftung v OHIM EU:T:2013:11 25n69, 108n26, 116n86, 125n156, 127n172, 158n151
Case T-295/11 Duscholux Ibérica v OHMI EU:T:2012:420 26, 26n77, 82n57
Case T-353/11 Event v OHMI EU:T:2013:147 76, 123n137
Case T-361/11 Hand Held Products v OHMI EU:T:2012:377 115n77, 116n83, 123n136, 127n170
Case T-393/11 Masottina SpA v OHIM EU:T:2013:24 25n68, 35n140, 59n289, 143n43
Case T-437/11 Golden Balls Ltd v OHIM EU:T:2013:441 25n67, 60n296, 157n143
Case T-450/11 Galileo International Technology v OHMI EU:T:2014:771 .
Case T-451/11 Gigabyte Technology v OHMI EU:T:2013:13 .
123n138
.35n142, 36n153, 109n32, 114n72, 125n153, 128n184
Case T-460/11 Scandic Distilleries v OHMI EU:T:2012:432. . . . . . . . 21n28, 38n162, 146n68, 157n142
Case T-467/11 Colgate Palmolive v OHIM EU:T:2013:633 .
Case T-504/11 Paul Hartmann AG v OHIM EU:T:2013:57 .
Case T-505/11 Aldi v OHIM EU:T:2013:332
Case T-514/11 i-content v OHMI EU:T:2013:291
90n91
. . . 108n25, 116n84, 117n89, 125n154
34n139
113n64, 124n142
Case T-528/11 Aloe Vera of America v OHMI EU:T:2014:10 52n252, 57n267
Case T-529/11 Evonik Industries v OHMI EU:T:2012:598 21n29, 33n122, 78n45, 86n75
Case T-537/11 Hultafors Group v OHMI EU:T:2013:207 22n42, 79n49
Case T-555/11 tesa SE v OHMI EU:T:2012:594 41n176, 93n113
Case T-558/11 Atlas v OHIM EU:T:2012:615 117n89
Case T-569/11 Gitana v OHIM EU:T:2013:462 22n38, 78n46, 125n146
Case T-580/11 McNeil AB v OHIM, Alkalon ApS, EU:T:2013:301 183n115
Case T-599/11 Eni v OHMI EU:T:2014:269 47n214
Case T-600/11 Schuhhaus Dielmann v OHMI EU:T:2014:33 79n50
Case T-623/11 Pico Food v OHMI EU:T:2014:199
Case T-624/11 Yueqing Onesto Electric v OHIM EU:T:2013:137
Case T-41/12 LS Fashion v OHMI EU:T:2015:125
Case T-54/12 K2 Sports Europe v OHMI EU:T:2013:50
Case T-55/12 Su-Shan Chen v AM Denmark A/S EU:T:2013:219
Case T-89/12 Repsol YPF v OHIM EU:T:2013:335
Case T-170/12 Beyond Retro v OHMI EU:T:2014:238
Case T-195/12 Nuna International v OHMI EU:T:2014:804
Case T-218/12 Micrus Endovascular v OHMI EU:T:2014:760
92n107
27, 59n282, 157n142
62n303
34n136, 93n108
64
65n315
45n193, 58n276, 111n42, 121n119
120n110, 124n142
113n59
Case T-221/12 Sunrider v OHIM EU:T:2014:25 113, 113n60, 113n65, 116n85, 119n106, 124n142
Case T-229/12 Advance Magazine Publishers v OHMI EU:T:2014:95 27
Case T-231/12 Rocket Dog Brands v OHIM EU:T:2013:264 97n124
Case T-247/12 Argo Group International Holdings v OHIM, Arisa Assurances (ARIS) EU:T:2014:258 171n49
Case T-285/12 The Cartoon Network v OHIM, Bommerang TV SA EU:T:2013:520 185n132
Case T-288/12 EI du Pont de Nemours v OHMI EU:T:2014:196 120n115
Case T-328/12 Mundipharma GmbH v OHIM, AFT Pharmaceuticals Ltd EU:T:2013:537 163n11
Case T-330/12 Hut.com v OHMI EU:T:2014:569 58n275
Case T-338/12 Rocket Dog Brands v OHIM EU:T:2013:327
Case T-342/12 Fuchs v OHIM EU:T:2014:858
Case T-361/12 Premiere Polish v OHIM EU:T:2013:630 .
Case T-356/12 Debonair Trading Internacional v OHMI EU:T:2014:178
Case T-378/12 Capitalizaciones Mercantiles v OHIM EU:T:2013:574
Case T-379/12 Electric Bike World v OHIM EU:T:2013:529
Case T-382/12 Kampol v OHMI EU:T:2014:563
Case T-383/12 Ferienhauser zem See v OHIM EU:T:2014:12
43n182
29n88, 30n92, 37n159
36n154, 36n156, 80n51, 81
23n52
65n316
108n27, 114n66, 124n145
130n195
74, 94n116, 157n142
Case T-388/12 Singer v OHIM EU:T:2013:536 59n290, 109n33, 111n48, 130n195
Case T-395/12 Fetim v OHMI EU:T:2015:92 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 87n77, 157n142, 158n148
Case T-423/12 Skype Ultd v OHIM, Sky Plc EU:T:2015:260. . . .
