December 2022

LIVING IN TH cover story .

T

he whole city talks about it. The rumors are out. Sion’s not “Catholic enough.” But when you consider how Sion operates as a Catholic school, it’s hard to see how that statement could be true. With monthly all-school Masses, class retreats, Kairos, weekly Wednesday morning Masses or prayer services, peer ministry and theology requirements – Sion possesses all of the standard faithbased activities and requisites of a typical Catholic high school. However, over the years, the school has also developed a reputation for possessing a more progressive student body, which some consider to be at odds with its identity as a Catholic institution. “Sion is known for being a more liberal school. That’s why

some people from my middle school didn’t want to go here,” freshman Heidi Nance said. “The student body is more liberallyleaning, and a lot of the kids at my school didn’t think it was ‘Catholic enough.’” In an increasingly polarized world, Sion now finds itself in a uniquely complex position: a Catholic school, centered in Catholic traditions and values, made up of a student body where the loudest voices heard, at least currently, are the liberal voices. The community now faces the question of whether it’s possible to reconcile these identities, and if students of different beliefs can find a way to communicate respectfully in order to coexist. As a Catholic school, Sion’s institution is already separated from other area schools by its unique commitment to honor all faith traditions by promoting interfaith dialogue and education. The manifestations of this commitment create a diverse faith education that differs from most other Catholic schools and, correspondingly, also promotes greater diversity within the student body. “In our school there are lots of different ethnicities, religions and backgrounds,” freshman Adele Milligan said. “It shows you that people come here not just because it’s Catholic, but because other Catholic schools don’t have that wide range of ethnicities and religions like Sion does. It’s a big part of Sion’s community that helps people to choose to go here.”

DIVERSITY OF THOUGHT

14 | LeJournal

79% of 143 polled students and staff members answered “yes” or “maybe” when asked if they feel the Sion community leans in a particular political direction. When asked to elaborate, the majority expressed the belief that the school community is left-leaning. While the belief systems of the Catholic church and the Democratic party do not always oppose one another, some topics have become especially contentious within the school walls. “The Catholic church does lean conservative, but they also sometimes lean on the liberal side too. They’re pretty anti death penalty, pro-immigration and pro taking in refugees, which I feel like isn’t really talked about,” sophomore Natasha Wulff said. “But abortion is a pretty heavy topic. I’ve heard some people say that they can’t talk about what they believe here for fear of being kicked out of their friend groups.” Many young people start becoming civically engaged in high school. When asked which aspects of their lives played the biggest roles in forming personal political identity, most poll respondents cited parents and family as their first sources of political socialization. Many also added that as they have gotten older, exposure to new ideas, people, higher education and social media have played a significant role as well. Social media is the easiest and most convenient setting to engage in unproductive debate. Carefully constructed algorithms feed one-sided information to consumers, building a false sense of the reality of political dynamics. Social media also allows people to convey opinions with the safety net of being faceless, nameless and unidentified. It should be much more difficult to look at a classmate or