SRJIS/BIMONTHLY/ SWATI DETHA (5540-5544)
POLITICS OF FOLK CULTURE Swati Detha Scholarly Research Journal's is licensed Based on a work at www.srjis.com To unravel the past of any region, „we have to start with the idea that man in society constitutes the ultimate object of historical research in which he is the leading protagonist. Social history is in fact a key for all history‟.1 The operation of political machinery involves the study of multiple techniques of behavioral control and correction in society. „Disciplinary power is managed by „experts‟ and guided by knowledge: psychological, sociological, biological.‟2 While studying history our analytic emphasis should be on the ordering of the forms, institutional, ideational, psychological, within which social actors are situated. The point of understanding “systems” was ultimately to understand the basis of “social action”.3 A historian should be interested in exploring not so much the political institution, but forms of power. These forms of power categorize the individual, mark him by his own individuality , attach him to his own identity, impose a laws of truth on him which he must recognize and which others must recognize in him. It is a form of power which makes individuals subjects. „The identities culturally made available to us are often deforming and debilitating, at once constituting and limiting, providing people with a narrow sense of possibility, keeping them in their places.‟4 The parameters of personal identity-especially of one‟s place within a system of social differences and inequalities are structured into the objective environment. The organization of spaces (in houses, in villages and in cities) and time (the rhythms of work, festivals, celebrations) embody the assumptions of gender, age, and social hierarchy upon which a particular way of life is built. „As the actor grows up, and lives everyday life within these spatial and temporal forms, s/he comes to embody those assumptions, literally 1 Georges Duby, The Chivalrous Society, University of California Press, London,1977., p. 3. 2 Michel Foucault, Discipline and Punish,trans. Alan Sheridon, Vintage, New York, 1977., p. 80. 3 Nicholas B. Dirks, Geoff Eley, and Sherry B. Ortner., Culture, Power, History, Princeton, 1993 , p. 13. 4
Ibid., p. 244.
MAY-JUNE 2017, VOL- 4/31
www.srjis.com
Page 5540
SRJIS/BIMONTHLY/ SWATI DETHA (5540-5544) and figuratively. The effect is one of near – total naturalization of the social order, the forging of homologies between personal identity and social classification.‟5 Understanding of power therefore invites analyses of the multiple ways in which power is deployed. „Power can not be stripped away from social relations.‟6 Without understanding it, history can not be understood. One of the forms of power through which it sleeps into social life is ideology. Ideological power derives from the human need to find ultimate meaning in life to share norms and values, and to participate in aesthetic and ritual practices. „Control of an ideology that combines ultimate meanings, values, norms, aesthetics, and rituals bring general social power.‟7 Ideological power generates distinct organizational forms. It is predominantly diffused, commanding through persuasion, a claim of truth and inviting participation in ritual. „Its diffusion has two principal forms. It may be socio- spatially “transcendent.” That is, an ideology may diffuse right through the boundaries of economic, military, and political power organizations. Human beings belonging to different states, classes, and so forth face similar problems to which ideology offers plausible solutions. Then ideological power spreads transcendentally to form a new, distinctive and powerful network of social interaction. Second, ideological power may solidify an existing power organization, developing its “immanent morale.” Transcendence is a radically autonomous form of power; immanence reproduces and strengthens existing power relations.‟8 The concept of honor and status has remained pertinent to Rajput civilization. These have remained central to the lives of the people, history of the region, political behavior and social hierarchy. In all cultures these concepts are reflected through symbols, rituals, historical narratives, mythology, literary tradition and art forms. They acquire distinctive forms and categories in different regions and cultural traditions. Significantly, status and honor, as exemplified in the region of Rajputana, reveal, a specific pattern that is quite a part from that of other regions of India. „Honor and status are projected through symbols and rituals which have formed a significant component of political life irrespective of the form of polity.‟ 9 The rulers of Rajputana deployed different symbols and rituals in varying political contexts to create legitimacy and to mould people‟s understanding according to their political interests. In Rajasthan there were some historical characters which are still alive in the public memory through oral traditions. These characters are worshiped by the people. Reverence is the 5 Ibid., p. 13. 6 Michel Foucault. op.cit., p. 88. 7 Michael Mann. Sources of Social Power, Cambridge, 1993, p. 7. 8 Ibid, p. 8. 9 Pratibha Jain and Sangeeta Sharma, Honour, Status and Polity, Rawat, New Delhi, 2004., p. 10.