Case T-436/12 Deutsche Rockwool Mineralwoll v OHMI EU:T:2015:477 . .
151n102, 185n134
23n51
Case T-444/12 Novartis v OHMI EU:T:2014:886 43n182
Case T 445/12 Koscher + Würtz v OHMI EU:T:2014:829 25n75, 38–39n163, 220n79
Case T-453/12 Zoo Sports Ltd v OHIM, K-2 Corp EU:T:2013:532 180n100
Case T-480/12 Coca-Cola Company v OHMI EU:T:2014:1062 18n11
Case T-486/12 Golam v OHMI EU:T:2014:508 140n33
Case T-487/12 Eckes-Granini v OHIM EU:T:2013:637 45n195, 46n196, 76, 84n67
Case T-493/12 Sanofi v OHMI EU:T:2014:807 34n138, 112n53
Case T-502/12 Ferring v OHMI EU:T:2014:192 34n138, 65n321, 181n108, 182n113
Case T-505/12 Compagnie des montres Longines, Francillon v OHMI EU:T:2015:95 111n42, 130–31, 131n200
Case T-509/12 Advance Magazine Publishers v OHMI EU:T:2014:89
Case T-515/12 El Corte Inglés v OHIM EU:T:2014:882
Case T-516/12 Ted-Invest v OHMI EU:T:2014:811
Case T-523/12 Rani Refreshments v OHMI EU:T:2014:571
Case T-531/12 Tifosi Optics v OHMI EU:T:2014:855
Case T-533/12 IBSolution v OHMI EU:T:2013:582
Case T-544/12 Pensa Pharma v OHMI EU:T:2015:355
Case T-1/13 Advance Magazine Publishers v OHMI EU:T:2014:615 .
49n231, 78n42
60n298
118n98, 126n159
20n18
65n315, 106n8
33n121, 74, 78n48, 80, 157n142
36n148
59n286
Case T-12/13 Sherwin-Williams Sweden v OHMI EU:T:2014:1054 34n132, 91n105, 93n109
Case T-26/13 dm-drogerie markt v OHMI EU:T:2014:70 39n168
Case T-38/13 Pedro Group v OHMI EU:T:2014:241 151n103, 158n150
Case T-75/13 Boehringer Ingelheim Pharma v OHMI EU:T:2014:1017 110n35, 112n52, 113n57
Case T-76/13 Compagnie des montres Longines, Francillon v OHMI EU:T:2015:94 79
Case T-78/13 Red Bull v OHMI EU:T:2015:72 24n66
Case T-90/13 Herdade de S. Tiago II v OHMI EU:T:2014:778 54n256
Case T-122/13 Laboratoires Polive v OHMI EU:T:2014:863 39n168, 76
Case T-184/13 Skype v OHMI EU:T:2015:258 24n62, 150n90, 153n120, 155n129
Case T-227/13 Bayer Intellectual Property v OHMI EU:T:2015:120
Case T-254/13 Stayer Ibérica v OHMI EU:T:2015:362
. . 24n64, 33n117, 46n196
119n109
Case T-262/13 Skysoft Computersysteme v OHMI EU:T:2014:884 . 24n63, 34n134, 119n103, 129n188
Case T-265/13 Polo/Lauren v OHMI EU:T:2014:779
Case T-272/13 Max Mara Fashion Group v OHMI EU:T:2014:1020 .
Case T-282/13 Iglotex v OHMI EU:T:2015:226
Case T-297/13 Junited Autoglas Deutschland v OHMI EU:T:2014:893
Case T-324/13 Endoceutics v OHMI EU:T:2014:672
Case T-333/13 Westermann Lernspielverlag v OHMI EU:T:2015:490
60n295
34n139
34n131, 52n251
59n285
24n60, 33n118, 181n107
33n128
Case T-341/13 Groupe Léa Nature v OHMI EU:T:2014:802 74
Case T-350/13 Jordi Nogues v EUIPO EU:T:2017:633 52n253, 82n59
Case T-384/13 Intermark v OHMI EU:T:2015:158 73n33
Case T-388/13 Costa Crociere v OHMI EU:T:2015:118 119n101, 125n150
Case T-491/13 Perfetti Van Melle Benelux BV v OHIM, Intercontinental Great Brands LLC, EU:T:2015:979 202n231
Case T-514/13 AgriCapital v OHMI EU:T:2015:372 125n155
Case T-518/13 Future Enterprises Pte Ltd v EUIPO, McDonald’s EU:T:2016:389 195n195
Case T-521/13 Alpinestars Research v OHMI EU:T:2015:474 36n149
Case T-543/13 Three-N-Products v OHMI EU:T:2015:134
Case T-559/13 Giovanni Cosmetics v OHMI EU:T:2015:353.
Case T-581/13 Royal County of Berkshire Polo Club v OHMI EU:T:2015:192
Case T-608/13 easyGroup IP Licensing v OHMI EU:T:2015:282
Case T-645/13 Nezi v OHIM EU:T:2016:145
Case T-657/13 BH Stores v OHMI EU:T:2015:449
Case T-665/13 Zitro IP v OHMI EU:T:2015:55
45n194
63n308
21–22n36
84n67
126n165
109n30, 113n64, 116n79
90n98
Joined Cases T-711/13 and T-716/13 Harrys Pubar and Harry’s New York Bar v OHMI EU:T:2016:82 96n122, 120n114
Case T-715/13 Lidl Stiftung v OHMI EU:T:2015:256 . . . . . . .
