Daily
Herald
the Brown
vol. cxlvi, no. 6
Wednesday, February 2, 2011
Since 1891
r ot c r e co n s i d e r e d
U. to offer int’l master’s to juniors
News in brief Nearly 400 bumped from poli sci course More than 380 students will have to search for a new course to take this semester, as the Department of Political Science has capped POLS1510: “Great Powers and Empires” to 300 students. “I’ve taught this class before and I’ve never had a problem giving overrides or students not being able to take the course,” said Minh Luong, the adjunct lecturer of political science who teaches the course. “Right now there are 680 people enrolled in this class, which way exceeds the capacity of (Salomon 101).” The capacity of Salomon 101, including the balcony area, is 594 people. According to Luong, another 125 students who had not yet registered were also trying to enroll in the class. Luong said James Morone, professor of political science and chair of the department, told him the class must be capped and that only juniors and seniors will be allowed to enroll. Luong said that he felt this was “within
By Ashley Aydin Senior Staff Writer
Herald archives
Amidst heavy student protest, the faculty voted to abolish Naval ROTC in the spring of 1972. Now, after Congress’ repeal of “Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell,” 24 students have applied to sit on a committee to consider the program’s return. See more coverage on page 2.
Questions linger in alleged intimidation By Jake comer Senior Staff Writer
While the owner of the security firm accused of participating in witness intimidation in the William McCormick case denies wrongdoing in a November deposition obtained by The Herald, his testimony fails to put the issue
continued on page 4
to rest. In the deposition, Pat Brosnan — the owner of Brosnan Risk Consultants — states that an investi-
News analysis gator in his employ anonymously hand-delivered a package to the home of witness Mike Burch’s
girlfriend to get a photograph of Burch. But the investigator already possessed a picture of Burch from the internet, and did not take a picture of him after delivering the package. Brosnan states the purpose of the ploy was to covertly surveil — not threaten — Burch, continued on page 3
Five science profs elected to national society By TeD Burke Contributing Writer
Five Brown professors were elected fellows of the American Association for the Advancement of Science this December. Professor of Medical Science Edward Hawrot, Professor of Geological Sciences Timothy Herbert,
Professor of Medical Science Agnes Kane, Professor of Geological Sciences John Mustard, Professor of Biology Gary Wessel and the other 498 fellows honored this year were recognized for their “meritorious efforts to advance science or its applications,” according to the association’s website. The association describes itself
as an “international non-profit organization dedicated to advancing science around the world.” It also produces Science, one of the world’s most widely read science magazines. The association “facilitates and greases the wheels of science,” Mustard said. The association’s Council elects fellows based on nomination by
other members of the association. “It is wonderful that these five faculty members have been selected as fellows of (the association).” Clyde Briant, vice president for research, wrote in an e-mail to The Herald. “It recognizes them for the outstanding contributions that they made continued on page 2
Fish Co. goes belly up A retrospective
Courtesy of Miriam Furst
inside
The Fish Company, always a scene on Wednesday nights, has closed.
news...................2-5 Comics...................5 editorial..............6 Opinions...............7
Monsters Ink In Prof ’s new children’s book, math can bite Campus news, 8
For 10 years, students have ventured off campus seeking the overcrowded dance floor, the blaring pop music and the copious drinks. But Brown’s Wednesday-night tradition has come to an end with the closing of the Fish Company. After a month of rumors about renovations, a New Year’s Eve reopening and conflicting Blog Daily Herald reports, Fish Co.’s website has confirmed that Brown’s Wednesday night hot spot no longer exists.
The Rhode Island State Police Underage Drinking and Nightclub Safety Task Force raided Fish Co. Nov. 4, and arrested 26 people for “Unlawful Drinking and Misrepresentation by an Underage Person,” according to a Nov. 5 press release. Three Brown students were arrested at the bar. Raymond White, deputy superintendent and chief of field operations for the Rhode Island State Police, told The Herald that he was unaware of the direct effects of these arrests on the bar. “Nightcontinued on page 4
Unique?
Examining Brown’s need to compete opinions, 7
weather
By Miriam Furst Staff Writer
The Office of International Programs will announce today the launch of “Brown Plus One” — a program that will allow juniors to begin earning a master’s degree from either the Chinese University of Hong Kong or The University of Edinburgh. Juniors will complete the first half of a master’s during a semester or year abroad and then return for another year after graduating Brown to complete the degree. The program will offer degrees in the hard sciences, social sciences and humanities, Kendall Brostuen, associate dean of the College and director of international programs, wrote in an e-mail to The Herald. The application process for the program will be similar to the standard study abroad application process, with one addition — students will need to declare their intention to return to a foreign university to complete the degree after graduating Brown. Students will also be asked to explain their objectives for the fifthyear international master’s program and how the program will help them develop their liberal learning foundation at Brown, Brostuen wrote. The program includes requirements for those enrolled. “While abroad as juniors, students must complete a full-time course of study, including a Global Independent Study Project, or a GLISP, linked to their area of concentration,” Brostuen wrote. The program’s coursework will include at least one graduate-level offering, which will be accepted in partial fulfillment of the master’s requirements, he wrote. The program — which is part of Brown’s internationalization initiative — aims to provide students with the opportunity to incorporate a global perspective into their baccalaureate studies and build upon that knowledge by adding a focused fifth year of study, Brostuen wrote. “Brown undergraduate students have demonstrated over the years that they have the maturity and the self-discipline to excel at graduate level courses delivered here in Providence,” he wrote. This program, he added, will allow them to do so at “two globally recognized universities.”
t o d ay
tomorrow
38 / 15
30 / 10
2 Campus News
Twenty-four apply to ROTC committee
calendar Today
february 2
12 P.m.
ToMORROW
february 3
4P.M.
Annual Hazardous Waste Training,
Queer Faith Discussion Group,
Brown Office Building, 4th Floor
J. Walter Wilson 411
5 p.m.