MAY-JUNE 2017, VOL- 4/31
www.srjis.com
Page 5541
SRJIS/BIMONTHLY/ SWATI DETHA (5540-5544) highest form of devotion to any belief and can serve as a best form of instruction. In the folk culture of Rajasthan, narration of the stories of Pabuji, Gogaji, Tejaji, Devnarayan, Sawai Bhoj, Sultan, Galaleng, Dungji, etc., is going on since generations. These folk heroes are still alive in public memory, because of the narration of the stories in the musical form. When sung by specialists, along with the instruments, they are called ‘pawadey’.10 The singing troops used to go from one village to another and perform there. „The stories were usually very long and some times they used to go on for months.‟11 The heroes of these stories really did exist once upon a time but they were not as miraculous as these folk performances depict. „Many imaginary incidents and characters kept adding on to the real story over a long period of time.‟12 It is natural to happen to anything which remains a part of oral tradition for a good enough period. Since, there is some element of historical reality in it and the folk culture keeps giving testimony of this truth (though in a magnified form), the folk culture acts as an interpreter of past in present. The culture speaks in a tone as if it has really been the spectator of the event. Testimony‟s authority lies, of course, in its promise of historical proximity, indeed in the impression or the illusion it creates of being the past or at least closer to the past than accounts of professional history. It is specially powerful when it comes in the form of the oral, and even more so when it is visual as well: I was there, and now I am speaking to you and you can hear me speaking. With testimony there is promise of a certain emotional and gestural vividness- a vividness strongly reinforced by the customarily oral form of its delivery- that operates to transform it into a virtual transparent form of transmission. In the folk performances, Pabuji, Gogaji, etc. have been demonstrated as the embodiment of all the ideals of a perfect human being. Since these legendary heroes laid down their lives for the values highly venerated by the society, they are worshipped. „But, actually, in their form the people worship those qualities for which they lived and died.‟13 Thus, they unknowingly try to imitate them and live those characteristic qualities in their own life also. „This is only one aspect of the individualizing and normalizing technologies of power.‟14 These traditions act as museums or exhibitions, where only that are displayed, which is to be presented. All these „sought to allow the people, and en masse, to know than to be known, to become the subjects rather than the objects of knowledge‟.15
10 11 12 13 14 15
Satyendra Upadhayaya. Role of Folk Literature, Ajmer, Garuda Prakashan, 1983, p. 58. Usha Kasturia. Rajastahni Veer Gathatmak Pawadey, Delhi, Hindi Academy, 1980, p. 58. Ibid., p. 59. Usha Kasturia, op.cit., p. 56. Nicholas B. Dirks, Geoff Eley and Sherry B. Ortner, op.cit., p. 9. Ibid., p. 10.