Case T-717/13 Chair Entertainment Group v OHMI EU:T:2015:242 .
Table of Cases xxi
62n304, 74, 120n114
. . .25n71, 27n80
Case T-102/14 Deutsche Post AG v OHIM, PostNL Holding BV EU:T:2015:279 . . . . . . 202n229, 202n230
Case T-123/14 BSH v OHMI EU:T:2015:52 58n274
Case T-145/14 adidas v OHMI EU:T:2015:303 28n87
Case T-169/14 Ferring BV v OHIM, Kora Corp. EU:T:2015:280 220n80
Case T-194/14 Bristol Global Co. Ltd v OHIM EU:T:2016:42 22n37
Case T-197/14 La Zaragozana v OHMI EU:T:2015:313 34n139
Case T-210/14 Mederer GmbH v OHIM, Cadbury International Holdings EU:T:2016:105 199n217
Case T-273/14 Lithomex v OHMI EU:T:2015:352 32n116, 118n100
Case T-351/14 Construlink -Tecnologias de Informação, SA v EUIPO, Wit-Software EU:T:2017:101 176n74, 180n98, 180n103, 185n134
Case T-352/14 The Smiley Company v OHMI EU:T:2015:491 . . . . . . . . . . . . 32n115, 45n193, 120n114
Case T-369/14 Sequoia Capital operations v OHIM, Sequoia Capital, EU:T:2015:733 .
Case T-420/14 Wine in Black v OHMI EU:T:2015:312
Case T-485/14 Bon Net OOD v OHMI EU:T:2006:53.
Case T-535/14 The Cookware Company Ltd v OHIM EU:T:2016:2 .
220n79
36n157
98n128, 202n233
Case T-541/14 Azienda Agricola Vitivinicola Dei Conti Leone De Castris Srl v OHIM EU:T:2016:51
Case T-549/14 Lidl Stiftung & Co. KG v EUIPO EU:T:2016:594
20n22
20n16, 49n232
116–17, 116n80
Case T-554/14 Lionel Andrés Messi Cuccittini v EUIPO, JM. EV-e hijos, SRL EU:T:2018:230 169n39
Case T-557/14 BrandGroup GmbH v OHIM EU:T:2016:116 91n99
Case T-562/14 Yoo Holdings v OHMI EU:T:2015:363 30n98, 122n128, 128n181
Case T-613/14 Industrias Tomás Morcillo, S.L. v EUIPO EU:T:2016:198 112n49
Case T-621/14 Infocit v OHMI EU:T:2015:427 34n130, 58n273, 59n284
Case T-687/14 Novomatic AG v OHIM EU:T:2016:37 113n63
Case T-745/14 TeamBank AG Nürnberg v EUIPO EU:T:2016:82 96n123, 199n216
Case T-785/14 El Corte Inglés, S.A v OHMI EU:T:2016:160 34n133, 34n138
Case T-816/14 Tayto Group v OHMI EU:T:2016:93 59n287
Case T-13/15 Deutsche Post AG v EUIPO, Media Logistik GmbH EU:T:2017:434
Case T-21/15 Franmax v EUIPO EU:T:2016:241
Case T-53/15 credentis AG v OHMI EU:T:2016:136
Case T-67/15 Polo Club v EUIPO, Lifestyle Equities EU:T:2016:657.
Case T-75/15 Rod Leichtmetallräder GmbH v OHIM EU:T:2016:26
Case T-85/15 Alfa Wassermann SpA v EUIPO EU:T:2017:336
Case T-99/15 Sfera Joven, S.A. v EUIPO EU:T:2016:321 . .
202n232
49n233
22n41
163n11
128n177
112n54, 132n207
Case T-225/15 QuaMa Quality Management GmbH v EUIPO, Microchip Technology, Inc EU:T:2017:10
34n139
199n216
Case T-228/15 Grupo de originación y análisis, S.L. v EUIPO EU:T:2016:530 90n93
Case T-250/15 Speciality Drinks Ltd v EUIPO EU:T:2016:678 93n110, 180n102
Case T-312/15 Market Watch v EUIPO EU:T:2016:303 36n150
Case T-358/15 Arrom Conseil v EUIPO EU:T:2016:490 102n158
Case T-399/15 Morgan & Morgan Srl International Insurance Brokers v EUIPO, Grupo Morgan EU:T:2018:192 171n48
Case T-407/15 Monster Energy v EUIPO, Hot-Can Intellectual Property, EU:T:2016:624 179n91
Case T-408/15 Globo Comunicação e Participações S/A v EUIPO EU:T:2016:468 241n49
Case T-454/15 Laboratorios Ern, SA v EUIPO EU:T:2016:262 111n45
Case T-457/15 Fakro sp. z o.o. v EUIPO EU:T:2017:391 .