6:30 p.m. Tea and Feminism,
Anand Giridharadas Book Signing
Sarah Doyle Women’s Center
and Lecture, Smith-Buonanno 106
menu SHARPE REFECTORY
VERNEy-WOOLLEY DINING HALL LUNCH
Beef Tacos, Vegetarian Mori Soba Noodles, Vegetarian Tacos, Chocolate Krinkle Cookies
Turkey Tacos, Vegan Burritos, Corn and Sweet Pepper Saute, Chocolate Krinkle Cookies
DINNER Castle Hill Inn Pork Spare Ribs, Sticky Rice with Edamame, Vegan Ratatouille, Fudge Bars
Rotisserie Style Chicken, Spinach Quiche, Broccoli with Cheese Sauce, Squash Rolls, Fudge Bars
Sudoku
Crossword
The Brown Daily Herald Wednesday, February 2, 2011
By Bradley Silverman Staff Writer
Twenty-four undergraduates have applied for the two student seats on the University committee formed to consider the return of the Reserve Officers’ Training Corps to campus. According to Diane Mokoro ’11, president of the Undergraduate Council of Students, the two undergraduate committee members will be chosen by Friday morning. While all the details of the process by which the committee will reach its recommendation have yet to be announced, undergraduate committee members can expect to attend 10 90-minute meetings, Mokoro wrote in an e-mail to the student body announcing the application process. The committee was announced in the wake of Congress’ vote to repeal “Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell,” the policy under which gays could only serve in the military if they did not reveal their sexual orientation. Since the vote, Brown and other Ivy League schools have announced intentions to reconsider their bans on campus chapters of ROTC. In early January, the University announced plans for the formation of a committee to consider its response to the policy’s repeal. Dean of the College Katherine Bergeron will lead the committee, which will submit recommendations to the faculty and administration on future ROTC and military recruitment on campus. Brown, along with many other universities, banned ROTC in the 1970s in the midst of anti-Vietnam War protests and allegations that
ROTC students were not held to the same high academic standards as others. Since then, the 1993 passage of “Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell” has resulted in resistance to re-implementing ROTC on many campuses. According to a University statement, the original decision to end Air Force and Naval ROTC in 1971 and 1972, respectively, stemmed from academic concerns, such as whether the program should have its own department and whether or not its courses should carry academic credit. “It will be an open and rigorous process in line with Brown’s academic goals and policies, as well as its responsibility to serve the nation’s needs for outstanding leadership,” the statement said. Many other schools, including Harvard, are considering allowing the program to return. “The repeal of (“Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell”) is a historic step,” wrote Harvard President Drew Faust in a statement. “I look forward to pursuing discussions with military officials and others to achieve Harvard’s full and formal recognition of ROTC.” But obstacles to the reintroduction of ROTC still exist on many campuses. At some schools, it is not clear whether there is strong enough interest on the part of students, faculty or the military to justify ROTC’s return. Currently, Brown students may participate in ROTC training through a unit at Providence College. As of last Spring, only one student — Joy Joung ’11 — was participating in the program, according to an Apr. 29 article in The Herald.
But Lynn Della Grotta ’13, who is currently spearheading efforts to bring ROTC back to Brown through a group called Students for ROTC, wrote in an e-mail to The Herald that it was never fair to hold the military responsible for a policy imposed by civilian elected representatives, noting that the armed services take their orders from Congress, which originally passed the policy. “The absence of ROTC may have been a reflection of students’ sentiments in the sixties and seventies, but now I believe Brown students, along with the entire nation, are aware of and thankful for the sacrifice these courageous men and women in uniform make in order to keep our country safe,” she wrote. “Therefore, it only seems right to have in this decade the return of ROTC, in order to reflect students’ sentiments today.” “Having a greater presence of Brown students in leadership positions in the military would allow for input into how the military would evolve in the future,” she added. Abbott Gleason, professor emeritus of history and slavic studies, began teaching at Brown in the fall of 1968, shortly before ROTC was banned on campus. He said that the program was wildly unpopular at the time due to student attitudes about U.S. foreign military involvements. “At almost all of what you would call liberal colleges in the United States,” he said, “attitudes flung wildly against ROTC because of the Vietnam War.” — With additional reporting by Nicole Boucher
Science association welcomes profs continued from page 1 to their fields.” The five faculty members — who will be formally welcomed as fellows at the association’s annual meeting Feb. 19 — all said the honor came as a surprise. Being named a fellow is “more of an acknowledgement” than a new job, Wessel said. Hawrot said it is a “great honor to be recognized for science over ones career.” He said the election of five professors puts the University on the national stage, and that the Univer-
Daily
the Brown
sity should “receive some praise for the investments they have made for the high quality of research going on here.” Wessel researches sperm and how eggs are activated at fertilization. He also studies germlines, which eventually become a stemcell and then an egg or sperm. “I love doing my job here,” Wessel said. “Students are the background for research. The process of educating is two ways.” Hawrot, who is also the associate dean for the program in biology, focuses on understating the “structurefunction relationship of nicotinic
Herald
www.browndailyherald.com 195 Angell St., Providence, R.I.
Ben Schreckinger, President Sydney Ember, Vice President
Matthew Burrows, Treasurer Isha Gulati, Secretary
The Brown Daily Herald (USPS 067.740) is an independent newspaper serving the Brown University community daily since 1891. It is published Monday through Friday during the academic year, excluding vacations, once during Commencement, once during Orientation and once in July by The Brown Daily Herald, Inc. Single copy free for each member of the community. POSTMASTER please send corrections to P.O. Box 2538, Providence, RI 02906. Periodicals postage paid at Providence, R.I. Subscription prices: $280 one year daily, $140 one semester daily. Copyright 2011 by The Brown Daily Herald, Inc. All rights reserved. editorial
(401) 351-3372 herald@browndailyherald.com
Business
(401) 351-3360 gm@browndailyherald.com
acetylcholine receptors,” he said, the basis for nicotine addiction. He also studies alpha-neurotoxins, which are derived from snake venom. Mustard, who studies how the surfaces of planets are shaped and looking for major changes, said he is interested in both planetary and environmental science. He also said he hopes to answer the question of whether life ever existed elsewhere in the solar system. Kane, who is also the chair of the department of pathology and laboratory medicine, directs and helps build graduate training programs and gets funding for them. Her research is focused on asbestos fibers and nanomaterials and the adverse health effects with which they are associated. She collaborates with Robert Hurt, professor of engineering, in her research. Kane has also worked on a number of both national and international advisory panels. Herbert is the chair of the Department of Geological Studies. He said he focuses on “understanding the ways in which climate can change naturally,” by studying the ocean’s bottom. He and his team produced the world’s longest paleotemperature, a recording that helps understand how temperature changes over time.
