Actions Evaluation Matrix: Qualitative
Actions Evaluation Matrix: Quantitative Actions
Quantitative Metrics
Climate Roadmap Action ID and Title
Approximate full build-out capital costs and net operating costs by 2050 in millions of 2022 dollars
Cumulative greenhouse gas emissions reduction potential at full buildout by 2050 compared to business-as-usual (Measured in cumulative mtCO2e reduced)
Cumulative cost-effectiveness of greenhouse gas emissions reductions: at full build-out by 2050 (Measured in millions of dollars for every cumulative mtCO2e reduced)
Annual GHG Reduction by 2050 Relative to 1990 Baseline (Measured in mtCO2e)
$9,020
$276,000
$32,681
17,800
0
CR-1.2: Modernize Muni Metro
$700
$137,000
$5,109
8,800
5,800
CR-1.3: Initiate Geary Subway
$20,000
$15,000
$1,333,333
0
15,300
CR-1.4: Initiate Central Subway Extension
$1,680
$22,000
$76,364
2,300
1,500
CR-1.5: Implement Muni Forward Improvements
CR-1.1: Build the Five-minute Network
Annual GHG Reduction by 2040 Relative to 1990 Baseline (Measured in mtCO2e)
Actions
Community Benefits
Climate Roadmap Action ID and Title
Racial Equity
Public Health
Safety
Economic Travel Vitality Experience
Air Quality
CR-1.1: Build the Five-minute Network
High
High
High
High
High
High
CR-1.2: Modernize Muni Metro
High
High
High
High
High
High
CR-1.3: Initiate Geary Subway
High
High
High
High
High
High
CR-1.4: Initiate Central Subway Extension
High
High
High
High
High
High
CR-1.5: Implement Muni Forward Improvements
Medium
Medium
Medium
Medium
High
Medium
CR-1.6: Improve Transfers
Medium
Medium
Medium
Medium
High
Medium
CR-2.1: Expand Bicycle Parking
High
High
Low
Low
Medium
Low
CR-2.2: Subsidize E-bikes
High
High
Low
Medium
Medium
Medium
CR-2.3: Pilot Mobility Hubs
High
High
Medium
Medium
Medium
Medium
CR-2.4: Expand the Bicycle Network
High
High
High
High
High
High
CR-3.1: Increase Engagement in Commute Benefits Ordinance Programs
Low
Medium
Medium
Low
Medium
Medium
CR-3.2: Increase Share of Employers Offering Commute Subsidies
Low
Medium
Medium
Low
Medium
Medium
CR-4.1: Expand Paid Parking on Sundays and Evenings
Low
High
Low
Medium
High
High
CR-4.2: Gradually Charge the Right Price for Every On-street Space, Lower Range (Note: mutually exclusive to 4.3 for modeling purposes)
Low
High
Medium
Medium
High
High
CR-4.3: Gradually Charge the Right Price for Every On-street Space, Upper Range (Note: mutually exclusive to 4.2 for modeling purposes)
Low
High
High
High
High
High
$2,960
$228,000
$12,982
13,600
8,800
CR-1.6: Improve Transfers
$45
$6,000
$7,500
300
200
CR-2.1: Expand Bicycle Parking
$9
$2,000
$4,500
60
40
CR-2.2: Subsidize E-bikes
$6
$13,000
$462
500
300
CR-2.3: Pilot Mobility Hubs
$6
$400
$15,000
10
10
$898
$141,000
$6,369
6,700
5,500
CR-3.1: Increase Engagement in Commute Benefits Ordinance Programs
$4
$86,000
$47
3,400
2,200
CR-3.2: Increase Share of Employers Offering Commute Subsidies
$3
$91,000
$33
4,800
3,200
CR-4.1: Expand Paid Parking on Sundays and Evenings
($222)
$55,000
($4,036)
2,200
1,400
CR-4.2: Gradually Charge the Right Price for Every On-street Space, Lower Range (Note: mutually exclusive to 4.3 for modeling purposes)
($980)
$369,000
($2,656)
14,700
9,600
CR-4.4: Increase Residential Parking Low Permit Fees, Lower Range (Note: mutually exclusive to 4.5 for modeling purposes)
High
Low
Medium
High
High
CR-4.3: Gradually Charge the Right Price for Every On-street Space, Upper Range (Note: mutually exclusive to 4.2 for modeling purposes)
($8,750)
$1,761,000
($4,969)
69,900
45,800
CR-4.5: Increase Residential Parking Low Permit Fees, Upper Range (Note: mutually exclusive to 4.4 for modeling purposes
High
Medium
Medium
High
High
CR-4.4: Increase Residential Parking Permit Fees, Lower Range (Note: mutually exclusive to 4.5 for modeling purposes)
($25)
$95,750
($261)
4,800
2,500
CR-5.1: Expand EV Charging Stations
Low
High
Low
Medium
Low
High
CR-6.1: Develop and Implement Community Transportation Plans
High
High
Medium
Medium
Medium
High
CR-4.5: Increase Residential Parking Permit Fees, Upper Range (Note: mutually exclusive to 4.4 for modeling purposes
($80)
CR-5.1: Expand EV Charging Stations
$161
$446,000
$361
24,800
24,800
CR-6.1: Develop and Implement Community Transportation Plans
$41
$493,000
$83
19,600
12,800
CR-2.4: Expand the Bicycle Network
$383,000
($209)
15,200
9,900 Actions Evaluation Matrix: Qualitative
Actions Evaluation Matrix: Quantitative 78
79