Anne Boleyn: Separatng Myt fom Realit
ho was Anne Boleyn?
Anne Boleyn is described as one of the most controversial women in English History. A scheming young woman who devoted her life to sabotaging England’s religious ties to the Catholic faith, using her powers of manipulation and seduction towards King Henry VIII.
Anne’s image is largely shaped by biased accounts and propaganda deliberately created to tarnish Anne’s reputation, especially during her fall from power. The idea of Anne being considered a seductive and manipulative figure, reflects more on contemporary attitudes towards women, especially women in power.
Anne’s story has been rewritten countless times it is within these novels that we as an audience must question why certain versions of her character still persist. We must challenge these dominant narratives and open the discussion of gender, myth and the dangers of power
Do you know the real story?
Let’s look beyond myth!
There are many literary portrayals that paint Anne Boleyn as a seductive young woman who manipulated Henry VIII. sympathetic approach, in Shakespeare’s Henry VIII, Anne is presented as a pawn of fate rather than intelligent and ambitious. Obviously since this play was written after the reign of Elizabeth I in 1613, Shakespeare wanted to avoid controversy as Anne wasn’t just Queen but mother to a future reigning monarch. Instead Shakespeare downplayed Anne’s influence on Henry VIII This could be considered a kinder approach to Anne, considering what else has been published since. Phillipa Gregory’s novel, The Other Boleyn Girl , published in 2001, depicts Anne as a stereotypical seductress whose ambition leads to her eventual execution. Within the novel itself we can see quarrels with her family, especially her sister (Mary Boleyn, a former mistress of Henry VIII). “You should know better than to think there’s room for two stars in the same sky.” This novel reinforces the ideal that Anne was too power-hungry and far too ambitious for her own good.
Quots fom Anne Boleyn in ‘Te Oter Boleyn Girl’ Novel:
“I shall not be a king’s whore. I shall be his queen.”
“You should know better than to think there’s room for two stars in the same sky.”
“When you are in the king’s favour, you live at the centre of the court. When you are out of favour, you are nothing, nobody.”
“I am not like you, Mary. I was never content with what I was given. I wanted more.”
olf Hall
This novel, written by Hilary Mantel, published in 2009, depicts Anne Boleyn in a harsh and unforgiving manner. Mantel tell’s Anne’s story through the lens of Thomas Cromwell
— who was also surrounded by myth himself, due to his influence in the trial of Anne Boleyn history has painted him as Anne’s sworn enemy who was always scheming against her in order to gain more control over Henry VIII and therefore England. Despite this Cromwell was not entirely innocent when it came to Anne’s death. Cromwell falsified many testimonies and constructed cases of adultery with other men including her own brother, George Boleyn, eventually leading to her execution. This novel does not portray Anne in an over-sexualised way but rather villainises her character, making her a bully in the English court. Mantel paints Anne as an exceedingly unlikable character who uses mockery and sarcasm to assert her power over others. However, despite this, Mantel translates the pressure that Anne is under. Anne’s position and circumstance purely depends on her ability to produce a male heir, Mantel shows this through Henry VIII obsession of having a son, “If Anne cannot produce a son, she will go the way of Katherine.”
The fact that Anne’s life hangs in the balance of something she cannot control — the gender of her rst child— highlighting a woman’s worth in the dynasty. Without an heir she is powerless and vulnerable. In her nal days Mantel writes about Anne’s paranoia as she sense those at court are turning against her. Cromwell sees this as an opportunity to strike and plots Anne’s downfall. In conclusion, Mantel describes Anne as the Tudor queen who made enemies at court and had to pay the price.
Quotes from the perspective of Thomas Boleyn about Anne’s character:
"Anne’s voice is never warm. Even when she means to please, she has a way of sounding as if she is giving orders.”
"Anne is watching him. Her black eyes are sharp as a bird’s. She is afraid of him, he thinks. She should be.”
"She’s nobody’s fool. She’s been dealing with men—managing men—since she was a girl.”
"She thinks she is the equal of men, and for that alone she should be feared.”
"She is trapped in the role she has made for herself.”