The Brown Daily Herald Wednesday, February 2, 2011
Campus News 3
Private investigator’s testimony fails to settle allegations A timeline of events in the McCormick case August 30, 2006 — First-year orientation begins for William McCormick, then a member of the Class of 2010 and a wrestling recruit. Sept. 6 — A female classmate of McCormick’s makes a complaint to the University that he has been stalking her. Sept. 13 — The female student alleges that McCormick raped her on the night of Sept. 6. McCormick is forced to leave campus. Sept. 14 — Russell Carey, senior vice president for Corporation affairs and governance, hands McCormick a plane ticket home to Wisconsin. He is not informed that he has been accused of rape. Over the following days, McCormick is made aware of the accusation, begins preparing a defense with his adviser — assistant wrestling coach Mike Burch — and hires attorney Walter Stone to advise him. According to federal court records, Stone’s law firm — Adler Pollock & Sheehan — was representing the University in a separate matter while Stone was advising McCormick in the disciplinary process. Oct. 3 — The female student’s father — a University alum, donor and fundraiser — e-mails President Ruth Simmons, “Ruth … I am working to resolve the matter with the student who attacked (the female student) — the goal is to have him withdraw from Brown and not have a University hearing. This will enable (the female student) and the other students to avoid having to come in contact with the student and face questioning from his advocate.” Oct. 15 — McCormick withdraws from Brown, citing medical reasons. In court documents, he will later allege the experience aggravated an existing seizure condition. September 2009 — McCormick’s new lawyer, Scott Kilpatrick files a complaint under seal in Rhode Island Superior Court. The claim alleges that McCormick was falsely accused and that the University mishandled the accusation because of the financial relationship of the female alum’s father to the University. The motion to seal is granted, and there is no public record of the suit. The case is soon transferred to federal court, where it is again placed under seal. April 12, 2010 — The Herald prints a story based on a leaked copy of the complaint. The case is unsealed later that day at a hearing in front Judge William Smith. Sept. 27 — A package addressed to Burch — who has been named a witness in the case — is hand-delivered anonymously to the home of Burch’s girlfriend, a single mother. It contains an invitation to a free meal at Downcity Diner — a restaurant across the street from the law firm representing McCormick. Burch shows up for dinner, where he finds out the restaurant was given cash by two women to pay for his meal. The next day, Burch receives an anonymous phone call about the package.
continued from page 1 but the investigator called Burch about the incident the following day from a blocked phone number. He testifies that the investigator was offered money to obtain the picture in 2009, but the investigator did not attempt to do so until late 2010. He testifies that he was unaware Burch had spoken in the press about the case, but he had received news articles — attached to e-mails — about the case. The deposition was taken Nov. 3 by McCormick’s lawyer, Scott Kilpatrick, two weeks after he filed a motion alleging that Burch had been subject to witness intimidation. Burch — a former assistant wrestling coach and the University-appointed adviser to McCormick when he was accused of rape in 2006 — received an anonymous package Sept. 27 inviting him to a free dinner at the DownCity Diner “to show our appreciation for everything you do.” The following day, Burch received a phone call about the package from a blocked number. Using subpoenas, Kilpatrick’s law firm traced the call to a phone owned by Pat Brosnan, the founder of a New York private investigative firm known to work for the father of the female alum who accused McCormick of rape. McCormick is suing the female alum, her father and the University in federal court. In the deposition, Brosnan states he was retained in 2009 to surveil Burch and ensure his daily patterns would not bring him into contact with the female alum, then a senior. Brosnan says the surveillance ended in 2009, but that at that time he offered the investigator assigned to the case, Sharon Clatch, $1,000 to obtain a picture of Burch if she were to find herself in Providence in the future.
He states delivery of the package was not a threat but a ploy to lure Burch into a situation in which Clatch could take a picture of him, and that neither he nor the female alum’s father were aware of the ploy until after it had taken place. But according to Clatch’s notes — subpoenaed in connection with the deposition — Brosnan’s firm already possessed a picture of Burch taken from the internet. And according to Brosnan’s deposition, Clatch did not take any photograph of Burch after delivering the package, even though Burch went to the restaurant after receiving the invitation. Brosnan says he asked for the photograph “because I suspected, particularly when the civil case came above ground, that there may be a possibility this may evolve at some later date for the client into a focused surveillance … and it would certainly be very handy to have a recent photograph.” Brosnan states that his employees performed surveillance of Burch in September of 2009, but “never got a photograph.” Kilpatrick asks Brosnan, “You needed a picture of him because you didn’t have one and didn’t know what he looked like; right?” to which Brosnan responds, “I didn’t have a picture, no. There was no picture.” According to the deposition, Kilpatrick then brings Brosnan’s attention to notes from Clatch’s 2009 surveillance of Burch, which include a headshot of Burch taken from the internet. Brosnan confirms the photograph is of Burch and responds, “We didn’t feel that the photos were of sufficient quality and clarity and crisp enough in case that we had to go on a surveillance, on a focused surveillance, at a later date.”
After Clatch finished the ploy, Brosnan says Clatch called him to tell him, “it worked; he went to dinner. And unfortunately, she still didn’t get the picture.” When asked why Clatch failed to get a photograph of Burch, Brosnan first responds that he does not know. When asked why Clatch said she did not get a photograph, Brosnan responds “lighting.” “Maybe because she tried to draw him on at 7:30 at night,” Kilpatrick replies. Clatch’s invitation requested Burch come to dinner at 7:30 p.m. Later in the deposition, the questioning turns to Clatch’s phone call to Burch the following day, and the role it played in the ploy. When first asked why Clatch called Burch the following day from a blocked number, Brosnan responds, “I don’t know.” When asked again about the purpose of the call, Brosnan says Clatch “wanted to convey to (Burch) that there was no ulterior motive to the extent that she thought that this would be helpful to him to understand in some way. That’s what she said to me.” Brosnan states in the deposition that he did not know that Burch was a witness in a lawsuit “until recently.” He also states that although the female alum’s father had sent him news articles in which Burch talks to reporters about the McCormick case, he did not read the articles and was unaware Burch had been vocal in the media about the case. Brosnan says he does not think the package — which consisted of an invitation and flowers — could reasonably have been considered scary. He did not respond to e-mails and a phone call seeking comment for this story.
