Thanksgiving Menu 2025

Thanksgiving MENU 2025

All-Natural Soups

Roasted Butternut Squash

Soup

Roasted butternut squash, potatoes, celery, carrots, onions, shallots, vegetable stock

$14.99/qt. (serves 2) vg wf df

Holiday Soup

Classic “wedding” soup with escarole, chicken, pastina, chicken stock, and baby beef meatballs

$15.99/qt. (serves 2)

Cheese & Antipasti

Brandied Cranberry Baked Brie en Croûte

French brie filled with brandied cranberries, pepper jelly, orange, Dijon mustard, fresh rosemary and enrobed in buttery puff pastry

$19.99 (8oz., serves up to 6) v

Harvest Party Board

French brie topped with cranberry, mustard seed gouda, 24 month Parmigiano Reggiano, aged cheddar, pumpkin ricotta spread, Wensleydale cheddar with cranberries, sweet & hot soppressata, roasted nuts, dried fruit, Italian mixed olives, fig jam, honey, house crostini, decorated with fresh seasonal garnish and served with crackers

$124.99 (serves up to 12)

v (vegetarian) | vg (vegan) | wf (wheat free) | df (dairy free) | k (kosher)

Traditional Holiday Main Courses

Whole Herb-Roasted Turkey

Locally raised, all-natural, and free-range turkey, free of antibiotics, brined and seasoned with Carlino’s signature blend of herbs and seasonings, homemade turkey gravy on the side (2 quarts)

$155.00 (16–18 lbs, serves up to 12)

*garnish pictured not included

Boneless Turkey Breast

All-natural turkey breast, brined and seasoned with fresh herbs, roasted to perfection, and served whole with homemade turkey gravy on the side (2 quarts)

*slice upon serving

$175.00 (serves up to 20)

Sliced Boneless Turkey Breast

All-natural turkey breast, brined and seasoned with fresh herbs, slow roasted, sliced and served with homemade turkey gravy on the side (1 quart)

$89.00 (5 lbs, serves up to 12)

Holiday Extras

All-Natural Turkey Gravy

$8.99/qt.

Cranberry Relish

Whole cranberries, orange peel and juice, sugar

$7.99/pt. vg wf df

v (vegetarian) | vg (vegan) | wf (wheat free) | df (dairy free) | k (kosher)

Sides & Accompaniments

(One size, serves up to 8)

Traditional Italian Herb Stuffing

Homemade focaccia bread, chicken stock, celery, carrots, onions, homemade Italian sausage, fresh herbs

$34.99

Carlino's Cranberry Stuffing

Homemade focaccia bread, chicken stock, celery, carrots, onions, dried cranberries, fresh herbs

$34.99

Grown-Up Mac N' Cheese

Fusilli pasta, signature imported cheese blend, house focaccia croutons, baked to golden crust

$49.99

New! Autumn Quinoa Bowl

Quinoa, sweet potato, radicchio, celery, green onion, pomegranate arils, pepitas, fresh Italian parsley, maple and apple cider vinaigrette *served chilled or warmed

$42.99 vg wf

Glazed Carrots

Carrots, extra virgin olive oil, honey, brown sugar, fresh thyme, seasonings

$39.99 vg wf

Roasted Root Vegetables

Beets, parsnips, butternut squash, rutabaga and turnips, slow-roasted with a medley of fresh herbs and olive oil

$39.99 vg wf df

Garlic & Shallot Mashed Potatoes

Russet potatoes, butter, heavy cream, garlic, shallots, salt and pepper

$32.99 v wf

Roasted Sweet Potatoes

Oven-roasted sweet potato wedges, bell peppers, onions, rosemary, garlic, white wine, extra virgin olive oil

$32.99 vg wf df

Roasted Brussels Sprouts

Brussels sprout halves, extra virgin olive oil, dried cranberries, walnuts

$42.99 vg wf df

Homemade Desserts

New! Salted Caramel Mascarpone Cheesecake

Creamy mascarpone and salted caramel cheesecake topped with salted caramel sauce on a buttery graham cracker crust

$29.99 (contains nuts, 6-inch, serves up to 8)

Pumpkin Spice Cake Roll

Pumpkin spice cake rolled with old fashioned cream cheese icing and decorated for the season

$21.99 (serves up to 6)

Old

Fashioned Handmade Pies

10" Pumpkin Pie

Topped with maple whipped cream

$21.99 (serves 8–12)

9" Old Fashioned Apple Lattice Pie

Traditional flaky crust filled with apples, cinnamon, and a touch of nutmeg

$24.99 (serves 8–12)

9" Apple, Pear, & Cranberry Crumb Pie

Apples, pears, cranberries, orange zest and a touch of raspberry, topped with brown sugar and cinnamon streusel crumbs

$29.99 (serves 8–12)

9" Chocolate Bourbon Pecan Pie

Buttery crust filled with a decadent dark chocolate, pecan, and bourbon filling

$29.99 (serves 8–12)

Homemade Bread

Harvest Cornbread

Classic buttermilk cornbread made with unbleached flour, roasted corn kernels

$7.99 (serves 6–8) v

Parker House Rolls

Unbleached flour, potato, butter, active yeast, sugar

$0.65/ea. (one dozen minimum) v

Sourdough Loaf

Unbleached flour, natural starter, sea salt

$7.99/ea. vg df

Energy Bread

Stone ground wheat flour, unbleached flour, active yeast, toasted walnuts, dried apricots, figs, dark & gold raisins, cranberries, sugar, salt

$8.49/ea. vg df

Frequently Asked Questions

How big is the turkey?

We cannot guarantee the weight of the turkeys until they are in our kitchens. The bird will weigh between 16 and 18 pounds, serving up to 12 guests.

If it says wheat free, does that mean the item is gluten free?

No. Our items labeled wheat-free do not contain gluten, but they are NOT made in a gluten-free facility. There is a risk of cross-contamination.

Do

you offer delivery?

We are unable to accommodate deliveries during the week of Thanksgiving. Pre-ordered items must be picked up at our stores.

What is your cancellation policy?

Orders or parts of orders canceled within 48 hours of delivery or pick-up will incur a 50% cancellation fee. Online cancellation requests must receive a reply email from us to be considered valid.

When is the earliest pick-up?

The earliest pick-up is 10:00 am. Orders must be picked up within the time slot selected when you place your order. Please refrain from picking up your order sooner than your selected time slot.

How do I reheat the food?

Visit our website and select "Reheating Instructions" under the Catering section. You can also scan here to see our Thanksgiving Menu Reheating Instructions.