Case T-461/15 Guccio Gucci SpA v EUIPO EU:T:2016:605
Case T-495/15 Sociedad agraria de transformación No.9982 Montecitrus v EUIPO, Spanish Oranges EU:T:2017:173 .
Case T-503/15 Aranynektár v EUIPO EU:T:2016:261
Case T-504/15 Rafhaelo Gutti, S.L. v EUIPO EU:T:2017:150
Case T-521/15 Diesel v EUIPO EU:T:2017:536 .
Case T-537/15 Deutsche Post AG v EUIPO, Verbis Alfa sp. z o.o. EU:T:2018:384 .
78n47
61n302
179n95, 200n221
28n83
19n15
65n317
. 202n229
Case T-538/15 Regent University v EUIPO, Regent’s College EU:T:2017:226 184n126
Table of Cases
Case T-568/15 Giuseppe Morgese, Pasquale Morgese, Felice D’Onofrio v EUIPO EU:T:2017:78 . . . . 199n215
Case T-596/15 Batmore Capital Ltd v EUIPO, Univers Poche EU:T:2017:103 .
Case T-693/15 Clover Canyon v EUIPO, Kaipa Sportswear EU:T:2016:620. .
185n134
166n26
Case T-695/15 BMB sp v EUIPO Ferrero SpA EU:T:2017:684 235–36n22
Case T-701/15 Stock Polska sp. z o.o. v EUIPO EU:T:2017:16 180n101
Case T-768/15 RP Technik GmbH Profilsysteme v EUIPO EU:T:2017:630 180n97
Case T-18/16 Deutsche Post AG v EUIPO EU:T:2018:86 22n44
Case T-25/16 Haw Par v EUIPO EU:T:2017:303 38n161
Case T-39/16 Nanu-Nana Joachim Hoepp v EUIPO EU:T:2017:263 121n119
Case T-88/16 Opko Ireland Global Holdings v EUIPO EU:T:2017:32 113, 113n61
Case T-113/16 Arctic Cat Inc v EUIPO EU:T:2018:43 59
Case T-118/16 Deutsche Post v EUIPO, bpost NV EU:T:2018:86 202n229
Case T-159/16 Metronia S.A. v EUIPO, Zitro EU:T:2017:340 199n217
Case T-184/16 NRJ Group v EUIPO EU:T:2017:703 .
Case T-202/16 Keturi kambariai v EUIPO EU:T:2017:750
Case T-258/16 Mediterranean Premium Spirits, SL v EUIPO EU:T:2017:375
Case T-382/16 Asna v EUIPO (Asna Wings/Wings) EU:T:2017:713
Case T-398/16 Starbucks v EUIPO EU:T:2018:4 . .
Case T-406/16 Dogg Label v EUIPO EU:T:2017:482 .
Case T-448/16 Mr. Kebab s.r.o. v EUIPO, Mister Kebap SL EU:T:2017:459 .
150n87
20n16, 171n53
90n94
78n43
76
120n115
. 199n215, 199n216
Case T-722/16 Mapei SpA v EUIPO, Steenfabrieken Vandersanden NV EU:T:2017:808 . . .
176n74
Case T-824/16 Kiosked Oy Ab v EUIPO EU:T:2018:133 65n319
Case T-15/17 Dimitrios Mitrakos v EUIPO EU:T:2018:198 218n64
Case T-46/17 TDH Group v EUIPO, Comercial de Servicios Agrigan EU:T:2018:976 199n215
Case T-164/17 Apple and Pear Australia Ltd v EUIPO, Pink Lady America, EU:T:2018:678 178n85
Case T-261/17 Bayer AG v EUIPO, Uni-Pharma EU:T:2018:710 182n114, 187n147
Case T-346/17 Hotelbeds Spain, SL v EUIPO EU:T:2018:134 40n170
Case T-668/17 Maico Holding GmbH v EUIPO, Eico A/S EU:T:2018:567 180n99
EUIPO BOARDS OF APPEAL
R 519/2003-2, Tiffany & Co. v Emballages Mixtes et Plastique Sarl, 14 December 2004 106n13, 114n69
R 755/2009-4, Proxxon S.A v Franz Jost AG, 20 Oct 2010
R 0806/2009-4, Chocoladefabriken Lindt & Sprungli v Terravita, 9 Nov 2010
R 1877/2010-2, Absolut Company Aktiebolag v OHIM, Messe Commerzgroup Ltd, 17 Feb 2012
R 2492/2010-2, Tea Forté, Inc v Dr. Dünner AG, 14 Feb 2012
R 210/2012-1, Nemiroff Intellectual Property Establishment v BELVEDERE société anonyme, 5 Sep 2013
R 1802/2012-1, Industrias Relax, S.A. V Relax Natürlich Wohnen GmbH, 5 Sep 2013
246n76
246n74
236n24, 246n71
236n25
236n25, 249n90
197n205
R 1462/2012-G, Lifestyle Supplies V.o.F. v Ultimate Nutrition, Inc., 18 Sep 2013 197n205, 197n206
R 1565/2016-1, Flow Festival Oy v Producciones Baltimore, S.L., 2 Mar 2017 165n20
R 2133/2017-4, Robert Birnecker v Fisher’s Gin Ltd, 3 Apr 2018 229n124
R 2254/2017-4 Bekaertdeslee Innovation v Home Relax, 1 Aug 2018 197n207
EUIPO
Fabrimode NV v Robert Bosch GmbH, Opposition Division, No. B 2 783 002 (06/09/2017) 236n24, 247n78
Sun Stars & Sons v S.C. Carpathian Springs, Opposition Division, No. B 2 710 849 (22/12/2017) 236n23
Sun Stars & Sons Pte Ltd. v S.C. Valvis Holding, Opposition Dvision, No. B 2 710 807 (12/02/2018) 236n23
UNITED KINGDOM
32Red plc v WHG (International) Ltd [2011] EWHC 62 (Ch) 185n132
Adelphoi Ltd v DC Comics, Trade Marks Registry (Appointed Person), O/440/13. . . . . . . . . . . 48n220
Table of Cases xxiii
Alka9 Ltd v WP IP & Development BV, Trade Marks Registry (Appointed Person), O/342/14 . . . . . 98n129
Alterego Retail Group Ltd v Retail Royalty Company, Trade Marks Registry (Appointed Person), O/468/17 .