October 2010 — Using subpoenas, McCormick’s lawyers trace the number used to call Burch about his satisfaction with the gift to former New York Police Department Detective Pat Brosnan, owner of a private security firm. Brosnan works regularly for the female alum’s father. Jan. 6, 2011 — Well over a year into the suit, Federal Judge William Smith recuses himself without explanation. Jan. 19 — Burch is granted a temporary civil restraining order against the father of the female alum in Rhode Island Superior Court in connection with the package and phone call. Jan. 25 — Burch files a criminal complaint against the female alum’s father with the Pawtucket Police in connection with the same incident. The investigation is currently ongoing. Jan. 28 — Burch is denied a permanent restraining order in Superior Court because he had already raised the issue of witness intimidation in Federal Court. At the hearing on the restraining order, the female alum’s father says Judge Smith recused himself from the federal case because his daughter is applying to Brown.
Stephanie London / Herald
Mike Burch, a former assistant wrestling coach, alleged witness intmidation after a private investigator delivered a package to the home of his girlfriend with an invitation to a free dinner at the DownCity Diner (pictured above).
4 Campus News News in brief Students exceed auditorium capacity continued from page 1 reasonable limits of what the University believes is best for the students,” adding that an oversized class makes it difficult to grade exams and goes against fire safety regulations. “It’s upsetting obviously, I think everyone is upset about it,” said Rachel Rosenfeld ’13, who — as a sophomore — will not be allowed to take the course. She said she had heard Luong is “amazing.” “Given the unprecedented situation, there was a tough choice to be made and Professor Morone made it,” he said. “The people affected this year will have the opportunity to work with me in an improved version of the course in the future.” According to Luong, the Office of the Registrar was so sure that the class would have low enrollment that events had already been scheduled in Salomon 101 on some Wednesday and Friday evenings during class time. “I am both shocked and very humbled,” Luong said. “The last time I taught this class there were a little over 300 students and the time before that around 267.” Luong said that he has “no idea” why the course was so popular this year, suggesting that it was perhaps due to a resurgent interest in period movies, human rights and international relations. He added it might also be due to an impression that this course will not be taught again, as he had initially indicated in his first lecture. But given the popularity of the course, it will likely be offered again, he said. — Aparna Bansal
The Brown Daily Herald Wednesday, February 2, 2011
Fish Co. property to reopen under new ownership continued from page 1 clubs will be under scrutiny by us, but the licensing board will be the one who can make the decision. We had members of Providence Police with us (on the night of the Fish Co. bust), and they turn that information over to their respective licensing board,” he said. After the arrests, rumors circulated through the Brown community that Fish Co. was permanently closed. But according to the bar’s website at the time, it was only closed for renovations and was set to reopen on New Year’s Eve. At that point, the information on the website was true, according to Blaine Grinna ’11. Grinna had been organizing Brown Night at Fish Co. and knows the bar’s former owners, Jay and Gene, though he said he does not know their last names. While Fish Co. did get fined a total of $650 as a result of the Nov. 4 raid, according to Providence License Administrator Serena Conley, that night did not directly lead to the bar’s ultimate closing. A decision made between Fish Co.’s two owners months before the raid played a larger role in the end of Fish Co., Grinna said. The famous riverside building will reopen in March, but under a new name and new management, according to TonightinRI.com. Neither the former nor the new owners of the venue could be reached for comment. ‘An equal opportunity place’
“Fischco was an institution,” Grinna said. Fish Co. has been a staple of Brown’s social scene since 2002, when a few members of the Theta Delta Chi fraternity started Brown Night at the bar to earn money working as bouncers, he said. “All the alumni are sad about the
closing. It’s a formative part of the Brown cultural experience,” said Kate Whalen ’07. Whalen said the first time she went to Fish Co. as a first-year, she did not know what to expect. “You walk in, and it’s completely overwhelming,” she said. “It’s not like the rest of your Providence bar experience.” “I remember having so much fun dancing there freshman year,” she said. “You just go and get lost in the crowd. I think we did more dancing freshman year than senior year. Senior year was just more chill at Fish Co..” The news of Fish Co.’s closing circulated among Whalen’s friends within hours of it being posted on Blog Daily Herald, she said. “Fish Co. was so different than going out on Thayer Street or going to a house party,” she said. “Fish Co. was one of those places that regardless of who your friends were — whether you were a sports person or a frat person — everyone would go,” she said. “Fish Co. was an equal-opportunity place.” Even though she graduated Brown, Whalen said she cannot imagine not being able to return to the bar. “We wanted to rent Fish Co. to have a party for our fifth-year reunion. Everybody loved that place. I don’t know where else you could get dressed up and go out with 20 of your friends on a Wednesday night.” “And Halloween Fish Co. and all those special Fish Co.s — what’s going to happen?” she added. Mourning the ’Co.
Students on campus had similar concerns about Fish Co.’s fate. Walker Williams ’11 started a “Free Fish Co.” campaign Dec. 1, when Blog Daily Herald first reported a rumor that it was closing. “Whether you love it or hate it, Fish Co. was part of Brown culture,” Williams said. Williams designed a “Free Fish Co.” T-shirt and, within the first night of launching the website, there were 200 preorders, he said. “We wanted to show the owners of Fish Co. how much support they had behind them.” There were 1,500 hits to the website on the first night — “a quarter of the Brown student body, which gives you an idea of how big Fish Co. was on campus,” Williams said. Whalen and most of her friends purchased “Free Fish Co.” T-shirts to mourn the loss of the bar.
Courtesy of Miriam Furst
Students celebrate St. Patrick’s Day at Fish Company.
