CAMBRIDGE NEWS | 1
THURSDAY AUGUST 24, 2023
FREE
It’s a real newspaper
AUGUST 24, 2023
Split over voting age Jacqui Church
Mike Montgomerie
By Roy Pilott
A move to lower the voting age for local body elections is getting mixed reviews from the region’s politicians. Local Government Minister Kieran McAnulty introduced the bill into Parliament on Wednesday last week – but it has had virtually no publicity. The News asked elected local government members and MPs for their opinion. Early “poll” indications were that the move was supported – of the first half dozen responses, four were in favour, one opposed and one had no objection to the idea. But when this edition went to press 13 of 24 local and national politicians to respond had given the plan a thumbs down. If the bill is passed, candidates would have to go “back to school” when campaigning for votes in the 2028 local body elections – in other words, the one after next. The Bill establishes a youth electors’ category of voters and would see the creation of a youth electoral roll. It has been on the cards since the Supreme Court ruled in November that not allowing 16 and 17-year-olds to vote amounted to age discrimination. Labour has not sought to lower the general election voting age because it won’t be able
Jo Davies-Colley
Susan O’Regan
to achieve the 75 per cent yes vote required. National favours keeping at 18. But at local body level, it only requires a majority vote in the house to change the present law. Waipā local body politicians were divided in The News poll – nine were in favour and eight against. Alana Mackay, Andrew Brown, Clare St Pierre, Dale-Maree Morgan, Liz Stolwyk, Marcus Gower, Mike Montgomerie, Mike Pettit and Susan O’Regan were in favour, Roger Gordon was neutral. Andrew Myers, Ange Holt, Jill Taylor, Jo Davies-Colley, John Wood, Kane Titchener, Lou Brown and Sally Whitaker said no. Bruce Thomas, Elise Badger, Philip Coles and Sue Milner had not responded when this edition went to press. Waikato District Council has lobbied against the change – mayor Jacqui Church voted no in our poll, as did ward councillor Mike Keir. Taupō’s National MP Louise Upston said the line had to be drawn somewhere, and her party was happy with 18. But with the issue coming before the house, she noted “everyone’s views can be put forward for discussion. “That is when we can consider all the evidence and make an informed decision”.
Taranaki King Country MP Barbara Kuriger also voted no, and so did regional councillor Clyde Graf – regional council chair Pamela Storey was in the yes camp. Here’s a snapshot of some of the responses… • I’m hoping the lower age will generate more interest from younger people – Clare St Pierre. • If it happens it happens – Roger Gordon. • Voters need more life experience before voting - Kane Titchener. • Those with strong political views will vote but the vast majority will not unfortunately – Andrew Brown. • In general, teenagers at that age are not very aware of what goes on in both local and central government – Jacqui Church. • …it has to be done in conjunction with civics education in schools… so that young people are informed of how government works… - Mike Keir. • I believe there is evidence that voting earlier in life is more likely to lead to habitual voting – Mike Montgomerie. • Young people are heavily influenced by adults such as parents and teachers and therefore subject to coercion – Sally Whitaker. • I don‘t believe they have enough life experience and interest in politics to make
Marc van den Heuvel Partner
Offering a wide range of legal services Conveyancing - Commercial - Family -Trusts - Estates - Wills and Power of Attorney 22 Dick Street, Cambridge Ph 07 823 1555 www.cooneylaw.co.nz
Liz Stolwyk
Dale-Maree Morgan
an informed vote – Ange Holt • …most 16 and 17 year olds don’t contribute to rates through rents or rates – Lou Brown. • I think allowing younger people to vote could see precious money directed their way, when it could be better spent on parents in need – Andrew Myers. • The majority of 16-year-olds have not yet fully experienced some of the issues facing New Zealand that need consideration when voting – Jo Davies-Colley. • Left-wing governments and liberals already have an excessive influence on children while at school – Clyde Graf. • If a person feels they wish to influence the leadership, governance and direction of their community and country then they should be permitted to do so – Liz Stolwyk. • I am now more supportive of considering a change – Susan O’Regan. • The small risk of giving the vote to some young people who may not be ready to exercise that right is outweighed by the potential benefits of enfranchising those who are ready – Dale-Maree Morgan. • See full responses cambridgenews.nz • What do you think? Email editor@ goodlocal.nz • Next week: Three year term or four?
New name, same care. LOCAL, PASSIONATE, INNOVATIVE
Residential
Rural Lifestyle
47 Alpha Street 07 823 1945 www.cambridgrealestate.co.nz
Cambridge funerals is now Legacy Funerals.
Keep the story alive.