43n181
Alticor Inc v Nutrigreen Health Products Ltd, Trade Marks Registry (Appointed Person), O/335/07 84n68, 85
American Home Products Corporation v Knoll Atkiengesellschaft [2002] EWHC 828 (Ch) 54n258, 55
Apple Inc v Swatch AG, Trade Marks Registry, O/307/16 194n191
Apple Inc v Wapple.net Ltd, Trade Marks Registry (Appointed Person), O/277/13 22n43
Applied Energy Products Ltd v Hansgrohe AG, Trade Marks Registry (Appointed Person), O/090/06 57n269
APT Training & Consultancy Ltd & Anor v Birmingham & Solihull Mental Health NHS Trust [2019] EWHC 19 (IPEC) 4n14, 180n104
Argon Consulting & Management Ltd v JT International SA, Trade Marks Registry (Appointed Person), O/049/17 .
Argos Ltd v Argos Systems Ltd [2017] EWHC 231 (Ch)
Ashley v Rado Uhren AG, Trade Marks Registry (Appointed Person), O/640/17
Associated Newspapers Ltd v Express Newspapers [2003] EWHC 1322 (Ch)
Assos of Switzerland SA v Asos Plc [2013] EWHC 2831 (Ch)
Aveda Corp v Dabur India Ltd [2013] EWHC 589 (Ch) .
43n185
181n105, 223n97
47n208
49n236, 126n162
171n52
99n133, 100, 100n137, 100n138
Awareness Ltd v Plymouth City Council, Trade Marks Registry (Appointed Person), O/236/13 . . . . 110n40
Baker Street Clothing Ltd v La Chemise Lacoste SA, Trade Marks Registry (Appointed Person), O/333/10 41n178, 42–43, 45n192, 51–52, 51n243, 51n245, 51n246, 51n247
Balfour Beatty plc v PE International AD, Trade Marks Registry (Opposition), O/013/13 64n313
Barclays Bank plc v Rise Construction Management Ltd, Trade Marks Registry (Appointed Person), O/635/17 107n18
Bayerische Motoren Werke Aktiengesellschaft v Technosport London Ltd [2017] EWCA Civ 779 184n127, 192n180
Bon Catering Services v Aldi Stores, Trade Marks Registry (Appointed Person), O/411/14 98n128
Bowerbank v Michele-Textil-Vertriebsgesellschaft mbH, Trade Marks Registry (Appointed Person), O/070/07
BP Amoco Plc v John Kelly Ltd [2002] FSR 5 (NICA)
109n30, 124, 124n143
193n185, 207, 207n11, 209, 247n82
Brewdog plc v ABG EPE IP LLC, Trade Marks Registry (Appointed Person), O/048/18 . . . . . 101n151
British Shorinji Kempo Federation’s Trade Mark Application [2014] EWHC 285 (Ch) . . . . . . 49n236, 60n299, 61
British Sky Broadcasting Group Plc & Ors v Microsoft Corporation & Anor [2013] EWHC 1826 (Ch)
British Sugar plc v Robertson Ltd [1997] ETMR 118
.49n230, 128n187, 189n161, 211n30
. 106, 106n11, 106n14, 124, 124n140
Cachet Kids Ltd v Cath Kidson Ltd, Trade Marks Registry (Appointed Person), O/404/14 47n210
Chiemeka Eijochi v dm-drogerie markt GmbH + Co. KG, Trade Marks Registry (Appointed Person), O/058/18 22–23
Cobra Electronics Corporation v Cobra Automotive Technologies SpA, Trade Marks Registry (Opposition), O/380/10 38n161, 51n243
Coco de Mer Ltd v Chanel Ltd [2004] EWHC 992 (Ch) 59n292
Comic Enterprises Ltd v Twentieth Century Fox Film Corporation [2014] EWHC 185 (Ch) 79
Comic Enterprises Ltd v Twentieth Century Fox Film Corporation [2016] EWCA Civ 41 7n35, 7n37, 166n27, 167n29, 168n37, 172n57, 184n128, 190n165
Cosmetic Warriors Limited and Lush Limited v Amazon.co.uk Limited and Amazon EU SARL [2014] EWHC 181 (Ch) .