"Anne would rather be feared than loved.”
odern Women
The expectations for a woman’s intelligence in the Tudor period is drastically different to the standards of the 21st century. By today’s standards Anne would be on par with some of the smartest individuals of our day. No doubt Anne Boleyn would’ve pursued a further more in depth education if it were offered to her but instead Anne used every opportunity she could to learn about politics, literature, philosophy and theology to name a few. This is shown in Eric Ives’ work ‘The Life and Death of Anne Boleyn’ (2004) ‘Anne spent time in the courts of the Netherlands and France, where she was exposed to Renaissance humanism and reformist religious ideas.’Anne was also fluent in Latin as well as French, due to her time spent at the French court as a maid. This is confirmed by Ives noting ‘she acquired during her time at the French court from 1514 to around 1521, first serving Queen Mary (Henry VIII’s sister) and later Queen Claude’ So the question I propose to the reader of this zine is: Do we believe that Anne was snobbish and overambitious or was she just incredibly well educated. Of course many women of the 16th century were not as lucky to have the same education as Anne, but should she have been scrutinised for that? Certainly not in today’s society. We know from extensive evidence that Anne used her intellect to persuade Henry into breaking with Rome and form the church of England, this is due to her introducing Henry VIII to the writings of reformist, William Tyndale, who wrote ‘The Obedience of a Christian Man’. From this evidence we can ght back against the allegations of Anne seducing or bewitching the king to break with Rome. It was Anne’s intelligence that attracted Henry to Anne.
ympathetic approach
It's Important to note another interpretation of Queen Anne Boleyn. This time we’ll be looking at Jean Plaidy’s, ‘Murder Most Royal’ (1949), this novel contains a sympathetic approach to Anne. Anne is depicted as a passionate, ambitious and intelligent tragic figure of Tudor history. Although this novel is kinder to Anne’s reputation Plaidy still makes note of Anne’s ignorance and volatility in the English court. Anne is not painted as conventionally attractive within this novel linking to first-hand accounts from diplomats that came into contact with the queen. A Venetian diplomat for example descries her as “Not one of the handsomest women in the world”. The idea of Anne being seductive is also hinted in this novel. Jean Plaidy highlights Anne’s flirtation techniques as well as her sharp wit and unwavering confidence. “She was unconsciously graceful, and this habit of standing thus had grown out of a desire to hide her hands... but she had infused into this habit a charm which was apparent when she stood with others of her age.”
Despite Anne’s reputation as “the other woman” in Tudor history and being known as “The Great Whore” to Henry VIII, we as a modern audience must be sympathetic to the time in which Anne was living. We will never know for sure if her marriage to Henry VIII was a wish of her father, Thomas Boleyn or her Uncle Thomas Howard; or rather an authentic type of love for the monarch. In which case we must see all sides of evidence and not fall into the trap of believing harmful rumours about Anne’s character.
Jean plaidy’s narrative of Anne:
“She was not beautiful in the way that other women were, but she possessed a charm that made men forget all others when she was near.”
“Her tongue was as sharp as her wit, and she used both to great effect.”
“The court that had once fawned over her now whispered behind her back.”
“A queen in life, and a martyr in death.”
“She walked to her death with her head held high, for she was still a queen.”
“The court was her battlefield, and she was ready for the fight.”
“Anne Boleyn did not know how to be humble. It was not in her nature.”
To conclude this zine I would like you, as the reader, to ask yourself: how would you feel if the story of your life was published without true today, legal action could be taken to stop any defamation of their character, unfortunately Anne did not have any legal aid to defend her reputation in that sense. How would you feel if an author published false claims that misrepresented you and placed you into a category where you didn’t belong?
For me, I believe this is exactly what happened to Anne Boleyn. Of course everyone will interpret literature in different ways, but when an author has no background in the study of your life, is it fair for them to publish work that will paint you as the villain from every perspective. I think not. Anne Boleyn’s story can only be told from her perspective but we no longer have her voice. In a world where women are constantly pitted against each other it hardly seems fair to draw conclusions on literature that has no authenticity as to what really happened in her life; it blackens her name and stains her reputation and unfortunately she has no way of defending herself and expand on her own truth. Finally, we must always be open minded when radian literature about real gures and understand that what is published is not always the truth.
Thank you for reading!
Thats a wrap on this issue of Anne Boleyn: Separating Myth from Reality
I hope that this sparked your interest in Anne Boleyn and challenged a few assumptions that you have made about her character, or simply made you reflect on the myths you have been told.
Created by: Erin Goldson
Written by: Erin Goldson
Stay Connected
Instagram: @anneboleynarchive
YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@eringoldson8855
Parting thoughts:
"Anne Boleyn's legacy is not simply defined by her fall from grace, but by her profound impact on the course of history. Her ambition, intelligence, and courage in a world dominated by men shaped the future of England, and her story, though tragic, remains a testament to the complexities of power, love, and fate.” - Eric Ives.