Swathi Bojedla ’07 said that two years ago, one of her friends rented a party bus in New York City to take recent alumni back up to Brown to celebrate a birthday at Fish Co.. Bojedla still remembers her first night at the bar. “I thought Brown was the best place on Earth partly because of Fish Co.,” she said. “I also met so many of my good friends there.” During her senior year, Bojedla and her friends all signed up for the same existentialism class Thursdays at 1 p.m. so they could recap the night at Fish Co. together every week, she said. “Obviously, Brown’s an amazing school, and everyone is so smart, but it was great to have an offcampus crazy college bar to go to,” Bojedla said. “I don’t think a lot of other Ivys have that.” Bojedla and Whalen both said that memories of Fish Co. are something that alumni and current students can bond over and share. The end of an era
“Wednesday nights will never be the same,” Dave Rosen ’14 said. “Fish Co. was a great way to break up the school week . . . you can’t really dance at frats. Fish Co. was definitely the most wild and it was fun to chill on the porch there.” The University administration knew that “Fish Co. was the Wednesday night thing,” said Margaret Klawunn, vice president ofcampus life and student services. The University had to deal with
several incidents a year that occurred either at Fish Co. or as a result of an event that took place at the bar, she said. A policeman was also stationed at Josiah’s on Wednesday nights to handle any problems, which were more likely to occur when students returned to campus from Fish Co., she said. While Brown students dominated 515 S. Water St. on Wednesdays, Thursdays were Providence College Night. “Thursday nights were definitely Fish Co. nights and were a blast,” said Amanda George, a sophomore at PC. “It was the melting pot for all the schools and was physically bigger than the other bars we go to.” In addition to the end of an era of Wednesday nights at Fish Co., the closing will have further implications for Brown’s social scene. “Not having Fish Co. definitely changes rush,” said Adam Driesman ’12, the recruitment chair of the Sigma Chi fraternity. “It was a great place to meet a lot of the potential rushes and was an equal playing field for all the fraternities.” He added that the fraternity is seeking a new location for its “annual disco inferno party,” which is nicknamed “Disco Fish Co..” Even though “Fish Co. was the spot,” Grinna said he hopes students “can continue to have incredible experiences like we did at Fish Co. as a student body, not just as small cliques in respective College Hill bars.”
Campus News 5
The Brown Daily Herald Wednesday, February 2, 2011
Prof’s book explores NPR features Peruvian kinship bonds kids’ book continued from page 8
continued from page 8 Peters said. “We saw absolutely fantastic illustrations,” Peters said. “I told everybody in our company that this book would become a real classic children’s book.” A K Peters sold the book to mathematicians at various conferences, Peters explained. “I showed the book to (Keith Devlin) at the last mathematics conference,” Peters said, adding that NPR responded very quickly. “I believe mathematics is something that is completely misunderstood by the public because of bad teaching,” Peters said. He said he recalled an e-mail he received in which Schwartz was described as “a new Dr. Seuss.” “You Can Count on Monsters” won first prize in the children’s category in the annual Book Builders of Boston competition this spring, Peters said. Schwartz said he believes that his previous publications with A K Peters allowed him to get his children’s book “in the back door,” he said. “The children’s book market is brutally competitive.”
“I think she does a good job of understanding kinship as something to do with bonds that are more than just biological,” said Alfredo Aguirre ’10, who did independent research with Leinaweaver in 2009. “So kinship is more than just a blood type. But it’s also a social phenomenon.” Aguirre said it was “really important” to move away from the “very Western” view that kinship is “purely biological.” Leinaweaver found that parents often sent their kids away to provide them with opportunities, perhaps at a better school in an urban area. In other cases, a godparent would request to take care of the kids to have companionship, to gain extra help around the house or to help out the child’s family. Some of the kids she spoke to expressed a desire to leave to ease their parents’ burden. Leinaweaver told The Herald she found many “layers of motivation” that were in the end “difficult to untangle.” “The thing I miss most about Peru is the people I got to know,” Leinaweaver said. “One of the strange things about anthropology is we’re trying to find out about interesting anthropological (phenomena), but because we stay there so long . . . often it becomes a friendship.”
Leinaweaver is on leave this semester. While she was studying families in Peru, she was a single, childless PhD student. Now, she’s taking phone calls with her newborn baby in hand. She writes articles in between the baby’s naps, she told The Herald, and her latest work is on Peruvian immigrants in Spain. She said she spent the last two summers in Spain, comparing young Peruvians who have been adopted by Spanish families to the children of Peruvian families who migrated to Spain. Some of these families were the ones she encountered during her work in Peru. “In some sense, it’s a continuation of the earlier study,” she said. “I’m looking at the same question in a transnational sphere: adoption versus migration, how are they similar or different.” Next year, Leinaweaver will bring her “communication skills into the classroom” by teaching an introductory anthropology course, Lutz said. “I love to talk about my research when I’m teaching,” Leinaweaver said. “That is a way to make anthropology more real to students, to show pictures and say this is me doing fieldwork — harvesting potatoes and looking like an idiot. I think that incorporating that level of personal experience can be really effective in the classroom.”
comics BB & Z | Cole Pruitt, Andrew Seiden, Valerie Hsiung and Dan Ricker
Cabernet Voltaire | Abe Pressman
Dot Comic | Eshan Mitra and Brendan Hainline
Get the Herald delivered to your inbox www.browndailyherald.com/register
6 Editorial & Letter Editorial
The Brown Daily Herald Wednesday, February 2, 2011
Editorial comic b y s a m r o s e n f e l d
Paper cuts Brown’s independent bookstore has long been a point of pride among members of the community. Most other Ivy League schools’ official bookstores are actually specialized outposts of Barnes & Noble. In fact, the Brown Alumni Magazine reported that a University committee recommended outsourcing the bookstore to a chain like Barnes & Noble or Borders in 2007 before a protest movement sprang up arguing that “an independent bookstore would be more responsive to the community’s needs.” Ultimately, this position carried the day. Students and administrators have put up with some of the drawbacks of this arrangement — not the least of which is the significantly higher price for textbooks — for various reasons. Indeed, the current situation is buttressed by the pride of independence and an almost automatic, typically Brunonian opposition to the kind of corporatization that a Borders takeover of the bookstore would represent. And for the most part, the bookstore actually was refreshingly easy to use. The generous textbook return policy in particular often made the bookstore competitive with other textbook vendors despite the greater cost of textbooks. With unlimited returns throughout shopping period, ten-day returns after shopping period and no questions asked throughout, the bookstore facilitated a liberal shopping schedule and eliminated a lot of stress that would otherwise attend the purchase of textbooks. This is why we were so disappointed to learn of the bookstore’s recent change to its return policy. The Herald recently reported that under the new policy, returns will only be allowed three days after purchase during shopping period, only for dropped courses for the next two weeks and not at all for the remainder of the semester. What’s worse, all returns must be accompanied by physical proof in the form of an official transcript, course schedule or drop slip. This is a tremendous change for the worse at the bookstore. We understand that, as Director of Bookstore Administration Steven Souza told The Herald, some students previously abused the generous return policy to avoid actually paying for books. Some alternatives to the new policy come to mind; the bookstore could prevent a student from buying a book he or she has already bought and returned, for example. However, this new policy is a serious overreaction that immediately eliminates any advantages the bookstore may have had over other retailers like Amazon.com. At Amazon, textbooks are usually significantly cheaper than at the bookstore, as students can see from Mocha’s side-by-side comparison, and two-day shipping is free for all students through the new Amazon Student program. Perhaps most importantly, though, Amazon permits returns for a full month after purchase, and we’ve heard the mailroom can help with shipping. In our view, the bookstore has shot itself in the foot with this new return policy, which will undoubtedly cause many students to try out alternative methods for their textbook purchases. It might even lose more revenue from disappointed customers than the previous return policy cost. Like many Brown students, we support the continued independence of the bookstore. It’s actually a nice place, especially after the recent renovations. But this misguided change in the return policy has seriously damaged its appeal to students and undermines the argument that an independent store can be responsive to our needs. We urge the bookstore to reconsider the changes and look into other, more sensible reforms that won’t have such a negative impact on students, shopping period and the bookstore itself. Editorials are written by The Herald’s editorial page board. Send comments to editorials@browndailyherald.com.