Cromwell Group (Holdings) Ltd v Rexel State Ltd, Trade Marks Registry (Appointed Person), O/023/13
D Jacobson & Sons Ltd v Globe Ltd [2008] EWHC 88 (Ch)
193n189
123n139
130, 130n199
Dallas Burston Healthcare Ltd v Boehringer Ingelheim KG, Trade Marks Registry (Appointed Person), O/048/01 21n31, 147n74
xxiv Table of Cases
Datacard Corporation v Eagle Technologies Ltd [2011] EWHC 244 (Pat) . . .
Dear Choo, Trade Marks Registry (Opposition), O/286/16 . .
167n31, 226, 226n109, 226n110, 227n113, 228n117
180n99
Decon Laboratories Ltd v Fred Baker Scientific Ltd [2000] EWHC 57 (Ch) 150n88
Deutsche Telekom AG v E! Entertainment Television Inc [2006] EWHC 33 (Ch) 152n107
Digipos Store Solutions Group Ltd v Digi International Inc [2008] EWHC 3371 (Ch) 142n40, 146n62, 146n64
DKH Retail Ltd v Nadeem Anwar, Trade Marks Registry, O/522/17 229n123
Dreams Ltd v Pure Imports Ltd, Trade Marks Registry (Appointed Person), O/307/15 214n47
eBay, Inc v Dotcom Retail Ltd, Trade Marks Registry, O/347/14. 224n101
Ellerman Investments Ltd v C-Vanci [2006] EWHC 1442 (Ch) 153n110
Elliott v LRC Products Ltd, Trade Mark (Opposition), O/103/12 57n270
Elliott v LRC Products Ltd, Trade Marks Registry (Appointed Person), O/255/13 . . . . .
Elliot v LRC Products Ltd, Trade Marks Registry (Appointed Person), O/223/15 .
203n238
. 110–11, 110n39, 117–18, 117n91, 127, 127n173, 128n182
Enterprise Holdings Inc v Europcar Group UK Ltd [2015] EWHC 17 (Ch) . . . . . 4n13, 30n93, 145n58, 150n87, 168n34, 177–78, 178n84, 179n90, 184n128, 192n178
Enterprise Rent-A-Car Company v Eurodrive Car Rental Ltd [2005] EWHC 1429 (Ch) . . . . 30, 30n91
esure Insurance v Direct Line Insurance plc [2008] EWCA Civ 842 . .
186n140, 187n148
Evegate Publishing Limited v Newsquest Media (Southern) Limited [2013] EWHC 1975 (Ch) 49n236
Exxon Corporation v Kellogg Company, Trade Marks Registry (Appointed Person), O/373/04 122n128
Fenty & Ors v Arcadia Group Brands Ltd (t/a Topshop) [2013] EWHC 1945 (Ch) 186n138
FIL Ltd & Anor v Fidelis Underwriting Ltd [2018] EWHC 1097 (Pat) 179n93, 179n95
Fine & Country Ltd v Okotoks Ltd [2012] EWHC 2230 (Ch) 209n17, 211n30, 223n95
Fine & Country Ltd v Okotoks Ltd [2013] EWCA Civ 672 26n78, 27
Firm of ABX v Gurwitch Products LLC, Trade Marks Registry (Appointed Person), O/229/13
149n82, 149n84, 151n97
Frank Industries Pty Ltd v Nike Retail BV [2018] EWHC 1893 (Ch).
Geolabs Limited v Geo Laboratories and Edwards [2012] EWPCC 45
Ghias (T/A Griller) v Ikram (T/A The Griller Original) & Ors [2012] EWPCC 3
Giant UK Limited v Major League Baseball Properties Inc., Trade Marks Registry (Appointed Person), O/264/14
Giorgio Armani SpA v Sunrich Clothing Ltd [2010] EWHC 2939 (Ch)
Grant v London Relocation Ltd, Trade Marks Registry, O/204/17
192n181, 193n188
50n239
. 76, 87n78, 211n30
124n142
56n264
197n204
Green Flag Ltd v Groupama Insurance Company Ltd, Trade Marks Registry (Opposition), O/334/12 54n255
Hasbro Inc v 123 Nahrmittel GmbH [2011] EWHC 199 (Ch) 32n108, 32n109, 57n265, 170n45, 191n174
Hearst Holdings Inc & Anor v A.V.E.L.A. Inc & Ors [2014] EWHC 439 (Ch) 5n26, 51, 51n245, 166n24, 174n66, 175–76, 176n72, 190n165
HFC Bank Plc v Midland Bank Plc [2000] FSR 176 223n97
Hornig v Distell Limited and J Sedgwick & Company Ltd, Trade Marks Registry (Invalidity), O/325/13
Hotel Cipriani SRL & Ors v Cipriani (Grosvenor Street) Ltd & Ors [2008] EWHC 3032 (Ch)
Infamous Nut Co Ltd v Percy Dalton (Holdings) Ltd [2003] RPC 7
Imperial Group plc & Another v Philip Morris Limited & Another [1984] RPC 293
Interflora Inc & Anor v Marks and Spencer plc [2014] EWCA Civ 1403
55n262
10n52, 48n221
23n50
187n145
167n32, 169n43, 170n44, 172n57, 173n59, 181n105, 211, 211n31, 213n37, 214n47, 215–16, 217n58
Interflora Inc & Anor v Marks and Spencer Plc & Anor [2013] EWHC 1291 (Ch) 169n42, 170n44, 174n67, 183n120, 187n151, 212n34
Table of Cases xxv
Interflora Inc v Marks & Spencer Plc [2012] EWCA Civ 1501 . . . . . . . . . . 184n127, 187n145, 187n149
Intersnack Knabber-Geback GmbH & Co KG v Chiquo Ltd, Trade Marks Registry (Appointed Person), O/95/14 .