MAY-JUNE 2017, VOL- 4/31
www.srjis.com
Page 5542
SRJIS/BIMONTHLY/ SWATI DETHA (5540-5544) There are a large number of such performative stories in the folk culture of Rajputana, and all of them too long to be described here, but we can discuss the central theme and the chief traits of some of them. We have to at the same time focus on the supernatural, imaginary and miraculous aspects of this oral tradition to be able to gauze its impressive impact. Its ability to control the psyche of the people lies in the creation of a picture bigger than real. The core story of Galaleng or Gulal Singh is ‘veer gatha’16 or narration of chivalry. It depicts a hero who is brave and courageous, and gives up his life fighting the enemies all alone. It is a touching picture of an individual who is faced by the dual choices of either war or seeing his wife for the first time after marriage. Between duty and love, he prefers former and sacrifices his life for it. The story of Gogaji is popularly sung in Brij, Haryana, Punjab, Uttar Pradesh and Rajasthan. It shows how Gogaji‟s cousins got jealous of him, when he won kingdom for himself and intrigued against him, and how he defeated them in war. He is equally well presented by the folk performers as the protector of cows and savior of motherland from foreign invaders. The singing traditions put forward the image of a child with super human capacities. His love for Kevaldey and mode of winning her presents him as a total embodiment of a truthful lover and husband. His decision to wage a war when his wife was insulted, teaches people to follow the ideal of respecting and fighting for the modesty of women. Gogaji was also associated to have powers to cure the people of snake bite and bring them back to life.17 Even today he is worshiped in this respect. The folk musicians sing the praise of Tejeji who gave up his life protecting cows from dacoits. He was on his way to get his wife from her parental home when a guzari called out for help to save her cows. Tejaji immediately rushed to the call and lost his life in the battle. Presenting the example of ideal womanhood, his wife committed sati, who had not even spent a day with him.18 His continuous depiction in folk tradition has added a lot of imagination to this core story. It has definitely played a significant role in the historical time to teach the ideal of protecting cows. Devnarayan, the son of Sawai Bhoj of Bagrawat clan is worshiped and praised for fulfilling his duty of taking revenge. „The son who settles the score of ancestral animosity is worth public veneration.‟19 The birth of such a son is a blessing. It is believed that god himself comes down in the form of such a progeny. So, the child is definitely shown in possession of super natural powers. Both his birth and childhood is a testimony of it. The proof of his 16 17 18 19
Ibid, p. 64. Ibid., p. 65. Satyendra Upadhayaya, op. cit.,p. 92. Usha Kasturia, op.cit., p. 65.
MAY-JUNE 2017, VOL- 4/31
www.srjis.com
Page 5543
SRJIS/BIMONTHLY/ SWATI DETHA (5540-5544) bravery is clearly visible from his fulfilling the condition of getting the wooden doors from a demon for marriage. This brings alive the image of a hero who is endowed with qualities to control animals and nature. Finally, by fulfilling his duty of taking revenge, he proves himself to be a perfect human being, and worthy of social praise. Similarly, Pabuji is worshiped for protecting cows and taking revenge.20 In „Bhagravaton ki Katha’21 the folk singers bring out the live image of heroes who stood for the protection of women and taking revenge. The story of „Nihaldey – Sultan‟65 is depiction of the values and morals an ideal prince should live by. The tale of „Dungaji – Jawarji‟66 is yet another live example of keeping characteristics of patriotism and chivalry alive in society and inspiring the youth to embrace them in their lives. All the stories have been made interesting and more impressive by the attachment of issues like - brilliant and super-human childhood; brave deeds to win beautiful and ideal wives; stories of controlling animals, conversing with and taking help from them, faithful friends and brothers, devils, magical instruments, divine support, comments and satires, fire of revenge, cow protection, tests by gods, boons and curses, etc.- attached to them.22 All the elements add to the effect of moulding the minds of the audiences of these performances. The virtue of being an age old tradition, stands for the authenticity of these stories. The effective presentation style of folk artists makes the impact deeper and more real. The individual and personal incidents of this folk tradition help in making a general and collective impression on the people. Power is not all about military prowess, but is also about the authority over the ways the society is shaped. „Where instruction and rhetoric failed, punishment began‟.67 The culture is an important tool in the hand of politics for the near – total naturalization of social order.
20 Ibid., p. 68. 21 Ibid., p. 72. 24 Ibid., p. 75. 25 Ibid., p. 80. 26 Nicholas B. Dirks, op.cit., p. 10.
MAY-JUNE 2017, VOL- 4/31
www.srjis.com
Page 5544