t h e b r ow n da i ly h e r a l d Editors-in-Chief
Deputy Managing Editors
Senior Editors
Sydney Ember Ben Schreckinger
Brigitta Greene Anne Speyer
Dan Alexander Nicole Friedman Julien Ouellet Business
editorial Kristina Fazzalaro Luisa Robledo Talia Kagan Hannah Moser Rebecca Ballhaus Claire Peracchio Alex Bell Nicole Boucher Tony Bakshi Ashley McDonnell Anita Mathews Tyler Rosenbaum Hunter Fast Michael Fitzpatrick
Arts & Culture Editor Arts & Culture Editor Features Editor Features Editor City & State Editor City & State Editor News Editor News Editor Sports Editor Sports Editor Editorial Page Editor Editorial Page Editor Opinions Editor Opinions Editor
Graphics & Photos Abe Pressman Graphics Editor Alex Yuly Graphics Editor Stephanie London Photo Editor Hilary Rosenthal Photo Editor Nick Sinnott-Armstrong Photo Editor Jonathan Bateman Sports Photo Editor Production Dan Towne Gili Kliger Anna Migliaccio Katie Wilson
Copy Desk Chief Design Editor Design Editor Design Editor
General Managers Matthew Burrows Isha Gulati
Office Manager Shawn Reilly
Directors Aditi Bhadia Danielle Marshak Margot Grinberg Lisa Berlin
Sales Finance Alumni Relations Special Projects
Managers Hao Tran National Sales Alec Kacew University Department Sales Siena deLisser University Student Group Sales Valery Scholem Recruiter Sales Jared Davis Sales and Communications Lauren Bosso Business Operations Emily Zheng Business Analytics Nikita Khadloya Alumni Engagement Rajiv Iyengar Special Projects Arjun Vaidya Special Projects Webber Xu Special Projects Post- magazine Kate Doyle Editor-in-Chief BLOG DAILY HERALD David Winer Editor-in-Chief Matt Klimerman Managing Editor
quote of the day
“Fish Co. was an equal-opportunity place.” — Kate Whalen ’07
Ever wondered what it’s like to work at a student-run business? Do you like FREE PIZZA?
Then join the Brown Daily Herald Business Staff! We will be having info sessions on Wednesday, February 2 at 8 pm and Thursday, February 3 at 8 pm at 195 Angell Street. We hope to see you there! C O R R E C T I O N S P olicy The Brown Daily Herald is committed to providing the Brown University community with the most accurate information possible. Corrections may be submitted up to seven calendar days after publication. C ommentary P O L I C Y The editorial is the majority opinion of the editorial page board of The Brown Daily Herald. The editorial viewpoint does not necessarily reflect the views of The Brown Daily Herald, Inc. Columns, letters and comics reflect the opinions of their authors only. L etters to the E ditor P olicy Send letters to letters@browndailyherald.com. Include a telephone number with all letters. The Herald reserves the right to edit all letters for length and clarity and cannot assure the publication of any letter. Please limit letters to 250 words. Under special circumstances writers may request anonymity, but no letter will be printed if the author’s identity is unknown to the editors. Announcements of events will not be printed. advertising P olicy The Brown Daily Herald, Inc. reserves the right to accept or decline any advertisement at its discretion.
Opinions 7
The Brown Daily Herald Wednesday, February 2, 2011
Politics and patriotism in the ROTC issue? No thanks BY CHELSEA WAITE Opinions Columnist Two recent opinions columnists have expressed different views on the Reserve Officer Training Corps issue. Chris NorrisLeBlanc (“The ROTC Question,” Jan. 28) paints a political picture: Brown should not endorse the army by allowing an ROTC presence on campus. Heath Mayo (“The ROTC Answer,” Jan. 31) rejects the politicized view in favor of one centered around patriotism: Brown has a responsibility to support the forces protecting us abroad. The issue, while it can be made about politics and patriotism, should be about neither. As much as Brown students tend to be of a liberal persuasion, the University would be going a step too far in continuing to ban ROTC based on an apparently universal disapproval of our military’s actions. We send many students each year to be investment bankers and consultants on Wall Street — the actions and moral choices of whom I frequently question. But it would be ridiculous to stop Goldman Sachs from recruiting at Brown. Clearly, the situations have differences, but the point is that Brown has little business unilaterally opposing the military and everything it does through a ban on ROTC. Does that mean we have a patriotic duty to support our military in all of its
endeavors? No. As a Brown student generally skeptical of much of our international activity in the past few decades, I stand strongly by the claim that my skepticism does not preclude my patriotism. Brown students can and should continue to question our policy abroad. We can continue to do that even with an ROTC option here — in fact, it might make our questioning even more relevant. Ay, there’s the rub, and now we come to what will likely be the most controversial part of this column. I think we generally have very little direct experience with
Frankly, if more students at universities like Brown were to enter ROTC, and by extension the U.S. military, I think we just might give that military — and the missions it undertakes — a little more rapt attention. Perhaps if more of us actually knew about U.S. military presences the world over and had met some of the women and men making up those presences, we would be in a better position to make the changes we want to see in our foreign policy. Countless articles in recent years have exposed how much of the U.S. military is made up of recruits from rural America,
Frankly, if more students at universities like Brown were to enter ROTC and by extension the U.S. military, I think we just might give that military — and the missions it undertakes — a little more rapt attention. or connection to the U.S. military. Relatively few of us have acquaintances, let alone close friends or siblings, in the armed forces. An ROTC presence on campus would be exactly that — a presence that we hardly ever see now. It makes me cringe on Veterans’ Day when Brown students uncomfortably give a wide berth around uniformed men or women, wondering what business the army has on a campus like ours.