20n20
IPC Media Ltd v Media 10 Ltd [2014] EWCA Civ 1439 184–85n130
Jack Wills Ltd v House of Fraser (Stores) Ltd [2014] EWHC 110 (Ch)
44, 44n188, 55, 55n259, 146n64, 149n80, 153n119, 171n52, 173n58, 174n62, 192–94, 193n187
Julius Sämaan Ltd v Tetrosyl Ltd [2006] EWHC 529 (Ch) 193n185
JW Spear & Sons Ltd v Zynga Inc [2015] EWCA Civ 290 33n127, 184–85n130, 190n165
Kimberly-Clark Worldwide Inc v Multibrands International Ltd, Trade Marks Registry (Appointed Person), O/363/17 153n121
Knight v Beyond Properties Pty Ltd [2007] EWHC 1251 (Ch) 223n95
Kurt Geiger v A-List Corporate Ltd, Trade Marks Registry (Appointed Person), O/075/13 . . . 203n237
L.A. Sugar Ltd v Back Beat Inc, Trade Marks Registry (Appointed Person), O/375/10 . . . . . . . 5, 5n24, 165–66, 166n22, 166n23
L’Oréal SA & Ors v Bellure NV & Ors [2006] EWHC 2355 (Ch) . .
Land Securities plc’s Application, Trade Marks Registry (Appointed Person), O/339/04 . . .
Lewis v Client Connection Ltd [2011] EWHC 1627 (Ch) . .
206, 206n8
49n226
138n21, 150n92, 153n113
Lifestyle Equities CV & Anor v Santa Monica Polo Club Ltd & Ors [2017] EWHC 3313 (Ch) 49n223, 55n261, 158n149
Liquid Plastics Ltd v Imperial Chemical Industries Plc, Trade Marks Registry (Appointed Person), O/272/07 32n113
London Taxi Corporation, The v Frazer Nash Research Ltd [2017] EWCA Civ 1729 175, 175n71, 177n80, 239n45
London Taxi Corporation, The v Frazer-Nash Research Ltd & Anor [2016] EWHC 52 (Ch) 177, 177n78, 236n26, 239, 239n43, 246n70
Lonsdale Sports Ltd v Erol [2013] EWHC 2956 (Pat) 50n237
Lowther v Formula One Licencing B.V., Trade Marks Registry (Appointed Person), O/396/14 141n36, 146
Luen Fat Metal and Plastic Manufactory Limited v Jacobs & Turner Limited t/a Trespass [2019] EWHC 118 (IPEC)
Lunan Group Ltd v Edwin Co Ltd [2006] EWHC 3278
Maier v ASOS Plc [2015] EWCA Civ 220
193n188
63n306
9n45, 46n197, 58n279, 130, 130n197, 148n77, 153n117, 161n5, 171n50, 185n131
Martinez (t/a Prick) v Prick Me Baby One More Time Ltd [2018] EWHC 776 (IPEC)
Merck KGaA v Merck Sharp & Dohme Corp [2017] EWCA Civ 1834
Millenium Jeans v Zeco, Trade Marks Registry (Appointed Person), O/400/14
. 223n97
192n180
98n130
Mio Ottimo Jeans Officino Ltd v Ars Parfum Creation Consulting GmbH, Trade Marks Registry (Opposition), O/343/13 55n263
Moroccanoil Israel Ltd v Aldi Stores Ltd [2014] EWHC 1686 (IPEC) 223n97
N.V. Sumatra Tobacco Trading Co. v CTBAT International Co. Ltd, Trade Mark Registry (Opposition), O/005/18 61n301
Nature’s Gift International, Inc. v Merck Consumer Healthcare Ltd, Trade Marks Registry (Opposition), O/383/15 59n294, 76, 149n85
Neutrogena Corporation and Anr v Golden Limited and Anr [1996] RPC 473 223n95
Nicoventures Holdings Ltd v The London Vape Company Ltd [2017] EWHC 3393 (Ch) . . . . . 89n85, 182n113, 201n224
Noble Foods Ltd v McDonald’s International Property Co Ltd, Trade Marks Registry (Appointed Person), O/181/14
44n191, 45
Nomination Di Antonio E Paolo Gensini SNC & Anor v Brealey & Anor (t/a JSC Jewellery) [2019] EWHC 599 (IPEC)
Now Click 2 Eat Ltd v Kunnure, Trade Marks Registry (Appointed Person), O/485/17
O2 Holdings Ltd v Hutchison 3G Ltd [2006] EWCA Civ 1656
4n14
43n181
190n169
Oasis Stores Ltd’s Trade Mark Application [1998] RPC 631 27n82
xxvi Table of Cases
Och-Ziff Management Europe Ltd & Anor v OCH Capital LLP & Ors [2010] EWHC 2599 (Ch) . .