most of whom are from poor or lowermiddle-class families. For all that Brown students tend to criticize the military, we certainly don’t have much of a role in it. If we, and others like us, had more of a presence in, or exposure to, the armed forces, perhaps — dare I say it? — we would do more than passively disapprove of its actions. Coming at the same point from another angle, our judgment of our current
military leadership and decision-making does not have to color our judgment of peers interested in such a career, nor does it have to color the program in which they have chosen to enroll in order to achieve their goals. An ROTC presence at Brown would invite, I believe, a more dynamic discussion about the U.S. military and a more nuanced perspective from those inside and outside the program. In sum, I see the ROTC issue as one of choice and awareness. No one would be forced to enter the program, and quite honestly, I don’t predict it would be very big here. But allowing that option would open the range of experiences and perspectives on our campus. It could also help to populate the top tiers of the military with some well-educated Brown students who have trained in an environment of great ideological diversity. Furthermore, a closer-to-home experience with army recruitment and training might spur those of us opposed to certain military choices to back up our arguments more and take them farther. Whether it’s about politics or patriotism, I stand where I usually do: Let’s have a healthy debate about it. I believe that debate would be enriched by the participation of Brown students also interested in a military career. Chelsea Waite ’11 could have put this article on a sign at the Rally to Restore Sanity.
How we compete By kurt walters Opinions Columnist In President Obama’s recent State of the Union address, we heard repeated appeals to renew America’s long-term competitiveness and to “win the future” against emerging rivals like India and China. Similarly, in the decade following Ruth Simmons’ hiring as President in 2001, Brown has seen a heightened emphasis on becoming more competitive with other schools in the fight to attract the best students in the country and from around the world. After inheriting a stalled and stagnant campus, the Simmons administration quickly initiated a raft of reforms under the Plan for Academic Enrichment. Many of them were incredibly beneficial, ranging from need-blind admissions for domestic, non-transfer students, to impressive increases in fundraising and faculty hiring. But with the huge changes the school has seen comes a significant risk of losing the educational culture and university-college model that make Brown so attractive in the first place. In many cases, Brown’s leadership seems to be taking its cues more from trying to copy Harvard, Yale and Princeton — the “HYP(e)” schools for short — than from trying to improve Brown’s unique culture. Just take how the recent tenure reform debate was sparked by the fact that Brown has a considerably higher rate of tenure approval than other Ivy League schools, and how a principal argument for establishing the new school of engineering was “well, all
the other Ivy League schools have one.” Now, I don’t mean to suggest here that Simmons has some agenda to undermine the New Curriculum and the universitycollege model. Far from it — although Simon Liebling’s columns such as “Brown, Inc.” do have significant merit. Rather, the risk is that in the rush to make improvements, Brown’s culture will be overlooked through neglect and die a slow “death by a thousand cuts.” By the time we realize a shift has happened, it will already be too late. Brown has long had an emphasis on the liberal arts rather than professional or vocational training. In 1946, then-president
the process of de-emphasizing the Program in Liberal Medical Education that kept it unique and relevant to the liberal arts. Add to that the new school of engineering (everyone else was doing it!) and rumors of a future School of Community Health, and we see a subtle yet fundamental transformation away from Brown’s university-college identity. In the midst of these changes, we seem to have lost sight of the best way for Brown to compete — by staking out a position that is uniquely “Brown” rather than becoming an also-ran “Yale Jr.” For the subset of present and future students who are looking for a self-directed
In the midst of these changes, we seem to have lost sight of the best way for Brown to compete — by staking out a position that is uniquely “Brown” rather than becoming an also-ran “Yale Jr.” Henry Wriston lauded the University’s inclusion of engineering within the liberal arts college rather than “segregating it in a separate school.” Similarly, Wriston noted how Brown had eliminated previous experiments with programs in medicine, agriculture, business and forestry because they were found to be “fundamentally incompatible” with Brown’s commitment to liberal arts learning. Today, of course, it is no secret that Brown has a rapidly expanding medical school, which soon will be geographically separated from the main campus and is in
liberal arts education at a school with a strong focus on undergraduates and the resources of a university (as I once was), I don’t think it’s an exaggeration to say that Brown is the best choice in the world. There are plenty of great options for pre-professionals, but if you try to think of other true university-colleges, it’s hard to get much further than perhaps Wesleyan or Dartmouth. If Brown abandons its unique focus and model, it would leave a gaping void in the college landscape. By instead competing with ourselves to be the best Brown University possible, we will be de facto
competitive with both colleges and universities by offering the best of both worlds. With so much change, we are at a tenuous crossroads. But there are steps we can take to preserve our educational culture while still improving the school. First, let’s make sure that we aren’t promoting the segmenting of the University into many schools without good reason. Liberal education thrives at the intersection of many different disciplines, so we should be wary of putting up barriers to interdisciplinary contact by breaking up the University. Second, we must create incentives for professors to engage in undergraduate teaching and especially advising over exclusively prioritizing their research. Students come to Brown looking for undergraduate excellence, and faculty members must be here for the same reason. The New Curriculum, with its characteristic freedom and resulting reliance on strong advising, dies without a faculty deeply committed to undergraduates. Finally and most importantly, we need vigilance, energy and passion from the student body regarding the University’s governance and future. We should promote and be proud — not suspicious — of our differences from other schools. We cannot expect faculty and administration to maintain the New Curriculum and a culture that most benefits undergraduate students — we must fight for that ourselves.
Kurt Walters ’11 was ecstatic to see a page labeled “The university college” in the bookstore’s Brown promo pamphlet. Here’s looking at you, Brown PR team.
Daily Herald Campus News the Brown
Wednesday, February 2, 2011
Libraries get improved study spaces
Prof’s book wins 2010 Mead award
By Kristina KLARA Staff Writer
By Julia Longoria Contributing Writer
The fourth floor of the Sciences Library and a small area on Level A of the Rockefeller Library were recently renovated to create additional places for quiet study. “Recently we’ve had more students ask us for quieter study spaces,” said David Banush, associate University librarian for access services, adding that demand for such spaces in the SciLi was particularly high. The new space is divided into four rooms of varying size, which Banush said are “firstcome, first-served,” and a larger, open space which is designated for quiet study. In the main room, several white tables dot the variegated purple and brown rug. Freestanding white boards intersect the tables, and there are moveable purple dividers that can be used to section off study spaces. “I’m a fan,” said Sumitha Raman ’13. “It’s quiet and big and open.” Steven Lavallee, head of the Friedman Study Center, said requests for more space were voiced multiple times at a Friedman-Rock Advisory Council meeting. The committee consists of four students appointed by the Undergraduate Council of Students and four appointed by Brown’s library faculty. Stacks on the A level of the Rock were removed to make room
whole book took a thousand hours.” After receiving coverage Jan. 22 from Keith Devlin on NPR, the book leapt to the number-one position on Amazon for the children’s math book category for over a day, Schwartz said, one year after the book was published. The NPR coverage was “essentially a four-minute glowing advertisement,” Schwartz said. “It was on a Saturday morning, I actually overslept.” Schwartz published the children’s book with A K Peters, Ltd., a publishing company that focuses on books related to computer science and mathematics. Schwartz had several previous publications with the company, but he said they were very mathematically complex. “You Can Count on Monsters” is the first book for very young children published by A K Peters, said Klaus Peters, a co-founder of the company and a former professor of mathematics at the University of Erlangen in Nuremberg, Germany. The company had previously published other books for middleschool children, but this book is intended for children six and up,
Assistant Professor of Anthropology Jessaca Leinaweaver won the 2010 Margaret Mead Award for her first published book, “The Circulation of Children: Kinship, Adoption, and Morality in Andean Peru.” The award, given each year by the American Anthropological Association and the Society for Applied Anthropology, will be formally presented in April. “It’s the most prestigious award for a junior scholar in anthropology,” said Professor of Anthropology Catherine Lutz, chair of the department. Leinaweaver has “a very acute sensibility as to the lives of other people,” Lutz added. “She has a real ear for how people think and experience the world in different ways and a very strong ability to write what she’s learned.” The award bears the name of anthropologist Margaret Mead, who had a “knack for communicating her findings to the public,” Leinaweaver said. According to the association’s website, winners “interpret anthropological data and principles” in a way that is accessible to a world audience, not just anthropologists. Leinaweaver, who joined the faculty in 2008, is the second member of Brown’s anthropology department to receive this award. Professor of Anthropology Dan Smith accepted it in 2008. “I couldn’t believe it,” Leinaweaver said. “To me, it says I was successful in writing a book that can be read by many people. So it’s not just for my anthropological colleagues with extensive training in theory and methods of the discipline. For example, my husband’s grandmother read it.” Her book opens, “This child is abandoned.” Leinaweaver brings readers along on the journey she took from 2001 to 2003 as a PhD student in Ayacucho, Peru. The book examines a phenomenon she calls “child circulation,” where Peruvian children live away from home, often with an aunt or a friend of the family. Peruvian government and adoption officials would sometimes view these children as abandoned. “I was interested in finding out why that was so common,” Leinaweaver said. “I saw it as a sort of adoption, even though sometimes kids would only move temporarily, like for a year or two.” The book compares this phenomenon to another method of relocating children: legal adoption. Ultimately, Leinaweaver was interested in “how the government and Quechua-speaking people thought differently about where people should be and who should take care of their children,” she said. She gathered a wealth of perspectives, interviewing social workers, parents of the children, receiving families and the kids themselves.
continued on page 5
continued on page 5
Evan Thomas / Herald
Renovations to parts of the Sciences Library and Rockefeller Library have created increased study space for students.
for the new study space, and many shelves of books were moved to the Library Collections Annex. “It really reflects the changing nature of the use of library facilities,” Banush said. “We’re not acquiring as much printed material as we used to and people aren’t using it as much.” Banush said SciLi attendance figures from the last academic year were some of the highest ever. “We could probably sell seats at auction during exam period.” There will be seating for 96 people on the fourth floor of the SciLi, Banush said. New chairs are scheduled to arrive soon. The fourth floor of the SciLi will be open the same hours as the rest of the building — until 2 a.m. Sunday through Thursday
and until 10 p.m. on Friday and Saturday. “I’m just anxious to see how students like it,” said Lavallee. “We will certainly try to make our facilities more friendly to student needs,” Banush said. While the fourth floor of the SciLi was renovated primarily due to student requests, the renovations at the Rock had more practical reasons. The renovated space on Level A is right near the art books, many of which are large and on reserve for use in the library only. The tables near the books will allow people to look at them with more ease, Banush said, although he added that students had requested more comfortable study spaces in the
Rock. The new area will seat 15 to 20 students, and a new L-shaped rug has been ordered for the space. The lobby of the Rock has also undergone renovations — the reception desk where visitors previously presented their identification for entry has been replaced with a set of electronic doors that open automatically when the proper identification card is swiped. Banush said he wasn’t sure where the money for the renovations came from, but that “the money from these sorts of things typically comes from donations.” Raman said it was her second time in the space, adding that she thought she would probably return to the fourth floor. “It’s always a good thing to have more space.”
Math and monsters add up in children’s book By Ben kutner Staff Writer
From the author of “The Pentagram Integrals for Inscribed Polygons” and “Spherical CR Geometry and Dehn Surgery” comes “You Can Count on Monsters,” a colorful picture book featuring 100 maththemed monsters. Professor of Mathematics Richard Schwartz’s first children’s book offers young children a unique math experience. The book, recently featured on National Public Radio, is filled with colorful graphics of monsters that correspond with the numbers one to 100, presenting young children with a unique and exciting way to learn about concepts like prime numbers and factoring. The graphic of each monster is related to the number it represents — the number five monster, for example, is a five-sided star. The project originally took the form of a poster of the 100 monsters, which Schwartz said he had made for one of his daughters. “I wanted to just make something for her,” he said. Schwartz said he made several comic books when he was in his 20s and that creating graphics is a hobby of his. He created the pictures of the
Courtesy of Richard Schwartz
Monsters, like this one representing a factoring tree, fill Schwartz’s book.
monsters using X Fig, a program used by many mathematicians that brings up shapes and geometrical patterns, he said. The book contains three sections — an introduction explaining the concepts in the book, the
actual graphics of the 100 monsters and two appendices at the end of the book containing the Sieve of Eratosthenes and Euclid’s proof for prime numbers. “I kind of did it in bursts,” Schwartz said. “I’d estimate the