. 145n57, 146n63, 149n81, 151n100, 152, 152n109, 153n118, 184n129, 192n182, 205, 205n6, 206, 207, 207n13, 208n14, 208n15, 208n16, 209n19, 211n27, 211n28, 211n29, 212, 219–20, 219n76, 221–22, 223–24, 223n96, 225n105
Office Cleaning Services Ltd v Westminster Window & General Cleaners Ltd [1946] 63 RPC 39 203n238
Oney Bank v Onesavings Bank plc, Trade Marks Registry, O/065/18 214n47
Oska’s Ltd v Morgan SA, Trade Marks Registry (Appointed Person), O/317/04 142n39, 144n52, 149n79, 149n83, 150n94, 151n96, 151n99, 153n115
Pepsico, Inc v Teng Yun International Pte Ltd, Trade Marks Registry, O/134/18 223n97
Pfizer Ltd v Eurofood Link (UK) Ltd [2000] ETMR 896 113n58
Phones 4U Ltd v Phones4u.co.uk Internet Ltd [2006] EWCA Civ 244
Pia Hallstrom Ltd v Beale, Trade Marks Registry (Appointed Person), O/303/17.
Polo Lauren Co’s Trade Mark Application [2001] RPC 32
Powell v Turner [2013] EWHC 3242 (IPEC)
Pramic Ltd v F Bender Ltd, Trade Marks Registry (Opposition), O/376/09
Quad International Inc v Goldstar Publications Ltd [2003] EWHC 2081 (Ch)
185n132
102n157, 203n235
21–22n36
100–1, 100n139
23, 23n53
21n24
R. v Johnstone [2003] UKHL 28; [2004] ETMR 2 237n33
Raj Foods Ltd v Masala World Ltd, Trade Marks Registry (Invalidity), O/019/08 49n226, 105n4
Reckitt & Colman Products Ltd v Borden Inc [1990] 1 WLR 491 223n93
Red Bull GmbH v Stute Nahrungsmittelwerke GmbH & Co KG, Trade Marks Registry (Appointed Person), O/119/14 97n125
Red Bull GmbH v Sun Mark Ltd [2012] EWHC 1929 (Ch) 24n57, 31n106, 32n109, 192n184
Redd Solicitors LLP v Red Legal Ltd and Martin Crighton [2012] EWPCC 54 (PCC) 10n51, 57n266, 108n25
Reed Executive v Reed Business Information [2004] EWCA Civ 159 168n38, 189n158
Riviera Home Furnishings Pvt. Ltd v Riviera Holding B.V., Trade Marks Registry (Opposition), O/634/17
Roederer v J Garcia Carrion S.A. & Ors [2015] EWHC 2760 (Ch)
Rousselon Freres et CIE v Horwood Homewares Ltd [2008] EWHC 881 (Ch)
Royal Academy of Arts, The v Errea’ Sport SpA, Trade Mark Registry (Opposition), O/036/15
Saks Hair (Holdings) Ltd v The Little Wing Trading Company Ltd, Trade Marks Registry (Appointed Person), Application O/271/13 .
133n211
.5n25, 166n23
98n131, 99
64n313
.42–43, 42n179
Sarmad’s Trade Mark Application [2006] ETMR 2 41n175
S C Prodal 94 Srl v Spirits International NV [2003] EWHC 2756 (Ch) 58n278
Scentura Creations Ltd v Patrick Cox Ltd, Trade Marks Registry (Appointed Person), O/471/00 129n190
Schuh Limited v SHHH … Limited [2011] CSOH 123 130n196
Schütz (UK) Ltd v Delta Containers Ltd [2011] EWHC 1712 (Ch) 174n61, 174n66, 175, 175n69, 176, 177n77
Shanghai Commercial Bank Ltd v Groupement des Cartes Bancaires, Trade Marks Registry (Opposition), O/338/12 64n314
Sidhu-Robb v Nosh Beverages Ltd, Trade Marks Registry (Appointed Person), O/224/18 . . . 126n158
Sky Plc v Skykick UK Ltd [2018] EWHC 155 (Ch) .
171n51, 192n177
Societe Anonyme des Bains de Mer et du Cercle des Etrangers a Monaco v Anglofile International Ltd (t/a Monte Carlo Casino Entertainment) [2013] EWPCC 38 . .
41n177, 49n225, 153n111
Société Des Produits Nestlé SA v Cadbury UK Ltd [2012] EWHC 2637 (Ch) .
Société Des Produits Nestlé SA v Cadbury UK Ltd [2013] EWCA Civ 1174. .
Sofa Workshop Ltd v Sofaworks Ltd [2015] EWHC 1773 (IPEC)
233n9
233n9
49n234
Sölen Çikolata Gida Sanayi Ve Ticaret Anonim Sirketi v Growseed Aktiengesellschaft, Trade Marks Registry (Appointed Person), O/241/05 148n75
Soulcycle Inc v Matalan Ltd [2017] EWHC 496 (Ch) 170n45
